Get 3 months History Hit access for $3 using code 'timeline' bit.ly/TimelineSubscribe

@mamiamracha353

4 жыл бұрын

There is a close battle that the Prophet Muhammad told us about is the battle of Dabiq, it is an area near the Levant in Palestine, where the battlefield will be between the Romans and Muslims. Romanians, Westerners or Easters, for example, are they currently from Europe, America or Russia, but according to the opinion of scholars and researchers, some agreed that what is meant is uncle from Russia and what proves this blame, they control the Middle East because the Islamic caliphate is not established to defend the Arabs and Muslims

@yolamontalvan9502

3 жыл бұрын

It would have been cooled if the host was dressed up as a Roman soldier.

@heitoreduardodiasvieira7031

3 жыл бұрын

@Cornelia Fulmore 5t⁰

@michaelsolari7371

3 жыл бұрын

U

@michaelsolari7371

3 жыл бұрын

Uu

When Rome said something needs to be destroyed they really meant it.

@yolamontalvan9502

3 жыл бұрын

Donald Trump, the Death Cult President, is trying to do the same. Unfortunately for him, he’s in the wrong country.

@miguelpereira9859

3 жыл бұрын

@@yolamontalvan9502 You're a weirdo

@1994CPK

3 жыл бұрын

@@yolamontalvan9502 imagine thinking about trump 24/7. He's your whole life. Rent free

@yolamontalvan9502

3 жыл бұрын

1994CPK - Trump is in the 6 o’clock news every day. Do you watch the news?

@1994CPK

3 жыл бұрын

@@yolamontalvan9502 never cable news, this isn't the 1960s anymore.

I love how the phrase "Delenda est Carthago" is constantly switched around (i.e. Carthago delenda est) by historians. Everyone agrees Cato said it about one million times, but nobody can agree on what order this 3 word sentence goes in.

@reidmartin6209

3 жыл бұрын

I might be wrong but I think Latin is a highly inflected language so it means the same thing no matter the order That being said, true

@user-ly4yp8ml2i

5 ай бұрын

Yeah I've wondered loads of times.

@charlesbyrne71

2 ай бұрын

I thought order didn't matter.

Why do you keep showing the statue of Constantine over and over again? He was born 500 years after the Punic wars

@raymonddeflaviis9532

4 жыл бұрын

He is a millennial SJW. Everything he believes must be taken with a grain of salt.

@lonw.7016

4 жыл бұрын

Agree>!

@Insectoid_

4 жыл бұрын

Raymond DeFlaviis um. What

@overseer3072

4 жыл бұрын

alien cat 😂

@StopFear

4 жыл бұрын

@@raymonddeflaviis9532 Raymond, you are an ignorant cretin

Someone needs to make a film series about the the Punic Wars.

@cejka30

5 жыл бұрын

Or Hannibal crossing the alps!

@joshlanier8567

5 жыл бұрын

I think Sean Kingston should do the series. Last i heard he was at war.

@hrthrhs

5 жыл бұрын

There is one. I watched it on youtube a couple years ago. If i come across it I'll holla.

@justevil100

5 жыл бұрын

@@hrthrhs Any luck locating it?

@uspatriots877

5 жыл бұрын

There is one

Hannibal didn´t take Rome because he knew it would be impossible to subdue such a city with the army he had under his command. Even if he entered it the population was simply to big to effectively subdue.

When Carthage failed to take over Sicily it signed its own long term Death Warrant - for without Sicily Carthage would lack population (farming citizen-soldier population). The move from a citizen army (mentioned by Aristotle - in the old days no one could vote in Carthage unless they had first undertaken military service), to a mercenary army that could defeat Rome in battles - but never, in the end, in a war. The Carthaginians had been appalled by their losses in the wars with the Greeks in Sicily - but, by trying to avoid losses (by turning away from a citizen-soldier culture) the Carthaginians made sure that, in the end, their losses would be TOTAL. Ironically the Romans themselves turned away from a culture of citizen soldiers - thus signing its own long term Death Warrant.

@Charlie-ii5rr

3 жыл бұрын

That may be, but the disasters in the Cimbri wars exposed the weakness of the militia system and led to the Marian reforms.

@brohan914

2 жыл бұрын

@@Charlie-ii5rr Yup. Professionals will always be superior to citizen-soldiers. They key is keeping the generals loyal...

@Cleeon

7 күн бұрын

But the problems with soldiers who work only as soldiers, their loyalty not always for the motherland or fatherland, but with who pay the salary and guarantee their or their family life, which is general or just who pay them handsomely.

as a Tunisian I'm proud of my heritage and history , thank you for this

@inri247

2 жыл бұрын

Carthage wasn't tunisian wdym

@barcak1912

2 жыл бұрын

@@inri247 a significant part of Ancient Carthage is now in modern day Tunisia

@alikechiche9947

2 жыл бұрын

@@inri247Carthage is Tunis 😅

@tameredanslederriere

2 жыл бұрын

@@barcak1912 he is referring to the ethnicity of the people not the geography.. genetically speaking modern day lebanese is the closer you got to the carthaginians!

@wankawanka3053

Жыл бұрын

@@barcak1912 turks have a bunch of ancient greek stuff in their country so that suddenly makes them greek?

Timeline left out the influence of the ancient Greek colonies throughout the Mediterranean and their interaction with Rome and Italy as well as the Hellenistic influence on both Rome and Carthage. I was hoping to see a lot more in terms of Carthage's founding and early development.

How anyone can talk about Hannibal in Italy without covering the battle of Cannae is beyond me.

@tonymullins6627

5 жыл бұрын

Rome's worse defeat ever, about 60,000 killed (in one day of battle.) Hannibal was a military genius.

@keyboarddancers7751

5 жыл бұрын

Best to watch this first: "Hannibal: The Man Who Hated Rome"; it's all there.

@jaroslavpenkava5525

5 жыл бұрын

@Where Is Waldo My favorite, In time when beat Hanibal he been just 23 years old I thing.

@samray3297

5 жыл бұрын

Hannibal was Phoenician, from Carthage.

@jaroslavpenkava5525

5 жыл бұрын

@@samray3297 Scipius Africanus

A bit simplistic. Rome as the evil thugs versus Carthago as the noble victim. At the end of the day they were two major powers fighting over the same territory.

@Cybernaut551

6 ай бұрын

I agree.

@parjanyashukla176

4 ай бұрын

Carthage might have been imperialist as well, but Rome was no doubt a ruthless, savage empire. There is no comparison between the two. One is able to make this judgement only if you examine the world history in comparison, comparing and contrasting various societies.

@jonnyanderson8845

2 күн бұрын

​@@parjanyashukla176,Rome was remembered as ruthless only because they won all 3 wars, but what would have happened if they had lost? In Carthage, there was children sacrifice for the sake of the harvest, unlike the ancient Rome

“This isn’t some schmuck in a flak jacket” is the *funniest* thing I’ve ever heard

@The_ZeroLine

2 жыл бұрын

When/where was that said?

You love Carthaginians, you love history and your commentary is excellent. Thanks.

In 1996,almost 2,100 years of Punic Wars,a symbolic peace treaty was signed between the mayor of Rome and Tunis where Carthage was under a district jurisdiction marked the end of rivalry of 2 cities even it was changed on the time but also Italy and Tunisia are allies

@isaiahcalderon366

Жыл бұрын

So did Athens and Sparta 2,000+ years after the whole issue

@darwinqpenaflorida3797

Жыл бұрын

@@isaiahcalderon366 Yes that same year a peace treaty was signed between the mayors of Athens and Sparta, both in modern day Greece 🇬🇷

I can't get enough of Timeline on Rome. Well done

My 23andme test results line up with everything I've been studying about carthage and the Pheonicians. My last name is Cartagena, and as a Christian, I also learned about the dark practices of the Pheonicians, like Jezebel for example, and can tell that my ancestors may have also dabbled in dark practices. Learning all of this is so eye-opening and refreshing.

@bethbartlett5692

Жыл бұрын

You understand that the Roman Emperor Constatine (the guy that established the Religion) and his Priests made edits to the texts and the Roman Religion isn't what Jesus/Yeshua was teaching + he was a Practicing Jew and a Rabbi. It takes the History of the era, and an open mind + time to explore. Just your choice, to be Religion or to search for what Jesus taught. Either way, as long as you have clarity, are positively supported by your beliefs, and realize your self worth, ✓ Positive is absent of fear. Religion and then there's our personal, spiritual, experience and practice. Religion is organized and established by man, your spiritual is your direct link to God, Creator, Source of all. Take your time and trust your intuition and logic. Jesus will Guide you to what you seek, just ask and trust. 😘

@98Zai

8 ай бұрын

Most of your ancestors lived long before Jesus was born. Whatever happened to your ancestors, they were doing the best the could with whatever tools they had. The reputation they received came from the people who stood to gain from it. People in those times loved to embellish themselves compared to "the others" - savages, barbarians etc. Carthaginians did the same to Rome.

Each boat was marked *ίκεα*

@mamamarianovits9029

5 жыл бұрын

Peter Walker I have finally reached that part of the presentation.. and I finally understand your comment, which I read as it started.😂

@spudwesth

5 жыл бұрын

No.

@maverikmiller6746

5 жыл бұрын

That joke cracked up me. Thanks man :)

@hueym.3950

4 жыл бұрын

Έλα άλλος ένας Έλληνας 🤭😂🇬🇷

@mamiamracha353

4 жыл бұрын

There is a close battle that the Prophet Muhammad told us about is the battle of Dabiq, it is an area near the Levant in Palestine, where the battlefield will be between the Romans and Muslims. Romanians, Westerners or Easters, for example, are they currently from Europe, America or Russia, but according to the opinion of scholars and researchers, some agreed that what is meant is uncle from Russia and what proves this blame, they control the Middle East because the Islamic caliphate is not established to defend the Arabs and Muslims

Absolutely wonderful. Now only if all history lessons could be this informative and entertaining.

LMAO at the people in the comments saying this doc is "biased," that's the whole point -- traditionally we always get the Roman version, which is just as biased. Let the man tell the other side for once

@fuzzles9246

5 жыл бұрын

yeah well everything this doc said is actually facts, yet people used to Roman version, but there was a roman governor of carthage after the war kinda liked carthage and said it was wrong to erase carthage from history, he revolted against his emperor and took his place, he orderd the reconstruction of carthage and to write down whats known about the original carthage yet the roman version is itselfe biased, but thanks to other civilizations like greece and others confirmed or denied the stories and who kept whats known about carthage. yet history is written by victors .

@tadhgknight3484

5 жыл бұрын

FEZZ_HH And that governed would’ve had flawed info as well, because to revolt against an emperor (not a republic) he’d had to of done it at least 100 years after Carthage’s erasion

@fuzzles9246

5 жыл бұрын

@@tadhgknight3484 Exactly, Erasing something then trying to tell it with another way wont be the same, THEY even tried to rebuild Carthage and wasnt even close to the original one.

@lucasstemba

5 жыл бұрын

I don't mind the bias but there are some bits where the bias borders on unfactual. I.e. calling rome imperial when rome was far from an empire and and calling Cato a xenophobe when I have never heard anything to support he cared about race.

@laurelanne5071

5 жыл бұрын

@@lucasstemba xenophobia isn't about race, it's hating what is foreign. Imperialism, pure and simple, is invading other territories to profit from them as well as imposing your culture on the occupied areas, and that's what Rome was about since day 1.

38:45 Boat named "Hannibal" , that's awesome.

@ashtonsmith1905

4 жыл бұрын

Phil Tanics why

The Carthaginians were hated by the Greeks long before the Romans entered the scene. The Punic were seen as an evil race. Some of it comes from their (occasional) human sacrifices, which both the Romans and the Greeks had in disgust, but there's more. For example, sentencing your best general to crucifixion just because he's too popular with his mercenary troops after a victorious campaign in the name of Carthage. It happened more than once. Even the great Hannibal, he went to exile not because of the Romans but because the Carthaginian senate really were a crazy ungrateful untrustworthy bunch. Now that I think of it, I know of another crazy bunch like that: the Venitians. These merchant people just don't play by the rules. (I have great admiration for Carthage, I just like to play the devil's advocate.)

@hamilcarbarca946

5 жыл бұрын

That is the romain misinformation ! for greeks you should read politics written by aristotle chapter 8. Carthaginians had war with greeks but olso treaties

@marypoppins2044

5 жыл бұрын

"Occasional" human sacrifices? What about the 20,000 clay jars of burnt infants left behind in Carthage? Carthage was destroyed, but the Phoenicians had cities all over the Mediterranean coastlines. Then the Phoenician alphabet (modified) was in Rome. Then the Phoenician survivors fled to Venice and Genoa. Before they were known as Phoenicians, they lived in present-day Lebanon and we're called Caanites. Same folks, still no better behaved.

@isismccain915

5 жыл бұрын

One of the nastiest things the Venetians ever did was pitching in on the capture of Constantinople in 1204 in what was supposed to be the 4th Crusade. They sacked & pillaged Constantinople of anything of value, much of it going to Venice where those golden horses (still on display in Venice) were given to the "dogie".......one of the biggest traitors ever to Western Civilization, right behind the No. 1 traitor.......big Nick Ducas of Byzantium (1071 AD).

@2serveand2protect

4 жыл бұрын

..."fides punica"...

@XtoCee

4 жыл бұрын

It seems as if every foreign nation disliked the Phoenicians. The Ancient Israelites despised them, conquered them in Canaan (which was modern-day Israel/Palestine) and founded Israel.

Thank you, Dr. Miles. You brought the story to life.

As a Tunisian, it warms my heart to find such beautiful documentaries acknowledging the greatness of the Carthaginian civilisation. Great upload, you got yourselves a new subscriber! :)

@maxyakov273

7 жыл бұрын

It was great! But weren't they completely eradicated? If so, what is your connection to them?

@JoshuaAntonioLouisJacques

7 жыл бұрын

there is no connection....as usual trying to take credit for the real civilizations that preceeded them for eg persia,egypt etc

@triarii11

7 жыл бұрын

Tunisia's cool, of what I know.....Wisconsin USA.

@Alpha-xt6ow

7 жыл бұрын

maxyakov she is more connected to them than you can ever be.

@KittyKat6931

7 жыл бұрын

maxyakov If you paid attention to the documentary, it said that around 50,000 of them were spared and were enslaved by the romans. In any case, even if I'm not a direct descendant of the Carthaginians, they are still a big part of our history. JALJ3011 Wow, I never knew you were the official authority on "real civilizations".. I do believe historians and archeologists wouldn't be bothered studying a "fake civilization" now, would they? But I wonder how this "taking credit" you're talking about happens, even though the civilizations you mentioned took place year and miles away from the Carthage/Rome incident. Remember, we're talking about the west Mediterranean here.

Love this series & love learning bout Rome, thank you for this documentary, keep it up :)

4:43 Damn that sounds so cool It makes you sad about Carthage too

@cheriefsadeksadek2108

2 жыл бұрын

@Dan Dman it was burnt for 18 days they say

@rayenderbali1181

2 жыл бұрын

💔💔💔💔💔💔💔

@sanahirosplatoon6459

3 ай бұрын

Carthage let itself be destroyed, they were too modern for their own good.

Let this be a lesson for all empires,the elites are nearly always responsible for their empires downfall.

@genericname1366

3 жыл бұрын

Bernie Sanders.

@thorthegodofthunder9150

2 жыл бұрын

@@genericname1366 Mhm yup, Sanders is definitely the elite and Jeff Bezos isn't. Absolutely.

Thanks for the upload! I never really knew the history behind this. When it was mentioned in Gladiator, I never understood what it was about. Now I get it!

The current senate house was built a century after the Punic wars, so it is wrong to claim Cato spoke from those benches.

@davebox588

5 жыл бұрын

Yes, I think that's the Curia Julia that was started during Caesar's dictator years but not completed until after his death in 44 BCE. The previous one was nearly on the same spot though.

Thank you for this. Very well-produced, indeed.

Would it not have made sense for Carthage to see the writing on the wall, pledge allegiance to Rome and become a prosperous city-state within the Roman Empire? They could have kept their culture that way while also assimilating the best parts of Roman sophistication. No context at all is provided, I don't believe Rome would invest that much money and manpower to destroy a large city on another continent for no reason at all.

@seraphx26

Жыл бұрын

After two wars against Carthage the Romans realized the necessity of it's destruction, Rome had come to view it as an existential threat that could not be tolerated. How long after the scenario that you propose would it take for Carthage to rebuild and once again seize an opportunity to challenge Rome? there was room for only one dominant power in the mediterranean.

Way too many adds on youtube all of a sudden

@carbonfibercrypto2919

4 жыл бұрын

Nah it's just this douche adding in too many of them

@marcusaurelius3715

4 жыл бұрын

for your desktop use a adblocker. for your phone look up how to block ads with luna just download the vpn follow a few step and all ads on the youtube app are blocked

@thathistoryiscoolguy

3 жыл бұрын

Imagine if morgz mad this video

@tonycunha1847

3 жыл бұрын

I pay for KZread. Cheap money. I barely watch TV though so I may have a different opinion than many on here.

@carlosmedina9708

3 жыл бұрын

Fast forward rewinde & walaaas

Love , love, love all the history I can find!

@daveyhouston

4 жыл бұрын

Me too

@patriciacole8773

4 жыл бұрын

I like the book “ The Great Controversy “ by e.g. White it’s from a religious perspective but covers before earth to eternity. Covers everything in between. It’s said to be in the White House and distributed widely to politicians and royals and as many people as possible. In my opinion it’s the best information known to mankind.

I appreciate you and your passion and love for history thank you for doing this for us

What a wonderful channel and series of programs. I love the host as well, excellent voice and cadence.

That was great. Thank you. Your prononciation is also really good for my English practice.

@kevin6293

4 жыл бұрын

The English don’t speak English correctly. Learn from north Americans.

@lucnilis6622

3 жыл бұрын

@@kevin6293 lmaooooooo

@godfreybett1370

3 жыл бұрын

@@kevin6293 😂😂😂

"Carthage was the tutor who's feet Rome learned the art of Empire. So powerful it stood in the way of Rome's greatness." 5:50. Chills. Love this documentary!

Fascinating. Lots of detail I've heard nowhere else. I'll watch P1 and P2 more than once.

A much-needed perspective beyond the warped historical version of the "victors" The forgotten stories of the vanquished must be heard if we are to understand humanity. This is a superb documentary.

A 15 year campaign in Rome. That's literally enough time for boys to grow up to become soldiers, more than enough time to create entire new armies consisting of a new generation of soldiers. Hannibal's own soldiers would have started to hit middle-age at the end of the Italian campaign. There was no way Hannibal was ever going to defeat Rome by himself after that length of time.

@randomhistoryfan5749

Жыл бұрын

Thats right, technically after cannae, Hannibal suffered heavy losses and he calculated that even if hen tried sieging Rome another army would be assembled to end him for good. His men were very low on morale and exhausted, Rome just kept on sending armies, sadly even if we would make excuses, Carthage and Hannibal could not have winned the 2nd punic war.

@hydrolito

7 ай бұрын

England and France had a war that lasted 116 years although called 100 year war.

@user-ly4yp8ml2i

5 ай бұрын

​@@hydrolito😂❤

Hannibal at Cannae?? I was staggered that for a presenter eager to tell the Carthaginian story he barely mentioned Hannibal’s incredible military supremacy in winning all battles in Europe including his total annihilation of the Romans at Cannae! It was arguably the most brilliant, and bloody victory by any military leader in the ancient world and ranks up there with Alexs victory against Darius at Guagemala and against Porus at Hydaspes. Hannibal’s only defeat was at Zama, supported by the treachery of his own people.

@lddcavalry

3 жыл бұрын

Pulsonar This wasn’t written by a historian.

@morgothvikramaditya4977

3 жыл бұрын

Porus didn’t lose to Alexander, that is a lie

@Pulsonar

3 жыл бұрын

Morgoth The Real MVP Alexanders Macedonian army and Indian allies defeated King Porus in 326 BC at the Hydapses River. This is not propaganda it is fact, recorded in the Anabasis by some of the most famous historians in antiquity. Alexander was tested to the max and was nearly killed it that engagement, the closest he came to defeat in over a decade of conquest across Asia.

@giantgrowth4204

2 жыл бұрын

His calvary was godlike

@cantbanme792

2 жыл бұрын

there was a whole documentary on it, this one is about the fall.

And now let us switch over to the history experts in the comment section:

I didn't know Robert Webb presented history docs

Lol this guy tells history this way: "Carthage were minding their business happily making money of their trade routes and singing along in camp fires, while suddenly, a greedy, violent evil monster without scruples rose up to steal and kill them all...a monster named...Rome!"

@D0wnshift

2 жыл бұрын

Pretty much.

@johnjobs3027

2 жыл бұрын

Another young white indoctrinated to loath western civilization and prop up any inferior culture or society as the greatest in history. It wasn't history, but rather cheerleading.

@matiusbond6052

2 жыл бұрын

YES ROME WAS A MONSTER

@echelonanglo2226

2 жыл бұрын

@@matiusbond6052 just like any other civilization at the time by today standards...they were just better at it than the rest

@selena9527

2 жыл бұрын

Rome is monster cuz it ruined the all city and architects of carthage

Superb video. Thank you..I've always wondered what was the true story. Well presented.

This is why I treasure my Carthaginian coins. History of an Empire seen as an ultimate alternative history empire is very significant.

Carthage still so salty

@WorkerBeesUnite

5 жыл бұрын

I know. To this day you still can't even talk to one of them about it wink face

@ReasonAboveEverything

5 жыл бұрын

golden shadow Well, from heavenly wealthy might that dominated the mediterranea to erased among civilisations. What would you expect.

@abrahamgarza537

4 жыл бұрын

🤣😂

@daveyhouston

4 жыл бұрын

And peppery too but I prefer mustard

@mjhmab

4 жыл бұрын

I live in Carthage now and sometimes i think how would this place would be if they beat the romans .

I can't stop thinking of That Mitchell and Webb Look. He is constantly walking at the camera!

@Ligerpride

3 жыл бұрын

Haha. Brilliant. Watch the football!!

Great documentary, Jez!

yet another great upload thanks again :)

Great documentary so far, very informative but can we talk about why no one has noticed that this narrator is absolutely gorgeous and his voice goes through my ears like liquid silk? I could listen to him talk forever. Can i have him? To read me old literature until i fall asleep every night?

I really enjoyed this ... Very well done 👍

Absolutely fantastic documentary. Thank you

Great program I just wish it was longer.

220 ships in just 45 days!?!?! That's incredible!

I read about this when I was a kid(I was a fan of ancient Roman history), but forgot about it after all these nearly thirty years. It's an unfortunate part of history, and I still wonder why the Carthaginians deserved this punishment.

@user-ly4yp8ml2i

5 ай бұрын

According to historian Tristan Erwin in The Cults of Moloch and Baal--no I can't spoil it for you. But he gives the reason with lots of Roman references. Very interesting.

D E V A S T A T E = Destroy to the uttermost.... this is the operative word that Rome deployed against the Carthaginians in order to annihilate them and assure that they would NEVER rebuild / re-populate Carthage. Not only did Rome destroy all of Carthage's buildings, but they sowed the soil with salt so Carthage could NOT grow any crops. Rome accomplished its survival purpose as demonstrated by the fact that there was never a 4th Punic War.... objective undeniably fulfilled.

Interesting documentary, but it should be noted that Carthaginian civilization did not disappear with the destruction of Carthage itself. Many Punic cities survived long after the bloodshed and prospered under Roman rule while maintaining much of the culture of their Phoenician ancestors.

@sscxcc8053

5 жыл бұрын

Exactly this is clear misinformation!

@tt3p9

2 жыл бұрын

Yes it wasn't a genocidal attack to exterminate all Carthaginians.

@bilelmliki8475

2 жыл бұрын

We still breathing and we are here the carthaginians 🇹🇳🇹🇳

@Hborn

2 жыл бұрын

How much was a slave there

Thank god for KZread where I can binge on stories of history and great civilizations from the past. I thought I was biggest history buff but looks like there are a lot of us out there. I've been watching a lot of documentaries on the Roman empire, American Revolution, French Revolution, Russian Revolution, Dark Ages, WWI and WWII (I like to jump around). I haven't even started on Greece, Egypt, and other ancient civilizations. So much to watch, so little time!! haha

I love this doc, thank you!

You are correct IMO. Great information and presentation.

Great work!

Nice, Phillip Glass as part of soundtrack!!

Ads breaker....Forward till the end before play the video.... Will only have 1 ads than playback the video....

@bobbiec6074

4 жыл бұрын

Legend!

@dave9401

4 жыл бұрын

Do you mean click the replay button or move the time scroll back to the start? If this works youve saved me from many frustrations.

@Vicky-cq4lc

4 жыл бұрын

@@dave9401 yup.... Bt u'll get 1 add at the end.... Hope it works well for u....

@kevin6293

4 жыл бұрын

# Vicky, that wasn’t a yes or no question, lol.

@Vicky-cq4lc

4 жыл бұрын

@@kevin6293 🙁

Really really good luv it, more please.

Very well presented thank you, I enjoyed this documentary.

They needed photon cannons and Protoss Carriers to defend the city.

You talk about murdered Carthaginians, but you don't mention that before that Carthage tried to wipe out and MURDER all of Rome.

Hannibal really took the meaning of "holding a grudge" to a whole new level when he marched with elephants from Spain all the way to Rome. That looks like a massive hike if you just look at the distance on a map, imagine how long and arduous it was in real life. And the ironic part of it is that in the end, after all that effort, Hannibal still didn't achieve anything significant in terms of inflicting any serious damage on Rome's power.

i was in carthage the other day having a breakfast in the punic art cafe that it had a great view of carthags bay and i was imagining the invasion of the romans and the years of siege it was a mixed feeling of sadness and fantasy.....

You missed a few key details, after his first major victory, one of Hannable's allies insisted that he head right for Rome, use that victory to it's fullest and take Rome while its stunned and demoralized. Hannibal knew his limitations and that Rome had a huge wall around it, it was heavily fortified. When Rome finally defeated Hannibal they did not want to just kill him, Rome had a habit of parading their enemies through the streets and torturing them long before they kill them.

@gregoryglass9040

5 жыл бұрын

They didn't kill him

@Bazooka_Sharks

4 жыл бұрын

He committed suicide before the romans could take care of him

@zimbabwean8719

2 жыл бұрын

@@Bazooka_Sharks where did he say they killed him?

@robertgiles9124

2 жыл бұрын

@@Bazooka_Sharks No thry didn't ...He got away... FAKE NEWS there Joe.

@robertgiles9124

2 жыл бұрын

Actually they often made Allies of those they defeated. You need to study more...it was a looooong Empire with many Leaders and results and "habits". .

The Romans gave Carthage a choice of surrender. That no harm would fall upon them. But of course Carthage refused and the slaughter began...

Thank you Dr. Miles.

I was pretty luke warm about this guy until he bellowed "Delenda est Carthago, Carthage must be destroyed" with the echo, I felt that. 32:33 if you want to hear it again.

Another Great video of the day! Imagine if the Senate had sent the seige equipment, Hannibal ordered?

Rome knew it's time was at an end, and its leaders saw that Carthage was becoming everything rome had failed to be. Their anger and jealousy now echo through the ages. And the lesson still stands today.

There is so many historical inaccuracies here... Most important - (1) by the time of the 1st Punic conflict, there is no reason to believe that anybody considered Rome an upstart. It had already defeated Greek armies on the battlefield and conquered Greek cities in Italy. (2) Sicily has its own history. The Romans never agreed to let it be if the Carthaginians would let Italy be. Sicily was contested by the Carthaginians, the Greeks and the native Sicilians. The complication came about when disbanded Roman and Italian soldiers formed an enterprise to own a Sicilian city and succeeded introducing a 4th faction into the conflict and providing Rome with an excuse to intervene in Sicily (because they feared that Carthage was going to win Sicily). (3) Historians provide none of his ignorant and wholly made up 'fear and greed' motives. They simply state that the Roman state 'feared' or, more so, 'believed' that it was Carthage's intention to surround Rome and isolate them. Either Rome fought to prevent the encirclement in Siciliy or Rome would have a harder fight at some later point. Polybius is the most credible source on the matter... just read. (4) Exterminating cities was not as profound in that era. He should have been more clear that many cities received the treatment that Carthage got instead of making this seem unprecedented. I think people need to know that they are being lied to by a presenter that is either ignorant or dishonest. Don't take this seriously, it appears to only be entertainment.

@kekistanikekfrog7051

6 жыл бұрын

Marc Otac Agreed and so many modern historians will LIE in order to push the Marxist world view. Don't fall for it!!!

@ricksanchez9288

6 жыл бұрын

Marc Otac Exactly! Well said.

@HoboTango

6 жыл бұрын

Its like that for every single documentary. Ask any historian what documentary show they watch. Their answers will be none.

@chucknorris5788

6 жыл бұрын

Cite some sources on all that please. I suggest you read Mary Beard's books and publications.

@dfinlen

6 жыл бұрын

I appreciate your well thought-out and detailed commentary. Most of these documentaries are dramatized to pull in more viewers. No one would listen to, we have evidence along these lines and oyher evidence possibly that there's also x y and z. A fair discussion of the understanding does not make for good TV. Someone that is truly interested might stay to the official presentations at conferences and the research papers presented. I appreciate the intent of the documentary to interest and hold the viewer. Regardless you have added value to my understanding, thankyou.

Beautiful Tunisia 😍

@juliuscaesar3458

3 жыл бұрын

Thx sister 🤗❤️

With the power of hindsight i can say Carthage paid for it's complacency. It should of recognized Rome as a danger much earlier on & laid siege to their city before they grew to powerful.

@Charlie-ii5rr

3 жыл бұрын

Nothing changes much. Carthage's complete lack of ability to sense danger reminds me of the Republican Party in the U.S. They're too busy grubbing after money to know when danger is creeping up on them. This may be out of context, but the historical parallels are striking.

@j.a.weishaupt1748

3 жыл бұрын

*its *should HAVE *too

@HittokiriBatosai

2 жыл бұрын

Or just supported their general when he was over there causing ruckus and turning Italian provinces to his side

@francisagodi9441

2 жыл бұрын

They were the most powerful group in that region. I'm pretty sure their scouts would have made reports on the threat that Rome poses but I guess they were too drunk in their influence so they chose to underestimate them and paid fatally for it.

@Ubique2927

2 жыл бұрын

And what do you think Hannibal was doing for a couple of years!

The Romans rebuilt Carthage as a colony and she eventaully became famous as a home of Christianity's most powerful bishops until (ironically) the Bishop of Rome superceeded the Bishop of Carthage. Check it. Carthage didn't just vanish.....she was moved and the city was renamed Tunis by the Arabs.

@hannibalbarca1801

Жыл бұрын

Carthage vanished when Muslims destroyed the city after conquest in the 7th Century

@wankawanka3053

Жыл бұрын

It ain't carthage without the Carthaginians

Great educational and entertaining work here, thank you for posting this

Fire with fire. Carthage basically did a slaughter in Spain. They were conquering and destroying several Iberian tribes. One of those tribes were trade partners to the Roman republic and war followed. Hannibal showed the world Rome was mortal. Hannibal killed more people then the Romans did in Carthage. Two major wars and 1 smaller one and not to forget Hannibal aided the Seleucids in war against Rome. They destroyed the city. Which is a very normal choice for a republic of that strength and in that time.

@jason4275

5 жыл бұрын

They were both equally evil empires.

19:57 that's a lot of boats

For those who are saying that modern day Tunisia have no connection to ancient Carthage : Oumouk tangou is an ancient Tunisian tradition of invocation of the rain which was inherited from the Punic traditions . Tangou is another name of Tanit , goddess of fertility in ancient Carthage .My mother told me about it , she learned it from her mother before her : "Ommek tangou ya nse , d'aat rabi 'al shte" which means : "Oumouk tango, O women, ask God to rain" .

@zacharymccoy2418

5 жыл бұрын

Lol i know right. Blacks say that carthage and egypt were black lol. Look at the people there today they r the same

@DarkPsy

5 жыл бұрын

Moving to Germany, aquiring citizenship and being assimilated by the german culture doesn't make you german. Only your genetics make you german.

@fuzzles9246

5 жыл бұрын

@@zacharymccoy2418 well they're not black first Its hot there that your skin get darker in matter of hours under the sunlight, second Carthage same as modern Tunisia formed by settlers from all over Mediterranian sea, name it Turks Arab Spanish Italians Greek Africans. Natives like Amazigh and Berber(they're not even black), well people say Many things, without backing them.

@zacharymccoy2418

5 жыл бұрын

@@fuzzles9246 wait wait wait. I think there is a huge misunderstanding i was saying they weren't black we agree lol

@fuzzles9246

5 жыл бұрын

@@zacharymccoy2418 yeah i know, i just confirmed what you said lol

Thank you .

Brilliant stuff.

Thank you Sir for this documentary I think it's would be interested to contact Mr. Karim Mokhtar he has many truth about Carthage

I learned a lot, Thanks. Liking underdogs, I've always had a special liking for Carthage (but didn't know much about it, except Hannibal's elephants and the Phoenicians). And liked Troy, another underdog.... i liked here the first Scipio's wisdom: That Rome needed Carthage to keep it sharp, and to inspire improvements.

@jl9211

4 жыл бұрын

Rome was the underdog. Rome didn't even control all of Italy, Carthage had lands all over the Mediterranean. The Romans won Spain because the local tribes joined them against Carthage, and their army was a militia as opposed to mercenaries.

@carlcushmanhybels8159

4 жыл бұрын

@Thelondonbadger Watch the video or otherwise... E.g., the video and other investigations show that Rome produced BS anti-Carthage propaganda to self-justify Roman genocide against Carthage. Such as: the false story Carthaginians killed their babies and cooked them. Truth is Carthage was simply the main rival to Rome.

I love you timeline !

There are some glaring errors in this. The colosseum wasn't built until way after the third punic war, 216 years after to be exact. The Roman Empire wouldn't have even have been a conceivable notion to the Romans at the end of the Punic Wars either. And Hannibal had no chance of sieging Rome, he intentionally avoided sieges throughout his campaign because of that. Through skill and luck he repeatedly outwitted the Romans but had he stopped in order to siege a city Rome could bring overwhelming numbers to bear on him.

@denisshillingford5891

5 жыл бұрын

Hannibal had to Rome by the throat. Had Rome Under Siege. But back at home the ruling class had negotiated with Rome behind his back and his provision lines had been cut. If they had not negotiated a peace with Rome Hannibal would had broke through the gates of Rome. Rome did not negotiate in good faith. A year later they were off the coast of Africa ready to come ashore. they came and they killed all those who negotiated with Hannibal behind his back. They burnt down the city and salted land.

@walkinaxyl

5 жыл бұрын

Son Of Perdition The colosseum was an aqua duct

@lucasstemba

5 жыл бұрын

@@walkinaxyl lol

@lucasstemba

5 жыл бұрын

@@denisshillingford5891 "Hannibal had to Rome by the throat." Kinda "But back at home the ruling class had negotiated with Rome behind his back and his provision lines had been cut." Yes "Had Rome Under Siege." Never happened "If they had not negotiated a peace with Rome Hannibal would had broke through the gates of Rome. No, he lacked the tools necessary to ever siege Rome itself. If anything, Rome's meteoric recovery and rise after Hannibal just goes to show how little he really affected them.

@davebox588

5 жыл бұрын

@@lucasstemba I just wanted to credit Quintus Fabius Maximus Verrucosus who took the Agnomen Cuncator (delayer) for his tactic against Hannibal of attacking his supply lines and only engaging in minor skirmishing attacks. This held Hannibal back long enough for Scipio Africanus to wreak havoc in Iberia. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quintus_Fabius_Maximus_Verrucosus I understand that only something like one in ten military age Romans survived Cannae and the other two major battles (whose names escape me), so understandable that Cato the Elder was so insistent that Carthage had to be destroyed..

When did Robert Webb start narrating documentaries?

@termeownator

6 жыл бұрын

phaedrus000 Ha dude I was just thinking the same thing. Sounds exactly like him. I was imagining some weird hybrid of jez and Mark that had jez's voice and Mark's penchant for history... and this fella's face I guess

@BreadWinner330

6 жыл бұрын

lol exactly

@marcokite

5 жыл бұрын

exactly what i thought, they must be related

@billybragg2729

5 жыл бұрын

Haha..Dammit.. went through comments after implying same thing.

@liamsymes1

4 жыл бұрын

Mate i was looking for this comment 😂 he even sounds like him

Tell me this dude hates Rome without telling me he does

Hannibal at cannae 2 August 216 BC managed sourond and to slaughter over 67,000 Romans while hannibal only had about 50,000 in total. This made rome panic but when the Carthaginian fleet with supplies lost Hannibal had no choice but raid through Italy. But after a few more years Hannibal got called back home when the romans surprised Carthage with an army in africa on Carthaginian home land. But when the Roman army led by Publius Cornelius Scipio at the battle of zama 19:th of October 202 bc manged to defeat Hannibal. Hannibal got banished due to this and Carthage got forced to sign an unimaginable harsh treaty

this is all overstated

Hello, can you please tell me the name of the song at 4:40? Thank you!

wow avicii is such a great presenter

@anhedonianepiphany5588

5 жыл бұрын

_Who?!?_

@frenchartantiquesparis424

4 жыл бұрын

LOL.

@robertfulton5033

3 жыл бұрын

You think so?? I thought he was awful and seemed full of hate for people who lived almost a few thousands of years ago. This video was completely one sided and bizarrely ignored the attacks, killing and destruction of the Roman mainland by the Carthaginian army.

@LifeAdviceSite

2 жыл бұрын

Robert Fulton he said in the beginning that the history was written by the victors (Rome), and he wanted to tell the story of Carthage, so that's what he did.

@robertfulton5033

2 жыл бұрын

@@LifeAdviceSite Yeah but he completely ignores the terrible misdeeds of Carthaginian empire building while accusing the Romans of the very same thing. It's bizarre and completely biased history. Sure, tell the story of Carthage but don't pretend they were something that they were not, because they were certainly no more virtuous in their political life and military conduct than the Romans were. And it's a blatant lie to say they were.

As Carthage stood up from the ashes of the roman holocaust . Tunisian democracy will rise and shine despite all obstacles.....

Great video. This guys voice sounds just like that guy from the peep show. If you know you know

At the end of the day, the Carthaginian sociopolitical framework was no match for that of Rome.

@lonw.7016

4 жыл бұрын

AT the end of the day. Baal and Melcat

@joshuahalpern4426

4 жыл бұрын

We know about the Carthaginian culture only from Roman and Greek descriptions. Both Rome and Greece hated and envied Carthage. It is very likely that the child sacrifice cult and other horrific allegations are false. Carthaginians were first to develop sophisticated alphabet and iron manufacturing, spoke Hebrew and were very close to the other Hebrews, including the Israelites. They were probably descendants of the Dan tribe as they were originally Phoenicians. One century later, the Romans puled the same massacre to the Jews, but with less success. However, the Romans invented antisemitism against the Jews, which is alive and well to this day and beyond. Negative statements against the Carthaginians of which you know very little, is similar to gratuitous antisemitism.

@unknownvip00

4 жыл бұрын

Joshua Halpern thank you for that ignorance is truly wide spread

@rustyshackleford2719

4 жыл бұрын

@@joshuahalpern4426 There is evidence of the child sacrifice in Carthage. What a surprise, a Jew who doesn't like Rome!

@soupgod1448

4 жыл бұрын

@@joshuahalpern4426 do you have any links or proofs or are you just spreading conspiracies?

"by 300 BC Rome was punching and kicking its way to becoming a militarised state by some monstrous embryo with a destiny to fulfil straining to be born" 11:45 absolutely loved it

@boertje

5 жыл бұрын

Michael Gamba If you can't protect it you don't deserve it.

Love you Timeline