Terry Bristol, Institute for Science, Engineering and Public Policy
ABSTRACT
The research reported here is concerned with understanding the components and composition of reality, according to the systems engineering worldview. To start, George Bugliarello argues that what engineers do, their progressive development of reality, is a natural extension of biological evolution. The implication is that biological evolution is, and always has been, an emergent, systems engineering enterprise. Reality, therefore, should be understandable (intelligible) both chronologically and ontologically as an emerging system of technological structures and functions.
As I will point out, the Systems Engineering Worldview is not new. In Plato’s Timaeus reality is presented as the emerging product of the actions of the Architekton, the Master Craftsman, the global systems engineer.
I develop this approach in several steps. In Step One, I briefly present the modern philosophy of systems engineering, as represented in the works of George Bugliarello, Walter Vincenti, Sam Florman and Herbert Simon. In Step Two, I report on my investigation of the illuminating Uniformitarianism debate in geology, contrasting Lyell’s scientific worldview with Cuvier’s systems engineering worldview. In Step Three, I argue that the historical and geo-physical sciences can never be reduced to the hard, time-space invariant mechanical sciences. What is needed is a meta-paradigm shift to the more general, superseding participant systems engineering worldview. In Step Four, I review another earlier, systems engineering worldview that surfaced in the 17th and 18th century Europe in the works of Leibniz and the Carnots. Thermodynamics and engines are seen to be essential to the systems engineering worldview. In the Final Step, with the insights gained from these last three steps, I revisit Step One issues in the modern philosophy of systems engineering suggesting enhancements and clarifications.
References
Bugliarello, George (1973) “The Engineer and the Historian”, in The History and Philosophy of Technology (Eds. George Bugliarello et al., Univ of Illinois Press, Chicago, London
Bugliarello, George. (2003). The BIOSOMA: Reflections on the Synthesis of Biology, Society and Machines, Polytechnic Press, New York, NY
Vincenti, Walter (1990/1992) What Engineers Know and How They Know It. John Hopkins UP Baltimore, London
Florman, Sam (1996) The Existential Pleasures of Engineering, Griffin, NY
Simon, Herb (1996) Sciences of the Artificial, (3rd Ed) The MIT Press
Petroski, Henry (2010) The Essential Engineer: Why Science Alone Will Not Solve Our Global Problems, Knopf
Bristol, Terry. (2018) “The Engineering Knowledge Research program” in Fritzsche, Albrecht and Sascha Julian Oks (Eds). The Future of Engineering: Philosophical Foundations, Ethical Problems and Application Cases, Springer. Heidelberg, Berlin, New York
Bristol, Terry. (2018) “The Philosophy of Engineering and the Engineering Worldview” page103ff, in Mitcham, Carl et al. (eds) Philosophy of Engineering: East and West, Springer, Heidelberg, Berlin, New York
Gillispie, Charles Coulston (1951) Genesis and Geology: The Impact of Scientific Discoveries upon Religious Beliefs in the decades before Darwin, Harper & Row, NY
Coleman, William (1964) Georges Cuvier, Zoologist: A Study in the History of Evolution Theory, Harvard UP, Cambridge
Cuvier, Georges (1813/ 2018) Essays on the Theory of the Earth, Forgotten Books
Cuvier, Georges, (1829-1832) History of the Natural Sciences from its Origins to the Present Day, in Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences (ed. Pietsch, T.W.; trans. Beatrice Marx, Paris: Publications scientifique du Museum (2015) Open Edition Books (2019)
Lyell, Charles (1833) Principles of Geology. Pantianos Classics
Zittel, Karl Alfred von (1901). History of geology and palaentology to the end of the Nineteenth Century. Charles Scribner's Sons, London.
Cornford, Francis M. (1957) Plato’s Theory of Knowledge (The Theatetus and Sophist of Plato) Liberal Arts Press, Bobbs-Merrill NY
(trans. Desmond Lee) Penguin Classics
Cornford, Francis M. (1959) Plato’s Timaeus. Bobbs-Merrill, Indianapolis, NY
Dewey, John. (1929, 1980). The Quest for Certainty: A Study of the Relation of Knowledge and Action, Perigee Books, New York, NY
Leibniz, Gottfried (1991) Discourse on Metaphysics and Other Essays (Hackett Classics) UK ed.
Gillispie, GC and Raffaele Pisano, (2014) Lazare and Sadi Carnot: A Scientific and Filial Relationship, Springer
Maupertuis, Pierre, (2010) Essais De Cosmologie (1751) (French Edition) Kessinger Publishing
Kelly, Kevin. (2011) What Technology Wants, Penguin, London, UK
Reid, Robert G.B. (2007) Biological Emergences: evolution by natural experiment, The MIT Press, Cambridge MA
Schneider, Eric and Dorion Sagan. (2005). Into the Cool: Energy Flow,
Thermodynamics and Life, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL