I'm a doctor for 26 years. Seeing this, i believe the designers clearly have no idea how hospital traffic works.

@LeonNeuton

Ай бұрын

Don't you believe there was a case study before this "reimagination"? Efficiency is paramount for our future cities and its infrastructure.

@gamm8939

Ай бұрын

@@LeonNeuton You think some random company for Qatar did that?

@Hari-tv

Ай бұрын

​@@LeonNeuton its to wide, some traffic need fast acces or short time to reach. They add to many blank space for nature. From what I see they add nothing for central for quick acces. Just a bunch of garden. I know garden seems nice. But we need central processing like processor. Like emergency room, where they can easly to acces, from entrance to surgery room and check up. They dont need to add bunch garden like that.

@Hari-tv

Ай бұрын

If they want make futureristic design, make it like processor or modern like DPU.

@ThomasTomiczek

Ай бұрын

As a non doctor le met tell you - you demonstrate how you lack anything more than medical education. You think you know hospital traffic - but do you in a time when you will have more robots doing work than humans? When you will have to rework a lot of your "traffic" on a nearly every couple of years method due to significant changes in medical knowledge and approaches? When i.e. your cancer section turns into giving people injections to train their antibodies - and not doing chemo at all (and yes, this stuff is in medical trial)? When - seriously, this is the future. They plan on a 20 year timeframe. When people are now field testing treatments to partially reverse aging. And you see nothing - because the overview is too high level - about emergency room access etc . - it is quite possible one of the blocks IS an emergency room with operations right on the next block with a fast transfer.

This hospital design basically brings into dysfunctional operation, both for healthcare staff and patients. The patient immediate csre goes out of the windows into the open areas. Idea could may well suited for a regimental school. OMA seems to be pinned on to design visuals.

@Another_Story_

Ай бұрын

yes its a bad design. You can have green spaces but if you gonna make 50% of the hospital greenspace that looks exactly the same squares it starts to turn into an inefficient maze

@ThomasTomiczek

Ай бұрын

@@Another_Story_ Maybe you need to - cough - get your self declared unfit mentally because one has to be EXTREMELY stupid to consider a chessboard (squares) with major links on both axis to be a MAZE. Especially in a time when we cna assume you ahve walls with instructions everywhere. Are in A3, need to go do D7? What the heck do you think a MAZE looks like?

@cgmax9768

Ай бұрын

@@ThomasTomiczek My uni is designed exactly like this, and even if the sections are numbered on big panels i can tell you it's a maze, even after being in the school for several months. You need time to accomodate to your regular pathways, so i can't imagine newcomers that only are here for few hours to few days. And, there is no need to highlight your rudeness with Caps. Also, with this design, if you want to go from a section to another, you have no direct and efficient pathways, you need to constantly make turns which is longer than a direct optimal line between the two points. At the end of the day, your hospital's capacity is less than what it could be, because you lose precious time in transfers.Totally agree with the critics here about that hospital being really dysfunctional.

@Hari-tv

27 күн бұрын

@@cgmax9768 i agree with you. He clearly no idea what hospital in operation. He must be living in hospital for 5 years to understand what we know.

Imagine having to move patients between several departments! For example from ER to the Female Ward (which may be the the extreme end of the building)...With normal hospitals, it would be as simple as getting the patient into the elevator, through the general passage to the room, while in this case the logistics of moving patients would be more strenuous and costly.

@qataribananahamock1495

Жыл бұрын

im sure they wouldnt put a dentist next to an emergency room. we already have 3-4 story hospitals, and they function waaay better than a highrise tower hospital cause the lift is used by everyone all the time. here its 2 stories only. i think its more functional like this, cause cars can enter close to each side of building, less queues inside. should they need more floors i, sure some section can go bit more vertical.

@nnamdinwadialo8118

Жыл бұрын

Well said true ...i am a doctor

@muktarajibola4634

Жыл бұрын

I imagine it will also be possible for high speed horizontal lift systems, escalators, self driving emergency cars and carts.

@theinternetsavedmylife

Жыл бұрын

@@muktarajibola4634 All those things you mentioned reduce efficiency, occupy more space reducing ergonomics and are not just costly to install but also to operate. I don't know if you've ever moved a disabled person before, but I doubt escalators are that friendly to someone on a stretcher. Your comment only validates my point. As a Nigerian, almost all our hospitals are built like this. Land is most times wasted and underutilized. My auntie had an accident and had to be hospitalized. We paid #40,000 just to move her from the Accident Unit to the female ward. They had to hire an ambulance and all that. That's a huge waste of resources! And when you think of it, all of that space could have been used to create a garden which is very important for physiotherapy and patient's general wellbeing. I know the stress involved in moving from one department to another, especially when you're not feeling well. In the West you see a compact 6 storey building housing everything. You just have to get in through the front door and every department is just a floor or room away. If any patient needs relocation, they put you in a stretcher, get in the elevator (most times there is a special elevator to move special-case patients) and viola! You're on another floor. Easy-peasy!

@theinternetsavedmylife

4 ай бұрын

​@@AkitoTenkai Are you an idiot, no offense! Strategic placement? Did you just learn that yesterday and want to show off your new knowledge? Do you have any idea how diagnosis works? Have you ever been in a hospital? Doctors refer you to different departments and specialists based on new information gotten. Diagnosis is basically trial and error. Doctors cannot treat you until they know what is wrong with you and if one diagnosis comes out negative you have to try with a different specialist. If that specialist is on the extreme end of the building, what would you do then? If they just build up, that's another floor but in this case that 300 or 500 metres away! Tell me that's not stressful especially for someone who's sick! You have no idea what you're talking about

Would you believe that some time last year I came up with a very similar concept and made plans in building this hospital / research facility and natural preserver? And it's now 10:17 pm where I am now 2023 and I just found this video? I think this is a sign. I will contain to work on The PCH hospital portfolio. Thank you for making this, you just pushed me further to preserve generations and secure a brighter future for people around the world.

@rosemadder5547

Жыл бұрын

I had a dream about it, and ended up here bc of searching for something similar to my dream… it was so detailed and real I almost thought I must have been seeing something that exists already 😂 I know it’s crazy but it is what it is 😅 I’ve tried to draw the place…

@yeowchongong5608

Ай бұрын

Too bad, OMA come first 😂

@IPad-hv2nl

28 күн бұрын

Yeah every infrastructure project coming out of the Middle East seems to be more for show and looks then actual function. “Is Miami a mini Dubai? Dubai is a fake Miami!”

Very Beautiful. One Thing hospitals of today dont take into account is the Passive role a visible green cover and fresh sunlight plays in Recovery of a patient .

@joshuamaka876

Ай бұрын

Do they really want their patients to recover vs treating them infinitely...

@ThomasTomiczek

Ай бұрын

@@joshuamaka876 This is an arab project. Yes, they want them to recover.

@qutibplay1152

22 күн бұрын

cringe The patient is treated with medications and surgery. You are confusing treatment and recovery after treatment. For this, the hospital is not needed at all.

@ThomasTomiczek

22 күн бұрын

@@qutibplay1152 As someone who has spent weeks in hospitals and ICU let me tell you - not every culture is as indifferent to nice environments as yours obviously is. Many prefer hospitals not to looks like shitholes when it can be avoided. I personally loved the terrace and amazing 5 star service I had at a hospital in southern germany, overlooking a pretty large courtyard with an internal park and garden. So, cringe yourself. In some cases, you need more than medications and surgery. My father once spent a year and change in a hospital, tons of surgeries and 3 heart attacks during surgery. You think during a 15 month or so stay in a hospital you would prefer - well, you likely not. Seriously, you say cringe - I am disgusted by your ridiculous inhuman attitude.

@studyAt6

22 күн бұрын

@@qutibplay1152 i pity you , i understand Treatment and recovery well ! Wont explain How ! Just imagine this , stay in 10*10 room with no natural light or visible gardening + you are on a Hospital diet + Hospital by nature is an extremely negative space with Trauma,pain ,angry , grief etc -Imagine That. You have to have a good Mood and conducive environment even to respond to a treatment and that has to be Artificially created in Hospital bcz of its virtue , as explained Above ! Also lemme tell you, treatment is Just 10% , rest 90% is recovery! Radical eg , 12 hr surgery is done well , you are in hospital for next 30 days. count your own percentage !

While I admire this design and the positive intent behind it, I would like to see a near-complete reworking of what a “hospital” should or could be. I would very much like to be able to go to a single facility for ALL of my healthcare needs and receive-in a SINGLE visit-a full preventative checkup. This would include a physical, imaging, labs, hearing, vision, dental and psychological evaluation. Why wait for illness to strike? Shift the costs of reactionary treatment over to preventative care. Healthcare is a right, and we need to design our processes around that notion.

It would be a nice experience to the patients and definitely it would benefit them psychologically , on the other hand take in consideration that the luxury of the place would definitely increase the cost of the hospital bills so not all people would be able to get the medical care.

Usually i dont really care about modern architecture but this is amazing. I absolutely love that they added traditional architecture from that area. Modern architecture needs to implement more vernacular and traditional architecture from the specific area its in. When you look at it you just instantly know where its from.

One of the things that kept me sane at any point of my life while being in a hospital is the view. This blueprint looks like a nightmare.

Amazing 🤩 I can't wait until this hospital 🏥 becomes a relity 😄👍

Hospital with 'touche with nature' concept is really good, Lot of capacity tho, but it's too 'horizontal' and vast, good luck for visitors, looking for patient room🤔

The perspective of it as a system is fresh but think about the circulation, how difficult would it be for a staff to move in between two different places?

@emmanuelsaenyi5645

Жыл бұрын

High speed elevators , escalators

@rosemadder5547

Жыл бұрын

They should make it circular, with the staff areas in the middle…. I had a dream about that last night and ended up here looking for something that looks like my dream 😂 I know it’s crazy 😜 or a staff base in each area

@stefanvanr.5006

10 ай бұрын

@@rosemadder5547 That’s crazy I had a similar dream a couple of days ago and I was looking for concepts just like you 😅

@rollinghippo2940

Ай бұрын

@@rosemadder5547 did u wet urself after that?

@nayanmolla32

Ай бұрын

​@@rosemadder5547👍🏼

Tooooo ......Great ........🤲💕

Is it Stanford University?

building vertically with balconies would be a much better design. elevators actually speed up transport times because everything is closer together. and now its small enough to be built in a city where a hospital belongs

@ruben4447

Ай бұрын

Yeah but its not that necessarily. Its not like people are trying to save as much space in the desert as possible. Thats the only upside with building in the desert. Space isnt that much of a problem.

It would be a real challenge so it can be functional according to the flow of each activity and what the law allows. I visualize this project as multiple hospital units with different specialties.

Hospitals shouldn't be growing their own food. That's not their purpose. Hospitals belong in cities where people live, not in cornfields or the middle of a desert.

There's a reason why modern hospitals are high-rise, they take less land surface area. How realistic is getting such a large piece of land in a metropolitan area?

Reminds me Jony Ives Voice! 😅Incredible, as Apple´s commercials

a brand new city, dedicated wholly to a next generation corporate hub . . . a state-of-the-art downtown infrastructure spanning an area of millions of acres, six times bigger than both Lower Manhattan & Shanghai combined . . . a precisely planned downtown showcasing the best of vertical infrastructure engineering . . . no less than 284 skyscrapers will be built simultaneously over a project tenure of 36 yrs . . . estimated project cost €344 Bn - €563 Bn (approx) based on a 12% inflation . . .

two floors makes the construction cost cheaper and easier to do, I think the only two problems are the speed of getting from one area to another and emergency isolation in case of dangerous diseases

Espetacular!!

My question is how you create a beautiful model and edit 😊

How do you find a room if the building is re-architecting itself every time?

Hm, I wonder how a Code Blue would work in that type of hospital setting.

I like it i need something like it for my psychiatric hospital in the Evergreen

Much more eficient a vertical building than a so big space used.

In hospital logistics nightmare and even now to get an emergency consultation doctor have to run from one end to other end , if that is the future we have to learn electric roller skates

Good video

How much billion to build this hospital?

Iya Luxury Hospital juga...

While communities should be comparably built.

Looks like a modern El Alhambra.

utopía o distopía?

we lov it

feels like those sci fi horro movies in space

@Mohammad-cf2hd

Ай бұрын

But it’s possible and being made

@folatech4404

Ай бұрын

@@Mohammad-cf2hd well well that should be fun

2:22 Yo, that's Mars.

This hospital needs a metro system now

this is looking as though its on MARS.

This hospital for poor people or wealthy people?

project approved

❤❤❤❤😊😊😊 underneath tunnels. For air ambulance 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

PC Jersilds "Babels hus" (som utspelar sig på Huddinge Sjukhus) utkom redan 1978, så... nej, inte direkt framtiden? (I'm writing in Swedish, since the voice-over speaker has a Swedish accent!)

Em Marte oO?

Middle east petroleum daddy pays well.

❤❤❤❤AeroDromes😊😊😊😊😊😊😊lands

chaska medicine also

I'll spend 6hrs of the round just walking between patients LMAO

Gli ospedali sono il luogo dove si nasce e si muore , dovrebbero essere luoghi sacri.

Whom do I submit project Country of future......😮 Country of lifetime😊

@kalpeshwani8520

Ай бұрын

Build it by self.... Per day join people double the self.

Wait, why are there so many sick people on Mars? The colony is messed up.

Muito bonito, porém pouco prático. Precisa de muito mais espaço para ser construído o que não se tem em grandes centro urbanos.

where the fook do we park cars? they fly in?

Wow such Innovation 👏👏👏 Now let's re-imagine sharp edged knives as beautiful edgeless cylinders. Who cares about utility, let's just innovate for the h€ck of it.

A paper cut bandage will cost 6 figures

Why do we need Hospital that big if there is no sickness.

Hospitals, Government buildings, and churches need to be tall and stand out in a city. I'd hate to have my life on the line at an random city and not be able to find a flat ass building the next block over.

Hmm. There is no such thing as the hospitable of the future. We sure do need good hospitals now, though let’s focus on preventing the need for them. The future will not need hospitals if health becomes a priority. Now that’s the future. Healthy and strong individuals who care about greater matters like love, truth, and liberty.

@stanfordleonard338

Жыл бұрын

Corona virus and future virus will come

@gbpferrao

10 ай бұрын

what about car acidents bruh

@brunzieri

10 ай бұрын

@@gbpferrao I’ll walk.

oma god

why put so much emphasis on hospitals? how about proper nutrition and diet? meaning moral and ethical agriculture, good environment, and the like, take precedence.

@evanstayuka381

Ай бұрын

Because there will always be people like you who do nothing but criticize those who are at least trying to do something.

@fengshui2151

Ай бұрын

@@evanstayuka381 constructive criticism is to be appreciated by open minded beings

@ThomasTomiczek

Ай бұрын

Because some areas are planning to be medical hotspots where people come to treatments. Also, you think proper nutrition and diet will fix many of the ailments? That would put you right into retard territory - plenty of genetic diseases, plenty of bacteria etc. Now, if you would have said medicine changes in some years - ok - but your argument, man, get SOME education.

its supposed to inspire creativity... but here in the comment section we have people judging others and fighting...🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂

@Hari-tv

27 күн бұрын

Its not only about positive thinks. What we concern here, area to large, with no main traffic for quick acces

Patients become Professor X? Okay Im in

Wow Good Design for Moon and Mars, Not feasible on Earth, cause we don't have that much free land in the metropolitan and normal cities , thats why we build stories or tower buildings

You can sell anything to the Arabs as long as it's huge and uses all the catchphrases.

Зачем?

Give me 10 years. AI 200 tech and medical specialists. A database of everything medical. And death will be a thing of the past.

Elon Musk's hospital on Mars

They have all these ideas. But never finish it. Or change it completely when they built it.

Its kinda ass, it would only be cost effective for the highest income brackets

As an professional architect i think its a nightmare for hospital staff in a study millions of dollar are wasted every year in use because of people asking for directions from hospital staff and don't forget the medical staff like nurse i had read in a reseach paper that nurse walk about 2 to 3 miles daily in their shift and this design layout would increase he walking distance by 10 times i guess.

@olayinka.o9213

Ай бұрын

I'm sure their taking that into account

@Hari-tv

27 күн бұрын

@@olayinka.o9213 im not sure enough. Im already to much visiting hospital. In my opinion, this is not effective. To much waste time and will confuse patients and visitors.

will hospitals even be an architectural form when AI bots could theoretically come right to your house?

😎🤖

Fuck it, thats owsoem

And it’s going to cost USD15,000 per night

Seems too much focus is on civil engineering and less on medical science

The hospital of the future is no hospital 🧠

This is VERY not practical. If there is a code on a patient, they will die before any doctors are able to make it from the doctors lounge or from far across in another module instead of just running down/up some stairs

Incredibly stupid space inneficient hospital right in the desert where a hospital isnt needed. Getting arround in this thing would be an absolute horror

If only the world wasn't ruled by megalomaniacs😢

#🧐⚙️🌐🌍 location side hospital teknologi canggih dunia first in Malaysia come dan seluruh dunia now projek kewangan project new money world national 🌍🌐❓📊👈💯🤑 money shares in world mega projek 3:24

Its all nice and glorious in 3D until its built, you have to man it and maintain the damn thing. Not pretty.

Hospital designed by a villa designer

China already did it prefab and module... this is not a new or impressive idea...

This design makes no sense. How can anyone move efficiently about this place after frequently being expanded? You’d need those walking escalators or horizontal elevators to get around. I couldn’t imagine the nightmare of moving from one department to another. Let’s not even talk about the endless security risks of random ppl causing havoc in that place.

This is not futureproof design without thinking about traffic flow in hospital. Also a nightmare for visitor because they might be to park their car very far way and then they need to walk from a far away of lobby to far a way of ward. I guess every ward can be functional as operation room as well but if not, i guess the patient will die first before that reach operation room..

could easily be refurbished into a prison after the hospital fails

Better as an office than a hospital. Not correct layout for hospitals, Oma not knowing healthcare just marketing videos

The system is just too literally square and that’s all I can say aggressive corners not even Lego would build a Hospital that way. Let’s hope the AI has learnt some lessons by reading bad KZread comments.

This layout produces a prison structure with limited visual freedom...not everyone is ok with closed off spaces fed by mini courtyards! At least begin with visual freedom areas, that heals them mind and hence the body. So I find this machine-like design idea to be too basic and flawed. It is only hyped because of the name of th firm involved

Doesnt feel like a hospital

@Lyonessi

11 ай бұрын

Yeah I hoped not

😂 seriously? I thought they will tell how department should be built efficiently to tackle situation and they can be interconnected in a better way but it's just a bunch of crap video editing . Any doctor will laugh at it 😅

Lame

taking up too much land very pathetic idea, everything should be 'apartmentalized'

This is a future death clinic. However, no one will be able to die because I will deny them entry into the afterlife.

Why everything that Dubai or Qatar builts never sounds like Natural.

But one pblm.... This requires more land... 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻

"What's your unit?" This hospital: 𝘆𝗲𝘀