The Bizarre Painting No One Fully Understands
This piece is called Stańczyk by Jan Matejko. Stańczyk was a 16th century court jester during the Polish Renaissance under the reign of King Sigismund I the Old. This painting is also referred to as Stańczyk during a Ball at the Court of Queen Bona in the Face of the Loss of Smoleńsk. The jester was a very witty and intelligent man known for his satire around politics and matters of the nation. It was in this way that he was able to illuminate the hypocrisies he saw occurring in the court in a way that those in power would actually listen to him. And because he was so insightful, he knew what the loss of Smoleńsk meant for the future of his beloved land.
It’s clear that the artist saw a lot of himself in the jester and it’s understandable why. They were both very patriotic, behind the scenes actors fighting for the soul of their nation. Since neither of them were elite or royalty, they affected change in the best way they knew how. For Stańczyk, it was through riddles and jokes; for Matejko, it was through paint and canvas.
Despite how amazing this piece is, there are some mysterious discrepancies hiding within it. Thank you for watching!
#arthistory #art #classicart #fineart #clown
Credits:
Fire special effect from Vecteezy
Circus Tent - Netherworld Shanty by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. creativecommons.org/licenses/...
Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Arcadia Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Пікірлер: 886
I think the most heartbreaking thing about this painting is that Stańczyk was a jester, but also a patriot, and was known for his social commentary. He knows EXACTLY what that letter means, he knows EXACTLY what’s going to happen to Poland, but he’s just a clown, he has no power to do anything about the situation, and the people who do have power only worry about frivolous things like their party. It’s…sadly relatable in a modern context, especially when I think of issues like the climate crisis. It’s a timeless truth that people who care have no power, and people with power don’t care.
@totallybuggedout_
Жыл бұрын
i agree. this is one of the saddest, and truest, art piece ive ever heard of
@sweetbunnybun
Жыл бұрын
what will happen to poland? this painting is about the loss of Smolensk and poland took it from kievan rus
@7spiritualcompass706
Жыл бұрын
What climate crisis are you referring to? Curious.
@anonymous3637
Жыл бұрын
@@7spiritualcompass706 the one where the sky is falling
@christienelson1437
Жыл бұрын
I agree and the stress of trying to entertain the Royal house and remain in favor. Jesters became very close and involved in their lives hating them and loving them on a whim. These personal entertainers were highly intelligent, eclectic and social stars making their lives full of chaos.💕❤️❤️♥️🙏
Stańczyk was really sassy irl. He once got ridiculed and his clothes torn up by some boys on the street, and when the king saw it, he laughed. Stańczyk replied „Your Majesty, I got stripped of my clothes and you got stripped of Smoleńsk, that’s way worse”
@k.999
Жыл бұрын
How did his clothes tearing up has anything to go with Smolensk
@czerwonykwadrat6843
Жыл бұрын
@@k.999 the city was *torn* away from us
@inkenhafner7187
Жыл бұрын
@@k.999 It's in the video.
@k.999
Жыл бұрын
@@czerwonykwadrat6843 Right I got to know later in the video. Thank you
@genovayork2468
Жыл бұрын
@@czerwonykwadrat6843 Hold on right there, lad, the city was never Polish, but in the Lithuanian part of the Commonwealth. And Lithuania got it by conquering the Principality of Smolensk, which gained independence from the Kievan Rus'. The language is Russian, the people were never Polish or Lithuanian.
Ok. So I'm polish and I did the magnificent research of reading polish Wikipedia. There are two anegdotes in our chronicles under year 1533 about Stańczyk. Both are very "jester-like", but in both Stańczyk is reminding the king that he lost Smoleńsk. One of them is more specyfic - not only he lost Smoleńsk 20 years earlier, but also after huge victory battle he didn't take it back. So basically this painting is merging the fact of loosing Smoleńsk with anegdotes which are telling that 20 years later Stańczyk still remember about this and didn' loose any chance to remind this fact to the king.
@orzelgryf
Жыл бұрын
EDIT: I put here original polish text, but I didn't need to - another good soul in other comment translated the whole thing. Check carboard2night comment.
@kathykrisko3228
Жыл бұрын
This makes a lot of sense!
@rebeccaweil1
Жыл бұрын
Excellent research . Thank you because I was going to try to figure it out and because I have no polish roots, I therefore have no real insight of the dates.
@chriskershaw7968
Жыл бұрын
Excellent, thank you!
@venusblade4ever
Жыл бұрын
Nice. Great research. I thought it may had something to do with Poland’s politics (apparently the Polish king at the time was born 1533)
Call me stupid, but were you to ask me about this painting, I would have told you that Stańczyk lived during the partitions of Poland, not early XVI century. Maybe it's because Matejko's art is so strongly connected with the time in polish history you mentioned. But well, I actually learned something about polish culture thanks to your video (and I am from Poland). Now to the question you asked about the date - I didn't do much research, just googled it in polish, but there was an information that 1533 was the year polish truce with Russia ended and the next year a war started that didn't go very well for Poland. My interpretation of this would be, that Matejko purposefully made the point in time unclear to show that this picture is not just about one specific event, but a series of those, which later in a way repeated and resulted in Poland being partitioned. For me, knowing polish history and the general style of Matejko's paintings, I get a strong feeling of "we never learn from history and while nobody was giving a shit Russia came and destroyed us". It's like Stańczyk is trapped in time, observing the polish history through centuries and being depressed because there's nothing he can do about it. That's why he has Matejko's face. He's not just a historical character, he is a personification of the grief over the loss of Poland that connects both men. My polish teacher in school would be so proud of me for this interpretation 😂
@Cat-tastrophee
Жыл бұрын
Wow, that was an excellent interpretation! Thank you 👏
@Jestanothernobody
Жыл бұрын
Wow!
@amanakonda
Жыл бұрын
Wow! Beautiful interpretation
@user-mc5vy2vk5n
Жыл бұрын
I'm not your teacher and I'm proud of you. Great comment. 👏 One thing more, though. In English language the word "polish" means among others "nail polish" - what you are looking for is "Polish", the adjective. You don't need to believe me, feel free to check in any dictionary.
@vincentfreddoyle7555
Жыл бұрын
@@Cat-tastrophee polish teacher 🤨
The painting is basically about how Stańczyk is the smartest person in the room but can't do anything for his country because he's just a jester
Imagine making a heartfelt painting about the most devastating news of your time, and for it to be used as a reaction meme centuries later. Lol
@StanislawStanczyk-by4gg
3 ай бұрын
And imagine that reaction meme to be your 28x great grandfather LOL
@kyrab7914
2 ай бұрын
Honestly it's prob nice in a way. Your work is still around, tho sadly still relevant. But it is appreciated, and I mean it's a kind of immortality, for the emotions depicted in one's work to be so poignant and accurate they become a meme.
This year, Poland was getting ready for war. The letter in the painting is from Samogitia. It was there that the Lithuanian nobility rebelled, which did not want to submit to hetman Radziwiłł. The Moscow War lasted from 1534 to 1537 and was ineffective. Poland did not regain Smolensk. The picture shows the reasons for the loss of Smolensk - no action on the part of the king, whose chaotic and erroneous decisions delayed the commencement of hostilities (a carefree ball in the background of the painting) and the unsuccessful mobilization of a popular uprising, which was caused by the conflicted and reluctant to war nobility.
@profezzordarke4362
Жыл бұрын
Probably the best answer and way too far down here.
@Cammmila
Жыл бұрын
This makes a ton more sense than the theory in the above comments above. This should be a higher rated comment!
@TomoyoTatar
Жыл бұрын
Thank you.
@bricksthatcanmove9679
Жыл бұрын
69 likes. Nobody change that.
@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim
Жыл бұрын
I’m Lithuanian and F yeah we rebelled
A comet in the sky was often regarded as a threatening omen - well, back in the old days. Interestingly, Halley's Comet makes its cyclical appearance every 75-76 years. Using 75.5 as the interval, going back 5 cycles from 1910 (the year Mark Twain died and when it definitely appeared) you get the year 1533, which is on the document on the table. So maybe the artist was drawing a parallel with cataclysms and the fall of Smolensk - in which case the specific year would be less significant than the association of heavenly portents of change. Or ... I could be a complete ignoramus. But I really appreciated the lesson - thank you!
@papagaiofilmes6642
Жыл бұрын
"The economy, fools!"
@Fern635
Жыл бұрын
Interesting! That seems almost too perfect to be a coincidence.
@14thbattlegroupcommander
Жыл бұрын
@@papagaiofilmes6642 if only we had comet sense...
@The_Ballo
Жыл бұрын
I don't buy it. It probably refers to the beginning of the reign of Ivan the Terrible or another historical event.
To answer your question about date 1533, from polish wiki article about this painting: "The title refers to one of the well-known anecdotes about Stańczyk, in which he accurately reminded King Sigismund the Old of allowing the loss of Smolensk , an important fortress in the east of the Polish-Lithuanian state [15] . This anecdote was written down in 1533 by the historian Marcin Bielski in the Polish Chronicle (Book V)" the anecdote is basically that king received a bear in a chest, the bear was released, everyone ran away, the queen Bona was so terrified she miscarried, but king just laughed at the whole ordeal and mocked Stanczyk for running "like jester" and Stanczyk supposedly said "the one that releases bear is a jester, not the ones who runs from it!". The bear is a well known symbol of Russia.
@blackr2d
Жыл бұрын
Released (uwolnił, wypuścił). Realised to "zdał sobie sprawę" albo "zrealizował".
@sweetbunnybun
Жыл бұрын
Smolensk was founded back in kievan rus period, so it wasnt always polish
@ilikedinosaurs392
Жыл бұрын
ran away instead of runned away ;) Also thank you for the fact
@thesinguIarityawakens
Жыл бұрын
i think you mean released instead of realised?
@cardboard2night
Жыл бұрын
Yeah, sorry, wrote it in a hurry so my grammar was a bit... not good x) I'm not Polish, btw
I also thought that Stańczyk's disheartened pose was also due to the fact that jesters were sometimes sought out to announce particularly devastating news to rulers and elites because of their ability to make a joke of it or lighten up the delivery. For example, one of Henry VIII's jesters was the one who told him that his fifth wife, Catherine Howard, was cheating on him. Here, Stańczyk is that crestfallen because he's unsure of how to make light of the loss of Smolensk. I don't know, just a theory that came to me. I absolutely love your videos - as a history and art fan, they're always so entertaining and interesting to watch! :D
@nicktallfox5266
Жыл бұрын
An alternative interpretation might be that this is Stańczyk right after delivering the bad news, slumped in the chair knowing that losing an important city to russia wasn't urgent enough for the nobility to stop partying and get their stuff together. It's an interpretation i like because it just ads this crushing hopelessness to the image, which i find fitting with the historical context of both Stańczyk and Matejko. "The country is falling/has fallen apart and you can't do anything about it" kind of vibe.
@The0Stroy
Жыл бұрын
@@nicktallfox5266 And that interpretation seem to be more in line with what happened in PLC in times after that. King power erode and nobility was tightly keeping to their privileges, making reform and stability very hard. Serval (elected by nobility btw) kings care more about art and parties than trying to put nobility in line. Then come Russian en masse bribery of the most important nobles.
@xXSprMgaAwsmFxyHtXx
Жыл бұрын
Poor Catherine didn’t do anything. She may have been raped before she was married but that’s not her fault
@johngough2958
Жыл бұрын
I think you have got it! That's exactly what's happening. The jester had the distinguished role of main critic to the ruler - and was indemnified in this pursuit. Stanczyk looks like a man who realizes that he, the clown, knows and cares more about the the fate of his people than the ruler. Satire outrun by reality!
@BrainsBrainzBrains
Жыл бұрын
He was probably bummed out because he had to come up with new material
I'm so happy to have found this youtube channel! It's an absolute gem, the deep dive into certain art pieces is just fascinating and thought provoking. Thanks for making such great videos!
@MagicNash89
Жыл бұрын
Agree 100%. I've been looking for books with this same content and there are so few that actually explain the context and meaning deeply, and this is a whole youtube channel😀
@britneypennington8502
Жыл бұрын
Totally agree!!! These are so great!
@Shahzad-ss1jq
Жыл бұрын
I found it when subs where under 100k I am so happy
@TinyEpics
Жыл бұрын
Agreed!
@nedanother9382
Жыл бұрын
I'm sorry but I've listened for a good bit and thought this was really a joke....like a meme or something. A more professional non social media like version of this very painting can be found at The Canvas channel. I have no affiliation but after watching I think you'll understand why I thought this was for humor rather than a real interpretation. I mean no offense (impossible of course)
From Wikipedia: The best known anecdote about Stańczyk is that of a hunting incident. In 1533 King Sigismund the Old had a huge bear brought for him from Lithuania. The bear was released in the forest of Niepołomice near Kraków so that the king could hunt it. During the hunt, the animal charged at the king, the queen and their courtiers which caused panic and mayhem. Queen Bona fell from her horse which resulted in her miscarriage. Later, the king criticized Stańczyk for having run away instead of attacking the bear. The jester is said to have replied that "it is a greater folly to let out a bear that was already in a cage". This remark is often interpreted as an allusion to the king's policy toward Prussia which was defeated by Poland but not fully incorporated into the Crown.
@Katafrakt_
8 ай бұрын
The same Prussia which eventually partitioned Poland.
Wow that was a lot more heartbreaking than I was expecting it to be.
@Conserpov
Жыл бұрын
"They liberated their own city from our occupation" - what a tragedy.
@weareallbornmad410
Жыл бұрын
@@Conserpov Huh? Who liberated their own city? Russians? That's not how history works. Fascinating to see someone actually thinking this way, though.
@Conserpov
Жыл бұрын
@@weareallbornmad410 How does history work then? There is no dispute about Smolensk being a Russian city and its people considering this a liberation. What you are doing is bringing your own political bias into history.
Bless you for including Matejko's background. There was another art history video about this artwork in similar style, but it didn't include the most important part which was really saddening me. It's and old patriotic painting of someone longing to live in a free independent country without occupants. A country that was long gone during his time and all thanks to uncaring royalty and nobles. Keeping his background information in the video shows the true meaning behind the artist's work.
@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim
Жыл бұрын
his letter is about the Lithuanian uprising… so talk about wanting to live without occupants, bud
@ujjeshasrivastava5552
Жыл бұрын
Lol I just watches the canvas video I know what you're talking about
Your analyses are perfection. I use them to get inspo for my D&D campaigns. Thank you ma'am
This is by FAR my favorite art history channel. Thanks to all the Polish commentators for helping fill in the blanks!
Good comedians are by nature more intelligent persons than most.
What a great description of the painting ! As a Pole I want to add that in Poland we all see our history through Matejko's eyes, for instance the images of our first rulers invented by the painter are now on our banknotes. And Matejko left a huge heritage in his beloved Kraków - did you know that he designed the columns and decorations of Sukiennice (Cloth hall on the Market square) ? He, a son of a Czech father and mother from a Protestant, German minority became a huge patriot of a country that didn't even exist at that time but which had a great history - and a great future !
@Pigraider268
Жыл бұрын
Small correction: His mother was of both german and polish descent. She wasn't fully German
Maybe the inconsistencies were meant to show how events that were once so impactful and heartbreaking to everyday people become forgotten, misrepresented or inaccurately depicted by later generations.
This channel is a treasure. It’s translating classic and modern art in layman’s terms, while also giving insight into the minds of some of the world’s most famous artists. Would love to see/hear your take on Goya’s Black Paintings. Or Guernica by Picasso. I don’t care if everyone else has talked about them, it would be fun to hear YOU talk about them and dive into the historical/political contexts
It’s amazing how much a talented artist is able to say with a pose, an expression, a detail. You’ve shown me a lot more thought goes into these famous paintings then I ever realized!
You don’t just explain paintings, you allow us into the canvas where we can feel the texture of the past beneath our fingers. Awesome work!
This painting hurts. I am not Polish myself, I am Ukrainian and I feel this painting differently. The loss and frustration of this man in the painting is not in a date. Tragedies happen and shatter your world, they shock you like nothing else have ever did. And when you try to recall events or just pull yourself together it all blurs. Faces, days, events, places... they get glued together like torn crumpled pieces of paper. All messed up and hardly holding, but you cannot tell the difference anymore.
@uzytkownik15
Жыл бұрын
Stay strong, friend!
@vikusfikus4390
Жыл бұрын
@@uzytkownik15 thank you ❤️ turns out we have so many friends around the world. People I've never met make it a bit easier When we win, we will make this world a better place hopefully 🙏
@meridaskywalker7816
Жыл бұрын
I'm not really sure what to say, but I'm sending you hugs from Poland
@vikusfikus4390
Жыл бұрын
@@meridaskywalker7816 hugs received 🤗
@karolinakuc4783
Жыл бұрын
No wonder. Though Ukraine was back then just a borederland with mix of ethnicities (Polish, Russian, Ruthenian and Balkan outlavs, Jews) some Cossacks the ones that were heroes who did all in their might to stop Jews from robbing that land and closing Orthodox Christian churches suffered greatly the fall of Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth as they were forced to relocate from land they already had sprouted their roots. Some rebeled against tsar for stealing land. Ukrainians were always very attached to land they were living in. There are some who haven't moved out even from area that has been said to contain contamination from Czarnobyl explosion. They are called "samosioły".
I have watched every single one of your "explained paintings." What caught my attention was your style, what kept my attention is what I've learned. I never paid attention to this type of Art, now I'm in love. Thank you, thank you, for doing this work.
As the Grandson of a Polish woman I found this interesting, particularly the comments on it. I've never really thought of looking into Polish history, except the time my Grandmother lived through because that feels personal, might start looking into things more now.
The big red elephant in the room has completely been missed here. A jester's role is that of a wise fool. Employed by royalty to keep themselves entertained; little do the royal spectators realize that the jester whom they view as a fool is really a wise sage. They look down on him, not realizing that he is laughing back at them. His witty remarks are sage, and the wisdom he imparts flies over their heads. In this case, the jester seems beyond frustrated because he cannot get anyone to recognize the dire circumstances headed their way. They are too caught up in their hedonistic pursuits. Matejko put himself in that position because he relates to the jester. His painting consists of a warning about troubles close on the horizon, while the affluent are literally "left in the dark." The artist sees himself as equivalent to the court jester. As a jester, he is looking back at these people with scorn and ridiculing them. The jester ordinarily laughs openly towards such decadent people, allowing them to think that the joke is on him. But the jester has reached a low point and he can no longer entertain their ignorance. Matejko is completely sympathetic to the jester. The artist sees outlook and predicament of the jester as one and the same with himself. His painting mocks the affluent and they remain completely ignorant of the fact. He feels the despair and isolation of the jester. Matejko the jester is the most important character in the painting. His bright red clothing couldn't make that any more clear.
@briangoldstein3007
Жыл бұрын
exactly my friend.. the unfortunate thing for the jester is that sometimes he doesn't realize and doubts his own wisdom. He fools himself into thinking he wants what they do, inadvertently becoming their pawn in a game they can never satisfy themselves with.
Stańczyk wasn't just witty, he was also a thoroughly educated man of the renaissance - often knowing about the world and politics more than King.
Even though I’m polish and I’ve studied art history so I know that painting story and saw it many times, I can’t skip your video!
@orzelgryf
Жыл бұрын
That was the reason I was watching this video, I love listen about our culture from outsider perspective :D
@baronesselsavonfreytag-lor1134
Жыл бұрын
@@orzelgryf My impression is that Polish people have a lot of heart and soul, and have maintained their identity despite outside interference. Plus I was lucky to grow up in a heavily Polish-American town with fresh pierogi.
@Kazuki_0
Жыл бұрын
Omg siema polak
I didn't even notice the marat laying on the floor. It's so visible how anybody can imagine him dropping it out of shock.
Dude was so iconic, he became a meme before he was even painted.
I started watching every painting interpretation on this channel like 2 weeks ago. And now i got polish art episode. FeelsGoodMan.
Many people do not connect the importance of Jesters who probably became today's Comedians. They were often the conscience of general society and were able to get away with saying things that others could be hung for. I'm really enjoying your channel.
It looks like Stanczyk here is reflecting upon his reply to the King after the incident with the bear hunting (1533): "It's a greater folly to let out a bear that was already in a cage". That was a hint on losing Prussia or Smolensk.
If I were a court jester in Poland, I'd look like this every day. Very insightful video!👍
I was listening to you and with every your word I was more impressed how deep and well you have studied our history along with alegories typical for Matejko's paintings. Thank you for the great reliability of your work :)
You've made me fall in love with art history! What?! How?! Your enthusiasm is contagious, and your writing is on point as well!
I love your analysis, your editing, and your sense of humor! Amazing work.
Thank you for talking about Polish painting.
He looks like he’s thinking “in spite of all my efforts, it was in vain”
How does this channel not have more views? Amazing engaging analysis!
The thing is that Matejko is known for making 'mistakes' in his historical paintings. Painting people who couldn't had partaken in perticular events bc they were for example long dead, events taking place in wrong locations or even completely mixing two separate situations into one. It all is (mostly) intentional and all those creative liberties were taken to get specific point across or just nicer composition. If i'm not mistaken on wikipedia there are whole sections of historical inaccuracies in Matejko painting.
Wow! I truly appreciate these posts about the painting and the history of Poland. Thank you for the insights!
@MarcColten-us2pl
Жыл бұрын
excellent choice of name. always a fan
And here I was, thinking it was Rigoletto! Everything fits. The opera Rigoletto was first performed in 1851, just the right time for this painter to be inspired by it.
Please keep these coming, I love them while working, and it makes my visit to the art museum a bit more tongue in cheek!
I am absolutely loving your KZread vlogs. The paintings become even more alive after your artist bio and the effect it had on both the art community and the people on the canvas. I look forward to each and every new video. Wondering if you could do a vlog on "Le Sommeil" or "Bacchus and Ariadne?"
I am SO glad I found this channel! First, I absolutely love art. Used to be mesmerized by details on art books as a child, would spend hours looking at Bosch pieces specially, so it's amazing you bring such rich details. Second, your voice is delightful to hear, and I am very easily annoyed by voices. And finally, the humor, the amazing humor. Thank you so much!
Thanks a lot for great video. Love and peace from Poland❤️
I love how you tear every painting apart and put it back together again! It's all in the details.. thank you for your research.. from one art history teacher to another!
Poor Stanczyk, he sounds absolutely Shakespearean.
great analysis
your videos are so interesting and have really rekindled my love for art. keep up the great work!
You have a soothing voice. Just lovely
Love itttttttt Stańczyk
Your videos truly manage to analyse the story and history of a painting with great editing and humor and in less than 10 minutes, now thats amazing! This painting for example has become a meme but really anyone knew what was the story behind it nor bothered to learn. Keep making these videos there are so informative
Great art channel.. Love the lighthearted tone, yet deep dives in art history. Excellent youtubing
There's a wonderful creator on yt that uses this as a thumbnail for his channel and when I saw the image, I immediately checked your channel out. I have learned much about this painting and artist that I knew nothing about. Thank you.
I’m so happy to find that you are posting these videos regularly now. They are so entertaining and informative. Thank you!
I think there were a lot of things going on in that time period, the 1500s, in Poland. These must have reflected the artist's own experience as he lived through a similar period. Apart from all the other stuff like invasions and battles that happened in the 1500s, there was a lot of outside 'influence'. Polish politics were impacted, perhaps not always for the better as a consequence of more 'gentle' outside pressure, as well as more overt actions The treaty of perpetual peace with the Turkish ottoman empire was signed in 1533 and that treaty influenced Poland's political landscape. So, at every level Poland, whether violently or otherwise, was being coerced, battered, pushed around, squeezed and that's been the case for Poland, for a long time. Living in England, a country that was last successfully invaded and conquered almost a 1000 years ago, it's difficult to comprehend that constant infringement upon your national identity and sovereignty.
@grzegorzbrzeczyszczykiewic1139
Жыл бұрын
Well I don't agree. In 19th century Poland was under occupation. 1500's was the golden century of Poland. Economy was booming and Poland was very influential. Matejko rather points out that the problems that led to downfall of Poland began in the period of glory and power. Elites were full of vanity. They allowed Moscow to rise in power. Poland was mostly inactive in Muscovite-Lithuanian wars. Is this a right assesment? Well, to a certain degree. Poland peaked in it's power a few decades later but seeds of future decline were already there. Treaty of 1533 was a good thing for Poland because wars with Ottomans were unnessecary loss of resources.
I love how you deliver intelligent content in a humorous way. Thanks!!!💖
Great video, and I think you're right in ur implying the dates were intentional: imo, his style alone makes it clear that this was not the kind of person who would make a mistake like that.
I've always wondered about this painting! Thanks for shedding some light on it.
Wonderful!!! The painting AND the excellent explanation of the painting! I love being able to look at things a little bit deeper.
Ok, so the date on the letter: in 1514 Polish-Lithuanian Comonwealth (I'll just say Poland after this for brevity) had stronger army and better political alliances than Russia, but the king hessitated for almost 20 years to retaliate and claim Smolensk back. In that time Polish position weakened and by the time they demanded return of Smolensk and then declared war when refused, it didn't go well for Poland. Many historians see that as the start of gradual decline of political power and internal cohesion that eventually led to the Particions. The way it was taught to me in school, this painting is part of the semi-dedactic works "for bolstering spirits" after the failure of the November uprising in 1830-31 and the subsequent fragmentation and infighting among the imigrants. Artists used Polish history as a subversive way to provide role models and give warnings about past mistakes so we can avoid repeating them. So the meaning of Stańczyk, as it was taught to me, was to unify and do something "now" because waiting will do no good. Considering the failure of the January uprising (which happened about 30years later) and its conseqences, he was probably right.
LOVE your channel! Thank you so much!
I recently gotten interest in classical painting (thanks to quarantine during COVID-19) this channel is very informative. Thank you!
I am so grateful to have found your channel. Thank you for what you do.
Your voice is so full of grace. Thank you for the breakdown.
I love this channel. Constantly posting interesting documentations about art and making it interesting. True masterpiece, please keep posting.
Love the style here. Narration, pace, sound - all good.
Hey, just wanted to say that your videos are always awesome and enjoyable. The research you do is amazing and your way of presenting makes it all fun to listen to.
omg you should do sculpture next, i recommend doing The Pieta from Michelangelo it has details you can story about, the behind story of it behind christian stories, even the controversy about how Maria looks bigger than jesus while it's actually proportionate. Love the series so much
I saw the KZread channel ‘The Canvas’ talk about this paint recently lol glad to hear you say your take!
I love your videos, i am really happy that YT recommended you. Much love ❤️
When you turn up to a fancy dress party, and another party goer is dressed the same.
He's like Cassandra, the lady who was cursed by Apollo. The god of the sun gave her the power of prophecy, through which Cassandra would always foresee the future, but as a downside to this amazing skill, Apollo also cursed her to never be taken seriously whenever she warned someone about their future. I see Stanczyk sort of like mirrors this concept, in that he knows what tragedy is about to happen to Poland but nobody would believe him or laugh at him because he's a Jester..
Enjoy your vids. Always informative and insightful.
I’m echoing other comments here by saying I love your channel and content. The algorithm was looking out for me yesterday and I have been hooked ever since! Thank you!!! ❤
Woah. Thank you for making a video for this. I requested this months ago together with Juan Luna's Spolarium.
This channel opens my eyes so much. Everything about it is absolutely beautiful.
5:46 you hit that so good I couldn’t stop replaying it 😂😂😂 “why you so obsessed with me” musical 🎵
Love your videos, thanks for sharing!
He's just trying to figure out how to break the news to the king without losing his head!
My god, I so appreciate your great pronunciation of Polish names. Thank you ❤️
I love this format of your videos! They are as entertaining as they are educational. Finally an art history class I enjoy! Thank you! Subscribed!
Aren't we all Stańczyks right now?
@kilmenypl
Жыл бұрын
Yes, and it’s equally painful. We can see where we are headed… but cannot do much about it
I don’t know if this is significant… but 1533 is the birthdate of the King of Poland and Prince of Transylvania (Báthory István, who died in 1586) during Jan’s lifetime. So, maybe it was also a comment of the happens of his time period and what was happening in Transylvania and Poland at the time.
Just wanted to say I love ur videos! 😄 super happy I found your channel
I love your video and your channel. You inspire people to achieve whatever they want!
Just recently started watching your videos. Great stuff!
I love watching you explain these beautiful paintings
I used to have a colleague who clearly had a knack for drawing, and when I rhetorically asked him how he can do such and such, he would respond saying "you just draw what you see". He wasn't trying to be funny. Some people have been impressed by my skill in solving computer problems. Different people have different talents, and here, I am staggered by the skill required to be able to derive so much information from one painting. This painting, as well as others sampled in this video, is beautiful, but the narration provides much, much interesting and beautifully presented information, that I would never be able to derive on my own. This is like being introduced to a new art form that deserves serious appreciation. Thank you.
Thanks! This is what I love about the internet. An artist unknown to me, a picture I nver saw before, and all of a sudden a gate is opened to a whole new world. My theory about the historical misake: it takes away the protrait from the actual event and makes it an expression of all time when something like that happens. It transcends the actual date and event ad makes it into omething biger than that. Thanks again, this was realy worth watching.
i appreciate your honesty....keep up the good work! :)
I never knew I would be interested in these paintings since i never knew any of those would have a backstory. I always appreciated the artstyle tho. I love your channel. It made me really interested in these beautiful paintings. Now whenever i see paintings of 19th century, i delve into it to find what each element would have been representating.
He has a " wth am I doing with my life " face
There is an album cover kind of similar to this: The Jester by Dutch singer/songwriter Yorick van Norden. I happen to know him and if I get the opportunity I will ask him if he knows the painting. Edit: I recently received an email confirming that Yorick van Norden was inspired by this painting making the album cover of The Jester.
Relatable indeed! Thank you ❤️
5:41 why you so obsessed with me? my new favorite song ;) Thank you for the video!
You are so excellent explaining everything!
Thanks for an excellent video.😊