It’s a shame we’re getting more history lesson on KZread than the actual History Channel.

@artawhirler

5 ай бұрын

Well, except for "Ancient Aliens", of course! 😅

@cleverusername9369

5 ай бұрын

Why is it a shame? We're getting fantastic history lessons from enthusiastic, passionate people with actual expertise in actual history for free. This is arguably better. Plus, good old school History Channel content is still available on KZread. The History Channel is dead, long live History Hit.

@fotograf736

5 ай бұрын

I think they moved all that to Military Channel, I agree HC has no more content matching its name.

@wayside70

5 ай бұрын

History Channel used to be great at military shows ..now sadly it caved in to "reality" t.v. trash.

@feemster8861

5 ай бұрын

There is a channel called History that has a lot of their old content such as Dogfights on KZread. However, I agree that there are several channels that have far more suprior content than the History Channel ever did. That is why I do not have a TV.

Napoleonic videos will never get old

While Austerlitz is famous because of it's scale, some of Napoleons victories in Italy are no less incredible. He was able to turn the tables on opponents that had him flanked, out numbered and surrounded by making pivotal decision at exactly the right time. By comparison, what made Austerlitz work was all the little things Napoleon did leading UP to the battle to cast the illusion of disorder, weakness, confusion, lack of supplies, ragged, demoralized and ill prepared. Surrendering the high ground, the Pratzen heights, was the cherry on the illusion cake that caused the Russian's to swell with confidence and take the bait.

@2adamast

5 ай бұрын

But with napoleon you never know, when losing he will give a story about his generals losing the battle., surrendering the high ground was maybe just that.

@theoutlook55

5 ай бұрын

Agreed on all counts.

@Shljapko666

5 ай бұрын

Hear me out, Suvorov's siege of Ismail is a masterpiece. You could say that this man was single-handedly responsible for the Russian Tzardom surviving Napoleon.

@lotennaokeke3414

5 ай бұрын

But the film said it was all about the allied army fallen down a frozen lake, what is this Dan Snow??

@VaibhavGupta-hr8vc

4 ай бұрын

The film is just a fictional part. It was Napoleon's strategy but they depicted him as a simp and loser.​@@lotennaokeke3414

I wonder what Dan Snow was thinking during his interview with Ridley Scott, whilst Scott proudly boasted about belittling his historical advisers on the set of ‘Napoleon’, by asking them, “How do you know? We’re YOU there?” It seems that movie directors are now our historians?

@UkrainianPaulie

5 ай бұрын

Scott is an ass. Tired of his wannabe un-historical movies.

@geecee2526

5 ай бұрын

Scott is an arrogant twat. I'm disappointed that Snow had originally posted a rather negative critique of the film (and Napoleon) pre-release, but for some reason, he changed his tune after that interview. Scott has always played roughshod over historical facts

@amysill3815

5 ай бұрын

Did he really do and say that? What a fool.

@BillyProulx

5 ай бұрын

Apparently Scott took his ‘history’ from the self serving and greatly embellished dispatches Napoleon would send back to Paris in order impress Josephine. God help a generation that gets its history from movies.

@englishjim6428

5 ай бұрын

That “interview” was pathetic. Quite disappointed in Dan Snow.

The use of terrain is top notch. The setup at the meeting highlighting the “best possible approach” for the opposition is brilliant. There’s definitely something to be said about Napoleon’s tactical thinking. Too bad bravado encroached upon that a little too much… or maybe lucky it did.

@kariannecrysler640

5 ай бұрын

Oh, I really appreciate that this video came out on a snowy winters day. 😊

@RommelsAsparagus

5 ай бұрын

It was really masterful, giving up the heights as bait and luring the enemy off the Pratzen heights with the thinly held village of Solkonitz. Timed it with the mist/smoke perfectly. Total genius stuff. I would *never* have even considered that, given the risk...

@kkidcruz6118

5 ай бұрын

I wouldn't wanna sit across Napoleon at a poker table.

@murrayscott9546

5 ай бұрын

California, dreaming.

@murrayscott9546

5 ай бұрын

​@@kkidcruz6118Baccarat, more likely.

Great video and also very nice to see you visit the actual battlefield! Loved it! Thank you

I don´t know much hosts presenting history like Dan Snow does. I watched many documentaries presented by him and he still has that passion that makes me to watch him so eagerly.

Great video on this battle, as it's a huge part of the early chapters of War and Peace.

Just found this channel and hearind Dans voice is so nostalgic. Loved 20th century battlefields as a kid! Everytime you paused i always expect to hear your dad picking up the narration. Well done, love many of the videos ove seen on this channel with Dan and really appreciate his delivery and appreciation of history.

This is insane thank you for sharing this history

Really enjoyed this, very well presented concise assessment of the battle, great selection of appropriate paintings, scenes and graphics.

Well explained and pointing out the terrain there on the site of the battle helped it come alive. Well done.

I was hoping you'd do a video on this! Thanks!

thank you guys for doing this. its awesome. truly.

Fantastic work. Thank you. Bless 👊

Nicely done! Definitely my favorite battle to study of the Napoleonic Era.

This is great! Can I make a suggestion? In films like this, when shots of maps are used, can you leave them on a bit longer and enlarge the relevant bits a bit more? Some of us are a bit aged, I fear. Nice one Dan and team. ⭐👍

@ronturner7926

3 ай бұрын

❤

The whole Sharpe opening riff was a great addition❤️

I wish the Napoleon movie had centered around Austerlitz instead of whatever it was Scott released.

@murkyseb

5 ай бұрын

It takes up 25% of the movie, pretty accurately too

@pauls064

5 ай бұрын

@@murkysebit’s a tiny scene in the film and the most inaccurate depiction humanly possible. Literally the worst recreation of any battle on film I’ve ever seen.

@murkyseb

5 ай бұрын

@@pauls064 as a historian I can say it's an accurate depiction of the battle

@pauls064

5 ай бұрын

@@murkyseb as an actual, working, real historian, I can tell you you’re full of shit. No “historian” would ever make such a claim. I’ve been twice to pratzen heights and Telnice in the last 5 years and the geography is comedically bad in the film, the movie portrays the battle in a tiny valley when the line was 12km long, when the Satchan ponds were emptied after the battle, they found only 3 bodies and 150 horses (the “drowning” was an inconsequential part of the real battle), there was no snow and the day was sunny and bright after the morning fog, etc etc etc etc The whole battle scene was so bizarrely bad, myself and several peers (also historians) who were reviewing it nearly gave up…. I had the displeasure of working on a Randall Wallace film as a researcher and never thought anyone would direct battles so badly, but scott is the master of screwing up every possible fact in a historical battle.

@ejfheoshrjde

5 ай бұрын

@@murkyseb It's about as accurate as the battle of sterling bridge scene in braveheart and had the strategic grace of a multiplayer round. Sure a number of allied troops died from some ponds, but misses the whole heights portion of the fight.

Finally someone who knows the plural of canon is canon. Respect Mr Snow

@Imugi007

3 ай бұрын

It's a shame you can't even spell cannon... And you're still wrong anyway. Cannon and cannons are both acceptable as the plural form of cannon. You're trying to look smart but it's not working very well when you can't even spell correctly. And you're wrong on top of that.

There is nothing like a Napoleonic video it never gets old

@StarshipToMars

11 күн бұрын

Heh heh. Thanks for the chuckle. =)

6:42 Napoleon's soldiers are so dedicated to guide him they're still shining lights to this day.

awsome as always Mr Snow

Thank you Brilliant video, brilliantly narrated highly factual as I studied this battle-and even with my amateur in depth studies the video filled MANY GAPS-But I want MORE!

Awesome video about Napoleon very interesting!

Incredible! This low cost network documentary can present combat scenes (using the ubiquitous napoleonic reenactors) more dramatic and genuine than a Hollywood production of several million dollars!

@neverstopschweiking

5 ай бұрын

There is a reenactment every year at Austerlitz, so even Napoleonic soldiers fighting at the location in the proper season, that's something anyone can film on a smartphone these days.

What a treasure this channel and Dan are

“Never interrupt your enemy when he is defeating himself.” ---------
― Napoleon Bonaparte

@tomhirons7475

5 ай бұрын

he should have have thought of that when invading Russia.

@ososnake97

5 ай бұрын

@@tomhirons7475 "One must never ask of fortune more than she can grant" -Napoleon Bonaparte

@kevinjohnbetts

5 ай бұрын

@@tomhirons7475 The invasion itself was a good move. The Russian Empire was Napoleon's last great Continental enemy and defeating it would have made him master of Europe. The interesting conundrum is whether he should have pushed on to Moscow after Borodino or Wintered around Smolensk. Militarily this would have made for a sound strategy but politically it might have made him appear weak and indecisive. The alliance with Prussia was shaky and the peace with Austria was uneasy at best. Imho it was the invasion of Spain that doomed Napoleon. It sapped French strength and confidence whilst giving the British public, particularly the urban middle-classes, the impression that their taxes were achieving something other than subsidising foreign armies that Napoleon kept defeating. No Peninsular War, Britain makes peace after the defeat of the Austrians at Wagram and the 5th Coalition collapses, Napoleon has no need for his 'Continental System', and a Polish 'buffer state' is established as Russia turns its attention towards The Ottoman Empire. As a bonus Wellesley commands the British forces during the war of 1812 and the United States of America is returned to The Empire as he is granted the title of 'Duke of New York'. * *I may have gotten a little carried away there. 🤣🤣

@olivierpuyou3621

5 ай бұрын

Personally I like it because I find it funny: “You can do anything with a bayonet, except sit on it”.

@Thomas-xd4cx

5 ай бұрын

When he’s making a mistake*

Thanks for the link, Tristan!

Very good video. Thank You Sir.

Thank you Tristan this was refreshing a news real view

@6:44 I just love the little farm tractor/JCB in the background with it's wee flashing orange light when the advancing allied armies are being discussed....

I haven't seen the movie, but this is amazing military tactics and sheer courage

A dramatic retelling of the battle of Austerlitz, of Napoleon comprehensively destroying the Allies as Dan Snow walks around the battlefield. He really brings the battle alive, (for all the death that was wrought on that day !! )

I went to Austerlitz on the anniversary back in 2015 and watched the re-enactment. It was fascinating to be immersed in history

Excellent, finally some serious attention for this famous battle!

@soloar2007

5 ай бұрын

this battle has evaded attention?

@basderue512

5 ай бұрын

@@soloar2007 yes, in napoleonics, it’s always Waterloo, Waterloo, and some more Waterloo just in case.

The central strategic masterstroke can be more clearly explained than here. The occupation of the Pratzen Heights was the key to commanding the battlefield. Napoleon abandoned them, inviting the allies to occupy the high ground, which they did. He left his right (southern) flank conspicuously weak, inviting the allies to leave the plateau and attack his right. But unbeknownst to the allies, Davout's III Corps had arrived overnight in a spectacular 110 km forced march from Vienna to the south. Shrouded in fog, his disciplined corps had arrived just in time to shore up Napoleon's southern flank. When the allies abandoned the heights to attack what they thought was the weak spot in the French line, they ran into Davout's disciplined and battle-hardened Corps. Exactly at that point, Soult led his IV Corps through the mist to occupy the now abandoned heights, trapping the Russians from above and cutting off their retreat. It became like shooting Russian fish in a barrel. Omitting the action to the north, this was the battle's strategic masterstroke.

@joshuagrover795

3 ай бұрын

Davout's III Corps (nicknamed Napoleon's 'X Legion') forced marched for two days to the battlefield, which is a fantastic feat in itself. Considering going straight into action on the right flank, afterwards, holding the flank in a stalemate until Marshal Soult's attack on the centre. Marshal Davout Napoleon's finest Corps commander by far.

Hey HH. Love your work 👍

Awesome video thank you

Thanks to Tristan Tate who shared this video to me and now i see Napoleon"s battle was much more interesting than the movie which i didn't and wouldn't see

@Sapper-wm1cc

4 ай бұрын

Talisman video guide 👍🏻

@Fishing-fanatic

4 ай бұрын

That’s why I’m here too.

@wozniak_steven

4 ай бұрын

Absolutly, thank you

@-paul-2191

4 ай бұрын

Fr

@kellykiser7600

4 ай бұрын

Aw my brothers….. Get of YT and get to F’ing work!!! 2024 is OUR YEAR!! TODAY IS OUR DAY!!

Cool of that Austrian soldier at around 8:30 to recount for us his experience of the day. He’s lucky to be alive after this battle.

Great video, I’m now ready to jump back down the napoleon rabbit hole

its amazing how brave people can be

Great video!

Dan is the man!

Thank you T

Thanks tristan

Thank you tristan tate for giving me this link

Very informative

I know a bit about Napoleons journey across europe, fun fact he was actually first a officer of the Artillary battalion (dont know exact which one) and he became commander of a small army after stopping the French Revolution, when he got his army france went to war with Europe and he had to fight the Swiz and the austrians. This battle was a massive victory since his army was made of low trained troops and people who were really hungry. He's military skill saved this battle and he was only 20 - 28 years old! And this was the beginning of he's power...

My 3x great grandfather was a sergeant in the Royal Scots in the Pennisular wars and at Waterloo so I am always interested to know more about this period and Dan is a great narrator. I was so dissapointed with the Ridley Scott movie.

Great video! I really appreciate that it has been filmed here on the actual battlefield! I just want to add something to the story of thousands of men drowning in freezing ponds (as it might be interesting for people who are into the battle). The ponds were actually drained just days after the battle and just a few horses and some canon were found there - no drowned soldiers, except for one or two who were pulled out immediately after the battle. Napoleon himself created the story to make his great victory go down in history as even greater. We have protocols from the draining of the ponds - and they just do not support this story.

@pauls064

5 ай бұрын

Correct! 2-3 bodies and ~150 horses. The “lake” was just shallow polder and many of the men in the water were pulled out by the French themselves or simply waded out and surrendered.

@Raguel1984

5 ай бұрын

unlike what they show in the movie right? :D

@pauls064

5 ай бұрын

@@Raguel1984 The movie made the whole battle about that one thing implying that Napoleon tricked the entire Austrian army to cross the lake while retreating so he can destroy them by drowning. Just idiotic Hollywood stupidity

@arupsan

4 ай бұрын

Well good lot of actual info coming out …

Excellent Episode of History as always!!! 😁

Excellent

Shoutout to the talisman for recommending this, fascinating stuff.

Thank you for the recommendation Tristan

Thanks to Tristan Tate I was able to get such an education about "The Battle of Austerlitz"! This was so much more entertaining to watch & engaging imagery compared to school history education! Thank you for the video!

Thanks Tristan ❤

To think that such beautiful terrain could the scene of so much slaughter.

I would like to extend thanks to Tristan for recommending this great piece of historical media, portrayed wonderfully unlike in the recent Napoleon movie.

This is better than the new movie.

This is insane thank you for sharing this history. “Never interrupt your enemy when he is defeating himself.” ---------
― Napoleon Bonaparte.

@frankgesuele6298

3 ай бұрын

That would be rude😃

Good program to see right after I saw a movie trailer on this battle.

A personal question out of interest Daniel Snow: Where is your dad ? You and him presented the 2 brilliant documentary series in the 2000s - 20th century battlefields and Battlefield Britain 🇬🇧

@nigeh5326

5 ай бұрын

He retired December 23rd 2021 he’s now 76. He was the senior news presenter on UK Channel 4. He’s been a well known journalist and reporter in Britain since the 1970s.

@eaphantom9214

5 ай бұрын

​​​@nigeh5326 According to my source i researched from, he's now 85 🤔 Good, my assumption that was gonna be made was unfounded! (Not true)

@nigeh5326

5 ай бұрын

@@eaphantom9214 according to Wikipedia he’s 76 I know he has been on UK TV since the 70s. Either way I’m glad your assumption is wrong too. Either

@eaphantom9214

5 ай бұрын

​@@nigeh5326l Google said he's 86.... 🤔 Huh...odd. Still the ages aren't too far apart

@kyllerbuzcut

5 ай бұрын

His father's younger brother is the channel 4 news presenter

Thanks to Tristan for sharing this video

Tristan's recommendation 💪

Awesome movie I just seen it last night thanks for sharing you did a great job with this video 👍

@ccptube3468

5 ай бұрын

The movie was fckn terrible u doofus!

@alfredoa.arguelles2267

5 ай бұрын

the new movie sucks

dan snow is the man !

Thank you Tristan for sharing this

Strange how in a long documentary like that about Austerlitz you have not once mentioned the Mamluks who were the elite cavalry in Napoleon’s army and who were the ones breaking the Russian imperial guard in that battle.

Thanks Tristan

As an 1812 reenactor I love this time period in history. Such a great period of power struggles. both in Europe and North America

Tristan, thank you for what you do & for the recommendation. I just wanted you to know that I made a donation over Christmas as a gift to you & your brother to the British Heart Foundation. I hope your mum is doing better. God bless.

It was a great explanation and introducing of that decisive battle ( Austerlitz), which was a first Napoleon Bonaparte victory ✌️ on correlation forces .thant you (🙏 history Hit) channel for sharing.

I watched it Tristian thx

So badly depicted in the movie

@taylorarnold5311

5 ай бұрын

They literally only show the end of the battle as if that was the whole battle.

@warbandplaysAU9178

5 ай бұрын

I don't know why this channel is shilling this movie so hard. It's bad.

@jakubmateju3092

5 ай бұрын

Did enjoy it but it was soooo so clueless....

@eaphantom9214

5 ай бұрын

​@taylorarnold5311 So how long would it be if they showed all of it? 😅 A tad bit more than 5 minutes me thinks!

@christopherf8912

5 ай бұрын

@@cleverusername9369 Practicality

wonder what Dan's actual thoughts are on the historical inaccuracies within Ridley's film

@murkyseb

5 ай бұрын

There were very few inaccuracies

@celston51

5 ай бұрын

@@murkyseb There were several but other commentators have explained them better. 1) Napoleon's army did not shoot the tops of the pyramids off. 2) Josephine died an entire year before Napoleon wanted to return to France for the 100 days. 3) Napoleon was not present at Marie Antionette's execution as he was already in the south of France fighting the British. 4) Napoleon did not lead a cavalry charge at Borodino as he was unwell that day, possibly with a urinary infection. 5) Brunswickers, Nassau, King's German Legion, and Belgian troops are absent from Ripley's depiction of Waterloo, even though they compromised a large chunk of Wellington's army.

@injusticefight5970

5 ай бұрын

​@@celston516. Napoleon did nothing in Waterloo due to hemorrhoid, let alone leading a final charge

@NamoYugen

5 ай бұрын

@@murkyseb you sure bro? lol

Napoleon even earned Czar Nicholas' respect with that battle.

@jabm344

5 ай бұрын

You mean tsar Alexander?

@hhvictor2462

5 ай бұрын

@@jabm344 yes my bad.

Wow just imagine if this battle was portrayed in a blockbuster *angry french noises*

@JayvH

5 ай бұрын

Waterloo was even more of a joke in that movie.

@bine35

5 ай бұрын

Wait you're saying this isn't in the movie?

@deathbringer2336

5 ай бұрын

@@bine35It is but it just consists of people charging into each other and firing artillery into ice

@ToonStory-fh4gn

5 ай бұрын

@@JayvH Ah yes with the legendary charge of Napoleon at the head of its cavalry under the threat of a british sniper

@deathbringer2336

5 ай бұрын

@@ToonStory-fh4gnIt surely went down in history

I still think the best part of the battle was that despite Napoleon’s brilliant planning, the battle still needed his improvisation and effective leadership to be fully won No plan ever survives contact with the enemy, the Russian imperial guard’s near suicidal charges stalled the French advances and inflicted brutal casualties. It was napoleon and his staff’s quick thinking and organisation that turned the situation from a costly won hill into a decisive checkmate

How much of this am I actually going to remember?

To Tristan, speaker of truth. Leader of young men everywhere. HUZZAR! ;)

Artists and musicians on the side of France and her conquests expressed their sentiments in the populist and elite of the time. Prussian music critic E. T.A. Hoffmann, in his famous review of Beethoven's 5th Symphony, singles out for special abuse a certain Bataille des trois Empereurs, a French battle symphony by Louis Jadin celebrating Napaleon's victory at Austerlitz. Leo Tolstoy memorably dramatized the battle as the conclusion of Book 3 and Volume 1 of War and Peace, making it a crucial moment in the lives of both Andrei Bolkonsky, who is badly wounded, and of Nikolai Rostov.

The thick accented French and Russian narrating voices were a nice touch lol.

Do Rivoli!

The Battle of the Three Emperors. With Napoleon the soldier victorious ⚔

THE TALISMAN TATE 💪

The Talisman sent me here

That movie made me lose my lunch with frustration.....I'll never understand these film makers THE TRUTH IS SPECTACULAR ENOUGH!.✌️

Up next - his retreat from Moscow... Probably the most savage exodus of any army, hounded and hunted by merciless Cossacks.

Here because of tristan

I'm really excited about the movie " Napoleon "

Just great, thanks from Montreal! Just back from Corsica where they hate Napoleon (he was Italien, hence his reg height). Both my granfather's and step dad served, granmaw's 1st husband, shell shocked commited suicide never to see his daughter...

@DennisHeikki

5 ай бұрын

served in the napoleonic wars?

Top T, brought me here 🔥

"I am little tired" sounds like quite understatement.

It's possible to send this to Ridley Scott ?

Tristan Tate a G for bringing this to everyone’s attention 💪🏽

Even after 200 years ,napoleon are quiet popular in french peoples heart....a real leader in world

16:32 Dang. Just... Dang. I know from experience that war truly is Hell at times. But... Dang! Imagine this: You are already defeated; and you and your soldiers are in a (somehow organized) retreat; You're trying just to escape with your life from the battle, in the freezing cold, exhausted from combat. And then some jack-hole goes and tries to bring the ammo cart onto the only exit pathway, an extremely narrow pathway, at that, which is the only way that you and your soldiers can possibly get to safety (if only temporarily), forcing you to take the riskier route across some ice that you can only hope is thick enough to support your weight, and it does, just barely...sigh! And then you hear the incoming cannon fire, see and then feel its impacts, and then the ice all around you cracks loudly and quickly... And then comes, immediately, the shock of the freezing cold water, the now wet weight of all of your heavy wool clothes and your boots, your weapon and its powder, your other supplies and equipment, all of them soaked right along with you and however many others of your soldiers had been able to get that far, at least; all of whom (including yourself) were given no other options once that one jack-hole decided that his ammo cart was more important than all of your lives combined... Dang.

Tristan tweeted this video