16+ at least and a trigger warning to warn against the harms of these topics!

Im praying for colleen hoovers writing downfall🙏

@juhirawr

10 ай бұрын

I second that

@TheDanishGuyReviews

10 ай бұрын

And if allegations come out against her in some way, I pray for her downfall in everything else.

@janapauldo

3 ай бұрын

I’m just curious what is it about her that makes her so bad

@justwonder1404

24 күн бұрын

From the excerpts I've seen, there's not much of a height to fall from.

I don't think IDing and age restricting books would work. Much as it seems great on paper - age itself is no longer representative of an individual's maturity. It's not just teenagers you have to worry about. Anyone with a warped lens or an individual who suffers from mental health issues may take these fictional books meant merely for entertainment purposes and seek out a partner who is toxic because like you say they are interpreting this terrible behaviour as 'passionate love'. I think it would be beneficial if with every book resources were provided where abuse charities provided links and Colleen herself plugged awareness on how those representative in her books are fictionalised versions of the types of partners she wishes people would avoid. Maybe that's what she's trying to do in writing these books?. But it seems she herself is executing it in a warped fashion.

"They say she's sold more copies than the Bible ..." Pretty bold claim for someone who's not a household name. Agatha Christie and Stephen King have actually sold more copies than the Bible, and as such, everybody knows who they are. Hoover is a no-name compared to those two.

@thelovechildofautumn

9 ай бұрын

I think it's only true for the USA for THAT year

Exploiting trauma for personal gain is a proven formula for success in what passes for arts and letters in America.

Hi Alex, you're a good presenter. But either you're microphone isn't catching you properly or else there's an editing issue to resolve. After coming in from some other videos, I had to really increase the volume to begin hearing you.

In germany, many bookstores have an age waring and cashiers often ask for the customors age if they think the person buying the book is under that age :) ofcoure parents can still buy their children/teens books but (in for example Thalia) the staff will often warn people if they mention buying the book for their child ! Anyway, I completly agree with you, the formatting was nice and it didn't get boring (I haven't taken my adhd meds yet ) definatly going to check out your channel! :D

"you can't have one without the other" I disagree strongly with this one. You can imply that something is wrong without giving elementary school'ish examples of the moral good. It's about how things are framed, and that happen also with dialogue or narration.

Wow I’m surprised that this channel doesn’t get many views, it’s videos are well made

I think that content warnings work best when accompanied by a comprehensive disclaimer from the author. Because they only cover topics, and rarely - the way these topic are going to be presented. And in entertainment, especially with heavy topics in entertainment, it is important to help the audience engage with these things safely. In case of Colleen Hoover's first-person narrators, there is another complicated issue: the narrator is unreliable, but the author doesn't see that. For an inexperienced reader, it might be impossible to tell that the author is "wrong", when the character reacts (wildly out of character, following author's whim) to things we never saw before with emotions that contradict the situation. Such as, every moment in November 9 that characters see as romantic.

I'm beyond surprised how nobody on YT is talking about her son asking a minor for n*des, and when the girl reached out to colleen, she blocked her

i agree with all you've said, i really like this video format and would love to watch more of it

Loved this video. Very elaborate and detailed

Colleen Hoover's books are everything I really loved and connected to her characters

@zeinababukar1933

3 ай бұрын

seek help

@Jeremysepicreads

3 ай бұрын

@@zeinababukar1933 I don't need to

Good video essay! :) It is a complicated problem... I don't want certain subject matter to be taken out from books but it is the way it is portrayed that matters. Bad things happen in relationships and it is okay and even important to show that, but it is then crucial to make clear that the behaviour is not good behaviour, and prevent young people to romanticize it. I have a similar issue with certain films. My niece (12) loves horror films and my sister and I often watch horror films with her. All these films have a 16+ age restriction in the cinema, but some of the films of the After series (which feature toxic relationships from what I've heard) are 12+ (here in the Netherlands) and thus accessible for my niece. In my opinion we need to ask ourselves what is potentially more harmful to watch. Yes there is violence and scary beings in horror films but at least it is explicit (i'm not saying that it needs to be 12+ per se). Some other 'suitable' films show things that are more subtle: there might be no sex or explicit violence but the way the characters interact with one another and how the film engages with this might make young people glorify toxic relationships for example.

I bought. it ends with us and my brother bought, it starts with us and i haven't completed either but i don't hate the novel but I'm not in love with it maybe i shouldn't make an opinion so early but i will fill you in after i finsh both books 😊.

great video, love the jellycats 🤭🤭

i read it ends with us at 14, it was so overwhelming and overall horrible to read. all of her books are the same, half-baked “romance” stories that romanticizes horrible things 😬

These books should come with a warning…not for young people…disgusting

who's colleen hoover?

@TheDanishGuyReviews

10 ай бұрын

My thought precisely. "Allegedly sold more copies than the Bible." What, without everybody knowing her name? Absurd.

@junainahrahman4156

10 ай бұрын

Believe me u are better off not knowing 😂

say it louder for the people in the back

I play video games and idk why I am on here

Good video, but please hold mic still and not so close to your mouth as it is catching your exhale on Ps rather harshly, and raise video volume overall please, thank you.

Love me some CH hate. But girl, how are you going to keep that expensive mic on your face and yet have such bad sound quality? 😭 Just record with a apple earphone mic x

She like the bungholio dance

You can't trigger warning your life so adding such things only makes you anxious.

@arkkon2740

3 ай бұрын

You can't control your life either, you can control what you read and its not bad to think what people are write is weird as hell

With the dirty hair finish

I think a good solution could just be like a trigger warning/psa at the beginning of a book that discusses possibly triggering or controversial issues like this. I think Hoover could definitely handle the topics she writes about with a lot more care but at the end of the day it is only a story.