Cyril and Methodius: invent a script specifically designed for slavic languages *Poland: I'll pretend I didn't see it*

@rl55555

3 жыл бұрын

They are Catholics... Maybe that's the reason.

@stefantsarev4442

3 жыл бұрын

@@rl55555 They are. In Modern Europe it can be clearly seen which of the Slavic peoples are Catholic and which are Orthodox - the Orthodox ones adopted the Church Slavonic in the churches, monasteries and the Royal courts as the main liturgical and diplomatic language. With the development of the different peoples came the differences in the languages, which were strongly influenced by the unique dialects of the common folk. The Western Slavic peoples fell under the rule of the Polish and the Austrian empires, which were both Roman Catholic and thus required the gospel to be spoken in Latin. Even after the fall of the Polish Empire the Polish people remained Catholic. Together with the Czechs, Slovaks, Slovenians and Croatians, they use the Latin Alphabet, this indicating their Catholic heritage. There are two deviations of the rule, one of which is an even better evidence of the use of language and religion. The first is Romania, an Orthodox country. Until 1865, the Romanians used the Cyrillic alphabet and the Gospel was spoken in Church Slavonic. However, since then they adopted the Latin alphabet and changed the gospel language into Romanian. The reason is simple - Romanian is a Romantic, not a Slavonic language, and thus the Latin alphabet was adopted to adhere to the Romantic past. The second is a small Bulgarian community in an area between modern day Serbia, Romania and Hungary. In the past it was part of the Austrian and later - Austrian-Hungarian Empire. The area is called Banat. The Banat Bulgarians settled in at the end of the 17th century (after the Chiprovtsi Uprising), became Catholics and adopted the Latin Alphabet. They still use it today and thus Bulgarian actually has two standards - in Cyrillic, which is the main one, and in Latin, used by the Banat Bulgarians.

@rl55555

3 жыл бұрын

@@stefantsarev4442 interesting...

@kalinkalki

2 жыл бұрын

Replacing old misconceptions with new misunderstandings. Poland will be followed by Slovak, Czechs and Croats will remind everyone that Glagolitic script was brought to them by St. Jerom of Stridon few centuries before the time of the two saints mentioned above.

@davidfreeman3083

2 жыл бұрын

Well actually Cyrillic is easier to use to write many other European languages as well. For example, Deutsch which is how Germans call themselves & their language, can be written with only 4 letters with Slavic Cyrillic. (The tsch in German takes the ch sound, which is only ONE letter in Cyrillic). Not to mention Cyrillic is designed to be a little more flexible, so if Germans adopted Cyrillic for their language, it's very likely that they can come up with a letter to represent the eu sound (sounding like oi in oil). Which means they can write this word with only, THREE letters instead of SEVEN as of now. Also, many Italian words can be written in Cyrillic easily also. And it'll be a lot less confusing & a lot more straightforward. Try these: pizza, cacio, spaghetti, gnocchi, Parmigiano Reggiano, prosciutto, etc.. (Hard & soft Cs, hard & soft Gs, z stands for ts, using of double consonants, etc. NONE of that is necessary in Cyrillic alphabet, oh and what's the deal with sci to represent what could be represented with a single letter in Cyrillic?). So that's why, politics aside, I just checked, Romanian can be written perfectly in Cyrillic alphabet. The Moldovan as well as the pre-independence (from Ottomans) Romanian Cyrillic alphabets actually make sense. Politics aside of course. And in fact Romanian was first written in Cyrillic too. It wasn't until the 19th century when Romanian nationalists decided to go with Latin alphabets and base mainly on Italian orthography. Although phonology wise it's also pretty smooth of an adaptation (Latin letter based Romanian), by creating a couple of new letters (one for sh and another for ts, by adding a 'tail' to s & t respectively), and using the soft-hard C-G which can be a little confusing. And for other languages, like English & French. Too many vowels? Creating new vowels and 'long semi vowels'? (Like English u in use and French oi which pronounces wa). You know you're not alone right? Cyrillic alphabets have the capacity to represent those sounds with a new, distinct alphabet. (There's one for the /ju/ sound, and for the /wa/ you can create one if you want to. That's how Cyrillic alphabet is meant to be used initially at least). Also because of that the same letters of Cyrillic alphabets sound more or less the same across the languages, because there's not a need to change the spelling rules across languages when you can create new ones. My point here is, hence, adaptation of Cyrillic should not be looked at from a plain Slavic or not perspective. Yes they were created by Slavic ppl but the additional sounds they can represent already exists in many other languages, such as Romance and Germanic languages, or even modern Greek. But only that the classic Latin itself doesn't have those sounds (like sh, ch, zh, j/dzh, etc.) hence that's why Latin script itself needs to be modified a lot to accommodate those sounds (and it's not only Polish or Czech, I mean German, Italian, French, etc. too like I mentioned before). And I think because of the influence of the Roman empire & the catholic church, and the status of CLASSICAL Latin as an 'official' language across the Western Europe (including Poland & Bohemia, etc.) people there are more or less refrained from dramatically altering Latin script such as creating brand new letters. As it might be seen as 'lower class' I guess. And that's how you end up with all those diatrics & diagraphs and 'special letters' that look like and unlike any Latin letter at the same time in not only Polish & Czech, but all other Western European languages as well, as well as different sounds of the same letters across languages, like j, c, x, most of the vowels, as well as even g, z, y, h, etc.

Extremely modestly designed and well-developed art style. Perhaps one of the most impressive historical semiotics introduction video I've seen in a while. Magnificent!

@ElektrickMe

4 жыл бұрын

Thank you!

Human stories can't be told without language but definitely can be told without script

Прекрасно видео! ❤️🇧🇬

@renukajadhav6182

Жыл бұрын

Cyrillis

@Mikhayl_S_V

6 ай бұрын

​@@renukajadhav6182О май год

This was very well made, nice work

@ElektrickMe

5 жыл бұрын

Thank you.

Great project!

Cyrillic and Old Church Bulgarian language (called Old Church Slavonic as well), from which Russian language had been developed, are the most successful project ever of The First Bulgarian Empire and Bulgarians! Of course, for being honest, we don't have to forget that the contemporary script of Cyrillic is developed first, after a reform made by The Russians during the Peter The great in 18 century, and after that in the beginning of the 20 century after the communist revolution!

@mihailnikoloff2554

4 жыл бұрын

Russians only invented the letter Я which is backwards R.

@mihailnikoloff2554

3 жыл бұрын

@Proton Russia flourished with our cultural achievements.

@alek6208

2 жыл бұрын

Slavs, bulgars are just Slavs like other Slav countries.

Proud Bulgaria 🇧🇬💪

Thank you to Bulgaria and Macedonia for creating such a wonderful script! Cyrillic, especially Early Cyrillic, has been my favourite writing system for about a year. Its history, its letters, the message in their names and especially its diversity of ancestor scripts really show that Kliment (and whoever helped him) was thinking outside the box when making the alphabet. - Rodrigo Santos, from Portugal

@oggimihaylov9609

10 күн бұрын

Mecedonia???

Thumbs up guys :) The video looks cool!

@user-do7vg6nw6d

3 жыл бұрын

But its not Bulgarian

@VELIkiq8

3 жыл бұрын

What is not Bulgarian?

@user-do7vg6nw6d

3 жыл бұрын

@@VELIkiq8 Glagolica

@claus1516

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-do7vg6nw6d Do you understand english? Because there was no such statement in the video. The Glagolitic script is not bulgarian, but the Cyrillc is.

Много яко !

@yakublmaoo8468

3 жыл бұрын

Да нали ?

@jordanmaclin8754

2 жыл бұрын

съгласен съм

Все таки кириллица очень удобный алфавит, я думаю, что, к примеру, польский язык был бы более прост в написании, если бы они изначально выбрали кириллицу, и писали звуки "sz" и "szcz", как "Ч" и "Щ"

@ball_gum

3 жыл бұрын

Sz это Ш

@Askhat08

2 жыл бұрын

Szcz - это ШТШ.

@snezhanamilanova4382

2 жыл бұрын

Конечно, когда то поляки писали именно ползуясь болгарской алфавит, но как покинули православие и приняли католизицъм, приняли и латнискую авфавит.

@parapiskolojirehberi4791

Жыл бұрын

szcz шч

@Vatras888

Жыл бұрын

@@snezhanamilanova4382 Poland was never orthkdox in history.

Keep up the good work!

an example of youtube failing a terribly deserving channel.

Love from Greece ❤️

Very good 👍

Now it's very explainable. Thanx. :)

great, thank you

I started watching for the content but got distracted by the audio quality - if this is text-to-speech, which software did you use?

Beautiful

bro made the best cyrillic edit and thought we wouldnt notice🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Nice one Cyril

Great video

Latin is full of inconsistency because of the palatalisation of c and g and the i that turned become j and y in Spanish. Hence, you can see that inconsistency in English "c" can be pronounced similar to "k" or "s". "Z" can be pronounced from "z" to "ts". "C" can be pronounced as "k", "ts", "ch" and "j" in various language and many more. While with Cyrillic, you have "ц" will be the same letter for "ts" in any language that uses it and so on. That's the reality, Cyrillic alphabet is the best pair for Slavic languages because it supports consonant weakening that happens largely in Slavic languages. That's why some Slavic languages like Slovak and Czech, they have very much letter, while if they use Cyrillic the number of the letter can be reduced, for example, the letter "d" and "ď " can be written as "д" and "дь" using Cyrillic, the same for "t" and "ť " can be written as "т" and "ть" using Cyrillic. But, this is all because of the religious issue in the past

@navneetshyam1335

8 ай бұрын

You are right, I suggest all slavic languages need to be written in Cyrillic.

Me encantó.-Comienzo a estudiar cirílico.-

@navneetshyam1335

8 ай бұрын

Where are you now? Did you learn the Cyrillic script and any slavic language?

This is actually my favorite alphabet so far.

The brothers only unify church texts and the church canon! The Bulgarian language and alphabet are much older!

Bulgaria owns the Ciliric but we let the other slavs to use it .

@Militos238

2 жыл бұрын

Not really, Greeks made it for u.

@debnadaebna9981

2 жыл бұрын

@@Militos238 Not really, there is a prototype and similarity in Linear A, B and Elinian letters, but no ""Greeks" ever invented any alphabet... It's made by Thraco-Pelasgians and Phoenicians. Also the first Greek grammar was written by Dionysius the Thracian ... What is now modern Greeks have no connection to any Thracians, only the Bulgarians does. Even genetics has proven that.

@Militos238

2 жыл бұрын

@@debnadaebna9981 don't make me go book mode and prove u we stuff u should be learning at school. Grow up

@debnadaebna9981

2 жыл бұрын

@@Militos238 Kid, please... What I've said is written in the historical sources, don't think Wikipedia will help you...

@Militos238

2 жыл бұрын

@@debnadaebna9981 nah I jsut checked wiki so... U rlly have to back off. Ur just embarrassing

Someone please tell me that this video is 100% historically accurate. Thanks in advance.

@iamtedski

3 жыл бұрын

I don't really think there is such thing as 100% accuracy when speaking about history, but I will say that this is 95% :), there is more info in Wikipedia, and even more if you read Bulgarian

@gonzalez6073

3 жыл бұрын

Teodor Valov большое спасибо!!

@user-do7vg6nw6d

3 жыл бұрын

Hahaha its not

@user-do7vg6nw6d

3 жыл бұрын

Everyone agrees they werent Bulgarian

@michomarinoff5299

3 жыл бұрын

IT IS NOT. Kiril and Metodi were from Solun ( part of Macedonia at that time ) - Today's Thessaloniki ( Part of Greece in present day). That makes them born as Macedonian. St Kliment, who made the Cyrillic and gave it the name by his Teacher ( Kiril) is from Ohrid, Macedonian town ( at that time and today). However, all 4 were traveling trough the Slavic countries in order to translate church books to a language understandable for all Slavic People, but the origin ( start) was from Macedonia.

рог Isтra юок ла тот. Love to everyone of every language that uses the Cyrillic alphabet

Let's be honest here. Anything that allows you to include Russia on a map makes it look widespread even though 90% of Russian area is VERY sparsely populated.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

But the number of people is close to the population of the USA. It isn't small. But the teritory of Russia is no brainer if you know geography.

@user-vz2fj4wq7d

2 ай бұрын

​@@vasil.kamdzhalovthe number of people in Russia isn't even close to the US's population

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 ай бұрын

Yes, it is a mistake. Was talking about the whole sum, not just Russians.@@user-vz2fj4wq7d

why are you so underrated

What music is in the first minutes?

I love the video. Who made it?

@ElektrickMe

4 жыл бұрын

Thank You. We (www.elektrick.me) made it.

@joaoribauesteves8466

4 жыл бұрын

@@ElektrickMe you should do other animated stuff like this

Руснаците да слушат не да говорят че била тяхна азбука...

@kaloyantsonev4903

4 жыл бұрын

Те не разбират английски

@500mandarin

4 жыл бұрын

Никто не говорит что кириллицу придумали русские. Мне с детского сада рассказывали про святых Кирилла и Мефодия, и о том что они были подданными Болгарии.

@godzilko

4 жыл бұрын

Да,но много твои сънародници не знаят.

@500mandarin

4 жыл бұрын

@@godzilko и какая вам разница от этого? Никто не упоминал их, вы сами пришли и написали о том, какие Русские плохие, нашу азбуку себе забрали.

@Kris-rj9wc

4 жыл бұрын

@@500mandarin Not only are you wrong, you are stupid

It's original intent was for slavic languages, now it is being used in not just Slavic Languages but also Turkic Languages

Thank you from Russia! 🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺

This isn't named for the same cyril that had hypatia murdered right?

@vasil.kamdzhalov

Жыл бұрын

No, that would be around 500 years off, if Wikipedia is correct when writing Hypatia.

@priestkingskeptic

Жыл бұрын

dumb dumber dumbest

As a bosnian i can say this is corekt for rhe most part

@dayanbalevski4446

3 жыл бұрын

If you could enlighten us with which part is not correct?

@JustSlav98

3 жыл бұрын

Everything is correct and when you google it you can see that

@southamptonfan3460

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you very much ! As a Bulgarian it makes me happy that there is Yugoslavs that acc know the truth about the cyrilic. Happy we recognised Bosna as a independent state first !

@alek6208

2 жыл бұрын

@@southamptonfan3460 Yes Cyrillic is Bulgarian although the two brothers were not, they were Slavs. The most ancient writing system is from Vinca culture (currently) that spread across Serbia and west part of Bulgaria. I don’t think it’s fair to call it Serbian or Bulgarian, we’re the same kind.

@southamptonfan3460

2 жыл бұрын

@@alek6208 seeing you don’t claim other things from us like our “mongol” dna as you lot claim then you don’t claim cyrilic . It’s our history get your own . And the cyrilic was created 30 years after Cyril and metodi died. St naum was bukgarian

Много лепо! Ово би требало да нас учитељи уче.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

Правилно! Благодаря за коментара.

@southamptonfan3460

2 жыл бұрын

Bravo momche ! Istinski slavianen si !

@HeroManNick132

2 жыл бұрын

@@southamptonfan3460 Баси кирилицата няма що...

@southamptonfan3460

2 жыл бұрын

@@HeroManNick132 кой те назначи като “интернет полиция “ да питам брат 😅

Our big brains? Really?

T3rima kasih k@ka

Background music too loud

I have the old/early cyrillic keyboard from gboard

Big ups Bulgaria

And Never forget: Russian alphabet is like American language, it simply doesn't exist.

@Eridelm

2 жыл бұрын

Okay, you inmplying that all people using Cyrillic script can without any learning get into Russian letters? This comparison is surreal.

@user-hx2xl2km2e

2 жыл бұрын

@@Eridelm There are no russian letters. This is what I meant and what you failed to understand. Just like there are no spanish letters. There are Roman or Latin letters, there are Bulgarian letters.

@Nothing_serious

11 ай бұрын

@@user-hx2xl2km2e By your logic, there are no Greek or Latin alphabet because Latin was derived from Greek which itself is derived from Cuneiform. There were only four civilizations in history that independently created the idea of writing. The others just copied them.

@__Man__

8 ай бұрын

@@Nothing_serious not really, when you start modify the form for then it becomes a different alphabet. That is an arbitrary border of it.

To be fair, only Soviet Union countries uses Cyrillic , other than few Balkan countries.

@noelxlk

4 ай бұрын

the second part of your comment contradicted the first one

🇧🇬

Some people write Д as "D"

Why Russian use this alphabet?

@JustSlav98

4 жыл бұрын

Because they didnt have an alphabet and bulgarians gave it to them

@user-pl3zh8lu3i

4 жыл бұрын

@@JustSlav98 Wrong

@JustSlav98

4 жыл бұрын

@@user-pl3zh8lu3i You serbians also use the bulgarian letters so dont cry

@user-pl3zh8lu3i

4 жыл бұрын

@@JustSlav98 No, we use Vincian letters! Bulgarians didnt made Cyrilic alphabeth! It was made in todays Bulgaria but it was not made by Bulgarians!

@JustSlav98

4 жыл бұрын

Лука СРБ are you fucking stupid? In that video it explains who created it

From as far as bulgaria to mongolia cyrillic is used

What makes us human? Is it because of our big brains Lmfaooo

@lauragraves4342

3 жыл бұрын

If that's the case, I'd have to sadly count myself out of the human race. 🤔

@reisu4748

3 жыл бұрын

@@lauragraves4342 we must be Martian then

@lauragraves4342

3 жыл бұрын

@@reisu4748 yep. 😆

Over 300 000 000 people in europe are using the alphabet created by the BULGARIANS - Naum, Kliment and Angelarii. BULGARIA gave these letteres and not only. Bulgarians have fought against mongols, arabs, muslims, crusades, byzantium, otomans, greeks, english, french, russians, romanian, serbian and we are still here, small but still here from 681 till now 1340 years officialy old. Put this in your brains 1340 years officialy old and still existing. There is no country in Europe oldest than Bulgaria.

So the Cyrillic just appeared out of nothing?

@JustSlav98

7 ай бұрын

Didn’t the video explain how it appeared 😂 i also got a book about Cyrillic ( german one because i live in germany) and it explains the same as in the video

@huskytail

7 ай бұрын

@@JustSlav98 oh nice, so explain when, where and who created the Cyrillic 😋

@JustSlav98

7 ай бұрын

@@huskytail did you read my comment 😂 i said it explains it in my book the same way as in the video so i can 100% assure you that it’s correct😂 . Also i googled and google said the same

@huskytail

7 ай бұрын

@@JustSlav98 I read it very well, you don't understand what I'm asking of you it seems 😆. Just repeat what's written in your book and this video and we will see together how that explains the creation of the Cyrillic in comparison to the actual facts. Is it clear now?

@JustSlav98

7 ай бұрын

@@huskytail What do you mean in comparison with the actual facts when those are the actual facts? If they weren’t, they wouldn’t been written all over books, the internet and also studied in school. If you got any other facts i want you to prove it by sending either a link where i can read them or a page of a book. I don’t listen to people who spread „facts“ and don’t send proof to those „facts“ because everyone can rewrite history how they want, but the real history stays.

А за глаголицата нещо казаха ли? Много преди Кирил и Методий сме имали писменост и култура!

@Kris-rj9wc

4 жыл бұрын

Половината от видеото е за глсголицата

@user-ut4uj2vk7h

2 жыл бұрын

За съжаление всичко е изгубено..Всички гледат да ни мачкат от всякъде,гледам в коментарите как се набляга на това че гърци са писали нашата азбука,и че ползват гръцката азбука за да напишат Кирилицата...

@kalimancheto

2 жыл бұрын

Не е вярно, преди Кирил и Методий се е писало само на гръцки и с някаква форма на руническа писменост! Пък и да не си мислите, че повечето хора през Средновековието са могли да пишат? Писмеността е създадена за административна комуникация в управлението. Тъй като в България до 9 в. се е писало основно на гръцки, глаголицата когато е внесена е била решение за писане на славянски, но е била доста неудобна за писане, та най-вероятно затова княз Борис е помолил Наум и Климент да сложат по-познатите гръцки букви на мястото на глаголическите. Винаги е имало писменост култура - няма спор; но наистина кирилицата е дала огромен тласък на развитието на българската култура.

so cyrillic is created with help of ogur runic/chuvash?

@JustSlav98

4 жыл бұрын

Merke Tarif what are you saying?

@Avrionov

4 жыл бұрын

No, as the Chuvash people were never Bulgar and never wil be, while the Turkic hypothesis is outdated by about 70yrs. Your implication is wrong.

@mihailnikoloff2554

4 жыл бұрын

cyrillic was created for the bulgarian state and people

@debnadaebna9981

2 жыл бұрын

I don't understand what any "chuvash" have to do with Bulgarians?! Neither in history, neither in language, neither in genetics there is any connection with Bulgarian ppl (neither Proto-Bulgarians)...

used this for fortnite

Почему Кирилл произносится как Сирилл?😳

@vasil.kamdzhalov

Жыл бұрын

Латински им работи, така са решили.

@TheOzumat

Жыл бұрын

The Latin letter C can be read as K or S, and for some reason they decided it's S in Cyril, even though it's actually K, from the Greek Κύριλλος. Whoever decided to use C in the transliteration made a mistake which confused millions of people.

@NikeBG

Жыл бұрын

For the same reason that, in English, "Caesar" is pronounced as Сийзар rather than Кайсар.

Много хубаво направено, но го направете и на български език.

@emilaltanov7807

4 жыл бұрын

It was supposed to be for people that are not bulgarian and yes i am bulgarian im just writing in english to trigger you

@debnadaebna9981

2 жыл бұрын

@@emilaltanov7807 Toй пише " И НА български", с което най-вероятно иска да каже още едно такова видео, но на български. Нема к'во да ми се "тригърваш"...

@emilaltanov7807

2 жыл бұрын

@@debnadaebna9981 who tf asked

The Russian Title is a legit tounge twister

@Oniontowner

Жыл бұрын

It's not Russian

@JustSlav98

7 ай бұрын

It’s Bulgarian.. existed before russian and russian was based on Bulgarian

И това видео отново не може да се намери никъде в инстаграм, за да може човек да го сподели.

@VJregneva

2 жыл бұрын

Може да споделите това, то е нещо като преведена и доразвита версия на това видео. ;) fb.watch/dcMAnWrLNf/ пак на същите автори.

Напишано на кирилица изгледа многу поубаво, не знам зашто моите сонародници претпочитаат да пишуваат на латиница.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

"Модерно" и западно предполагам. Не виждам смисъл всичко да е уеднаквено.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

@@monikastojanovska9654 Съгласен съм с това, тие неща ще ги унищожат, но латиницата в държавите ви не са от скоро и до известно време всеки искаше в Италия, Франция, Германия и така нататък.

@HeroManNick132

2 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov Очевидно е, че заради сърбите, с тяхната измислена латиница! Те гледат колкото повече да са по-близо до тях и по-далече от нас.

Кирилицата не е във Босна и Херцеговина, Узбекистан, Туркменистан.

@BulgarGeography

10 ай бұрын

ТЯ Е СЪЩО ВЪВ ТАДЖИКИСТАН

14 English letters in Cyrillic C(s) Y(u) 3(z) 4(ch) Q(f) P(r) B(v) R(ya) S(dz) H(n) X(kh) 61(y) W(sh) F(gh)

Failed to mention Romania, although a latin language, also used Cyrillic for many years.

АБВ

Польска цицрилица

Geliefde Liefde has a cult of accounts spamming around Bulgarian Videos like "Learn the Cyrillic alphabet in one Video". Under the name Dove and oldest alphabets under the name Grace he deleted. This troll is obsessed and doesn't provide actual facts, just states website titles and says go read it. He is contradicting himself and a liar about the Bulgaria culture, language and Cyrillic alphabet.

@HeroManNick132

2 жыл бұрын

Той е шведски трол! Шведите са също руснаци, нали знаеш?

Nice video, little silly though ;-) In 862 king Rostislav of Nitra (Nitra is the first historicaly documented Slavic kingdom, metropolis of by-modern-historians so-called "Great Moravia") sent a message to the Byzantine Emperor Michael III. with a request to send a bishop and a teacher who would lay the foundations of a church (independent of the Frankish bishops) in Great Moravia (today's western Slovakia and south Moravia). The inhabitants here were already familiar with the church teachings of the missionaries from the East Franconian kingdom at that time, but Prince Rostislav feared the political and religious influence of the East Frankish Empire, and so he had the Frankish priests expelled from Moravia. Thus, there was a lack of clergy in Moravia, and this may have been one of the reasons for Rostislav's request. The Emperor and Patriarch Photius eventually decided to partially comply with Rostislav's request. For knowledge of the language, Constantine and Methodius were chosen for this mission. In the course of preparation, Konstantin compiled a new script (Glagolitic) for the Slavic language and, together with his brother Methodius, translated the liturgical books necessary for worship into Old Slavonic. Konstantin is credited with compiling the Proglas, that is, the preface to the Old Slavonic translation of the Gospels. So (and there) our / your Cyrillic alphabet appeared. It remains a sad fact that later the Franks (today´s Germany and France) were able to impose the Western Catholic rite (and writing) in Slovakia, Moravia, Bohemia and Poland). Insidious politics and cruelty, of course... to be traced down through centuries and to be see even today in western Russia, Kyjevan Rus, so called Okrajina. Macedonians, Bulgarians, what are you writing here, that is is You You You who discovered America: we love you, just come back to the Earth, please ;-)

@vasil.kamdzhalov

Жыл бұрын

Check the difference between Glagolithic and Cyrillic, what you talk about is Glagolithic which is what you talk about and it is explained in the video. Cyril Methodius created the Glagolithic, their students after being expelled created a newer version which is very different in form.

@bjalon69

Жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov Sure, check it ❤ it shall help You better understand what I was writing about :-) You are almost there.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

Жыл бұрын

@@bjalon69 Ohh please dont be belittleling. The ruler of Great Moravia wanting to distance himself from the Latins and the church asked for help the Byzantine emperor. The task was given to Cyril and Methodius, the created Glagolithic using the slavic dialect around Thessaloniki. The two brothers were well recieved by in Great Moravia at first, the Pope too granted rights to do their work. Methodius I think died in service to the Pope translating book for him. At that time bishops didnt like what they tried to do so eventually their work was destroyed and their student expelled. Some of them come to Bulgaria and Boris the first grants them refuge and gives them rights to spread Glagolithic but in the same time create a better script. The students Naum, Climent, Gorazd, Sava and Angelarius while some of them die early all contribute. The two main literary school where in the capital of Veliki Preslav and the other in Ohrid. Is the enough, this is accepted by Europe and the EU as factual we arent making up things.

@bjalon69

Жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov Good job brother, well done! I see we are now fully aligned about the FACT that Your Azbuka writing origatess in western Slovakia. Sure, Your ancestors in Bulgaria committed as well, no doubt about it. By the way: death to the Fourth Reich = EU! лека нощ ;-)

I don't like Cyrillic because it doesn't have developed minuscule and looks archaic.

@priestkingskeptic

Жыл бұрын

true but cyrillic script is artificial and created by two drunk guys...it was not naturally evolved...latin script is far older...just like orthodox church cyrilliuc will die too

@19n05k83

Жыл бұрын

@@priestkingskeptic All scripts are artificial, dumbass

@priestkingskeptic

Жыл бұрын

@@19n05k83 no...scripts develop from pictorial representation du m bb a ssss

@orth0bro

Жыл бұрын

Ok who cares?

@priestkingskeptic

Жыл бұрын

@@orth0bro why did you hav a profile pic of a massive f aa ggo ttt?

See? Writing systems were invented, languages were invented, words were invented, books were invented, Holy Books were invented, concepts were invented, concepts of God were invented, religions were invented.... By humans. So there's no such thing as a Holy Book that came down from the sky!

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

Books are created to spread knowledge, in the past more enlighthened people wrote so they spread ideas and the evolvement of humanity, now is more for clicks on the Internet or just money. I would take seriously the came down from the sky but most of the times it comes suddenly like it is from the sky. I don't know if you hate religions or something, but if you do, just take what you like from it, either way is too corrupted nowadays. Invention of the mind to help the spiritual but not invention as a product to be sold that was the alphabet. Such kind of thinking without looking into details can radicalize in many ways. Thats why religions and idealogies work so well for some people.

@michaelcoceski5442

2 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov No hate brat. Where religion prospers people suffer. Find out about Summerian Clay tablets. Jewish religion is retelling of that information - but has given god human weaknesses like jealousy and super ego. Christianity and Islam are offspin of that. God is a different concept. Religion is all about control. Pozdrav.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

@@michaelcoceski5442 Not at first, as an example on one of their gatherings in Rome, the Catholic church somewhere in 880s (9th century) decide they won't follow God's word, they would follow "God" but that is doomed from that point, they knew what they wanted and from that part of they became political entity, who wished control, land and influence and you can see it in the next centuries, in modern day they don't have that much and must act nice but still as far as I know any church that is catholic in the world and it's property is to the Pope. What they do in recent times, go against family values and are famous for abusing little kids.

@michaelcoceski5442

2 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov Agree. So now the question is: - So god who knows and sees and is capable of everything .... why does he allow all this suffering of numerous innocent children over thousands of years ???

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

@@michaelcoceski5442 I see it like this, people are on this Earth to evolve as beings, this being spiritually too, God is an image that a person can follow if he is uncertain. Morality and higher sense of being etc. If God existed too I don't think would want to help people like this when it is their duty to do it themselves. I'm not religious so you know, I don't defend God per se.

To call Cyrillic an alfabet that got only 2 letters from Cyrillic alfabet is quite the stretch. To create the Slavonic alfabet they took 2 letters from the Cyrillic alfabet, 31 from an existing nongreek alfabet, that could be seen in archeological artifacts from long before 800AD, and 12 new letters. Was still a complicated alfabet but infinitly more useful than Cyrillic one. The insult and injury is with the non Greek alfabet that they borrowed 31 latters from and to which in time they reverted back almost entirely and call it Cyrillic too.

Why this British guy saying he is Bulgarian? Lol

@noelxlk

4 ай бұрын

maybe because he is and just speaks english?

Fixed the Bulgarian alphabet lol Dg Иu Пn Tm

Думата “славяни” я няма изписана никъде по света преди 16-ти век. Братята Кирил и Методий са превеждали църковни книги на “старобългарски”, а не на “славянски”. Терминът “славянски староцърковен” или “Old Church Slavonic” е използван за пръв път от Josef Dobrovsky във Виена през 1822г. Нищо не намеквам, никого не искам да обиждам, но това са съвсем известни и доказани факти. Освен това нямаме много славянски некрополи и т.н. Спокойно можем да заместим името "славянски език" с "български език"./ The word "Slavs" was not written anywhere in the world before the 16th century. The brothers Cyril and Methodius translated church books into "Old Bulgarian" and not into "Slavic". The term "Old Church Slavonic" or "Old Church Slavonic" was first used by Josef Dobrovsky in Vienna in 1822. I'm not implying anything, I don't want to offend anyone, but these are well-known and proven facts. Also, we don't have many Slavic necropolises, etc. We can easily replace the name "Slavic language" with "Bulgarian language".

@vasil.kamdzhalov

Жыл бұрын

То че не се наричало славянски църковен да, но не можеш да кажеш, че говора тогава навсякъде е бил български. Имаме само претенции към писането, всички са си пригодили азбуката както е било удобно.

This video is a lie. The video is not mentioning for whom the writing was created, that it was for Moravians. So the Bulgarians falsely claim the ownership of the writing.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

Жыл бұрын

Glagolithic was for Moravians by order of the Byzantine emperor to Cyril and Methodius and then their students as shown on the map with the path going to Bulgaria shows the way of the students of the two brothers and the start of the Cyrillic development. Every kid in Bulgaria knows this story even if generally. This clip is for other people not in perticular slavs, question yourself how much do you want to have in a clip you create so to have the most improtant parts and not bore the viewer.

@pradrev

Жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov your argument is false because in such important thing as glagolitic was, omitting the most important part of the story, the origin of the writing in Moravia, is a misleading of the viewer to the profit of Bulgaria. It is the same as talking about Christianity without mentioning Jesus.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

Жыл бұрын

@@pradrev You make a mistake here, Glagolithic wasn't created in Moravia, the king of Moravia wanted to distance himself from the Latin preaching so he went to the Byzantine emperor for help, then the script was more or less created and went to Moravia to spread it and teach people, how do you think Cyril and Methodius just went from Byzantium to Moravia and why do you expect they will go without having nothing to present, they used slavic speaking people around Thessaloniki to base their new script and then went to Moravia and taught people and their students but it failed. Thats it, Moravia this and that doesn't make sense but it was a bridge point for the story of this events. Cyril and Methodius die and even when the Pope endorsed their work they were expelled by local power and church and their students either were invited or on their own went to Bulgaria, that's it. I don't know what more to tell as this is what happened. Most people don't even know Glagolithic is a thing but still you can see the letter when it is mentioned, I fdont know what you expect, this was for an event in the real life and people put what they had done, it wasn't ment to be a full documentary and as Eurovision has rule for example the songs to be 3 min. here is similar, there are obstacles. Sorry if you are disappointed but the starting claim to begin with is wrong.

@M.Georgiev8527

9 ай бұрын

​@@pradrevYou should learn the difference between Glagolitic and Cyrillic before spitting your bulshit across youtube. You might actually learn something interesting by just google it for 30 seconds you ignorant fool.

Филмчето не предтсавя коректно историческите факти и заблуждава. Българицата (българската азбука, наречена от византийците славянска, за да ни отнемат рождеството и) е създадена от Климент Охридски по разпореждане на Цар Симеон, а не на Цар Борис 1ви. Също така премълчава защо е наречена Кирилица, когато Глаголицата е кирилица, а Българицата е създадена 30г след смъртта на Кирил.

@Nailone420

Жыл бұрын

Точно !

Georgia, Armenia have their own alphabets Türkmenistan, Uzbekiston, Qazaqstan and Azerbaijan use Latin alphabet your map is incorrect :)

@ClydeDatastruct

2 жыл бұрын

Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan used Cyrillic until the end of Soviet rule. Of these four, only Kazakhstan is the last one to switch to the Latin alphabet

Македонски ☀️

@gigachad3004

6 ай бұрын

Какъв македонски бе…вие нали се имате за гърци,що не говорите гръцки…тва си е български език дето говорите

@oggimihaylov9609

10 күн бұрын

Тъпанар

The word Slavs, as something other than slaves, appeared in the early 16th century, but acquired its current meaning in the 18th century, when the Russian Empress Catherine the Great developed the doctrine of Panslvism for geopolitical reasons. If you show me one historical source that says about Slavs before the 18th century, I will give you $ 1,000.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

Your correct, yet the alphabet worked for specific group of people who had similar speach, so such group existed but in different name then.

@cius96

3 жыл бұрын

The Slavic ethnonym (and autonym), Slavs, is reconstructed in Proto-Slavic as *Slověninъ, plural Slověně. The Slavic autonym *Slověninъ is usually considered a derivation from slovo "word", originally denoting "people who speak (the same language)", i. e. people who understand each other, in contrast to the Slavic word denoting "foreign people", namely němci, meaning "mumbling, murmuring people" (from Slavic *němъ "mumbling, mute"). The latter word may be the derivation of words to denote "Germans" or "Germanic peoples" in many later Slavic languages: e. g., Czech Němec, Slovak Nemec, Slovene Nemec, Belarusian, Russian and Bulgarian Немец, Serbian Немац, Croatian Nijemac, Polish Niemiec, Ukrainian Німець, etc. The Slav ethnonym at first denoted the southern group of the early Slavs. This ethnonym is attested by Procopius in Byzantine Greek as Σκλάβοι (Skláboi), Σκλαβηνοί (Sklabēnoí), Σκλαυηνοί (Sklauēnoí), Σθλαβηνοί (Sthlabēnoí), or Σκλαβῖνοι (Sklabînoi),[7] while his contemporary Jordanes refers to the Sclaveni in Latin.[8] In Ancient Greek there are no words with the root sl-, thus the original ethnonym was transformed into skl-, as that root was present (in sklērós, "hard"). In East Church Slavonic manuscripts, the ethnonym is spelt Slověne (Словѣне), such as in the Primary Chronicle, Sofia First Chronicle, Novgorod First Chronicle and Novgorod Fourth Chronicle.[10] In the source dating to 898 included in the Primary Chronicle, the term is used both for East Slavic tribes and more often for a people (in the Kievan Rus' society, alongside Varangians, Chuds and Kriviches). For more about it check: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavs_(ethnonym). Oh, by the way, if you intend to keep your word I can leave you here my Paypal address so you can make the payment.

@TzvetozarCherkezov

2 жыл бұрын

Hi there. I know I'm a year late, but I just saw this comment. Here is Il Regno degli Slavi (The Kingdom of the Slavs), which is a history of the Slavic people written by Mavro Orbini in 1601 - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_of_the_Slavs. And, yes, I've read it (here's the Bulgarian copy: www.ozone.bg/product/carstvoto-na-slavjanite/ ). Written in 1601, a full one hundred years before the 18th century. Shall I give you my PayPal account, so you can deposit 1000 US dollars, please?

@o6ina

2 жыл бұрын

First mentioned in Jordanes'' "Getica'' circa 551. The oldest known source of this work, that survived modernity, is form 1442.

@TheOzumat

Жыл бұрын

@@cius96 So first the Romans call the Germans "barbarians" because they say bar bar bar, then we call them "немци" because they can't speak. I don't know, I find it kind of funny. I wonder if the Germans have a similar word for outsiders/people whose language they can't understand. Poor Germans... 😂

“Then the Cyrillic alphabet spread across the world” Ah yes, to the Soviet federation and then…uh… Hmm… uh…

@vasil.kamdzhalov

Жыл бұрын

You are late with like a 1000 years for the spread of Cyrillic, if you see only USSR. It was meant for slavs so we dont care how big or around the world it is.

Hmmm.... and how come still no one said they were Macedonians and all started from Macedonia (like usual) ?!?@?

@user-fl3nb9kq3s

4 жыл бұрын

They are NOT macedonians they are Bulgarians.

@danbien

4 жыл бұрын

The answer is simple- they are not macedonians.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

Macedonia exists in it's modern form form 1945, bdefore that majority of people there saw themselves as bulgarians and in historical point of view is more improtant what they felt as than what you claim they are today so you could feel good of your lack of acomplishments.

@forlandiego2577

2 жыл бұрын

@@danbien The question is simple How many Kliment's and Naum's do you have in Bulgria 😂

Bulgaria Caput Mundi

General population majority were macedonian people as the bulgars (tatars from central asia) and immigrant from the north occupied the region. Kiril and Metodij were from macedonian lands.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

Some of the things you said show that you didn't even see the video, nevermind what you wrote.

@AS_888_

3 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov i dont have to see a video on youtube to tell me about my history. I know my history and my history is macedonian. Bulgarian history on the other hand is central asian, tatars.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

@@AS_888_ The problem with your logic is that you believe that this is only our claim but this is just proven by the world history society. Hisotrians and scientists have agreed that this is true and there is a reason after that the European union to agree to such a "claim". In the end yours is just talk. The difference is explained in the video and it works as the same you can see in text in Wikipedia. In the end tatars are mongols, they form 500 years after we settled in the Balkans so your just plain rasist.

@AS_888_

3 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov there is no problem with my logic as this is fact. Macedonians existed before the Bulgars/Tatars came from central asia.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

@@AS_888_ No there is a problem, because there isn't more than I guess one 1 source ( yours ) that's claims you directly desend from the ancient macedonians. You just bare the name and it is a very recent decision of your, there isn't a problem with it is just not factial as to what you claim. In the very least in the 5th and 6th centuries there were invasions of huns and vandals and were at least 4, death was present of wide scale as cities weren't even spared, there was low or no population left when the slavs came and Byzantium for a time lost control of territories as far as the Peloponese in Greece, there was no barrier, no cities left whatsoever and you claim that macedonians survived so you colud say you are them.The only macedonian that could have survived was in Solun as it never fell. So yes, you aren't taught well in school and is normal as it won't fit what the goverment claims. The modern macedonians were born to serve a purpose to the communist government in the end of WW2.

Pekne videjko, len trošku smiešne..;-) В 862 году Hитрянский (Великоморавский) князь Ростислав отправил послание византийскому императору Михаилу III. с просьбой прислать епископа и учителя, который заложил бы основы церкви (независимой от франкских епископов) в Великой Моравии (сегодняшняя западная Словакия и Южная Моравия). Жители здесь уже были знакомы с церковными учениями миссионеров из Восточно-Франконского королевства в то время, но князь Ростислав опасался политического и религиозного влияния Восточно-Франкской империи, и поэтому он имел Франкские священники изгнаны из Моравии. Таким образом, в Моравии не хватало духовенства, и это могло быть одной из причин просьбы Ростислава. Император и Патриарх Фотий в конце концов решили частично выполнить просьбу Ростислава. Для знания языка были выбраны Константин и Мефодий для этой миссии. В ходе подготовки Константин составил новую письменность (глаголицу) для славянского языка и вместе с братом Мефодием перевел на старославянский язык богослужебные книги, необходимые для богослужений. Константину приписывают составление Прогласа, т. е. предисловия к старославянскому переводу Евангелий. Так (и там) появилась наша/ваша кириллица. Oстается печальным фактом, что впоследствии франки смогли навязать западно-католический обряд (и письмо) в Словакии, Моравии, Чехии и Польше. Коварная политика и жестокость, конечно... Македонцы, болгары, что вы тут пишите, что вы вы вы!!! открыли Америку: мы вас любим, только вернитесь на землю, пожалуйста ;-) Ahoj!

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

Малко си грубиян и не разбираш и не си чел, отделно ние учим това в училище за вашата история и причини да потърсите императора на Византия. От там получавате Глаголицата , тя е направена само от Кирил и Методий. С времето те и техните ученици и работа не са желани в Великоморавия и са изгонени. Кирил и Методий, един от двата умира преди това да стане, другия отива при папата да превежда книги и умира там. Техните ученици и по скоро на Кирил се разпръскват, 5 от тях отиват в България и имената ги има в клипа, наредено им е да създадат нова азбука за изполване в България. Тя се оказва по ефективна и се разнася из други славянски народи, така имаме Кирилицата. Аз да ти се нервя ли за дето не знаеш и не искаш нио да научиш за България, а съм си направил труда да знам нещо за Моравия/Великоморавия/Бохемия или ако си от Словакия тогава Унгарското кралство или Галисия.

@TheOzumat

Жыл бұрын

You're telling the story of the Glagolitic alphabet, while the video is talking about the Cyrillic alphabet, which was made by Cyril & Methodius' students. I don't know who needs to come back to the ground.

@bjalon69

Жыл бұрын

@@TheOzumat :-))) Глаголица, или, реже, устаревшая глаголица, является самой старой, сегодня только в исключительных случаях используемой славянской письменностью. Его название происходит от старославянского глагола глаголати - говорить или существительного глаголъ - слово. Glagolitic, or more rarely and outdated Glagolitic, is the oldest, today only exceptionally used Slavic script. Its name comes from the Old Slavic verb glagolati - to speak or the noun glagolъ - word. Glagolic = Cyrillic Sooo - if You "don´t know" - it is You, dude ❤

cyrillic... russian.... they are the same

@ElektrickMe

3 жыл бұрын

Not that I would like to disappoint you but Russians are using the Cyrillic alphabet/script, also its being used by around 50 different languages and more than 300 million people. Its the one of the three official scripts in the European Union (Latin, Cyrillic and Greek)

@JustSlav98

3 жыл бұрын

As you can see Cyrillic was created in Bulgaria and russia got it from Bulgaria

Syrillic .........FU

They were Macedonians from Ohrid , not Bulgerians not Greeks.

@JustSlav98

3 жыл бұрын

Ohrid was part of the First Bulgarian empire when cyrillic was created , google and you will see

@JustSlav98

3 жыл бұрын

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clement_of_Ohrid Next time it will be nice to prepare yourself

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

Even in macedonia today of the church of Clement Ohridski it is written Klement from Moesia which is in today North Bulgaria. It would be strange how all 7 of the happened to be macedonians just for ease of north macedonians today to feel great. Well you could feel great without those fake events as the European union wouldn't just except something without being proven to be true. Macedonians could have all the history from 632 of empires and kings but Alexander is cuter I guess.

@_0_restart_0_

3 жыл бұрын

They weren't a certain ethnicity. They were slavs. And at that point, the slavic people were in one country known as bulgaria, but that did not make them bulgarians. Modern bulgarians are slavs just like any other but only bearing the name of the previous slavs name. So, it's safe to say they were Slavic!

@iseethroughyouresoul.5605

3 жыл бұрын

Ah yes brainwashed by tito

Yea ok everyone seas its not Bulgarian.

@user-th3nx6zj2f

3 жыл бұрын

Nice London.

@Howkeek

3 жыл бұрын

You deleted and reposted the same comment that had something close from 15 to 22 replies just so nobody tells you acutal history than what you usually learn in Serbia, truly sad

@user-do7vg6nw6d

3 жыл бұрын

@@Howkeek i didnt delete anything

@Howkeek

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-do7vg6nw6d Хахаха nice try, but i saw it just 5 hours ago

@user-do7vg6nw6d

3 жыл бұрын

@@Howkeek what this comment is 2 months old

The Macedonian language is the root of all Slavic languages. The Glagolic and the Cyrillic Alphabets are made only for the Macedonian language open Britannica on Old Church Slavonic.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

Go read it too, it seems you don't know either 😂

@dove5591

2 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov I don't know what?

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

@@dove5591 The comment most recent to your explains it and I read it before that part you showed as a source.

@dove5591

2 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov what are you even babbling about

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

@@dove5591 Hello Dove this should be you: Geliefde Liefde has a cult of accounts spamming around Bulgarian Videos like "Learn the Cyrillic alphabet in one Video". Under the name Dove and oldest alphabets under the name Grace he deleted. This troll is obsessed and doesn't provide actual facts, just states website titles and says go read it. He is contradicting himself and a liar about the Bulgaria culture, language and Cyrillic alphabet.

Cringe Ohrid is Macedonia it has NEVER BEEN IN BULGARIA

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

From 832 to 1014 is the first time and the second from 1217 to 1241 at least. Stop with your bullshit history and stop trolling.

@tedv8323

Жыл бұрын

You know history as much as the cat from your avatar picture!

@oggimihaylov9609

10 күн бұрын

Да го духаш тъпанар!!

Само чекам Бугаре да кажу да је то Бугарско писмо, а Срби писали скоро истим писмом 2000 година раније😂

@user-uk1bi4fp4z

4 жыл бұрын

Сърбите пишете на маймуница/шльокавица.

@user-pl3zh8lu3i

4 жыл бұрын

@@user-uk1bi4fp4z :P знао сам да ће се напалите на то

@user-uk1bi4fp4z

4 жыл бұрын

@@user-pl3zh8lu3i Ами истина е. Не съм видяла един сръбски сайт, в който да пише на кирилица. ;]

@gloglogloyper7888

4 жыл бұрын

Kako sam ja razumeo jezik koji smo mi, srbi koristili je bio pisan sa romanskim i grzkim slovima, a taj stari srpski jezik se jos davno bio pisan na staroj ćirilici, bugarsko carstvo je kasnije napravilo reformaciju cirilice koja se malo promenila danas i koje mi koristimo (bez nekih slova). Ako gresim molim vas recite mi jer nisam siguran koliko je ovo istinito i voleo bi vise da znam, hvala vam i pozdrav iz Spanije!

@user-pl3zh8lu3i

4 жыл бұрын

@@gloglogloyper7888 srpski je pre pisao samo starom ćirilicom pre nego što su ga Bugari "modernizovali" A pored toga samo nešto kratko glagoljicom.. veliki pozdrav👋🏻

Святые Кирилл и Мефодий (др.-слав. Кѷриллъ и Меѳодїи) - македонские братья из Фессалоник в девятом веке[3][4][5][6], ставшие миссионерами христианства среди славян Великой Моравии и Паннонии. Своим трудом они повлияли на культурное развитие всех славян, за что и получили титул Апостолов славян. Им приписывают изобретение глаголицы, первого алфавита, использовавшегося для расшифровки старославянского языка.[7] После их смерти их ученики продолжили работу и деятельность среди славян. Оба брата почитаются в Восточной Православной Церкви как святые с титулом равноапостольных. В 1880 году папа Лев XIII ввел их славу в римско-католический календарь. В 1980 году Иоанн Павел II объявил их сопокровителями Европы вместе с Бенедиктом Нурсийским[6]. Спасибо македонским братьям 🇲🇰❤️🇷🇺

@drevnata

2 жыл бұрын

Вы надо учиться сначала... У вас большие недостатки в истории. И на совести.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

Какви македонци бе, можеш ли да четеш или слушаш поне? Издивели като вашият лидер Путин, "кирилицата от македонски земи", не може да каже, че е от Македонците защото не е вярно. Идиот и после ми пише мерси на македонците. Сега като се сетя пък колко българи разчитат на руснаците и се опитват да ви вярват, а вие и базисна история за азбуката не можете да възприемете пък да не говорим и как е дошла при вас, чрез Криприан и Григорий Цамблак от Велико Търново като метрополити на Киев. Отнесете се с увежение един път какво очаквате от останалите славянски народи, няма да ви сецне гордостта.

@asen2442

2 жыл бұрын

ХАХАХАХ

@HeroManNick132

2 жыл бұрын

Хаха, според твоята логика Адам и Ева, Аристотел, Зевс са ,,антични македонци," родени в Античната нечувана досега Македонска цивилизация, майката на всички държави, раси и като цяло всичко от първия неандерталец до Клеопатра. Исус е роден сигурно в Скопие, Библията е първо написана там, те са първите християни, а не арменците. Или пък екваторът разделя Северна от Южна Македония? Прав ли съм, мой руски агресоре, предателю?

@Christian-su2df

Жыл бұрын

спокойно, ние знаем, че от руснак не миже да се очаква истината :)

Поредната манипулация.

@mihailnikoloff2554

4 жыл бұрын

Кое е манипулация ? Обясни, тъпанар

Здравейте българы

Cyrillic alphabet doesn't have anything with bulgarians, Cyrillic alphabet came from Macedonia and bulgarians just came from the steppes as nomads in that century. Bulgarians didn't even speak our language, they were Tatars until they mixed with Serbs and other Slavic tribes

@vasil.kamdzhalov

2 жыл бұрын

You barely know the dates it seems. Tatars are mongol people and they came 700 years later. Serbian was one of the tribes that later everyone beared their name in you region but to tell everyone was serbian at first isn't accurate. You barely united into one state in 10th century. The dates you miss: 1. We came 680/681 and mixed with the Seven Slavic tribes in today Wallachia, not your area. 2. Christianisation comes around 855 in Bulgaria and it is with no arguing the first slavic state orthodox church apart of the Byzantine one and get a patriarchate first which start the concept of everyone having one that isn't the one in Constantinopole. 3. You saw the story in the clip, who made what and when. 4. Tell your story to the European Union, politics weren't that strong in 2007 and even then they would be some intellectuals on the topic to object if it was wrong. EU isn't that dumb to proclaim such things when they don't really enjoy dealing with Balkan states. 5. Quiet down your pride as we like to tell " The world is Serbia."

@FreshVito_bg

2 жыл бұрын

That’s what your fake country want you to think. The bulgars mixed with the slavs. And Macedonia was part of our countries. You are just brainwashed Bulgarians who think that they created the Cyrillic. It’s lies. Your language is dialect of ours. You copy everything from the Bulgarians and the Greeks. You stole the history and pretend to be something different. But it’s not that way. Your not gonna enter the European Union if you continue to lie. Just expect the true. Bulgarians try to be nice and made us one people because we are the same. But you Macedonians make things more and more difficult to happen. You dare to burn Bulgarian flags, and to brake our statues. Get on our level.

@user-hx2xl2km2e

2 жыл бұрын

The serbs are our enemies, we should not expect anything different than that. I really hope you stop watching Bulgarian videos and watch some serb related videos like Srebrenica, for example.

@asen2442

2 жыл бұрын

Check Ottoman records, Macedonians are not mentioned even once as a people - because such a people did not exist at that time. Your ancestors are Bulgarians. You have the internet, search for information yourself.

@HeroManNick132

2 жыл бұрын

Serbian propaganda 🤡Just like how you took Macedonia.

Свети кирил и методиј беше македонци и не Булгарцки. Oвие само работали за Булгарство цар. славјанци се мешаали со античките Македонци (Денес Македонци). Вие и грците сакат до го крадете Македонскиот идентитед. Извинeте за мојата македонски Поздрав од вашата руско-германски брат

@user-yi4zs7vi5p

4 жыл бұрын

Сърбоман чети истинска история

@JustSlav98

4 жыл бұрын

Cyril and methodius were greek not bulgarians nor macedonians , but their students who created Cyrillic were bulgarians i even have german friends that all know that Cyrillic is from bulgaria not macedonia , even history books say its from bulgaria , learn history

@JustSlav98

4 жыл бұрын

ImCurigi you are macedonian , because all germans and russians that know history know its from bulgaria, no one says its from macedonia , its not hard to read a book or to open google

@user-yi4zs7vi5p

4 жыл бұрын

@@JustSlav98 dont think everything in books and google is true

@JustSlav98

4 жыл бұрын

@@user-yi4zs7vi5p Oh okay so books writen by historians are not true , but what some 15 year old macedonian kids that have never studied history in their life say is true ? Your logic makes perfect sense!

I agree that the Cyrillic alphabet is the best in the world. I disagree that is coming from Bulgaria as much as a lot of things s, that are actually coming from there. Bulgarians are Tatars and have 0 European culture not to mention that they invented Alphabet. Yes, they were good thieves and warriors who damaged the Byzantine Empire but using and what they inherit from the Byzantine empire such as religion, culture, tradition does t make them innovators of anything. Simple users or even better made up themself s as the authority of something that they never possessed Alphabeth Religion Culture and Tradition. They were never Slavs then how come they made a Slavic Alphabeth ?!

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

This is proven by the world historiography not just bulgarian, as an example that is why the European union officially recognizes our ancestors as its creators. You comment in the end is just plain arogant and disrespectful. I might even guess from where you are, it won't be hard. You talk of european culture you show not a slitest of it, nor your people.

@Bodlasona

3 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov it's irrelevant whatever you say will never delete the fact that you are immigrants from Asia

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

@@Bodlasona You quickly try to say that you are from here, there isn't a problem to call yourself macedonians today if you so wish, but the whole problem is that in your happy fantasy world you have been that the whole time, which isn't correct. Even if you try to ignore that in the very least you aren't pureblood and only macedonians. You got from all the nations on the balkans (almost). We know that we have from our tribe, slavs, thracians and a bit of greek so this isn't a problem for us. But in your poor consept we are only tatars and in your schoolbooks it starts with that, that we are tatars,robbers and nomads who practically don't deserve a nation and you expect to enter EU with the european values of friendship and trade. Even the tatar thing is not true in a way because last discoveries suggest we come from the area of Iran and Tibet area. Tatars is the other name of mongols, mongols emerge in 13th century, we are here since 7th century and try to explain me how we preseed the mongols with 500 years? Don't worry I expect you to think of some other bad mouthing so I won't be surprised.

@Bodlasona

3 жыл бұрын

@@vasil.kamdzhalov You are the one who copies not Macedonians You are the one who took Byzantine traditions, not anyone else . And to claim something that you clearly copied its absurd. Besides who cares about the EU everybody knows that you do all these crappy things because Germany was a mediator of EU.And you had some kind of support . Kiril and Methodius were from Souln -Tesalonika . Their missionaries Naum, Gorazd, Klement,Angelari were everything but Bulgarians. Everyone know s that you want to claim a monopoly over the Balkans, now that's your Fantasy, not any others .If you were for unity we would know long time ago.We don t need EU to know who you are remember that.

@vasil.kamdzhalov

3 жыл бұрын

@@Bodlasona The only byzantine we took was chirstianity. We can't do much for the change in lifetstyle of the territories we took. If we did something was to improve them in our own way. We know that Ciril and Methodius where from Thessaloniki/Solun and when we study about them, it is just said that they had at least one parent from slavic origin, not bulgarian, so we don't change it. The students where sent by our rulers to study from them or else after their death they could just return to the byzantines but they didn't, they willingly came to Bulgaria and we tasked to finish the imrpovements into a new alphabet. That happened in Preslav, then Ohrid was chosen to act as a centre of the region of Macedonia, sorry to say but again when it was conquered the byzantines named it theme Bulgaria as the other already where Moesia, Thrace etc. You talk bad about the EU but still you want there, the improvements they made where because of those principles I said last time, if you can't trully follow them, there is no point.

Just Islam is true religion

@petrovich_sokolov

4 жыл бұрын

The only decent Islamic teachings are the Shia teachings, everything else is fake Islam and fake religion.

@man08839

4 жыл бұрын

@@petrovich_sokolov not beating is not allowed in Islam.just Sunni teaching are true.read holy Quran for success in life and after death.Subhanallah.start pray 5times namaz for success in life and also success for after death☪🌴🌴🌄🌅🕋

@aleksk4151

2 жыл бұрын

Islam is not true. kzread.info/dash/bejne/f5WMxa-JlsnOfrg.html check this video. Jesus is the Way the Truth and the Life!

@priestkingskeptic

Жыл бұрын

but how come buraq donkey fly in space and why did momo drink camel ur ine mixed with milk? YUCK :D

@priestkingskeptic

Жыл бұрын

black cube worshipers...there are 1000 cubes in yemen, go run around them

CYRIL LIRYC, METHOD DO THEM (DO ĆEM/TO ŚCIEM) -> I hope, you get the idea. It is a fantasy story. Writing systems are much older. Glagolica is motivated by the bark drill technique as is still used in India to write Sanskrit. It has a complex structure and has a whole religious story to tell, which is of course much older than Christianity. We should remember that it is not the script, which is the challenge. The challenge is the writing material. Paper and computers permit us to write more than ever. We write more not because we are smarter, but because the technology is better. And I am not even sure that paper-techniques haven't existed before in antiquity in all of eastern Europe. Latin script probably originates in Vinca, hard to tell, but definitively the s-c-k confusion group or the p-r-g-ja confusion group stems from different writing traditions, so old, that they are at the roots of creating major IE-language groups. By the way, Cyril and Methodius look like Perun and Veles. In that case, the story was true but the date was wrong. :]