The Best Submariner Homage, Until It Wasn’t - Sugess Submariner Review
Тәжірибелік нұсқаулар және стиль
SUGESS SUBMARINER V2 ► s.click.aliexpress.com/e/_Dlf...
Today, we're gonna dive deep with a watch review of the Sugess Submariner - an affordable automatic watch vying for the title of being one of the best Rolex Submariner homages on AliExpress.
There are a ton of submariner homages from brands like Pagani Design, San Martin, Cronos, and more - so how will this Sugess Submariner v2 / Sugess Seaman stack up to them?
If you're on a budget, you'll be stoked to know that the Sugess Ocean Star is one of the best submariner alternatives under $200.
Don’t forget to check out the sale prices for this and other affordable watches during the 2023 March AliExpress Sale that’s happening now! You may just get a killer deal.
***************************************
Follow me on Instagram : / wristwatching_yt
Collaboration inquiries : wristwatching1989@gmail.com
DISCLAIMER : The "includes paid promotion" tag you might see in some of my videos means I got sent the watch for free or at a discount so I could do a review on it. But don't worry, I wasn't paid or anything like that - all my opinions are totally my own!
Some links are affiliate links. Purchasing through these links will help support the channel at no extra cost. Thank you!
Timestamp:
0:00 - Introduction & background
0:20 - Price & Colours
0:35 - Packaging
0:56 - Dimensions
1:10 - Case
2:11 - Bezel
3:00 - Crystal
3:12 - Dial, hands & indices
4:07 - Lume
4:40 - Seiko NH35 Automatic Movement
4:49 - Trouble in paradise
5:25 - Bracelet & Clasp
6:28 - Likes
7:27 - Dislikes
8:03 - Summary
#aliexpresssale2023 #submarinerhomage #watches
Пікірлер: 141
I just got my second one and it seems they've figured out the crown. More Sub than my Cronos and it doesn't have the unreliable PT5000, I've broken several. Thanks for the great review.
@WristWatching
7 ай бұрын
Great to know it's been fixed! There were multiple reports of the crown issue around the time I had mine, I guess it was probably a bad batch. Pinning your comment so others know this. 🙂
@davidbarclay3651
7 ай бұрын
The hands on mine are perfect and the movement of the bezel is perfect, no back play and great feel, like a real Sub.
@Gr1mR34p3r85
6 ай бұрын
@@WristWatching They fixed nothing, their QC is very bad. On mine that I just got the bezel is very hard to turn when it comes to 6 o'clock. And the crown is very hard to unscrew and screw, plus it doesn't screw all the way in, I can still see half a mm. Even Pagani Design has the crown figured out, it screws like butter. But otherwise I can see quality to it, even the edges of the clasp are nicely rounded and polished. If they could up the QC on bezel and crown, it would be almost the same quality as a 500€ Clean factory replica. And it's a PITA to return it as I paid 72€ for customs and I will have to pay 11€ for return shipping, and they will only return me 197€ out of 280€. Last time I buy a 150€+ watch on AE, I thought I learned my lesson with two Octopus Kraken watches which were just as bad. Seestern S434 which is also on the way to me is my last hope to get a good 200-300€ AE watch.
@Ott0vonBismarck
5 ай бұрын
How does it compare to the Cronos l6005?
@davidsonviray1403
4 ай бұрын
How about the lume compared to the san martin and cronos sub?
I got their Top Chronometer watch on April 2023. Watch stopped working around November of the same year. Sent back to Sugess on December for warranty repair. Been following up on when I can get it back ever since. It's March now and all the response I got is "we'll keep you posted". Don't waste your money on this brand, it's not worth it.
@WristWatching
4 ай бұрын
That's disappointing to hear, especially since they've had your watch for a few months. Hope you get it sorted out soon!
@MrJumpol48
3 ай бұрын
Did your watch use SL-480 Peacock movement(Clone 4130 Daytona)? I plan to order it too, I heard this is a solid movement.
Great video. The stem was cut a little too short and that's why it actuated the date when unscrewing it. Yeah it sucks but you can order the stem for a few dollars. It's a little tricky to install it but that would probably fix all the issues
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
Thanks a lot! Yeah it was probably the stem length. I was hesitant to replace just the stem, because my movement accuracy starting going wild after a week or so. Thought there may be something else wrong with it besides just the stem.
I think the rehaut absolutely makes this watch. Such a cool minor detail, and it's enough for me to try a Sugess over the other homages.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
It’s a bit of a mixed bag, some love it but some hate it. I found that detail cool too!
Thank you for your detailed and objective review! Also, such high quality resolution vid! Because of you, I got me one. Can’t wait to enjoy it!
Great review man, no unnecessary drama, straight to the point.
Just bought the Sugess GMT Tudor homage. Can’t wait to get it. You should try to grab it for review. You were very unlucky with this one for sure. I have the same issue with the Serica homage. PT5000 movement just stopped working. Will probably replace it myself as can’t be arsed to return it
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
I have the Sugess GMT on the way! The Serica homage looks amazing but I just couldn’t pull the trigger on it. Good luck with your movement replacement, that’ll be a fun project!
I have a seestern monster and it works perfectly. I also have the sugess moonphaser on the way and the seestern gs homage. I haven't heard of any issues with the movements just that at times bezel is light..
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
That’s great to know, I’ve heard only good things about Sugess/Seestern before my experience. Would love to check out the Seestern 62MAS homage soon too.
"But as you and I know, that's not how this hobby works" - a very true statement 😂😂😂. Nice review bro! From MY with love.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
Just stating facts ahaha. I’m missing MY so much, thanks a lot man! 🙏🏽
So, this Sugess or the San Martin SN0111? Which would you choose and why?
@WristWatching
5 ай бұрын
I haven’t had that specific SM model, but the Sugess is more accurate to a modern sub and it comes in significantly cheaper, especially during sales. I still think it’s the best modern sub homage out there.
I ordered another one. This is by far the best value. Your reviews are great. Such a great voice and accent.
@WristWatching
8 ай бұрын
Haha you’re going to have a collection of Sugess subs
@DJSIC82
2 ай бұрын
are these watches reliable for swimming?
Torned between this or the ixdao engineer for my only watch which do you think will fit my wrist gracefully? My wrist i think is between 6.4 to 6.6 inch
@WristWatching
3 ай бұрын
We have similar wrist sizes so I think you can get away with both, but they might be near the limit for you.
@davidsonviray1403
Ай бұрын
Which do you think is better finish this? Or the ixdao engineer? And more bigger on wrist?
Ive yet to experience a bad sugess you definitely should try their daytona homage housing a clone 7750 its incredible
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
I've heard nothing but great things about Sugess, I was probably just unlucky. Their Daytona homage looks amazing, but I'm not fan of the Daytona style in general.
@davidbarclay3651
8 ай бұрын
I have 3 of them. Hard to read the time but they do get attention.
A pleasing spoken voice and nice review.
@WristWatching
11 ай бұрын
Thanks so much!
I was watching this video wearing my Submariner 124060! So interesting to see everything the homage does right as well as the things it does wrong. The bracelet, clasp, and case dimensions are spot on. I have no doubt it's just as comfortable as a Submariner. Even the shape of the crown guards was nailed down. The bezel action sounds almost identical to a Submariner's (even if the Sugess has backplay). The finishing is just as good even if the dial has imperfections. I think the movement even ticks at the same frequency as a Submariner. Things the Submariner does better is the date window numerals, they're perfectly crisp and not porous. And, of course, you don't get the Rolex Oystersteel, in-house movement, and quality control. But the Sugess seriously looks the part, maybe 75% of the way there!
@WristWatching
3 ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing your take as a Rolex owner! That’s incredible to hear.
I bought a PD EXPLORER 2 HOMAGE. It looked and felt great. And it worked for four days then quit. They were good about a refund but it took a long time. Sad to say but no more Chinese watches for me. If you've had good luck with them then great, I'm glad it worked out for you.
@WristWatching
6 ай бұрын
That's a bummer. I guess it really is the luck of the draw with these things. I've been pretty lucky so far, I've purchased over 30 Chinese watches and I only had issues with 2 of them.
It has a quick date shot when it hits midnight?thanks
@WristWatching
3 ай бұрын
The date on the NH35 movement doesn’t instantly change. It slowly changes across 4-5 hours.
Nice review. Bummer about the movement. That’s always a concern of mine when looking at a homage watch using a Seiko movement. I know the movement will be fine but less sure about the installation of that movement. Hopefully it’s not a QC problem. Looking forward to seeing more of your videos.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
Thanks so much mate! I definitely got a lemon. A few people on Reddit mentioned they’re having the same issue with their ST2130 version. I’m guessing it was probably a bad batch of crowns that were cut too short by Sugess, affecting both their NH35 and ST2130 sub models.
Are the parts of the gen submariner compatible with sugess?
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
Highly doubt it
That first package looked like a great extra. 👍
I have two of these, they are both perfect.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
I was really unlucky with the QC on my unit
Great review!! Thanks!!
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
Thanks for watching!
Don’t feel bad I had a SW200 crap out in a Invicta 9937. I’m partial to the Steeldive. I don’t think the other more expensive homages are “that” much better. Another point, who came up with the name? They should get whoever did a new job like making pizzas or something.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
That’s a bummer, the SW200 is a solid movement. I guess we all get the ocasional lemon. I haven’t tried the Steeldive Sub, but I’ve heard great things about it.
@akpistol141
Жыл бұрын
@@WristWatching The part that is threaded broke away. I used to be a real watch snob. After seeing that I lost faith in the Swiss. Invicta just drops the movement in. Unless they are buying 2nd quality
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
@@akpistol141 I had a great experience with the SW200 on my Steinhart. Then again, their QC process and customer service is probably much better than Invicta. Not sure how Invicta is sourcing their movements though, definitely food for thought. Thanks for sharing your experience!
Hay i also bought the watch and the bracelet broke and after i made a dispute they offered me refund after sending it back but i don’t trust them anymore. How did it go qith your refund?
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
I got my full refund. Sugess have great customer service from what I’ve heard. I’m sure they will sort you out. How did the bracelet break by the way?
@schwainerschinkler5664
Жыл бұрын
@@WristWatching when i was wearing the watch it just suddenly felt loose and when i looked down i couldn’t close the clasp. By the way did you had to send the watch back to them or did you just got your refund ?
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
@@schwainerschinkler5664 That’s terrible luck. I had to send my watch back. The whole process from shipping it back to receiving the refund in my account took about a month.
Hello, do you know the dial size ? Hope its 28.5mm
@WristWatching
6 ай бұрын
I don’t have this watch with me anymore, but reach out to Sugess. I’m sure they’ll be able to let you know.
Did you have any issue with yours, or was I just unlucky with my unit?
@emersonsurigao8142
Жыл бұрын
Mine arrived 3weeks ago. So far still working okay, the fit is excellent. I bought the NH35 movement
loved this one! Please review the Cronos submariner l6005!! I would love to hear your thoughts on it
@WristWatching
5 ай бұрын
Haha I honestly got bored of sub homages. I’ve had too many of them, so I don’t think I’ll be reviewing another anytime soon. From what I’ve heard though, the Sugess is more accurate than that Cronos.
@Ott0vonBismarck
5 ай бұрын
@@WristWatching haha. Thank you for ththe information, I love the vudros
@WristWatching
5 ай бұрын
@@Ott0vonBismarck Thanks man, and good luck deciding!
@Ott0vonBismarck
5 ай бұрын
@@WristWatching Thanks, I just revived my cronos like a week ago, just wanted to hear your thoughts on it. my only conern/complaint is that the lugs are a bit too thick and chunky looking. Its a bit more exaggerated than the supercase
Why didn’t you contact Sugess? Their customer service dept is pretty good. And it’s hard to fault Sugess when it clearly is an issue with a seiko movement. You should look at the version of this watch with the seagull st2130 movement.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
It was still under the free return period, so it was easier to go through that process while I still had buyer protection. Someone else mentioned to me that their ST2130 version had the same problem, so it’s probably an issue with the crown stem being cut too short. We could be the outliers though, I’ve generally heard great things about Sugess QC.
@wittech6116
Жыл бұрын
@@WristWatching I have the version with a nh35, and it’s been perfect. Stem is definitely not too short. Has a nice “pop” when you unscrew the crown to the first position. I have the st2130 version on the way and plan to do a comparison video.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
@@wittech6116 looking forward to the comparison video!
"That's not how this hobby works." So true 😂
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
Let’s not kid ourselves 🤣
All KZreadrs start showing the bezel action and the sounds that come with it. None show the water dive test. It's odd.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
I don’t dive, but I take my watches in the shower no problem. A pressure testing machine is expensive, and most commercial ones only test up to 60M of water resistance. Gary from ‘I Like Watches’ has one if you’re interested to check some of his videos out.
@amangrayfilms1538
Жыл бұрын
@@WristWatching Thanks
They should have made it without the date modification. Most people l talk to prefer a clean dial no date, like myself. All Submariner homage watches should be released in a non date first and foremost, date version secondary, as the original Rolex Submariner had no date.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
That would be amazing. I love the no date look, but there aren’t many good homage options out there. Cronos does a no date option of their modern Sub homage though, check that out!
@guntergiersch1245
Жыл бұрын
Invicta hast the Vintage 1953 as a Homage top the early Rolex Submariner. Ist's a very beautyful Watch!
I hope they do a GMT. I have a Cronos, but it has the HG movement. Would love to see the new Miyota in one, but NH34 would be alright.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
I’m in the same boat. Can’t wait to see the Miyota making its way to AliExpress watches. But like you, I think I’d snap up one of these with a NH34 movement too. Hope that’s in their pipeline!
Same thing happened to mine Unwinding the crown caused the date to change and the hands
@WristWatching
10 ай бұрын
Damn, did they sort you out with a refund/replacement?
@davidbarclay3651
10 ай бұрын
No yet. I just submitted it.
@WristWatching
10 ай бұрын
@@davidbarclay3651 Hope the process goes smoothly!
@danielhovet5675
8 ай бұрын
@@davidbarclay3651any update?
@robyee3325
3 ай бұрын
@@WristWatchingdid you ever get your new one? Did it have the same problem?
Bummer. I have one Chinese one (the Sugess moon phase panoramic date with small seconds) and two Russian ones (old Molnija manual winding movements in new but basic display-back cases). All of them run 100% fine, zero issues. Quality control is non existing though. So I get my local watch guy to give them a quick service which he often just does for free (I use him for all my other watch needs : waterproof seals and battery replacements etc etc).
@WristWatching
8 ай бұрын
That's incredible! I wish I had a local watch guy who's comfortable working with Chinese/Russian movements. I'd take punts on so many other watches.
Great looking watch, but why on gods earth did they put Seaman on the dial....literally.....
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
Lost in translation 🤣
Hopefully pegani design and San Martin are better
I find it hilarious that the model number is "SU126610LV". I mean... that's gotta be peak "clomage"
@WristWatching
9 ай бұрын
I never realized that 🤣
Is this watch comfortable to wear?
@WristWatching
3 ай бұрын
I generally don’t like the comfort of Sub style cases, but this was a bit more comfortable than Sub cases I’ve tried from other brands.
Except the bamboo logo.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
Bamboo? 🤔
How bout the Ginault?
@WristWatching
7 ай бұрын
I haven’t held one in the flesh, but from what I’ve seen they’re fantastic watches. They cost well above this though. Not many people want to spend $1000 or more on a homage.
SteelDive 1953
@WristWatching
11 ай бұрын
That's a great choice below the $100 mark, but the build quality on this Sugess is a few levels above that.
Did you own a Cronos?
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
That’s probably one of the few AliExpress brands I haven’t tried out. Do you have their sub homage?
@YannickKhong
Жыл бұрын
@@WristWatching yup! Got their latest sub date with blue bezel black dial pt5000. I was shopping between the sugess, San martin and cronos. I prefered the typography of the cronos dial so I went with it.
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
@@YannickKhong I love the PT5000. The smoother sweep just makes the watch feel much more refined. Enjoy your Cronos!
@ericarghirudis3462
Жыл бұрын
i own the l6005 blue - absolutely beautiful color and matching bezel- but the case overhang the bezel at 2 and 4 o'clock and it makes the watch wear bigger, also the date magnification is not enough. I would like to try the sugess/ seestern, it surely wears better. besides that the dial of a cronos is a thing of beauty. I strongly advise that blue enamel dial. you can see what I mean on the ' back in time' vidéo about the l 6005 on the wrist shot around 8,30 mns ( case protrudes at 2 and 4)
Did you have to mail back the lemon?
@WristWatching
7 ай бұрын
Yes, returned it via Aliexpress and got a refund. It was within the 15-day free return period.
squale and steinhart are significantly better but you will pay between $500 to $1000.00
@WristWatching
5 ай бұрын
Significantly more expensive though. Check out my video comparison of this Sugess vs my Steinhart, might be interesting for you.
Invicta homage?
@WristWatching
3 ай бұрын
Epic 🤣
sugess what a name , impossibe😂
When you sent the watch back, at what cost was it?
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
They had a 15 day free return policy with this specific store/item. I managed to raise a dispute with AliExpress and send it back for free on day 14.
@waris3732
Жыл бұрын
@@WristWatching so was the parcel and tracking number etc already paid for when you got to your post office/logistics company?
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
@@waris3732 Yup! AliExpress sent me a shipping label. I printed that out and dropped the package off at a local logistics company without any charges. Check out listings that have the ‘Free Return’ feature near the shipping details on the app. Those qualify for these free returns within 15 days of receiving the product.
@waris3732
Жыл бұрын
@@WristWatching I guess the only kink here is that you need to file a dispute with AliExpress and they need to resolve it within 15 days of receiving the watch. Very informative, thanks
@xenonny
8 ай бұрын
@@WristWatching Are u located in Europe?
Seaman 🤭
It’s possibly not the best homage then?
@WristWatching
9 ай бұрын
I was unlucky, I got a lemon
@lordcharfield4529
9 ай бұрын
@@WristWatching Ah okay…….only teasing - I enjoyed the video - great narrative and beautiful photography - subscribed- many thanks 🙏
@WristWatching
9 ай бұрын
@@lordcharfield4529 All good mate, it's hard to get sarcasm across on text haha.Thanks so much, and welcome aboard!
@lordcharfield4529
9 ай бұрын
@@WristWatching Thank you very much 🙏 Agreed re written text. My initial comment wasn’t very funny at all, with the benefit of hindsight! 😊
can you swim with this watch?
Would you rather have a sterile crown
@WristWatching
3 ай бұрын
I’ve reached a stage of my watch collecting journey where I don’t really care anymore 🤣
@richardvacanti9428
3 ай бұрын
@@WristWatching same here
cronos can be better than suggess sub
@WristWatching
Жыл бұрын
I definitely need to try the Cronos soon!
@dylanglyn
Жыл бұрын
Sorry but I've had all the homages..and the Cronos isn't even close to the sugess..get it with the high beat ST2130 and it even has the perfect magnification of the date wheel.. only thing spoiling it is the name .but if you're grown up it's fine...bit like TRUMP in the UK means fart..not far off the truth!!!
It’s still not the real thing, it’s a POS. Do not waste your money.
@WristWatching
11 ай бұрын
In all fairness, I don't want the real thing, and I couldn't afford it even if I did. This works for me.
I'm sorry, but I find it hilarious that a watch that looks almost identical to the original is called hommage. Near copy doesn't sound as nice. But even more hilarious is that folks actually expect these to last. You crack me up.