Apologies if my voice over is hit and miss on this one, my throat has been a bit rough so I had to record it in chunks. I also got a few pronunciations wrong but didn't realise until too late to fix them for the collab deadline, thankfully my guests did a much better job. Also two minor corrections: - Around 26:38, this treaty did not restrict Roman trade in Sicily, I got that wrong. - Lilybaeum became the modern city of Marsala, not Palermo as it says in the image at 24:37. Thanks to commenter Alessandro Gianni for the catch.

@napoleonbonapartei7245

3 жыл бұрын

19:16 Rome wouldn't be sacked for another 800 years...

@fabriziomangione3231

3 жыл бұрын

This documentary is pretty good, but you ended it before talking about a major battle on my hometown soil and that makes it even better. In fact all this collab made me somewhat homesick. I hope the next chapter comes out soon, keep up the good work, happy holidays! P.s. You look like a missing member of One Direction. I just wanted to point that out.

@YAH2121

3 жыл бұрын

You're a great presenter btw, well-spoken and know when and when not to add emphasis and control inflections. Nothing sounds awkward and overly scripted.

@taethegreat6607

3 жыл бұрын

Keep up the great work man! Your channel has inspired me to start work on my own mini documentaries on ancient history

@PalleRasmussen

3 жыл бұрын

You actually tell a lie. Rome *did* have armies- in the field even- after Cannae. That, coupled with the size of the city, was why Hannibal did not besiege it. I have not watched the rest yet, but will; you are doing well in your presentation and I have noticed nothing. Remember that you *always' find yourself sounding weird "on tape".

Cracking vid. Looking forward to the rest in the series

What an absolutely cracking video! It always scares me when we mention the same topics. My heart was in my mouth when you mentioned the political offices lol.

This is comfort content. Love the topics. Subscribed!

@josephk5385

3 жыл бұрын

Sup dude, big fan

@JasonSmith-ub8bj

3 жыл бұрын

Aye what’s up Diplex

@billyhodge2621

3 жыл бұрын

Same 👍

@rockinunderscore52

3 жыл бұрын

rock on diplex 👍

@BamaPigBows

3 жыл бұрын

Yo you should do a total war play using the Punic wars mod. It's amazing and super rich in detail, I'm sure your PC setup would run it like a champ. Keep up the great work bro, one love from Nebraska USA

It's great to finally put a face to the voice!! Have been a Histocrat fan some time now and really enjoy your work. I only wish I had the funds to support you more than just views. Hopefully once all this BS gets over with that will change. Thank You Sir for your time and efforts! They are truly appreciated!

@3DGECASE

3 жыл бұрын

I assume you didn't watch his Q&A video.

It's crazy how your content covers exactly my favorite periods and topics in history. Neolithic civilizations ✔️ Late Bronze Age ✔️ Late Roman Republic (Caesar) ✔️ Punic Wars ✔️ And each video is a masterclass in historical story telling. Awesome work brother! With the History channel being what it is, there's a surge in interest in historical content on youtube. Keep doing what you're doing (quality over quantity) and I'm positive that your channel will be huge.

12:00 I'm sure many know this but this event is where we get the term "phyrric victory"

Another ep I can fall asleep 300 times to

@IzabelParis

3 жыл бұрын

I do the same thing 👍

I always feel sad when I hear about Carthage. Super interesting underappreciated part of history.

@mawlinzebra

Жыл бұрын

They deserved it for sacrificing their first born

I was not prepared for the face reveal.

@leepeel7129

3 жыл бұрын

Gobsmacked takes a new meaning!

@napoleonbonapartei7245

3 жыл бұрын

He has shown his face before. I am genuinely surprised no one has seen his face.

@Tomartyr

3 жыл бұрын

I refuse to believe he doesn't have a beard and a sweater with elbow patches.

@gailhandschuh1138

3 жыл бұрын

Excellent narrator and content BUT, you need to learn to control your distracting hands. They add nothing to the storyline and simply are distracting for the viewers.

@BrassDragon275

2 жыл бұрын

@@gailhandschuh1138 I disagree, still hands make it appear artificial and weird. Moving your hands during long speech is perfectly natural

A Histocrat video I can finish in 1 sitting? It's a Christmas miracle

I'm glad there are people like you making quality content like this. And having different runtimes from different creators lets me do deep dives when I want to, or scan the surface to pick up the general concepts.

Love the video! There are so few videos on the Punic Wars and even less of such high quality. Both incredibly informative and extremely engaging. I can’t wait for the next video(s) in the series! Great work!

When does the rest of this series come out???

All HAIL the Histocrat. Can't wait to watch this.

10/10 high quality content here. You deserve way more subs and way more views

Nice to see your face this time too, freaking love your content, I watch it thru once than add it to my bedtime list and listen to your videos all thru the night.

I really like that you discuss the different historcial sources in your videos. Great stuff!

This is a GREAT documentary, well done, sub for sure, and I'll pass along the channel, and please give us the next chapter! I've now watched it a few times and am so ready for the next part!

History time on the phoenicians and histocrat on the punic wars, nice little early Christmas present 😁

Amazing content. Thoroughly enjoyed all the Early civilization videos. Glad to have subscribed, and I look forward to watching the rest of your videos.

Fantastic video! Really looking forward to the next parts.

Love it, wanna more of it! Congratulations on quality and formative aspect of your video

Love the channel! I also really enjoy these history youtuber collab videos you guys do!

Just noticed how recent this upload is. You always make great content. Looking forward to this one!

Great video, thanks for this! Thoroughly enjoyed it. And perfect hand movement, ngl.

Love the quality content you produce.

The struggle between carthage and rome is my favourite. Thanks for covering

I was just recommended this video after binging some Stefan Milos video’s yesterday. Subbed!

Awesome content as always keep up the awesome work!

Awesome job as usual - I look forward to your videos!!

This feels like tuning into a tv show having missed the first few episodes But then you watch it anyway because it's a great show

Another great video, thanks Charles

Great vid. Especially liked the naming of the ancient sources.

Amazing crossover from _Voices of the Past, History Time_ and _Stefan Milo._

Fantastic video mate - keep it up!!

9:15 Damn that's not what I expected you to look like. Awesome video though man. Very in depth. Read and watched a lot on the Punic Wars. But still found this very enjoyable and thorough.

great stuff! Thanks for this

Great video! Love your channel

The prime of history channels right here

I'd love to see more Rome related content on this excellent channel

very good and factual series on the Punic Wars; very good jobs. honestly, this period doesn't get its share of research many thx for shedding light on it

Give this man a TV CHANNEL!!

great video, thank you so much!

Well, now I know what imma fall asleep to.

@Zogerpogger

3 жыл бұрын

I'm on the edge of my seat! how can you fall asleep to this?

@MasterEsben18

3 жыл бұрын

@@Zogerpogger Haha not in the sense that its boring, but its exactly the kind of stuff i like to watch in bed before I go to sleep. Merry Xmas.

@Zogerpogger

3 жыл бұрын

@@MasterEsben18 Ahh I get what your saying, yeah, podcasts are great before nodding off. I recommend Mike Duncan's A History of Rome. Merry Christmas to you too!

@MasterEsben18

3 жыл бұрын

@@Zogerpogger Hahahaha, my man, I'm nearly done with it. But holy hell, that is one big podcast. Sound isnt great, but the history and narration is awesome! Two minds alike.

@Zogerpogger

3 жыл бұрын

@@MasterEsben18 Oh nice! I've listened to it at least twice now haha. Happy to meet another kindred spirit!

I have just finished Flash Point History's podcast and want to continue my study on this titanic trilogy of these wars. Now I will be able to know further my studies, thank you.

@shachmon1

3 жыл бұрын

Read or listen to Adrian Goldsworthy's 'The Fall of Carthage'. One of the best books on the subject.

Can’t wait for more!

Pff, people saying they weren't prepared for the face reveal, 10 steps ahead of you bud. Watched Atun-Shei's video about being a KZreadr. Jokes aside, great video! While I am inclined to whine about a new series coming out as opposed to the next installment of a History of Britain, anything you release will brighten my day; so thanks so much for making these documentaries! I totally understand creating new projects rather than continuing older ones, it can be difficult to find inspiration.

Rome's overpowered strategy: just never surrender. Can't lose always wins.

@TheHistocrat

3 жыл бұрын

The NO YOU of warfare.

@jackdonith

3 жыл бұрын

The thing is, all the parts Rome conquered, became Rome too. The conquered people were Romans themselves and most of the places in Italy had a lot of people (unlike say Africa) which meant Rome had a big pool of men. Lose a legion send two. Lose 2 legions? Send 3 brand new. Hannibal tried to break Rome's alliances but failed. And although he was unbeatable in Italy, Rome could stillhave enough garrisons and send legions beyond italy at the same time. If Carthage was like Rome, Hannibal would have gotten enough men after Cannae to besiege Rome itself. As it was he had so few men that he had to move from city to city losing each one once he left.

@babulburel547

3 жыл бұрын

What are they saying? Something about your mother. And so, the barbarians invaded Rome.

Loving the hand gestures. Also Ijust had to subscribed

another great video!

Very nice video.

Sad how many old books have been lost, or even destroyed, stuff we can't never find out about, despite their authors best attempts. Great video again!

Such great storytelling and research. We know more about these old wars than we do about many modern affairs.

@martijn9568

Жыл бұрын

I really doubt that. Modern affairs have many more sources floating around then what we have of conflicts from 2000 years ago.

So good I watched it twice

This has been a complete master piece of a video, I am looking forward to the 1st Punic war. There are no good videos in KZread about the 1st Punic war so if you do it you would get some good merit

@movieman6456

2 жыл бұрын

Check out Flash Point History’s series. If you are open to podcasts, History of Rome and Dan Carlin also do great coverage.

This is all fine and good but when is the next history of Britain coming out? Still an outstanding video

@TheHistocrat

3 жыл бұрын

There will be at least one in 2021. Going to Hadrian's wall and everything if I can.

I somehow got unsubscribed to this channel! Resubscribed! I love your content!

This is very good thankyou

Fantastic thanks very much 😁

Great video

Thanks!

love to see it !

Thanks for another video! Wondering if some of the videos that were taken down are elsewhere?

Love your library. Curious about the big red book with MI6 on the spine?

@TheHistocrat

3 жыл бұрын

It was a random gift from a family member, I will confess I've never opened it due to its extreme length.

Best ounic war vídeo ever!!!

Great stuff, I like you including yourself, brings more personality. A little bit too many hand actions though, it is distracting. I will be looking forward to the next part. Always love the small pieces of detail which bring colour to the painting of history.

@TheHistocrat

3 жыл бұрын

yeah gonna look to improve going forward, also didn't like how I shifted around a bunch in later takes (because I'd been stood in the same spot for 90 minutes and my feet were aching)

How does this not have more hits? Great stuff.

This entire video is incredible, and I wonder what you'd do if someone ever handed you a bag of money to make a documentary or series.

What a beautiful sight to wake up to.

first time ive seen you on cam. I like it gj

Thank you!!!

outstanding

As always, great job. I like that you've included clips of yourself explaining things in person. The production is great and reminds me of the golden age of the history channel, back when it was about, well, history... I digress... Now for some constructive criticism. The background of book shelves in these in person scenes is good, but I feel that a relevant map may work better. In these scenes, as some have noted, your hand movements can be distracting. I would suggest practicing some hand movements that have more meaning behind them with respect to the content being voiced. For example, when describing a timeline, start on one side and hold it for the line until it mentions the later date, at which point you then move your hands over to relay the passage of that time. Little things like these help to keep us, as viewers, both engaged and entertained. Thanks for taking the time to make such great content, and I look forward to the next installment.

Listening to these during the day then using them to fall asleep at night>>>>>

Good video.

A fan favorite.

Rewatch before seeing your new vid on the Punic War (264-256 BC)

bam actually the best youtube channel

History time is the absolute shit. Subbed my dude

Not sure if it is on purpose or not, but curious if you're trying to add more background audio effects to the videos lately? Many other history channels have so much background audio that they are unwatchable. I prefer yours because of the top not content and 'less is more' approach to the sound effects. Anyway, just curious if you could/would upload versions without a backing audio track at all - just voice commentary? I've seen a few other youtubers do that. Would be an incentive for potential patreons as well. Just my thoughts, and thanks for the great videos.

@TheHistocrat

3 жыл бұрын

Been considering doing that, its on the project list.

More on this!

your cadence has improved a lot, great stuff.

Rome when carthage started a war for the third time: "How many times do we have to teach you this lesson old man?"

Love the cameos by Stefan and Pete. Fantastic video, Charles!

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that at this stage of Rome, soldiers actually had to own land to become a soldier. And Maleventum was a disastrous defeat for Pyrrhus. It only became named Beneventum after the Roman victory.

Great work! What sources did you draw on for this video?

@TheHistocrat

3 жыл бұрын

Check the credits for sources.

I’ve seen your face now I’ll never unsee it when I listen to you

Came here after watching pka, was not disappointed

@thescroogemcduck

3 жыл бұрын

Same bro, never thought Pyle would lead me to a history channel

It would be awesome if some of these videos were audio clips I can pull from spotify or soundcloud. Something to listen to when I drive long distance

@Zogerpogger

3 жыл бұрын

Use youtube to mp3, you can download the audio from any youtube video.

You look much younger than Ive imagined you to

Very interesting video. Just note that Lilybaeum is now Marsala, not Palermo (Panormus).

yeeees my favourite historic showdown. a close second would have to be WW1.

OMG, a face to the voice. Great video.

You should make a video about the glory of cirta , numedia

I know how this ends, and yet, I can't help but root for Carthage every time.....

Watched it through twice now. You have to pay attention.

Have you ever made a video about Roman spies and foreign spies in Roman territory? Was wondering what that was like.

13:28 tfw future historians describe western representive democracies in the same way.

The REALY need to figure out how to make Garum again... YES I KNOW "FISH SAUCE" NOT THE SAME. That's all I have to say actually, gonna binge your Chanel now THNX!