We know how effective Roman armies were as a unit, but who would you back one on one, a Celtic warrior or a Roman legionary?

@gbendicion7052

2 жыл бұрын

Roman Legionary of course.

@stephensmith2601

2 жыл бұрын

In a one on one fight - assuming the two were equally fit and experienced - I guess it would depend on whether the Celt was armed with a spear or a longsword. I think a warrior trained to use a spear to lunge, cut and slice may well have had an advantage. That advantage would, of course, have been much greater if he/she had drunk some of his/her Gaulish cousins' magic potion.

@tjw139

2 жыл бұрын

Is it one of the bulk of Celtic warriors, who were not professional soldiers but armed 'peasants'? If so, I'll go with the trained, professional, Roman. If it's one of the 'proper' Celtic warriors? Might be a different outcome. But I'll still go with the Roman.

@bigchili1626

2 жыл бұрын

the veteran, professional soldier. every time

@1337fraggzb00N

2 жыл бұрын

Cheruskan.

I'm glad that you filmed the opening standing in ankle-deep water rather than someplace either sane or sensible

@jonmcclane7433

2 жыл бұрын

Hahahaha well played

@lindagoad2163

2 жыл бұрын

When the water hits his rolled up trouser it makes me very uncomfortable

@EdgyDabs47

2 жыл бұрын

Well, Caesar's amphibious assualt against the Britons was along that shoreline. They aren't just randomly standing in the water.

@jinz0

2 жыл бұрын

he is probably trying to reimagine the time or nature or something

@wally9935

2 жыл бұрын

When you go to the beach you dip your feet and if you don’t you’re a neet

lovely to see Ray Mears on these, I love the way he looks at history as a living thing and not just something from the past that has no value. You can see his brain whirling away as it relates to life in the outdoor world that some of us still live in.

@semprelazio8864

2 жыл бұрын

🦅SPQR

@petras8385

2 жыл бұрын

Yea Ray is a legend!

Fucking love seeing ray back on my tv, as a young boy he inspired me and still does.

Ray is a national treasure.

@kurgisempyrion6125

2 жыл бұрын

You aren't wrong - a lot more of a national treasure than some of the other so called candidates.

I grew up with Ray and loved his tv shows during my childhood, it's fantastic to see his cheery bubbly face again, love you ray:D

@petras8385

2 жыл бұрын

Yes same here, good to see him again, the original bushcrafter in my book

@northernembersoutdoors1045

2 жыл бұрын

Ray Mears is one of the few people I truly respect. His bushcraft series were amazing.

@malikmullings9009

Жыл бұрын

True

@chrisgibson5267

Жыл бұрын

@@petras8385 And let's not forget the one, the only, Major Les Hiddins.

@RZPPAA

Жыл бұрын

His mate talking about magic mushrooms was my favourite.

One thing is for sure. They marched 20 miles a day with full pack, sword, shield, pilum, shovel. And at the end of the day built a 'marching fort' which was taken down again in the morning. Their diet must have been high calorie and protein otherwise they would not have lasted.

@arthipex8512

2 жыл бұрын

I'm not a historian, but in his books, Caesar explains in great detail how his army was fed. They didn't use supply lines like modern armies do, as they would have been too vulnerable to raids. Instead, they mostly resorted to foraging in the surrounding area, and he gives many examples on how his enemies tried to deny them food by attacking foraging parties. They were often running low on food - even coming close to starvation at one particular example (siege of Uxellodunum). Therefore, I'd guess that their meals weren't standardized at all. They probably ate whatever they could find.

@carlericvonkleistiii2188

2 жыл бұрын

@@arthipex8512 "Foraging." No, Mr. Villager, you haven't been robbed. You've just been foraged, good and proper.

@stephenlyon1358

2 жыл бұрын

@@carlericvonkleistiii2188 skyrim for the nords!

@carlericvonkleistiii2188

2 жыл бұрын

@@stephenlyon1358 GRRM The Brotherhood Without Banners to Sandor Clegane. 😂😀

@MrBellsBlues

2 жыл бұрын

Carbs are more important here, not protein. Legumes are great as they contain both carbs and protein, i'd rather a handful of lentils than chicken to perform a physical task. also i'm pretty sure it was 30 miles not 20... so maybe an extra piece of bread for me please Centurion.

I think those volleys of pilums in the last moments of a charge must be one of the most underrated horrifying moments of those melee engagements.

@greypilgrim228

2 жыл бұрын

Especially as the opposing army would be pelting down the field towards the Roman ranks, so any pilum thrown would have hit home with twice the force, men would literally have thrown themselves on the point, unable to stop before it crashed through their chest and burst out the back. There are stories of men becoming standing corpses, because the pilum had gone through them (either the body, a leg, etc.) and down into the ground, fixing them to the spot. The effect would be absolutely terrifying as the first few ranks disintegrated before such a volley. Those behind stumbling over the dead and dying becoming a disorganised rabble, only for the Roman shield wall in-front to take 10 swift paces forward and begin the butchers work, meticulously stabbing and hacking with machine-like rhythm.

@emanuelgaldes3515

Жыл бұрын

The British disease, sticking an s at the end of any foreign word (in this case a Latin word) out of sheer laziness, to turn it into a plural. Latin UM plural A. So PILA not pilums, REFERENDA not referendums, STADIA not stadiums etc.

@johndaarteest

Жыл бұрын

@@greypilgrim228 We get the point - as they did really 🤔

@greypilgrim228

Жыл бұрын

@@johndaarteest 😂

@jameswells554

Жыл бұрын

That's where Roman Discipline shone the brightest.

I was there the day Caesar's legion lobbed us with onions. We all cried that day.

@davidwong9230

2 жыл бұрын

They’re firing onions at us. I don’t relish the experience 🧅 They had thought about firing cabbages instead, but the cabbages got leafed out of the supply requisition 😆

@anemicsilence

2 жыл бұрын

😂😂👍👍

I like the fact that when the reenactor didn't know the answer, he said so and then gave an educated guess. And as a retired combat veteran for anyone to promulgate the idea that a legion didn't eat everything available to it, beggar's belief. Either they have never been hungry or simply lack common sense. Your legion is moving through hostile territory you come to a village with sheep/goats/cattle etc, A. You leave the animals so the enemy can eat them after you pass. B. You kill the animals and leave them to be eaten by the enemy after you pass. C. You kill the animals and have a big frkn barbeque!

@kraigthorne3549

2 жыл бұрын

It looks like you are a better expert than the guy on the video.

@danstoye3902

2 жыл бұрын

@@kraigthorne3549 I learned a long time ago never to call myself expert at anything. I'm pretty fluent in German, but then a buddy of mine speaks it with a Bavarian accent. I'm on the chairlift feeling pretty good about my skiing ability when in front of me two young teenagers spring from the chairlift land next to one of the towers and proceed to absolutely kill a run downhill. Yup when somebody asks me if I know about something, I say just a little. Merry Christmas

@polaris30000

2 жыл бұрын

Not to mention that you can then dry out whatever meat you don't eat for later, or grind and mix it with the animal fats and whatever local vegetation you can find, dry it, and have your own ancient version of an IMP, which I'd gander is probably what they did.

@greypilgrim228

2 жыл бұрын

That's true, but you also have to be willing to pay for the loss of the animals to whatever village/town you take them from, provided you know the village is conducive to your side or remains neutral, because otherwise you can incite them to hatred and stir up more anti Roman sentiment in the region as your Legion/s march across open country. Napoleon found that out at great cost in Spain, which the Duke of Wellington exploited by paying for everything taken, not living off the land raiding villages for firewood/food/women etc. and encouraging people to rise up, or to support the existing guerrillas in the area.

@danielburgess7785

2 жыл бұрын

Grill, not BBQ. BBQ cooks with indirect heat via the smoke which takes much longer.

Ray Mears is one of my heroes. Very cool to see him hosting!

From reading Asterix, all Caesar needed to do was wait til 3pm when all the Brits would be drinking hot water(No tea back then!) & he could've landed unmolested.

I love that they went for an accurate 1st Century BC depiction of a legionary rather than the early imperial lorica segmentata look that everyone defaults to.

The pilum was genius, unable to be used by the enemy after being thrown at them, weighs down the shield it hits and makes it basicly unusable, and if it hits a person it still does "normal" damage.

@massimookissed1023

Жыл бұрын

Plus it could still pierce you even if you took cover behind your shield. But yeah, as a way of deshielding an opponent before fisticuffs start, it's clever.

@RaveyDavey

4 ай бұрын

Some guy on YT has tested the “unable to be thrown back” theory and found it wanting.

@RiTorpedo

Ай бұрын

Not only that. They had a some sort of darts weighted with led. they call it Plumbata. Those darts had a range more than 30 meters, far more than Pilum.

Pleased Ray is still around. Had no idea, as I’ve not come across him for aeons.

Ray deffo knows all the answers to the questions he's asking rays a legend here in the UK used to love his shows way back when

How wonderful to see Ray Mears - he brings such passion to everything he does.

Looking forward to seeing much more great content on this channel. Now I have to find out why Dan is up a ship's mast!

@HistoryHit

2 жыл бұрын

Very much appreciated!

@gushlergushler

2 жыл бұрын

I'd LOVE a collaboration between your channels. Two great ones of youtube.

@Cl0ckcl0ck

2 жыл бұрын

Let's hope it's for the Raid on Medway!

That reenactor has got some years on him but by the way he handles those weapons he'd sure as heck do me over.

I love Ray Mears!

Smirking Roman Soldier Happy At His Job.

Good to see Ray. He always makes a great video.

Props to these Roman reenactors. I've met a few in the reenactment community while doing reenactment (16th century English pike soldiers), and they are even shorter-staffed then our group. Imagine trying to demonstrate a testudo when you only have a few guys! Props to them for keeping up the good fight!

@stevewallis8197

Жыл бұрын

Surely you can't describe someone carrying a C16th pike as "short-staffed".... 😂

Ray mears- Legend

Wicked spiral on the pilum throw

Interesting to have Ray Mears doing this. Excellent

Great to see Ray Mears again. Would welcome more contributions from him!

It's nice to see Ray, a true legend. And the re enactor was a class act as well!

Good to see Ray back on the screen

This is one of my favourite channels now. I'm loving the very informative videos and the people on it, like Ray and David.

@Mr__Chicken

2 жыл бұрын

@@vigunfighter What don't you like and what channel's would you recommend?

The best 16 mins of KZread I have watched in a long time. Thank you.

This was a brilliant video, guys. Love your work!

Last time I was this early, Romulus was still an infant.

This is so interesting. Thank you for this video!

Huge fan of history hit, you guys do an amazing job, and I really enjoy the topics you choose. Keep up the great content.

Always happy to see Ray Mears.

The pilum was an amazing weapon. Amazing. I love it.

I found ray mears one of my favourite people ever, somehow doing something I love especially Roman history, why did I not find this before xD

I love the paper-thin shield at the start, but it looks like a fun watch and it's always good to see Mr. Mears.

This is based on a single account. To quote from the video "...Caesar telling us how jeopardous this whole invasion was and yet, the bravery of the Roman soldiers, led by Caesar ... having effectively to deploy their A game to win a very, very difficult fight ... We know this was a full-on fight to get ashore." I've read the translations of Julius Caesar's campaigns as written by him. It's amazing to have that connection to events so far in the past, but it doesn't make me an expert precisely because they are the only account available. The possibility that these are warts and all true accounts of his campaigns is zero. However we cannot know what was exaggerated and what was omitted.

@paulpeterson4216

2 жыл бұрын

Precisely, Caesar is not exactly an unbiased source. He was a good general. If it were going to be as hard as he claims it was, then he would not have made the attempt at that time in that spot.

@canadious6933

2 жыл бұрын

True and every historian knows this. That's why they usually cross reference as much as they can with whatever evidence they find. Then they make a rough estimate of what could have happened until more evidence is found. I think that's why everyone needs an open mind when studying history too, because new evidence does change the previous established narrative sometimes.

@johndorilag4129

2 жыл бұрын

Some people still don't believe that the Apollo 11 landed on the moon 50+ years ago so some today are skeptical and even accused Caesar of making up some kind of fiction or half-fiction fairy tales to fool the readers

@choronos

2 жыл бұрын

I find a contested landing difficult to believe. Hundreds of miles of coastline and you land where all the guys are to fight a costly battle? Doesn't add up. How did the Britons even know where to defend? How did they know they were being invaded and when it would come? Defenders along the coastline as far as the eye could see, really? I don't believe this happened the way Caesar claims it does. I think it's especially obvious that the contested landing story is a lie because it goes against human nature and any military doctrine I'm familiar with. No one wants to die, and commanders don't want to lose valuable troops. Caesar wouldn't have landed right in front of the enemy so they could take potshots at him while his armored troops in full kit awkwardly jump into WATER. To me it's clear he was sprinkling in a little Hollywood magic to make everything sound more badass. It sounds a lot cooler to have to fight for every inch of land than it does to say "We landed someplace quiet up the coast from the enemy so we could move into position unmolested."

Okay. I am so happy that the legionary is running montefortino helmet, delos gladius, oval scutum and hamata. THANK YOU

It's so good to see Ray Mears still doing TV I had no idea?

Great to see ray again I have always watched anything he is involved in

We lost our great great great great great great great great great great great great great great grandfather at Pevensey He was eventually found in a tavern on the floor, but his relatives were worried for a while

@jasoncreighton5140

Жыл бұрын

I think I met him

Ray Mears is the best :3

Great video. Well done. 👌👍

Love ray Mears. More plz

Good video, it's always interesting to see these things in real life. *The pilum,* it could be added that the iron would probably bend upon impact and the wooden rivets break where the wood and iron is connected, rendering the pilum useless so the enemy couldn't throw it back. *The landing on the beach:* Not a nice situation being opposed by a beach full of angry warriors throwing all sorts of pointy things at you: Javelins, curses and foul words, arrows etc.

One thing about the pilum that's not mentioned is that the metal was hard enough to pierce shields, but soft enough to bend once it was lodged into something. That way is was more or less useless for the enemies to throw back.

@TheReckoningBeginsToday

Жыл бұрын

They left out the entire reason the Pilum was designed the way it was. Absolutely unforgivable. Subpar effort by them.

@londonspade5896

Жыл бұрын

@@TheReckoningBeginsToday To be fair it didn't bend during their demonstration, that's probably why it wasn't mentioned

The guy cosplaying the Roman was really into it

@2bingtim

2 жыл бұрын

What others have said, scouts along the coast; plus they had good cross channel relations, spied & traded so they'd have noticed a large fleet & invasion army being prepared. One reason Caeser invaded was because Britons fought alongside some Gallic tribes, so we had people there at the time who could hop on a boat with the latest intel & traders/emissaries from Gaul would bring news too.

@jasoncreighton5140

Жыл бұрын

@@2bingtim Was that due to Brexit ?

The dramatic footage of the old man throwing a stick has inspired me.

Great stuff, thanks.

@HistoryHit

2 жыл бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it!

I think the qualifications to be an Aquilifer are 1) can you hold a pole 2) And you shall know no fear

4:30 I like the way he draws his sword

Ray Mears. Subscribed!

That ballista is a lovely piece of engineering but I'm sure they'd be much more powerful 🙂

That was really cool. That fellow who was taking us through the armaments and suchlike really knows his stuff. That big thingy at the end where they used onions as a stand in must have been a terror - it reminds me of the cannons going off in The Patriot and taking out whole bits of men - I'd imagine you'd be standing next to someone who suddenly didn't have a head. Nasty stuff!

That sword, a Gladius, looks longer than what I expected.

LEGIO 10 ✋ coming ashore !

I just invented time travel and this video has encouraged me to go back in time and give the Romans modern guns (in fair exchange for gold of course). Wish me luck!

The strength of a legion was in every man doing the same thing at the same time.

Great stuff

Very cool I wish Canada had history like this 🇨🇦

Clever man in dodging the shame of breaking the shield with bare hands

Great to see Ray Mears on here! Would love to see more of him on History Hit!

@garrl007

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed! He is literally my favourite human.

i've got cold feet just watching this

THE THINNEST SHIELD EVER!!!!

It what amazes me most about the romans is just how long ago this all was Coming from a land thats only been 1250 at the earliest its just astonishing

This channel is cooking my geese the proper way. Had no idea Roman soldiers were taught to stab and twist and all. Gnarly yet effective.

@HO-bndk

Жыл бұрын

No Roman source mentions anything about "twisting".

@jsieverink8409

Жыл бұрын

@@HO-bndk They do mention stabbing however, rather than slashing or cutting? Perhaps the twisting is speculation, brought on by visual sources?

Pretty sure the archaeologists have pinned the landing site to Pegwell Bay, some way north of Deal in Kent. Remains of 1st century BC Roman camp, weapons, etc.

The word ‘onions’ always makes Ray laugh 14:33

the whole presentation around the pilum made me sick in the stomach. just imagine being one of kelts warriors and slowly realizing how, bit by bit, your charge falls apart.

WOW, I was reading Caesar commentaries and he mentioned the throwing of the PEELUN?, super spear

Roman armies were so resolutive, self sufficient and disciplined it's not a surprise they conquered almost all the known world in that era. So advanced in tactics and fighting aswell.

@proudofyourroots9575

Жыл бұрын

Worth remebering that Boudicca was beating the romans when using guerrilla tactics but when she decided to face them on the battlefield we lost. things could have been very different had she stuck to her og tactics.

I hope that it will also be mentioned that Julius Caesar invaded England so as to "make a name" for himself with Rome. The 55 - 54BC invasion didn't "stick", although trade between Romanised Gaul and the various South Coast tribes continued, as it had for centuries before, until the more successful invasion by Emperor Claudius took place in 43AD under Aulus Plautius.

One has to remember that man was much closer to nature then. To keep in mind too that many legionaries were picked from sturdy farming folk, not city folk (who would have been soft and prone to instigate revolts against a hard driving commander, simply because they were not used to a physically hard life). Do not be surprised if the Romans had their own means of checking out water quality, considering that they could aqueduct waters from huge distances away and therefore needed to know that they were bringing to their towns and cities perfectly potable water or else they could be inviting very serious water borne diseases. Farming folk lived a bloody grim life. In fact one gets the very distinct sensation that being a legionary was easier for them than continuing in their grim farming life completely uncompetitive with the latifundia. They would know loads about food supplementing. Lest one forgets, Roman armies were full of different specialisations and food foraging and preparation would have been one of them. We do know that the Roman army used food as a weapon when they attacked barbarian lands or timing their campaigns as per crop cycles. The pilum, as far as I know, had a pin, that upon a throw would dislodge so that it wasn't as easy as disencumbering it from a shield as these guys tried to do. One part of the pilum would be through whatever it had been aimed at and as the pin dislodged, the other part would be left dangling, so that it was impossible to dislodge it and throw it back at the Romans. It would also have rendered one's shield useless as it tugged down on the shield arm with its sturdy weight, from which it got most of its penetrative power. What I found interesting was the succession in which the frontlines discharged their pila and how many times they were likely to have done that. Considering how wide a Roman army's front could be spread, several discharges along the front would stymie an enemy big time. The tired spearmen could also move back down their columns to be refreshed by mint killing machines chomping at the bit to cut down whatever remained of a horde. Not to forget their ranged weapons (archers, stone throwers, machines that would have supplemented the pila as per necessities) and their cavalry. And the various fighting solutions that could be adopted to solve different predicaments by experienced commanders and an army with a lore that would have gone back hundreds of years. Also, an ancient Roman army fought against a range of foes, always therefore being exposed to not just one form of attack and defence. So, they see these British by the water's edge and probably turned upon them a barrage of ranged weaponry and under that assault they disembarked and charged at them. Easy? no. Effective? yes. Caesar, knowing that back home his missives were propaganda for himself, probably dramatised the matter by having a signifer jump into the sea exhorting others to follow him. The man was more than versed in the art of rhetoric. He knew how to pin his audience to a seat back in Rome and make them root for his success on the edge of beyond.

Wait. Ray. Romans. Really awesome weapons. *IT'S ON*

They raided from Richborough. I've been to the exact point and there is memorials there

That, is a very flimsy shield used for the Pilum test.

Roman army was and is one of the most effective killing machine in history really powerful army they had

@JohnyG29

2 жыл бұрын

is??

15:20 Fire! *Santas' Sleigh comes crashing down*

Posca, very sour wine, also Caesar's slave assistant in the excellent series 'Rome'. :)

The Eagle 🦅 has landed on British isles. "I came, I saw, I conquer"

Ray was great at breaking down survival movies on some channel on KZread anyone seen that yet??

The pilum is designed to not come out. The idea was that it made the enemy’s shield unusable. And the iron head of the pilum will bend so the enemy cannot effectively throw it back once sweked.

I would like to know more about the wooden stakes/defenses made up of the three sharpened stakes.

The Britons were a resilient people. The Romans underestimated them a little.

Just like to point out the different grip Ray and the Roman soldier had on the javelin Rays being the correct way a full hand grip not fingers grip 😁

Need a video explaining why or when the Roman's stopped using the curved rectangular shields and started using the oval shields

@paprskomet

2 жыл бұрын

Romans mostly used oval shaped shields throughout their history so it is ironic that modernly peoply tyipicaly imagine them with type that was shortest ever used one.Nobody can give you secure answer on this but change on wide oval came hand in hand with other simultaneous alternations in equipment which were probably connected with each other.Since 3rd century Roman warfare turned more defensive and oval shape of shield is better for creating actual shield wall.

@2bingtim

2 жыл бұрын

Those shields(Squared or tall oval Scutums) were expensive to make from strip-wood ply construction. During later civil wars they went with the common Gemanic butted plank shields which were quicker & cheapier to make. They still fought pretty much the same way though, even with longer swords.

lol 13:58 what sources mention hemp being used for torsion springs?

I'd imagine they took game and knew how to forage.With accumulated knowledge the superiors must have allowed some cooperation for the good of the regiments.

Love hove all the History is just guessing 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

I built a small balista, more like a desk toy, I can get the bolts to go between 5 to 7 meters,

The ballista, the device which catapulted the inventor into the halls of fame

@matthewbreytenbach4483

Жыл бұрын

Or at least the guy who commissioned them XD

Anyone know where to get the full series or episode of this ? What it's called and what channel

poor gentleman must be cold with all the wind~

Imagine just playing with this stuff for a living

Wait, so the Ballista shoots rocks ... and the Catapulta shoots bolts? ... My whole life is a lie :O

@WT.....

2 жыл бұрын

How'd you think the term "ballistic projectile" came around.

@greypilgrim228

2 жыл бұрын

He meant the larger Ballistae, this one is one of the smaller versions that shot rocks. The much larger engines you're probably thinking of that were used for sieges were Onogers, akin to the medieval Mangonels and later Trebuchets.

I've never heard the purpose of the pilum described this way before and it suddenly seems so much more important than just killing some people.

@101Mant

2 жыл бұрын

The best case it goes through the shield (or misses it) and into the man killing or wounding him. Even if that fails just having it stick in the shield makes the shield usless and you have to drop it while charging, which makes another obstacle on the ground. Missile weapons were often as much about disrupting the enemy formations as actually killing people, you see it with bows and slings as well.

I thoroughly enjoyed this video but it was really funny watching the guy throw a javelin. I get he's not a soldier or athlete but even in slow motion it barely spends a full second in air before hitting the target that was seemingly 10 feet away