The House That Jack Built - Review - Why I Love the Most Polarizing Movie of the Year

My review for Lars von Trier's 'The House That Jack Built'.
Follow Me on Twitter: colebrax
Podcast on von Trier's entire career: wrongreel.com/podcast/wr389-lars-von-trier-a-provocateur-with-the-soul-of-tarkovsky/
#MattDillon #review #TheHouseThatJackBuilt

Пікірлер: 259

  • @dreamway9
    @dreamway95 жыл бұрын

    I unapologetically love Lars von Trier. Even when I am flinching, disgusted or rolling my eyes, I have seldom encountered a film maker that pushes me (sometimes forcefully) through so many emotions. The results he gets from actors (no matter what their relationship status) is amazing- always moving, sometimes terrifying.

  • @jevinday

    @jevinday

    3 жыл бұрын

    I agree, he's my favorite for precisely that reason.

  • @leonardfeuerstein

    @leonardfeuerstein

    10 ай бұрын

    Nah this movie made me only feel one thing. Disgust. Thats not what a good movie should do, i could go on LiveLeak and experience the same . And since all the characters (who we learned nothing about except for Jack) were super two-dimentional i didn't have any emotions for them or while watching this movie in general.

  • @FCSchaefer
    @FCSchaefer5 жыл бұрын

    Matt Dillon has always been one of the most under appreciated actors. And modern movie posters suck.

  • @Siggkins

    @Siggkins

    5 жыл бұрын

    He's brilliant in my opinion.

  • @amcaesar
    @amcaesar5 жыл бұрын

    Well, you're right about Matt Dillon: I have to admit this is the role of a lifetime for a guy who's kinda proven to be a one-note player for most of his career.

  • @janfranszuidema8512

    @janfranszuidema8512

    5 жыл бұрын

    @Bill Scurry Rumble Fish (1983, Coppola) is the biggest Matt Dillon film ever. As soon as I got a hold on it, I showed it. It is the Citizen Kane (1941) to all my weed smoking and couch lounging friends. The most beautiful Mickey Rourke. It was like wallpaper at a certain time in my life.

  • @janfranszuidema8512

    @janfranszuidema8512

    5 жыл бұрын

    It's very cool...

  • @MikelGCinema

    @MikelGCinema

    5 жыл бұрын

    He has never acted. Hes always Dillon for all roles, its himself. In this one, he tried at least.

  • @amcaesar

    @amcaesar

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@MikelGCinema I like that, it's a nice distinction I can agree with.

  • @janfranszuidema8512

    @janfranszuidema8512

    5 жыл бұрын

    @Mikel G Haven't seen the film yet, but... He's always , , , , , , , , , & . These actors were sooooooo not themselves in those other films. I have never noticed them in anything else... P.S. I'm drunk right now and I'm enjoying Malcolm McDowell's Royal Flash (Oliver Reed is somewhere in there).

  • @kylejoe8393
    @kylejoe83934 жыл бұрын

    Finally the first reviewer that actually points out the connection to The Divine Comedy

  • @rexhargrove5172
    @rexhargrove51725 жыл бұрын

    His films are consistently pushing the right boundaries, the right way. He’s required viewing for any real cinema/film fan. And Dillion is so underrated. He won me when he nailed, really nailed bukowski.

  • @akumasnowofficial
    @akumasnowofficial5 жыл бұрын

    Im just now discovering this director fascinated to see this film, stoked about the podcast blew my mind when you said its about his whole filmography!!!

  • @keithmounts1305
    @keithmounts13055 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for this. It's increased my desire to see this!!! I love all your descriptions on all of this ( Lars, Dillon, art, etc...) I've subscribed.

  • @Matthew9818
    @Matthew98184 жыл бұрын

    One of my favourite films ever . The black comedy in this film was fantastic . It was dark and had some very good horror and the lashings of black comedy really helped the movie be easier too stomach .

  • @geekinwithJamesHancock

    @geekinwithJamesHancock

    4 жыл бұрын

    Agreed. It is going to be tough for Von Trier to top this. Might be a good film to retire with.

  • @jevinday

    @jevinday

    3 жыл бұрын

    Also one of my favorite films ever. I bought it in DVD/Blu Ray the day it went on sale in the US (Which took until 2020). I am hopelessly in love with von Trier. He is a genius imo. I know that not everyone likes him but that's okay.

  • @hoshanm
    @hoshanm5 жыл бұрын

    Finally! Rational and detailed review about the house that jack built.. Thanks for your review. But please could you slow down a little bit for your non English speakers :) Thanks

  • @DungeonStudio
    @DungeonStudio5 жыл бұрын

    Intriguing review! I'm always amazed how people abhor A Clockwork Orange, Natural Born Killers, American Psycho, etc. as nothing more than gore fests. Yet when something happens like Mandalay Bay, or Charlottesville, they'll be the first to say 'what happened? Why did anyone stop this?' And what really gets me when they cite these movies for the motivation. Not that these movies have the answer, and not that they don't trigger the truly psychotic. But when the likes of Von Trier, Stone, Kubrick tackle the subject, I think there's concern and challenge they want to convey. Whereas some of these Sex & Slash flicks, or Special Agent Killem All are touted as cheap B movies not to be taken seriously. Who's the pot and who is the kettle, and how black does it have to get? Definitely looking forward to seeing this soon too!

  • @DaniGerman1499

    @DaniGerman1499

    2 жыл бұрын

    Charlottesville? He was attacked and didn’t hit those people intentionally. I wish he did though.

  • @andrewharris1391
    @andrewharris13915 жыл бұрын

    Another great review my man. Thanks James, I can't wait to see this

  • @sebastianmelmoth685
    @sebastianmelmoth6855 жыл бұрын

    I think you miss the point - Jack does not have an artistic soul at all. He is an engineer who wishes to be an artist. His "creation" however, is destructive - and he mistakes complete annihilation for the cycle of birth and destruction that is the hallmark of creativity. That is why he falls into un-being at the end of the film.

  • @annaliebdubino

    @annaliebdubino

    4 жыл бұрын

    Yes, absolutely!!

  • @s7lresearchdr.311
    @s7lresearchdr.3115 жыл бұрын

    This is one of best reviews of the film that I’ve seen/heard... I’ve subbed!

  • @jonahetheredge8977
    @jonahetheredge89775 жыл бұрын

    Was able to see the uncensored version as well. I personally thought it was incredible. Matt Dillon on top of his game. One of the best performances this year and I strongly believe it will be swept under the rug come award season.

  • @DesignzRUs1

    @DesignzRUs1

    5 жыл бұрын

    @Jonah Etheredge Fuck the academy. They mean nothing LMAO

  • @DaniGerman1499

    @DaniGerman1499

    2 жыл бұрын

    Probably because his imagery of Hitler. Those idiots think showing him on screen will magically create nazis again

  • @LarryMullins
    @LarryMullins4 жыл бұрын

    Hey man!! Love your reviews! Just discovered you recently. I just watched this film on Showtime and LOVED IT!! Love your review and your style!! You’ve gained a subscriber. Yes, I unfortunately saw the R-rated version. And I’m on your side about Lars Von Trier!

  • @dertodesking.
    @dertodesking.5 жыл бұрын

    I was already very excited about this movie. Didn't know about the Dante connection, which makes me even more excited! Should be grand. Can't wait!

  • @geriburrito
    @geriburrito5 жыл бұрын

    lol people who despise Lars von Trier for being too shocking are the same puritan close-minded type of people who despised Oscar Wilde for writing Dorian Gray.

  • @Luke_Radiosmash

    @Luke_Radiosmash

    5 жыл бұрын

    No they're not. They're liberals who view everything through a politically-correct lens. I'm a conservative Christian and Lars von Trier is my favorite director.

  • @denzelromero4796

    @denzelromero4796

    5 жыл бұрын

    Luke Funny considering Lars is apparently making fun of the “alt right” in the movie

  • @chriswilson9898
    @chriswilson98985 жыл бұрын

    It was about 20 minutes too long, but overall I enjoyed it. Great performance by Dillon. One or two scenes were a little too far over the the top. I give it a 7/10, I give Matt's performance a 9/10

  • @nevermindshort3
    @nevermindshort35 жыл бұрын

    Subscribed. In my opinion LvT is the greatest moviemaker of all time. Nobody makes me feel the way he did. There is a psychological deepness that nobody else dares to go into and least of all share with others in a graphical medium, and that makes him great.

  • @rebeccahopkins9522
    @rebeccahopkins9522 Жыл бұрын

    As with Antichrist (one of my all time favorite films and I HATE when people throw blind hate at it, it kind of hurts my soul a bit when they do; I’ve actually pissed off friends debating the virtue and artistic brilliance of this film 😂), Dogville, Europa (criminally underrated and under known), The Nymphomaniac Volumes (I’m a recovered sex addict), The Kingdom (in my top 3 favorite shows of all time, it’s exceptional and was light years ahead of its time), Melancholia (I’ve endured depression), Breaking The Waves (a perfect, provocative and powerful film), and Dancer In The Dark (Bjork. That’s all I need to write here😂), seminal renegade genius filmmaker Lars Von Trier gave us yet another masterpiece in The House That Jack Built. Firstly, the music used is chefs kiss. But it’s the OCD (I was 💀), Dante’s Inferno subtext overlay and conversations w/ Verge, who holds him in clear contempt which is just so delicious (and I agree with you 💯 and adore how it blends in the dark comedy feels with a bit of gore and LOTS of line crossing and protagonist narcissism 😂), highly stylistic choices, the possibility that we’re listening to an unreliable narrator, and that utterly sublime ending, that thoroughly pitches it into the masterpiece realm for me. It’s just. so. good. Often as misunderstand as the artist himself, LVT’s works are most often transgressive, always artistically brilliant, gorgeously shot, highly stylistic, never unoriginal, tragically misunderstood, and as with all artistic masterpieces, provocative. All great art provokes. It pushes boundaries, it challenges our reasoning and senses, our societal norms, moral structure confines, and perceived nature; ushers us into existential thinking, moves us into invoked response, stirs and churns up emotion, and most importantly, it hits back. The highest of great art doesn’t just cross the line, it erases it. And to me, no filmmaker living and working today uses these artistic tools to provoke so consistently, so brilliantly, so originally, always at the genius level, like Lars Von Trier. He is that rare thing: an artistic genius. And I will plant my flag and stand by that perspective and position unequivocally. The works of David Lynch may have my heart, but the works of Lars Von Trier spoke to and captured my soul and imagination long ago. I’m actually kind of glad the so called “mainstream critics” often misinterpret and bash his works and him as well. I don’t think they’re supposed to get this. It’s not for them. It’s for us. The ones with artistic sensibility, high level perception, original thinking and open minds. I’m so glad you made this video even though my comment to it is late AF (I’m a new sub and member) 😂. Because it’s actually so refreshing to hear from someone who gets it too. Long may his chaos reign. 😉 Thank you. 👏🏼 Edit: chaos will always reign. 😉

  • @daber2000
    @daber20002 жыл бұрын

    Good stuff. There is an element that I want to bring up: Free will. I wonder how von Trier sees this topic. Jack is shown to be ruthless since his infancy, as many killers are. He was never really free to be someone else other than what his brain shaped him to be. If we go with this deterministic view, we see that punishment at the end of his earthly existence is unfair, so we are ruled by unfair judges.

  • @electricfishfan7159

    @electricfishfan7159

    11 ай бұрын

    There was definitely a clockwork orange dilemma with his mental illness, and I interpreted that as being why Virgil (who can also be a certain perspective of Jack’s) said it was “hard to believe,” he’d be delivered to a higher ring of hell, and why he kept dwelling on his lack of love and understanding as it relates to art (life & judgement).

  • @KnivesMonroe
    @KnivesMonroe5 жыл бұрын

    best House that Jack Built review on youtube.

  • @aussiedonaldtrump
    @aussiedonaldtrump5 жыл бұрын

    I can’t believe I missed this review! This review is amazing! I loved this film. Half my theatre left (during the kids scene), but the ones that stayed loved it. In my opinion this is his best movie! It’s a brilliant movie,but you may hate it. Great review mate!

  • @catherinejeannette7351
    @catherinejeannette73515 жыл бұрын

    I loved the review! I wish you would slow down when you’re speaking though!

  • @SebDaviesMedia
    @SebDaviesMedia5 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for this. I cannot wait to watch it.

  • @savagesinema
    @savagesinema5 жыл бұрын

    Film is definitely not dead. Great review of LVT's extremely audacious, boundary-pushing work. The world of sinema would be significantly less without Lars.

  • @shalor8948
    @shalor89485 жыл бұрын

    Wow....lots of great info and insight! Can't wait to see it! (Side note: It's distracting that your face isn't in focus.)

  • @DonEnzone
    @DonEnzone5 жыл бұрын

    Guy sounds like PC Principal.

  • @sandracmyers
    @sandracmyers5 жыл бұрын

    A sickening masterpiece

  • @ronniejaye1
    @ronniejaye15 жыл бұрын

    Dillon was brilliant at expressing the longing to be in the Elysian Fields and hearing the" breath of the meadow" once again. It's literally palpable on his face. I've watched this movie a minimum of 15 times . The first 2 to enjoy it as a whole and the rest to understand the subtleties of this work. BTW , I have to skip past the duck scene every time. There's no becoming numb to that seemingly unimportant yet disturbing scene which grows inside you with horror and dread just by knowing it's coming.

  • @faq4490

    @faq4490

    4 жыл бұрын

    The duck scene was about as disturbing as watching someone cut a toenail. I can't believe people can make a fuss over that.

  • @jevinday

    @jevinday

    3 жыл бұрын

    You know that the duck scene isn't real, right? It was a rubber leg. I've seen this movie 4 times, I have it on Blu Ray. They have it for sale here in the US now as of a year or so ago

  • @ghostxflowers
    @ghostxflowers5 жыл бұрын

    I agree with you about lars. He's one of my favorite directors in film. hoping to see the movie soon.

  • @janfranszuidema8512
    @janfranszuidema85125 жыл бұрын

    The best Matt Dillon film is obviously Rumble Fish (1983)... ;) Looking forward to this film. I'm a big LvT fan. I once chose a one time showing of the second Kingdom series in the cinema over a WC (football) match of my dear Oranje in 1998. I made the right choice. Oranje lost to Croatia (and it was a 3rd place anyway). I'm expecting to see the directors cut (the version you saw) in the Netherlands. I understand that there is some controversy in the USA about that one. P.S. loved your wrongreel episode of Haneke. I'm a sociologist, so he was always an interesting filmmaker to me. I'm going to rewatch some latter Haneke. Btw, there has been this British journalist who impersonated Haneke on Twitter. You (and definitely Marcus) should read some of his tweets (he is very competitive towards Terrence Malick). It's very funny and he has actually met Michael later on.

  • @ColinBloodworth
    @ColinBloodworth5 жыл бұрын

    Really nice explanation, man.

  • @115shortfilms4
    @115shortfilms44 жыл бұрын

    I would love to see a commentary for the film done by you (and maybe some friends)!

  • @ShortyTwine
    @ShortyTwine4 жыл бұрын

    I hadn't really heard much about this film, then it popped up on a streaming service today and I decided to watch it. It was brilliant. I rarely watch movies more than once, but this is one I *know* I'll watch again.

  • @IsisMusic
    @IsisMusic5 жыл бұрын

    Spot on. Great analyze

  • @531katie
    @531katie4 жыл бұрын

    Enjoy the way you ‘see’ a film. I think you’re one of the few who grasps true objectivity in rating a piece of artistic work ... and always with humility that leaves out the certainty that usually doesn’t exist nor must. Me too - that same scene was extremely hard to take and what I agree as the only truly vile violence probably because it was too real and came at us without warning. The frail boy who I almost began feeling sadness for .. then boom! Just as immediate was the suffering we were forced to witness as a result. I would have liked to miss that. Was it gratuitous cruelty that cheapened the film ? I didn’t think it was necessary but I’d like to hear your opinion. Thanks for great insight on everything I’ve seen you review. Particularly when I’m left shell-shocked by the ending of either a movie or a series episode, I search first for your take. Then later, redit conversations fill in what’s left.

  • @theorangecollective.7663
    @theorangecollective.76635 жыл бұрын

    Alls i could think of last night was how confident of a filmmaker he is. Fucking confidence.

  • @benten2462
    @benten24623 жыл бұрын

    Have you watched Idioterne/the idiots? I’d just love to see you review it. Fantastic video!

  • @candydormizzi2500
    @candydormizzi25005 жыл бұрын

    Hell yes nice review !

  • @FoivosLoxias
    @FoivosLoxias5 жыл бұрын

    Amazing film! Thank you Lars!

  • @tidepride86
    @tidepride865 жыл бұрын

    Nice review bud, but damn, maybe try decaf?

  • @jackfahy2283
    @jackfahy22835 жыл бұрын

    Going to see it this evening, there's limited showings of it all over Ireland because of how violent it is so I'm happy to love close to a cinema that's playing it 🙌

  • @lifeandThings
    @lifeandThings5 жыл бұрын

    LVT's slow-motion is called LongMotion. 📷

  • @Waaazuuuubp
    @Waaazuuuubp5 жыл бұрын

    great, troubling, biblical, brave piece of art. Made such an impact on me, and i 100% agree with you on the predisposed "critics", who automatically disregard this movie because of whatever tf..

  • @krakenbowl7231
    @krakenbowl72315 жыл бұрын

    Hey James. I, like you, would love to revisit the movie to analyze those philosophical chats between Virgil and Jack, it was almost overload for me and I wished I was watching it on DVD so I could pause and go back. I kind of disagree that Jack's journey is somehow symbolic or representative of Von Trier's journey as a director and I think Jack is more an indictment of people (i.e. critics) who are incapable of creating so they need to tear things down and their "artistry" is only through destruction (you actually touched on a lot of critics unsavory relationship with Von Trier early on in the review and Von Trier actually joked in an interview that he's never fantasized about killing anyone, only journalists). They are not architects and are only engineers (and I think it's Virgil's constant push back on Jack that blows a hole in the theory that he is representative of Von Trier's journey). It's only fitting that Jack finds the harmonious cutting of the grass beautiful, nature being cut apart. But overall, great review and I really need to see The Kingdom thanks for the recommendation.

  • @ivanchavez6226
    @ivanchavez62265 жыл бұрын

    Where can i watch the uncensored version!!?? They dont play these moviee where i live i see a lot of bad hype about the movie i wanna see what its all about

  • @Jellycakelap
    @Jellycakelap5 жыл бұрын

    Aranofsky tried horror in 'Mother!' -- And succeeded in making a weird ass movie that was a little blood curdling. This is my second Trier attempt -- 'Antichrist' was a hole of nihilism -- but this -- WAS ART. Artist AS film. The only scene was the duckling one -- that made me go -- HE WOULD do this shit, but found that PETA already found out that it wasn't genuine. This flick is DAMNED GOOD -- and The Divine Comedy and the kalabasis of Vergil and Dante as a discussion of LARS VAN TRIER?! Damn, dude. This guy -- he knocked this one out of the park. (Each kill reflects circles of hell -- as descending...from the book).

  • @Jackson-kc8wz
    @Jackson-kc8wz5 жыл бұрын

    love the video... but why don’t you have all the books in the Wheel of Time series? You’ve gotta finish it !

  • @ahmadababaei3254
    @ahmadababaei32545 жыл бұрын

    Where can I find your top 10?

  • @holzmischel577
    @holzmischel5775 жыл бұрын

    Great review!

  • @johanneabelsen1644
    @johanneabelsen1644 Жыл бұрын

    I was in my late HIGH SCHOOL YEAR, when Lars von Trier made his big debut in Danish (and later international cinema) with The Element of Crime, and then late more recognition with his movie Epidemic. Now, we KNOW his filming style (hand-held camera), but what really got ME interested was the TV series The Kingdom. Both because of his new, raw filming style, but ALSO, because there came so many LAYERS up; Horror, mystery, comedy, and just absurdity, a few times.

  • @BradHominem
    @BradHominem5 жыл бұрын

    Can't wait for this. Nice review. Unfortunately, YourMovieSucks had a pretty bad reaction to the movie (and he's a Von Trier fan).

  • @poontang3zizo

    @poontang3zizo

    5 жыл бұрын

    Actually Adum isn't a fan per say of Von Trier. It's more of a love hate relationship

  • @francoarocha7287
    @francoarocha72875 жыл бұрын

    what is a good site to read critic's reviews of films like this one?

  • @PenskyMaterial

    @PenskyMaterial

    Жыл бұрын

    They all hated it. Go watch the movie and make your own opinion inatead. Its def not for everybody! Either you will hate it or love it!

  • @dondraper3898
    @dondraper38985 жыл бұрын

    Let's not go overboard. Everyone knows Matt Dillion's best role will always be Bob Hughes. I never wanted to try anything as much as that movie made me want to try dilaudid. When I finally got the chance years after I became an opiate addict, I remembered the line "Listen to me, you little punk- I'm goin' straight man! You oughta try it some time! It's good for the soul." I didn't touch the dilaudid and went for Suboxone treatment the next day. Maybe it's my personal experience that is influencing my opinion.

  • @jacquiedls
    @jacquiedls5 жыл бұрын

    Great review

  • @IsisMusic
    @IsisMusic5 жыл бұрын

    Really good review. You understand the movie :)

  • @Siggkins
    @Siggkins5 жыл бұрын

    I slowed this vid down to 0.75. That way it doesn't feel like I'm being hammered into a corner by someone who sniffed a bowl of speed beforehand.

  • @DeepFrigidWinter

    @DeepFrigidWinter

    3 жыл бұрын

    Good idea, now it sounds like I'm having beers with someone

  • @MrSnuffian
    @MrSnuffian5 жыл бұрын

    Please please please slow down

  • @cartmann227
    @cartmann2275 жыл бұрын

    Excellent!

  • @ahmadababaei3254
    @ahmadababaei32545 жыл бұрын

    I'm also fascinated

  • @AdamBDesign
    @AdamBDesign5 жыл бұрын

    This is a great video. Saw the R rated version last night and I am still unpacking. This commentary helped a lot with some of the imagery that was portrayed during the film. This is my second Von Trier movie. I have only seen Antichrist, which ones should I see next? Again, great commentary

  • @TorreLane
    @TorreLane5 жыл бұрын

    I just finished watching it... Alot of information for my mind to process but I thought it was fucking amazing... I'm just not sure I want to recommend it to anyone I know (because I don't think the average viewer can handle the subject matter, or rather see past it to actually take in the subtext)

  • @genebcolon
    @genebcolon5 жыл бұрын

    Mother!, The Killing of a Sacred Deer, the house that jack built!...

  • @s0urp0wer5

    @s0urp0wer5

    4 жыл бұрын

    Mother was stupid as hell but the other two are incredible you ever seen Dogtooth by the same director?!

  • @auriculus3058

    @auriculus3058

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@s0urp0wer5 I love Mother, especially the second half where it goes batshit crazy. Sure the movie has flaws, the first half is a little too long and the CGI looks not that good, but it's such a nightmarish, overwhelming, captivating, disturbing and surreal trip. I was on the edge of my seat in the theater and couldn't believe what I was witnessing. I left the theater shaking and completely worn-out. When a film achieves that, it did something right

  • @martinnielsen5805
    @martinnielsen58055 жыл бұрын

    Geeking with Kames Hancock- in which language did you see "the Kingdom" - I am Danish and can tell you there is a world of difference from the original to the US version.

  • @17samalex
    @17samalex5 жыл бұрын

    i saw the directors cut as well loved it In theaters Dec 14th and VOD Not directors cut One can hope for a blue ray directors cut

  • @irrefutablematt
    @irrefutablematt5 жыл бұрын

    i feel like to many ppl dont understand horror is a dissection of fear, violence and the human condition... they just see the violence and the fear and proclaim "this is sick, youre sick"

  • @andresesqueda1424

    @andresesqueda1424

    5 жыл бұрын

    exactly dude. I love horror films that make me feel uncomfortable because that means it's doing it's job.

  • @kittykuchi7896

    @kittykuchi7896

    5 жыл бұрын

    On the flip side there are many ppl who don't understand that there are many ppl who don't believe there needs to be a "dissection of fear, violence and the human condition", especially if it is to be depicted on the cinema screen for profit! They would probably prefer to see depictions of love, compassion and overcoming the human condition. But to understand the human condition is also to understand how human beings are incapable of understanding other human beings and to see the absurdity of that play out in all kinds of ways.

  • @irrefutablematt

    @irrefutablematt

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@kittykuchi7896 while def true to some degree i dont think its the case that a lot of them would rather see depictions of love etc.. as a lot of these very same ppl who criticize horror for reasons mentioned often have no problem with watching an action hero shooting 50 ppl because the violence is sterilized and no dissection and binary nature(good guy/bad guy) of such movies allows them to not think about the violence they are ingesting... they often just like a more "entertaining" sort of violence while at the same time decrying horror for its violence.. which imo is a bit more twisted than violence that makes you uncomfortable, i mean someone died you should feel uncomfortable to some degree... not sanitize it to the point that you dont recognize violence as being violence anymore it also neglects that connections such as love, compassion, etc can be formed around horrific tragedy, i.e the lovely bones... obviously this is not everyone though im sure there is a number of people who only like to watch more positive heart warming stuff... but a fair amount of the ppl i know who think "horror is sick" actually really enjoy action movies... but dont seem to register a shitload of ppl getting shot to death = just as bad as a handful of teens getting stabbed to death etc.. but i totally agree with you on the "not understanding each other being part of the human condition" and ppl criticize what they dont understand... anyway though this was a nice little chat but i really dont want to lose my sunday to a long philosophical debate over a 2 month old comment... so peace and have a nice sat/sun depending on where you are in the world

  • @kittykuchi7896

    @kittykuchi7896

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@irrefutablematt No need to expend your weekend over a trivial point such as this one. I'll just reiterate in a more simplified manner and you can decide if you wish to respond or not. People are simple minded! And that also includes people who make observations of other people being simple minded (a la yours truly). If they think a movie sends the wrong message or is simply gratuitous then they will object to the movie. And yes people can debate the rest of their weekends on what really genuine objectively counts as gratuitous. I think films are gratuitious to at least some degree by nature. It's a business and they market their product to those whom they expect will be willing to buy. It's the same with roller coasters, ultra spicy food, heavy metal music, rap, hip hop, porn, reality TV, the current POTUS, etc. What one person finds gratuitious or meaningless, the other sees virtue and meaning in it. Most human beings are not intellectualy equipped to investigate the facts of the matter.

  • @josephfatur1747
    @josephfatur17475 жыл бұрын

    See also "The Kingdom Hospital", tv series, Eng. subtitles. And the very unusual Dogville.

  • @johnkrummel2956
    @johnkrummel29565 жыл бұрын

    good review, I agree

  • @subversivelysurreal3645
    @subversivelysurreal36455 жыл бұрын

    I can’t wait to see this movie! Thank you for telling us that Matt Dillon did well in this role! I don’t understand what’s so misogynistic and/or ‘wrong’ about his films, they definitely get into my head, and I love the (agony) of the last film of his films that I saw...’ Antichrist ‘. Plus, after all, Ed Gein was an actual person!

  • @videopunk10

    @videopunk10

    5 жыл бұрын

    Except this movie ain't about Ed Gein, but an over simplification of serial killers, wrapped with pretentiousness used by Lars as a way to speak his (while desperately trying not to put himself in the film in order not to run into the trap of being a "auteur", even though he unintentionally did), and made for people who's hobby is labeling other horror movies with the puke inducing slur known as "torture porn". This movie is what happens when Lars Von Trier tries to make an intellectual version of a Eli Roth film. You want a better movie? Watch Henry, Portrait of a Serial Killer.

  • @irrefutablematt
    @irrefutablematt5 жыл бұрын

    super looking forward to this.... really like matt dillion and anything that makes festival critics so offended is my type of movie LOL glad to hear its coming out soon

  • @moshimanju7576
    @moshimanju75765 жыл бұрын

    how will you know if you watched the censored version?

  • @crjaded
    @crjaded5 жыл бұрын

    I enjoyed this video.👍

  • @jayn8392
    @jayn83925 жыл бұрын

    I'm very interested In this one. I like some of Von Trier's work but I'm not really a huge fan. I have no issue with grotesque graphic violence and sexuality, I just find some of his work somewhat self masturbatory/pretentious and some of it is downright boring to me. Not all of his work by any means, but maybe 50/50. I am quite fascinated by serial killers and how they think. I absolutely love serial killer movies and I think this kind of content is right up Von Trier's alley. Also, Matt Dillon look like he is absolutely killing (very punny) . I think I will leave my wife out the viewing though. She likes stuff like Seven, Silence of the Lambs and Mindhunter, but I don't know if she's ready for any of Von Trier's films lol.

  • @as-nm7qj
    @as-nm7qj5 жыл бұрын

    awesome commentary; love your allusions to the cultural classics. So no point!

  • @kathymassonne2614
    @kathymassonne26144 жыл бұрын

    People think I'm a movie snob because I want to learn something palpable when watching a movie. I will recommend this to no one because it forces you confront truths and ultimately make decisions. This movie is entertaining to me, only in the way that "1984" by Orwell is. And like "1984", I consider this a masterpiece for the ages. I see at as semi-autobiographical: completely exposing the director's definition of art and forcing his audience to agree with him or not based on the thesis laid before us. I find it fascinating that people squirm most at a duckling having parts amputated, when no one mentions a mother forced to feed her murdered child a bite of pie (apple no less.) We have devalued human bonds so much that an animal we regularly kill and eat, holds more regard than a mother's abject horror and pain. This is one of many juxtapositions in this film, that Lars von Trier uses to show us what he sees in us. And the point of the movie I fear, what you see in me is genuinely human. Pompous, enlightened, humorous cruel, studied, manic...complicated. You may judge him for this film, but in doing so you have defined yourself.

  • @eigen00
    @eigen005 жыл бұрын

    I was haunted too with the duckling scene which I think didn't add anything to the story and was only for the shock value. Other than that I enjoyed the movie and Matt Dillon's performance.

  • @aftertheshowmoviepodcast
    @aftertheshowmoviepodcast5 жыл бұрын

    I think Gasper Noe is my favorite controversial director.

  • @janfranszuidema8512

    @janfranszuidema8512

    5 жыл бұрын

    +ascullydotcom I've seen those Gasper Noe films, and Lars von Trier is the better director... ;)

  • @MrCholoPants3415

    @MrCholoPants3415

    5 жыл бұрын

    Nah, Gaspar Noe is actually intelligent. Lars is a hack. Antichrist and Nymphomaniac are pieces of trash tbh. I'm still excited for this film because although it still seems to have his laughably unsubtle "themes" that are overly explained, and it seems to have his shitty voyeurism style of filming/framing, I'm stoked to watch it tomorrow. This looks very different than his other stuff that I'm not a fan of at all, and I'm counting down the hours until my showtime tomorrow. It looks like he's finally said "fuck it" and is actually making a filthy, disturbing, but most importantly ENTERTAINING film. Watching his films (aside from Melancholia) is like having a nightmare where you're trying to run away and your body is stuck in slow motion. I have much higher expectations for this, and I have a feeling it'll live up to them after this review.

  • @mbmpablo3631

    @mbmpablo3631

    5 жыл бұрын

    Love both, Gaspar Noe is a genius love, Irreversible, Enter The Void, Seul contre Tous, Carne, he is the king of the plan séquence. Love Lars to Antichrist is beautiful. Try, Notre jours Viendra, by Romain Gavras with Cassel. Its a master peace for me to.

  • @franklippert4278

    @franklippert4278

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@MrCholoPants3415 I thought 'Antichrist' was actually brilliant. If we can accept that LvT is actually mentally ill (depression IS a mental illness after all) and not just posing as ill then 'Antichrist' is actually a serious exploration of said malady. And this is a difficult topic from an artistic point of view, because depression is just black and gray and not dramatic in its own right, normally. LvT splits himself up into 'man' and 'woman' (not physically but in the abstract Jungian sense as a collection of qualities) and lets the 'rational' man battle it out against the 'irrational' woman.

  • @andrewharris1391
    @andrewharris13915 жыл бұрын

    Alot of people hate Antichrist, but I've always loved it. And Meloncholia as well. But I have yet to see Nymphomaniac

  • @martinnielsen5805

    @martinnielsen5805

    5 жыл бұрын

    Watch his TV series "Riget" (the Kingdom) Absolute world class.

  • @crjaded

    @crjaded

    5 жыл бұрын

    See nymphomaniac.

  • @violenciariba666

    @violenciariba666

    5 жыл бұрын

    Vol 1 was really good but Vol 2 i liked until the end that was just a big Fuck you to everyone.

  • @neokt3701
    @neokt37015 жыл бұрын

    I loved it, even though watching all these absolutely horrific scenes, I could not stop grinning. I probs need to see a Doctor :0

  • @stonaraptor8196
    @stonaraptor81965 жыл бұрын

    just saw the R rated version. Whats different to the directors cut?

  • @stonaraptor8196

    @stonaraptor8196

    5 жыл бұрын

    @Obed Blas More of the killing or the taxidermy?

  • @bluestate69
    @bluestate694 жыл бұрын

    This film will have a very long "shelf life"?? That has added meaning when speaking of this film! Seeing as what he had in his freezer!

  • @stevenmarkhansen
    @stevenmarkhansen5 жыл бұрын

    wonderful

  • @tomfahey3305
    @tomfahey33055 жыл бұрын

    One of the best films I’ve ever seen

  • @jaybirdful
    @jaybirdful5 жыл бұрын

    Brilliant filmmaking

  • @arianthedude5742
    @arianthedude57425 жыл бұрын

    good review

  • @EctothermalPuppy
    @EctothermalPuppy5 жыл бұрын

    Great film.

  • @gremsa
    @gremsa5 жыл бұрын

    the dialogues in this film were astonishing

  • @SirRonJeremiah1er
    @SirRonJeremiah1er5 жыл бұрын

    NWR is good too for this type of movie ;)

  • @ethanethan9575
    @ethanethan95755 жыл бұрын

    maybe mention (spoiler review) somewhere in the title if you plan on spoiling the movie?

  • @gongashbk619

    @gongashbk619

    5 жыл бұрын

    glad i saw this comment before watching this, thanks

  • @scipioafricanus5871

    @scipioafricanus5871

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@gongashbk619 Ironically I usually read comments where they complain about commenters spoiling in the comments.

  • @bradrohach7924
    @bradrohach79245 жыл бұрын

    It's not for everyone but I thought it was genius. Its been a while since I watched a movie and I thought about all the symbolism and meaning for days after watching. I agree the debates are fascinating and what makes me want to watch it again. Dillon's acting was amazing. I loved the scene where he sheds only one tear when he sees the only place that made him happy right before he goes to hell.

  • @kylejoe8393
    @kylejoe83934 жыл бұрын

    More than just a comedy it was a Divine Comedy ;)

  • @edgaradams4624
    @edgaradams46245 жыл бұрын

    Thank you, Mr. Hancock. I attended the 11/28/18 viewing in New Orleans. Afterwards, KZread was flooded with reviewers who claimed to like the film while decrying the political incorrectness of the film. Those were funny to a point, but I dislike the whining of weaklings and it quickly became painfully stupid. Thanks, again.

  • @geekinwithJamesHancock

    @geekinwithJamesHancock

    5 жыл бұрын

    Hopefully this craze where film commentators constantly try and underline how sensitive they are will soon come to an end.

  • @fiffihoneyblossom5891
    @fiffihoneyblossom58912 жыл бұрын

    I love this film. All of the reasons people criticized it is why I loved it, the pretentiousness, the dark humour that is coupled with extreme gore, plenty of Easter eggs to look for....it's great

  • @dougbull2816
    @dougbull28165 жыл бұрын

    wow i have to see this i love divine comedy.

  • @florafloraflora5567
    @florafloraflora55674 жыл бұрын

    agree with everything you said. how dare people claim that film is dead when overlooking lars von trier.

  • @jacobrivera7942
    @jacobrivera79425 жыл бұрын

    Can’t wait to see this movie

  • @PJmusica

    @PJmusica

    5 жыл бұрын

    Excellent review. I just stumbled onto your channel and I really enjoyed your take on the movie. I consider myself an empathetic person and , for some reason, I didn’t find the movie that disturbing. I agree, and I too am surprised that this movie can’t be released as it is without cutting it. On the 14th I will go back to see the R version out of curiosity. This movie has me thinking, and I’m trying to find more meaning in it. You’ve helped me in what quest with your review. I, personally, do not think this movie is as good as Melancholia or Antichrist but I did find it interesting. I agree it was less laborious to watch than many of his other offerings. Especially Dogville. Yes, I watched the whole thing at home with my wife when it came out. Long and laborious. Thanks for your excellent interpretation and review of this film. I’ll check you out on Twitter, too.

  • @andreadoniz70
    @andreadoniz705 жыл бұрын

    You’re right, many film critics hate this film just because they dislike him personally

  • @ipsofacto1435
    @ipsofacto14354 жыл бұрын

    This movie is great. I feel it's important. Philosophy is cool.

  • @889Pammov
    @889Pammov5 жыл бұрын

    I want this movie 😁👍