The thing I wish they put in the movies is the whole relationship between Remus and Tonks (Lupin coming to Grimmauld place after finding out Tonks is pregnant). I love them two together and I'm gutted that they didn't include all there interaction in the movies

@nayanabhorkade5432

4 жыл бұрын

I love that scene!!!!!

My favorite book is The Prisoner of Azkaban, I loved the marauders story

@booklady2902

6 жыл бұрын

Ilaria Gabrieli The marauders should have their own books!

@brooklynbyers7048

6 жыл бұрын

Ilaria Gabrieli same

@DanaMusser

6 жыл бұрын

Ilaria Gabrieli i just love sirius black so same

@ayanaowens5495

2 жыл бұрын

MY FAVORITE BOOK HARRY POTTER AND THE PRISONER OF AZKABAN!💛💖💖/LEAST FAVORITE BOOK HARRY POTTER AND THE OLDER OF THE PHOENIX/FAVORITE MOVIE HARRY POTTER AND THE GOBLET OF FIRE SO VERY MUCH!!!!😇😆😉💛💖💖💖💖/LEAST FAVORITE MOVIE HARRY POTTER AND THE CHAMBER OF SECRETS/FAVORITE WEASLEY RON/FAVORITE VILLAIN BALLATRIX/FAVORITE MALE HARRY HE'S SO CUTE AND HANDSOME 😇💖💖💖💖/FAVORITE PROTSSER SPROUT/HOGWARTS EXPRESS/A FIREBOLT!/HERMIONES TEETH/DRACO/I'M 100TH HUFFLEPUFF!!😇😉😆💛💛💛🖤🖤🖤💛💛💛💖💖!/CHARMS/ACCIO/HARRY HE'S MY BEST FRIEND I LOVE HIM SO MUCH!!😇😉🙆‍♀️🤵👓👔⚡💖💖💖💖/INVISIBILTY CLOAK/SIRIUS BLACK/HALLOWS/

worst thing left out of the movies was Peeves he's so awesome

@theswiftieteacher

4 жыл бұрын

AND SPEW!!! I was SO SAD that SPEW was never mentioned

@mireilleoppenheimer6662

3 жыл бұрын

i don' t think they could have done it well tho, it would have been very disappointing i feel like. it's a hard thing to do well.

Bring one character back from the dead: Uhhh HEDWIG duhh

@stonecat676

6 жыл бұрын

lul

WHY FRED AND SIRIUS??? I have literally spent hours crying over their deaths.

I think Luna Lovegood is a very under appreciated character.

Hippogriff. Definitely a Hippogriff. I want my own Buckbeak! Plus when you're traveling using a Hippogriff you basically have a companion. Instead of just a stick..with other little sticks coming out of the back of it...

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Lolll that's very true! I'd love to have a Hippogriff friend! 💖

@FableForager

7 жыл бұрын

A Hippogriff friend would be the best! No more getting stuck in traffic, more money for books since you wouldn't have to pay gas etc. I think out of all the magical creatures in the HP world I'd want a Hippogriff the most. Maybe one of those miniature dragons from GOF too...but for sure a Hippogriff.

Remus Lupin is so precious OML

@mireilleoppenheimer6662

3 жыл бұрын

best character after neville longbottom

three words Sirius effing black

I love sirus black and Luna Lovegood and Hippogriff definitely

i hate that they didn't give Hermione a blue dress in the movie of GoF hahahah

@bluefire9147

6 жыл бұрын

fairy in training I guess... But I like the pink one better :/

@lydiaa9594

6 жыл бұрын

Yes, me too! I hate that she was so girly. The colour of the dress, the cut of it and her hair, it was all wrong

8:12 Also it is not given that Voldemort is ugly so we can just assume that we get to kiss the handsome Tom Riddle Jr. Anyway, I will not even go close to Umbridge.

Ahhh thank you for doing my tag! It's so much fun coming back to BookTube and seeing people having done it!

1: Goblet of Fire 2: Order of the Phoenix- if Cursed Child counts than that is the worst 3: Prisoner of Azkaban 4: Order of the Phoenix 5: Molly Weasley 6: Hermione Granger 7: Agh!!! I missed that 8: Lord Voldemort 9: Albus Dumbledore, Sirius Black, Severus Snape- sorry 10: Professor McGonagall 11: Listen to Lockhart rant 12: Elated Bellatrix 13: Hogwarts Express 14: Give Umbridge a Bubble Bath 15: Ride a Firebolt 16: Ginny Weasley and Horace Slughorn 17: Chamber of Secrets 18: Michael Gambon 19: Neville not being the CO 20: Half-Blood Prince 21: Ravenclaw- but that was early on- Hufflepuff later 22: Hufflepuff 23: Transfiguration or Charms 24: Accio 25: Luna Lovegood/Neville Longbottom 26: Cloak 27: Dumbledore's backstory, Dobby's death, Hedwig's death 28: Sirius Black 29: Hedwig, Fred, Dobby 30: Hallows I think I missed question seven.

I really think the movies should have included Hermione's Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare. It says a lot about her character.

I love how enthusiastic you both are in this video! I had no idea there was a HP Tag but now I totally have to do it once I finish my current re-read :)

Ahhh my favourite is Prisoner of Azkaban... To each her/his own. :)

I feel like Maya is Inej from Six of Crows 😊😊

My fav book was “the goblet of fire” and least fav was “the order of the Phoenix” in all books and movies.

The one thing I would change in the books: I'd like to see some good guys in Slytherin and some villains from other houses. This is tha one major thing that always bothered me, how Slytherin house was almost always a synonym for a bully and terrible person and I feel by not being quite as blatant the stories could have been even more profound. (This was, in fact, a thing I liked about cursed child because they changed that a bit and had Albus and Scorpius both be goos guys in Slytherin.)

You guys have totally inspired me to reread the series! I read all the books before their respective movies came out (gods I'm getting old) but I've never really bothered to read them all over again,. I did however watch the movies several times. Now I feel like my mental representation of the series leans more to the movies and after watching this I totally feel like I've forgotten all the really good stuff. So thank you for that!

If you lost your keys, you could say accio keys and it will come to you. You can't loose things with accio

I started freaking out as soon as I saw this video in my sub box because the First Sentence Challenge is one of my favorite videos of yours. I absolutely agree with Maya on Scott's Teen Wolf S1 hair (and Stiles'). Maya as Lucius just made my life tbh. (I'm just adding onto this comment as the video goes on so this might be super long and random.) I completely agree with everything you said about Ginny and also her and Harry's relationship, WE WERE ROBBED. Also, the lack of Draco's redemption arc hurts my heart. I would definitely pick a hippogriff. THE BLOOPERS AND YOUR CAT ARE THE CUTEST THINGS EVER. Okay, sorry for such a ramble-y comment, so I just wanted to end off with saying I loved every second of this, you're both gorgeous and wonderful and I hope you keep making videos together whenever you can.

What about Sirius wtf

LMAO @ 7:15. Great answers! It's cool that you and your friend are in Gryffindor and Slytherin. And I would probably pick the Firebolt because I've always wanted to be able to fly on a broom. I really need to re-read the books and watch the movies again.

I love your friend! 😂😂

I haven't even watched the whole video yet and I'm already freaking out!

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Bookerly 😊💖😊

@justalonelystrider5522

7 жыл бұрын

+A Clockwork Reader Goblet of Fire is also my favorite book and I would remake it (not to give them haircuts) so I can include other things from the book like S.P.E.W., the Quidditch world cup match, Winky and Dobby, Ludo Bagman and everything that was inside the maze

@ayanaowens5495

3 жыл бұрын

I love Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire so very much is favorite so far l love the triwizard tournament the Potter outfit the Yule ball I love Harry's short long hair I love swimming in the ocean I love to eat gillyweed salad with ranch dressing and I can't change my mind!!😇😊❤💛❤💖💖

01: Goblet of Fire 02: Cursed Child/Chamber of Secrets 03: Prisoner of Azkaban 04: Half-Blood Prince/Fantastic Beasts 05: Molly Weasley 06: Hermione Granger 07: Bellatrix Lestrange 08: Albus Dumbledore 09: Minerva McGonagall/Remus Lupin 10: Listen to Lockhart Rant 11: Elated Bellatrix 12: Hogwarts Express 13: Give Umbridge Bubble Bath 14: Hippogriff 15: Ginny Weasley, Horace Slughorn 16: Chamber of Secrets 17: Michael Gambon 18: Neville being involved in prophecy Scenes with Harry/Dumbledore in book 5 19: Half-Blood Prince 20: Hufflepuff 21: Hufflepuff 22: Charms 23: Accio 24: Luna Lovegood 25: Invisibility Cloak 26: Decanonise Cursed Child 27: Sirius Black 28: Hedwig, Dobby and Fred Weasley 29: Hallows

Love this video, especially the ending part with your cat. That was just too pure.

This made me so happy I was literally saying 'yessss' out loud throughout the entire thing 😂

Fiddler on the Roof is probably my favorite musical!! None of my friends have seen it though. I love Tradition!

I love this I love you guys so much omg. AND I WOULD RIDE A HIPPOGRIFF. I'm afraid of heights I need that support lol

very nice video, goblet of fire is my favourite book and movie

You two are magic together!! (pun intended, zero shame 😋) I absolutely loved this, Maya definitely needs to find her way back to this channel again some time soon. Also, a hippogriff. Hands down, no question. Just...any and every creature from the HP world is like an incredible, wonder-filled dream to me. Sending love from Ravenclaw ❤

Loved this! And the bloopers were amazing :'D

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Lollll thank you! 😂😊

The sacrfs, the badges, maya wearing Slytherin colours, I love this video😭

I hated the shoelace scene with Harry and Ginny in Half-Blood Prince. They needed the first kiss scene from the book.

this was great, maya is so funny! i would want to try flying on both but only like, a foot off the ground because i'm scared of heights 😂

OMG!!! This is the funniest video on the Internet! Thank you for giving me so much joy!

Also , they left out SO MANY DOBBY SCENES in Goblet of Fire, Order of the Pheonix in the Movies

two words. WINKY. SPEW.

when hannah said her fav is harry, I was like yesssssssss

my favorite of the books was the half blood prince. neville and remus are my all time favorite characters in the series.

Hippogriff hands down, I already love riding horses so the fact that the horse is now half eagle and can fly just makes it better.

That's a nice video by the way! I've never read some Harry Potter books and movies before but I should read them.

Liked before watching because it's an hp tag, and I love love love your hair!

Question 27: the epilogue for Deathly Hallows. That whole scene bugs the shit out of me. Especially the Teddy part. I kinda just want to rip it out of the book and forget it exists. The draco redemption arc is a good answer but I'm okay with out that ended. He needed time to sort out how he felt about everything so I never expected a 180 transformation at the end. It would have felt a little fake to me. I love that Dudley has a redemption moment and it kills me that it wasn't in the movies.

i love this video!!! i just filmed a harry potter tag, but i love these questions even more. i might have to use this one some day in the future. & i would definitely fly a hippogriff! (i also loved y'alls nod to fiddler... tradition!).

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

You should totally do it, It's so much fun!! Lolll yesss I love Fiddler! 😄

Luna, Neville and Hermiione Squad is everything

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

💖💖💖

@luna160881

7 жыл бұрын

Book Ginny can be part of it, too, of course!

OK... So I've watched this video thousand times by now.... But only now I noticed___ Love Hannah but whats wrong with her eyes at 9:01 whe they talk about Ginny . Couldn't help but it seems funny when you see it in particular. A very FUN video though

firebolt hands-down. I would be too nervous to ride a hippogriff. and lupin and fred are still alive to me. They are ok

Firebolt to be honest. I feel like I would freak out in mid air and like grab the hippogriffs feathers like really hard and annoy it and get myself killed.

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

LOLLL literally same 😂😂😂

I don't like the goblet of fire because of their hair too :D

Remus Lupin aka the person who deserved everything in this whole wide world !!😫😭

My first instinct is to say I'd rather ride a hippogriff. It's a difficult question. The Firebolt would be awesome, but magical creatures hold this special place with me, and it'd be crazy to actually have on let you ride it.

Hippogriff because it seems way more comfortable than a broom, and it's basically the equivalent of riding a pegasus, and who doesn't want to fly on a pegasus?

HAHAHAH give umbridge a bubble bath 😂😂 accio would be sooooo useful! or that spell molly uses to clean the house, TEACH ME MOLLY

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

troudadourin OMG YES!! You'd never have to clean your room again!! I definitely want that spell too 😄😄

@troubadourin6321

7 жыл бұрын

hahah i get so jealous every time harry arrives at the weasleys house in chamber of secrets

Loved this video!!! ⚡️⚡️

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Thank you! 😊💕

same with the hair!!!! it loooked soooo baaaaaaad

Ohemgee!! Agreed! The hair in the 4th movie ruins it for me!!! Wise woman, that one.

it did help that scott cut his hair tho

hippogriff because I just always choose magical creatures over magical items the little parts at the end were hilarious

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

The Sloth Reader that's a very good point! Also lolll thank you 😂 I had like 10 minutes of footage I could have used for bloopers but I thought that would be excessive lolll 😂😂

I FINALLY found someone who ranked PoA the lowest like me!

I TOTALLY AGREE WITH DRACO REDEMPTION ARC ! some people have complained to me about agreeing with it because they say that he can't be redeemed but i'm like ??? i'm yes he can PEOPLE CAN CHANGE !

favorite book Harry potter and the Goblet of Fire /least favorite book Harry potter and the older of the Phoenix/ favorite movie Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire!!/ least favorite movie Harry potter and the half blood Prince/ favorite weasley Ron/ favorite female character Hermione / favorite villain ballatrix / favorite male character Harry/ favorite professor Mcgonalle/ duel ballatrix/ ride on Hogwarts express/ ride a firebolt/ I prefer to the movies /Michael gambon /draco malfoy /GRYFFINDOR/ charms class / exspellmixs /best friends with Harry / the invisibly cloak/ Slrius black /Hallows/😇😊❤💛❤💖💖

This was so much fun to watch!

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Yayyy!! I'm so glad :D

I honestly forgot Fred was dead at one point in my life and then someone asked which one of the twins died and I was just like, "WHAT!!!"

I've seen all of the movies and I've read the first book but I just can't get over my reading slump, I HAVE NO IDEA WHY

I am dying 😆 when she said "I hate there hair"

FIREBOLT!!! And now I want to do this tag but I'm afraid it would basically be all of these answers again LOL

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

DO IT!! It's such a fun tag and you get to talk non stop about Harry Potter! If you do end up doing it, definitely let me know, I'd love to watch it! 😊💖

@TheNovelSanctuary

7 жыл бұрын

OKOK You've convinced me! Lol :)

yesss goblet of fire is like my fave and prisoner of Azkaban

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Both so goooood!!

@ayanaowens5495

3 жыл бұрын

I love Harry Potter and the goblet of fire so much is favorite so far l love the triwizard tournament the outfits and the Yule ball I love swimming in the ocean and pool 😇🦋💐🏵👸💖💖❤💛❤

I'd definitely ride a Firebolt. I'd be afraid to ride a hippogriff. Eek. I really want to reread the Harry Potter books now because I want to know my answers to these questions and it's been so long my memory isn't serving me well!

Firebolt!

i would remake the Chamber of Secrets movie because THE BOOK MAKES SO MUCH MORE SENSE

THIS MADE ME SO HAPPY!!!!!!!!!!!

Definitely a Firebolt. I want to play Quidditch and the Hippogriff isn't helping me there. :D

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Stang Books yesss same!! 😄😊

WHAT EVEN!!! WE BOTH HAVE THE SAME HARRY POTTER BOOKS BETWEEN DEATHLY HALLOWS AND THE GOBLET OF FIRE AND OUR LEAST FAVORITE IS THE PRISONER OF AZKABAN AND ALSO MY FAVORITE CHARACTER IS ALSO RON AND FRED AND GEORGE LIKE I CANT CHOOSE SO DONT EVEN MAKE ME TRY AND IM ALSO IN DENIAL AB DOBBYS AND FREDS DEATH BC THEY DIDNT DIE THERE IS NO POSSIBLE WAY

I literally started crying thinking about how draco should have had a redemption arc omf😭😭

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Sarah Jos I'm sorry, I understand your pain 💔💔💔

Hippogriff (I'm more scared of broomsticks becuase I don't think I'm capable. At least if it's a hippogriff Hagrid could potentially help me. I can't even ride a bike so my balance on a broom is not great)

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

ByTheBookcase True, having Hagrid's support would be very helpful 💕💕

One of the things that upset me most about the movies, was Tonks personality she basically isn´t in the movie.

OMG! Maya looks like a real life Inej from SOC and CK! OMG!!! :D

hypogriff all the way! Ps. I love this video!

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Amy Barnett123 Thank you! 😊💕

Hasn't A Clockwork Reader already done the Ultimate Harry Potter Tag? She has, I have it downloaded. Haha- the updated version I suppose.

Love this tag!!

favourite Weasly :Fred and George favourite female character: 100% Luna Lovegood favourite male character: Can't chose between Sirius and Draco

Hippogriff I think that would be amazing

1. prisoner of azkaban 2. Chamber of Secrets 3. Philosopher's stone 4. order of the phoenix 5. Was this question missed? 6. Ron 7. Hermione 8. I don't really like any villian?? but probably voldemort because he's a good villian 9. Remus lupin 10. Remus lupin 11. wash Snape's hair 12. Bellatrix 13. Hogwarts express 14. I CANT ANSWER 15. Ride a hippogriff 16. Ginny weasely 17. nope 18. Michael Gambon 19. REMUS AND TONKS' RELATIONSHIP 20. Prisoner Of Azkaban 21. Gryffindor 22. Hufflepuff! 23. Care of Magical Creatures 24. Accio 25. Probably Ginny?? or Harry~ 26. invisibility cloak 27. I just want Remus lupin to be happy and to liVE AND TO BE WITH HIS SON AND WIFE AND NOT BE HATED BECAUSE HE'S A WEREWOLF 28. remussss 29. Remus lupin ofc 30. Hallows

Prisoner of Azkaban and Goblet of Fire are the only two movies where they actually got the hair right IMO

My fav male charecter is Snape

I love this tag!

Where do you get those scarves? All the ones I see have such thin stripes.

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

My grandma actually made them for me!

@kanthamani5371

4 жыл бұрын

@@AClockworkReader omg that's so sweet

#I am A POTTERHEAD #Definately Hermione #Bill Weasly #Draco Malfoy #Rwemus Lupin

SIRIUS♥♥♥♥♥

I only don't like goblet fire because their hairs😂

@ayanaowens5495

3 жыл бұрын

Well I love Harry Potter and the goblet of fire so much is favorite so far l love the triwizard tournament the outfits and the Yule ball swimming in the ocean and pool I can't change my mind!!😇😊❤💛❤💖💖👸

Wait... what about Hedwig

neville is my favorite person ever

I want to be a part of that smart girls + Neville squad!! also MOVIE GINNY WAS THE WORST I think hippogriff but part of me really wants to play quidditch so i cant choose ugh

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

missmareadsalot Welcome to the squad!! ❤️ I'm the least athletic person in the world, but I'd LOVE to play quidditch too!

@emmagreenily

7 жыл бұрын

yesss. I might be too clumsy for quidditch too, but we can dream right??

Bring Hedwig back 😭

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

HOW COULD I HAVE FORGOTTEN HEDWIG. IM SO ASHAMED OF MYSELF

@simplybansari

7 жыл бұрын

You probably were in denial too :P

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

true 😂😂😂

I'd rather ride a firebolt... I actually play Quidditch and people are always like "but flying on brooms isn't real?!?!?!" So then I could just be like "yes it is bYE"

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

Rayna Liddell ahhhh that's so awesome!! 😄 I'm with you it's 1000% real!

i also hate goblet of fire bc of their hair hahahah

@AClockworkReader

7 жыл бұрын

glmrklls00 lollll it's a valid point 😂😂😂

@ayanaowens5495

3 жыл бұрын

I love Harry Potter and the goblet of fire so much is favorite so far l love the triwizard tournament the outfits and the Yule ball I love swimming in the ocean and pool I can't change my mind!!😇😊❤💛❤💖💖👸