Finally an Indian guy who understand movies. thank you. hated all other Indian critics, probably getting paid by chopras and johars like.

@indersinghchauhan1116

3 жыл бұрын

Tere ko unhone kan me ake bola kya

@manoshijbiswas9494

3 жыл бұрын

@@indersinghchauhan1116 chup kar ...sahi bola usne

@indersinghchauhan1116

3 жыл бұрын

@@manoshijbiswas9494 are shant reh bat bhi samajh ayi kya likha mene

@arnavpandey3823

3 жыл бұрын

They did not like this movie!!!!!! Were they on drugs while watching it!?

@sudeshnamukhopadhyay5214

Жыл бұрын

@@arnavpandey3823 There are many great film critics who don't like TDK. It doesn't Make them dumb. (I am not talking about MCU and DCEU shills and fanboys) Movies are subjective just like art.

omg !!! who are you man ? I've never heard one of my countryman talk so seriously of a Hollywood cinema!! Most of indian multiplexed audience wouldnt find the difference between Nolans Batman and the rest of the previous and post interpreted versions of the same!! Nolans Batman Trilogy is first of all a serious cinema made by a seriously high thinking film director. nolan has clearly ventured into the pshyche a super hero, the circumstances that lead him to be one and the existential questions that he has to battle within.....Brilliant Sir Good Job... wish to hear your analysis of the last film in the trilogy

@at8485

7 жыл бұрын

SREEJAY78 k

@dipinr963

6 жыл бұрын

You are absolutely right.

@rahulgaikwad1331

6 жыл бұрын

Exactly my thought. I have never heard anyone talk so meticulously about Hollywood films like he does.

@anant8884

5 жыл бұрын

naah man... there are other countrymen of yours who think about cinema that deeply !! though this guy is dreakin' awesome !!

@jitendra-ke5lb

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah this guy deserves much respect .

Excellent work. Dark Knight is definitely one of the greatest films ever made. The Joker constantly tries to prove to Batman that the society is selfish and will not act ethically when its survival is threatened. When he declares that Batman he should reveal himself and starts killing people, the people of Gotham start condemning Batman, even when he has done so much for them. He again proves his point with Harvey Dent, who leaves his noble intentions behind and starts seeking personal revenge. Batman is the only one who stands by his own principles and doesn't abandon them even when he suffers personal loss (Rachel's death). Joker admits this in the end when he says "You truly are incorruptible".

@RalphLindsen

8 жыл бұрын

They always say these movies are 'dark and gritty'. Well the tone and the visuals are, but it's core message is actually super optimistic about human nature. An optimism I don't share, but do admire.

@somnathdas8945

5 жыл бұрын

Amazing analysis buddy!

@georgeguja3192

4 жыл бұрын

If you want to another amazing analysis (in my opinion the best fior this movie) check the video made by Rant and Bollox believe it's amazing

@abhishekphand4789

4 жыл бұрын

Yes. But even people of Gotham and criminals don't blast each other proving that when chips are down people don't kill eachother. They are inherently good

@errwhattheflip

Жыл бұрын

@@RalphLindsen It's a bit more complex than just optimistic. It shows two sides to human nature. The negative action to people falling under harsh circumstances, and the other side of people being able to do good

Sometimes a mistake is so overt....it's covert!

@flyingufo9255

8 жыл бұрын

you must do an analysing vdeo of the wolf of the wall street!!

@rahulray9983

6 жыл бұрын

One mistake that you made was that ideas like the Noble Lie is purely Western Concept......Chanakya never discussed anything like the Noble Lie.... Here in this land it was always about Dharma and Adharma which is a completely different concept than that the Western thinker have had......

@vrushg

3 жыл бұрын

bring this guy back...we need mkre content

@arnavpandey3823

3 жыл бұрын

I love this movie. And the entire trilogy. The dark knight is my favourite movie of all time.

great video keep making more content you are the desi nerd we need right now

@kennybother8583

7 жыл бұрын

but is he the one we deserve?

@Ren-ls4yl

7 жыл бұрын

Kenny Bother 😂

@SirajRaval

7 жыл бұрын

lmaooooo

0:38 did you say "Fan boy Boners"? ..hahahah....Creative description.

@mayank6763

5 жыл бұрын

yeah cracked me up

@iamyourboss7495

3 жыл бұрын

😂

you, sir, are underrated. please keep up the good work.

Wow, I've seen a lot of the dark knight movie analysis and I must say without a doubt this movie has very deep philosophical meanings. Many KZread videos about the dark knight has different opinions about the theme of the movie and I think none of theme are wrong. Every time I watch a video about TDK I learn more about the movie, each time there is something new which makes me love the movie more. And I especially love this explanation from your point of view, you seems to have a deep understanding of the movie. Thanks

@siddharthakvr5154

4 жыл бұрын

Check out TDK by movies with Mikey...you'll gain even more insight

The ending lines in this movie narrated by GARY OLDMAN, the perfect dialogue delivery, still gives me goosebumps ... A movie where the villian wins, hero taking the blame and escaping into darkness.... "Because we have to chase him. Because he's the hero Gotham deserves, but not the one it needs right now, so we'll hunt him. Because he can take it, because he's not a hero. He's a silent guardian, a watchful protector, a Dark Knight."

Plot structure, characters, themes - this is one of my favorite movies and you have done a most excellent analysis of it. Thank you!

Honestly, I've seen this movie dozens of times, but you brought up things I had never noticed. Great analysis. :) Subscribed!

Amazing video, I have seen and read many analysis of The Dark Knight and this (very interesting) aspect has always been, in my opinion, the most overlooked until this video :D

7:49 "They are great because they hold a mirror upto ourselves..." - smartly placed shot from Taxi Driver. Eh!

he is forgetting about the Locke vs Hobbe theory prevalent in the film, people are animals and monsters at heart, when the chips are down, civilized people eat each other, therfore they need a powerful leader vs. Batman's thoery that people are good at heart

@TheGeorgeD13

7 жыл бұрын

Honestly, neither idea is wrong. I think it's more dependent on the individuals rather than the whole of society. It just so happens that the people on those boats chose to not kill the people on the other boat because more good people outweighed bad people. And I think that's true in the real world. The good vastly outnumber the bad. The bad just are good at creating chaos and anarchy and ruining it for everybody else.

@tylerasmith52

3 жыл бұрын

that's more Hobbe (life in nature is nasty/brutish/short) vs. Rosseau (romantic, live in the woods, private property is bad)

Man, this is wonderful. As a cinema lover, 7:35 to 8:05 gave me goosebumps.

@AbhijeetIngle945

4 жыл бұрын

Right

@krissathwara6709

3 жыл бұрын

Same man

@yaseerbeig8611

3 ай бұрын

Same

I don't really post on youtube vids but this is a great fucking review (with some wise words from he master at the end there); nice work!

Great job mate. Climax monolog and Montague gave me goosebumps. Thank u for that. I wish u could do more videos specifically on film cinematography, editing and sound.

This is such a fresh, and insightful take on the Dark Knight. Thoroughly enjoyed it. You're creating awesome content, dude. Keep at it.

"Great movies tell one story at a time, while exploring the truth of a lifetime". Very good video! Thank you for inspiring me and helping me with my writing. Keep up the good work, sir!

Probably the best youtube channel I have come across with the most unique style of depicting cinema. Keep up the good work and keep creating brilliant content!

Another great essay. Glad you sorted the audio this time :)

I just wanna comment that I made a video on Visual literacy (more of a ppt than video) for my college project, and I copied the last words of Martin Scorcese in this video as my last words in my project. Its my favourite video I have watched this video 8 times by now, thanks Vinit.

Loved how topics which contain this much excitement and passion are also explained in such a calm and composed tone. More than informative, this video is inspiring ( to explore the deeper part of cinema) and relaxing.

Love that Martin Scorsese quote at the end gosh that's why he is one of my favorite directors!!!

You made me want to go and read Republic again without the pressure of academics.

I really loved your work. The ideas you used to explain and content you choose to elaborate are both marvelous. Keep up the great work.

Please keep on posting such great videos in the future as well. Your work inspires a lot of people.

great video .. the Dark Knight is indeed a black comedy of today's society.. Nolan is a metaphor director

Wow....the attention to details you put in these videos is unbelievable.....really great

Vinit, I discovered your videos recently. Until now I haven't been used to the idea of a video discussing cinema-beyond just being a Hindi/English movie. Your content is refreshing. I'm loving it. Keep them coming!

I must say that you are really doing a good job. It makes more sense when you said that great movies not only have a great story telling but it delves itself into questioning the real rudimentary values. Kudos to the work you are doing.

I have to say brother, you are great in narration. Great hold on language and words. You are like making a documentary in every video. your work I admire. And definitely recommend others to watch.

Vinit you will be missed thanks for changing the way i look at this wonderful artform

Your voice and your content go together so well

You forgot to mention, great scores! :) Super underrated channel!

good work man . best review and analysis so far ,imdb and metacritic are chai pani kam

All time, you conceptualize the best in the cinema. Great analysis. Go ahead. No suggestions. You are going great. Thank you for bringing this to us. Well done.

You my sir have my respect. I appreciate the perspective you provide in your videos. It’s always something new, at least for me

I love movies and in recent time this channel is the best one I come across thanks man

Man, you're genius. I am constantly watching your views on movies and they all are great. Hope for more. 🙏😇

Vinit Bro....loved the video and your explaination !!

I love listening to you analyzing the movies.....lot to learn. Keep doing your revolutionary work.

My goodness, u seem to changed the way movies must be watched. Very inspiring n thought provoking !!

Such deep insights into the film making process and its impact... I hv stumbled upon something sublime.. Thank you again

great video... and you've given me a whole another level to appreciate this movie on, for which I thank you...

Great work.....Keep doing it and enlightening us

Brother, I thought I have different perspective of watching a cinema and interpreting it. But u are at a totally different dimension. How u connected cinema with Socrates's phillosophy is awestruck. Excellence at the par. Have seen ur other videos. Simply superb analysis. Keep up the good work.

Great vid. The theme is common to Nolan's Memento - where the protagonist lies to himself to maintain order in his life.

truly great work! Very thoughtful

That was an absolutely excellent analysis, thank you!

This was so great, I absolutely love your work Sir. As you have done some work on war movies and at the end of the movie I could see 'the lives of others' can you please do a video on "Das Boot" and "the lives of others" as well.

Great review on a Great movie.. I enjoyed it thoroughly.. Well I noticed a footage from the movie 'The Mirror' (1975) just after 'Citizen Kane' (1941) footage and it was not mentioned in the footage credits at the end. So I thought to bring it up to you.

@CinemaBeyondEntertainment

8 жыл бұрын

+Zed Zoheb Thank you Zed! My bad.

Awesome video and as well ur words , both are really powerful!!

Great video my friend, very powerful at the end.

I like how you mix psychology and philosophy in your videos. It helps to understand life beyond meaning.

6:24 That jab at Liverpool is priceless.

Gem of an analysis.. Earned yourselves a new subscriber!!

this is the best analysis I've ever seen. thanks Vinit. god bless.

Why didn't i find this channel before?? Subbed :-). Great Channel,buddy

If you guys don't know, Joker telling stories of his scars is iconic because it authenticate this version of joker. Joker likes to tell his fable tales of oppression and domestic violence to gain sympathy. That is how he befriends harley he brainwashes her and uses her for his own benefit. Harley is so gullible that she thinks he loves her but she is a mere toy to him, a distraction from his special someone.

Bhai bhai bhai bhai, itni wisdom le doobegi. You're the man we don't deserve but the one we need!

Man u have knowledge. Keep up the good work

I bet most of our Indians will not understand the dept of your videos and their contents. You deserve more .

Another gem from you, keep it up guys

The music by Hans Zimmer always touched heart. And the Gotham itself is a character in this movie at the end, joker tries to prove that the character of Gotham is that people will kill eachother when chips are down but he is proven wrong in the end.

Hey! Just love love your analysis, observations and the depth of your knowledge. Would you do ‘ Shawshank Redemption ‘ !??

its beautiful to see how you analysed the movie's philosophy, from Plato to Nolan!

And let's not forget about the ARG (Alternate Reality Game) that Noland made to promote The Dark Knight, he set up hundreds of websites, had gatherings and even delivered Gotham newspapers to the candidates with people trying to solve the whole thing while being identified as Joker's Henchmen, and others helping the police. Nolan made this ARG not only to promote the film but also to tell the story that takes place before the dark knight.

Hi, very interesting analysis. Are not you gonna make more of them??? One about Burning from Lee Chang Dong would be very interesting to hear. Thanks for sharing

Your work is God level! Respect!

Wow, you deserve way more subscribers. Great job.

Oh man! Your videos are so amazing

I don't ever comment on KZread videos, but I gotta say this: you've got yourself a fan. Looking forward to your future videos.

Epic video, I don't understand why this video has not that many views.

oh man you are great at your work .Never seen anyone better than you from india explaining hollywood like this.

Respect and love...great great analysis!!

My god this felt something else....don't stop

Have found this channel It's a treasure in the garbage of so many you tibe channels

Excellent analysis, you’ve earned a subscriber.

i would watch a film narrated and directed by you. Keep up the good work brother.

Dude who writes your stuff...They are amazing..!!!

You Vinit Sir....are a teacher...:)....true works of beauty and teaching combined, your videos are....thank you for these videos...:)

This is really smart and great, thanks for making this :D

superb as always....!! ur v talented....

You match up to Wisecrack man! Amazing work!

You added the masterpiece Zerkalo (Mirror) by Tarkovsky in the video but didn't add in the list in the end. I know you must have forgotten it.

Great analysis! Thank you!🍀

That video was awesome, dude

No one but you would have thought of the analogy of 'The Republic' in TDK! :D I have read the book "art and making of dark Knight triology"... I don't remember any mention of it. I always find some similarity between TDK and Rashomon though.. " Everyone's version of truth (& lies) and meaning towards achieving harmony" You think they both are talking about human condition? Kurosawa could be a good topic for a video I guess! Great job though! good one!

@CinemaBeyondEntertainment

8 жыл бұрын

+Nachiket Dhavalikar Yes I have plans to make an essay on Kurosawa as he is one of my favorites. And as per Rashoman and TDK, although the theme is ambiguity in presentation of truth/lies, in Rashoman, characters are constructing a version of truth necessarily for themselves whereas in TDK, Batman is constructing it only for others. People close to him, friends, foes, and we the audience are completely aware of the reality. But in case of Rashomon, I still have no idea who is speaking the truth.

@nachiketdhavalikar4544

8 жыл бұрын

+Cinema Beyond Entertainment : that is what he's trying to tell I guess... in Rashomon... "there's nothing like an absolute truth"!

@devarya8963

7 жыл бұрын

+Cinema Beyond Entertainment rashoman and tdk cannot be compared... One is pure classic and ahead of its time... And one is great, though overrated piece of work... For me nolan is still quite a mediocre director as compared to other giants in world cinema and even Hollywood... His movies are generally pseudo intellectual and pretentious. At least his last two movies, interstellar and tdkr are really weak and extremely overhyped. The Prestige also failed to impress me. Inception, tdk were good, but will some be forgotten. His only interesting movie was memento which also was somewhat boring. He weakness according to me, as a filmmaker is that he tells nearly everything verbally, but isn't able to create the atmosphere to communicate with out actually having to. And finally he casts really great actors.. But isn't able to derive best from them. Except for heath legder(which was his individual work)... None of the other actors have given even near memorable performance. Well this all makes sense as he never received big awards for his work. And i don't think he is ever going to get anything big for his direction.

@devarya8963

7 жыл бұрын

+Cinema Beyond Entertainment and there are also some serious problems with tdk

@CinemaBeyondEntertainment

7 жыл бұрын

+Dev Arya Of course there are... If I start nitpicking, then I'll end up with a longer video than this one... But I liked the underlying thought which I thought was worth sharing.

Wow your a genius I love your work man Amazing

salute to you man! what a profound knowledge you have got about cinema!

Loved the fact that you highlighted the contradiction of Batman's lie, wherein he ignores the evidence of people's moral inclinations and decides to tell them the authoritarian noble lie. Very interesting point and a great analysis overall.

i was instantly mesmerized dude .... thought i knew much about films ... turns out there is more to it ..... hats off for killing my ego !! you just made a fan !!

Great work man

last moment ghoose bumps well used of music and powerfull explanation

Just loved your analysis

These were the best 9 minutes of my life

The Dark Socrates, great video

your work is awesome brother...please do a analysis on the prestige movie