Look how blatantly the advisor to PM is avoiding the pinpointed questions. These guys don't have any answers other than blaming UPA for everything. A lost cause entirely on the Economic Front.

@kkece41

4 жыл бұрын

Agree with you.

@AshishKumar-on2ud

4 жыл бұрын

Guys please don’t ever vote for this communal Gobar bjp next time

@CharanjitSingh-on8my

4 жыл бұрын

Fully agree with you

@anonymousking2011

4 жыл бұрын

Rightly so,, not even single question he answered, he was just avoiding

As expected by us, Mr. Chidambaram answered to the point. There is none to match.

@sauravjoshi1929

4 жыл бұрын

Chidambaram and manmohan singh is to blame for the current crisis they left the banking system in a pathetic state. The loan were given to corporate without due diligence where these guys and bankers got commissions on their loans which all became the NPA so now banks don't have the money to give fresh loans. All infra real estate companies and their ancillaries don't have capital neither they are getting the loans. So there is big slow down in these sectors. There is global economic slowdown also. Auto sector will see revival after BS 6 and good monsoon will show growth in rural demand. The companies are also not doing their capex and last year was a election year govt capex was also low. Rules like Indian bankruptcy code and NCLT are helping banks to recover their loans back. they will take some time. FDI has picked up and their needs to be pickup in the sentiments for investment from pvt side where govt has done all it can do by reducing corporate taxes and all.

There are intellectuals and then there's Bibek..to balance it out..

@bAbApersianwale

4 жыл бұрын

🤣😂😂🤣😂😂😂🤣

@razenebe

4 жыл бұрын

Agree

@sreenivasanpn3506

4 жыл бұрын

WHY ALL OPPOSITION PARTIES JOINTLY GET AN APPOINTMENT WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP WHO IS VISITING INDIA 23 AND 24 AND EXPRESS THE PROBLEM AGAINST THE LAW CAA NP AND NRC as he has not on private visit

@boonslang6689

4 жыл бұрын

@@sreenivasanpn3506 That's exactly where Gujarat Trump Samman samiti comes into play. Modi sarkar ensured that the visit doesn't look like an official state to state visit but an invitation from a private ( still unknown) firm. The firm hence, has gained complete control of which, where, who, and when of this visit. if this were state to state meet, leaders of opposition will have to be invited as per protocol. GoI is a player but it's pulling the strings from background. Modi is too shaana to let anything of masala slip outta his hands. Use bs Modi+Trump dikhana hai, chahe kuch bhi krna pde.

These Modis durbaries not only incompetent in their field, they are incompetent even to hide their incompetancy

Indian politics is so much entertaining, like hell, the way that economic adviser dodged questions 🤣🤣

@maku8075

2 жыл бұрын

Let's see your government and ex government officials question by a news media not control by the CCP. 😂😂

It is impossible to defend this government's economic achievements. The frustration of the gentleman sitting next to Mr. Chidambaram is understandable. Poor guy. He exposed the Government even more.

Best show!👌 India Today keeps impressing me with every passing day with such insightful shows!❤️

The ultimate show with the ultimate minds !!! Expect for Bakbak Debroy :)

Bibek proved PC right that the patient is being treated by incompetent doctors. 😁 😁 😅

@vikrambhandolkar

4 жыл бұрын

Well said

@bAbApersianwale

4 жыл бұрын

😉👍

@mukeshranaminitinitoystori6424

4 жыл бұрын

PC is biggest looter, will surely go-to jail again. Swamy ka naam sunte hi fat jati hai

@SadiqPH

4 жыл бұрын

Mukesh Rana , You don’t have any jealousy and anger on him . So no problem .

@rigzinyuthok8527

4 жыл бұрын

Swamy is a chor. Even your step father modi is scared of him...

Venugopal Reddy stole the show. Hats off to him n his intelligent view of the topic n also his sense of humour. We need people like him in Govt.

@suheilpinto6964

4 жыл бұрын

For me bibek stole the show for ducking questions and blaming everyone.

@evelynsardinha1574

4 жыл бұрын

@@suheilpinto6964 that shows he is an escapist

We had a very decent, intellectual, professorial, visionary and exemplary patriotic PM Dr Singh. Look at what Dr Reddy said that Dr Singh invited all these economic advisors back from US in a very decent way have them space to work. That's leadership is all about and iam a big admirer of him. He is one of my role model. Dr Singh you are decent human being and we were fortunate to have you. Dr Singh was primarily responsible for bringing economics into public domain and making us question every move of the Govt.

@rigzinyuthok8527

4 жыл бұрын

Did you vote BJP and modi?

@rajendrajasathy4356

2 жыл бұрын

Dr MMS is a good economist, fully agree but not a PM material. If he would have been sticked to his expertise then the situation would have been different, but then he moved to PM office as a proxy for Sonia.

@mittemari

2 жыл бұрын

@@rajendrajasathy4356 sir so u are ok with the proxy of RSS now.

Arrogant advisor debroy kick him out he is not fit to advise economic policies .Like chidambaram and montek answered questions in polite calm and point to point manner .That idiot advisor is in denial mode now

@abganeshbabu

4 жыл бұрын

Is that cos, he kicked Rajdeep's ass. Trying to push his agenda. Stick to the book. It is book release. Sometime smartness to be brought down by insulting an journalist. He is journalist not Economist.

@javedakthar4230

4 жыл бұрын

@@abganeshbabu bhakt babu - when u don't have answers to questions ur bjps agenda brand him anti national .🤣😂😂😂 Then how chidambaram ,ahulwalia answered the questions book completely covers economy of present toooo

@kavisiddu

4 жыл бұрын

@@abganeshbabu You Remind me Bibek..

@vikrambhandolkar

4 жыл бұрын

@@abganeshbabu when you don't answers malign the person asking questions. I think anchor started of by setting the focus for the discussion. Questions were pertinent to the current econmics and hence he chose a panel of economists. Do you think Dr. Reddy is playing into Rajdeep.

@akashacharya9124

4 жыл бұрын

GST and demonetisation : yes

Bibek Debroyy has not made a single positive argument as to what are those so called "reforms" and "Talent " he is talking about.

@soonyanaidu7875

4 жыл бұрын

Like typical consultant. Never owns anything..

What a pity that our govt has people like bibek who is behaving like an eccentric to advice on our economic policies. No doubt we are going downhill with these guys at the helm.

No body can deny the contribution congress gave to this country in 1991 ,2004,2009.

@sauravjoshi1929

4 жыл бұрын

ya nobody can 1991 happened bcoz of their own socialist policies and current crisis is bcoz what they did from 2004 to 2014 to the banking sector. So ya they should be remembered for that always.

Mr Bibek is still a school student he will not answer out of the syllabus questions

@rrege1203

4 жыл бұрын

Muhammed Shaji they are discussing the book and not the current economic situation

UPA2 left in 2014 April , with a rising curve of economy! Economy(GDP/inflation/Deficit) of a country does not just change in a month or two. Once a government takes actions , then results are seen after a year! In Modi government the rising curve which was given by UPA2 continued till December-2016. Modi and his joker ministers did nothing for that! The crude price fell suddenly in 2014 when Modi came in! Pure luck which led to decrease in deficit and also increase in tax revenue! Even with all these Modi was absolutely clueless. His first major decision was Demonetization and a flawed GST in 2016-17! From then on economy has been going down post those moves. Like Gujarat lie of Modi the India story is also a big PR exercise. Gujarat was already an industrial state before Modi. He did not do shot except for 2002 riots! 2002 is his legacy and nothing else.

@sauravjoshi1929

4 жыл бұрын

rising curve i guess it was down 4-5 straight quarters. Chidambaram and manmohan singh is to blame for the current crisis they left the banking system in a pathetic state. The loan were given to corporate without due diligence where these guys and bankers got commissions on their loans which all became the NPA so now banks don't have the money to give fresh loans. All infra real estate companies and their ancillaries don't have capital neither they are getting the loans. So there is big slow down in these sectors. There is global economic slowdown also. Auto sector will see revival after BS 6 and good monsoon will show growth in rural demand. The companies are also not doing their capex and last year was a election year govt capex was also low. Rules like Indian bankruptcy code and NCLT are helping banks to recover their loans back. they will take some time. FDI has picked up and their needs to be pickup in the sentiments for investment from pvt side where govt has done all it can do by reducing corporate taxes and all.

@priyaprayog9034

4 жыл бұрын

Well said, now BJP I T cell beggars will try to defend BJP corruption, but people are no fools to listen to it.

@knightf8648

4 жыл бұрын

@@priyaprayog9034 yeah, BJP IT cell pays millions of people on internet to do their bidding. Had it not been the UPA policy paralysis,economy would have been better. UPA 1 growth rate was due to reforms and capital investment done during Bajpayee government.

BJP cannot answer a straight question. They r still in denial of economic slowdown. This BJP man is a fool. He call himself an economic advisor. If we have such people in govt who cannot see beyond their nose, we will fail miserably as this Govt has no economic reform or stability. We r in this situation becoz of such a bad economic policy as demonetisation n GST.

@sauravjoshi1929

4 жыл бұрын

Chidambaram and manmohan singh is to blame for the current crisis they left the banking system in a pathetic state. The loan were given to corporate without due diligence where these guys and bankers got commissions on their loans which all became the NPA so now banks don't have the money to give fresh loans. All infra real estate companies and their ancillaries don't have capital neither they are getting the loans. So there is big slow down in these sectors. There is global economic slowdown also. Auto sector will see revival after BS 6 and good monsoon will show growth in rural demand. The companies are also not doing their capex and last year was a election year govt capex was also low. Rules like Indian bankruptcy code and NCLT are helping banks to recover their loans back. they will take some time. FDI has picked up and their needs to be pickup in the sentiments for investment from pvt side where govt has done all it can do by reducing corporate taxes and all. GST has only hit ppl who were doing unethical practices in business.

@priyaprayog9034

4 жыл бұрын

Correct.

The hero of 1991 is in audience. Bring him on stage and then listen how he can pull this economy out of ICU.

Dr. Singh as calm as before.

Bibek Debroy has no clue wat debate is going on

@abganeshbabu

4 жыл бұрын

Debate is in English not in Arabic. It is a book launch.

@Change_willcome

4 жыл бұрын

@@abganeshbabu you didn't understand his comment.....# bhakth

@kavisiddu

4 жыл бұрын

@@abganeshbabu Every comment need not be seen through religious colors..

@pantherhjj5648

4 жыл бұрын

@@abganeshbabu Aa gaya chutya.... dharam ka thekedar

@pathouth6883

4 жыл бұрын

@@abganeshbabu why do you need to drag in language here? Don't you bhakt have any thing other than talking about religion and language.

Bibek Debroy in his ultra defensive foolish ways are only maligning the BJP govt. If he wanted to avoid the questions, he should never been on the dias. What a suffered guy.

Debroy is as arrogant as the top political brass in bjp..

Don’t worry. Patel statue will pour jobs

@abhaythakur955

3 жыл бұрын

yes it will boost indian tourism and tourism boost economy

@adharsh1300

3 жыл бұрын

@@abhaythakur955 🤣🤣

Pranab Mukherjee played the role of 'The Enemy Within' PERFECTLY by passing the highly UNNECESSARY '3rd stimulus package ! He did it out of spite ! Bcos he KNEW that he was going to be removed from the finance ministry for poor performance and WANTED to inflict max Economic damage on his way OUT in the form of that 3rd stimulus package and retrospective taxation policy !

@sauravjoshi1929

4 жыл бұрын

and don't forget same Chidambaram and manmohan singh is to blame for the current crisis they left the banking system in a pathetic state. The loan were given to corporate without due diligence where these guys and bankers got commissions on their loans which all became the NPA so now banks don't have the money to give fresh loans. All infra real estate companies and their ancillaries don't have capital neither they are getting the loans. So there is big slow down in these sectors. There is global economic slowdown also. Auto sector will see revival after BS 6 and good monsoon will show growth in rural demand. The companies are also not doing their capex and last year was a election year govt capex was also low. Rules like Indian bankruptcy code and NCLT are helping banks to recover their loans back. they will take some time. FDI has picked up and their needs to be pickup in the sentiments for investment from pvt side where govt has done all it can do by reducing corporate taxes and all.

After listening Bibek's first reply i just skipped Bibek Debroy's reply, bcs he is arrogant, not willing to answer any question seriously.

@anirudh_dh

4 жыл бұрын

@Amit Roshan 😂😂

@rajeshkannan886

4 жыл бұрын

@Amit Roshan 😂😂😂😂

@yogeshmishra3320

4 жыл бұрын

U listen what suits your inclinations, listening to other side and then fairly analyzing takes some fair and unbiased mind, something which is always cumbersome for few people.

@anirudh_dh

4 жыл бұрын

@@yogeshmishra3320 I agree with you great extent, but i think people like debate without being aggressive, you can counter their points without being arrogant. I always admired Arun Jaitley bcs he never tried to go below the belt.

@AshishKumar-on2ud

4 жыл бұрын

Entire bjp like this. Incompetent goons

I think debroy was acting as like as sambit patra

@SunilKumar-pv2il

4 жыл бұрын

The only difference is sambit is for street and debroy is for seat.

@odesau2b

4 жыл бұрын

And Sambit has the word 'caveat' And Debroy being economist uses 20 pages epilogue!!!!!!!

Dr Manmohan Singh is still calm. Still one of the best P. M ever in India.

Is Vivek DebRoy really serious? Or he is trying to avoid serious questions?

Govt doesn't seem very keen on talking about current situation

Bibek is pm economic advisor than how can we think govt is going to do anything better .....with a PM with MA in entire political science 😂

@KishanKumar-fw5ug

4 жыл бұрын

then what about gandhi dynasty ?

@riplex215

4 жыл бұрын

Atleast they were doing a better job ruling..

Really is it debate in this present time🧐?? Why other channels doesn't learn from this debate..... they're just entertaining channels only!!!

MODI is not interested in your money discussion plz talk about Pakistan.

@MillionairesClub2023

4 жыл бұрын

He is but he is not educated on the subject or any subject but on subject of pakistan .

@utubetruthteller

4 жыл бұрын

And rightly so because security matters most even more than economy.

@priyaprayog9034

4 жыл бұрын

Who cares, people need job not war, tell corrupt Modi to resign.

@elpatron7218

4 жыл бұрын

@@priyaprayog9034 then who manage? rahul gandhi who is already weak in maths..even in iQ 🤣🤣

@abhaythakur955

3 жыл бұрын

@@priyaprayog9034 people also need safe india not only jobs.becoz if india is not safe from outsiders then how can u expect jobs.UPA doesnt focus on india safety issues thats why 26/11 and others terror activities happened

Mr. Bibek doesn't obviously have any answers to the questions he was asked.

accept the current slowdown

What an ensemble cast of intellectual. Great discussion with utmost dignity.

Prsent govt is filled with Gobarnomics UPA govt was filled with Economics

@sauravjoshi1929

4 жыл бұрын

Chidambaram and manmohan singh is to blame for the current crisis they left the banking system in a pathetic state. The loan were given to corporate without due diligence where these guys and bankers got commissions on their loans which all became the NPA so now banks don't have the money to give fresh loans. All infra real estate companies and their ancillaries don't have capital neither they are getting the loans. So there is big slow down in these sectors. There is global economic slowdown also. Auto sector will see revival after BS 6 and good monsoon will show growth in rural demand. The companies are also not doing their capex and last year was a election year govt capex was also low. Rules like Indian bankruptcy code and NCLT are helping banks to recover their loans back. they will take some time. FDI has picked up and their needs to be pickup in the sentiments for investment from pvt side where govt has done all it can do by reducing corporate taxes and all. go read about bank npa and see the balance sheets of the companies of infra and real estate two major job providers to unskilled labor in india.

@CaughtOffiside

4 жыл бұрын

So PC has told FM to break the loans which had given in upa nda regime and had became npa 😂🤣🤣still no answer my dear friend and so why did present govt did give concession in tax cut to corporates

@sauravjoshi1929

4 жыл бұрын

​@@CaughtOffiside Tax cut are given to revive capex of the private sector and to increase profits so that they don't feel the pressure of the slowdown and to increase jobs and to increase investment in india. they were given by PC only in the upa regime go check the balance sheets of the companies where they are now and what has happened to them and what has happened to PSU banks because of these loans. Now banks can desolve assets and recover loans or sell the assets in NCLT to improve their balance sheets. Real estate and infrastructure are major source of the employment for unskilled labour in india.

@CaughtOffiside

4 жыл бұрын

Bjp kare toh chamatkar aur kohi kare toh aattyachar...ok then please tell FM to show all loans to public dud ka dud aur pani ka pani..she is our finance minister she should tell to all indians and not secretly to you

@sauravjoshi1929

4 жыл бұрын

@@CaughtOffiside it is there in the their balance sheets go check on money control or et now each bank's npa and companies loans.

Bibek is doing all escapism

@vinaychaudhary8629

4 жыл бұрын

And that is usp of present regime:escapism

Nation should debate like this on economy, health, environment, agriculture, unemployment, infrastructure, education, inclusiveness, gender equality etc. Not on unnecessary Hindu Muslim narrative.

I think the conference was about the book and that was why Bibek Debroy had agreed to come. Rajdeep being Rajdeep shifted the topic completely to the present economic slowdown. Maybe that's why he got pissed off.

This is India with BJP running under it. What Chidambaram is saying could be be expressed by the couplet: Bas aek hi ullu kaafi tha, barbad gulistaan karne ko: Har shaakh pe ullu baetha hae, anjaame gulistaan kya hoga?

Vivek deb Roy is trying to preserve his position in govt. He is not required as advisor to repair economy. He has to go.

@raydharmesh

4 жыл бұрын

Dr Y V Reddy excellently defined the current stagflation in the Indian economy

5:45 missing him

BJP never accepts their mistakes only says Jawaharlal Nehru makes mistakes.

@aaron7960

4 жыл бұрын

@New BJP is a party with a huge difference in many areas .

@ratan1686

4 жыл бұрын

Do not listen to politicians or media people. Be your own judge. Ask yourself why is the stock market gaining new heights year after year. We cannot all be economists, but atleast we should look out for such barometers. There is slowdown globally but we still manage to clock 5 plus growth rate and that is an achievement in itself

@aaron7960

4 жыл бұрын

@@ratan1686 you are Right the Media was the one who Inflated Modi in 2014 . Now it's his turn same fate as Congress.

@uditvk4623

4 жыл бұрын

@@ratan1686 yeah..thats y there is hike in unemployment...vodafone idea bsnl mtnl hal ongc air india...all are at a brink of breaking.. Juz look at the statistics..where the entire economy of india is in yhe hands of.... If there is economy slowdown..just accept it...dont pit the blame on the previous govts..

I dont know why educated class of india voted for modi🤔

@ponraja1

4 жыл бұрын

drugged with fake nationalism and right wing Hindusiam

@riplex215

4 жыл бұрын

Dream of a utopia called hindu rashtra

Dr subramanian swamy should be there on stage for discussion.

Y v reddy made real sense to me!!

@ashraf6202

4 жыл бұрын

Cz he is your uncle

@shaharukhnadaf7084

4 жыл бұрын

Y V REDDY AND D. SUBBARAO......R GREAT...

No answer to Shri.chidambarams questions!

Govt in denial still shocking 😵

Why is the person on the extreme right so RUDE ?? ALSO he seems incapable of a NORMAL SENSIBLE response to ANY ques !

@angryman5517

4 жыл бұрын

cuz he from bjp

Modi do not know about economy as he is not qualified and experienced economist. Many of his Ministers are also like him. Therefore they are bothered their seats and not for India's development.

PM''s economic advisor has avoided all the questions .

Thanks to Mr.Bibek, now we understand why economy is slowing down.

Bibek is shaming his own govt by saying young economist are not coming to India lately because govt does not want learned people this govt they do not need advise

@ajitreddy2382

4 жыл бұрын

Sanket Kulkarni first of all , what’s wrong in criticising own govt !! This is democracy brother not fascism! There is no mention in constitution that those who are in govt need not question ! Why 1991 reforms were successful becoz then govt accepted brw this govt is still in denial!!

@sanketkulkarni2390

4 жыл бұрын

ajit reddy LoL you dint get sarcasm he is not aware he is criticising without knowing he is criticising

Bibek is not expressing to his heart but someone is controlling him Bjp

Bibek proves he is on BJP side the way he answers the logical questions 😂

Rajdeep ..... rocking yaar💥💥

Oh man !!!! If that man Bibek is PM's economic adviser. We are in deep waters. He is dodging every question !!!

And prime minister manmohan watches the critism sitting in the front row ... Could not imagine this (humility) happen with even bjp corporation counselor ..

For India development...we need Focus on economy..

bad attitude of Bibek pisses me off. why dont they just accept the fact and proceed.

@ppd27575

4 жыл бұрын

bpgrmds because it will mean admitting to mistakes and giving up the gaddi

Debroy seems he is sliding into senility....

Mr. Chidambaram straight calls the gentleman sitting next to him as incompetent. What the gentleman would do.

Raj deep should have welcomed prime minister manmohan singh and acknowledged his presence

Awesome guests and the awesomest journalist 👌👌👌👌

I don't understand y in every such debate dr.singh is invited just to sit in the audience and clap!??.y isn't he invited on stage and asked to give feedback??..he was one of the architects of the 1991reforms..I hate seeing him treated like he isn't important

Bibek Debroy is making a glorious fool of himself.

Bibek bak bak debroy is eager for Ghar Wapsi of economist😂😂

Including PC is a shame. I don't think anyone other than Rajdeep will ever call PC a crook

Seriously? Bibek is a PM economic advisor??? Dumb guys are sitting there and making nonsense over the Broadcasting Channel about their incompetency in handling the economy...? Mr P Chidambaram is the only person I liked hearing to while this whole debate...

The present Modi-Shah Govt progressing towards economic slowdown to breakdown with collapsing mission. Congratulations to Modi-Shah BJP-RSS Govt

What is that bjp person talking about? It make no sense

Yv Reddy 👏👏👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏

Bibek kya maar kar aaya hai sabko bataye!😂😂

@shaharukhnadaf7084

4 жыл бұрын

Same question from me.....

@vinaychaudhary8629

4 жыл бұрын

I think gaumutra with gobar topping

@GurpreetSingh-iv1ur

4 жыл бұрын

Hahhah

I would say a lost decade, if it stops there, for india, in terms of economy and democracy.

Why this BJPs and their Advisors shouts soo much?

@pathouth6883

4 жыл бұрын

Because they don't have answers to the questions.

@rtikku9580

4 жыл бұрын

The anchor is trying to set an agenda and fix him in a corner. He however is giving back in equal measure.

@priyaprayog9034

4 жыл бұрын

Bcs they are no.1 corrupters,

Where's subramaniam swamy!!!!!!!

Great show to see.

Ordered the book. Cant wait to read it!

Well Conversation I have watched after longer time , thanks Rajdeep Sir

Rajdeep: What do think of Economy today? Debroy: Lets only discuss book Rajdeep: Is INdia's economy is in the downfall? Debroy: Lets only discuss book Rajdeep: Who are you ? Debroy: Lets only discuss book

@harry-xo3tq

2 жыл бұрын

He picked up the book up to 25 times..

Why is GOVT rep not talking sense

Mr Chidambaram, Savage ☺😁

Great economic minds discussing with Sambit Patra of Economics.

Hopeless Bibek👿

Key element..

Mr derby should take up AIR radio jockey

What a decent debate in this present days with such distinguished panel except one person in the panel.

Had high hopes but ppl are just playing too safe all the time!

Credit is sputtering......

What Debroy want to say? Isn't it having any answers

So first comment, why is not Dr MMS on panel as he is economist where as Chidambaram is just a lawyer.

I am typing without even watching because I saw Chidambaram so I am sure it must be something to watch out for.

@srividyadhardantu6

4 жыл бұрын

Watch out , he is crook

@waseem196

4 жыл бұрын

@@srividyadhardantu6 I totally agree with crook part but that doesn't take away his intellectual genius on economics

@Change_willcome

4 жыл бұрын

@@srividyadhardantu6 still still bhkath🤣

@srividyadhardantu6

4 жыл бұрын

@@waseem196 I agree

@anirbanbhattacharya2874

4 жыл бұрын

@@waseem196 he was an average student from privileged family, not brilliant. He was not even a brilliant crook, proved by his going to jail.

Bibek ...has no Vivek.

One if the so important episode

Peculiar position

46:20 LOL!

Correction : demonitization and not demonization.

RIP PV narsimha rao........ Dropped by to listen to sri yv Reddy. I am not a filthy to the core congress or bjp supporter but I can see in comment section hatred for people who support bjp etc. Jai hind.

I am afraid that this government will not be able to handle this crisis. However they will still blame the congress and the rest of the world and muslims for this. They will then start fomenting fear that only they can save India and not others. My fear is that a majority of people might fall for this marketing jhumla again. Oh wait, that already happened !