Someone here HAS to be able to get Rick in a room with Paul. I can see Paul enjoying it - a win for everyone!

@darrellstyner0001

7 ай бұрын

He's had Ringo's drummer on several times. I think it's time to sit down with Ringo, Paul, and, while we're at it, Joe Walsh.

@Alpha_7227

7 ай бұрын

Or George Martin's son to talk about production and engineering.

@jjk8417

7 ай бұрын

Amen

@JulesFox

7 ай бұрын

Agreed

@snidelywhiplash

7 ай бұрын

No kidding - Rick asks questions nobody else seems to. Bet Paul would dig it.

What staggers me is that McCartney did some good songs after the Beatles; Lennon did some good songs after the Beatles - but when they were together, always competing, always trying to outdo one another, they were absolutely insurmountable, inexplicable, just sublime perfection. Their competition created auditory beauty that has yet to be (and may never be) surpassed. xx

@christopherw3490

7 ай бұрын

I agree with your statement completely!

@manciano2009

7 ай бұрын

I would add that George Harrison made good music on his own, but when he had Paul and John and Ringo next to him the atmospheres (the Beatles atmosphere) was unsurpassed. The magic was provided by the group. Even at the time of sharing solo songs like Julia or Blackbird, there were still the bandmates to be accountable to: accountable for quality. If one imagines George's All Things Must Pass played by the Beatles, one swoons. And the same happens with McCartney or Plastic ono band. The magic was given by a truly magical balance of talents and personalities.

@nelsonpg2070

6 ай бұрын

Very good explanations!pg from Brazil.

January 1967. They recorded this in January 1967. This is less than four years after they released Please Please Me. I don’t know of musical evolution that fast, and not revolution but evolution, it’s demonstrably linear, anywhere in music. I don’t mean just rock. I’ve got experience in a lot of non-rock genres, I have a decent classical background that includes early music, but I’ve never seen evolution that far that fast anywhere. I don’t know if another example exists in human history.

@Khayyam-vg9fw

7 ай бұрын

The nearest thing I can think of is the transition in the early 1940s from swing to bop.

@sweptinblack

7 ай бұрын

Great post. What's crazier to think of, is Love me Do to I am the Walrus. Insane level of evolution as you said, in similar amount of time. It's one thing to follow others, but to be the biggest musicians in the world and do it from nothing.

@comradeozzbug

7 ай бұрын

I would actually describe it as a revolution. It was a paradigm shift. I think it can be comparable to the shift from Newtonian physics to Einsteinian physics.

@jodithomas9303

7 ай бұрын

Exactly. Perfectly articulated 🔥

@christopherw3490

7 ай бұрын

As a classically trained musician, I have always been interested in artistic growth.

A day in the life still sounds original even In 2023

@adrianokury

7 ай бұрын

Or especially in 2023...

@aurum1235

7 ай бұрын

absolutely

@MarshallArtz007

7 ай бұрын

And always will…

I love Ringo's drumming on this song as well. As always, it's exactly what's needed. No more, no less.

@joedecker3900

7 ай бұрын

But has tricks up his sleeve when needed, not boring at all.

@danielwoodard680

7 ай бұрын

I say the song almost has a lead drummer.. easily my favorite Beatles’ song.

@stracepipe

7 ай бұрын

It's nice to hear Ringo getting props. The amount of stick he gets is ridiculous. His drumming always perfectly complements the song, not to mention his metronomic time keeping.

@CFCMahomet

7 ай бұрын

Some of the greatest bands (Beatles, Pink Floyd, Stones) had drummers who did exactly what was needed and did it well.

@griffgames9538

7 ай бұрын

Radiohead's Phil Selway comes to mind. Although his solo work shows he's quite multifaceted.

Saw Paul McCartney in Melbourne Australia last Saturday night. His introductions to Beatles songs were priceless. He played for THREE hours, at 81 years old. The voice is still great, and he was very happy and funny, too. Love him.

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

Sorry, no, his voice is not great anymore. But it surely is impressive he still does 3 hour shows. He just needs to FINALLY throw "Maybe I'm amazed" out of his setlist! Just glad he doesn't do "My love" anymore...

@davidcaldwell3681

7 ай бұрын

Even though I live in Vic I had my one and only turn in life to see him way back in 1975 in Manchester. I'm sure it was a great experience in Melbourne last week.

@philgallagher1

7 ай бұрын

​@@gutgolf74Wait until you get to 81 and see how well you can sing! I'm 60 and I'm not convinced I could stand up for 3 hours, let alone perform! LOL!

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

@@philgallagher1 LOL, I‘m definitely not going to play three hour shows with 81 - but a fact is a fact. I‘m probaby the biggest Paul-fan you‘ll ever meet, and I was lucky enough to enjoy him live in 2002 when his voice was still good. It‘s not anymore, that‘s only natural. So it‘s just not true to call his voice „great“. And there are some songs he just shouldn‘t do anymore.

@eskaytwo

7 ай бұрын

His voice was great. Saw him in Adelaide a few days before the Melbourne show.

Ringo's drumming on this song (and on all of his recordings with The Beatles) is not just essential and elegant, not playing more than what was required, and serving the music perfectly, which is already the most anyone could hope for, but it's the most melodic and composed I've ever heard in popular music. Ringo's parts sound like orchestral percussion parts, but especially primal, direct and propulsive. He's a brilliant drummer.

@MartianTom

7 ай бұрын

Absolutely. Even as a kid, when I first heard this song (and was over-awed by it), it was the drumming that especially caught my attention.

@takfam07

7 ай бұрын

Orchestral percussion. You're right. A rock version of it. He influenced a LOT of drummers. Back when music was more...musical. (To my ears, anyway).

@tharman953

7 ай бұрын

I couldn't agree more. Absolutely perfect drumming.

@singlesideman

7 ай бұрын

@@tharman953 there's a video here on KZread of 'Rubber Soul' but it's just Paul and Ringo, and it has gotten over 300,000 views (listens) in only two weeks! I've listened to it more than once. 'The Word' and 'Wait' kick major 4$$.

@stevedrake360

7 ай бұрын

Agreed. George Harrison once said Ringo always played just the right thing. Phil Collins once said that Ringo's playing in "A Day in the Life" was very complex. Coming from Phil Collins, one of the greatest drummers ever, is quite a statement. Ringo was an equal member of The Beatles, talent-wise- and contribution-wise.

A Day in the life changed popular music culture and inspired many . A true masterpiece!

Most influential, ground breaking band ever. I never tire of listening to their music

@petersheenan4482

7 ай бұрын

ditto for me

@Alpha_7227

7 ай бұрын

I think they had a massive influence on bands during the 90's, especially Brit Pop bands like Oasis and Blur. Ringo's drum parts, George's licks.

@mysticmerman

7 ай бұрын

​@@Alpha_7227the studio techniques are massively influential!

@TheDivayenta

7 ай бұрын

@@Alpha_7227and Nirvana! Kurt always claimed the Beatles were a major inspiration.

@staggerlee7301

7 ай бұрын

@@TheDivayentaKurt was basically a punk musician who wanted to write like Lennon, and it’s one of the things that makes Nirvana so special, in my opinion

Probably the greatest song ever written.

I was genuinely listening to this the other day thinking "I wonder what Beato thinks of this song"

@NytronX

7 ай бұрын

Same here lol

@wesleyalan9179

7 ай бұрын

I think that whenever i hear any song, lol!! For real though 😂

@douglove2412

7 ай бұрын

Synchronicity!

I worked with Shelly Yakus (John's engineer on "Imagine") and while working with him, I would pick his brain about Beatles stories. He told me, that John told him, this song was assembled over the phone with Paul. It was always two separate and different songs merged together. That's the story I was told.

So many of John's chord progressions are just mind-bending and so beautiful. The dude was unique in so many ways: Unique conceptually, unique lyrically, unique musically - and, man, that voice. What a voice!

@gutgolf74

6 ай бұрын

Only this particular part was written by Paul.

@Kooky_Duzzfutz

6 ай бұрын

@@gutgolf74 LOL

@gutgolf74

6 ай бұрын

@@Kooky_Duzzfutz I know, it's laughable that Rick would make that mistake, like so many others, because that's Paul's voice on the "aaahs", because that's still his part. John did the verses and nothing else.

cant wait for you to interview Paul so he can call off the dogs and let you play Beatles tunes here.

@jamesparr6840

7 ай бұрын

Hear, hear!

@Greg-om2hb

7 ай бұрын

I think Michael Jackson bought the entire Beatles’ catalog decades ago. Not sure who owns it now.

@elissaaleph

7 ай бұрын

It's rarely the individuals, it's the companies.

@foleycj

7 ай бұрын

@@Greg-om2hb, Paul & Sony own it.

@musamusashi

7 ай бұрын

​@@Greg-om2hbMichael sold them back to Paul some years after buyng them.

Lennon’s Chord Progressions are surreal. “A Day in the Life”, “Strawberry Fields Forever”, “I am the Walrus”, “Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds”… nobody was as original a composer in rock/pop in 1967

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

And the "genius" chord progression from the ADITL transition was written by Paul.

@zeljkofatzek3670

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, nobody except Jimi Hendrix, Frank Zappa, Cpt Beefheart, Syd Barret, Arthur Lee, Lou Reed & couple of others I can't remember immediately...

@stephaniebradley4649

7 ай бұрын

Except for his bandmate, Paul McCartney. We are so lucky that those two met to make this incredible music!

@da_great_mogul

6 ай бұрын

​@@gutgolf74it wasn't, it was Lennon's verses. Lennon shocked and surprised with his choices and yet at the same time ensured they were seamless.

@gutgolf74

6 ай бұрын

@@da_great_mogul Eeeeh, yes, it were indeed Lennon's VERSES - everything ELSE was written by PAUL, Sherlock! Thank you for proving my point! 😀

Johns voice.. Just moving..there is just no one who could sing like him.

@TheDivayenta

7 ай бұрын

“ Julia” and “ All Across the Universe” get me everytime.

@MrJMS814

3 ай бұрын

Except Paul

@hw343434

Ай бұрын

@@MrJMS814nobody had the magical tone of John Lennon’s the signature voice of the Beatles

What's really amazing to me is that this all came about just over three years after "She Loves You." No act in rock has advanced so far in such a short period of time (three years is usually the time between one album and another these days).

@alangil40

7 ай бұрын

While true, all of music seemed to progress in this way during those incredible years, with bands feeding off each other's innovations. The Beatles perhaps led the way.

@jfo3000

7 ай бұрын

George Martin was always in the room.

At 11 years old, somehow I (along with hundreds of thousands of people around the world) knew that this song was the most special song on a unique and special album. Years later it was satisfying to learn that when Sgt. Peppers was released, John was mysteriously telling people how special this song was, without saying specifically why, despite the fact that he wasn't a bragging type. And the fact that A Day in the Life was "separated" from the rest of the album supported this, of course. Many would argue, but in a hundred or a thousand years, A Day in the Life may be called the greatest song of what was considered rock 'n roll.

I woke up. Fell out of bed. Dragged a comb across my head. “ this line comes to me every morning

@lauraturner4216

7 ай бұрын

and EVERY time I catch a bus!

Anyone else hear the intro chords to Goodbye Yellow Brick Road in here ...? 🙂 (16:07) Also Pink Floyd (18:00) the opening of the Momentary Lapse of Reason album ... It's also all over Fool's Overture by Supertramp.

Rumor has it that Steve Jobs being the huge beatles fan he was loved this song so much that the last “chord” of the song is the start up sound of The Apple Macintosh.

One of the greatest songs of all time

I saw Paul McCartney live in Melbourne last night. The show was fantastic. If you can get a ticket for the rest of the tour you should do it! I can't say anything new about his talent, gift, genius that hasn't been said a hundred times before but I can say his emotional impact on my life has been huge. There's something in his music that has touched me for over 30 years as a solo artist, with Wings and The Beatles...he's just magical.

@Alpha_7227

7 ай бұрын

I was there as well. The set was mostly upbeat and rock like, which I loved. His voice in my opinion sounded so much better than on his last record. The band were fantastic. Drummer, keyboardist and guitarists - so good. They play like a real band not just a bunch of session musicians. I understand they have been together for a while it shows that they know exactly what the others are doing.

@steve62301

7 ай бұрын

@@Alpha_7227 yes, I totally agree.

@chrissy1510

7 ай бұрын

Loved reading this post! I’m seeing Paul in Sydney this Friday. I feel as if I’ve been waiting my entire life for this opportunity, and I already know it’s going to be a milestone by which I’ll measure the rest of my life.

@radiooz2420

7 ай бұрын

@@Alpha_7227 the band has been together for 21 years. Definitely not just a bunch of session musos.

@Alpha_7227

7 ай бұрын

Pity then they don't have a name like 'Wings". Paul's ego getting in the way.@@radiooz2420

This song sums up the Beatles in one 4 minute package. IMO the greatest rock song ever written

This is the first song that blew my mind. I was 9/10 years old in '75/'76 at a friends house playing with lego or something, and Pepper on in the background. I was mesmerized and speechless until the end. I clearly recall after the last chord faded, asking "what was that?". "That's The Beatles, man, I told you they were cool". I was aware of some Beatles songs by then and Elton, Simon and Garfunkel, America, Sweet, etc. and had taken piano lessons since age six, but this transcended everything that came before in my consciousness related to music. I knew that music could be fun, or sad, or silly, but this song is like traveling through a dream that may or may not even be yours, but it's a fantastic journey none the less. Within a few months I was spending all my Xmas money on Beatle records and didn't stop until I had them all. Almost 50 years later and I still need to hear it just one more time before bed.

@Lennon6412

6 ай бұрын

It's a great song to get people into the Beatles. Hearing this and Strawberry Fields in a long car journey got me completely hooked at the same age

This is the greatest pop song ever written. Crazy that Rick isn’t even allowed to play it on youtube.

@Alpha_7227

7 ай бұрын

You are absolutely spot on. My thoughts exactly. If there were a countdown, this would be Numero Uno. There are so many parts to it that set it apart from anything ever written. The outro. Ringo's drums. Harmonies. The bridge. The orchestral part. It is a masterpiece in song writing and arrangement.

@latkagravas2967

6 ай бұрын

Soon after Sgt. Peppers was released, John was encouraging the press to pay close attention to A Day in the Life. To my (Beatles) knowledge, he never did that before or after that. He knew. I believe a hundred or a thousand years from now, music historians will agree with you.

@alisonsneed3707

6 ай бұрын

I know. It’s so obvious it’s for teaching purposes.

Love the way Rick breaks down the "what they're doing" "how they're doing it" & even "why they're doing it"...far better than most who instruct and/or breakdown the parts of a song

Rick, one of the major influences on Lennon and McCartney was the 5th Beatle - Sir George Martin. An accomplished orchestral arranger he is bound to have had a significant influence on them in their earlier days in the studio and encouraged them to explore different chord progressions. You need to ask Paul himself for the inside story!

Rick talking about The Beatles, my favorite group of all time. Doesn't get better than this....

And Ringo's touches on this song were perfect.

The Sgt. Pepper album changed my life. I languished musically as a child in an essentially tuneless family environment. I was gifted musically and didn't even know it. At 14 yrs old, in our school library, I noticed this very cool looking album sitting amongst others on a coffee table with a small turntable and an early '70's headset. Having nothing better to do at the time, I put the album on, donned the headset and proceeded to have my mind blown. I read along with the music from the inside cover and by the end of the album I looked around in astonishment at others in the room as if to say "has anybody heard what I just heard"? It's like I'd been eating baloney all my life and someone suddenly put a bacon wrapped ribeye in front of me. I bought a guitar and the rest of my teen years were spent learning all things musical.

In my opinion, Easley one of the top five best songs ever written. The Beatles were pure magic that I don’t think will ever be matched again.

@latkagravas2967

6 ай бұрын

I mentioned above in another comment that in 100 or 1000 years, musicologists may call it the greatest song of its time. Weird to call it rock 'n roll; it's more than that, but I can't find the words to say what......

John’s vocal- in performance and recording technique- is completely sublime. In isolation on a good system, it genuinely gives chills

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

As long as you are aware that it's Paul singing the "aaah"...

@koshersalaami

7 ай бұрын

George Martin talks about John’s vocal performance. It isn’t from processing - John sang it like that.

@nintendianajones64

7 ай бұрын

​@@gutgolf74George Martin confirmed many times it's JOHN LENNON

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

@@nintendianajones64 Half your time is up - any progress?? Where is just ONE of your "many times"?!

@W0oDy97

7 ай бұрын

​@@gutgolf74where did you find that out?

John’s voice here is out of this world.

The first time I heard "A Day in the Life", as far as I can recall, was when I was 11 years old. It was summer and my family, including all of my cousins on my dad's side, were at a cabin on a Wisconsin northwoods lake. The both of us had been getting into The Beatles. Although of course we were raised on early Beatles songs, on this trip we got into their psychedelic era tunes. We played "A Day in the Life" in our room and were left completely speechless. It was a jaw-droppingly monumental moment. Even though I couldn't have articulated it at the time, hearing "A Day in the Life" was so life-changing that I was overcome with emotion. I had tears in my eyes and wanted to weep. To this day, it still makes me feel this way. It is an absolute miracle of songwriting and music production and recording.

Yet more evidence of the Beatles' brilliance. Thank you, Rick!

After this, McCartney increasingly became interested in pastiche songs. The whole second side of Abbey Road was a collection of song bits and pieces that he produced into a medley. Then with Wings he did it again with "Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey" and "Band on the Run".

@BeatPoet67

6 ай бұрын

The second side of Abbey Road is absolutely magnificent. I think, as a whole it's their best album.

Lennon/McCartney, greatist song writing duo ever. John was the heart of the Beatles.

@anakina1

7 ай бұрын

I think most would say Paul was the heart and soul of the group.

@petersheenan4482

7 ай бұрын

they were both amazing, that's the crux of the group"s amazing output. the whole was grater than the parts.

@DeflatingAtheism

7 ай бұрын

I find in songwriting duos, you typically have the _artisté_ and the workhorse. The _artisté_ often gets over-credited due to the fact they manifest the Romantic artist-hero myth, but ironically, it is the workhorse who guides the sensibility and direction of the entire group. As well, it is likely it is the workhorse who rescued the artisté from a fate of plunking out their songs in his bedroom in perpetual obscurity.

@hw343434

7 ай бұрын

@@anakina1 Lol no, most everybody at the time declared Lennon the heart and genius of the Beatles. McCartney and his fans have been desperately trying to revise history after John’s death to favor Paul but the other Beatles themselves preferred John over Paul’s music as did most of their peers at the time like The Rolling Stones, Bowie, Elton John, Queen and others who all bowed down to Lennon. That’s not a knock on Paul, he was equally as essential to the Beatles, as were George and Ringo.

@artistaccount

7 ай бұрын

​@@DeflatingAtheismI read somewhere on KZread the same thing but explained with the left and right brain and many duos in history have it. Picasso and braque in painting jung and frued in psychology Lennon McCartney the example you noticed here in music And Others in politics and other fields I can't remember cause I forget where I saw it exactly on KZread but it's somewhere online.

Interesting to learn of a plagal progression. Elton John once said that he was taught if you ever need a hit just write a hymn. And I think that’s part of how that is explained, once you hear that and understand it a little better.

I think the runs of passing notes by McCartney makes the song emphasize accents and gives a bit of dissidence that gives energy to the riff. Genius. And with Ringo's fills, intense. And then how the bass holds down the transition note through the orchestra to the second part.

One of the most beautiful bass lines ever

For mine, this is the best piece of pop / rock music ever. We are still taking it apart, discussing it some 60 odd years later.

Rick you never cease to amaze me. Your ear for music is top tier and I always love watching you break down songs. No ego, never braggadocios, just your genuine love of music and always love how you compliment musicians for their skills.

@gutgolf74

11 күн бұрын

Too bad he kept praising John for things that Paul did...

People can have their opinion on The Beatles but for A Day In The Life really showed me how good the group was. And for someone who discovered them as a kid, this blew me away when i first listened to this yet out of their songs, this seems underrated? Not much "fans" and haters seem to know this track, at least from the people i came across so far.

@latkagravas2967

6 ай бұрын

Easier to be a "hater" of a group, or music genre, if a person doesn't grow up with it. Ok to not appreciate a band or genre, but to be a "hater" of Beatles songs reflects only ignorance.

A song that seems to sum up the whole 20th century. Resentment, frustration, futility and acception of life in 5 minutes with impeccable lyrics, melodies and musical innovation. Could very well be the most important moment in all 20th century music

@latkagravas2967

6 ай бұрын

I love your impression and summary. Well conceived. There's a thesis there somewhere, or betting several have already been done.

John's voice there is enough to bring a stoic to tears.

Love to see you give love to The Replacements and the Kinks!!!😂

One of the best “ear training“ bits I have seen on video with the Beatles is when John at piano and George on guitar are turning up to play John’s “oh my love“ during the Imagine sessions at his house studio in Weybridge… before electronic tuners! Lots of time together and in the studio.😊

Those descending chords sound like the opening chords to “Goodbye Yellow Brick road.”

@danielharris7710

7 ай бұрын

I thought the same thing.

@elementrypenguin3116

7 ай бұрын

@@danielharris7710 yes!

Friends who are cursory Beatles fans are always astonished that this is my absolute favorite Beatles song. Lennon's masterpiece.

@johndef5075

7 ай бұрын

I just saw this on a list of top 10 overrated albums. Couldn't agree less. Its a masterpiece.

@corinne_vintage

7 ай бұрын

This is my fave too!!

Probably the greatest use of recording equipment in the history of recording equipment. Every time I listen to this it still sends a chill up my spin.

This the video by rick ive been waiting since i discovered this channel

I was raised on the Beatles and I love most of their different sounds...this track along with Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane are for me the high watermark of their dream songs. You don't hear many covers of them as they are so richly realised

It was always clear to me, that Lennon heard things like most of us did not. Look at Happiness is a Warm Gun, or his take on a blues song Yer Blues.... just a little off the norm. So brilliant. Still amazed after all these years.

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

Still the most praise Rick heaped on here were on a part written by Paul! 😀

@JoaoGabriel-lk9cv

7 ай бұрын

@@gutgolf74no one cares.

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

@@JoaoGabriel-lk9cv Sorry, that's not true, either! 😀

@latkagravas2967

6 ай бұрын

I was much more of a "John" fan back then, but that middle part still has a strong purpose in the song, if not for anything but contrast. And no evidence Paul even wrote it, unless he has claimed it.@@gutgolf74

@gutgolf74

6 ай бұрын

@@latkagravas2967 LOL, John wrote the verses, nothing else. If the transition was his part, he would have done the vocals when they recorded his leads. Paul sings lead, he wrote the middle part including the transition. And there's just NOTHING you can say to prove me wrong.

Rick I notice you haven’t mentioned the song Julia ??? Surely one of the most unpredictable , mysterious sounding Beatles songs harmonically, melodically & also lyrically … love it if you are able to share an exploration of this 🐬✨ Love your work

@swampashtele

7 ай бұрын

Julia doesn't get enough attention.

John Lennon sings with such emotion on this one.Glissando.🙌

When you listen to Day in the Life, you just know it’s a masterpiece, but to hear technically how good it is from Rick is the icing on the cake. Love your videos Rick!

its a tonal poem that shapes your emotional response but some things are beyond words feelings, nothing more than feelings.

@user-rx4yb1db4v

Ай бұрын

John was a true artist and he could of excelled in any for poetry writing but all of us are so lucky that he chose music and met his alter ego at such and early age you couldn't ask for better collaborators one with the moody realistic look at the world from a window in Liverpool another a few miles away who could look out his window at the same city and be optimistic it makes you wond

@user-rx4yb1db4v

Ай бұрын

If there is something guiding the universe either way there still giving millions of people happiness and I think a little of the other rub off on each other I saw a video last night a talk show the man was playing cords on a guitare quite complex I might add and sir Paul got all of them right that is a gift.

@artistaccount

Ай бұрын

​@@user-rx4yb1db4vvideo title of McCartney getting chords right?

@artistaccount

Ай бұрын

​@@user-rx4yb1db4vvideo title of the Paul video?

I perked up when you, Sting, and Dominic took a moment to mention this song during the interview. I'm glad to see you circle back.

I believe it's Lennon's, the chorus after McCartney's "and I went into a dream..." gives me goosebumps every time. So deep after McC's lighthearted morning-routine section

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

I have no idea why Rick called this a "chorus" - it's a "transition" part and belongs obviously to Paul, since he's also singing it - contrary to popular belief.

@crjmoto

7 ай бұрын

@@gutgolf74 regardless what you call it, it's very haunting and beautiful. I feel like a lot of other artists play off of it even to this day

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

@@crjmoto That is correct. Sadly it's scarred by the common misconception that it's a Lennon part.

@musamusashi

7 ай бұрын

I always considered it a bridge in a chorus-less song.

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

@@musamusashi Indeed!

My favorite Beatles song. The Emaj7 (?) with lower 3rd (?) at the end is the BEST RECORDED CHORD OF ALL TIME. PERIOD.

Great point about that held E over the A (the 5th), then the E (tonic) and then back to the C (the 3rd). Dreamy, sublime, on point, and makes one take notice that the world is spinning around this man while he's stationary. It evokes a strong, thought-provoking feeling, which only the best song-writing is capable of doing.

@artistaccount

4 ай бұрын

Yup

Iconic song

We can discuss all the theory on the chords and melodies to this song and that's very cool. The irony is, none of the Beatles can analyze what they do. They simply just have great ears. They just know what sounds good!

@TheDivayenta

7 ай бұрын

Exactly.

Rick, that series of descending chords you mentioned (C--G--D--A--E) that sounded like that of "Hey Joe" was (albeit transcribed) in the song "Hush" in C, by Joe South, by way of Deep Purple. After each verse the band plays Ab--Eb--Bb--F--C. Same vocal melody, only with "na-nas" instead of "ah-ahs".

The use of suspensions came out of the folk music craze in the late 50's and early 60's - I was a beginner guitarist at the time and any time a D major came up on the chart I would suspend it with the little finger - just like everyone else was doing. Suspensions were a chord progression fad back when the Beatles were learning to play. Listen to the song "needles and pins" - down the tracks example of common suspension use.

Harmony comes from the relationships you discover in music. Melody comes from the relationships you discover in life.

@lauraturner4216

7 ай бұрын

a good philosophical observation! John was a philosopher, Paul has many as well. My favorite was an interview I saw in 1997. He was asked about the inspiration for "Let It Be" and he responded that his mother "came to him" as he was awakening saying "Let it be". Her name was Mary (died when he was a teen and John's mother consoled him when she could). He said he hears music all the time and writes or sings alot of it. Then he composed a song on the spot, out of "thin air" so to speak. John heard words, lyrics, poems in addition to melodies. Amazing human beings.

Rick, I reckon you’ve heard it many times before, but is there any chance Paul and/or Ringo might be accommodating to an interview? You have all the cred anybody could hope for, and they might appreciate discussing their musical ideas rather than typical fluff they’d be asked about by others. They must know who you are by now. If anybody can pull it off, it’s you! 👍

I believe the early Moody Blues tune "Go Now" uses a similar chord and bass progression

The Sus2 chords follow the melody. The "Hey, Joe" progression was their way of transitioning from Paul's middle section to the return of the main section.

This is Lennon and McCartney at their finest. The whole SPLHCB album is just timeless and magnificent. This is our classical music.

@anguineus_vir

7 ай бұрын

Lennon and McCartney at their finest in this song? Yes. The whole album timeless and magnificent? Not really, it has many forgettable songs, actually one of the worst Beatles albums

@tomcon21

7 ай бұрын

@@anguineus_vir😂

@anguineus_vir

7 ай бұрын

@@tomcon21 Fixing a Hole, She's leaving home, Being for the benefit of Mr Kite, Within you Without you, Lovely Rita, Good Morning. 6 very forgettable songs. The only really good ones are Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 1 and 12 tracks, With a little help from my friends, Lucy in the sky with diamonds and A day in the life, it means the ones at the beginning and at the end of the album. 5 out of 13 it doesn't scream timeless and magnificent

@tomcon21

7 ай бұрын

@@anguineus_vir You’re entitled to your opinion. Have a nice day.

@anguineus_vir

7 ай бұрын

@@tomcon21 Sure you have a nice day too ✌🏼

Rick was living with "the knob finger" for 50 years and problem solved within one KZread comment. 🤣 Love the breakdown Rick!

John and Paul could pick up and complement each other so naturally

I've heard that the orchestral "tension modulation" (just building tension until anywhere would "be home") is the inspiration for the THX deep note- and I believe that!

Rick, your are a real master! I would love to watch you interviewing Sir Paul McCartney, this would be a milestone!

Rick breaking down the Fab Four will never get old!

Every time I watch one of these videos I am left with this sense that I'm missing so much! There is so much more to all of this than I will ever grasp. There is almost a desperation to it... like being denied profound wisdom because you don't speak the language. It's like physics... trying to understand it with limited mathematics skills... there is something huge here... I can tell, but I'll never fully understand it. I may not know exactly why, but I do know that songs with musical complexity interest me, simple, predictable music does not... the difference between the Beatles and today's Pop music.

This is the song that made Sgt Pepper Iconic. Though I'd still opt for Rubber Soul, MMT or Abbey Road

That lydian triad you point out with the Zeppelin song is actually a major progression in Supertramp's "Fools Overture" as well

This has always been one of my favorite songs of any band since it first came out. I agree with you that this is the quintessential Beatle song as it was so completely different from anything else when it came out, and I cannot think of any other song that is anything like it, musically or lyrically - and especially singing wise; Lennon at his absolute finest.

Rick, I’ve been following you for a few months now, and for most of my life, I’ve been happy to accompany myself singing with pretty basic chords. But late in life, I’m really interested in learning to play really well, just to see how far my talent can go in whatever time I have left. I have the Beato Bundle, and have already learned a bunch. So thanks. I’m starting to be able to pick out stuff by ear like crazy (and I haven’t even gone near the ear training course yet), and playing guitar is more fun than ever. Thanks for helping to make it so.

"Finger Extenders"... Start with some thumb picks and a heat gun. Heat the picks up and reshape them to fit each finger and hold properly onto the finger. Use silicone to make a pad for the finger tip to push against and a little bit up the finger to create a pocket for the finger tip to fit into. Add a blob where the "new" finger tip is going to be and let it cure for a few days. Then put the tops on the fingers and use a Dremel tool with a sanding tube to shape and fine tune everything so that it works for you. If you find that the position moves around on your finger tips or are unstable then try using some of that adhesive that makeup uses to glue prostheses onto an actors faces.

I have been waiting for you to disassemble this song for over 3 million subscribers ago. Thank you.

Deep Purple's 'Hush' uses the two bar per chord version of the bridge's plagal cascade. In that case, I think it was an unconscious influence taken from A Day In The Life. By that time, everyone on the planet was immersed in the Sgt. Pepper record.

@johnyarusso4953

7 ай бұрын

Yes and Deep Purple also uses the exact vocal notes contained in that section of A day in a life.

@georgesonm1774

7 ай бұрын

and they did cover "Hey Joe' as well :)

@siljeff2708

7 ай бұрын

@@georgesonm1774same album too!

@davnroll

7 ай бұрын

😁

@davnroll

7 ай бұрын

yep i"m on the Hush's side too ;)

Always makes me so happy when I see a Beatles song pop up on your channel

The Day in the life verse is also the progression for Mind Games.

Definitely the best Beatles song.

I love this song. I'm fortunate enough to be able to work alone in large rooms during the day, so I sing all day. This is one of my regulars. People have told me I actually sound like Lennon. But then they've told me I sound like Barry Gibb, too. Maybe I have a career in singer impersonation! I think this song also has some great, understated drumming from Ringo. I especially love the fills in the final verse.

@MobiusBandwidth

7 ай бұрын

that's where the money is!

@Kuzey457

7 ай бұрын

Beatles songs covered by Barry Gibb.. perfect part time gig. Feel free to sing at my wedding

@latkagravas2967

6 ай бұрын

Karaoke. Just do it.

Wonderful how opposites creatively complement each other. I still reckon The Beatles are UNDERrated in spite of the clamour of books about them, but, Mr RB, you are an unwavering beacon on the hill - so pertinent, so lucid. Ta from the UK!

You can identity ANY Beatles song just by Ringo's drumming

@gutgolf74

6 ай бұрын

Yeah, even the ones where Paul's drumming!

This song will be played at my memorial service someday.

Original comment in the live chat from Rustie Cage: ​"beatles had songwriters and studio musicians like other chart topping movie star bands." @rustiecage, you can feel free to share the substantiation you have for this, but I already know you don't have any. You're just assuming, based on what you know of today's music and how it's created. Which makes sense. That is the music industry today. And there were definitely pop bands in the 60s who had great stardom based on songs that others had written. It usually wasn't a secret. There really were no song doctors and no session players for the Beatles, except perhaps George Martin, who was their producer, who often played keyboards and no doubt influenced a lot of the writing and arrangements. He'd probably say he didn't, but I think he's got his fingerprints for sure. But no. No song doctors. No Wrecking Crew. No ProTools, which COULDN'T have happened, there was no digital anything. Everything was played, sung, recorded and edited analog via multi-channel recordings onto magnetic tape. If you really want to delve into it, read Mark Lewisohn's and Geoff Emerick's books. They both document to the nth degree all of the recording sessions and who was involved. I doubt you'd want to, you're clearly not a fan, at least not yet (there's still time for you 🙂). But there's plenty of documented evidence about who had anything to do with Beatles songs and recordings.

To think that 2 albums previous to this was Rubber Soul. People always point out the Beatles musical progression. Starting with the simplicity but just as charming "Love me Do". But the complex musical ideas on Sgt. Pepper's was a real leap. Pure genius and incredible talent.

@ewoh24

7 ай бұрын

Think of Robert Schumann Rick!! No frickin “Finger Extenders” or you’ll ruin your budding concert pianist career, marry the underage daughter of your piano teacher, become one of the greatest composers ever but die in an insane asylum at 46…

So putting these chords together is like knowing how words rhyme. Chords rhyme in the same way. Very interesting

It's impossible to pick my favorite Beatles song. That said, this is likely the one. My daughter wrote a beautiful essay about it for her English class in the early 2000s. It's an incredible piece. Thank you for taking my non musician self inside the composition.

One of my favorite songs of all time.

To me, when John sings the Na-na-na-na….. it sounds as if he is crying, wailing as if in mourning. It’s heart wrenching and that’s what excellent music does. You feel it.

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, only that's Paul...

@johnsummers2822

7 ай бұрын

@@gutgolf74sorry you’re wrong or just being contrary. If you come from northern England you can definitely tell the difference. It’s John and Giles Martin confirmed this to be true.

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

@@johnsummers2822 LOL, nopes, YOU are wrong and you obviously can't tell the difference between their voices! As for Giles, I was shocked he made that mistake, looks like he only has his father's name but not his ears! Because it's literally impossible to be John. Why it shouldn't be John: It's Paul's part, end of story. No need for John to sing lead on Paul's part in Paul's dream. That's also why we only see PAUL during this part in the official video to ADITL. No John AT ALL - but he returns right when HIS part, the last verse, starts. They were finished recording John's vocals for ADITL 2 weeks before and just returned for recording Paul's part on February 3rd. John NEVER sang this part when he had the chance to. Also, note the position of the voices in the stereo-picture: John is on the right, Paul on the left. The "aaah" start on Paul's side and move over to cue John's return. Why it couldn't be John: Since -- in contrast to Emerick's fairy-tale - there is absolutely no cut between the "dream" and the "aaah", it must be still the same lead singer, Paul. You can even hear him take a breath between the "dream" and the "aaah" on the isolated vocal track. Since John is doing his trademark NASAL high falsetto in the background AT THE SAME TIME it's impossible for him to also do the lead aaah. Also, the lead aaah doesn't sound like John AT ALL. It's a chest voice that would have been too high for him to do. Please name a single example where John sings like that - I bet you can't! With Paul you only have to go as far as "Lovely Rita" to find a very similar example. There are many experts who very thoroughly listened to all the actual reels and went through all the paperwork and wrote very highly praised books, like Kevin Ryan and Brian Kehew (from the book "Recording the Beatles", p. 444): "Though many have understandably attributed this vocal to John Lennon in the past, isolation of the vocal reveals it to be Paul. As the part progresses, his voice takes on a more nasal tone; this, in combination with an application of Repeat Echo similar to that already applied to John's, does much to give an impression of it being Lennon." Or John C. Winn, who actually pointed out all the little differences between every single mix every made of any Beatles song: (from the book "That magic feeling - The Beatles' recorded legacy, p. 86): "Paul then corrected his vocal blunder by taping a new vocal on track 2, also adding some soaring "aahs" over the circle-of-fifths segment that linked back to the final verse". And of course Sam Okell, who did the freaking Sgt. Pepper's REMIX and totally debunked and contradicted Giles Martin: "Paul's main vocal track is in stereo, because we gave it some spread with the Waves S1 Stereo Imaging plug-in, so it has a different sound than John's lead. We also split off two little bits to be able to pan them left and right. His fourth vocal track is the 'aaah' section, and below it is an 'Aah delay' aux track." "Inside Sgt. Pepper's": Sound On Sound. SOS Publications Group. 26 October 2021

@johnsummers2822

7 ай бұрын

@@gutgolf74 are you American? So Giles and Geoff are wrong ha ha ha! It’s Lennon.

@gutgolf74

7 ай бұрын

@@johnsummers2822 Yep, shockingly they're both wrong. I guess you missed the quote from Sam Okell, who did the actual remix FOR Giles Martin - he totally contradicted and debunked Giles, who obviously doesn't have a clue, sadly... Google "Ken Scott vs. Emerick" and you'll get some eye-opening statements about how that fairy-tale book of Emerick came to life and how it's completely filled with false and made-up stories.

The best song of all time!

What about the relation between lyrics and music, between word and tone? That's when it starts getting interesting. The heavy delay on John's voice, its slow wandering across the stereo panorama, Ringo's nervous fill-ins, the 5 bars (twice) in the vocalise part and so on. 27:49

@gutgolf74

6 ай бұрын

It's Paul's voice that's wandering from left (Paul's side) to right (John's side), where it leads back to John coming in with the last verse.

That "hey joe" moment 7:25 chord progression also found on Deep Purple - Strange Kind Of Woman (1971) bridge, with almost identical melody to Beatles chorus here.

@markpavletich747

7 ай бұрын

And on HUSH.