This journey has no END

@kison7715

2 жыл бұрын

WHAT A TWIST!

@SlavJerry

2 жыл бұрын

LES GOOOOOOO

@diaquallo

2 жыл бұрын

Yup

@Lazziness_

2 жыл бұрын

What A Twist! (2)

@takoandpotato8804

2 жыл бұрын

Yeap, History repeat itself again and again and again where cavillation raise and fall , where Time , Space and Nature kept giving humanity to rebuild and redo but where there cavillation there bound to have Chaos and so the loop will never end ~~ Kronii already adapt improvise overcome this is why she perfect

"Civilization will never learn from history, instead of changing her, it's better to enjoy the happiness she brings you as soon as possible" is such a raw quote.

@steelreign5529

2 жыл бұрын

This should've been pinned instead.

@Aeriaa81

2 жыл бұрын

Oof this quote hit me so hard when I think about Rushia. We lost so many holomems because of ourselves and our actions…

@Berry-vn6bv

2 жыл бұрын

@@Aeriaa81 ikr, fans are mad about cover terminating rushia, when those very fans are the ones that made the small issue such a big deal and pushed Rushia to the edge, resulting to her mental breakdown and into her making bad moves in attempt to clear her name

Mumei's lore why she is forgetful hits hard right in the feels

So kronii chooses to not act familiar on purpose since it's not the same "mumei". Loved this story from start to finish

THAT END HELLA SPOOKED ME, almost became super sad for this banger to end Yo that’s cool, get to see the whole series again and see all the happy and good moments

This went from "random cute drawings with comedy" to "deep lore and drama" real quick. I'm happy that this isn't the end and I'm hyped to see more! Also, I think I have a very lane theory that Kronii actually did the things she did because she knows that whatever happened won't happen again because it's in a time loop. But then, maybe whatever happened will happen again and that the Atlantis one will actually repeat again. So hyped for next season!

這劇情藏得令人畏懼，結局來看，Kronii打從一開始就知道闖入Very room的這位小姑娘是誰，只是他不能破壞時間軸，所以他扮演了"你是誰"的橋段，而且還是每次Mumei重生來到Very room他就必續再次演一遍，即便這條世界線會導致文明毀滅，然而他最後也明白到既然歷史必定會重演，何不在他發生前盡可能地享受在一起的時光。 至於自然的Fauna，自然反對文明的成長，因為成長必定會促成文明走向滅亡，而他也受夠每一次文明滅亡、失去了Mumei後歷史又會再重演一次，最後卻被已經想通的Kronii開導，選擇了接受結果並且陪伴文明的成長。 而Sana則是一直將這一切都看在眼裡，也明白Kronii這麼做並不是在促使文明滅亡，而是一起陪伴文明快樂的離去。 細絲極恐阿，蘋果大大，點讚了。

@umbra9472

Жыл бұрын

Oh god google translate changed all the pronouns to masculine.

@ditchfood8047

Жыл бұрын

Wow. Is this lore, fanfic, or just philosophy?

@jianxianlee5892

Жыл бұрын

@@umbra9472Well in chinese, 他 can be mean he or she, male dont have specific pronouns, while female has specific pronouns 她, so google translate actually did nothing wrong here.

1:20 i still love that kronii made a house shaped like her head labelled perfect house and just has a picture of herself at the front door

she was happy and smilling, she knows mumei will arrive at that time AAAHHHHH ITS SOOO GOOOD the ending gave me a sense that its a never ending loop of good memories to be made

Can we just take a moment and appreciate the one panel with Gura in it? She's literally digging through the rubble of her home amidst corpses of her people, with her civilization literally dying behind her.

@silvercrescent1264

Жыл бұрын

We need more fall of atlantis stuff... even if I think in Gura's lore atlantis isnt destroyed

@Ozymandias2x

Жыл бұрын

Ha! Classic Gura comedy.

@silvercrescent1264

Жыл бұрын

@@Ozymandias2x Your a sick man...

@Ozymandias2x

Жыл бұрын

@@silvercrescent1264 You're taking my joke about 300% more seriously than you should be.

@silvercrescent1264

Жыл бұрын

@@Ozymandias2x ...didnt get the reference did you?

Even without voices, this is so emotional I started crying in public while watching this :,)

Poor Baelz. She has fallen through that portal and had the same conversations with Mumei countless times. She's basically experiencing West World

I'm not crying. There's sand in my eyes 😭 Awww what a beautiful ending. I hope they can avoided the civilization + chaos ending that haunt all of them Can't wait for the final season, hope this got noticed by Council too!! xD

@OGNOLLID

2 жыл бұрын

we gotta make sure civilization keeps going my friend.

@jefalmero5658

2 жыл бұрын

Yes pls i wna hear their thoughts

@sherwengalleza8627

2 жыл бұрын

@@jefalmero5658 me too...

@goremyst

2 жыл бұрын

THAT DAMN POCKET SAND!!!!!

@marioprawirosudiro7301

Жыл бұрын

Discovering this vid 6 months late. A video with cute characters really shouldn't put anyone to tears. Yet it did.

This is very similar to what Kiara has to go through whenever she's once again reborn, losing memories. Very well though out story with a deep message behind it!!!

@Esjay_CH

2 жыл бұрын

In that regard this makes comparing her to Mumei even more fitting in that case

@spooderlover3512

2 жыл бұрын

At least her memory loss is temporary

@VVheeli

2 жыл бұрын

Good news for Kiara’s lore: with Calli now being her reaper, she no longer forgets

@namegoeshere5220

2 жыл бұрын

@@VVheeli Boy, that's convenient! /S

Is no one gonna talk about Omega watching over the council at 9:48? and then shes missing in the picture frame at 10:01? amazing touch and great work as always...

@enoenthehero

2 жыл бұрын

The final boss is here~

@Bulletmoaf

2 жыл бұрын

woah, totally didn't notice that on my own, thanks for calling it out for us blind folks :O

Now it’s Sana’s turn.

Like what our favorite Guardian of Civilization once said: “Please don’t end this here. I need you, still.” Still that was a roller coaster of emotions. Thanks for this masterpiece!

"Civilisation can never learn from history" has hit closer than ever to heart as of recent

As much as I enjoyed the random doodles when season 1 started, I live the story this turned into. That ending is perfect

This hit in a special type of way that left marks... I think the lack of voices heightened the effect too. Perfectly laid out and executed.

I just realized that Sana asking Kronii why she's "doing this" was to Kronii deciding to be with Mumei after she sent her to be reunited with Bae, not after she convinced Fauna to accept that Mumei will make the same mistakes forever. So Kronii really did everything with a plan. The Council really offers so much room for really interesting stories. I mean their representations individually yes we had a lot of time travel, space travel, ode to civilization etc and there are stories involving gods of time and nature and such, but stories with the personifications of those elements as main characters? Very rare. I've been pretty hyped about fan fictions about the Council and this series really showed the potential. This sure has been an interesting ride.

This hurts now, since Sana is gone ;-;

Ok, that was a incredible series with 2 seasons, and i love it. I don't know if you want to continue doing that until we reach the "present" with holomyth or if you want to continue doing the animations based out some clips. But whatever you do, i'll gonna watch and support you, you make awesome and cute videos :D

恭喜第一、二季完結灑花!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 雖然Mumei與其他議會成員有所不同 她可能會經歷的生離死別較多 甚至在每周目都忘卻掉曾經的回憶和同伴 但其他成員依然接納了她 相片也換成議會全員的合照 感動，這或許就是友情的羈絆啊QQ 期待第三季之後的冒險~ "文明終有一死，何不沉浸於美好的當下?"

@NO9baga

2 жыл бұрын

是說mumei記憶力不好的梗嗎?

@artjio

2 жыл бұрын

@@NO9baga 是

[文明永遠不會從歷史中吸取教訓]，我個人覺得這句話用得太好了，看看全世界的歷史何嘗不是這樣呢，這部影片就像是歷史的縮影一樣，像是個循環一樣

So Kronii has the picture with three of them all the time before the video introduces the storyline. In this video, Kronii finally replaces the picture with all five of them. And Mumei's loop goes on... This story is a wholesome.

Not one, two, three but infinite loops had been made.Yet the series give us alot of emotion

@poem179

2 жыл бұрын

I started to notice a lot of thing doesn't add upp too :)))

Is there no one noticing Omega in the uniting scene of 5 members. In the last scene, we see Kronii is changing the frame on the wall from 3 members to 5 members. But Omega is not in that photo wherein the actual uniting, we see Omega is hiding behind the tree. My theory is that in a specific (present) timeline where Omega exists, the loopholes would be broken as Omega is technically the one who recruits the holo council into Hololive. To trigger that specific timeline, there should be an event to distort time and space themself. An event includes a specific ground-pounding detective stealing the watch of the time warden and recruits Myth.

Watching this again for obvious reasons.

Omg i never thought this cute animation would bring tears to my eyes. Praise to superappleman for not only creating such an awesome lore, but also teaching us to treasure the moment with your loved one. I really hope the council will see this.

今天sana畢業了，回來看到這個影片，眼淚有下來了QAQ!

@gingerkth

Жыл бұрын

same here🥲

i came back cause i am looping

The most important thing here is that everyone's reunited. Together again, even if this loophole is repeating itself without alteration or disruption in the space-time continuum.

Holy crap we need to get Council The Voice this! Or react to it. This story had layers and is surprisingly deep

Really like the touch of "memories" as the ending song. Made me think the line "the memories bring back you" could mean that mumei only keeps reappearing because the others remember her otherwise civilization would just disappear after destroying itself (which it does many times)...

It's insane how it started like a cute lil comic about Civilization and such but became a great story. The ending really made me so happy, seeing Kronii knowing that Mumei would appear and her smiling and the song that played in the back it's just so good

I'm not crying! There is just some berries in my eyes! It was a such great story about friendship. Thank u for making this Superappleman The paradox continues!

I’m now waiting to see holomyth appear in this and cause more chaos… especially gura since she already seems to have a bit of beef with mumei, just cause she lost her civilization really

@n4m31355h4dow

2 жыл бұрын

And Watson who have a watch taken from kronii

@jefalmero5658

2 жыл бұрын

Also the fact that Ina knows Sana from before

0:20 así es como Sana estará amparando por nosotros.

This brought a tear to my eyes such a heart warming tale of friendship

I feel like this has to be a landmark piece of content, this community should still remember and take inspiration from, even in a decade's time... 🙂

OMG! So it's not only that history is keep repeating itself, it's also a stable timeloop? This story is so amazing, short sweet and yet has a lot of stuff to unpack. Amazing job my friend, a really amazing job! I really hope the Council could see this

If this get an anime adaptation or maybe a voice over I'm gonna die at that moment from happiness. THIS IS JUST SO AMAZING! Pls keep up the good work bro👍👍👍

原來克羅尼才是一切的推手 為了所有的朋友能快樂 而裝作自己這些事是順其自然發生的 克羅尼的暗線安排真好

I hope there always five of them. Complete untill the end. Thanks superappleman. I hope this video will be seen by cover or yagoo. i am speechless. Your work is so amazing. I hope Coucil want to be seiyu for this masterpiece.

Didn't expect such a cute looking story to have such deep lore. It seems chaos is what is getting Mumei stuck in a cycle. However, a cycle is order so maybe the chaos that caused the loop can break it.

劇情很好也讓我們看到他們的友情非常堅定....失去了他又一直重來他們還是沒放棄他...最後的地方感覺又重來了😅😆

This story goes hard man Such a great message, told to us in such cute drawings. Props to you Apple

You have done more work in this clip than Hollywood has in the last 20 years

Me: OH! This should be a funny adventur- *Watches it,* Me after: Oh.

This was just too precious. Tears on my eyes on how cute this all was. Such a fun time following this story with every post you’ve made, both here and on Twitter. I look forward to many more projects you may have in the world. Blessings to you, my friend! 🤟😎

This is beautiful... please, PLEASE someone show this to the council!

I enjoyed every second of this. Everything is so cute and the way of drawing everyone from the expressions to Mumei's outfits are stunning.

Causal Loop, Igor Novikov, Novikov self-consistency principle, The bootstrap paradox. This story is like Tenet movie. You are genius, you made story for the councils like that. 👏👏🙇🙇

Civilization is a marble rollings on the track of the curvy circle of time. I really want to see all of HoloEN react to this video.

不如盡快享受她帶給你的幸福，這句話真的是在對所有人說，自己所喜歡的推，總有一天會離開，所以要把握好現在她們還在的美好時光，能推就推、能支持就支持，盡可能地不要留下遺憾。 感謝蘋果人帶給我們你那優質作品，萬分感激 謝謝

Such a sad bitter sweet, but also satisfying ending. Thanks for all the hard work you did. This entire thing blew me away. 😄😥

And this is we’re Hololive Council has begun

Man I've seen this clip many times but, 2:40-3:45 is still hitting me hard. I love that part, so heartwarming! Season 2 is so beautifully done. I wish they notice ur work! Your really did a wonderful job here. Thanks for this awesome mini series! 👍👍👍👍👍👍 I hope there's more to come.

Joder, que gran historia tío, me he emocionado y todo macho que final épico, buenísimo, buenísimo!

1 year later.. still tear up watching this... A thought occured to me too about how intertwined their lives have probably become since starting their journey... whiich makes the whole loop of happy and sad of them all kind of being together but separate a bit more profound.

Oh my god you don't know how much you made me cry, but it's a good thing, you've made a perfect combination of sadness, true, kindness and even put a lot of lore into, i love it and you made me cry a looot it was beautiful

I really enjoyed this, but my only concern is that Bae seems to be more of a pet than an equal member of Council. My hope is that if this is continued, Bae will have actual speaking roles and more agency. But good work overall, I really enjoyed the story that you told here.

Much love to you mate I also love that you added omega

Thank you for punching me in the feels. I really love how, to me, it shows how life has good and bad moments, you can remember the good with fondness, or dwell on the bad and suffer; but neither the good or bad moments last forever, they inevitably end and become memories. Once again thank you for all the work you put into this and I cannot wait to see what other proyects you work on.

"Memories bring back, memories bring back you." Just like this video, give me deja vu.

Hard to believe this was a made over a year ago. This journey definitely has no end to me watching it time to time.

Biarpun jauh dari mata, Takkan hilang di hati, Terus gagah melangkah pasti, Hari-hari yang ku lalui, Pada Tuhan ku berdoa, Waktu kan mengubati, pasti

Thank you for making this beautiful storyline :) it really makes me happy and feel sad at the same time

This has to be some of the best storytelling I’ve ever seen

Not gonna lie when I saw you upload your first ever HoloCouncil comic I thought it would just be a few short comics. I've been following this story since the beginning and I loved every single second of it. I hope you continue to make more amazing sketches and I plan to stay for the journey. This was a blast and I hope that someday, they will dub this story and make it cannon.

This genuinely so amazing, It almost had me shedding a tear. The story and music are so evocative. Thank you for making this.

Holy shit this is so heart warming and touching. I can't believe this got tears to my eyes. A true masterpiece. Thank you so much for creating it

Thanks for putting together this cute and awesome story. It all comes together with the limited dialogue and great art. A great circle loop of a story that doesn’t end but has the opportunity to bring new happy memoirs every time.

Everything about this series was / is awesome! Also love the Omega in the back!

文明的一生~~這是個暖心結局😊，議會都團聚了~~看了很感動~~期待下一部

Thanks for this heart warming series, i cant wait for the other lores 👍👍👍

this is amazing the lore runs so deep it for no good reason and I love it

I am a Japanese Nikki. I enjoyed it a lot. If this story were subtitled in Japanese, I think people would know more about this lovely video! Keep up the good work! From deepL

@angelochile8103

2 жыл бұрын

Aw sweet!

Man HoloEN lore is so painful. Myth and Council. Time, Chaos, Civilization, Death, the Ancient Ones, Ame and the time traveling. Thank you for this. Let us all continue to support them.

@DianaProudmoore

2 жыл бұрын

And that Mini-lore collab of Coco and Ame~ Hits right in the feels~!

@justapassingbycursemancer6254

2 жыл бұрын

5:19 and Gura is literally losing her home and Family here.

@DianaProudmoore

2 жыл бұрын

@@justapassingbycursemancer6254 *Might controls everything~*

@TheNukedNacho

2 жыл бұрын

@@justapassingbycursemancer6254 Someone also made a comic and posted it on the hololive subreddit. Destruction of Atlantis by Civilization, because the Detective gave them technology far too advanced for their time.

@justapassingbycursemancer6254

2 жыл бұрын

@@DianaProudmoore Without power you can't even protect anything, even yourself. - some Motivated Man.

Such a cute, simple art style, yet the lore is surprisingly deep!

This is so amazing! The use of Rauf and Faik really got me feeling emotional.

man this storyline is sick gimme more did a great work on this. subscribed.

The Council is like the opposite of the Greek Gods. Instead of being easily jealous of each other and causing wanton destruction for petty reasons, these gods are willing to allow bad things to happen just so they can continue their wholesome friendships.

Way way too beautiful.... the music in the end hits real hard too.

So well made and much love put in. Thank you so much for this experience❤️🙏🏻

Thank you for this :)

this honestly makes me teary-eyed, love it

Not gonna lie, a Chill went down my spine when I saw... huhh... Omegaα

This is such a perfect story, thank you, apple man

看完之後又哭了一次 但感覺很美妙

This is incredible, I look forward to seeing more of your work. Congratulations on this 👏👏👏

The art is cute. The feel hits hard. Thankyou for your hard work.

謝謝你超級蘋果人~真的感人又好看!!!

Beautiful Master Piece. I am crying, thank you for this. I love your job and videos

That was the sweetness I needed to finish this week off right

I’m getting the chills geez this was good

Man, that was amazing, my eyes started watering here.

awww~ so cute and sad and very well done good job appleman

Thank you for this 🙏