Great video! I especially appreciated that you took the time to explain how the war memorials (& cemetaries) are Soviet, not Russian. For us in Germany, that's an important difference, especially in the context of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. It's important to understand that the graves in Tiergarten and Treptower Park hold the bodies of not just Russian soldiers, but also Ukrainians, Georgians and many other nationalities that made up the Soviet Union. Current-day Russia (and some of its sympathisers) may try to use these sites as propaganda tools these days. But one day, with the Putin regime a distant memory, these memorials will still be there to tell about the history of the Battle of Berlin and how Soviet, not just Russian, soldiers defeated Nazi Germany in Berlin.

@AndyMcloone

Жыл бұрын

Yes a very important distinction to make. And during the Cold War the Soviet Army was my ‘Enemy’ as a NATO soldier. Now 30 years later it is all just history. Thanks for your comment.

@Hongaars1969

Жыл бұрын

Similarly it’s important to always make a clear distinction between Nazis and Germans.

@klawlor3659

Жыл бұрын

There's always some silly comment about the "Russian invasion of Ukraine" installed into a video like this. I guess with all the BBC/Sky propaganda surrounding this, it's par for the course. I'm not a Russophile by the way, just sick of hearing this same old trope wheeled out time and time again ad infinitum. Especially when there is a hell of a lot more to this "invasion" than what is being shown on western media. I guess that every time I see something regarding the US I should comment about the US invasion of Iraq (and subsequent murder of hundreds of thousands of people) or the other times the USA has invaded sovereign countries and deposed their leaders in order to install sympathetic puppet regimes. Maybe I should mention the genocides in Vietnam, or the "dirty" bombs used in Iraq (and subsequent deaths and illnesses amongst Iraqi children) and other horrors inflicted by them?

@jondeare

Жыл бұрын

I loved this video. Very Well Done.

@Arthion

Жыл бұрын

Given that Pootis himself seems to hate all soviet leaders that weren't Stalin and his general views on the Union, it seems fitting to keep making that distiction.

Fun fact. The Soviet war memorials in Tiergartgen, Treptow and Schonholzer are controlled by treaty, which is a reason why they still exists.

@pettahify

Ай бұрын

Let us hope that the governments of Germany keeps the memorials not just because of some treaty, but also to remember. There's some crazy countries that keep removing memorials like these for some weird reasons.

@Alexzander19736

Ай бұрын

That is what he said also.

Fantastic video, Andy. Brings back many memories. I spent 6 years in BAOR in the 70's with frequent trips to Berlin. Little did I know that today I would return with this great video. Many thanks, Andy.

@russcattell955i

Жыл бұрын

My wife served in BAOR in the 80's & 90's. She too was sent to Berlin on the train, passed through checkpoint charlie a few times. She didn't recognise it today. But remembers travel documents returned hot from communist photocopy machines.

5:34 ironically the German parliament (called the Reichstag) was powerless since 1933 and therefore the Reichstag building was merely a hollow shell.

@hannsg7116

11 ай бұрын

... es fehlt in diesem Zusammenhang der "Reichtagsbrand" im Jahr 1933, mit dem daraus beschlossenen "Ermächtigungsgesetz" , wobei sich die gewählten Abgeordneten selbst den Weg frei machten, für die folgende Hitler-Diktatur . Auch viele Deutsche Bürger wurden ab diesem Zeitpunkt verfolgt, oder sind in KZ Lagern inhaftiert, oder ermordet worden

I guarded hess or prisoner no 7 from 1984-1987 when posted to Berlin. Charlie looks a lot different now.

Fascinating video Andy. Been to Berlin a few times and remember the fall of the wall but haven't visited all these sites. Your German/DDR videos particularly have been wonderful. We have family in Hungary and I remember driving all the way there as a boy and still seeing DDR registered eastern block cars in the early 90s.

Don't know how i stumbled on this video, but I'm so glad I did! I have been to Berlin only once and didn't see half of this so a return visit is must! Very clear and straightforward presentation, it is so sad to think of the amount of sacrifice it took to bring WWII to an end, and here we are again with a war in Europe, I wonder how the next generation of war dead will be honoured.

For Russian dead of 80,000 that works out around 2,857 killed every day no wonder Eisenhower halted his armies at the Elbe, more American lives lost at this stage of the war would have sparked outrage in the US, not only that, but fighting for territory that was already earmarked for the Russian occupation zone.

Wonderfully done telling the history of the bitter end of WW2 and rolling into the Cold War and into the opening in the unification of Germany.

That was, frankly, an excellent video - respectful and thoughtful, well written and presented. Superb!

I am really pleased of how well the subjects are researched and presented. I live in Berlin, as a foreigner that likes the city's past I've been and read about the sites you showed countless times but man, your (hi)story telling makes me feel like I visited them for the first time

I was stationed there from 1988-1991 (Tempelhof/T-Berg). I thoroughly enjoyed seeing all the old sites. Great memories.

LOL, "Hesscos" Tescos, brilliant! Thanks for yet another great documentary!

Having lived in Berlin as a kid (Dad in the Forces) and then worked in the city from 1999-2004 I found this the history put forward in the video really interesting as i did visit most of the sites dipicted here. Great work Andy.

Spandau is a town where the prison was located, actually quite nice

Thanks for this terrific, informative video. Well done and respectful.

@AndyMcloone

Жыл бұрын

Much appreciated!

I was a very young boy when I went through a checkpoint from west Germany to east. I still remember it very well, even though I was very young. I still to this day, have a piece of the Berlin wall that I chipped off myself as a young fellow. I’m sure it’s worth nothing but to me it has terrible significance. After the wall came down, we were able to see my grandfather’s bakery, which still stood. They had run the wall right down the middle of the street. And on the west German side, it thrived. On the east Germany side the building was collapsing and still riddled with the bullet holes of World War II. Completely unusable because the wall was right in the middle of the street. On the west German side the economy was good enough to deal with that situation. Very much not so on the east German side. Old memories, but they still retain their value.

I served with Berlin Brigade at US Mission Berlin on Clay Alle. When we toured East Berlin we had to wear our class A uniforms. An East German merchant marine once approached me in a cafe and asked if grade B actor Reagan was really elected as US president. I said go figure.

This channel should have at least 100k if not a million subs with the content you provide here...

Another great video Andy…..Especially for highlighting and noting sensitivities at the commencement, and throughout. History is history and the realities and the facts cannot be altered. Please keep posting these interesting and informative videos. Thank you.

your story really encapsulates the massive loss of lives on all sides in just one single battle during the war

Wonderful video Sir. 🇮🇹

I will be in Berlin July 2023. I will go to most these sites. I served in the U.S. Army durring the Cold War and this visit is a must for me.

I've spent a lot of time in Berlin as my Mother in-law moved there in 1988 and lived there for over 20 years.I was based in Dortmund with the R.A. in the 80's and met my wife whilst on detachment to the Army Mountain Training Centre in the Harz Mountains) I first travelled to "West Berlin" in march 1990 as the DDR still existed and the wall still stood (although crossing over into East Berlin was possible) I remember.seeing the Soviet troops guarding the Soviet War memorial at the Tiergarten,East German border guards at the wall in front of the Brandenburg gate,the death strip,Checkpoint Charlie (also bravo and alpha getting to and from West Berlin) Friedrichstraße (Tränenpalast) etc.Over the years since the wall fell the city has changed a lot but there is still enough of it's cold war history to be found and seen.

Thanks for the tour and your comments. My understanding is that now the Berlin office of parks and gardens is responsible for the upkeep of the memorials. I would have included the former Soviet Embassy on Unter den Linden in the list. Schoenholtlzer Heide was new to me, and I appreciate the distinctions you make between it, Treptower Park, and the memorial in the former West Berlin. It all has an echo of Ozymandias.

Fun fact three: I lived in the building on the left side at Warschauer Strasse and Karl Marx Allee (Stalinallee). I'm really enjoying your videos. If you make your way back to Berlin let this American buy you a beer!

"History is there to be learned from" These words never meant so much.

Stalinallee was built in a style that was supposed to be reminiscent of the stately architecture of the Empire (just like the NVA was essentially a Prussian army). The facades were so dominant that the groundplan of the houses didn't fit them. So occasionally there are rooms that are half obscured, or are in between two windows.

@urbandiscount

Жыл бұрын

Kaffee Moskau is not in soviet style, but clearly expresses Bauhaus International Modern Style. In fact, Rotterdam, which was rebuilt after the war has reconstruction architecture that is very much like East Berlin (also reconstruction architecture).

I like your videos, thanks. It makes me want to visit Berlin.

13:56 Perfect description of Soviet architecture-‘Brutalist.’

@urbandiscount

Жыл бұрын

Berlin's architecture is not "Soviet" . Much of the spirit of Bauhaus went into designing and building East Berlin, at least until the late Ulbricht years, when Honecker was already gaining influence. I think it's still a shame that Palast der Republik was torn down, but that's another story

Great video. :) It brought back a lot of memories. The first time I was in Berlin was in 1986, briefly in 1989, and then again in 1992. It was an unbelievable difference even though it was just a few years apart. 1986 one felt watched all the time whilst in East Berlin and there were uniformed people all over the place. 1992 everything was so relaxed. I even drove through the Brandenburger Tor, which was btw not allowed (I didn't know that and was just a "stupid tourist" :)). " Mr. Gorbatjev...tear down this wall!". He didn't do it...the people themselves did. :)

Great Video as usual Andy. Obviously as a 1st Battalion ,Queen's Coy Bod it brought back some great and not so great memories of Berlin. Especially as we lost a couple of the blokes recently RIP Budgie .Skid And Juppy.. Guarding that prison was a bloody pain. but an experience none the less ,We had a Company Photo in 2 dress taken outside the Reichstag , i think it was a museum then(1980) Also i really enjoy the Soviet content as we used to do Train Guards ... only went to the East a couple of times as we went on a couple of Orientation trips in uniform ,to the war memorials . etc. only been back there once for a day during a Baltic Cruise.... must go back again before i get too old ha ha.. Keep up the great work Andy.

@AndyMcloone

Жыл бұрын

The 1979 - 1981 Berlin Tour was just before my time. I joined in Hounslow. All my cold war stuff is from the 1985-1991 Munster BAOR posting

Thanks Andy, I really love your work. Keep it up mate. Love hearing the stories from when you were stationed there.

Another very interesting and captivating video Andy, thank you for making these... can you show us around Teufelsberg next time?

Awesome video 👌🏻 In 2013 I was attached to 3rd regt RHA, prior to deploying to Afghanistan. We had a cultural tour to Berlin, looking at the sites of importance to the BAOR. I was amazed at the damage, still evident on a lot of buildings in Berlin. I also went up the Berliner Fernsehturm and was fascinated by the difference in building architecture between the DDR & West Berlin. One final point, a hotel I stayed in, in the UK was owned by an ex guards regt CSM. He was one of the British contingent who guarded Hess at Spandau 😳

Nice job, Andy. Well done! Thank you.

Good content and well presented.

Thanks, Andy. Quite educational and eye-opening as always! Love the 4K resolution, too.

Spandau Ballet is a band yes, but also the name of the struggle against the hangman's rope. I can never get the image out of my mind when that song comes on.

Excellent and very informative. I have been to Berlin several times, but have only visited the Tiergarten memorial. Wish I had seen the others you have shown us!

Andy this was great. Wish you made it last year when I returned to Berlin! I’ve definitely seen some of these sights but you’ve given me other spots to check out on my next visit!

Thank you Andy for this interesting and balanced documentation. I did a quick check on the spectacular photo of the Moltkebrücke. It seems it was shot in the opposite direction as your film shot, i.e. from the Reichstag’s perimeter outwards. The book Panzers in Berlin 1945 mentions that Tiger II Tank No. 314 from the schwere SS-Panzer-Abteilung 503 knocked out several Soviet tanks in this place.

Thank you so much! Excellent documentary. 😊👍🇬🇧

Really well done. Thank you!

Hello, thank you for this wonderful video! It is a pleasure to see, to review, and to learn, thanks to your clear and unbiased explanations, these different places in Berlin. Sincere greetings from France!

Anther very informative video Andy, thank you.

Well made video! Thanks to show it to the world.

Great videos! I live about 50km north of Berlin and we have no anti-Russian sentiment in our village, we even have our own little Soviet war memorial. I never knew about Schönholzer Heide, a definate visit planned for next time in the city. Thanks.

Another great and informative video. Thanks for the content.

Amazing video! Thank you for sharing with us.

Thanks for the great video. Very interesting.

Excellent video!

Teufelsberg is the best and most interesting Cold War site in Berlin, by far. It was build by the Americans. In East Berlin, the most interesting Cold War site, well sorts of Cold War, is an abandoned amusement park called Spreepark. I would say.

@mikebillett7935

Жыл бұрын

I am also fascinated in the story of Teufelsberg, is it true that the entire elevated area was built out of the rubble from Berlin?

@lcdh5601

Жыл бұрын

@@mikebillett7935yes. There are actually several of these ‚rubble mountains’, ‘Trümmerberge’, in Berlin, Teufelsberg is just the largest.

@michaeltovey02607

Жыл бұрын

Teufelsberg was built in the BRITISH sector of Berlin and yes it was a rubble mound.

Nice and accurate documentary. I know Berlin very well, but it's nice with clear reminders.

Great Job Andy!

Andy, Absolutely enjoyed your presentation. Very informative. Thanks.

Excellent, excellent video!

"They did not arrive as liberators"... very good point and well put. Thank you for another smashing video.

Another great video. Really interesting and I love all things Berlin. I have been to Berlin several times in the 45 yrs I lived in Germany but it is nice to have the history and on my next visit will hopefully get to have a look of some of these sites. Thank you.

love your video, and I agree you, memory must not be erased, it must be keep for future generations

Absolutely wonderfull video, of my favourite city. Well done!

Fantastic segment

Well made video. Thanks for this. In 1987 my father and I went to west Berlin for a 4 day visit. We arrived late at night and went for a walk. Came across the Soviet War Memorial in Tiergarten at about 10PM. As we approached it for a better look, 2 West German Policemen with guard dogs chased us away. We didn´t know it was forbidden to get near to it. And less at night.

Very interesting. Thanks.

Great video! Thank you.

BZ Sir! Excellent documentary. I’m very pleased to have found your channel. Ian

This is another really impressive video from you. Its extremely hard to cover the naunces and complexities of the post war situation in this kind of format and you do it really well. Especialy the distinction between an invading and liberating army and the appalling treatment meted out to the civilian populatoin before the arrival of the Western powers., and how this is the lens through which the memorials are often viewed. The ending of the video is fantastic. A soldier's respect for fallen soliders really comes through.

Thank you great video, most interesting!!

Good content! Thanks!

Enjoying your videos tremendously.

You tell a great story.

very good,learnt a lot there.thanks.

This is a quality video my man

Great video! In my next visit to Berlin I'll consider all your background information about these monuments and sites.

*_I have 2 grandparents from Russia and 2 from Germany. I hope to visit both countries someday._*

I really enjoyed watching this video (documentary). 👍🙂

Thank you for an excellent tour , with the exception of Spandau and the final cemetery l have visted them all , however as is often the case with the absence of a guide certain key points are missed , grateful for your time and effort filling in the blanks . Berlin is fascinating, having recently done the OKW bunkers at Zossen i look forward to a return trip , i have my sights set on the Seelow heights .

Really impressive and complete video, really enjoyed it. The information was on point!

Interesting fact regarding the memorial in Treptower Park: Together with the Rear-front Memorial in Magnitogorsk and The Motherland Calls in Volgograd, the monument is a part of a tryptich.

This was an excellently done video for us. Subscribed.

A great tour. I recall in the 1970s twice sending correspondence from America to an address in WEST GERMANY and having each time it returned to me. Each time with WEST GERMANY crossed out and grease penciled in large letters the FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY. Someone was sensitive about the division :)

Coffee Moscow is today coffee Kiew - The style of the clock in the GDR was slightly different (more edgy and no ads underneath) compared to those at Platz der Vereinten Nationen nowadays. I moved 1987 to Berlin(West) from south of FRG and one of my first political outdoor activities was to burn out the candles that the Nazis set up in Spandau on the day of Hess' death. It was a very good decision to swap the prison for a supermarket so as not to create a place of pilgrimage here! Thank you for the video ..... good job!

Fantastic video's. Really enjoy them

Excellent video. Super.

Excellent video. Interesting, informative, and well crafted. You, sir, have a new subscriber.

Great video!!!!

Many thanks for these educational videos!

amazing video..thank u!!

Great video, you really know your stuff 👏👏

Another excellent video. I enjoy the detail and the pace. Your tone was appropriate too - no jingoism.

Superb video. Thank you for all the work. I learned something.

I love your work thank you for all this hard work

Great video. I was in West Berlin twice when I was a naval officer but never ventured into the Soviet Zone. Didn’t have the time or inclination as I knew photography was strictly verboten and I took a camera everywhere I went. Didn’t want to wind up in a gulag or face disciplinary action.

Excellent!

Great stuff!!

Loving all your videos 🫡

i would love to visit these sights in person; very cool and interesting.

Subbed good stuff. clear to the point no ads just facts and first hand account this is quality content.

Fantastic video x

Great work, thanks.