An Asian woman like Chan had to beat all the odds to achieve the position she has today. What a great performance.👍

Beautiful, I'm speechless. This performance, this symphony has touched my heart. Thank you

it's wonderful. Orchestra, coductor and this symphony best matched,then making nice sound and music.This is the most baranced rendition of symphony no5.

There is something both tragic and heroic in this opening theme. A victory that has not to be known, a victory that has to be converted into an unknown pain in the chest of the composer. It is easy to think so, when you know a little bit about Tchaikovsky. And all his life he wrote such beautiful music, like this. Concealing most of the pain. Wonderful playing by the orchestra, and I like very much the conductor Elim Chan!

@kostgir9380

3 жыл бұрын

Staffan, you said everything to be said in 4 lines. Elim is a great conductor but she is unlucly, the great orchestras prefer something different, thats the truth..

Bravo! One of the best performance of this symphony. Elim Chan is a good musician.

@bruh7130

4 жыл бұрын

She’s a good Musician but the performance wasn’t rlly one of the best I guess

Ms. Chan is a very fine conductor!

14:07 2. Andante cantabile, con alcuna licenza 26:45 3. Valse: Allegro moderato 32:30 4. Finale: Andante maestoso - Allegro vivace

I thank the wonderful conductor and the fabulous orchestra, and the way they worked together and supported each other. I have got such a more clear understanding of this symphony. Thank you so much.

Mil gracias !

Oh, what a fine fellow! BRAVO!!! So cleanly and efficiently executed. It's nice to listen to a well-tuned orchestra where all the instruments are audible. Once again, Bravo! To the conductor - my respect! With love from Russia! Ах какие молодцы! БРАВО!!! Так чисто и качественно исполнили. Приятно слушать хорошо отлаженный оркестр где все инструменты слышны. Ещё раз Браво! Дирижёру - моё почтение! С любовью из России!

I, officially, adore Elim Chan!

@gianni5316

5 ай бұрын

Moi aussi. Pure io.

Wunderschöne Aufführung dieser romantischen Sinfonie mit gut harmonisierten und perfekt synchronisierten Tönen aller Instrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt lyrisch. Die geniale Dirigentin leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut phrasierten Tempo und mit möglichst effektiver Dynamik. Sie versteht das Wesen der europäischen Musik. Echt bewundernswert!

He visto a Elim Cham dirigir en México y tengo que decir que es una grandiosa artista. Siempre brillante.

A beautiful orchestra and a gorgeous orchestral hall! Kudos to the conductor and the wonderful musicians!

Wonderful ! 🎶 Last Sunday in Amsterdam...and this week here on You Tube...Thank you...

Elim Chan, so young.

Great!

magnificent rendering : the atmosphere of dark anxiety accompanies you from the beginning to the end

une belle symphony de Tchaikovsky

wonderful

Großartig incl. Dirigentin. Dankeschön.

Mooie . Goed gedaan . Wonderful .

bravissimo !

素晴らしい演奏!エリム・チャンの流れるような指揮は表現力豊かだ。将来絶対世界的指揮者になるだろう。

A very good performance. Thanks! I always fast forward to the climactic sequences in the first and 4th movements to check the performance of this monumental symphony: the first movement from 7:20 to 8:50 and the 4th from 37:28 to 38:00, seemed to me somewhat tamed and restrained with a hurried brass timing. Compare with the performance of Russian State Symphony Orchestra with the young Petrenko at the helm also available on youtube.

Geweldig. Van de week een setje bose 601 serie1 gekocht voor 4 tientjes en nu dit concert uitgezocht om ff te zien wat bose zo slecht maakt. Haha nee geweldig heb er van genoten. Toch maar eens live meemaken.

광고 없이 고화질로 볼 수 있는 차5 중에 최고

Thank you all.

noiiice

驚奇!!! 像極了天使在指揮。奇特又靈動十足的指揮架勢，日後必大有可觀。!!!

我倒想起了倚天屠龍記中，明教兩大護法三大法王齊聚武當山，跟張三豐共餐時，張三豐狐疑的問了張無忌一句，"他們(明教大頭目們)都聽你的嗎? " !! yes， Elim Chan能指揮歐洲樂團，在歐洲第一流的音樂廳中，確是奇蹟!

I recommend checking out the version on KZread with BSO and Bernstein. Not because it’s better, actually I prefer this version. However, the BSO clarinetists are much better imo with the BSO.

チャイコフスキー 交響曲第５番 ロシア有名交響楽団演奏賛辞 世界的女性秀麗有名指揮者大賛辞

Μεταβασιςυπερυψουμενηςοδουουρανιας

Et ça tousse!!😒

Good conductor bravo. for me the principal can move less.

Tchaikovsky's characteristic is usually the inexhaustible richness of his inspiration. This symphony, on the other hand, appears poor in musical themes. I only appreciate the ease in composing for the orchestral mass. I don't pronounce on the execution, because the symphony can't attract my attention and I don't want to compare it with alternative realizations

@staffanolofsson8201

4 жыл бұрын

"appears poor in musical themes"?????? OK, that is your opinion, I will not argue with you. But I do not agree.

Good performance ruined by constant coughing from the audience. Watching many concerts in Royal Concertgebouw, it seems to me that distractive coughing from the audiences is a definitive characteristic of this place.

@borisbrinkmann

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, Jan. 2020... Everybody had CoVid, probably...

I liked the sound and the playing of the orchestra, but the director’s facial expressions, imho, don’t go with the mood of music. She needs a wider range to communicate better her intentions. She did a very good job... anyway...

@francescodefendi3201

4 жыл бұрын

@@@mariannevleeshouwers3031 Of course Marianne, the show... must... go on : ) I was just missing some facial/body communication...Not the most important thing, but significant... I will check for her other videos. Thanks

Horrendous performance! Elim Chan 🤮

@fgiord8fgg

2 жыл бұрын

perhaps it could have used a little more passion, but it was a very solid performance with a fine young conductor who has a great future.most certainly not an horrendous performance by any means.