Watch the full NBF episode: kzread.info/dash/bejne/ontrtq5qdtqzfc4.html Support Safina Society: www.patreon.com/join/safinasociety

The nuanced discussed regarding the beard in the Maliki Madhab is literally mind blowing. Shaykh Shadee, couple of my subscribers were requesting that you recite Dala'il al-Khayrat again, would you be open to doing so? JazakAllah Khairan💚

whoever made your intro is a genius. May allah bless him.

I was gifted with a beard at the age of 20, and I trim it nicely-not too long or too short. I also shave the higher hairs on my face and neck, and it looks great.

learning a lot from you sir.

Here’s what I learned of the Maliki school, the principle is to separate Hadith from Sunnah. Imam Maalik RA made fiqh based on the customs of Madinat al-Nabi, as they would have the best understanding of the practices of the Prophet pbuh since he lived among them. Essentially if there was conflict between authentic Hadith and the practices of the People of Medina, he would choose to side with the People of Medina on what is closer to the practices of the Prophet pbuh.

Allah yubarik ya shaykhna ❤️

Come to BHA Houston again

So would a goatee be permitted in the school of malik where you define the beard as what grows on the chin??

JazakAllah khair

What if your hair is very curly and they roll up even though if you stretch it, it would be fist length or closer?

I remember as a revert i use to grow my beard long. I never really liked how i looked. I usee to go with tabliq jummaht and i was always very nervous to cut it and felt sinful. However i feel now, with it trimmed down that looks much nicer on me, even my mom said it looks much nicer on me and i dont look so weird. By the way this is just me personally, alhualim but i feel nicer when the barber takes off the end and trims up my neck line. However its not very short, i can still grab it. I dont like the long beard and bald moustache, i think on some brothers, it looks ugly to me.

@nomaanalwi9495

2 ай бұрын

Why’d you stop going in khurooj?

@yeahbuddy4712

2 ай бұрын

@@nomaanalwi9495 where?

@ren.8137

24 күн бұрын

Yeah fr

I have seen some Maliki scholars with only moustache or they have beard only on the chin and shaved from the side. I listened to a Maliki scholar saying that facial hair is to negate the difference between men and women so any amount of facial hair like only moustache or only on the chin will fulfill the wajib. Please guide in this regard.

@patop6419

2 ай бұрын

moustache is haram

@hamzamedina146

2 ай бұрын

That's what I mean there are many Maliki scholars with different opinions from masjid to masjid they can't even come together and agree on what is common on simple like the beard. Another thing as well is many are sufi or extreme sufi it's hard to tell the difference because sufi don't publicly proclam their practices on bidah and there extreme lengths of the bidah they find acceptable...

@jassimarsingh6505

Ай бұрын

@@patop6419 it’s not, you have to trim it so it doesn’t cover the top lip

@7SMJD

Ай бұрын

Thats not the only reason, it's also about not imitating the disbelievers and idol worshippers and to keep the fitrah i.e. natural disposition Read islamqa question no. 75525 for more info

The strange thing is that many have a big beard and get praises heaped upon and go into discussions about the big beard. May Allah help us

@WaheedAli-lx4hh

2 ай бұрын

The question you must ask is how did the sahaba have their beards? And most narrations will be of men with long beards therefore who understood the hadith as it's supposed to?

@markward3981

2 ай бұрын

@@WaheedAli-lx4hh ? By what methodology must this question be asked

I’m confused you said can’t shape etc but you have it shaped in this vid?

@theimmitigableone8056

2 ай бұрын

He’s talking about shaping lines of the beard to the point where it looks artificial and unnatural, his beard looks maintained and natural.

@SafinaSociety

2 ай бұрын

He said shaping w a blade

@ren.8137

24 күн бұрын

He said its makruh not haram

@ren.8137

24 күн бұрын

Learn how to listen

Have you shaped it, Shaykh?

Never knew so many rules. My goal was as long as possible. 😢

@Servant-of-the-almighty

Ай бұрын

I mean if your a shafi, hanafi, or Hanabali. You can

@ren.8137

24 күн бұрын

Dont look too crazy

There are a few malaki opinions because ive seen plenty imams shave the sides, goatee and just chin hair or was than an old fatwa of a different time?

@sajjadnasir1120

2 ай бұрын

yes i noticed this sheikh is strict

@ren.8137

24 күн бұрын

“This sheikh is strict” no he isnt 💀

@hamzamedina146

24 күн бұрын

@@ren.8137 I've learnt that this is a standard because a hanafi imam also mentioned this in jummah

What about the other prominet madhabs stance on the beards opnion and practice?

@ibrahimSmina

2 ай бұрын

You take what is in your madhab. And let others take what is in their madhab.

@adampops6473

2 ай бұрын

@ibrahimSmina but the whole point of a madhab is the follow the teaching and actions of the Prophet Muhammad saw. All the prominent and most famous scholars make clear that we are trying to follow the sunna and actions of the prophet saw. With that being said what did the prophet saw do or not do to his beard

@ibrahimSmina

2 ай бұрын

@@adampops6473 yes my friend I agree with you that the purpose of madhab is to follow the prophet teachings. But sometimes scholars may have different opinions. For the beard I follow the madhab of imam Malik and I know that it is forbidden to shave it.

@zain1132

2 ай бұрын

​@@ibrahimSminaNo you follow your desire not madhab. You don't take from what you like and leave what you don't. Leave the bears or cut it to a fist length. These are the only two authentic opinions

@ibrahimSmina

2 ай бұрын

@@zain1132 I follow the whole madhab. I don't choose what suits me. For clarification on madahibs I suggest you to see sheikh Said al kamali ' s videos.

اللهم صل على محمد

I’m doing a beard transplant

Question 1) How can one completely remove the cheek hairs (ex:with a blade) but avoid to trim the beard nicely with a blade? It seems in contradiction unless someone makes an effort to remove his cheeks hairs in an inconsistent way as to make his beards look badly designed which seems a bit ridiculous and we see that Shaykh Rami Nsour and Shaykh Shadee himself seem to have a well designed beard. To remove the cheek hairs with a clipper seems as "well designed" as to clip it with a blade. I don't get it. 2) If one has hairs between the lips at the two extremities of the mouth, does that count as the beard? Could he remove it with a blade? Baraka Allahu fikum

So we can trim the beard to a low length but cannot be clean shaven?

@SafinaSociety

2 ай бұрын

Correct in the Maliki school a man must have a beard even if short and cannot shave it with a blade

@user-wf8nq7cm8t

2 ай бұрын

Not permissible to trim short in other schools. In Hanbali it's makrooh to trim beyond fist.

@harjad9546

Ай бұрын

Must have a beard? What if no beard grows at all? Can't help genetics.

@yahya319

Ай бұрын

​@@harjad9546 the specific term in Arabic is let your beard grow not force it to grow. So you are ok in shaa Allah

@harjad9546

Ай бұрын

@@yahya319 I am a kafir but interested in your weird rules.Jazakallahu khairan. 🙏

What about those people who can't grow full facial hair? The hair are far apart, looks like the street lights. Is the modern method of growing hair which involve artificial hair permissable? And whats the fatwa about body and arm hair? Is it haram to shave?

@SafinaSociety

2 ай бұрын

Any hair on the body can be removed except a beard and mustache if it grows normally. Men should not shape eye-brows like women

I see a lot of Egyptian clerics with clean shaven faces. Is there a ruling that support supports this practice?

@Mayranos

2 ай бұрын

in the shafi'i madhab absolutely. Their position is that the beard is under the rule of the customs. and that shaving it completely is makrooh and not haram. Egypt has all 4 madhabs but it is majjoritarly shafi'i

@karimbulldogs1435

2 ай бұрын

@@Mayranos JazakAllah Khair brother

@7625e

2 ай бұрын

@@Mayranos Can you cite a reference for this please. I never heard this before and would like to verify

@Mayranos

2 ай бұрын

@@7625e to be honest you could have searched for it on your own. It is a very well known position of the shafi'i madhab. But still here you go After quoting the statement of Imam al-Halimi in his Minhaj, “It is not permissible for anyone to shave his beard or his eyebrows,” the great scholar and hadith-master, Ibn al-Mulaqqin commented, “His position regarding shaving the beard is a wonderful position, despite the fact that the position that is prevalent in the school is that it is [merely] disliked. “[ Ibn al-Mulaqqin, al-I`lam bi fawa’id `umdat al-ahkam, 1.711?712 ] 2: In the Chapter on `Aqiqa in his interlineal commentary on the Rawd of the Yemeni scholar, Ibn al-Muqri, Shaykh al-Islam Zakariyya al-Ansari said, and [ : it is disliked to prefer beardlessness and pleasant looks by ] plucking it [ i.e. , the beard when it first sprouts ]. The author of the marginal glosses on this work, Imam Ahmad al-Ramli, who was one of the greatest Shafi`i scholars of his time, remarked on the above by saying, Just as it is disliked to pluck the beard, it is also disliked to shave it. Halimi’s statement in his Minhaj that, “It is not permissible for anyone to shave his beard or eyebrows,” is therefore weak 3: Imam Ahmad al-Ramli also stated this explicitly in his collection of legal answers. The Chapter of `Aqiqa in his Fatawa says, [ Question: “Is it unlawful to shave or pluck the hair on the chin or not ?” Answer: “For a man to shave his beard is disliked, but not unlawful. Imam al-Halimi’s statement in his Minhaj that ‘It is not permissible for anyone to shave his beard or eyebrows,’ is a weak position” ] 4: Imam Ahmad al-Ramli’s son, Imam Muhammad al-Ramli’ whose works are relied upon by the late Egyptian Shafi`is for the issuing of formal legal opinion [ fatwa ]said in the Chapter of `Aqiqa in the “Nihaya” : “It is recommended to part and comb one’s hair, and to comb one’s beard. It is disliked to pluck or shave the beard.”

@khairt1731

2 ай бұрын

​@@7625erecite to what reference? This is the shafi fiqh books. Find them and read them

Asalamualikum sheikh Is the one fist rule for chin only.

@SafinaSociety

2 ай бұрын

The sides can be shortened according to the custom of the pious Muslims in your area

@lonemurtaza2276

Ай бұрын

Here fist rule is applied to whole beared. But from sides my beared becomes fuzzy and curly and even not reaching to a length of fist. I am getting complements from people to trim it.

Did Prophet Muhammad ever tell us to trim the bears this small? Did he ever do this?

Some men dont hav facial hair naturally. As a woman i dont like men with long beards . And some of them look very untidy.

@hak78612

Ай бұрын

You dont have to like it.

@abu_muhammad

25 күн бұрын

The 1% or less who don't have facial hair are exempt as common sense will dictate so you don't have to worry about them or use that as an excuse for your dislike of a sunnah. Also, you are 1/10, your dislike for bearded men means nothing when the most beautiful faces that ever walked on this earth, the Anbiya, were men with long beards. Yes, every single one of them. It's the face that's most liked by Allah and that's what matters.

@ren.8137

24 күн бұрын

Incels 💀

To have a fist full beard is wajib period!!!!

@andrewdavanzo8497

2 ай бұрын

Brother 3/4 school of thoughts say it is disliked to trim less than a fist.

@reefatbakht

2 ай бұрын

Difference of opinion exist on the matter, and this is a mercy on the ummah. May Allah be pleased with us all.

@AK_UK_

2 ай бұрын

Thanks anonymous youtube scholar. Glad you finally settled the matter. I'll reject the legitimate differences of opinion amongst massive scholars now that you have given your ruling on the issue!!! 🤣

@elmajraz6019

2 ай бұрын

That's your Madhab. No need to say "period" as if it's unanimously agreed upon.

@dakhan

2 ай бұрын

Calm down 😂

"the beard should be apparent". Is it just me or is the Shaykh's beard not apparent? And why would the Shaykh follow the "bare minimum"? This Shaykh discussing the beard for 10mins seemed very ironic.

@Mehmet_Fateh

2 ай бұрын

It's just you bro.

@ashrafcrew7525

2 ай бұрын

Fair enough. Better put my glasses on

@hamzamedina146

2 ай бұрын

That's what I mean there are many Maliki scholars with different opinions from masjid to masjid they can't even come together and agree on what is common on simple like the beard. Another thing as well is many are sufi or extreme sufi it's hard to tell the difference because sufi don't publicly proclam their practices on bidah and there extreme lengths of the bidah they find acceptable...

@Mehmet_Fateh

2 ай бұрын

@@hamzamedina146 Bro, the Maliki opinion is clear. Growing is recommended, being clean shaven is haram. Why are you using this as a springboard to start taking about sufis and bid'ah?

@bosnaEdis

Ай бұрын

@@ashrafcrew7525 i find it also ridicolous that this guy is talking about beard when he is clearly not following the sunnah of the beard.

The beard is as necessary for a muslim as it is to do hajj for a hungry homeless muslim. The fiqh has priorities for certain contexts and beard was never the status quo of muslims. The sikhs , hippies and judaic faith people also have beards. Hence the distinction is gone in our times

@AdamAli516

2 ай бұрын

If you had basic knowledge of fiqh, you would know that hajj is not necessary for the poor Muslim.

@SafinaSociety

2 ай бұрын

Distinction is not the only reason. Following the Prophet ﷺ is the more important one.

@hamzamedina146

2 ай бұрын

Beard necessary for hajj? That's a lie or a new Maliki fatwa? It's hard to tell because opinions change from imam to Scholar it's confusing

@Umair1

Ай бұрын

@@hamzamedina146 That's not what he said. He tried to make a joke. It was not funny so don't worry that you didn't understand it😂

To my understanding the Maliki madhab relies more on the Medinan way instead of authentic Hadiths. But the method of Ahmad bin Hanbal brings us closest to the Sunnah. Despite being born into a Hanafi family I now follow the Hanbali madhab.

@OiledOttoman

2 ай бұрын

Be humble brother it is not for us to say on which ruling, which Imam was the closest. They were 4 of the greatest scholars and everything we learn from them is from the Sunnah.

@ashequebinkhaled3909

Ай бұрын

@@OiledOttoman No disrespect to any of the Imams, problem is with the blind followers. Every single of the 4 Imams advised the followers to practice on the Authentic Hadiths, even if that goes against their Fiqh.

@OiledOttoman

Ай бұрын

​​​@@ashequebinkhaled3909 akhi, we're all blind followers. Even great scholars like ibn Zayd al Qayrawani followed a madhab. Because the madahib are on the Quran and Sunnah. The mujtahid mutlak Imams talk about taking the strongest opinion, but they're not talking about you and me. They're talking about people who are flawless in the Arabic language and who posses knowledge about the primary and secondary Islamic sciences. We're not the ones to decide which opinion is the strongest and what not.

@kishikishin9810

Ай бұрын

It's not just the medinan but people that studied directly from sahabah in the town Prophet that lived in. Yeah not closest to the Sunnah.

The beard thing is laughable.

None of the sahabah had less than a fist full The amal of the sahabah speaks volumes