Syrians and Afghans moving into Germany -> "These are the New Germans!" Ok, so what's Al Jazeera's opinion on this? Israelis moving into Palestine -> "These are the New Palestinians!"

@dexterlecter7289

6 жыл бұрын

Mike Drop!

@dexterlecter7289

6 жыл бұрын

That's debatable and I believe, generally null. There are multiple ways of conquering land and populating it with people. By your logic Germany can become completely Arab in ethnicity yet still function as the Germany of 2010. I see your point and it's a fair one to consider but when considering long term sociological implications one must take much more into account.

@mangalores-x_x

6 жыл бұрын

The first thing is understanding what a refugee status is and what germany traditionally does with it. Namely once the status evaporates most refugees of war countries return or are returned within a decade, not months or weeks but inside 10 years. Maybe more will stay this time because their countries are a mess even if we claim they are normal (which we Germans would still consider a hellhole) but this is not actual immigration or a guest worker program like with EU citizens or like in the 60s. We had the same rightwing BS of arsonists burning down asylum homes with people inside in the 90s- The difference is just how germany reacted this time around.

@haboubia

6 жыл бұрын

Then why don't they call themselves Palestinians ?

@odtandthebackupplan

6 жыл бұрын

right

OK. I am a German and I am living in Doha. I want to eat pork, I want drink alcohol and I want a church here to pray my god. This is how I want to be. But I am not allowed to do all these things here. If I can not live here without these things, I should go back to my beloved country, simple as that.

@tibbygaycat

7 жыл бұрын

You are allowed to do that in Germany you dipshit, just get over it and let them live.

@amoss5844

7 жыл бұрын

Yes, if I am visiting a Middle Eastern country, I am supposed to respect their culture.

@Adi-gh9du

7 жыл бұрын

there is churches and yes you can drink and eat pork.....but truth is you dont pray and dont care about god.

@Adi-gh9du

7 жыл бұрын

theres lots of churches in qatar, end of the day dont play with people on here.....be honest be a man....

@amoss5844

7 жыл бұрын

:-) Seriously? Lots of churches? Yeah, 'don't play with people on here'. It is OK to play elsewhere.

Why don't those arabs go to arabia?

@Kiviantares

6 жыл бұрын

Because of financial reasons

@ileanaacacostaacosta1813

Жыл бұрын

Hijab doesn't belong in Germany or any westerner society I hate it when I see those women with those rags on their heads aahhgh

What I'm curious about: if he's been in Germany for 3 years, why does he still not speak German? In the scene in the mosque he even needed the parallel translation. Why is that? If he considers himself a new German, why doesn't he take some hints from the first generation he interviewed in this movie and starts by learning the language? A big part of the cultural divide (between any two or more cultures) is always the language barrier.

@zgoombah1308

6 жыл бұрын

Even if they assimilated perfectly, they are racially non-German and must be utterly expelled. Race is not skin deep.

@Marina-vd5vm

6 жыл бұрын

Sooo.. why bother learning the language? Or what's your point?

@Marina-vd5vm

6 жыл бұрын

So I ask again: what's your point? Ppl shouldn't learn the language of the country they're living in, because why bother? Sorry, but that's ignorant and dumb. And disrespectful to the country you chose to make your home.

@jennedortmund7510

6 жыл бұрын

edu train what? where do you get that from?

@angelaschonebeck3252

4 жыл бұрын

@@Marina-vd5vm He does speak German and is most certainly still learning it. However, as a good journalist, he wants to make sure to understand everything precisely in order to ask further questions or sort out relevant information for his documentary. The documentary showed in different scenes (e.g. at the very end) that he speaks German. Have you ever tried to master a language as an adult, especially a difficult language such as German? It takes time and three years will be enough to live your everyday life in Germany but not to create such a complex and well researched documentary. I, as a German, think it's a shame to insult someone as ignorant and dumb just because he wants to work properly. It's easy to write a comment like yours under this short film but it's mentally challenging for some to empathetically put your mind into his position.

They are not new Germans, they are people who live in Germany and they have foreign ancestry and nationality. It is not so easy to achieve German citizenship, and it will not happen because a person will learn a language. A person must follow German law, rules and respect the culture. When I go to Germany from a neighbouring country and live there that does not mean I am German.

@artygracja2097

6 жыл бұрын

Chopper Morton It is not necessery to go to Japan. I live in Poland and here we also have safety and monocultural society. I know many foreigners but they are europiens or at least they respect Europien values. But I also think that multiculturalism which means that different cultures are mixed on one soil is failed. It does not work. It is not a case of colour of skin or nationality, it is a case of values and a question do people love new country and will follow social rules of that country.

@Zgmflegend

6 жыл бұрын

You are German when you are Germanic. Do you not understand this?

@MichaelPolios

6 жыл бұрын

haha even if these immigrants learnt the language, followed the law and respected the culture, it still wouldn't be enough for you. Ultimately, only if they change the colour of their skin will it be enough.

@Zgmflegend

6 жыл бұрын

It is *a lot* more than just skin colour...Like racial feature/traits differences you have with dog breeds.

@informed.martin.mediacriti6769

6 жыл бұрын

Thats cuz your a POLLACK

😂😂😂. Sod off, Germans are Germans, there's no new German. Dream on.

@PodcastCentral333

3 жыл бұрын

Are French nationals only white?! Many countries are multi ethnic like germany

@freckleheckler6311

3 жыл бұрын

JD Visuals those are foreigners who have received national citizenship. Doesn’t make them French. Europe is multiethnic and some countries are too but that is a result of wars, rape, and migration INSIDE Europe. These “multi-ethnic” countries are also a result of government decisions. Doesn’t make it true. We were never asked. And then these treacherous governments used these realizations to bolster and justify immigration. Nationals of Europe are SUPPOSED to be white you silly idiot. Your political correct obsessiveness and “tolerance” hinders you from being conscious of what’s going on. You’re stupid.

Its not about immigration its about losing the German Culture and Identity.

@BitOfUltraviolence

6 жыл бұрын

That is about immigration as well.

@celticfrost86

6 жыл бұрын

the true german culture die after ww2. not in 2017

@jennedortmund7510

6 жыл бұрын

I'm German. Pls explain to me how my "Culture and Identity" is lost.

@tammymills5461

5 жыл бұрын

Jenne Dortmund your not having children anymore, and Islam is about colonialism , they will not become westernized, their belief is Sharia Law, woman must be covered, and according to Mohammed you can pick your wife at 9 years old, and have more than one wife! Woman are half as a man according to Sharia. It is very obvious Muslins will over populate and you Germans are no more! Multi-Culturalism is another word for Non Whites, the Globalist want you to believe that Whites are more responsible for slavery, tribalism, and hatred ! This apparent problem that Germans have prejudices , ask me does Saudi Arabia accepts Christianity? Does Iran allow Free Speech? Does China allow Multi Culture? Does Japan accept Multi Culture? Tribalism is fine for Europeans, we want Free Speech and our women free of backward idealism Islam is not a Religion

@last_words596

3 жыл бұрын

@@tammymills5461 oh u got brainwashed by some random website

Maybe this documentary should have been about a more important question: Why do these people flee their own culture and societies? Why didn't they immigrate to an arab nation? Why don't they want to stay in neighborhoods with other migrants? This is on a much deeper level...

@bliss448

6 ай бұрын

That's because most of the Arab countries are under constant attack, by war, genocide, drone strikes, etc....just look at Palestine, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Libya etc.....

40:01 The man is sitting in a *completely Arab neighbourhood* in Germany, drinking and selling Arab coffee to Arabs, they have Arab shops and still they complain about not being tolerated. Even the young man at 40:48, he can just come to Germany and find a job at an Arab shop in no time, while many immigrants from other countries have no job opportunities and structures at all. *What do these people expect*? They want Germans to give them a Mercedes or BMW for free as a sign of acceptance?

@ileanaacacostaacosta1813

Жыл бұрын

Why are they complained He should be glad that you people accepted and tolerate d him and allowed him to come here and live in your country I don't know what they want you Getmanßcare to be blamed if their work ethic is not d strong as yours that will allow them to have BMW or a Mercedes firvthatvyouvh as vectobwork really hard indeed

I saw the title and I just laughed.

@PodcastCentral333

3 жыл бұрын

I didn't. Germany is becoming multi ethnic.

@hunter1211

3 жыл бұрын

There was once a beautiful continent named Europe... RIP Europe.

Maybe Qatar should have accepted Ramy the refugee, hmmmmm Al Jazeera?

@zackabee5498

Жыл бұрын

Qatar and saudia Arabia supported in the killings of Iraqis and Syrians why would they take him? Now Europe is not doing it for free they’re stealing our resources No worries plus Arabs were forced to fight for the Germans the uk and the French during ww1, nobody compensate them or they’re families. Consider them as retired veterans.

Be a German if decided to live in Germany. Adopt the culture and be part of it.

I as a german really do appreciate Al Jazeera documentaries. But just for the sake of truthfulness, you should have mentioned Dunja Hayalis homosexuality, at least in a short sentence. She is a german, arabic, tattoed and homosexual journalist. Now, ask yourself whether she could have amassed the same amount of credibility and on air time in Iraq or Qatar... No hate! :)

@bliss448

6 ай бұрын

And what does that have to do with anything?

"They lived in camp-like conditions, returning to their barracks late at night. They had no cultural or political influence at all" ... sounds a lot like the conditions for foreign workers in the UAE especialy in Qatar (Football World Cup).

Qatari propaganda! Arabs are not German

Those Syrians aren't anymore German than a German is a Syrian.

My mother came here in 1965 when there was shortage of workers here. We have worked hard to integrate here. We dont push our culture into forefront. We respect this country and culture! Its a bitter truth that you will be never a German unless you are white and have a German name

@ileanaacacostaacosta1813

Жыл бұрын

Well becgrateful that they received you and accepted you don't ask for more

@bliss448

6 ай бұрын

@@ileanaacacostaacosta1813 shut up.

Yesterday met a man who Hated himself for being WHITE, everyday people called him out for racist, bigot, and Islamophobic judging the colour of his skin. I felt awful about that especially when he told me that he has two adopted children from Indonesia. He took them out of the orphan house since they were just babies......

@bliss448

6 ай бұрын

and what does your comment have to do with this documentary?

New Germans? Not quite. Are these new Germans willing to die for Germany or even get jobs and pay taxes?

"Germany will one day become a home"... things that make you go uhm. Interesting choice of words for the end of the documentary.

No such thing as a black German. Who do you think you are to completely deny, undermine and redefine German identity?

There were Afghanis living above her and Somalis below. And she hated it. .... I know how she feels.

Great job cherry picking your people to interview.

46:30 What a nonsense. Europeans had rich folklore before 11-12th century.

These are not Germans and never will be! Nobody cannot change the ethnicity.

@PodcastCentral333

3 жыл бұрын

Ethnicity doesn't equal nationality. We don't live in primitive times of ethnocentrism

learning the language of the country that gives me everything is my first task... dudes a genius yall.

Are there really as many American racists as these KZread comments sections seem to indicate? It's more than a little scary.

German culture is hard work. Germany is an export nation. Germany has an hightech industrie. Germany needs highly educated people. Poorly educated people don't find jobs in Germany and stay poor.

@ileanaacacostaacosta1813

Жыл бұрын

Whatvyou said is true you are a hard working people you are exporters and your indudtrie is high tech people who are not educated don't get good jobs but these people s work ethics hmn are not steon as yours, that's why they are relegated In life if you want something you have to work hard to get it and most of these don't have what it takes to be somebody

The main problem is that in Germany refugees are commonly concentrated in the poorer areas of the towns where people are frustrated with their economic and social situations anyway. When a few years ago the administration of Hamburg tried to build a refugee home in a noble quarter of the town the inhabitants of that area filed a suit and tried to prevent this from happening. Their argument was that if this refugee home were to be built in their neighborhood the prices of their real estate would drop dramatically. The court saw it their way and the construction of the refugee home never happened. This may demonstrate another facet of the situation in Germany not discussed in the documentary (the easier process of integration only touched upon by the example of the woman who now lives in a more rural area of Germany, she too wanted to move away from the multiethnic neighborhood she was forced into when she came to Germany and Cologne). The more educated people in Germany like to frown upon and sneer at the lower classes and more conservative citizens who engage in the activities of Pegida or who complain about the situation in their neighborhoods. This includes academics and politicians. I hypothesize that many of them - especially the Green party - live in a kind of ivory tower: They are more likely to originate from more educated, well-to-do families and therefore received better conditions of upbringing, had usually a higher standard of living in a middle to upper-class environment, etc. In the case of students, academics and the like they usually only encounter the "other" on campus or at their workplace, where the immigrants and their offspring are already well integrated and assimilated. They have already shown that they embrace the value system of western society by performing well at school and trying to advance in a society that values achievement and engagement. Also, a Green politician is not likely to buy their grocery at a common discount store but rather from a farmer or in a wholefood shop. They live in the good areas and work at parliament. Those people will never understand the problems of the poor and the workers in the run-down areas. They leave those people alone. It this this feeling of detachment that the Germans notice when they hear those people talking on these matters. They seem to have no idea.

@feetthong624

6 жыл бұрын

Linguaphile you are so dumb

they shud rename this documentary to "How Germany dug its grave ? "

@mosesbullrush8051

7 жыл бұрын

Exactly, Reuters is Jew propaganda.

@maxmustermann220

7 жыл бұрын

You should learn English.

@MrxxPityFans

7 жыл бұрын

Tony Montana was a refugee was he not?...lol

@Psych0nautilus

7 жыл бұрын

Tony Montana was a character in a movie...

@umbrellacorporationwuhanfa3731

6 жыл бұрын

Annon lel You realize Merkel was reelected right? He is right, it's over for Germany.

RIP GERMANY 1871-2021

These are not Germans and will return soon. To Qatar maybe.

@PodcastCentral333

3 жыл бұрын

Nope. Inshallah Islam can spread

A remarkable report that warns us all about the slippery slope of prejudice.

@alexgoslar4057

3 жыл бұрын

@Hansie Voko Prejudice is a universal malady.

Germanstan ,coming soon

At least send them back once the war in syria and afghanistan is over right? 'oh no they're germans now'

Say goodbye to Germany..

"1.5mio arabs living in 16 federal states. that's close to 2% of their population. Not a lot but enough to be noticed" The 1mio refugees costs nearly 30 billion a year. Every unaccompanied child/teen under the age of 18 costs the german taxpayer between 4 und 5000 € a month.

Very interesting and well presented documentary about the immigrants and refugees.

@anon8979

5 жыл бұрын

lol how? its propaganda insinuating anyone can be German but i cant just be Chinese or African so how can they be German. How is this a hard concept?

I liked the documentary, it's an interesting point of view. I don't really understand why it has so many dislikes. The only thing that bothers me is how bad the translations are... Half of the time the translations from German to English are wrong or at least miss some important nuances.

Germany 🇩🇪 is a beautiful country. Immigration is a difficult situation. Peace , prosperity and tolerance is needed around the world

@jaysonwitting4671

3 жыл бұрын

Mass immigration to Germany is killing the country because it feels invaded and outnumbered, something I can’t tolerate

@last_words596

3 жыл бұрын

@@jaysonwitting4671 ok Wolfpack

@brykzo

Жыл бұрын

each people in his country.. This is needed to bring peace to this World.

Not even the Romans could conquer the German tribes what makes you think the third world has any chance of completely taking over Germany before native Germans unleash on them.

@Rugonnaeatdat

6 жыл бұрын

corrion1 Germany lost two world wars.

@redknight801

6 жыл бұрын

Valid point, but have you seen how pathetic Germans have become since then?? They are a lost cause!

@VagoniusThicket

5 жыл бұрын

They suffer from imposed post war guilt and will accept any new liberal left bs dumped on them.

@last_words596

3 жыл бұрын

@@VagoniusThicket nope just you

@last_words596

3 жыл бұрын

@@redknight801 oh wow tough guy calling over 1 million people pathetic

What is the background music at the beginning ..can any one please tell me ?

a future with no culture is no future at all.

I do not care about the origin of immigrants who have made it to Germany. What is most important is how they behave in our country, it is all about mutual respect! Therefore, they are welcome, no matter if the God they preach to is called Allah or Jesus Christ! Currently, there is a shortage of workers in some parts of the economy, so we have to make the best out of this everlasting phenomenon called immigration. What is more: the incidents of New Year 2015 were the result of failures on the part of the local police, and the perpetratures were NOT immigrants from Syria, but mostly Moroccans.

Those Who Do Not Learn History Are Doomed To Repeat It.

The attackers were mainly Algerians, Tunisians and Moroccans who have no right to be in Germany their countries are not at war. They are economic migrants. They are not really liked anywhere in Europe.

They've got to go back!

Hope you are back enjoying Syria again, given it's been safe and sound for a few years now.

fleeing war and violence, for making it here?

The narrator guy is Hungarian, his name is Zsolt Pál, he also dubbed the Chuck Norris epic airplane split video . I just cannot get enough of his voice :-)

So does all this mass immigration solve the problems in their home countries? When has running away from your problem helped to solve the problem in anyway?!?

Qatar should take them in.

There's another group of people from the Levant that the Germans originally welcomed into their midst... the Middle East may not be safe but neither is Europe

THERE WILL NEVER REALLY BE TRUE PEACE WITHIN THE HUMAN RACE...IT IS NOT HUMAN NATURE TO LOVE AND CARE ABOUT EVERYONE...I WAS BORN IN GERMANY BUT RAISED IN CALIFORNIA...I AM GLAD TO HAVE SEEN THIS

Yep, not new Germans.

#RefugeesNotWelcome

Documentary about Arabs in Germany? With tons of downvotes? :D Must be a good one then!

Immigrants of any background moving to another country MUST integrate and assimilate into the culture of their new home.

@hamzab3659

4 жыл бұрын

Not the religion

@anshuraj4277

Жыл бұрын

@@hamzab3659 Religion is untrue bs

@bliss448

6 ай бұрын

Nobody has to assimilate and as you've heard in this documentary, even those who have are steal being othered.

Well only time will tell it will either work or it wont

12:30 egypt is 2.8 times more vast than germany

This doesn't sound like German to me

15:16 "I wanted to get away from other foreigners."

@crowhillian58

6 жыл бұрын

Her attitude made sense to me. She wanted to be surrounded by Germans to give her daughter a chance to learn German and to better integrate into German society. She seemed well educated, probably capable along with her husband of making a living without state help and thus contibuting to German society in a positive way. However, the 'foreigners' she moved away from in Cologne may well take a different path.

They aren't 'German,' new or otherwise.

I wish she had fully explained why they did give their children Arab first names. My guess - It was more important for HIM to assert his will and dominance than to help their kids be accepted into society. It isn't good enough that they already had an Arab last name, he couldn't even compromise because of his arrogance. If my assumptions are wrong, I'd like to hear another explanation.

@hamzab3659

4 жыл бұрын

Being accepted into society should have nothing to do with the name . Especially in a « democratic » called one

Germans say that Islam is from middle east and is foreign religion but they forget that also christianity is from middle east and in start was foreign religion until the roman empire forced with sword to all european nations.

Leni Riefenstahl would be produd of this film.

Why are they not "refugees" in Thailand? Maybe the money European countries like Germany pays?

you come to a country ,mostly uninvited, and you expect that country to change to acomodet you needs, ,, you are a fool ,, what I see in the future in Europe,,, a civil war , unfortunately,,

Immigration is not the answer to offset the ageing demography in Germany, at least is not sustainable... Germans should realise that procreation is vital for their economy...

But what do germans think of other europeans living and working in Germany?

@ingridp4457

6 жыл бұрын

Aku Jo they don’t give them trouble like the arabs do, therefore You don’t hear too much about them

That's the cons of being a refugee to a country where 'government' opens it border but the half of the society are reluctant but have to accept the consequences.

Your translations are very misleading.

LoL i was a migrant all my life in Europe, and i never felt welcome, but that is because the people here are more closed, and friends are not seen as family. This is not bad, but it means that to feel at home, you must make your self a home, as i understood that my situation changed, and i never felt better since :) Take care everyone.

al Jazeera al queda tv

Gobbels would be proud!

@PodcastCentral333

3 жыл бұрын

By Germans they refer to German nationals, which any ethnicity can be :)

@freckleheckler6311

3 жыл бұрын

JD Visuals your tolerance eventually leads to a decline. All you have is your “moral superiority” and that’s pathetic. Apparently if a migrant or foreigner were to arrive on China, make outlandish demands and be denied the Chinese should be declared racist bigoted nazis 😂 you’re absolutely delusional.

ich bin auch immigrant wo ich jetzt bin assimilation war immer im vordergrund nur die die durch irgendeinen religiösen wahnsinn gestört sind und dadurch am freien denken gehindert werden meine ich werden sich überall schwer tun

Amazing only aljazeria and where are they from

Great documentary! 👍👌

The Egyptian lady Hend is the only good thing in this bad documentary

New germans? :D my thoughts are 80 years old :D

the truth is: arabs are allowed to come to Germany. but don't expect equality, if you understand. ;) greetings from Deutschland!

when you are in your own country. its ok to feel entitled, but when you are an auslandischer, atleast learn to know the rules, language and integrate to the country. give respect. its sad to know whats currently happening to germany. theres nothing wrong about practicing your religion, just dont push it too far. ive seen documentaries that muslim threatens jews and other religion. remember no one is above the law. and the old immigrants who have been intergrated and was able to be successful in Germany are now affected because of what the some of the refugees are doing. so sad

'said to be' HAHAHAHAHAHA

Report: Al Jazeera optimistic DW news optimistic. All is sunshine and rainbows.

We always have the reconquista

The only chance Germans have to preserve their cultural roots is by leaving the multicultural type cities and move to other less mixed cities where it would be more difficult for non germans to move to. Take power there and further solidify German dominance in those cities. Vote with your money.

We live in a Crazy World. Nobody choose to be born Black,white, yellow.Lets stop treating others as Aliens from tha Mars .

Isn't Al Jazeera stemming from Qatar? Why did germany have to do more for syrian refugees than Qatar? This is pure disgusting Propaganda. "New Germans". Everyone would agree with the opposite: A german can not be an arab just because he feels like it. A german is someone who comes from german ancestry. Also, how many muslim countries are there the Arabs could go to? Close to 60? Not only in the arab world. Whole asian world. There's dozens of culturally similar countries. Why do they come especially to germany? Because they love german culture and tradition so much? Good joke, even further to say, many times they even share an utter disgust for european culture and tradition. The arabs that come to europe nowadays come all the long way from the asian/arab/islamic world and through all of europe, because for economic reasons, nothing else.

the truth is that the cost to the taxpayer of 1 refugee is 3000€ per month, so please give a correct total view, this money could have helped 20 times more people in their original country, but now it was wasted on 1 economic migrant

Depicting the 'Demographic Change' as the main reason to help people in need is more than ignorant, ever heard of the 1951 Refugee Convention, the Treaty of Rome, the Maastricht Treaty? But Refugees welcome!

putting nice music underneath this story doesn't make it all fuzzy lovey. Arabs and africans will never make this work. the sooner they go back the better for everyone.

Germany´s immigration problems will be solved if they take good professionals from Asia like India, Africa or Latin America. They will integrate easily into this society.

@colmansmartinez5843

7 жыл бұрын

you not, why Africa you guys have taken everything from africans

Prejudice is a human malady that is despicable anywhere. In Myanmar, In Germany in Japam, in... you name it.

I knew something was up in 2002 world cup, Germany had one African origin player... that was the beginnig. Before then, always Germans or atleast Whites in German team Now look how many non German players? Ozil etc..

sorry but i never met a an german born arab who call lthem selfs german

To become a thread -you need integration. To be a positive thread -takes assimilation.

Waltersteinmeyer... wow no wonder Germany has refugee issues..

Germany is for the Germans not Arabs Merkel Muss weg pay Germans to have chikldren

When are you all going to join me as a member of the " human race " my best advice , look for the need and ignore the difference .

Don"t forget...all of our ancestors came from the african continent...