I may have liked more of the show... but the bad is still bad. Particulary how Miriel and Galadriel find common ground... how Elendil recruits a few folks... the Númenorean xenophobia... and the Mary Sue Galadriel who apparently can climb as well as any Assassin's Creed hero!

@Too-Odd

Жыл бұрын

The showrunners are from Bad Robot - where all main female characters are Marvel super heroes or Mary Sues.

@refi6438

Жыл бұрын

How do you known we are half way through? Do you know how many episodes there will be? Some series can have as many as 20 episodes. Where u all getting this info cause its not on Amazon? Do you know how many seasons there will be?

@Too-Odd

Жыл бұрын

@@refi6438 Amazon announced eight episodes for season one of The Rings of Power.

@refi6438

Жыл бұрын

@@Too-Odd Oh ok thanks!

@thebaron2277

Жыл бұрын

Also she climbed in a dress. My GF said that that is virtually impossible and it's so dumb

If this “Galadriel” is supposed to be inspirational for girls, imagine what she will inspire girls to be. Angry, unkind, unsympathetic, raging against anyone who says “no” to them, self-righteous, self-absorbed, ready to murder people who disagree with them, and unaware of how to read a map.

@gazlator

Жыл бұрын

Heheh!! And let's not forget to scowl all the time too...

@CorePathway

Жыл бұрын

And stronger than 4 men. I mean, I’ve been to the gym and I can’t count the number of times I’ve seen 130 pound women jacking more iron than any yoked 250 pound Liver Kings.

@djnorth2020

Жыл бұрын

This saddens me, more than turning a powerful states person to a warrior, that she wasn't.

@geminierica4077

Жыл бұрын

Why does Galadriel need to be inspirational or anything at all to young girls lol.. whenever they cast a man is he expected to be an inspiration to young boys? What a dumb take. I have issues with her character but who cares if she's inspiring..

@nalublackwater9729

Жыл бұрын

So... Twitter denizens, then?

"From her earliest years, she had a marvelous gift of insight into the minds of others, but judged them with mercy and understanding, and she withheld her goodwill from none, save only Feanor." - J.R.R. Tolkien This description of the true Galadriel makes Amazon's pathetic version even more laughable!

“It's not about the money, it's about sending a message” - Galadriel, as she burns down a pile of cash.

@jakomioftherose2434

Жыл бұрын

And Tolkien's Legacy with it.

@RangerMcFriendly

Жыл бұрын

@@jakomioftherose2434 I would laugh if it wasn’t so pathetically sad!

The part where Gandalf told Galadriel: “My mama always said life was like a box of chocolates. You never know what you're gonna get.” brought tears to my eyes, best adaptation of Tolkien ever. #wokeness #metoo

@charlesw5919

Жыл бұрын

I just consulted one of the premier Tolkien scholars on Amazon's staff, he verified this is from Tolkien's writings.

"Nobody goes off the trail! And nobody dislikes the show!"

@anneselby2293

Жыл бұрын

🤣🤣

@Domestikos88

Жыл бұрын

The sea of reviews is always right! lol

"the enemy of my enemy is my friend" elendil, as he teams up with sauron to defeat galadriel because all agreed she is the worst...

@rodneyholland1867

Жыл бұрын

I started to think this too... the evil character is Galadriel and everyone will rally together since she pizsed everyone off.

Even Inigo Montoya, driven since childhood by vengeance, is a far more interesting character after only a few minutes of screen time than Galadriel. I suppose the intent is that she will have a 'character arc' (bit of an overused term) and will evolve to learn humility and wisdom and all that; but the trick of such an arc is to make sure we as an audience _care_ about her enough to follow her on that journey. Instead, the only reason that anyone cares is because they know in advance (from Jackson, at least) what she will become.

@gogaonzhezhora8640

Жыл бұрын

I don't think she will have that arc. That's the subconscious hope of Tolkien fans that they at least in the end will still lead to Tolkien. My guess is she will just remain this unbearable Mary Sue Karen and there is no hidden agenda for her development. That's just how they see "empowered" women.

I’m still in shock at how is it possible that people are giving this 10/10 reviews.

@hamletksquid2702

Жыл бұрын

"They drove a dump truck full of money up to my house, I’m not made of stone!" - Krusty the Clown

@JCO2002

Жыл бұрын

Filthy lucre.

@redrum3405

Жыл бұрын

Some people need to watch things. They consume huge amounts of content and it erodes their standards

I don't know why I keep watching so many people break down (roast) this show lol. I have like four queued up and I've never watched an episode. It can only be morbid curiosity.

@faffywaffle4243

Жыл бұрын

I do the same. I have Prime but no way on earth am I even watching this shit. It sounds like a God awful disaster that will always be made fun of till the end of time.

@ayonafulls3364

Жыл бұрын

I think youtube created a market of people roasting mainstream companys.

@ozi618

Жыл бұрын

It sounds weird but #metoo.

@michelledelaloye8555

Жыл бұрын

Same here. It could be morbid curiosity, or perhaps because the roastings are much more enjoyable and funny than actually watching the show

@testdep

Жыл бұрын

me too, yesss!!! anyone can recommend new small channels with

Hallbrand teaching thousands of years old Galadriel how to behave was a weird scene.

Honestly I'm zoning out every 5 mins trying to watch RoP. It's a real endurance test

@tomservo7404

Жыл бұрын

So true I can’t watch an episode without my phone next to me. Boring as hell

@x0xax0x

Жыл бұрын

I fall asleep everytime i turn the show on

Notice how Galadriel actually asks to see the manager (the king) because things are not going her way... well she demands to see the manager. The dwarf storyline is by far the most interesting and enjoyable to watch. That is why the episode was better, more of the focus was on them and the plot of it is actually going places and things are happening, instead of repeating the same (looking at you Galadriel) back and forth.

@PoopaChallupa

Жыл бұрын

Next she will demand to speak to God.

@sunsin1592

Жыл бұрын

Except for the lame ass inclusion of the balrog. And Aretha Dwarfkin. And the ridiculously stupid rock-breaking contest. And their refusal to show the kids. And the lack of beards. Nope; the dwarf storyline is as dumb as the rest.

@Kaitonel

Жыл бұрын

@@sunsin1592 the awakening of the Balrog happens though, granted it is happening at the wrong time to the wrong Durin but still, it is not exactly lame ass to include it. Plus it has not even happened yet. The stone singing is fine, it's not a new concept in fantasy for dwarves to do such a thing, they practically worship their mountains. Tolkien may not have conceptualised it but he didn't say they don't do it either. He had stated that dwarves are much more attuned to the depths of the earth, as the elves are to trees and nature etc. Not seeing the kids changes nothing about the plot so that doesn't bother me. As for the beards, it's a lore thing yes but like the kids changes nothing about the quality (or lack of) of the writing for the plot line. I can't argue about the stone breaking as that was stupid for the plot yes. But as a dwarven ritual it was fine though, plenty of cultures have similar ritual competions. Overall the dwarf storyline is still the superior part of the show, but the bar is so low its not difficult to be.

@zhenc6479

Жыл бұрын

Karendriel

@sarahgopats4571

Жыл бұрын

This Galadriel only is nice/pleasant when it benefits her. She’s on a vengeance crusade And she comes off as angry, selfish, vengeful and will do some kinslaying to get what she wants. How anyone made her a commander I’ll never know. She’s the least likeable.

It's just mind-boggling that they seemingly didn't have any kind of QA in the pre-production. Aren't there tons of people in Hollywood and elsewhere who are professional proof readers and experts on catching errors like the ones they are making here? This script would barely pass as the first iteration of any screenplay, it should have been canned and redone before the first actor was cast and before the first scene was shot.

Four episodes in and Galadriel has already asked to speak to the manager twice.

I love the way that all of Galadriels non-CGI fights are off screen (escaping her escort, trapping the guards in her cell).

So if I'm following what the ROP writers are telling me, Adar and the Orcs care more for their companions than the Harfoots 🤔

@florencen4884

Жыл бұрын

Or the main character Galadriel lol wow

@Olivia-W

Жыл бұрын

I got that vibe, too.

What the heck was that “volunteering” at the end? Like… Numenor, the greatest power there is, needs volunteers to protect their Queen. Honestly, so many scenes are soooo stupid. Galadriel man handling 3 guards into a prison. this is worse than I imagined. I was expecting a ton of made up stories, but the writing is just downright awful.

Well, the good news is that Adar looks the most Elven out of all the Elves, corrupted or not (possibly Arondir as an exception).

@Too-Odd

Жыл бұрын

"... possibly Arondir"? You believe Arondir looks anything close to an elf in Middle Earth? This isn't Forgotten Realms.

@ecthelionofthefountain8267

Жыл бұрын

@@Too-Odd He certainly looks closer to an elf than Celebrimbold and Boy in a band Elrond with pompadour hair.

@Verion01

Жыл бұрын

@@Too-Odd yeah in Forgotten Realms he might even pass for Or tel quessir (sure, they are supposed to have tanned, coppery skin but he would be fitting enough, I think.) As long as he doesn't try those weird-ass spins when fighting, that would get him offed right quick.

@Too-Odd

Жыл бұрын

@@Verion01 If only Amazon had chosen to purchase the Forgotten Realms IP for adaptation, maybe this would have had a chance.

@Too-Odd

Жыл бұрын

@@ecthelionofthefountain8267 His facial features maybe, but his skin and hair are not even close. That is not to say the others are close either. The showrunners have no comprehension what Tolkien elves look like.

I really cant stand how this show expects you to know what characters are talking about when they reference the first age but expect you to ignore what's supposed to happen in the second. Also, didn't Payne & McKay promise us no real world politics? How soon before we see Pharazon basically go full MAGA on us?

@RangerMcFriendly

Жыл бұрын

The fact that Amazon entrusted such a beloved series to two newcomers is staggeringly incompetent.

@FlyfishermanMike

Жыл бұрын

Pharazon's son has been described as Trump Jr...

As an American you don't clearly see some obvious "americanisms", that are a massive cliche.... They add missery to the poor acting and dialog From a European point of view this is a massive tragedy from the first second. As much as all previous episodes

@JCO2002

Жыл бұрын

Exactly. It's just more of the typical cliched garbage that Yanks produce.

Something to think about: It really, really feels like they're cost cutting. There's a significant lack of action. The action scene we did get this episode was boring and in slow motion, which made it really boring. The Adar scene was used twice, but just cut early at the end of Ep 3. They're reusing a lot of the same sets for multiple scenes. Sometimes one scene will end, they'll switch angles, and focus on different characters on the same set. All of the actors are unknown. I heard someone else say it - and I do think there's money laundering going on lol. The money is NOT on the screen.

You haven't seen the things that I have seen, have you? No, no you haven't, Because only I have seen those things. Sure you've seen some things, but I'm not talking about those things, I'm talking about the things I've seen because you haven't seen them. And because I've seen them and you haven't that makes me better than you in every way. -Galadriel Take that Tolkien!

They rapidly turned Adar from a somewhat intruiging character to an idiot, very fast. He inexplicably allows Arondir to leave, which directly leads to him killing the orc who was about to retrieve the sword from Theo, an item which Adar is searching for.

@anneselby2293

Жыл бұрын

Although it's possible that Adar feels that any fight against the Watchtower is already won and perhaps he hopes Arondir will take it as a gesture of good faith. I'm just stretching here, it does make no sense that he was given his weapons back. What would be more likely is that Arondir would be delivered to the gates of the watchtower by the orcs, beaten within in an inch of his life, or perhaps even dead with a message stuck to him. An arrow stuck in his eye would do it.

I am really starting to hate Galadriel. She was wise enough to stay away from being involved with Feanor but is really impulsive here and stupid. Galadriel is supposed to be wise. This Galadirel is insufferable... Instead of this thing, have a story about Feanor or his sons instead!! Some of the decisions people make are very infuriating! Theo purposefully puts others in trouble because of the sword. Isildur purposefully screws up and, as a consequence, gets his friends fired. Dwarfs are fine, but I hate how insensitive Celebrimbor is towards Elrond. The sons of Feanor were the ones who destroyed his family, yet, he casually talks about Eärendil. I wish this would be explored! How the actions of Feanor have affected Elrond and Celebrimbor!!

@Verion01

Жыл бұрын

Pretty much all elves (save, maybe, Elrond) are portrayed as utter morons... one has to wonder, how such a bunch of inepts managed to fend off Morgoth for any stretch of time (unless, of course, SuperGaladriel did it all alone ;) )

@Olivia-W

Жыл бұрын

Please don't drag the sons of Fëanor into this. I'm pretty sure the eternal darkness is better than potentially becoming a short haired and dumbed down pseudo-elf.

My Daughter: That's not Galadriel, that's a selfish b****. She's still raging

It was toward's the end so I wasn't paying as much attention, but were they asking for volunteers in Númenor to send a force to the Southlands? We are to believe that Númenor did not have a navy?

@Verion01

Жыл бұрын

Well, with the ships they are shown using in the show.. nope, they do not. Those tubs would not make it through any stretch of an ocean with that weird mast and sails setup they got.

I managed to watch halfway through the second episode. I don't feel like watching anymore. But watching videos of people commenting on what a disgrace it is, is almost mesmerizing. It's fun. Bad work needs to be criticized.

@gamble777888

Жыл бұрын

It would be so interesting if we could compare what the shows REAL ratings are to how many people are watching reviews tearing the show to pieces online. I would bet a lot of money youtube videos on the aggregate are getting more real views.

John Wick is a vengeance-driven monster and he has more charisma and generates more empathy that Galadriel.

Hear me out: It's a remake of Roots starring Kevin Bacon as Kunta Kinte. Only Kunta (Kevin) is non-binary transgender, but this struggle isn't revealed until the end in a massive show tune. We call it Rootsie!

Changes to historical material for narrative reasons (i.e. for better filmability) are okay in films - Only Glorfindel or Tom Bombadil in LoR should be mentioned here. And no one would object to Hamlet or the like being portrayed in a completely different context. A Macbeth equivalent set in an Indian kingdom doesn't hurt anyone. But to mutilate characters or content in original stories or settings beyond recognition, is an affront to someone else's cultural achievement. The worst thing about RoP is that most of the male characters are portrayed as jerks, or seem slightly gay. But the crowning glory is the character Galadriel, who slaughters her way through hordes of orcs and trolls as Galadriel the Barbarian. Nothing remains of the dignified, powerful and enigmatic sorceress in Tolkien's works. Admittedly, the two colored actors (Elf & Dwarf) still have the best performance, in terms of acting. I'd rather not say anything about the Harfoots, they remind me too much of the Ewoks from StarWars.

It definitely was the most watchable of all the episodes so far. Galadriel can not be fixed. We have to try to endure the petulant, smarty-pants Amazonian warrior. I really enjoy everything they are doing in Khazad Dum. Elrond, Durin IV and Dísa have great chemistry. It is too bad they couldn't give us this kind of interaction anywhere else. They really messed up Miriel too. The actress's acting has been horrible up to now. I still haven't figured out what just happened in Episode 4. She was clearly anti-Faithful. Then she goes to her father and said something like: the moment we have long feared has come. The Elf is here. That is clearly what a elf-hayer would say. Then the next episode she and Galadriel are BFF. Just stupid, awful writing...

@rodneyholland1867

Жыл бұрын

Maybe Galadriel is Sauron? She seems to be the most destructive character so far.

It's hard to replicate something when the very foundations of your being are opposite to those of the original's creator: elves that are just people with pointy ears and highly-selective wufu; people that are just a checklist of stereotypes; harbits that are savages and haven't even achieved animal husbandry; and incoherent timeline and geography, with nonsensical dialog. Even without dragging Tolkien's name into it, or the $1bn most-expensive-evah, it's still awful television.

I guess the food equivalent of TRoP is Eowyn's fish stew.

@Lillogicaallegria

Жыл бұрын

ahah! ...but I supposed was meat fat, not fish. it was so jelly and slimy!

@TheSaintBigFoot

Жыл бұрын

It was camp food that was so horrible they used it on set

They stole thier intro from a video ten years old. Just shows how little actual imagination they have.

These is already an Assassins Creed game set in Middle Earth and it is far cooler than this show.

@mixelplik

Жыл бұрын

Shadow of War breaks the lore, but in a creative way that fits in with Tolkien's world, by not destroying current lore. Rings of Power goes out of its way to destroy lore.

@luthasunspell8365

Жыл бұрын

Shadow of Mordor/War get the lore way wrong… and it’s still more fun, interesting, consistent, and on theme than this show. For one thing, Celebrimbor didn’t look like my grandmother in pointed ears.

* Elrond bangs on stone wall * "Shave and a haircut.... "

Galadriel is so angry all the time, what were they thinking with this, no one could ever get behind a character like her, shes angry and aggressive and whenever she doesn't get her way she insults and ridicules those that she seeks help from. Truly exceptional. Imagine watching that character for 8 seasons, as a 1000+ year old elf she isnt going to do much changing either.

watching this mess, I have a feeling that theres so much they filmed but had to cut out because they didn't have the rights to most of it. The show looks like it's missing so many scenes, and most of what we are watching is just filler and reshoots, that's why we see just a couple of characters on scene at a any given time.

@Olivia-W

Жыл бұрын

It looks like a desperate rush job, tbh.

Wait... You let one rope slip and you get kicked off the boat and it ruins 3 people's entire lives!? Lolol

I'm just happy to see you put your headphones on correctly this week

The aspect of Galadriel's revenge arc that annoys me most is it's pointless. We know she fails, we know she survives, we know Sauron reforms. We even know Finrod "gets better"!

The ending was a great visual feast, but it was completely unearned. is absolutely no reason why Muriel changed her mind - except the pedals falling from the sky. In other words, there wasn't a dramatic story for her to change her mind.

I seem to recall that Durin I discovered Mithril in Kazad Dum back in the first age... and in the PJ movies, Gandalf points out a mithril vein on the main level of the city as they are passing through it. Mithril was 'THE" wealth of Moria.

@Tar-Elenion

Жыл бұрын

"Later some of the Noldor went to Eregion, upon the west of the Misty Mountains, and near to the West-gate of Moria. This they did because they learned that mithril had been discovered in Moria." LotR, App. B, The Second Age

I'm officially done with RoP. Watching the first three episodes where a chore but by the fourth, 10 minutes in I tapped out.

Awesome to find more Tolkien gatekeepers on KZread. You are doing an awesome job with these reviews

When Guyladriel threw Finrodimus a saw and said he had 5 minutes to saw of a limb and live before the Werrwolf would come, that was powerfull.

I always look forward to your reviews and comments. I think the showrunners are banking on a Stockholm Syndrome effect with their audience, or whatever it is to call it: as the show gets less bad, viewers will give their sympathy and then their loyalty and become fans of it. Or, whether that's the showrunners' conscious intent, I think it's a danger for a lot of viewers who are kind-hearted and inclined to give others the benefit of the doubt. As far as I'm concerned, I will have peace with Amazon's show when it hangs from a gibbet for the sport of its own crows.

@TheOne-ok7gn

Жыл бұрын

gibbets and crows? dotard! - jeff bezos

And the season is half over. 😂

None of this music will be played in concert halls 20 years from now

Well this is better because the plot was actually advanced. and the last scene was great even though it was completely unearned. I like how we're introduced to all these characters as if they are all Sauron all the time. Maybe Galadriel will be Sauron. That would make some sense.

This is now twice where the director cuts away and we don't see Galadriel in action. evidently she has no action skills or ability

Who cast Marilyn Manson in the role of Adar? Maybe it was the same person who decided to put Disa's beard on top of her head.

Every Tolkien character is butchered! They’re nothing like their book counterpart. All 8 - Pharazon, Muriel, Elendil, Isildur, Elrond, Celebrimbor, Gil Galad, and especially Galadriel!!

I tried. I really tried but couldn't make it to the end of the first episode. Glad to know I'm not missing much

Elrond saw the cave in and never helped his friend save anyone??!!!!

Galadriel can make you root for orcs and sauron to destroy these stupid elves sooner!

3:32 While Isildur is a composite, and Isil alone is stressed ISil, I think the correct application of the Antepaenultima rule that Tolkien reapplied to both Sindarin and Quenya from Latin would be isILDur. Not ISilDUR.

After looking up some pictures of Adar, he really looks like the most elven (though evil/corrupted) elf so far... which means they can in theory get it right-ish, just chose to not do so most of the time? What a mess

@dw620

Жыл бұрын

From what we know already, no elf was ever so *willingly* evil in Tolkien's work. So, if you mean by "right-ish" 1% right rather than 0.1% right, I suppose so... ~

@Makkaru112

Жыл бұрын

Imagine if it was something like a failed experiment and he isn't evil per se, that could drive us toward actually giving us actual second and first age content regarding the Avari elves and many of them being taken by Morgoth etc.

@silmaril8989

Жыл бұрын

@@dw620 I was referring more to how he looks like, not that he's evil. To me he looks elvish, just obviously not like a normal elf but somehow corrupted/evil with the burned skin (one of Morgoths and later Saurons theme was fire so... I guess it fits? Or maybe I'm trying to read actual lore into it :D) and him seemingly leading orcs

Harfoots? Harfeet! Yayyyy ..(applause)

The contrived reason for Galadriels single mindedness is the death of her brother. The problem is that this happened in the first age. Sure it is Sauron who sends the werewolf to do the fell deed. The battle we see is not the occasion where Finrod was killed. Then we have a problem with time. When the rings of power were fashioned Tar Palantir was not yet born, that was 1500 years later. Yet in the show the crafting of the rings has not even startet and we are in about the year 3200 or so. When will happen all that has happened heretofore? There is not enough time for all of that, particularly the fortification of Mordor, the founding of Umbar, the erection of Baraddur!

Isidul about to get his diploma any day now but drop out because he heard a voice from the ocean.

The structure looks like the Tower of Babel. Remember, Numenor was destroyed because they made war on the Valar.

@RangerMcFriendly

Жыл бұрын

Something tells me that Eru Iluvatar will not be the cause of their destruction because he is the God of Tolkien’s lore. Can’t have God in Hollywood shows… it will be an earthquake since that’s what they are hinting in this episode.

@br1472an

Жыл бұрын

@@RangerMcFriendly Yeah , Religion Bad , except devil worship, Hollywood all for that .

They like writing the Duren/Eldor relationship because they are use to writing soap-series. They love love triangles with some gay/bi action involved 😂

my guess is, each character story was assigned to a different writer/s bcoz the quality of writing changes accordingly. for example the person writing galadriels lines is not the same as the person writing durins lines, just a thought but its very possible.

Has anyone thought of how many new characters Amazon and their beloved writers created already just to perform 4 episodes so far? And on top of this watching a known character like Galadriel performing the way these brilliant minds wrote so far her plot?

I decided I was too quick to shut the show down - I gave it 23 minutes in episode 1 and turned it off. I binged the four episodes last night and I will say visually it's stunning (then it should be given CGI tech) Bear McCreary writes a great soundtrack. Some of the performances, despite the writing, are good. (Here comes the Ned Stark "but.") The uneven writing and lack of cohesive story is the fail. At times I try to figure out if the writers are trying to write like they think Tolkien would mimic Shakespeare or if it's Shakespeare mimics Tolkien. Doesn't matter because it doesn't work. This writing team needs to put a 100% bona fide fantasy author in charge. They just don't understand the genre and are too trope reliant and ask for too much suspension of disbelief (Galadriel is going to swim across an ocean - many, many, many, eyerolls).

Guyladriel is the worst.

Middle earth shadow of war is effectively lotr assassins creed.

Lot of teleports in this episode...

They just keep butchering Tolkien’s work more and more .fuck this show 😂😂😂😂

Honestly it was probably my favorite episode so far because…no harfoots

Love your reviews.

Looking forward to your long form review of this episode.

This show is GARBAGE

How long ago did they start shooting that Regis was able to complete all of his Celebrimborn scenes?

Rings of Power: Episode 4 Analysis and Reaction | Rings & Realms: kzread.info/dash/bejne/Z6OBs9Sjg9W-lrg.html

I'm LOVING this

Your a true hero to endure so much suffering of the ring

Where is the "ticking time bomb" in this story? It's already half way through and none of the main characters is faced with the pressures of time running out. This gets worse because the pace is so glacial.

Somehow Galadriel climbing outside of the tower reminds me of Schwarzenegger's Conan the Barbarian; didn't he climb a tower, too?

His eyes are so beautiful, like a clear sky.

Happy that we didn't have to suffer through the dirty Harlots. At least for one episode.

Were they going to row Galadriel all the way to Middle Earth, with her standing the whole way?

Great video.

why do the main characters have every right to know every secrets? especially a dwarven secret.

The best part of this episode - no Harfoots!

Why is there farm land on the island. They only eat fish but the only boats are military craft. After all the SEA IS ALWAYS RIGHT!

A better episode but that's not saying much in view of what we've already seen. It's reached the mediocrity mark. It didn't leave me feeling anything too negative but also continued to fail to pull me in. Very forgettable in both ways.

Adar is the Mouth of Sauron

Perhaps like the fan edit of the Hobbit trilogy that cut out all the fluff into one long movie there'll be a similar thing to this program. Can't fix the written portions but by at least cutting the unnecessary the storyline can actually move and develop a more than a glacial pace.

@AudioEpics

Жыл бұрын

I really hate the very concept of fan edits, personally.

Vilya's real power is teleportation

I gave up ...

eh. i think the daikinis are actually cute. the kids love em. there should be a separate children's program using the daikinis.

Hey the sea is always right and the sea really really really wants get rid of galadriel.

Galadriel is an Elf,... Legolas is an Elf,.... Did you watch Legolas in either the Hobbit or LoTR,?... They have enhanced balance, timing and strength.

I think they could get rid of the harfoots, Arondir and Bronwin. I don't care about any of those characters. They grind the pacing to a screeching halt every time they're on screen. Halbro should take center stage in the Galadrial plotline. He's way more interesting and likeable.

Joseph Mawle (Attar) is a proper actor. I hope they make good use of him. What grated on me was the Dwarf queen referring to her kids as 'wains', which is a Glasgow colloquialism. Are the Dwarfs going to be eating fried Mars bars and drinking Irn Bru at their next feast?

@baldrbraa

Жыл бұрын

A stonner supper for me please.

We still haven't seen Anarion

I'm going for Adar being Maglor.