Sad to see so many people disregard the young girls song. No matter how different we are we are all still family. Our differences shouldn't separate us. Diversity is a beautiful thing.

@gardennovice7896

5 жыл бұрын

The song is about suffering that our people have endured, but we are still one people.

@mikethomas3848

4 жыл бұрын

With that mentality is how they lost for centuries

@Onionoil467

3 жыл бұрын

I don't disagree that we are one people. When it comes to us Mong, Hmu, and Xong we are all connected under the name of Miao. As much as we dislike that name that's our connection to each other. My problem is when people start calling everyone Mong because they aren't. If you get down to it their are multiple ethnic groups under the name Miao. But there's this veil placed on us by the Chinese that tricked us into thinking just because they're Miao, they're Mong. History says that we once were one people but if you listen to this song and you're Mong, you cannot tell me you understand what they're singing. We should embrace the Hmu and Xong as fellow "Miao" people but not as Mong people. You say diversity is a beautiful thing but with this comment your inadvertently homogenizing us. Because the Hmu and Xong don't even claim to be Mong but people keep pushing them into erasing any diversity we have. Ca kuv xauv le nuav; I agree that we shouldn't let our differences separate us, but I don't like it when we start erasing and blurring the lines between not only their culture but ours; Because when you do that there's an underlying thought of superiority within it either consciously or subconsciously. But you're entitled to your opinion as well as I.

@jackjackyphantom8854

3 жыл бұрын

@@Onionoil467 What about Mien people?

Damn, sis was hitting NOTES

Wow so beautiful. I am Hmong/Miao but fr Laos and I wish I can understand the Miao dialect. Would love to visit them in China in the future.

@manedwolfmusic

3 жыл бұрын

Such an incredible culture and people! I loved the song. I really hope you could visit them :)

@tbc7789

3 жыл бұрын

I am also hmong from Laos living in the USA and someday I'm going to visit our hmong people in China

@jackjackyphantom8854

3 жыл бұрын

@@tbc7789 In China they're called Miao not Hmong, I think. And I think the Hmong girls in Vietnam are especially pretty, more pretty than the Hmong girls in US. I don't know why Hmong girls in Vietnam look cuter and Hmong girls in US look more mature.

@pershop4950

2 жыл бұрын

@@jackjackyphantom8854 It just means you can find any kind of girl in any kind of country and culture. To generalize that some girls of some group are better than others or worse than others, is a fallacy.

@jackjackyphantom8854

2 жыл бұрын

@@pershop4950 I realized that the Hmong peoples in Vietnam and US look kinda different. The Hmong girls in Vietnam have the Kawaii vibe and the Hmong girls in US are really Asian American looking.

Miao dates back 4000 years? WOW! Being Hmong, I wonder where my ancestry is from.

@pershop4950

2 жыл бұрын

I saw a brief story of Hmong history and when I realized they are a people during the B.C. times, that's when I realized, that could be the reason they are a people without a country. Their time has come and gone. Even many of these modern day countries that exist today, were formed in the A.D. time frame, It's reasonable that in between, many nations rise and fall, many cultures appear and disappear, and many peoples merge into others or try to remain distinct but don't have their chance to make a come-back.

@baqikenny

2 жыл бұрын

yep, miao/hmong and han shares major lineages, not just small amount, major major significant %%

@FhillipFry

Ай бұрын

It's actually 8000 years

Yes Hmong and Miao are the same. Some of yall are too small minded and don't even listen to the narrator lol. Just search hmoob suav here on youtube and listen carefully how they speak, replay it a few time. They speak hmoobsuav with a strong Chinese accent like how we speak hmonglish. For us Hmong meka, we picked up words from laos/thai/vietnamese as we keep migrating through different countries. As you all know Hmong dont have words for everything thats why many speak hmonglish. The world is always evolving and new words are form.

Lol, they live simple lives in a romantic landscape. Feng Huang is such a crazy touristic place now (even 10 years ago already). They must have struggled to not show footage of KTVs, tourist shops and legions of tourists in this video. Most people there wear traditional costumes for the tourists only, although some old grandmas are still wearing it as part of their daily life. Watching the video I so want to go back there, but reminding myself the reality I think I had enough of once. That video is beautifully made though. The perfect dream.

That girl singing in the beginning is wonderful. She can sing. I love how she ended the song. I'm in love with her 😍😍😄😄😄

Love from Mizoram North East India. Your cultures and traditions look so much alike like us. Especially the way you guys dressed reminds me of the Lai tribe of Chin-Kuki-Mizo. The girl who is singing is so beautiful. 😍😍👍. As a Lusei, I would even fight 10000 soldiers for you and beheaded them.

@rempuiikhawlhring2708

2 жыл бұрын

Lol

They are sooo ❤️ attractive and vibrant

Fanghuang is a beautiful village..got to see it in 2010..

oh my god what did i find???? this is remarkable, lucky me! I was literally cussing out Iphone for mishearing me and putting miao instead of LMFAO and my intuition told me to google it on KZread and wow just wow. I am so grateful I was able to learn about this.

Beautiful and lovely song.

you guys are more in style than any other hmong around the world

A lot of Hmong people do not look the same. You have the ones that have monolid eyelids the stereotypical image of a Chinese person and then you have some of the people with bigger eye sockets with the eyelid crease. I know watching these videos I'm noticing miao representing Hmong but then I noticed there were so many of them in different parts of China and they all have different dialects and some of them still sound Hmong, and for the rest of the others completely Chinese to me I guess because they live next door to others influencing the change in their sub culture, and language.

@tauyang9561

4 жыл бұрын

@@MoonSun12342 Thank you for the clarification.

@tauyang9561

4 жыл бұрын

Also I found through more studies Hmong going by all names given with rejecting o assuming, Check out YOUR LAST NAME, derived, but looking at your grand parents, yourself, history, check out Khorasan, Naga mong, etc. The ria rio Rui rue ur ue uo hg ie io ao ai on eo ui uo ue ONE IS PURE.

@mylxiong08

3 жыл бұрын

@@MoonSun12342 Articles/books on this?

@Onionoil467

3 жыл бұрын

@@MoonSun12342 I like your comment but I wonder, the Mien also share our DNA, does that mean we're also Mien? We also share similar culture with the mien like shamanism, wearing turbans, the pants women wear, etc, does that mean we're Mien? Mienic languages also fall under the language family, does that make us Mien? Mien people have a similar origin to us does that make them Mong too? Outside our ethnic group Yi people wear similar clothes to us but they aren't Mong.

@Onionoil467

3 жыл бұрын

@@MoonSun12342 But lahu people play the qeej. Are they Mong? And what cultural traditions makes us the same? How are the languages the same? Can you understand Hmu and Xong? If you can't then how is the language the same?

Wow, is she singing "kwv txhiaj?" That's so cool! I wonder if they can speak the "Hmong" language or understand it? Sounds like they only speak Chinese?

@pershop4950

2 жыл бұрын

The Miao people still have their own language but just like how you speak English because you grew up in USA (or some other Hmong person speaks French because they grew up in France), they also may be speaking Chinese. And if you can speak Hmong also, that is great as well.

@ruatapachuauruatapachuau9116

2 жыл бұрын

Though I am not Chinese, I prefer to learn Chinese and Asian languages more than those European and Western countries.

@MiaobuMiao

3 ай бұрын

I am Miao from America and I have a Miao friend from China. She speaks Hmong and Chinese. She and I can understand each other a little bit here and there then we won’t understand but then we understand a little again. We have common words that are mutually intelligible (with different sounds and pitches, of course) on words like qeej, kuv, koj, nco, pw, some numbers, colors, etc. However, we have different words for many other stuff more than not, such as phooj ywg (my dialect loaning from Chinese) and her word for friend is (forgive my spelling cus she and I don’t know Guizhou script) pronounced something like lee ying, if my memory serves.

Her kwv txiaj I can almost understand and I am Hmoob Daw

Same drums we use at funerals.

Damn she hitting those notes and she hella pretty

The ending of the song reminds me of some USA southern black folks song. Btw I am Hmong

@difencrosby

4 жыл бұрын

But I thought the Hmong are the same as Miao. Aren’t you the same ethnic group with the same language?

@rohanr.9714

3 жыл бұрын

@@difencrosby yes, miao is just the chinese term, but hmong is the native term.

@difencrosby

3 жыл бұрын

Rohan R. Thanks for clarifying

@user-qj8li6qt3p

3 жыл бұрын

@@difencrosby Yes & No. Depends on who u ask. Same language branch, not always the same language or more specific dialect. Miao is a broad term. Most Hmong outside China would argue they are not Miao, but any Hmong person outside China who were to go back to China to visit would likely b classified as Miao. Miao itself has many sub groups & dialects. Some of those sub dialects can be as different as Italian is to Spanish is to French and a very few as similar as American English is to England's English. Also within the subgroup, they call themselves something different and not all would call themselves Hmong, although a few would call themselves something close to it and a few something completely different. That's why when they hold Miao big events in China they have to use Mandrin the national language as the groups can't even communicate with each other with just their own group dialects alone. Although there are a lot of cultural similarities between the groups.

@difencrosby

3 жыл бұрын

@@user-qj8li6qt3p I know a family at my church from Thailand, they say they are “White Hmong”. What does that mean?

Where can I find this song

How good is this girl!

The place looks kool

Nice culture

Im Hmong American. When i went to China in 2009 met a old Chinese palm reader. He read my palm and said my ancestors where from the yellow river region. Doesn't matter Hmong or Miao. We all originate from China

Did I just hear her say, "Ua siab ntev os?" 1:27

Please inform me indigenous ancient Miao counting 1--10,20,30,100

😘😘😘😘

As a mienh person I see some similarities

Yes! These are the Miao group.

Here also in India we have miao clan and also a place call miao

@youtuberx199

Ай бұрын

Where? Why would they choose to stay there?

Tus me ntxhais no zoo nkauj kawg li 3 hmoob tej me ntxhais niam no zoo tshaj mab sua lawm

Pozdrawiam Piękną Dziewczynę z Chin z. Poland ❤ ❤ 😊

these people are hmong. No doubt, they are just a different group.

@xiaoliu3397

3 жыл бұрын

Their tribe chief helped government to kill other tribes at ancient time, so they were allowed to live there, and were called civilied Miao

@D2E80

Жыл бұрын

@@xiaoliu3397 cooked miao

Miao traditional dress, from china to taiwan to ASEAN to india, tibet-nepal... Bhoo.tan resort american.

@engchoontan8483

6 ай бұрын

Convert the ultra-testaments to giraffe african-american

@engchoontan8483

6 ай бұрын

The-west don't understand nature-climate-weather. The most-colourful and the most-beautiful are usually the most-toxic and most-poisonous. See snakes and sea-snakes and frogs-toads and fishes and ... Never see beautiful clouds and walk straight in... Unnaturally beautiful is worse than poison fog.

@engchoontan8483

6 ай бұрын

Diesel slow burn engine to sucker and spew particulates-soot which is encapsulating and sometimes neutralizing. Battery-EV is activating-detonator catalyst...

These miao and hmong have a totally different language. If you go to real true hmong village in china you will understand them if you're hmong. These are miao. I think hmong and miao came from the same ancestor but over the past hundred or thousand of years we are all split into different group. Hmong are hmong. Real hmong chinese living in china speak hmong that we hmong globally still understand. This miao is more like chinese than hmong if you ask me.

@niamtxiv

2 жыл бұрын

Hmong are a subgroup of Miao. It's like Cantonese and Mandarin to Wenzhou to Wu to Hakka to Shanghainese. They all don't understand each other. What's your point?

@CrayZJo3Davola

2 жыл бұрын

@@niamtxiv my point is many hmong people think all miao are hmong and its the same but its not.

@wavetoearth8260

Жыл бұрын

Yes I can understand miao language and I am Hmong it is very easy to understand

@youtuberx199

Ай бұрын

Was your logic based on DNA testing? If not, you have to question your educational level?

so cool. love culture. not the bland homogenized western-wannabe megacities. - Thomas Lee

China should really be divided into different countries

What if they are the real hmong

Dayak china

how about uploading one without that annoying over voice?

No way hmong and Miao are one the same. We can’t even understand each other. We hmong stuck with our language for thousands of years... We should be able to understand and talk the same if we were one. Nope/ not buying it

@ericvang2827

5 жыл бұрын

Ikr

@gardennovice7896

4 жыл бұрын

Your wrong! Our current youth can't even speak proper Hmong Der. Besides, every country we moved to, we picked up a different accent and have even changed the tones a bit. This also includes picking up different styles of dress and food. Miao was the old name before we changed the name during the secret war of Laos. We were called Meo in Vietnam by the Vietnamese because they could not say Miao correctly, but on the same note used Meo as an insult. Some Lao and Thai also use Meo and Miao as an insult, but its rare now a days since we are mainly known in Southeast Asia as Hmong. China is the only location where we are still called Miao, but if you ask your elders (70-90es years of age), the name Miao was not unheard of nor uncommon. Do some actual research before making statements. Miao is a vast group of people with different languages and beliefs.

@cloroxbitch2491

4 жыл бұрын

Miao and Hmong are one in the same, we just have slightly different accents and dialects. If spoken slow enough we can understand 95% of eachother. Now a lot of Hmong-Chinese people speak a lot of Mandarin. It's just that the Hmong people who remained in China were influenced by Chinese culture and the Hmong people who fled China into Laos picked up some of their culture. If you look up their folklore songs, dances, instruments, clothing; It's all very similar but you have to keep in mind that Hmong who fled to Laos were poor so they did what they could to resemble the traditional clothings etc.. Dont forget that Miao people have different clans. The common dialect in USA and Laos is the white and green dialects. Even the Hmongs who speaks the white dialect cant fully understand Hmongs who speaks true green dialect.

@d-unit1015

4 жыл бұрын

@@cloroxbitch2491 THANK YOU!!!! I could not even come close to what you just said...

@vangwizard

4 жыл бұрын

Listen to hmoob plog, hmoob thai, hmong nyab laj, we could barely understand them. We're losing our traditional hmong language and depending on our region has adapted. If you listen closely you'll be able to hear that in fact we have similarities.

Let me be clear, Hmong and Miao are NOT the same people.

@niamtxiv

5 жыл бұрын

Dude, don't come on my videos to prove how uneducated you are. Hmong are Miao. Gtfo.

@Vangboi414

5 жыл бұрын

tshav ntuj kaj nrig dude, Miao is Chinese term non Han minorities. Why you do obsessed with Miao lol. You can call yourself Miao but please don’t include us Hmong here as Miao. Hmong and Miao are not the same, only to the Han Chinese think that we all the same and use that term for us all.

@niamtxiv

5 жыл бұрын

@@Vangboi414 do I have to educate you? Man, there is always an idiot commenting on my video. Dude, shut up and go away.

@Vangboi414

5 жыл бұрын

tshav ntuj kaj nrig dude you’re dumb man! You can’t even let people have different opinions lol. Lao and Thai have very similar language and cultures and Lao and Thai are still not same people. Same with Chinese and Japanese lol. You Claim these Miao as Hmong is an insult to them as well. You need to educate yourself bro. Hmong and these Miao are two different groups. The only Miao that closest to Hmong in south East Asian are those in Yunnan and Guangxi provinces where we can understand them up 80% without problems. These Miao is completely different group with different language that we don’t even understand at all.

@nhykue7392

5 жыл бұрын

​@@Vangboi414 Gao Xiong (the Miaos in this video), Hmub and Hmong all belong to the same language family group and share several cultural identity. But its not so much Hmong ppl claiming everyone of them as our own as much as they do the same to us. Yang Geli or Geli Yang (clan name Yang) is a famous Hmub miao singer in China who's learned to speak white dialect Hmong has made statements that the sentiment that we are one is quite normal among different Miao/Hmong groups. Yang Geli has even made a personal stop at my brothers farm to get a cow from his Yang relatives in California. I myself have had the honor of meeting his younger brother who is also a musician at the Sacramento Hmong new year and the sentiments rings true with with him as well. Also because our languages isn't mutually intelligible doesn't mean we aren't any closer to each other, just look at Han Chinese, they have 12 different dialect many of whom are completely mutually intelligible from one another. Even Jet Li and Bruce Lee theoretically couldn't understand each other if they tried (Jet lI speaks Mandarin), Bruce Lee (speaks Cantonese) but yet are still considered the same ppl.

All the hmong men that couldn't escape the genecide we're all killed during the Chinese invasion and substituted with Chinese husbands so most of those miao are mainly Chinese not even Hmong anymore. The real Hmong are the ones in America, France, Australia, Laos, Thailand, and Vietnam.

@pershop4950

2 жыл бұрын

These "real" Hmong that you mention are the ones that came out of China into other countries like Laos, Thailand, and Vietnam. And even in the 1970s and 1908s, some of those Lao Hmong people added to the populations in Thailand and Vietnam. So in that case, they're not real either then. I think it's not possible to trace which Hmong groups came from where and where they went, and which Hmong groups added to them over the centuries. For me, I think the Miao are the ancestral group. Other Hmong groups came from them. This includes the ones who ended up in Laos, Vietnam, Thailand, and other SE Asian countries where we customarily think of when we think of Hmong people. As for the ones who left SE Asia, that can be directly linked to the consequences of the Vietnam War, and so most of those came from Laos.

@yangvue1573

2 жыл бұрын

@@pershop4950 Hmong men that escaped the genecide fled south to Northern Vietnam, Laos, Thailand, Burma, and ext. With their family and then during the vang pao era due to the Vietnam war the Hmong people whom sided with the Americans have to flee Laos also due to procecution escaped to Thailand and then sponsored to France, Australia, America, and south America. All the Miaos in china are communist Chinese non of them are real Hmong now. I dear you to go ask who their grandfather is. LoL A Miao Hmong singer from china even admitted that her grandfather is Chinese, but her grandmother was Hmong. 😂

@yangvue1573

2 жыл бұрын

Hey make sure they don't take you on a training regimen or you'll never return. Communist are very evil.

@Jaybee82

Жыл бұрын

Dude if they genocide back then how are our modern hmong even real hmong lol. No disrespect but no hmong now a days are pure . Lao/hmong , han/hmong etc etc...

@youtuberx199

Ай бұрын

LOL. Even Hmong Americans got their DNA test and results say that they have large amount of DNA's are Chinese. Unless your DNA is mixed with others in South East Asia.

As we are the Hmong peoples (The Hmong nation), we prayed God to save our peoples, our lifes and our futures. GOD, we pray you days and nights to protect our nation, our lifes and our futures by giving us back of our country that was taken away by our enemy Chinese peoples. The Chinese peoples used to killed our peoples for more than hundreds of millions lifes in the past over 13,000 years ago, and still intend to continue to kill and genocide our peoples without stopping it. God, we pray you, you should mercy our peoples, our nation. Because we are the most love nation in this world, who loves the most freedoms, peaceful, and deserve the most ambitious futures, and we're the most innocent nation in this world, so you should save and protect us to keep our nation to sustainable in this world. This is the only way you can save and protect our nation from being eliminating to disappeared by our enemy. So, please must hands us up by giving us back of our country soon. Thanks to GOD for saving our nation in the PAST for many millions of years and to THE ENDLESS FUTURES.