In their documentary, Teddy and the girls shared that they were hesitant to release WHISTLE because it was different and had a lot of elements that were considered "new" during that time. But all of them really loved it and how its not the typical sound so they released it. Contrary to their worries, a lot of people did love it and to this day is still very popular 💗

@OO27.88

Жыл бұрын

whistle is such a gem fr

@caitlinbensonn

Жыл бұрын

I’m glad! It’s not a bad song or anything! I just didn’t vibe with it. I’m happy that many people took to it well! 💕

@flymetotheup9904

Жыл бұрын

I heard they are also the one who pushed that song to be their debut song even tho other producer don't like it they have like vote.

@tmitrs

Жыл бұрын

Whistle got me into them! ;( I'm so happy she got to react to it, it feels like GOLD and very brand-new music at that time!!! I wouldn't hesitate to play it for anyone to hear

@_c.c.c_

Жыл бұрын

I can never not sway my hips when Whistle plays I LOVEE it 😩🔥 One of the most unique gg songs in the industry (so is Pink Venom. Probably the most.)

I NEVER CLICKED SO FAST

@_afanboy

Жыл бұрын

Same

@henriquebentes7187

Жыл бұрын

Same

@jaeyey

Жыл бұрын

DUDE. SAMEEEEE LOL

@hope_sunshine07

Жыл бұрын

Sameeeee brooo sameee

@tiana6862

Жыл бұрын

Me too 😂

At Coachella Jisoo had a really hard back pain but she was really strong and slayed at 100%!

@bonjolivent7130

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely. she's so awesome 🥺

@lalalalisa41

Жыл бұрын

You couldn't even tell she was sick or in pain too! Girl is a beast 😊

@Kamelia1311

Жыл бұрын

Jichu is the strongest person out there, she must be protected

@yevgenyalekhinelargo1662

Жыл бұрын

I think this is the reason she can't dance so well unlike before, like she still can but you can see the difference. Maybe they didn't want her to release that publicly or so. Still back pain is painful indeed.

@blackpinkblinkfam7197

Жыл бұрын

@@yevgenyalekhinelargo1662 a lot of ppl get sick when traveling to different countries they never been before. That’s what she said happened

I was actually crying in front of my computer when Coachella happened (it was aired live). Like a proud mom!!

@typagirldemijnk6588

Жыл бұрын

SAMEEEE

@lilith5633

Жыл бұрын

no cause it was Easter weekend and i got up at like 4 am to watch it and i had to leave at 7am to go home but i was crying in my bed and i was so so so proud of them sjdsjdsj

@tmitrs

Жыл бұрын

No way THAT'S SO ADORABLE MY HEARTT

Dont Know What To Do is my best and favorite Side-B ever!!!!! The song??? The vocals??? The dance?????? Overall???? 1000/10

PLAYING WITH FIRE is still my #1 no matter how many years have passed already 😭💕

@shejemon

Жыл бұрын

Me too.

@ilovemylayswithbaekhyunfla7847

Жыл бұрын

Same

@SonniesPlace

Жыл бұрын

Same

@Luna-ij7xz

Жыл бұрын

Same😭❤

@japjapbanehit8689

Жыл бұрын

for real ❤ my fave choreo til this day too haha 2016 releases were amazing

They are the head liner of 2023 Coachella !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Since this was the Coachella upload, they cut down on the crowd noise. I watched it happen on YT and it was insane.

@caitlinbensonn

Жыл бұрын

Ahhhh! Okay got you!

They don't have the coachella live album, but they have the In Your Area Tour live album on streaming platforms and for the tour they used the same band, it's pretty sick

The more popular the artist, the more haters they have. No matter what, BLINKS will always be the support and protection for our 4 beautiful queens.

@sanketsarkar4704

Жыл бұрын

True

@tmitrs

Жыл бұрын

WELL SAID!

The band they have coachella is the band they always had in their concerts. Their live performances, majority of it, have a live band and it makes their song 10x better.

The fact that whistle was one of their debut song is just- Also in Whistle the whistles in the background was jisoo

To be honest, these discovery videos are my favorite thing to watch. I either discover a new group, or I get so see someone reacting to a group I like for the first time. And Caitlin creates such a cozy environment and her reactions are so sweet.... I often rewatch her best discovery videos, like G-Idle, P1Harmony, Pentagon... Brilliant stuff! Thank you for your hard work, Caitlin!

@_.varnelle

Жыл бұрын

I rewatch her discovering Monsta X so much

@some-g1rl

Жыл бұрын

@@_.varnelle omg, I just watched that a couple of hours ago! it's a great video!

When they did their coachella stage, JISOO was really sick then and she talked about it in their documentary but nobody can tell. They slayed their performance, they were the talk of the town! Jennie and Lisa with their charisma and stage presence while Jisoo and Rosé were so stable then despite the very windy weather situation. Not to mention the pressure too. Theyre coming back this year as headliners which is exciting. Queens!!! 🔥👑

Be ready for their boombayah performance at coachella 😭 I think you accidentally missed it, but that's on their channel so that'll be safe to react. ALSO they covered wonder girls' so hot (it's a blacklabel remix) and it's also available on their channel. Always take your time ❤️

@caitlinbensonn

Жыл бұрын

No I didn’t miss it lol I said in the video that I have a limit to how many videos and songs I can react to before it gets blocked so I only had room for those 2 stages.

49:22 Finally! Finally there is someone who understands what blackpink receives is "hate" not the "Constructive Criticism" as the people of other fandoms calls it! And we, blinks, try to defend them- we are automatically labelled as TOXIC!! Like I am literally done with these people who at this point hate Jennie even for breathing (other receives too but not on personal level as much as jennie do)

@lalalalisa41

Жыл бұрын

It's always Jennie LOL even when she literally has nothing to do with whatever the issue is. Girl is just minding her own business and haters gotta drag the poor girl into it 🙄

@alishashj2151

Жыл бұрын

@@lalalalisa41 ikr, even on google if someone searches who is the most hated kpop idol, she is the one who pops up on the top! And for what reason? God knows! She is the one who gets hate for everything by other fandoms and all we get in turn if we speak against those people is "TOXIC"!

@lalalalisa41

Жыл бұрын

@@alishashj2151 I still hate it, being called toxic, even when I'm just trying to be a decent person. Yeah, I'm a fan and would of course come to their defense if they're wrongly hated on, but any decent person would come to their defense. Because decent people would understand that you just don't go around spouting hateful things like that about people you don't know. I'd never do such a thing to other people's faves...words can really hurt and it's sad to see that these people haven't learned and are just repeating history again.

i saw born pink tour in london last year and my god whistle live was INSANNEEE im telling u. jisoo said "hey" and before she could even finish saying hey boy the screams were INSANE

as a blink since debut I really appreciate your words at the end. lately the slut shaming, body shaming and many other very detailed and disgusting tweets are even more present with a lot of likes, so it's hard to be a blink on twitter and not get upset and question what these 4 women did to them all. I once said, and stand by it, that other kpop fandoms will appreciate and give credit to blackpink only after they disband, because then they will see all the records objectively and not as their biggest competitor. their loss, because I can proudly say I witnessed it all with them.

Blackpink's debut was seriously the best. Like nothing will ever top it for me. The diversity in sound??? The looks???? Truly an iconic debut!! But really, any debut out of YG is going to be top tier

Their coachella performances are so iconic and now they’re returning this year as one of the headlining acts, I’m so excited to see their performance :)

"The Show" is one of their best performances, new raps, they performed other artists musics too

"Don't know what to do", is such an underrated song & so is it's choreography😪. It's definitely one of my top 3🤗

They're doing Coachella again this year, can't wait 😆

THEYRE HEADLINERS IN THIS YEARS COACHELLA LETS GOOO!!!

The last bit was so real. The hate was always insane but now it has evolved into literal sexism and misogyny. It is very disheartening because I just wish people went back to calling them flops or that they have no stage presence or something, like that's how vile it has gotten. Thanks for always being honest and just enjoying what you like. Blackpink really worked hard and still do with a literal world tour and headlining major music festivals. So heartwarming to see you give them the credit where it's due.

@lalalalisa41

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I'd rather hear the flops and ig models than the slut shaming, strippers and sleeping with the entire industry comments. Just makes me sick....

their "hiatus" every once in a while made it harder for me to completely stan, but the entire Coachella performance made me respect them even more. The entire performance got little to no breaks and they did so well!

Fun fact: one of the songwriters for whistle was b.i

*from being invited as guests performers at coachella 2019 to being the MAIN HEADLINERS AT COACHELLA 2023, BLACKPINK became icons.*

I don't know exactly why but something about Playing With Fire opening tune gets me teary and reminiscent. It's truly and immortal phase of blackpink's career and a precious one. :')

the aura they have is unmatched...

the fact that they’re one of the headliners for coachella this year 😭

Just wanted to say that I've been loving this series! The content, the editing everything looks super great, excited for the rest of the artists to come :)

Lisa went viral after this stage, as "Girl with ponytail" all over. it was crazy. Alot of people including celebrities were hyping their performance up even before they arrived. they had no idea exactly how excited people were for this. They did an amazing job, and I'm sure they are going to kill it again this year!

@marksmith8210

10 ай бұрын

It was ponytail rapper.

I actually love how minimalistic Whistle is. It’s still so different to this day. Singing this song with the girls during their concert will forever be a core memory cuz I’ve been there from the beginning 😭

7 years later and whistle is still my favorite BP song ❤

Thank you for giving YG artists a chance. I mean, I know you have your favorites already. We are not expecting anything but for you to take time to listen to them. Thank you.

the fact that playing with fire and whistle are one of the first songs they put out is crazy also the coachella performances are really out of this world.

Kim Hanbin aka B.I is credited as a lyricist for Whistle, their debut song. its probably the hook. everytime anyone at YG got stuck with the hook, it was the king of hooks who helped out. Epik High - Born Hater and Psy too

I'm so excited for pinkchella 2.0! Back then Jennie was the only one who performed her solo song now we'll have a 4/4 solo stage for them 🥹

they gagged the WHOLE world with this coachella performance and now they're headlining the festival this year... it's gonna be INSANE!

i also love when main rapper jennie raps!!!! 😩

Somewhere in the 400+ comments in here someone has probably mentioned this....but just in case bc i think bands who perform with artists don't get enough recognition....but the band that was live at Coachella with Black Pink has been touring with different YG artists for years and i mean at least since Big Bang was still promoting because I saw Big Bang live in concert and the Band Six was with them. That band is freaking fire they always bring just so much energy to concerts. Thanks for all the time with these reactions they're amazing! 💜

OMG, thanks for reacting to it, Caitlin. Suddenly missed the olds days of BP... this is truly nostalgic! So proud of what the girls have achieved and what they have become now, because of their passion and handwork. Love this. ❤💯

Yeah, they're the headliners for this year's Coachella ✨ They're also headliners for BST Hyde Park in Europe.

watching coachella performance always makes me emotional and now they’re headlining they’ve come so far im so proud of them🥺♥️♥️♥️♥️

Playing with fire is still my favorite song of theirs. Everything about it is just so good

The most satisfying about this is how we react on their rookie era. Queens indeed❤

*Playing With Fire* gives off such a sad yet fresh vibe. Straight SLAYY

you are so real for notifying the fact that blackpink receive an insane hate train every time they breathe. These girls have been in the industry for a long time and have accomplished so much, I feel like they will never do well enough when they are the biggest girl group in the world. People will always find an excuse to put them down even when they don't do anything just because they are successful women and move away from the traditional kpop group but I love them unconditionally they are the first kpop group that i discovered and i am so proud of them even if i even though I knew them when they were already famous. They will be back to perform at Coachella as headliners next month, they are the only non-white women along with Beyoncé to headline this festival i'm really proud of them and i hope they will continue to go far.

Shut down has a connection to all of their old MV it was really cool to see

As yg stan, i just want to appreciate this series since some people just "blacklist" yg artist straight away bcs of the 2019 scandal eventhough it has nothing to do with most of YG artist. Also if you don't mind, please check out the Mino x Bobby / MOBB in Winner episode, thankss

37:05 “you will never catch me at coachella cause i don’t do festivals like that. im too short” this is such a mood but also caught me so off guard i laughed for twenty straight seconds

The visual The music The stage The outfit The vocal The rap The dance So powerful ❤

For covers recommendation I will definitely go with sure thing cover it's uploaded in their channel I think it's safe to react to and there's also so hot cover they have a performance for it and a studio version I'm not sure if the stage performance is the safe but the the audio is definitely okay, those 2 covers are SO GOOD and everyone loves them I'm sure you will too! BTW I really loved your reaction as always, and thank you for it as well! ~❤✨

Kiss and Makeup Tokyo Dome 2019-2020 is excellent. There’s footage of them singing it with Dua Lipa as well.

as y’all may know our Jisoo is making her official debut as a solo artist this 31st of March. Today, the goals for JS1 had been stablished by the official fanbase!! KZread: 🔥24hours - 40M views (primary goal) - 50M views (secondary goal) 🔥 48 hours - 70M + (‼️ remember that goals are NOT the limit, we can do so much more) Spotify: 🔥24hours - 5M unfiltered 🔥1st week - all tracks debut top 30 - 16M unfiltered (primary goal) - 22M unfiltered (secondary goal) Apple Music: 🔥24hours - global top 200 🔥1st week - global top 200 iTunes: 🔥24hours -iTunes 40's #1 🔥1st week - iTunes 50’s #1 Let’s work hard for our Jisoo so we can give her the best debut possible!!

Now I need a part 2 of coachella reaction. I love this reaction so much just like the rest of your reactions. ❤️

Official videos of live performances will tune down the audience in order to hear the performers better. Watch fancams to get the real feel of the live performances. Their charity performance in France recently was night and day different between official video and fancams.

Girl ,they are headlining this year and i hope you can go to see it personally how they perform

since "Don't know what to do" came out it gives me goosebumps every time I listen to it

Whistle is one of my fave Blackpink songs. BI is one of the songwriters! Been with BP since predebut so watching Shut Down was really like a trip down memory lane.

Rosés covers on sea of hope, and the covers on her channel, their sure thing cover

Tbh I’ve never seen Jisoo so slayful.. and in the backstage vids you can see she can’t even bend her back and she performed like THAT. Like my respect skyrocketed.

@OO27.88

Жыл бұрын

THIS!!

Yes!!!!!! "Don't Know What To Do" is one of my favorites! I'm obsessed with the choreo and vocals on that song, and Jisoo's high note with "you" on the chorus is so, so, so good! Thank you for this label view and your honesty in your reactions - one of the reasons why you're one of the best!

Yeah they really did a great job role model of girl empowerment. Can we try the japanese version of their live concerts? I enjoyed this vid marathon of yours

Watching the whistle dance practice gave me a lot of nostalgia, girl group vibes were strong asf

FYI I streamed coachella in 2019 on KZread to watch these performances live. I believe we'll be able to do the same this year as well.

I LOVE THESE EPISODES AND HAVE BEEN ENJOYING SINCE!! AHHH YOU'RE THE BEST❤

dkwtd choreo is just superior in so many levels

They actually did an hour of performance for 2 days, not only these two songs 🔥

They slayed on that Coachella but this years Coachcella..OMFG!!! They ruled!!

Whistle was their first number one in korea ! It's iconic

My girls!! I'm seeing them on 26th I'm so nervous I don't know why lol. Maybe I'm just so excited

I just know Caitlin would lose her sanity if she was able to see BP's full set in Coachella. Worse, she wouldn't survive. 😂

thank you for your reaction caitlin!!! love you 💗💗

I absolutely love this reaction and this series. Thanks Caitlin

Love how you get all hyped up and the support 🥰✨

I am so glad you made this video/reaction, Caitlin! This was so entertaining!! Thank you so much!

This react is so beautiful❤ thanks for reacting to our girls Caitlin🥺💗

THANK YOU FOR THIS CAITLIN!!! LOVE YA!!! ❤️

You are the best Caitlin,ILYSM ,thank you for these

Just wanted to say that I appreciate your videos so much! I feel like I get to know these different groups easier watching your vids! Again thank you!

I mean girl we need part 2 of thissssss lol love your honesty ❤️.

I discovered your channel like a month ago and I have been obsessed. I even became a patreon. I usually hate pausing but I don’t hate when you do it bc you’re hilarious. I can see all the hard work you put into all these videos and I appreciate all of it. F the haters and keep shining your light ❤

whistle is a feel good song but playing with fire is one of the best song i've heard from them.

oh, that was so great! that Coachella - they killed it biggest time. can't wait to see them this year as headliners! (through twt cuz I'm to far away to even consider going to the festival 😂) since you asked: there's still Forever Young Dance Practice (it's one of the b-sides they promoted alongside with DDDD, like DKWTD with KTL); there's also a Dance Practice for As If It's Your Last, since you've already watched the MV; and the Dance Practices for their solos as well (can't quite remember if you ever reacted to them besides their MV/performances) also, for songs you didn't reacted (like their b-sides that doesn't have videos), there's a couple of gems you might not be aware of: Black - G-Dragon (feat Jennie) Without You - G-Dragon (feat Rosé) Special - Lee Hi (feat Jennie) all of those are from pre-debut, and in fact Rose's featuring was on the same year she joined YG! girlie wasn't even one year into training lol also, Jennie and GD's feat has a stage performance on a music show - that was the first stage of hers, ever, and she was just 16 back them. but particularly, I really really love Special; it's one of my favorite Lee Hi's songs and I think it's sad we never got a performance of that one as for cover: Jisoo and Rosé covered JB's Love Yourself on a show, not sure if it'll be blocked but it's on MBC's official channel; BLACKPINK covered "Sure Thing" by Miguel and it's uploaded on their official channel; and there's also a special performance Rosé did for a ending year show, where she partined with Chanyeol, JIHYO and singer 10cm for a mashup of their songs (and she's playing the guitar on that one!!) that you can find on SBS official channel (again, not sure if it'll be blocked, but since it's from a official channel...) Rosé also has a couple of covers that I guess you don't know about: Until I Found You by Stephen Sanchez; Eyes Closed by Halsey; Wildfire by Kawule Viva La Vida by Coldplay Don't Look Back in Anger by Oasis December by Neck Deep The Christmas Song by N.K.Cole most of them are on her own yt channel, but as for Eyes Closed and The Christmas Song you can find on B0's official channel Jennie has a cover for When Will My Life Begin (yes, the Tangled song) by Mandy Moore on her very first KZread channel video that is just lovely also, back in 2021 when rosé was promoting as a soloist, she guested on a show called Sea of Hope and she did a couple of beautiful, beautiful acoustic covers that you can find on the official JTBC channel here - there's even a compilation made from the official channel and I know some people reacted to them and it never got blocked, so I guess it's safe to watch. songs she covered then: Slow Dancing In a Burning Room by John Mayer (she was noticed for that one!) The Only Exception by Paramore Because I Love You by Yu Jae Ha Lovely Day (feat ONEW, Suhyun and Yoon Jong Shin) by Bill Withers Lucky (feat ONEW) by Jason Mraz Read My Mind by The Killers Time Spent Walking Through Memories (feat ONEW) by Nell and an impromptu performance of If I Ain't Got You (feat ONEW and Suhyun) by Alicia Keys just for a little bit of fun, you could also watch their "24/365 with Blackpink" episode 5 where they talk a bit about their trainee days and Rosé plays the guitar and they sing a bit of the songs they used to cover during that time! (and it's a reality from their official channel too, if you're interested I would really, really enjoy you reacting to their realities "BALCKPINK HOUSE" and the whole 24/365) that's the stuff I remember from the top of my head. more than that, I hope you'll be catching up with Jisoo's solo next week! loved the episode and loving that series so far! ❤❤ edit: just included Sea Of Hope on the list!

thank you for the reaction queen 💖

Playing with Fire will be my forever favorite, close second is Whistle (I'm a fan of those songs since release and I'm still inlove with it.) Also DKWTD is a runner for me. And seeing how you just reacted to it now shocked me cuz it's a crazy coincidence how you haven't listened to my faves until now. 😭💕

Shutdown was basically just a big reference video to multiple other songs and videos

Caitlin you made my day 😘

I love you discovering shots from Shut Down in this look back at their older MVs :)

You should see the 4D performance they did in "the show". It has the same live band and some fire, rain, etc. Trust me you have to check The show, especially 4D

OMG IM WATCHING THIS AND FEELS LIKE NOSTALGIC WHEN I REALLY LOVES THEM IN EARLY THEIR DAYS IM CRYIN RIGHT NOW :(

Bro, what a nice suprise ❤🔥 Love it

Their bside is super solid tho like it can even top the title track😭😭😂

still in awe how shut down's mv is a reference to their past music videos, theyre impressive af. thanks for this!

Thank you so much!❤

Kyle Tutin is an AMAZING choreographer and dancer.

i was really waiting for this and i'm excited HAHAHAHAHA

Eu AMO tanto o seu canal !! Tava esperando por esse vídeo, obrigada ❤🇧🇷