She has the right to free speech. As long as she's not threatening or harassing anyone, then she's well within the bounds of the first amendment and the law. If people don't like her, then they don't have to listen to or associate with her. We're still a (semi) free country.

@azul8811

11 ай бұрын

True enough, but you say that people don’t have to listen. So what does some student and their family do sitting at the graduation? How do they not listen?

@najwaalsadi

11 ай бұрын

I totally agree with and she spoke the truth, like or not, stop the bullying.

@lastfm4477

11 ай бұрын

Except that you want you receive your diploma in person, you *HAD* to be there and so *HAD* to listen to her. I have no problem with her expressing her political opinions. It was the "“Time, Place, and Manner” regulations" that made her speech not acceptable. It is reasonable for a public school (ie, that receives tax payer money) to place a reasonable restriction on what is said at school-wide graduation gatherings where there is a wide spread of racial, religious, and political beliefs - where those folks had little choice in being there.

@abdell75roussos

5 ай бұрын

@@najwaalsadi Imagine coming from countries where murder, execution, prison, harassment for; gay, trans, other religion. Modern slavery. Death for dating another religion.... little to no women's rights, child marriage, genital mutilation.... Why would a person like her with her ideas live in the USA then? Obviously even hates its constitution. Wonder how long it takes before this comment is flagged.

@abdell75roussos

5 ай бұрын

@@lastfm4477 This person is pretty vile, and considering her background... I wonder if the problem with their own religion is so over whelming and troubling, that the go on the offensive? Know the stats for 911, and who did it? Irrationality is also part of the mix. Serious question, what do you think?

Thank you Sir for clarification of her rights

@abdell75roussos

5 ай бұрын

Wonder what her rights are in the countries she comes from?

@SIMBAofSIMBA

5 ай бұрын

@@abdell75roussos that's irrelevant you twat,she lives in the US and US law should be applied

Notice she was not interrupted, in any way. Do you think an Israeli student would be able to make a speech there without interruption? That’s the true test of Rights.

@hamzazad5258

Жыл бұрын

What would an Israeli student say lol Israeli student are part of the settler colonialist program that is Israel. Your analogy, like your state, has no leg to stand on.

@chief_9938

11 ай бұрын

do the israeli students need a free speech? Fox news is enough for them.

@JonDoe-fo3kl

11 ай бұрын

i never seen anyone lose their jobs for croticizing palestine...But say the word jew and you lose everything lake yeezy kyrie ect

@faceplants599

11 ай бұрын

Because Palestinians are on the right side of history, Israelis are turds

@CJLAKE123

11 ай бұрын

That’s a prime example of individuals who are too afraid to give push back, apathetic to give it because they don’t believe that it doesn’t affect them & when she’s done she’ll go about her day & that’ll be the end of it. Or, they don’t know how to push back.

Proud of you Girl❤🎉

Truth truth

Thank you for your honest review!

Words are not bullet…bullets are bullets

Proud of our Yemeni sister, she's very intelligent. You go, girl, put them in their place. May Allah protect you and bless you. #FreePalestine ❤️🖤🤍💚🇵🇸✌️

What a brave woman! I can imagine her speaking out the same way when Hitler indiscriminately targeted European Jews.

I have no problem with her expressing her political opinions. It was the "“Time, Place, and Manner” regulations" that made her speech not acceptable. If you wanted to receive your diploma in person, you *HAD* to be there and so *HAD* to listen to her. You could not just walk out with no harm to yourself. It is reasonable for a public school (ie, that receives tax payer money) to place a reasonable restriction on what is said at school-wide graduation gatherings where there is a wide spread of racial, religious, and political beliefs - where those folks had little choice in being there.

@rebirth_mishap

7 ай бұрын

they could've walked out if they wanted. they would just get their piece of paper in the mail

@lastfm4477

7 ай бұрын

@@rebirth_mishap No. They *earned* the right to be at their graduation ceremony. Not be run out of it.

@rebirth_mishap

7 ай бұрын

@@lastfm4477 I agree. IJS they don't have to stay if they don't want to

@lastfm4477

7 ай бұрын

@@rebirth_mishap Glad you agree that graduates shouldn't have been run out of their ceremony by the drivel of this speech.

@naimaabedin6111

4 ай бұрын

She's bringing attention to literal CRIMES and atrocities and your issue is "it's not the place"? People need to realize what these speeches and protests are meant to do. The aim is to make you uncomfortable, to make you think. What would be the point of her speaking to only pro-Palestinians or pro- whatever else she stated? She'd be talking to people that already agree with her, how is that helpful? Every place is the damn place to do it until there's a change.

Gawd, imagine having to listen to THAT at your graduation.

@Mandyesq

Жыл бұрын

I know. 🫤

@rachelcorrie8928

Жыл бұрын

l listened to it 11 times, it's inspiring to hear the truth.

@BishopWalters12

11 ай бұрын

@@rachelcorrie8928 LOL, good one

@brice8015

11 ай бұрын

SubhanAllah

@faceplants599

11 ай бұрын

Fatima is a hero

She has the right to say it but nobody has to hire or work with her in the future because that is how freedom works.

@faceplants599

11 ай бұрын

Oh you Zionists will definitely use your influence to make sure she isn’t hired

She seems ... "nice"...

Yes this is true. It also applies to Major League Baseball on how not too long ago in the 2009 out a player can be composed to go through mandatory training for what they said that may or may not be offensive

@johnnymookergee4935

11 ай бұрын

Not only is she is a Jew hating racist , she can’t speak English

If only such a speach had been delivered at a graduation ceremony in any Muslim country,US authorities would have announced a Nobel prize for her courage of convictions.

@hswing11

11 ай бұрын

And you leave my country NOW

@fauxbro1983

11 ай бұрын

She wouldn't be attending college in a Muslim country. Lol

@ahmadzenji

10 ай бұрын

@@fauxbro1983 *me a Muslim disappears as I learn that my college never existed according to your comment*

@citizinslife

7 ай бұрын

Hope you that the graduation gown that westerners all wear comes from Muslims. So I think it fits the occasion

@lacasitos60

6 ай бұрын

@@fauxbro1983the first university was founded by a Muslim woman Fatima in 857 in a Muslim country

Dia dan temannya adalah wanita yang cantik dan membuka pikirannya ke masa depan

Thanks for an objective view

Right the First Amendment is powerful. Israel does not provide the same right.

I think she is talking about her own religion but projecting it onto Israel because she wouldn't dare say anything against Islam.

This brave sole from Yemen is my hero!!

@briancox9357

10 ай бұрын

Soul.

I would have definitely interrupted her, she was courageous for making this speech, but where were the students to Retort her comments??

She doesn't have to practice law or even live in the US. If you don't like our systems, and our ways of doing things, you don't have to live here. She is free to take her bias elsewhere.

@mahjabeenkausar4917

7 ай бұрын

People who can't handle the condemnation of the wrong doing will use the "leave my country card" Because according to you what government do is the right thing if tomorrow the government occupied your house you will be happy for that as well tomorrow the government take your kids brainwash them you will be ok with that too because according to you "the government and the system is always right" 😂😂😏😏 and people say western countries are more liberal and has freedom of speech 😏 they can't even digest the true colors of there own government

@sadiya09

6 ай бұрын

@thomast8539 i hope your opinion about this girl has changed. If not its sad.

@naimaabedin6111

4 ай бұрын

What kind of asinine comment is that? If people from history that criticized their country just left instead of working towards a change, how would any improvements to the system be made? Also, bias is a stupid argument to make when someone is literally just stating facts.

She did say what's on the mind of the oppressed people.

@digger1825

9 ай бұрын

Who is oppressed here in the USA? I'm tired of these little brats crying over something that never happened in my lifetime or hers. I didn't get to go to a Prestigious college, am I Oppressed? If you don't like it here go somewhere else 🙄

@electriczombie8299

9 ай бұрын

​@@digger1825people claiming to be oppressed in the west are just trying to gain leverage and power. And the mainstream conservative movement (with some exceptions) are a bunch of cowards who are too scared to call them out because they don't want to be called racist.

@abdell75roussos

5 ай бұрын

You will find flight out very cheap, to countries in the ME where you will be happier where there is death or prison for those wanting women's rights, gay, trans, non believers, forced marriage, those that leave the religion.....let alone free speech.

She is as anti-American as she comes. The true question is, will she condemn Hamas?

@brice8015

11 ай бұрын

SubhanAllah

@najwaalsadi

11 ай бұрын

This is always the response from people like u when they lose the argument, who is killing children, women and men?? “Israel “ who is imprisoning Palestinian Children, women and without due process for years?? “Israel “ Who is stealing land, homes and possessions of Palestinian? “Israel”

@env0x

11 ай бұрын

you mean anti-american-hegemony*

@HoldenNY22

8 ай бұрын

@@najwaalsadi - And Who killed Innocent Olympic Athletes at the 1972 Munich Olympics- Palestenian Terrorists. Who is killing innocent Jewish Civilians in Israel and aorund the World- Palestenian Terrorists.

How embarrassing. Imagine being that out of touch with reality.

@brice8015

11 ай бұрын

SubhanAllah

@faceplants599

11 ай бұрын

She’s a hero

@brice8015

11 ай бұрын

@@faceplants599 Bigg Talk

@idontcare6505

11 ай бұрын

Go to the Muslim lands of Israel. You’ll see if she’s out of touch with reality.

@ramlah91

7 ай бұрын

Imagine that😂 Oh the irony! People like you wouldn’t recognise reality even if it hit you in the face.

She is absolutely 💯 right!!

@Bytheriversofbabylonhc

Жыл бұрын

This is the brain of a people that believes they are getting 72 virgins in heaven., And that camel urine is healthy for those that drink it 😂😂😂

@hamzazad5258

Жыл бұрын

Yeah.

@ddavis235

11 ай бұрын

She is 100% an idiot.

Medieval blood libel

@HoldenNY22

9 ай бұрын

I agree with you. It is a lie to say that all Jews are Rich. I live in a Studio Apartment in Queens, NY with no Car, No Dishwasher and not a lot of money in the Bank

A fair assessment of her speech without personal judgements. I did not hear one antisemitic statement. Thanks.

Fatima for president!

@azul8811

11 ай бұрын

Of Yemen.

Protected speech, sure, but to give that as a commencement speech is off the charts obnoxious. I wonder what the parents of her classmates who came to celebrate their children's accomplishments thought after being subjected to that virtue signaling tirade. I also wonder what law firms will think of the terrible judgement she demonstrated as she and her freshly minted law degree enter the real world.

@najwaalsadi

Жыл бұрын

When was it a crime to speak the truth of what’s going on with the Palestinian situation dealing with brutal regime Israel?? Or is freedom of speech is permissible when it suits us??

@azul8811

11 ай бұрын

@@najwaalsadiWho said that it was a crime?

@brice8015

11 ай бұрын

SubhanAllah

@najwaalsadi

11 ай бұрын

Since when speaking the truth leads to all your gloomy and unfounded accusation and predictions, she will do just fine whether u agree or not.

@lastfm4477

11 ай бұрын

@@najwaalsadi Can you read English and actually understand it? The point if this comment was that to give this speech, even if truth, was inappropriate at a commencement ceremony. Did the comment you are replying to say anything about what she said being true or false?

They shouldn't, and can't, punish her. But, they never should have had her speak to begin with.

@najwaalsadi

Жыл бұрын

What did she say?? That was so wrong?? She spoke the truth even if don’t like to hear it.

@JonDoe-fo3kl

11 ай бұрын

​​@@najwaalsadihe said what we know but cant say...google rachel corrie shes not the only one but there are laws that prohibit us from criticizing a j*w. antisemite is a word they created to prevent ppl from speaking up. They not even real semites they came from germany n russia

@faceplants599

11 ай бұрын

She’s a hero, CUNY should be proud

@idontcare6505

11 ай бұрын

According to the 1st Constitutional Amendment of America, everyone has freedom of speech and freedom of religion. However, hate speech does not count as free speech. She is only talking about the violation of human rights in Israel and spreads awareness about it. So why should you take away her freedom of speech?

@Sheryl510

11 ай бұрын

@@najwaalsadi You keep saying the same thing in every comment. Why is it the truth? Because you keep repeating it? She's right about the indiscriminate killings by Israeli forces, but she needs to butt out of black people and white people issues.

I didn’t hear any antisemitism remarks. She is criticizing a government of Israel. This is so scary that in usa you can criticize anyone including your government but you cant dare to criticize a foreign government ( Israel)

@ghostq8625

11 ай бұрын

But she mentioned the nakba that happened in 1948 and has nothing to with Israel, at that time other Arab nations expelled the Arabs who call themselves Palestinian, and people forget that they r refuges also in Syria and Lebanon but that doesn't go with the Palestinian agenda

@HoldenNY22

9 ай бұрын

Anti-Zionism is many times thinly disguised Anti-Senitsm. In this case of her Speech it was. She never once talked about Peace between the Arabs and Jews in Israel.. Her use of the term Colonial Settlers was just another way of saying Rich Jews. That is an Evil, Evil Lie to say that all Jews are Rich and they run the World.

@ramlah91

7 ай бұрын

@@ghostq8625Educate yourself before trying to educate others. The nakba in 1948 is due to the terrorist state of Israel.

Its truth not like it.Tuff.

Pure facts she said

The biggest problem is that people are listening to these lies and think it's all true. Coming from a Law Department in a NY University! That's crazy. Give terrorist a safe place to live and free education and that's what you get...

@NetanelMaor

6 ай бұрын

She is a terrorist

@NetanelMaor

6 ай бұрын

What happened on Oct 7th just proved that. Radical islam is a cancer spreading through the world... Islam in general is growing in an alarming rate ⚠

I agree with her on BDS. Cancel culture started somewhere and until various political sects acknowledge it, there won't be any progress. But unfortunately, Ben Shapiro owns The Daily Wire and they have a disproportionate voice right now and he'll never admit it.

Saya tidak faham kenapa Konservatif Kristian & Liberal-Sosialis mahu menyokong Zionis walaupun ajaran sebenar nilai kekeluargaan, malah sesat dari nilai agama mereka sentiasa mahu memburuk-burukkan orang Islam & juga Yahudi anti-Zionis. Saya bertaruh jika Sosialisme Komunis mahu mempertahankan pelajar Yaman Pro-Palestin walaupun terdapat ketegangan ideologi terhadap agama. Tetap solidariti dengan Fatima Mohammed dari Malaysia. Walaupun CUNY dikecam oleh ahli politik AS yang pro-Ukraine, orang Islam, Cina & juga Rusia akan berdiri solidariti untuk kebenaran atas pembohongan. Jika Ted Cruz menuduh pelajar Yaman di AS kerana antisemitisme, maka kami akan menuduhnya menghasut Islamofobia.

Such students should not be allowed to give speech. She is not a 10 year old kid. She should show the maturity to give right message based on time and place I don't think her upper level is fully baked yet. She should not be allowed to graduate with such low attitude.

I'm glad I got into crypto when I did because it was a turning point for me financially, and it was the best decision I've made so far..

@sophiaclark820

Жыл бұрын

INTERESTING HOW CAN I DO THAT?

@George-232

Жыл бұрын

@@sophiaclark820 You actually need an expert trader assigned by a registered brokerage company to help you out. I currently trade with Mrs Brisa Richardson . She is the best when it comes to high profits in the market!

@pamalapaul9545

Жыл бұрын

Wow😊l know her and I have also been trading with her, she's such an amazing woman with good skills keeps me happy all week knowing I earn 15thousand extra income trading with her.

@mariohugo6219

Жыл бұрын

Actually thought I was the only one trading with Mrs Brisa Richardson!. she currently manages all my funds too and she also provides webinars on how to trade perfectly without losses, I haven't started on my own yet, still building up my portfolio with her help now.

@Fontesmedlin

Жыл бұрын

Mrs Brisa Richardson is the best expert trader I have seen on a certified broker, I've invested with her for years. Profits are secured and over a 100 percent return on investment. Everyone she processes his or her trade is so lucky, all you have to do is believe in her and follow her guidance. Then sip your drink and relax.

Hell, Israel lost its land 2000years ago. Palestinians are the interlopers here. Israel was the country given to the remnants after thevholocaust. I would have walked from this.😊

@najwaalsadi

Жыл бұрын

Unfortunately u need some education, read more u owe it to yourself. No one has the right to give someone else’s land to another.

@najwaalsadi

11 ай бұрын

Palestinian have nothing to do with the holocaust, by the way when western world Germany killing Jews the other western countries such as England, including America refused to allow Jews to land on its soil, the Arab world opened its arms and welcome Jews to their land including Palestine. Read a history book it may benefit u.

@idontcare6505

11 ай бұрын

“We were kicked out of our land because we were busy killing prophets and ignoring the teachings of God. So when God punished us, we were surprised. When we finally got our land back illegally, we decided to kill people who did nothing wrong to us only because our ancestors killed our ancestors. At the end of the day, God forgives murder and mass genocides.”

@ghostq8625

11 ай бұрын

The first zionist congression was assembled in 1881, even before the First World War I, and has nothing to do with the Holocaust

@8redbeat4

11 ай бұрын

Lol Palestine had cities built before Ibrahim even move to that land.. So the Jews were temporary occupiers before... And they are occupiers now.. U know what's funny? Occupiers always lose and perish in the end

She's just parroting the current official ideology of the American Empire except for the part about Israel. Support for Israel is an unprincipled exception for the Regime.

Why do all of these Muslim women sound the same when they speak English? She sounds like Ilhan Omar.

@bibishah7754

5 ай бұрын

I think that people with semitic languages as their mothertongue has this nasal sound to it and often you can hear this among native speakers of arab and hebrew when they switch to their second language