The production of this documentary is outstanding. The revisiting of the empty cable car throughout the film is a powerful symbol of death, loss, and remembrance.

@Lardenoy

Жыл бұрын

True ! Very sad and symbolic...

@Ghiani16

10 ай бұрын

i agree. except for the dubbing part. I dislike it a lot. I dont like an English speaking person translating someone speaking Polish Looses authenticity

@120M

9 ай бұрын

It is not a cable car.

@richardduplessis1090

4 ай бұрын

Not as bruital as Gaza though

@timnicholas1832

3 ай бұрын

​@@richardduplessis1090 Well, for cryin' out loud!

Old Warsaw Ghetto is now mostly Muranów district of Warsaw, i lived there recently (close to Pawiak prison) and fact worth mentioning is that most of those reconstructed buildings were made using rubble of old ones. And the remains of people murdered are still there. It was the intention of post war architect of the district to rebuild this place this way, so there was no actual professional exhumantions. "Sea of rubble" was 3 meters high so they didnt dig into the basements and just builded over it (thats why most of the buildings stands on little hills). If you do any groundwork around the district you can still find human bones, old building parts etc. Some of which are right under the sidewalks (old building rubble) and visible as the sidewalk slowly collapses over time. Living in this part of Warsaw was really special, hard to explain, it was just different than anywhere else. To all souls lost in this tragedy - rest in peace. Never again war

@Tali5899

2 жыл бұрын

It's an appalling atrocity how you have built parts of buildings and sidewalks built from many old Jewish graves with inscriptions still clearly visible.Youf people have no regrets and no respect obviously. A shame and disgrace.And on top of that your government has tried to deny the Holocaust.Well unfortunately for you Jews have long memories and we will make sure the world remembers.

@glendaharris7219

2 жыл бұрын

And yet now 2022 we have horrible things happening in Ukraine 🇺🇦. May we all remember Hitlers terrible reign! Never again....

@56dh

Жыл бұрын

Ty for this insight. I have studied the Holocaust, but didn't know about rebuilding on top of the rubble.

@Superstarshaker

4 ай бұрын

@reykuu, thanks for the information, very interesting and informative

@2TexasTuff

Ай бұрын

Sidebar : If i became aware of remains/artifacts I would reverently step back as to not disturb the memory/essence of those individuals and their places of life. 🙂‍↕️

My mother was from Lodz. Her and her family was put on a train going to Auschwitz. She survived but her mother and father and brothers and sisters didn't. My poor mother may she rip...

@martinanedvedova5248

Жыл бұрын

I am deeply sorry for your loss. I am Catholic. I always think of Jewish people as my brothers and sisters. I am grieving for what they had to go through in this world and sometimes they still have to. I would like to ask them for forgiveness. I do not know whether it is even possible. Hello from Prague.

@user-se1xs2et3t

9 ай бұрын

all lies all fake

@2TexasTuff

Ай бұрын

@@martinanedvedova5248indeed we ARE all brothers and sisters no matter our beliefs and non beliefs. 🙏🏼 Hello from Arizona US…

@trubberdox3089

28 күн бұрын

You a zionist?

@Maya-11146

28 күн бұрын

I am sorry fpr you loss. 😔

A sad, and excellent film. I was in Warsaw in 1973 and saw the old city being rebuilt, and noticed the contrast between the beautiful, old Polish architecture and the stark, concrete blocks of the Stalinist buildings. It was the saddest city I have ever visited. In the centre there were shrines on almost every corner where the Nazis had massacred people, Poles, Jews or whoever was in their way. Let us not forget.

I always like to be in the company of older people and listen to their life story they simply have a vast knowledge of life..

@ajantaellora9414

3 жыл бұрын

Vast experience too

@BaenjaminS

3 жыл бұрын

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

@Teacher7791

3 жыл бұрын

You are not alone,l am too.....

@veenalouis5625

3 жыл бұрын

@@Teacher7791 that's nice...

@veenalouis5625

3 жыл бұрын

@@ajantaellora9414 your right

I am a young Varsovian, and I hope that everyone gets to see the city at some point. Today’s Warsaw is not like Their Warsaw anymore, but it is beautiful in its decay, modernity, but first and foremost, history. We shall never forget what happened, never again!!

@amazingsupergirl7125

2 жыл бұрын

Except it has happened in other countries and is happening in China right now

@normamimosa5991

2 жыл бұрын

From the perspective of the physical Warsaw (versus the people, its history and soul), from this documentary I see a city bathed in trees and soviet structures. Overtime, perhaps these structures will be imploded and new ones built. Having said that, I bet the apartments in those soviet buildings are larger than apartments and condos in today's hastily built glass towers.

@jazura2

2 жыл бұрын

It would be good to see how Warsaw looked before the war. It was a beautiful city. Then see it now 2021. It has changed so fast even in the years since this documentary. I was there in 1991..There was nothing. No skyline except the Russian Culture building.

@jerzykowalski7772

2 жыл бұрын

I'm Polish, Warsaw was very beautiful, but for now this city is a garbage. But current polish government want to rebuild more old buildings, so lets wait and See how will the Warsaw looks like.

@fishingpinky3165

2 жыл бұрын

I will be in Warsaw Oct 5 2021. I have watched holocaust history for many years. Excited but sad to visit. Love from the USA, Florida

This is my home. I'm 2nd generation American. My grandparents moved here before Hitler invaded Poland. They would have surely died in the camps. God bless all who suffered and rest in peace 🙏💔💋

@MsAliceinwonderland

2 жыл бұрын

Thankful your family relocated.

@lindataylor3834

2 жыл бұрын

Praise God that your family moved away in time.

@tonyapatriot9350

2 жыл бұрын

God always saves a remnant of His people! Blessings!

@HafizRakiman

2 жыл бұрын

RIP 😢

@leonaphelps7204

2 жыл бұрын

Lool) pomp) kpbs ml.l Mo 9 Lllk

I've been to Warsaw couple of times, it is a vibrant, modern city full of happy and amazing people. It is unbelieveable how much history, tears and blood that city saw. Warsaw is like Fenix, the will of people will always keep it alive. Greeting from Australia and all the best, Poland please become a local superpower and keep progressing towards the strenght.

@fbeshir1163

2 жыл бұрын

Bible can't be a historicaI document because it contains prophecies.

@Tali5899

2 жыл бұрын

They are totally spooked by the people they buried under the newly built Warsaw.

@ukaszmuszynski9788

Жыл бұрын

We r geting there. Meaning becoming local superpower. We use to be very strong country and one of the biggest in Europe. We could fight with other superpowers at the same time and usually win if not we still made it to exist. We had to fought with Ottoman Empire, Holy Roman Empire of German House, Teoutonic Order, Russians (we had to occupie Moscov for 2 years) Sweden, Tatars(Mongols) Czech Kingdom and others. But finally we had lost. Losers dont write history. Winers do. Thats why in English speakin countrys Such as yours we r seen as dumb savages, barbarians. Its proven that thanks to German imigrants to the States and Canada and Iam sure Australia too. We have been viewd as stupid, dumb and very backwards cultur Group of People. Mark my words. Poland will b superpower again and Its gona Take US that long. Look already what we have achive during only 30 years of real independence. Poland is not developing country anymore. Its developed one. We have stronger economy then any of eastern European country. Economy is bigger then Grece, Portugal and geting close to Spain and Italy. All of this in just 30 years. Australia become a new superpower, better then U. S. ALL THE BEST TO U PEOPLE.

@KrisKASK

Жыл бұрын

@@ukaszmuszynski9788I promise you not in America they think that. There’s many of us polish diaspora here

@alijamil122

Жыл бұрын

Kyt

History must never be forgotten. We should respect each other. Say no to any kind of racism.

@lindacollins6939

3 жыл бұрын

Never, never,never forget.

@cherrybell2995

2 жыл бұрын

Love should always be stronger than hate. Even if it is just our own heart. We can't always control outside forces or political powers,, but with God's grace we can be kind and loving to all of God's children creation.

@prairierider7569

Жыл бұрын

It just happened and still happening in the Middle East, China, nk, Russia, ukraine and Canadians that are unjabbed

@Jenvlogs404

Жыл бұрын

Race is not the topic here, certain ideoIogies should say no to and even written in some books, trying to equaIize is the worst thing and taking their voice.

@j.k.3642

Жыл бұрын

I agree with you!

Thank you for this documentary. I have been living in Warsaw for the last 8 years and I think it is the best city in the world. It was rebuilt from the ashes and now it is again a 2-million-people metropolis. It is my home. There is no comparison to the night view of the city skyline rising upon Vistula riverbanks in the evening. This city has the ability to survive and thrive no matter what. Documentaries like this one are important, especially today, in times of hate, discrimination, lies and misinformation - we must NEVER repeat the mistakes of the past. NIGDY WIĘCEJ WOJNY - KEIN KRIEG MEHR - NO MORE WAR.

@olavwilhelm6843

3 жыл бұрын

i've been to Warsaw once and i am sure it once was beautiful but today one rather ugly city with all the communist concrete architecture

@alphagamma6709

3 жыл бұрын

I will visit your beautiful city once the pandemic is over.😃

@patriciabrenner9216

3 жыл бұрын

@@olavwilhelm6843 it may have been beautiful. Now it reminds me of a Disney cartoon Nowy swiat ulica was rebuilt as it was before the one that was destroyed because they had no money.

@MrPaultopp

3 жыл бұрын

Didn’t foreigners rebuild the city ?

@JanGotner

3 жыл бұрын

@@MrPaultopp No, Polish people themselves returned to live in ruins and rebuilt the city with their own hands, women and men alike, including many renowned pre-war Modernist architects like Bohdan Pniewski or Stefan Karpiński. Forgeigners from USSR were partially involved only in the construction of the Palace of Culture and Science in the centre of Warsaw.

My heart weeps for those who perished. Thank you for sharing this. May their memory be a blessing. Never forget and never again.

Thanks for a superb doc on the terrible times of the ghetto . We must never forget … 🙏

I recently watched Mark Felton's series on the ghetto uprising and now this. I am so thankful for all the high quality documentarians on youtube.

@patriciabrenner9216

3 жыл бұрын

The kibbutz Lochamei hagetaot in Northern Israel was founded by survivors of the uprising of the Warsaw ghetto, notabli Icchak Cukierman

@elvenkind6072

2 жыл бұрын

Professor Felton have great productions and so much bizarre and normally, historically unknown content.

@CimotaTJ

2 жыл бұрын

Where can I see the movie?

My grandfather was polish and came to the uk at the start of the war. He was part of the polish Air Force. He was always an angry man and would never ever discuss the war. If something came on the tv about the war or concentration camps, he was roar in anger to switch it off. Sadly we will never know what he saw or lived through. He always loved his home country and only got to return once, and that was when he retired. He seemed calm and happier when he came back, for a time but, at least he got to see his family one more time. Over all the years they kept in touch by letter every single month and he always sent money, right up until he had a massive stroke and couldn’t anymore. It’s disgusting what happened to the people of Poland and especially Jewish communities all over Europe too. May they all rest in peace.

@andrewjoyce9038

2 жыл бұрын

England not uk

@karenjewell6543

Жыл бұрын

When I was a kid,in the 70s,my Polish grandma would collect our old clothes and send them over.(from US) Her family was still there & letters were sent back n forth..One time she showed us a picture.There was a boy my age (8ish) wearing my old baby blue,fake fur cuffed parka..With a smile like he hit the lottery..That's when I got the poverty/communism talk..The coat was warm,that's all that mattered.Spun my head..When I was older she told me that she would put brand new Levi's in the boxes that they could trade for $$$..

@jennawalden8547

Жыл бұрын

@@karenjewell6543 that’s a lovely account. Bless your grandma and your family x

@jennawalden8547

Жыл бұрын

I know there was a Polish airforce based here in the UK. And they fought hard. The British Government treated them appallingly after the war, completely dismissive of all their vital help. This country wouldn’t have won the war without the Polish. Perhaps that’s why your grandfather was so angry. A very belated thank you from myself and my family ❤️❤️

@cherylk.2474

Жыл бұрын

@@karenjewell6543 Both of my father's parents came from Poland, but my Grandma died in 1963, I was about 7 years old. My Grandfather never spoke of anyone in Poland, I don't think he was able to contact any surviving family. I know he came from Tarnow, and I found on-line records of his 1880 baptism. I intend to travel there after I retire.

What a wonderful film. Thank to all who were involved in the film's production. It's been years since I've been in Warsaw but wish to return and follow the ghetto history.

This was a very moving documentary. You could almost feel the fear and pain of some the people in the ghetto

An empty tram running through the streets of Warsaw every year... So powerful.

@swissotto1

3 жыл бұрын

Yes. Very poignant!

@tomflendodo7297

3 жыл бұрын

@@swissotto1 : AN EMPTY TRAM ?? WHAT'S THE POINT

@tomflendodo7297

3 жыл бұрын

@@degamispoudegamis : DID U HAVE ONE ??? DO U HAVE MOMMY ISSUES !!!! NICK ????????? Y DID SHE HATE U ??✡ ✡ ✡

@aniagoszczynski8194

3 жыл бұрын

Robert, U need to Pay attention to the translation 😓❗️

@robertc6343

3 жыл бұрын

@@aniagoszczynski8194 , what have I missed?

This is a film that must be seen. Poignant and unflinching in it's telling of a terrible truth all should know. Thank you Alfons Ziółkowski. Thank you Eric Bednarski and all those who took part and were involved.

I learned a lot of information from the documentary that I had not known previously. It's good that there are documentaries like this to provide more details about such an important part of history that should never be forgotten.

My grandmother had to sell or exchange her breast milk to the orphans at the hospitals to feed her children. Something I will never forget. 😪

@williamfunes2740

3 жыл бұрын

Didn't know that was a thing.

@italianalcapone

3 жыл бұрын

Salute from the bottom of my heart to her love and struggle

@21iseeit50

3 жыл бұрын

Act to stop 21st nazi china camp. Be human. Thank you.

@flosslittle5231

2 жыл бұрын

@Captain Blacktooth That's sad for today, im very lucky to live in Australia.

@irishcanuck9489

2 жыл бұрын

@144,000 seconds til midnight did you forget your medication again, now go take it before someone reports you and it is court ordered, failing that you'll get to visit your buddies in the psyc ward again, it will be an extended stay with lots of medication and where all Bibles are consficated and you get to play checkers all day with your buddies. I bet you miss them a whole lot!

Thank you DW.... Superb Doc... There is no limit to human madness... Sad part is that History repeats..

@missmodern

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, now it's the oppression of women in Afghanistan.

@powderskier5547

2 жыл бұрын

yes very sad history repeats itself, have a look at what they are doing to the arabs, mainly Palestinians

As a native German I lived abroad and met Holocaust survivors. Having been made aware of German crimes at an excellent school I felt responsible for these crimes and grew up with an awareness for tolerance and decency. When I watched this film, I once again realised the atrocity of it all and broke out in tears, especially, when I saw that young boy being beaten by the policeman. This film is made to commemorate Warsaw what it used to be, and the murdered Jewish community and their suffering.

@keridrowatzky9543

Жыл бұрын

Remember, the atrocities will never be your fault. They are the fault of those who actually never took responsibility for their own actions, ie Hitler , Goebbels, Himmler, etc.. their failures and the loss of WW1, the financial climate after that war and the Depression was the fault of the Jews. They made excuses as do people here in the USA do. The slavery issues of the Civil War are being blamed on people of this day and she. Like your parents, our families could barely get along during the 1800s. No one had the time to pay attention nor could they afford to.

@arturart2480

Жыл бұрын

I met some Germans who refused to have an opinion about this documentary (not interested) So your comment is very welcomed here Also to be reminded those Jews were Polish citizens only difference religion After the Jewish Getto population was killed Germans were planning to kill the rest of the Polish population (Catholics) but the war ended watch it the lady speaks about it how Warsaw was divided and why

@MarkAnderson-ng8vc

Жыл бұрын

I've never understood why someone would feel responsible for things that happened before they were even born.

@patriciabrenner9216

Жыл бұрын

@@MarkAnderson-ng8vc You know, most Germans still have things stolen from the Jews... Furniture, pianos, art etc. They never gave the loot back

@britannia5370

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for your acknowledgement, most welcome

God bless the man who shot the film. I never understood about Warsaw and what it was about until now. Thank-you!

Thank you DW for another outstanding look into the history of WWII and what took place across Europe. The reports issued by DW are always very insightful, and are not a mish-mash of previous information reported by numerous other sources. It is a modern look into the events of the past and helps us remember. If we remember, we do not repeat the horrible mistakes of the past.

@georgebrown8312

2 жыл бұрын

I second that. We should indeed remember the lessons of the past.

R.I.P. to all who suffered.

@kewsiyehboah6058

3 жыл бұрын

Amen to dat..

@ElMakz

3 жыл бұрын

Lol

@girumzemichael704

3 жыл бұрын

@Tyler Evans I highly doubt you would feel or think so if it were your misery that was being talked about. Beware of losing your sympathy for human suffering, the rest can be discussed, debated, philosophized about.

@univuniveral9713

3 жыл бұрын

I feel so bad.

@21iseeit50

3 жыл бұрын

Act to stop 21st nazi china camp. Be human. Thank you.

Been to Warsaw many times.... This city suffered so much ...but respect to the city for rising from the ashes and RIP to every person who lost their life, and those of their families

@chiefswife1212

2 жыл бұрын

City suffered so much? City rebuilt, dead are gone.

@HafizRakiman

2 жыл бұрын

Rip 😢

@AleksandraLexi

Жыл бұрын

@@harisa.8697 what?!?

I am first generation German, I'm absolutely ashamed to what happened to the people of Poland, the ghetto. Poor Poland suffered so bad between the Germans and the Russians. Sad

@EWAMILENAP

2 жыл бұрын

💕🐻

@marcinm2871

2 жыл бұрын

so pay war reparations you nazis, you don't want to cause you are proud of what you did.

@themartaklima

2 жыл бұрын

As a Polish person I can confidently say that Poles do not blame the Germans or Russians who were children back then, let alone weren't even born at the time. Your comment warms my heart because what you said and the time you took to learn about the past shows what a good person you are. As long as the past is remembered, and lives in us, there is a chance that this terrible history will not repeat itself. Love from Poland

@corneliakobilke4638

2 жыл бұрын

Sorry but the polish chased their own :(

@usa5439

2 жыл бұрын

Poland shot at Civilian planes first and literally provoked the German invasion thinking they would be defended by other nations.

Aww, god bless that poor little boy, being beaten by that thug! His nose was all bloodied, as he ran away, in fear! No one was allowed to help him! Heart breaking. I am very greatful to everyone who has taken the time and the effort to show people such as myself, the reality of those bad times! This must never be allowed to happen again - ever!!! I wish you all Love and Light, from The UK. xxxxx

@philippeceline984

Жыл бұрын

NEVER forget that 98% or 99% of these innocent people are dead ! ... Men Women Youngs olds All of them in the Warsaw Ghetto ! and Almost all of them excepted the camps survivors ! That is more than Terrible ...

@born2comment

Жыл бұрын

never allowed? check ukraine.

@twinkle3026

Жыл бұрын

@@born2comment I don't understand what you mean??? "Check Ukraine".

@sjam1159

Жыл бұрын

@@twinkle3026 Check the Christian Armenians who already were mass murdered but haven’t been allowed to even publish the movie they made of it out of threats of death. Now, they’re attacking them again.

@twinkle3026

Жыл бұрын

@@sjam1159 Thank you, i will check it out. Those poor people. god bless them. xx

We don't realise how lucky we are ,we can get all kinds of help when it's needed,they had no one to help them, parents trying to find enough food for their children is just one of the things that's heart breaking,never mind all the other things that broke their hearts

@kiariejohn410

Жыл бұрын

Has nothing to with luck it's about prejudice where you're it could happen to you depending on who is the ruler

Thanks for coming forward and teaching the next generation! God Bless all of you! Many of us know the quote "Those who refuse to learn from the past, are condemned to repeat it .

As Polonia, as a Polish-American, I weep for my people. I weep for those who suffered then and still suffer now on account of the cruelty and hatred of the Fuhrer and his Reich. I weep for the land of my forefathers. Long live Poland and the Polish people. God, Honor, Fatherland!

Very moving, many thanks for posting. The empty tram moving across Warsaw at night is a haunting vision, but very fitting. Can't understand why there are any 'dislikes' for this excellent film.

When I was younger I hated so much history I always thought about the past is the past and we should move forward. Now that I'm older and a little bit wiser, I love documentaries and history because now I know that thanks to the past history im here. And im always so grateful for the past and for learning about it

@benb2941

3 жыл бұрын

"History does not repeat, but it rhymes " I don't remember who's quote. Try understanding history as a perpetrator. What made people, just like you and me, do these things? How can I make sure I will choose better, what would the consequences be?

@youme1414

3 жыл бұрын

With the way Trump base is doing these days we aren't free from it yet. They still spew the hate online in every simple opportunity. It is sad most human beings haven't learnt anything from history.

@youme1414

3 жыл бұрын

​@Frogfur FightingAgainstTrudeau All right! Here we go again. Trump supporters always resorting to threat when they are told the truth. This is not Capitol Hill though. This is not slander either but reality. To deny that fact is to deny reality. I have been in many online platforms long enough to know that my previous statement holds. Actually, Trump base is a form of cult-personality thing without reserve for decency in most cases. Those following him will attack you for every opportunity, like you are trying to do now. I hope you read my post with an open mind. If only you are ready to change and the alleged and unverifiable 80 million plus followers. The staggering number is scary and points to slim hope for a better humanity. On the final note, I am not spewing hate. At least, you would have to point it out in my prior post rather that just using that term for comment sake.

@koushikdas1992

3 жыл бұрын

@@youme1414 You sound like nazi, period! Try to be a human.

@patriciabrenner9216

3 жыл бұрын

The past is never dead. It's not even past. (Faulkner)

38:04 brought me to tears... a precious little boy trusting his daddy.... who knows what horrors may have come to them. May God never it happen to my precious little boy. God help us.

@volkhen0

3 жыл бұрын

Yep. Same here. Imagine the pain of the father trying to explain why they are there. The boy must have asked many times.

@Tali5899

2 жыл бұрын

@@volkhen0 Hey, I have Jewish family in Israel called Kozlovski.

eerie similarity to Gaza

This is one of the best documentaries I've watched on the Warsaw Ghetto. It places the ghetto in perspective to the rest of Warsaw allowing the viewer to see the scale and geography of the city districts and the ghetto. The % of Jewish people who comprised the population of the city is also emphasised. This information is missing from every other documentary on this subject. I have a far greater understanding of the subject as a result of watching this very moving and impactful film. Thank you

@DWDocumentary

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment!

@EE-hp4qe

2 жыл бұрын

Yet the same thing is happning in Palestine.. yeah thats sick

@maryhjort7318

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed. This really opened my eyes to other things as well. I got a very clear sense of what the Warsaw Ghetto actually was, how it became what it was, and how it was maintained and then destroyed. I never heard or considered what the logistics of such an endeavor would involve … never considered that it involved everyone who wasn’t German. I was not aware of the plan to “erase” Warsaw and all non-German people from Poland, In fact to erase Poland itself. No doubt that was the plan all across Europe. No more Europe! Only Germany? The enormity of it … I come to the conclusion that the word Holocaust has not really been seen fully … at least in my education (born USA 1948), we were never given the depth of knowledge to really even begin to grasp the multi-dimensionality or depth of human depravity that was visited upon these people. Thank you for airing it.

@knockshinnoch1950

2 жыл бұрын

@@maryhjort7318 There is still so much to learn about this horrific period in world history- tragically there are similar events occurring in our world today that news media "conveniently" ignore. I must agree that when ever I meet American's I'm amazed at just how little they seem to know about world history (and geography). Most that they do know seems to be a simplified version and seen through American "patriotic" propaganda such as "America won the Second World War- with zero knowledge of the massive contribution and sacrifice of over 20 million Russian troops and civilians- this was deliberately overlooked during the Cold War and of course has persisted.

@luthermcgee3767

2 жыл бұрын

AGREED! Having an A in college level drafting, and having drafting in my blood, I was attracted to this video more than any on the subject of Floorplan and city layouts.

Always coming through with the most eye opening documentaries. Thank you DW!

@newreast3904

3 жыл бұрын

i live for the day that a documentary about nazi germany atrocities in greece is shown. the villages and the villagers they left in ashes...

@fresatx

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah.. Thanks Germany for setting the world on fire so you could make cool docs about it later!

@Shazz_Wazz

3 жыл бұрын

@@newreast3904 I never heard about that. They should explore more documentaries about lesser known atrocities from WW2

@sheilaboston7051

3 жыл бұрын

@@fresatx You spelt Nazis wrong. The average German soldier was like any other soldier.

@kayvan671

2 жыл бұрын

@@fresatx Your welcome

It’s so painful to know the horrors of what was done to these innocent people. The horror of living in that time, is for me just unimaginable, it’s terrifying to watch. God only knows what it felt like. I hope that their stories are never forgotten. This should never happen again. So very sad. Thank you for sharing. X

@786swe

3 жыл бұрын

Patricia The same thing gas been happening to the Tohingyas in Burma.

@annazfker2028

2 жыл бұрын

FACT: ISRAEL IS KILLING WOMEN AND CHILDREN IN PALESTINE. FACT: ISRAEL IS A TERRORIST STATE. FACT: THE US SUPPORTS ISRAEL.

@mayaweirtel4623

2 жыл бұрын

LOOK at what is taking place in Palestine nowadays, those who suffered are doing the same to Palestinians They surely forgot, don't what to remember, or plainly playing STUPID! Makes no sense. ..... Those prior discriminate DISCRIMINATE today!! pathetic PATHETIC!

When you are young you have nothing but the future; but when you are old you have nothing but the past. When taught correctly, history is a combination of both. That is why I am so grateful for these documentaries because it is never too late to recognize evil and correct its wrongs.

@georgebrown8312

2 жыл бұрын

And it is not too late to learn from the past and determine never to repeat those mistakes.

@ctgctg1

8 ай бұрын

@@georgebrown8312I agree, but if you look around you can see humans are still repeating history even in democracies. It’s horrendous.

Every country suffered under Nazi occupation, but the Germans & Russians had particular animosity for Poland. It is heart-breaking & tragic the horrors that unfolded in a wonderfully vibrant country. Yet the Polish people never gave up! How ever dark the hour was, pick up ANY book of the Second World War and you'll understand how ferocious, tenacious and relentless were the Polish forces fighting for the Allies. From the Battle of Britain to Montecassino in Italy to the Falaise Gap in France, never underestimate the Poles! Neither Fascism nor Communism ever stood a chance with Poland!

@yolomanolo2601

2 жыл бұрын

Starting a war over it was stupid but there is some reason why poland was disliked by its 2 neighbours. Nevertheless diplomacy should have been enough but the idiot Hitler was out of his mind.

@nvp4564

2 жыл бұрын

Over 500000 Soviet soldiers gave their lives to drive nazi out of Poland in the winter of 1945! It is a historical fact.

@Katie-pc5yg

2 жыл бұрын

@NVP no one denies the sacrifice the Soviets made to defeat Hitler but it is correct to say that prior to the Nazi invading the Soviet Union the non aggression pact.between Hitler and Stalin saw Poland carved up between them.

the bloody nose child....what a strong child. anyone complaining about how tough their life is... should watch this. my question is why...why?

@billmers3219

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah there's kids in middle school that bow or sit during the pledge of allegiance.... Spoiled little bastards

@xgamesfan7094

3 жыл бұрын

@@billmers3219 now explain how that is relevant

@amazingsupergirl7125

2 жыл бұрын

Why? Money and power. It’s always about money and power.

@mystyk5896

2 жыл бұрын

None of the adults standing around did anything. Shameful.

@suziewhattley3917

2 жыл бұрын

@@billmers3219 Yeah, they need to stand up and salute like good little nationalists. I bet you side with the collaborating cop beating that starving kid, too.

It is so very difficult to watch it! I am crying each time I watch such painful videos. I will never forget my mom telling me about ghetto in Radom where people were buried still alive!

@joannab7403

2 жыл бұрын

I hope the victims rest in peace forever. Hope the murderers fry in hell...

@chichi775

2 жыл бұрын

what??? buried alive???

@Tali5899

2 жыл бұрын

Krystyna Poblocka.Do you mean Radomsk? Would that be the same place?

@Tali5899

2 жыл бұрын

@@chichi775 Have you not read what the nazis did to people.That was fairly uncommon.

@user-se1xs2et3t

9 ай бұрын

deep fake

Absolutely and without a doubt, this is one of the best documentaries that I've ever seen. Thank you so very much.

A superb production indeed. Thank you so much!

Thank you for this -- I think you make some of the best documentaries in the world and I am so thankful that you create content in English. I am grateful.

@desertodavid

2 жыл бұрын

Have you checked out Mark Felton Productions? I just finished watching a 3 episode documentary on the Jewish Uprising in the ghetto. Very detailed. If only the Poles would have helped the Jewish resistance Fighters fight the Nazis in the ghetto when they had the chance...

My grandparents lived through this in Warsaw...and still despised the Soviets more. My grandpa was 19 and my grandma 21 when the war started. We aren’t Jewish but they were a part of the resistance army during the uprising. Man they had some stories...I miss them...

@janinabarcicka329

3 жыл бұрын

Spisuj wszystkie te historie! Moja babcia to rocznik 1920. W dniu wybuchu wojny była w Warszawie u swojego wujostwa (Nowolipki). Siedzieli w piwnicy i żywili się czekoladą Wedla, bo taką zapłatę od firmy Wedel dostał jej wujek za naprawę samochodu. Chyba w poblizu był sierociniec Korczaka, bo ona się z takimi później dziećmi kontaktowała. Tez poznałam trochę historii, niestety babcia zmarła.

@patriciabrenner9216

3 жыл бұрын

@@janinabarcicka329 Yes these histories should be written.

@patriciabrenner9216

3 жыл бұрын

Well they weren't Jews. My parents blessed the Russians who saved them. Then they left Poland forever as let's say they hadn't a lot of good to say about Poles either.

@rameez6696

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah its true unity has been broken got divided and distributed

@GlobetrotterBR

3 жыл бұрын

I've lived in Poland for a while and every single person who I met hated more the Soviets than the Nazis, which was a surprise for me at that time. They say that more than 40 years of Soviet humiliation was much worse than what the Nazis did.

My great grandfather's brother Mendel Oppenheim (72 years old at the time) built a bunker as a preparation to the Ghetto uprising, where he was hiding with his sister Anna Oppenheim (aged 58), his daughters Judith Oppenheim (aged 33) and Malka Hoffman (aged 45) and her family - husband Gershon and two daughters Hava (aged 20) and Ida (aged 25) , also Mendel's son Fred Oppenheim (aged 43) with his wife Rachel (aged 38) with two children a boy and a girl aged 7 and 9. The bunker was discovered by the Germans in the first few days of the uprising, all of the family was dragged out, put against a wall and shot. I have an eye witness report. For many people this is not history, but a leaving pain. May their souls rest in peace, their blood revenged!!!!

@patriciabrenner9216

2 жыл бұрын

I am so sorry. My maternal grandmother escaped, but my uncle Marek, my aunt Frania and my grandparents Gitel and Yankel were murdered there.

@user-se1xs2et3t

9 ай бұрын

we wil get all of you this time

@miguelleruitte7001

Ай бұрын

Vengé contre les Gazaouis peut être .

To see those beautiful, brave and innocent kids risking their lives just for smuggling some food, breaks my heart. Not even in a thousand years, Germany will be able to get rid of this awful legacy.

@timmolloy7574

2 жыл бұрын

Israel too, has learned to use the same tactics as the Nazi's on the Palestinians

@bigmajordawg

2 жыл бұрын

LOL…cry me a river

@timmolloy7574

2 жыл бұрын

@@bigmajordawg N azi

@annabees

2 жыл бұрын

The thing, Germany has an aweful legacy yes, and a lot of other countries have one as well. People from the world need to remember not to ever reproduce those atrocities again, not expect other people to amend for a past which is not theirs, but those of their parents...

@051963mf

2 жыл бұрын

@@annabees i agree with you, but what Germany did cannot be compared with any other country. The scale of evil the Nazis Implemented is unique in its criminality. The Japanese were very close in their crimes and evil, but far away for getting to achieve such massive, organized, industrial type of human extermination. Yes, we can’t blame the current German generations, but the dark and awful history of their country remains as a fact.

Just excellent, one of a best history documentaries I have ever watched, great work!!

@timmolloy7574

2 жыл бұрын

Very similar to the Gaza Ghetto

Also with a great sadness and horror in my heart, I thank you for posting this video.

@sylwia4378

Жыл бұрын

Kkujjkķkkkkkkook 😅

@user-se1xs2et3t

9 ай бұрын

lol

I feel horribly uneducated about this time in world history, so I’m learning through watching these documentaries. Its made me realize how diligent we must be to make sure this never happens again. The horrors that people suffered are incredibly sad, the resilience of survivors is absolutely astounding. I think everyone needs to watch these shows lest we forget history. This must never happen again.

@eunicestone6532

8 ай бұрын

My Father in law fought in WW2 and he told me he learned more about history and the war on THE HISTORY CHANNEL than he ever knew. Apparently it was on a NEED TO KNOW basis and the US Government felt like they just didn't need to know.

@anyq_CS

7 ай бұрын

Gaza is the modern day warsaw ghetto

@handmadenftart5244

5 ай бұрын

Te recomiendo que leas desde la WW1 para que te formes un criterio más sólido, te aseguro que te sorprenderás

Every time I think things are hard in my life whether it was in basic training in the military or whatever I got through it by imagining the people that survived this if they can survive the ones that did I can survive anything that's ever been in front of me God bless all those that suffered I can't even fathom such horrific inhumanities!

@laurahoward5426

Жыл бұрын

Yes!! I have been going through hardships and travails, and watching something like this makes me realize what true suffering was....it was so horrible, but those street markers...to think it was only 3 years, 900 days...m😭

@jerrydonquixote5927

Жыл бұрын

@@laurahoward5426 I hope things get better Laura🙏🏻

Compelling, gritty, and deeply moving..

In the past year, I read slot of holocaust and saw testimonials, documentaries, real life stories and it just overwhelms me to a point where I feel so sorrowful for the men,women and children who died for no reason! I’d just want to say that they are all remembered and I pray for the peace of their souls and family.

@saeedhussain15

3 жыл бұрын

Hii

@ricog7147

3 жыл бұрын

@brendabooker1488

3 жыл бұрын

Amen.

@cheapcraftygirlsweepstakes2338

3 жыл бұрын

That’s the worst part. Some of them aren’t remembered. Entire families were wiped out. ☹️

@oldschoollgearjammerlongmi5209

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah I feel sorrow for all the white people who lost their lives on both sides!

Very moving. Thank you for making this available.

@DWDocumentary

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment!

I like it that German makers of this documentary had enough civility to call the perpetrators of this horrible crime by their real name, i.e., ‘Germans’, instead of cryptic ‘Nazis’. They didn’t have enough civility, though, to go into the mass killing that their forefathers perpetrated. It was mentioned but without much emphasis. The geographic layout of the Warsaw Ghetto was given much more attention, as if it really mattered.

All the darkness of the world can’t extinguish a single candle of hope....RIP to those who lost their life in one of the most darkness times in the world. Blessings always 🌼

@islanddweller3674

3 жыл бұрын

None of thses people had a glimmer of hope. No one ever will uless each of us stands up to bullies and oppressio nDeath was a welcome release. Please stop these glib words

@richarddomasky3131

2 жыл бұрын

@@islanddweller3674 ?? Hi hi cuih\hi. B"""v,h:::;;;;opp

@oldschoollgearjammerlongmi5209

2 жыл бұрын

Especially all the Germans and all the white people who lost their lives on both sides. Right?

@Tali5899

2 жыл бұрын

@@islanddweller3674 Not true bc otherwise there would not have been an uprising neither would any have attempted escape.

Whereas many other countries refuse to talk about the more unsavory aspects of their history, Germany and their broadcasters produce some great productions to commemorate this very dark event and in this case DW seems to have gone to place, fully knowing there is little left, to speak to people who lived during that era. Fantastic work. I cannot say that I am surprised by your professionalism here.

@SurG30n

3 жыл бұрын

If you put someone in a ghetto, you take their fortune, a good name and life. It was the perpetrator of this crime who did it only for the money.

@patriciabrenner9216

3 жыл бұрын

Because they couldn't deny it. As simple as that. If they could, they would.

@gurufabbes1

3 жыл бұрын

​@@patriciabrenner9216 It's more than not denying it, it's the active participation in the historiography, particularly by people of a new generation who had nothing to do with any of what went on.

@patriciabrenner9216

3 жыл бұрын

@@gurufabbes1 Nothing to do? Not really. They are still sitting on the loot.

@gurufabbes1

3 жыл бұрын

@@patriciabrenner9216 What loot? Germany was ravaged during WW2 and still plays reparations to this day. I am not sure you know what the hell you're talking about. Yeah, the new generation in Germany has nothing to do with the Nazis, anymore than I have anything to do with something done 80 to 100 years ago perpetrated by any of my grandparents.

Fantastic thank you... Incredibly important for humanity to remember to relive and never ever to forget

This is for me the most powerful documentary I have seen to date on the Warsaw ghetto. Your resarchers have done an incredible job of finding original film. The little boys smuggling goods into the ghetto and then been beaten. They ran away as if they were not 41:44 affected. This video with the empty tram running through the street made a visceral impact on me as well as much of the video. 😢 Such a horrific tragedy. Truly grateful for your work as ever, although painful to watch. My ❤goes out to the survivors and the Polish people.

This is the saddest part of World History that the People Of the World should never forget Thank you very DW Documentary channel make the world aware of this sad past Keep up the great job

@DWDocumentary

3 жыл бұрын

Hi @Altamash Khateeb,thanks for your comment!

The subscriber count for this channel will grow even further. Remarkable work!

This is something everybody should watch from time to time to not forget and not repeat the same story.

One of the best channels on youtube, by far. THANKS!

To describe the pain, horrors and atrocities would be an underestimation. I hope we all learn a lesson about the effect of dehumanization, which is the cause of hate and destruction. In essence, we are truly one; all of us, regardless of race, ideology, sex, nationality or religion, it's called the human race. Let us focus on the 99 % we have in common. The world is so ready for healing, love and unity.

@dianavoak4634

2 жыл бұрын

Unfortunately the world has leant nothing from this atrocity....

@poppygirl...

2 жыл бұрын

Amen

@isaacwolowik

2 жыл бұрын

@Randy Homes Very sad.

@coniston3106

2 жыл бұрын

@@dianavoak4634 I wouldn't agree with that. If the world hadn't learned from the atrocity, Holocaust would have happened everyday.

@BitterBetty76

2 жыл бұрын

Let's not forget the dehumanization of the unborn humans legally murdered in the womb every day. That's where it all starts. Abortion is the holocaust of today.

Great documentary and channel but my God shocking events that sadly are still happening ...

A really good historical documentary. I know a lot about the Warsaw Ghetto but obviously not enough. I'm really touched by the strength all of the Polish people of all religions showed under Nazi occupation and then under the Soviet Union's oppression. They both wanted to annihilate Poland but both failed. Lets never forget and always watch out that nothing in this way can ever happen again. May the dead rest in peace xxx 🙏🙏🙏

Thank you, DW, for your insightful study on WW2 and other historical events.

The music was beautiful. Thank you!

Being Jewish living in America, I look at the pictures, read the books , watch the films and to be honest I have nearly an impossible time trying to understand what happened but also trying to understand what it was like to live under the circumstances that existed during that time., and I just can't do it. Hard to wrap your mind around it.G-D bless all then and now !

@mihiec

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you for shering this. Greetings from Poland.

@brendabooker1488

3 жыл бұрын

Amen .

@Barbara-ld4ug

3 жыл бұрын

My parents survived. There was always Jew hatred in Europe it was seething. Various institutions accepted hitler. The pope was the first to recognize hitler giving his acceptance. They knew Jews were not strong. They didn’t have a country they could go to. America had very strict quotas against Jews. Jews were stranded in a hell hole. The Red Cross was only there for the Jews after the war to search for relatives. They even refused to recognize the Magen David atom- Israel Red Cross but, they. Accepted the Muslim crescent. Jew hate didn’t die. It’s underground

@Celisar1

3 жыл бұрын

Same here. I know so much about that time and all that happened but i simply cannot understand it on a very profound level. sometimes I’m trying to imagine the horrible things when standing in a place where some of the events took place but it’s hardly possible. we have step stones in many places, golden stones in the ground with the names of people on them who fell victim to the nazi regime including some additional information. I love this idea because it honors the dead in a very personal, respectful way and integrates their memory into our everyday life.

@ID-8491

3 жыл бұрын

@sunny It's not an act of censoring. They do it out of respect.

this is one of the best documentaries about this tragic time. its chilling and heartbreaking

Wow this footage is priceless! Thank you!

Thank you for sharing this. . . . Blessings

Thank you so much.

Excellent documentary. Thank you for posting on KZread.

Beautiful documentary 👏❤ Thank you

Love your documentaries

This was very moving. There's a number of small things I'd never actually seen captured before. Tho, I've grown up and all my life have reflected on this subject matter. This is an intimate docu that brings together so much of what happened. Thanks.

I found this very valuable to watch, and would not have known about it otherwise, thank you for the documentary.

It is one of the best documentaries I've seen on the subject.

We are lucky that we didnt live on those times. Hearing there stories make you realize how awful human can be.

@davesbainrps6909

3 жыл бұрын

People sone forget

@anujavyas3027

3 жыл бұрын

We are again almost living in same time ,this time enemy is not visible to naked eyes.

@J3MOdh3NOWX3S

3 жыл бұрын

Were more advanced now. I dont think todays people of germany would get caught up in the propaganda or histaria.

@bigmajordawg

2 жыл бұрын

After there I stopped reading

@ivansime9127

2 жыл бұрын

@@anujavyas3027 very true Bosnia, Rwanda, North Korea, and China have all been through or are going through genocides

As always you don’t disappoint DW. I never knew Warsaw suffered so much during the Nazi regime - The ghetto and what the Nazi’s really planned for the disappearance Warsaw. Insightful and heart breaking. Thank you for posting DW.

@piotrrajmundkoprowski4732

3 жыл бұрын

That was not "nazi regime". It was German occupation.

@nadyagazda885

3 жыл бұрын

No - I didn’t know either. How dreadful. How heartbreaking....

@justynagorka3972

3 жыл бұрын

They were Germans of Nazi ideology. There wasn't Naziland

@virginiawolf6431

3 жыл бұрын

@@piotrrajmundkoprowski4732 Yes, German occupation for all Polish citizen

@CthuIhuu

2 жыл бұрын

German Socialist regime.

Great work, so moving and well done. We need to remember especially now.

Heartbreaking, informative, and a Solid Warning to future generations ...!

An amazing documentary thank you for posting

@tedpert8786

3 жыл бұрын

All I can say is that this world is blind!

It’s such a heart wrenching reality. How could they do such a thing?

@thomseng

3 жыл бұрын

Well in real, "Kristallnacht" and capitol riot r not all that different. "president 4 life" gives me the shivers

@Just-One-God

3 жыл бұрын

Of course humans have the potentials to do such things. We already have the term for it, "Xenophobia". There will always be those type of people who will address the Jews as either "greedy rich people" or "masters of conspiracy", the same type of people who will address us Muslims as "terrorists" and the Asians as "kung-fluers".

@Just-One-God

3 жыл бұрын

@Zahir ADATs I'm not even an immigrant, you ignorant.

@DreamteamCarlo

3 жыл бұрын

@@thomseng I see a very large difference between the two events. Attacking a symbol of power or abusing one's power to kill / lock up thousands of innocent people for their 'race', is a huge difference imho.

@thomseng

3 жыл бұрын

@@DreamteamCarlo OK ; apart from scale, I see no difference. The overall idea is the same, the rhetoric is the same and the violence is the same.

Excellent video! Thank you.

Outstanding coverage

Thanks for the doc... We can't forget what our brothers went through

@TheAbrantino

3 жыл бұрын

@Molly Mew yes I meant all people

Beautifully done. Love the music choices especially and the handling of the old 8mm footage. Thanks

Thank you for this film

Excellent documentary with rare archival footage

*Excellent documentary DW!* *People always say the future belongs to the youth but no one cares it's the old who persevered*

It's always so difficult to understand how come people from the same land of Beethoven, Thomas Mann, Schiller and so many enlightened people could commit such a horror.

@fraudebs8786

3 жыл бұрын

Unbelievable..💔

@scottgordon8902

3 жыл бұрын

Its not. When a group of people feel disenfranchised or neglected they naturally gravitate toward something that will lift them up personally.. this is occurring over and over throughout history to this day. Qannon is the latest garbage.. all of these things are just lies and bring together people WANTING to do believe

@ehanoldaccount5893

3 жыл бұрын

It is that mind set that allows it. People don’t realize it can happen anywhere with the right conditions, which is why we can never forget.

@maryloujohnson8610

3 жыл бұрын

@@ehanoldaccount5893 There is so much truth in the saying "if we do not learn from our mistakes, we are destined to repeat them." We are riding the rim of that situation with Donald Trump/Proud Boys/Oath Keepers/QAnon...If we allow this to continue, there is no doubt where it is going to end.

@Barbara-ld4ug

3 жыл бұрын

Not so difficult it was arrogance and hate

Polish people are really nice people. I've been blessed to call a lot of them my friends

Beautiful film, and it touches the heart. Thank you for sharing...

The horrors of just thinking about all that pain just to cross one little street inbetween the two communities. Being terrified of the foreign officers in your own city. Unimaginable

I remember reading a book called Escape from Warsaw as a child. I found it exciting, but I had no idea or grasp of the true horrors that occurred.

@RocketRoketto

3 жыл бұрын

so youve never seen schindler's list?

@davidbranin969

3 жыл бұрын

@@RocketRoketto yes I have. Read Escape from Warsaw in 1971 when I was 11. Just a bit before most folks knew about Mr Schindler and the list that saved lives.

So incredibly sad. Thank God all the people who remember have it on film. All these programs should be in all schools throughout the WORLD.

In 1982 I took a ged class with a survivor of this. Her name was Sophie. She watched uprising with us kids and cried and told stories about the war in 39,43,and 45. She came to America in 1950. It's beyond, my comprehension the unchecked hate. I don't get it. I probably never will