5 years from now and you will see andy making video about how good lebron james/chris paul actually

@Eshaw205

4 жыл бұрын

Namtsu D man....that time is almost near huh

@shrek8651

4 жыл бұрын

Namtsu D prob not lebron because we all know how good he is

@michaelboyles714

4 жыл бұрын

He almost already did a how good was Chris Paul actually, he just didn’t call it that. When did all these players get old? (Looks in mirror) oh no...

@Niko-he4ji

4 жыл бұрын

@@michaelboyles714 haha

@LiiftYourself

4 жыл бұрын

The derrick rose one gonna hit

I'm getting far more confused about traveling violation nowadays

@SpeedHomeAttack

4 жыл бұрын

I'm getting more confused about flopping nowadays

@dacooooo

4 жыл бұрын

Even travelling has become subjective now a days..! smh

@hellobruh4569

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah same bro

@jylim3733

4 жыл бұрын

Why does these comments makes me think of james.. the hardened ones

@Ozem_Israel

4 жыл бұрын

Curry did exactly hardens step back in a game and got called. WTF?

How good is andy hoops actually?

@tomasroberts3481

4 жыл бұрын

Da goat

@lifesfailure939

4 жыл бұрын

If you need to ask how good Andy is you need to get your life in check the answer is obvious

@kajioverheaven7520

4 жыл бұрын

Life's Failure it’s a joke chill out bruh.

I love how the NBA kept trying to screw wilt over with the rule changes and still dominated the nba. Man imagine trying to guard wilt in his prime tho.

@blinblinthing

4 жыл бұрын

Yet we always hear how unstoppable Mike was or how he'd score 100 in today's league.

@Somm_RJ

4 жыл бұрын

@@blinblinthing well, he kinda do. Guards thrive these days and MJ is a guard. Wider lanes without illegal defense and no more hand-checking. The game in the old times rely heavily on bigs, so that's not a surprise. If you have a dominating center back then, then he will get the ball almost everytime. In the earliest times, just like today, they also play without hand checking. Remember, hand-checking was introduced in the 70s and removed in the 2000s.

@12savage68

4 жыл бұрын

@@Somm_RJ we saw guys like Kobe and Iverson play with and without hand checking....there was no significant improvement for them....🤷🏿‍♂️

@FlyingV555

4 жыл бұрын

Jay Waz not even LeBron or Kawhi hell even Jordan could guard him.

@Somm_RJ

4 жыл бұрын

@@12savage68 I love how you conveniently ignored the other parts of my comments. The only post-player to win the MVP since the change is Nowitzki, which is only part-time post-player. It was an even spread of bigs and perimeter players in the scoring leaders before the change. Tony Parker led the league in points in the paint. Guard's scoring went up after the change. Unassisted field goals went up. Iso ball era. Team-scoring league-wide increased by 4 points. Detroit Pistons (2003-2004 Champion) went from legendary defensive team to elite defensive team after the rule changed. The reason why the 2 players you mentioned did not improve significantly is that they chose not to shoot more.

The offensive rebound shot clock rule change was made to conform with the fiba rules

I think hand checking should be allowed, theres a difference between having your hand resting lightly on the other plays back and say pushing or holding the other player. It's getting to the point where if a defender even makes any slight contact it's a foul. It's so soft and much harder for defense to stop the offense. They're basically relying on them to mist shots now lol.

You must be extremely uncompetitive if you're upset a 24 second shot clock was implemented.

@Johnkoth

4 жыл бұрын

24 second clock turnovers, shot attempts and higher scores. More fans of NBA too

@kylethomas2993

4 жыл бұрын

@@Johnkoth I can see how people thought 24 would be too fast, but it was a great change. I am probably a bigger CBB fan and probably prefer the 30 second shot clock with a more slow it down pace, but I think 24 fits the NBA better with a faster pace

@Bigedub101

3 жыл бұрын

That be painfully boring 😴 if I watched a game where players just held the ball for 5 minutes

@aaronsung6208

2 жыл бұрын

24s was drastic when it goes from infinite time to 24. NCAA player sometime aint able to get good shot for 30s.

of course the 24 second shot clock had to be implemented

@Johnkoth

4 жыл бұрын

or else the NBA would have gone out of business.

@stpbasss3773

2 жыл бұрын

It would be teams passing it around 50 times in one possession like before they had the shot clock. Watching clips of that period doesn't even look like basketball lol.

How good was Bob McAdoo a Underrated scorer in the the 70s.

@bigstupidgrin

4 жыл бұрын

hell yeah to this video

@clix8100

4 жыл бұрын

Omfg yes and I'm all about him and the braves

@timhoward5

4 жыл бұрын

Heat. Very Underrated

@andreaspapadakis2602

4 жыл бұрын

@@timhoward5 having seen both enough as good as KD..same height same extension carazy handles for his era and a better jump shot as well..didnt have a game from outside the 3 zone but noone did at the time...

@timhoward5

4 жыл бұрын

@@andreaspapadakis2602 Exactly!

It would be a very bad rule change to make 3 pt attempts only earn 2 free throws on fouls. The reason it was created in the first place was because at the end of games if a team is down three, it prevents the team in the lead from gaining an advantage by intentionally fouling a shooter.

How good was Dikembe Mutombo ? Top 5 defensive player of all time

@chanafool1459

4 жыл бұрын

No

@duck8624

4 жыл бұрын

@@Letthat After Hakeem you lost all credibility... Hakeem is top 2, not sure if Scottie is even top 5, Rodman is top 5 but the other ones you tried too much to look different but now you look hella dumb

@Johnkoth

4 жыл бұрын

I would not put Hakeem top 5. Bill Russell yes. MJ. Wilt ?, then ? ?

@duck8624

4 жыл бұрын

@@Johnkoth top 5: Bill Hakeem Rodman Mutombo MAYBE Pippen

@Johnkoth

4 жыл бұрын

Rodman did a better job on Shaq than Hakeem did. Hakeem is no #2.

Informative as always Andy! I think changing the 10 second to 8 second cross half court rule sped the game up a good deal!

The shot clock rule is a good rule and should be implemented in general basketball. Not just college and professional levels.

hack a shaq rule being removed...

@TheIcemanthomas

4 жыл бұрын

it wasnt fully removed. Only in the closing minutes of quarters.

@Johnkoth

4 жыл бұрын

Its a dumb rule.

How good was Nick van Exel Imo very underrated player.

Bravo - now THIS is great video idea, and I'm surprised nobody did this already :) Not that I don't appreciate the ' how good was xx player really" vids, they're cool. But they *can* get a bit thin in interest range, whereas this is widely appealing and applicable to all eras/ages of interest. *Grand slam, mang!*

Great video keep up the good work

Nice video Andy. More to come.

2:09 So we not gone talk about him getting caught slipping

Good video. Great information!

Great topic idea!!! 😛😛😛

Great video brother !

24 second rule saved the league

@razkable

4 жыл бұрын

the 48 bullets won a title without a 13.5 ppg scorer..thats how bad the baa and nbdl were back then ....thats why the shot clock rule had to be made...thats just nonsense to win a title without a true go to scorer at all?.you all can just score 2-12 as a team and win a title?...stupid...

Hand checking abuse = straight up fouls Idgaf

@LordCaltricBlue

4 жыл бұрын

Rodmon once said he thought that was how you play basketball

@TyBrezzy11

4 жыл бұрын

IN ED If you get stopped by Hand Checking after 2010 nigga you suck 😂

@aidansrandomstuff6843

4 жыл бұрын

For all the people who don’t know what idgaf means it’s i don’t give a fuck

@bakercorps

4 жыл бұрын

@@TyBrezzy11 cant no nigga hold me.

@sbtruestone

4 жыл бұрын

@@TyBrezzy11 you are indian who tf gave you the n word pass

How good was Chris Mullin actually?

@nicholasalexander9866

4 жыл бұрын

That’s a good one

Love this channel

How good was Andy Hoops videos actually? Very good actually

I'd love to see teams be able to challenge most calls at least and 3 challenges a game. Furthermore harsher penalties for flops as well as stopping where you can just stand there and take a charge.

Great video

The Defensive 3 second rule, IMO, has had a bigger impact than the hand checking. It's practically taking the Big Man out of the defensive side of the court. :(

What about a video analyzing the career of Danny Ainge? Form college to GM? Thanks for the great work!!

Andy please make a vid about jerry stuckhouse and how good was he. He is one of my favorite NBA player. Thanks and more power to your channel!

Cool video. But I think the institution of Flagrant Fouls in 91 also changed the game tremendously.

@toddpacker1015

2 жыл бұрын

Pistons abused the fact they could beat the shit out of Jordan had to be done

@nonamewillbegiven6847

Жыл бұрын

I/diot

7:55 I agree that's a good idea! Also I would allow hand shaking beyond the 3-pt line.

@TyBrezzy11

4 жыл бұрын

TheCategor Hand Checking needs a return and 3 second defensive violation should be abolished

Still waiting for “how good was really tony Allen” please please next videos

LMFAOOO remember when lebron was on the heat and you litterally couldnt touch him at all. 😂😂😂😂😂😂

@TyBrezzy11

4 жыл бұрын

Lebron KING James He’s buns

@petargotich

3 жыл бұрын

2011 finals

The technical foul rule from 2010 where you get t'd up for reacting to a foul or arguing with a ref is trash and fully completed the pussyfication of the league

Hi Andy.. always wanted to know in your opinion, who’s the greatest defensive player of all time? Quite underrated topic.. anyway to for the great video as always..

The defensive 3 second rule completely negates the allowance of zone defense.

Do how good was brad miller actually

Shot clock saved the game, without it Lacrosse and Golf would be bigger than Basketball.

Andy, like most commentators or nba fans, you didnt get the actual meaning of the charge circle, as the Defender being inside the circel doesnt automatically make it a defensive foul, it just eliminates the charging foul (offensive foul after a drive from outside the box).

The "gather step" is a big change I think, and we haven't seen it's full effect, as players are only starting to use it fully (following Harden)

Handcheck needed to be ruled again in the game seriously. It would be effective for players who has great Perimeter Defense it would be more competitive ,Flopping is legal but Hand checking is illegal lol

Allowing zone defence was the correct decision even though the stars like T Mac and Kobe didn’t like it. At the end of the day basketball is a team sports. I don’t see why teams should not be allowed to play defence as a team unit. Plus the illegal defence was just so confusing to everyone.

@TyBrezzy11

4 жыл бұрын

Gordon Tseng People just ran zones anyway

@razkable

4 жыл бұрын

kobe and t mac got lucky cause the nba got rid of hand checking right after they allowed zone defense for real....kobe and t mac in 2004-2008 had great seasons cause of this when healthy....they looked like superstars even after the got older cause the league allowed them to shoot freely after they played in their primes against it...total b.s....it also opened a shorter player like d wade or curry or ai to still be able to dominate so ai did not age fast like he would of if hand checking was still allowed..his prime like many perimeter player's primes was extended due to this rule...which makes mj even more impressive .....if only zone defense was allowed when he played..thats really the only rule he exploited a little...everything else went against him in his era

@federalfreemoneylackofrese9937

3 жыл бұрын

@@razkable Is there any difference btw had checking era vs when it was removed? What was the avg score to win a game when it was implemented vs after? Any evidence it made it harder?

Hand checking , better defense in general needs to come back

@AriEru16394681315

4 жыл бұрын

Thats why steph curry is dominating from 3pt line

@duronbryant5921

2 жыл бұрын

They need to get rid of defensive 3 second rule, that would change the game completely and carry it back to the old days. And they to get rid of the 5 second rule, they also need to carry back Hand Checking

Andy u said u would want 2 free throws for a foul on a 3 point shot. That would be really bad because in a situation a team is down 3 points with not much time, the other team could just hack on purpose and only be punished with 2 free throws.

@ivanburden4658

4 жыл бұрын

That's what would happen in the 90s if a team was up by three, they would foul any three point shooter. I even remember some almost tackles to make sure they didn't hit the shot.

The Malice in the Palace was the main reason why hand checking rule was banned on the NBA for the past 15 years & it happened on the same year that infamous incident had happened. And of course it also includes the Flagrant Foul violation & automatic ejection if a player had committed a technical foul twice on the same game.

@TheIcemanthomas

4 жыл бұрын

the malice incident has no correlation to hand checking.

@wazzup233

4 жыл бұрын

@@TheIcemanthomas The former NBA Commissioner David Stern wants his league to have clean & fair games after that incident (i.e., he doesn't want Hooliganism in the NBA) so that hand checking should be forbid to use & he'd also increased the penalties on technical foul & even introduced the flagrant foul calls (in the case of FIBA, its called unsportsmanship foul). The Bad Boys Pistons in the 80s had introduced the hand checking method & it was a dirty move for some of the NBA Players like Larry Bird & Micheal Jordan.

I really miss the good old nba with realk defense and physical players like the old Knicks or Pistons! Today every game looks looks like a training game....and all the 3s! Make the NBA great again!

@VictorFernandezBigdestroyer

4 жыл бұрын

ajztdauz I’ll get you banned from KZread

almost 300k!

Andy your the G.O.A.T at NBA History

I’m surprised that the cylinder goal tending rule wasn’t on this list, it is definitely one of the reasons along with 3 point shooting that hurt the big man

Andy 300k subs on the way !!!!

Mikan's dominance dwindled as the lane got wider

ANDY PLEASE REPLY TO THIS. CAN I USE SOME PARTS OF THIS VIDEO FOR MY ASSIGNMENT? I study Sports Management Masters in Melbourne and just last week, I was tasked with an assignment about how sports evolve over the years. Most of the people in my course are doing this assignment about Cricket, Soccer, Rugby and what not but I am doing it about my love - Basketball and it just happens that you uploaded this great video about how rules changed in NBA. I wish to use some parts of this video in my assignment and I want your permission to do that. P.S. Sorry for all caps. I just did it to get noticed.

@KORANHORACIO

4 жыл бұрын

That's not how this works find a email

I would re-add hand checking. Contact only allowed to the torso (hips and above - chest and below) no contact with the shoulder or arms. and only 1 second touches, no holding onto players or maintaining contact with players.

The only reason why the NBA change the rule of having 3 free throws when a player draws a foul while attempting a 3-point shot is because of what happen in the 1994 NBA Finals. In Game 3 of the 1994 Finals between New York and Houston, John Starks draws a foul while attempting a 3-pointer and was only rewarded just 2 free throws which led to the Rockets winning the game by just 4 points.

I used to hate when I used to cheer against the Miami Heat and Dwyane Wade used to pump fake a defender in the air and then jump right into him and get the foul call

@TyBrezzy11

4 жыл бұрын

Dwayne Carter that was 200 IQ

@razkable

4 жыл бұрын

don't jump into him

Once he started talking about the bad boys pistons I got a Recommendation for how good the bad boys pistons were

What about the ninja headbands??

Yup andy

I wish hand checking was back

Half court shots should be worth 4pts

@TheIcemanthomas

4 жыл бұрын

no

@johndavis9321

4 жыл бұрын

Nah

@timhoward5

4 жыл бұрын

No

@raizario942

4 жыл бұрын

why? its unnecessary and its not even impressive...0 athleticism. anything that any grade 8 can do should not impress any fan of professional sports.

@utubebroadcaster

4 жыл бұрын

@@raizario942 I guess that on that basis they should get rid of 3pt shots?

Can you please do a how good was Monta Ellis actually ? Please

Removing hand checking didn't improve popularity of nba, but rise of social networks and access to Internet did. Not in every country you can watch nba on tv, however once everyone got computers and Internet naturally popularity rose.

0:32 the guy in the bottom middle looked like tom holland

Surprised ESPN hasn’t reached out to you for a segment, been good for years.

Cool fact but pistons played in both the highest and lowest scoring games in nba history and won both🔥🔥💪💪

Dikembe Mutombo ? one of the all time best defensive players

The NBA came along way

2:11 boom

Today's game may be more soft, but I like it's faster pace, higher scoring, spread out floor, more passing, more zone & switching, and less isolation ball. And Andy acknowledges the current NBA has exploded in popularity because of it.

@ogmusik2549

4 жыл бұрын

Iso is fun boring just watching thr same shot over and over. W

@raizario942

4 жыл бұрын

its fluff man. NBA exploded because of social media and not because of rule changes. The social media gives fluff and excites people from a shallow standpoint. Nobody is playing D when the score is above 110. DPOY is still worth even? How are you an athlete when a grade 8 basketball player can do what you are best at in an NBA court (3 pointers). How is that more impressive than somebody dunking on your center and your power forward while being hacked by your shooting guard on his way up? how is a step back to create space more impressive than a lean back fadeway jumper. its the fluff of social media that helped the explosion of the NBA. Gah! these NBA players are getting payed more for doing a lot less...

regarding the 3 free throw rule: If they would change it back teams probably would start to abuse it against players like curry or harden.Conceding 2 FTs is better than a made 3 pointer. it would be better to change the rule for what is a foul so shooters can't force them that much.

If Jordan played today he will be scoring at will. If Lebron played in old school basketball he will stop driving to the basket.🤣🤣🤣

i heard players and coaches from the 1960s state that in that era, that double hand checking was alllowed. so how was it in 1976?

How good is Anthony Bennett actually? He the GOAT

Do a video on Baron Davis

Does no hand-checking means that if I post up with back to the defender, they can't use their arms or hands to even touch me?? I am a post-up guard and often people will just shove me out of the position using their hand and say t's not a foul since I have my back to them. Very annoying....

@xStokelyx

4 жыл бұрын

They can have their arm on you (bent elbow, not stiff-arm) if you're posting up below the free throw circle (I think). However, they shouldn't be shoving you, but should be holding their position. I might as well add that this applies to rebounding as well. I see a lot of lazy players 'boxing out' by stiff-arming and shoving rather than getting in proper position with their feet and blocking with their bodies. One way to combat aggressive post defense like that is initiating contact once to get a feel for their positioning (unless they're already right up on you when receiving the ball), then spinning off them on the next initiation in anticipation of their 'push.'

@rockie8254

4 жыл бұрын

@@xStokelyx Thanks Steven, Andy pointed out such a good point, let us watch new season of NBA to see if any one actually use elbow against post-up guys. I mean it is obviously that the NBA has become more guard/shooting centric, which is not a bad thing IMO. I am not tall but relatively strong as a guard, so I post up on almost every first possesion of a pick-up game or last possesion, totally catch them off guard. ;p

3 point limits! Bring back the post!

Whats the website to find out every NBA rule?

Day 2 on hoping Andy does a video on Mehmet Okur

Teams played zone back in the 90s

@LordCaltricBlue

4 жыл бұрын

It still was illegal tho.

Hi, they banned free throw dunks When Bill was a Rookie, not Wilt. They were banned in college before Wilt was in college so while the rumor is that he did dunk free throws in high school he did it exactly zero times as a college or pro athlete.

Changing rules then : Game changer. Rules now : Ban on ninja headbands

they should remove the flops :))

I hope the NBA adjust the rule regarding foul baiting. Rusty Buckets made a video about it and he said that when an offensive player fakes, jumps into the defender's body to draw a foul it should be called an offensive foul.

@closer7735

4 жыл бұрын

If the offensive player fakes and the defense jumps, whos fault is that? The defense. Thats a clear foul, the defense is completely blocking the offensive players drive.

how bout "5-8 Steps is not a travel but a ticket to Shaqtin a Fool Rule"???

How good was Nick Van Exel?

Wilt chamberlain dunking free throws should tell you just how less advanced they were back in the day. A 7 footer would smack it out of the air before it even got back to wilt today

Recent explosion in popularity? Viewship has been way down over the last ten years. This 3pt era sucks. Its hard to watch and super boring.

@toddpacker1015

2 жыл бұрын

Ratings are as low now than ever... this video is from 2019 so who the hell knows

Next major change has to be with threes me personally the nba is gonna find something that James harden does to initiate contact or when he steps back that is a violation and make something like that a new rule

@LordCaltricBlue

4 жыл бұрын

So no more step back jumpers?

They should bring free throw dunks back, that would be the shiiiiiit Edit: the white shadow shoulda done an episode on the introduction to the three

2:12 Since the basketball court was widened from 12 ft to 16 ft in 1964, it is now impossible to get a 100 points or more record in a single game for a player. Wilt Chamberlain's 100 points record had done that record just two years before it was widened its court & the only NBA superstar had almost beaten that record was Kobe Bryant on an 81 points record in 2006. If the basketball court is still 12 ft wide today, surely the Black Mamba would beat Wilt's record by probably 101 or 105 points, but due to the change of the width of basketball court in 1964, it won't happened anytime soon.

@TheIcemanthomas

4 жыл бұрын

not necessarily. Smaller courts, mean mess spacing. Which gives kobe less room to operate. Theoretically that means it would be harder for him to score not easier.

I think the playoff seeding change deserve to be in the top 10

first lol awesome as always man!

What about the 8 second half court rule. Instead of 10 seconds to bring it up to half court, the nba changed it to & seconds. Made the game move faster. Also the Sam cassell incident in the playoffs, clippers vs suns.

How good was Elton Brand

If goaltending was allowed, think of how big and tall they would be

like gaming patch notes and fixes lol

How good is Latrell Sprewell actually ?