TikTok wishes it was this dramatic | Casta Diva | Opera Singer Aria Explained

Ойын-сауық

My apologies for all the cuts, but the copyright claims were threatening to block the video entirely!
In order to appreciate this aria fully, I decided to look at multiple singers, including Maria Callas, Montserrat Caballé and Rosa Ponselle, but trust me when I say that there are so many more! On my Instagram, you’ll find many other examples of this aria by none other than Cecilia Bartoli, Anita Cerquetti, Joan Sutherland and so many other wonderful singers!
Whose interpretation is your favorite?
00:00 - 01:42 Bellini ain't messing around
01:43 - 04:12 Book Norma into evidence, Your Honor
04:13 - 10:22 Maria Callas leaves her soul in Paris
10:22 - 13:33 Most perfect setting for Norma that exists
13:23 - 16:08 Oldies but goodies
16:09 - 18:35 This tea is PIPING HOT
18:36 - 24:44 Sing on the consonants!(?)
24:45 - 27:01 Bel canto humbles us all
#mariacallas #opera #pavarotti
____________________________________________________________________
Want to get more OperaAnna content? Please consider sharing this video and/or donating via Buy Me a Coffee. Because I run OperaAnna in my spare time, I don’t upload as much as I would like to. By helping the channel financially, I’ll be able to make more and more content to #operaupyourlife!
👉 Buy me a coffee!
www.buymeacoffee.com/operaanna
I’m now a Sing Pretty Designs ambassador, which means you can get 15% off your entire order with the code: OPERAUP! Copy and paste this code at the checkout to receive your discount. It helps both Jenny from Sing Pretty Designs and myself out - happy shopping!
👉 Brand Ambassador: singprettydesigns.com/
👉 Subscribe and follow!
Instagram: @opera.anna
For more singing videos visit my official KZread page: Anna Trombetta
Official Mezzo-Soprano Instagram: @anna_opera_trombetta
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. _____________________________________________________________________
opera, pavarotti, nessun dorma, reaction, react, Diana damrau, l'opera et ses zouz, the charismatic voice, professional opera singer, franco Corelli, Joyce didonato, giacomo Puccini, giuseppe Verdi, singers, maggie renee, marco meatball, opera singer reacts,

Пікірлер: 144

  • @Peter-CT
    @Peter-CT6 ай бұрын

    Hello Anna. I love your channel, and opera needs you desperately in this era where children are not routinely taught music. Casta Dive, all by itself on an arias album, turned me from someone indifferent to opera into an Opera Maniac. I thought if Bellini could write this exquisite thing, there was likely more gorgeous music in the complete Norma which someone had lent to me. One joint and six vinyl sides later and Bellini had turned me into a gobsmacked opera freak. And then I heard Callas and it was all over. Down the rabbit hole forever. That was 50 years ago. An interviewer once asked Callas how she prepared to sing Casta Diva which is so difficult to sing and comes so early in Norma when you know you have hours of hard singing ahead and must arrive at the end with all your powers blazing in order to sing the finale effectively. The Divine Maria answered: "Well, first the flute plays it,. And then you sing it." That's all there is to it according to her. Yeah. Right.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    6 ай бұрын

    Thank you for your comment, Peter! She had quite a directness to her didn't she..

  • @davidmolina7543

    @davidmolina7543

    3 ай бұрын

    My exact same experience.

  • @sandywaddell4303
    @sandywaddell43032 күн бұрын

    I’ve read that Callas admired Ponselle very much and studied her recordings carefully. This is a terrific video - your enthusiasm is infectious. Brava. Also: the group Italian facepalm? Hilarious!

  • @gregglienna1442
    @gregglienna14424 ай бұрын

    Callas was in character even before she sang. No one compares to her!

  • @clubconorte
    @clubconorte9 ай бұрын

    MARIA CALLAS IS AND ALWAYS WILL BE THE MOTHER QUEEN OF ANY SOPRANO IN THE WORLD.

  • @figaroverdi

    @figaroverdi

    5 ай бұрын

    Amén. Not to take any credit from all the great singers from the past, but to me Callas embodies raw emotion and conviction when she sings. She makes me feel opera to my core. Viva la DIVINA. ❤

  • @atizaries5512

    @atizaries5512

    2 күн бұрын

    There is Callas and the others....

  • @GiampietroDiSanto
    @GiampietroDiSanto7 ай бұрын

    Hi, Italian here. I've just stumbled upon your channel and I found it amazing, instant follow. I must confess I'm not an opera habitué when it comes to regular, every-day listening but my dad was (real enthusiast) and he fortunately educated me in good music: this is an aria he often used to listen to while reading in the living room so I basically grew up with Casta Diva (and Verdi, Rossini, Mozart etc.) and I love it so much. You made me relive such sweet memories. Thank you for these analyses and keep up with your ownderful channel. Ciao

  • @user-xo9pz7fd3j
    @user-xo9pz7fd3j12 күн бұрын

    Fantastic reaction! Very informative and deep. Your italian accent is nice! 🎉🎉🎉

  • @marcosalterio6306
    @marcosalterio63069 ай бұрын

    there were, there are and there will be amazing singers, but nobody can show emotions like Maria, her body language was out of this world. And yes, there are many similarities between Callas and Ponselle, after all, Ponselle was Callas' favourite soprano. And about Caballe, Maria thought of her as her successor, so this whole video makes so much sense! Thank you for sharing this!!

  • @maninironmask7925
    @maninironmask79254 ай бұрын

    Callas is just sublime. But Poncell was incredible too, her voice was so strong and thrilling.

  • @jnieuwerf
    @jnieuwerf10 ай бұрын

    Nice one again, great to hear all these great singers and compare them.

  • @kerstinej
    @kerstinej8 ай бұрын

    Callas and Caballe are both fantastic in this aria but I just love Anita Cerquetti’s version!

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    8 ай бұрын

    Isn't she great?!? I discovered her for this video!

  • @allanmoore4353
    @allanmoore435325 күн бұрын

    Ponselle might have been one of the earliest recordings of Casta Diva, but the opera debuted in 1830, many many people sang this opera in the 19th century.

  • @frb1808
    @frb18089 ай бұрын

    OOOOHHHHH *THAT* ARIA! Great video as always!

  • @txsphere
    @txsphere8 ай бұрын

    So good, glad I found your channel. Of course the master class with Joyce got me here.

  • @MargeDooley-iu9jv
    @MargeDooley-iu9jv10 ай бұрын

    This was an incredible episode! I love the care and passion you put into these explanations. I already loved casta diva, but I get so excited when I see you’ve posted. You make me love them even more. If you get the chance, could you please do a video about song to the moon from Rusalka? It’s one of my favorites! Thanks again for another great video.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    So glad you enjoyed it!! Song to the moon is a great one to look at! I'll keep it in mind 😊

  • @minnyh
    @minnyh10 ай бұрын

    Excellent - great way to start off my Monday morning

  • @rintintinification
    @rintintinification5 ай бұрын

    Everyone tell all your friends to Love OperaAnna. Great videos, thank you. A master class.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    4 ай бұрын

    🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @ninas992
    @ninas99210 ай бұрын

    Gorgeous! thank you

  • @casmirdb5357
    @casmirdb53577 ай бұрын

    Great video! Love your channel.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    6 ай бұрын

    Thank you!!!

  • @Ralf6287
    @Ralf62879 ай бұрын

    Hi Anna,I m italian and I am an enthusiastic opera lover.I wold express my gladness discovering a channel like this of yours,youthful but/and with a very in-depth knowledge about all the wide opera world.Besides the compliments,I would like to see your reaction and review to "Vesti la giubba" aria of Pavarotti,the on stage one,I think Pavarotti was just incredible not only in that,absolutely,but in particular in that performance,simply marvelous.Thanks anyway for your great job for all of us great lovers of music,and I apologize in advance for any mistakes I even committed cuz my bad english.See you soon and keep it up just like you are doing,bye!

  • @minnyh
    @minnyh10 ай бұрын

    okay - my vote goes to Montserrat Caballe - the purity of her voice is what I am drawn to. Funny and self deprecating but resolute in her artistic sensibilities - her way or the highway 🤣

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Lol love it! She's absolutely stunning

  • @jphubert

    @jphubert

    10 ай бұрын

    I agree. Calles is always great, but IMHO, Caballe was simply stunning here.

  • @jenylogan1

    @jenylogan1

    9 ай бұрын

    @@jphubert’Callas is always great’ is so facile, and not really apropos as this point of comparion. Caballe, here in her prime, has incredible breath control, and superb pianissimo, but really, much as I admire her, that is it. Callas here, is not in her prime, but her interpretation is so much deeper. Hear her earlier with Stignani or Simionato, and you will hear the Norma for the ages.

  • @dyby
    @dyby8 ай бұрын

    Love this! Excellent

  • @jphubert
    @jphubert10 ай бұрын

    I think the incredible pianissimo that is performed by Caballe here is very similar to those of Franco Corelli. They both were capable of holding a note for ages. What was so remarkable to me is that they could begin at fortissimo and smoothly transition to pianissimo with no change in quality (no mixed voice or falsetto vocal tricks for Corelli). The two were very well-matched even better than Corelli with Calles or Nillson. This video was superb. I have been interested in opera for over 50 years and I learned many new things from your comments and interpretive insights. Thank you so much.

  • @MC-rr5iz
    @MC-rr5iz10 ай бұрын

    Italian subscriber and follower here: your diction of Italian words and names in all your videos is very very good. Not perfect..but very very godd, you can still improve . Thank you for the video and the melodramatic explanation ❤

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Hhahaa thank you!! I haven't practiced in forever, I really need to... You're welcome as well!

  • @12zaf1

    @12zaf1

    4 күн бұрын

    Italian here as well. I disagree with above comment and your pronunciation of italian words is essentially perfect. Many italian native speakers do not have such clear diction.

  • @consciousnessrenaissance7804
    @consciousnessrenaissance78047 ай бұрын

    Callas is the most awesome 🎉❤👍🙏🌺🎉🎊

  • @flyinghow
    @flyinghow5 ай бұрын

    Callas and Caballe have such different voices. Callas will always be #1 for me in that she causes me to feel the music more deeply, however, I certainly appreciate the glorious high pianissimo Caballe is master of.

  • @thomase5772
    @thomase57728 ай бұрын

    I'd love to see more of these videos, especially analysis of Maria Callas. The goddesses of opera are so terribly underappreciated by my generation.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    8 ай бұрын

    Ask and you shall receive 😏 next video goes up Oct 1!

  • @RBP1963
    @RBP19633 ай бұрын

    Definetely, Montserrat Caballé in her antologhical Orange’s Norma in 1974 ❤❤❤

  • @Carpe-Diem-101

    @Carpe-Diem-101

    2 ай бұрын

    Perfection.

  • @charleskramer8995
    @charleskramer899510 ай бұрын

    In relation to the comments at the end of the video, I once heard something like the following about another bel canto composer: Rossini. "There are two types of Rossini singer: Those who show us just how difficult the music is and those who show us just how easy the music is."

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    No way! I wish I'd known the quote before ❤ he definitely said it better than I did hhaah

  • @ogvita9019
    @ogvita901910 ай бұрын

    Norma is my favorite opera so I’m thrilled to hear you talk about it. Would you consider doing a video on Adalgisa’s confession aria? It is a very beautiful and sadly underrated moment from the opera and as you are a Mezzo, I would love to hear your thoughts. 😊

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Absolutely!! Would love to

  • @carolmcbride7552
    @carolmcbride755221 күн бұрын

    My mother loved opera and Norma was her favorite

  • @jorgechavesfilho
    @jorgechavesfilho4 ай бұрын

    Great! To me, Callas is the best.

  • @xwiirastusx
    @xwiirastusx4 ай бұрын

    I happened to vacation in Catania, Sicily this past summer. I'm a great lover of opera, but I've never cared much for Bellini. All I knew by him was Norma and the aria Casta Diva from it. By mere accident I ended up visiting Museo Belliniano, housed in a building the composer once lived in. A very good and modern setup, an eye opener indeed! There were many virtual opera boxes to sit in to hear his music and learn how the audiences reacted to it at the time. It came as a surprise to me that his operas got booed out by hostile listeners so many times. And how his dead body entered the city in triumph during his funeral procession, the citizens recieving him not only as native son, but as a national hero.

  • @pierluigiboccardi7576
    @pierluigiboccardi75766 ай бұрын

    Sono 60 anni che seguo l'opera. Ti volevo ringraziare per l'amore che trasmetti e la speranza che mi doni. Non è importante chi è il tenore o il soprano o baritono ecc ecc, l'importante è che ti faccia battere il cuore. Grazie

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    5 ай бұрын

    È troppo vero! 🙌

  • @ER1CwC
    @ER1CwC10 ай бұрын

    All great singers! The things that jump at me are the tears in Callas's voice, the sheer richness of Ponselle's, and the fact that Caballe doesn't need to breath. Cerquetti (pronounced Cherkwetti!) should be better known. She was a noted Abigaille as well. I think she spreads a bit too much (not necessarily here though). One reason why Ponselle might've taken the descent fast was because of time restrictions of the recording technology (cylinders, I believe). There was roughly a 4-5 minute time limit. That's why she makes cuts in her recordings of Ritorna vincitor, and why she does not extend the length of the trill in her recordings of the cabaletta of the Ernani aria, whereas she reportedly did in live performances. Fun fact about the Callas performance is that the chorus is completely off in the B section, and she gives them the stink eye. (I do think she was in vocal trouble by that time, which explains the lack of support in the B-Flat in the cadenza.)

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Of course!! I should've thought of that when listening to Ponselle. That makes so much sense. I didn't notice Callas putting the chorus in their place, I'll have to pay closer attention next time I listen.. I need to do a full vlog on Callas. Her life was so interesting, and maybe i'll finally have all the dates straight in my head once I do!

  • @ER1CwC

    @ER1CwC

    10 ай бұрын

    @@operaanna She also raises her hand before she enters, I think to try to get them to stop! A video on Callas would be great!

  • @Peter-CT

    @Peter-CT

    6 ай бұрын

    She does not give the chorus the stink eye, she tries to let them know that they've come in too soon. Everyone's back on track in a few seconds, Mistakes happen, and she knows that which is why her concentration is not disturbed.

  • @ER1CwC

    @ER1CwC

    6 ай бұрын

    ​@@Peter-CT I just reviewed it. The chorus is off for the entire B section! Things get a tiny bit better in the second half, but during the first half, half of the chorus is a beat late. I see two stink eyes from her, one to her right and then one to her left. But more seriously, it's interesting: the chorus members are all holding scores. I think it goes to show that Norma wasn't performed all that often. I can't imagine their having to use scores for the choruses in Traviata.

  • @Al-hk6yi
    @Al-hk6yi5 ай бұрын

    bella e brava, ciao from Italy

  • @JM-wr2fo
    @JM-wr2fo8 ай бұрын

    Callas for me all the way. Her voice haunts me... She's so distinct, so... Callas. Loved this video!

  • @robertsfelix1583
    @robertsfelix15837 ай бұрын

    María Callas La Eminencia Dé La Ópera Del Siglo XX ❤

  • @stefanwild326
    @stefanwild3264 ай бұрын

    I'd love to know your thoughts on that relatively recent recording from DECCA (I believe) that is like a "reconstruction" based on the original score with period instruments and Bartoli as Norma and Sumi Jo as Adalgisa?

  • @alanalan-tc8no
    @alanalan-tc8no10 ай бұрын

    I can't believe you listened to Anita. Did you already know her, did someone recommend her to you, did you find her by chance on youtube? I ask because very few outside Italy know her. With other opera lovers here in Italy we have often had the same reaction as you upon hearing her voice. Something already heard with a touch of melancholy. I and other friends tried to give an explanation. For us it is like an ancestral voice in the sense of matriarch. A voice of a mother, a grandmother comes to mind. A voice that may be velvety with a touch of melancholy yet retains a spine of almost regal strength and dignity. It can probably make you laugh as a consideration but I wanted to share it with you. Maybe you can tell me what you think. Bravissima, nice video.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    I actually found her while researching for this video! I had a bunch of different options, but I thought her voice was just so stunning, plus the story of her replacing Maria Callas. I am definitely going to be listening to her more! Interesting connotation her voice has in Italy!!

  • @paganpoet3
    @paganpoet32 ай бұрын

    Maria is the last example of the enternal Hellenistic spirit.

  • @JeffSearust
    @JeffSearust2 ай бұрын

    First time I heard all of Norma, I was stunned...

  • @ganson560
    @ganson56010 ай бұрын

    Love this comparison format! Personally, i love Bartoli's rendition more than Callas. And i love Cabale! Thank you

  • @eberlinpascal2837

    @eberlinpascal2837

    9 ай бұрын

    Bartoli 👎👎👎

  • @edithhenson6917

    @edithhenson6917

    7 ай бұрын

    I agree. Opera is the farthest thing from boring! There is no greater music and I just do not know how anybody can do it, yet there are so many great ones.

  • @edithhenson6917

    @edithhenson6917

    7 ай бұрын

    I love your comments about Montserrat. I loved her so much. I am making a doll of her in that roll and I’ll never get it to be good enough! I’ve been working on it for 2 yrs now. Words cannot describe the greatness of Caballe’ and she was also a very fine person, a great lady!

  • @edithhenson6917

    @edithhenson6917

    7 ай бұрын

    I want to leave this thread, but I agree with your premise. When you said freaking mouth, what a turn off, especially when you are talking about such unparalleled people as these incomparable singers. You shouldn’t use words like that when referring to these great people! It just doesn’t fit! You have such good pronunciation in the words you use, but that phrase just killed what you are discussing. It is repulsive. It negates any credibility you may have!

  • @edithhenson6917

    @edithhenson6917

    7 ай бұрын

    Shut up!

  • @blackbox7708
    @blackbox77085 ай бұрын

    QUEEN OF Opera

  • @shogunshogun
    @shogunshogun8 ай бұрын

    22:05 - Montserrat's from a higher note to diminuendo into pianissimo is so beautiful! The same level of pianissimo (although not held out as long as Montserrat) but more difficult and more beautiful is from a tenor: Giuseppe Di Stefano (kzread.info/dash/bejne/lYOf1tCAdJutj5M.html). Starting from 5:08 (La présence) - Rudolph Bing (before becoming the GM of the Met) writes that hearing Pippo sing from a High C to a diminuendo into pianissimo was the most beautiful sound he heard (from his memoir: 5000 Nights at the Opera) More parallel to Montserrat's diminuendo into prolonging pianissimo in E lucevan le stelle (kzread.info/dash/bejne/c6SLytSsgJq_k6w.html). Starting from 1:29. Also another version is on KZread (kzread.info/dash/bejne/po1rlMawkbG1lps.html) taken from Pavarotti discussing his influences. Starting the aria from 7:24.

  • @leadingblind1629
    @leadingblind16296 ай бұрын

    So you remember that Magic Flute trailer? Apparently it's out on hulu. I do not have Hulu

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    6 ай бұрын

    Really! I'll have to look

  • @saraalvarez518
    @saraalvarez51827 күн бұрын

    Norma is my favorite opera ever. What draws me to it is Norma herself and the complexity of emotions that can be portrayed differently by every singer. To me, she is THE ultimate and true heroine in opera. I like different movement pieces with different performers, but as for Casta Diva, Anita Cerquetti is my favorite. *also the damn coughing and the talking is so unnoticeable but when you notice it, it is so annoying and you can never unnotice it!😂* P.S. but Callas's In mia man is the best interpretation imo.😁

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    23 күн бұрын

    Anita Cerquetti is an absolute dream! It's a shame she stopped singing so early (and took so long to get a career going!) Really sorry about all the cuts! The video was going to be blocked, so I had to keep trimming it down 😢

  • @michaelgoetze2103
    @michaelgoetze21036 ай бұрын

    I'm glad you mentioned the ambiguity of Maria Callas. I've had a love/hate relationship with her for decades. I find her voice quite ugly yet it produces such beautiful sounds. Never heard of Anita Cerquetti. She sounds amazing. Thanks for your videos.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    6 ай бұрын

    Such an interesting phenomenon! Thanks for your comment ❤️

  • @johnfields8308
    @johnfields83087 ай бұрын

    it has been a long time since you posted a new video

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    7 ай бұрын

    Unfortunately it has 😖 I have some videos lined up, but life has been completely ridiculous lately. I will be posting again soon!!

  • @johnfields8308

    @johnfields8308

    7 ай бұрын

    @operaanna that I understand. I had the vacation of my life set up(Sicilia), and my knee rebelled. I went and used a cane. Caught Covid on the flight back. My doctor's kid had Covid, so we did phone. He set me up with an orthopedic doctor. They want to do a titanium knee, so I am waiting for the insurance to approve a gel shot to stave off surgery. Meanwhile, work runs my butt off. So I understand

  • @judyjones2475
    @judyjones24755 ай бұрын

    Montserrat caballe the best Casta Diva ever , Orange 1972 just a miracle performance ♥️ 👏 ❤️ ✨️ 👌 🙌 ♥️

  • @nathanfraga7538
    @nathanfraga753810 ай бұрын

    Requesting again; React to Mario del Monaco please, him and corelli were "rivals", both seeking the perfection in the art of singing the whole life.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Yes! On the list, coming up

  • @edithhenson6917
    @edithhenson69177 ай бұрын

    You are mistaken. With Caballe’ this is 1974 in Orange, France in an amphitheater. The winds blowing are called the mistral winds.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    7 ай бұрын

    How am I mistaken?

  • @maxmaxime8380
    @maxmaxime83806 ай бұрын

    Callas is an enigma... She is not the greatest technician or the most impressive but she brings an emotion much more powerful than any other lyrical singer can give... She gives the impression of singing like a whole everyone and that makes her close to us, she doesn't sing an opera aria but she sings about life and pain and that touches us much more deeply....

  • @kheireddineguellour40

    @kheireddineguellour40

    5 ай бұрын

    Callas Is not the greatest technician, AHAHAHAHAHAHA fa già ridere così.

  • @roberthouston3809
    @roberthouston38098 ай бұрын

    Is this the song that is in the movie Bridges of Madison county?

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    6 ай бұрын

    No idea! I'll look into it.

  • @aflethgsb
    @aflethgsb4 ай бұрын

    Casta Diva, no, actually the entire opera is flooded with marvelous music. In fact, the last half an hour of Norma I can only listen to with damp eyes. I really love your enthusiasm. It has some similarities to Antonio Pappano's opera explanations.

  • @leadingblind1629
    @leadingblind162910 ай бұрын

    Ok. Please help lol Wtf is happening during Te Deum (Tosca)???? I'm just trying a few new arias tonight and ran into that one.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Girl I got you!

  • @user-wc7vn4cu3m
    @user-wc7vn4cu3m6 ай бұрын

    Could you make a video about your lifestyle? (How opera singers exercise, what they are eating) I heard that opera singers are one of the heathiest people

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    6 ай бұрын

    I sure can! I'm planning on filming while working in Vienna so it should be out in March or so? If you follow me on Instagram, I also have some lifestyle stuff, and I'd like to do more

  • @user-wc7vn4cu3m

    @user-wc7vn4cu3m

    6 ай бұрын

    @@operaanna thank you very much!

  • @nikiseminara4345
    @nikiseminara43454 ай бұрын

    An italian : the pronounce of Anita Cerquetti is very well. Your italian is fairly good, not perfect but good. Brava!

  • @thomasborgsmidt9801
    @thomasborgsmidt980110 ай бұрын

    I've heard Monserrat Caballe.

  • @PEriani67
    @PEriani6710 ай бұрын

    Yes in cases like Cerquetti in the "que" part each letter should be spelled separately like "q-u-e" differently by Spanish or French. Like in Questa e quella per me pari sono from Verdi's Rigoletto. By the way, so at least singers learns from the composer of the piece and not the other way around, like it has happened to me with musicians? Where there were always but the piece needs to be interpretate, but this is how I felt it, and so on... 😒

  • @ludovico6890
    @ludovico689010 ай бұрын

    I knew nothing about Norma until I watched this very video. That aria is used in like chocolate bars and car adverts. Each time I hear it I picture a woman cracking a piece of Caramilk.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Man I wish I'd known about that beforehand!

  • @ludovico6890

    @ludovico6890

    10 ай бұрын

    @@operaanna Maybe it's a false memory, not certain where I heard it before, but I'm fairly sure it was in an advert.

  • @saelind73
    @saelind733 ай бұрын

    Callas was not the most beautiful voice, ever. But the most divine one.

  • @ludovico6890
    @ludovico689010 ай бұрын

    And I thought Mozart's characters were naughty.

  • @rintintinification
    @rintintinification5 ай бұрын

    Big OperaAnna fan

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    4 ай бұрын

    ❤️❤️❤️

  • @sanlkar
    @sanlkar6 ай бұрын

    Hay que ser muy fanatico para preferir ESTA version de Callas antes que la de Caballé.

  • @franciscogutierrez6144
    @franciscogutierrez61447 ай бұрын

    Caballe own norma forever

  • @albertolara4297
    @albertolara42978 ай бұрын

    React to Diana Navarro is Maria Callas singing Casta Diva 18.11.2017 programa de Antena 3TVE TU CARA ME SUENA (YOUR FACE IS FAMILIAR TO MEI,m suscribe.Diana is the woman with three lungs.Thank you and greetings from Zaragoza (Spain)

  • @ericlilley4706
    @ericlilley470610 күн бұрын

    Caballe wins.

  • @xwiirastusx
    @xwiirastusx3 ай бұрын

    I know you'll hate me for this but I have never cared much for Maria Callas either. She was a definite Primadonna Assoluta of her day, but after her voice dropped and her difficult behaviour as well as her choice in men (virtually becoming a pet of the Greek tycoon Aristoteles Onassis) I lost respect for her.

  • @leadingblind1629
    @leadingblind162910 ай бұрын

    Hey Anna! What is it about very old opera recordings that make their Divas sound like mature 60 year olds when they open their mouths?

  • @ludovico6890

    @ludovico6890

    10 ай бұрын

    Bad/primitive recording tech at the time. Also different criteria for the voice. That's my hypothesis anyway.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Hahaha oh no 😂 sadly, the earliest recording devices stripped the voice of a lot of the richness of and overtones. In our history class, the teacher once brought in a really old recorder (can't remember what kind) and it made everyone sound really similar for exactly the reasons I said. But if you listen to them enough, you can hear the differences and piece together what the voice sounded like.

  • @atizaries5512
    @atizaries551225 күн бұрын

    Dear. Anna, are you not well learned to differ lyric tenor from spinto tenor repertoire! It is unanimously acknowleged, that the part of Calaf has always been solely for Corelli, not Pavarotti, who would never surpass Corelli!!

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    23 күн бұрын

    There is no tenor in this aria...

  • @atizaries5512

    @atizaries5512

    2 күн бұрын

    Do you r😢eallything l am that ignorant? I just couldn',t find that. cl😊ip in which you admire Pav.

  • @thomasborgsmidt9801
    @thomasborgsmidt980110 ай бұрын

    It was perhaps the aria that destroyed several singers. Maria Callas primarily. I believe it was this this opera that smashed Callas in Rome and did not come out after the interval. She probably comitted suicide - her freind Elisabeth Schwarzkopf tried to visit her. And Schwarzkopf was a battleaxe. There is a video with Callas where she recieves applause and is definately not satisfied. Ponselle only appeared in Italy in one - now forgotten opera - otherwise she is an all-american singer. She retired early. Monserrat Caballe had a sad ending as well. She was convicted of taxevasion in Spain through Andorra. She did not go to prison, as she was much reduced and not fit for prison - she died shortly after the pardon. It might be that the operas are beutifull,, but the theater world is ugly. Perhaps that is why so many sopranos are bitches. Nelly Melba being now only remembered for the dessert named after her. Louisa Tetrazzinii is another of food fame. She had a sad ending as well, because her lover stole all her money. Now for taking a bow, there is nobody like the "Gioisa": Bartoli. She once made an encore with "Non piu mesta" in the applause and dragged the whole cast - including choir - into it. She is now the manager of the Monte Carlo opera. Which is a good thing - if you disagree with her in theater matters - you better come prepared, as she will crush hams. Allmost as bad as confiscating the parmesan cheese in her lugage. Now there is a problem with interpretationn.. Mozart f.i. wrote down the bare minimum and in his performances he added ornaments. We know that positively, as there is a letter where his sister Nanrl wants him to write out ornaments - which he does. The other problem is that most arias are tailor fitting to a particular voice. Meaning there are more than one appropriate score. Beethoven is particularly difficult here. He generally had his score for symphonies printed in 50 copies, but when a theater/orchester bought a score he read through it before sending it - and he CORRECTED the damned score - and not consistently. So if you perform a Beethoven work the question is allways: Which version. Beethoven dispared over Fidelio and left it with: It is as good as it is going to get - after writing 3 ouvertures. Carl Nielsen had the same problem: He did not know how to end "Maskerade" and finally threw his hands up and said: That is the best I can do - as his ouverture is one the best pieces in Danish music. He hated his job.

  • @leilathomas2536

    @leilathomas2536

    2 ай бұрын

    Callas didn't commit suicide. It's confirmed that she had dermatomyositis, which contributed to her vocal decline as well

  • @martinfitzgerald6705
    @martinfitzgerald67053 ай бұрын

    While your analysis is excellent, I find your constant interruptions over the course of the aria more than annoying! Perhaps an uninterrupted video of the whole aria followed by a more detailed breakdown of the various parts of the aria would be more satisfactory and informative for your loyal subscribers ❤

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    3 ай бұрын

    While I would love to be able to show the full aria first, unfortunately the copyright on many of the videos I show lead to a video being blocked if I leave it up for too long before stopping it again. However I absolutely understand your point, so perhaps I can direct people to the full video linked in the description box first, so that they might be familiar with it already! I'll try that next time, thank you for the suggestion

  • @pepitogrillo8263
    @pepitogrillo82638 ай бұрын

    Callas always struggles with the higher notes. For me is a super turn of because bell canto always have the peak of emotion in the higher note and she always trips in the most important moment. Screams, slows the vibrato and loses harmonics.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    6 ай бұрын

    I would say that only starts to happen in the later years of her career. Before the voice started to suffer she had a mastery of the high notes, and there are many examples of it to be found. I agree though, in the later years her top notes really really suffer.

  • @pepitogrillo8263

    @pepitogrillo8263

    6 ай бұрын

    @@operaanna She never had later years she retired at 40. Most greater sopranos have their peak at that age.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    6 ай бұрын

    @@pepitogrillo8263 I said the later years of her career. Don't forget her incredibly tumultuous personal life that completely shot her confidence, which she herself said was the reason her voice suffered.

  • @istvanbartha7985
    @istvanbartha798510 ай бұрын

    Now I got tired of your comments, zip it

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    If you read the description, you'd know it and abuse I'm trying to keep the video from getting blocked. 🤷

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    I also find it slightly annoying 🤐🙈

  • @riastal6129
    @riastal612910 ай бұрын

    I don't know why but i don't like Callas. My vote is for Montserrat, i think she is one of greatest singers of all time's. I had never heard of this other singer, Anita, but she is good too.

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    10 ай бұрын

    Interesting! Do you not like her specifically here or just in general? I'd also never heard of Anita but upon hearing her in this I had to include her!

  • @riastal6129

    @riastal6129

    10 ай бұрын

    @operaanna I'll never liked her. Not her voice and not and not who she tries to be. I feel she is not "real" and plays always the same role.

  • @riastal6129

    @riastal6129

    10 ай бұрын

    @operaanna I am a big fan from Joyce DiDonato, she is real and a great person too. She has a fantastic voice.

  • @santi7616

    @santi7616

    9 ай бұрын

    I like a lot Anita cerquetti, her voice is really beautiful , no wonder she was THE other Norma in Rome . you said that callas reminds you Ponselle ,yes I agree with you , I feel the same , I imagine she used to listen a lot of live broadcasting from the Metropolitan while living in New York city as a teenager . your channel is fabulous ,I've just discovered . I wish one day you talk about my favorite aria "al dolce guidami" and Edita gruberova .😊❤ best regards

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    9 ай бұрын

    @@santi7616 I'll add it to the list! So glad you like the content! 🥰

  • @edithhenson6917
    @edithhenson69173 ай бұрын

    Just shut up and listen to the beautiful voice of Callas!

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    3 ай бұрын

    If you'd like to watch the uninterrupted version of Callas' interpretation, I have it linked in the description box! ❤️

  • @istvanbartha7985
    @istvanbartha798510 ай бұрын

    Good that you recognise good music...perhaps you should talk a little less and listen more

  • @bonkerss2073
    @bonkerss2073Күн бұрын

    Can you do Come E Bello from Lucrecia Borgia

  • @bonkerss2073
    @bonkerss2073Күн бұрын

    all soubd fabulous in their own styler but for me Caballe is the best Norma.

  • @panagislefkokilos3082
    @panagislefkokilos30827 ай бұрын

    i love opera and i love opera singers i am 55 years old and i cant explain even to my self why i cry when i look and listen to that woman but i dont think it happens because i am greek i think it happens to many many people that woman had something divine if only i could find the words in english to explain what i mean .i can tell you this every time i listen to maria i feal loved as a human in this earth if that make any sence love from greece

  • @operaanna

    @operaanna

    7 ай бұрын

    Makes sense! I agree, she had something divine

  • @billlegakis9155
    @billlegakis915510 ай бұрын

    Have I told you how cute you are?

  • @billlegakis9155
    @billlegakis915510 ай бұрын

    god you are so damn cute....

Келесі