Get 20% off of my music theory for beginners course with code DAVID20 over at Artmaster: www.artmaster.com/course/music-theory?+video&+theory+david+bennett 🎼🎶

@sunblock8717

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for making this video but I wish you hadn't mixed and matched the examples. It's hard to hear the full chord progression when you keep switching from one song to the next midway through. It's also hard to hear when more than one song is played at the same time.

@schitlipz

Жыл бұрын

What was that telegram thing?

@DavidBennettPiano

Жыл бұрын

@@schitlipz any telegram things you see on KZread are scams!

@schitlipz

Жыл бұрын

@@DavidBennettPiano Oh. Sorry pal. Nice and quick reply. I like that. You're good at all the music stuff. Thanks for some of the things you're helping me figure out. Ok. Later.

@jpshy1130

Жыл бұрын

@@sunblock8717 I disagree He was literally playing it on the piano, and the renditions of all the songs were beautiful Please keep doing these

the mashups are so beautiful!! Honestly this video was so well done and edited perfectly

@DavidBennettPiano

Жыл бұрын

😊😊 thanks!

@GizzyDillespee

Жыл бұрын

Right after I read your comment, I paid extra attention to the audio editing. It was right around 4:00... talk about bad timing! (I mean the deep rumble stuff... probably I wouldn't have even noticed it if not for the just reading the comment about great editing. This isn't a complaint about the rumble (it didn't bother me), just noting a weird coincidence of timing while reading g the comments. Plus, I had to pause the vid to prepare myself for the 3 truly overused chord progressions... perfect time to write my own comment...EDIT: ah, the rumble is during all the Nord recordings, I think. Maybe check for this in the future.

@delroyopondo

Жыл бұрын

Honestly though,David has done an absolutely wonderful job with this

@nicetomeetyou701

Жыл бұрын

@@GizzyDillespee dude no one cares

@lolzlarkin3059

Жыл бұрын

@@DavidBennettPiano was that just a way to get around copyright strikes?

I second the lyrics being the key selling point of her music. I think the variety of styles and layers of textures she and the musicians she works with are able to bring in with instrumentation also helps keep her music fresh. Also, great job on the mashups.

@RadioMuse1

Жыл бұрын

I agree with all of that. I also think she focuses deeply on the rhythm of the vocal as well as the melody. I would imagine the chords - initially sketched out on piano or guitar - are secondary in her writing process to the lyrics and the means by which they're delivered. I doubt that she writes to backing tracks very often (I think I remember an interview regarding "Out of the Woods" that attested to that - because that was a Jack Antonoff backing track that Taylor then wrote to - which was unusual for her). Anecdotally - when I've tried to write songs melody-first* I tend to find the chord progressions naturally end up pretty simple - a lot of 2, 3, or 4 chord loops and consisting of only I IV V and vi. I can jazz it up with substitutions, but that can easily start stepping on the the vocal. And in pop music there's no bigger crime than stepping on the vocal. *I typically write "harmony first" - which I think is pretty common of "rock" and "jazz" musicians and less so of "pop" musicians. But by writing that way and trying to craft the melody to fit the chords it's a lot easier to end up with "special" chord changes.

@jaydenli8089

Жыл бұрын

^^ this

@guitarpaul3645

Жыл бұрын

Yes, the lyrics are important to many of her fans, but one thing that was overlooked here was Taylor's utterly amazing sense of melody. Melody, and strong melodies at that, are a huge key to making memorable songs that people fall in love with. Her variety in melody makes songs which happen to have the same progression sound distinctly different harmonically.

@guitarpaul3645

Жыл бұрын

@Hazel Allison As a percentage, the songs she has "written to track" are pretty small. Taylor's real musical brilliance is her melody composition, and she is still doing that even if someone else crafted a backing track. On 1989, "I Wish You Would" has an awesome vocal melody hook, and she composed that. And it would be no different if she was in a band.. other members coming up with various instrument parts. I think she really enjoys writing with others because it is fun. Even when she takes a song she essentially wrote herself (like Blank Space .. pretty much) to a producer, there's a ton of fun to be had adding all the instrumentation etc.

A lot of people mention Swift's lyrics, which are definitely very good most of the time, but I actually find her melodies her most enjoyable parts. The fact she can weave such diverse melodies and emotions over such generally simple chord structures is one of her strong suits. She also does have nice ways of mixing things up with the way she plays the chords (often incorporating some kind of drone note, or adding 9ths or sussing chords). Also, increasingly, and in part thanks to her collaboration with Jack Antonoff, her arrangements and harmonies are very interesting, and lend themselves very well to repeat listens. Edit: For instance, All Too Well, Out of the Woods and Should've Said No are very different sounding songs with completely different energies, even though they use the same chord progression.

@guitarpaul3645

Жыл бұрын

100% and absolutely correct, and what I said in my comment. I can't believe David didn't point this out in the video. Her musical genius without doubt is her outrageous gift for melody. Almost anybody can pick up a guitar and play a simple progression, but coming up with dozens and dozens of beautiful hook melodies is a LOt more challenging. "Forever and Always" is an absolute masterclass of melody. As is "Blank Space". It is great melodies that will make millions of people fall in love with your songs/music. Ask John Williams.

@two-handpianist4517

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much for appreciating her melodies. It's what i've been trying to point out as a fan of her while explaining why i love her music so much. Repeated chord progressions, yes, but you can tell most of the times that her songs are different from each other (with a few exceptions from lover area, i think)

@TheflyingkiwiRC

Жыл бұрын

Couldn't agree more. Her genius lyrical talent is only exceeded by her ability to find beautiful melodies amongst such well used chord progressions. I find this video somewhat simplistic because there are no mentions of her great middle eights or the way she moves around within the 4 chords that always seems to work.

@TheMOReviewers

Жыл бұрын

@@TheflyingkiwiRC Oh yeah her bridges are goated, great point! How You Get the Girl is a great example. It's just the same 1-5-4 progression, but has such an incredibly tasty and different feeling melody over it. Loving all the points y'all are making in this thread, keep em coming!

@nuclearcatbaby1131

Жыл бұрын

I think working with Jack Antonoff too much ruins her melodies. Her self-written songs are best.

I think these chord progressions also elicit a pretty strong emotional reaction which is why they’re so effective

@AutPen38

Жыл бұрын

Much of modern pop has something in common with old folk songs or nursery rhymes. The harmonies are so predictable and comforting, but a bit too childlike or even boring to those of us that grew up in a different era. That said, Taylor must be greatly talented to keep finding something new and interesting to say over chords we've heard millions of times.

@Samantha-vlly

Жыл бұрын

@@AutPen38 I was never a listener to her song and belong to Gen Z, but I agree. I listen mostly old pop songs from 70s and 80s simply because of how creative their overall making of that music.

@TrevorParsnips

Жыл бұрын

Taylor is pretty lazy at this

@silly_hue-wheat

7 ай бұрын

expression and delivery too

@catsinwonderland7473

6 ай бұрын

@@TrevorParsnipsnah

I’m not even a big Swift fan but I love this, it shows how even if her genre has changed over the years she still writes similarly to her old country music

@jcarty123

Жыл бұрын

Musically, she's boring AF. And yall call it, keeping her unique style. Good one. I'll remember it the next time I want to insult-without-insulting some artist for being very, very, very limited & repetitive. "Oh, she's so loyal to her own style & vision" wink wink.

@qqw743

Жыл бұрын

Without saying I like it or dislike it, I'll say that I'd be hella bored if I were the artist. I feel the same way about 12-bar-blues artists, or reggae 2-bar bands. Dontcha wanna try something else? Especially Swift, who can do just about anything she pleases and retain fans. Try some wacky new chords, collaborations, instrumentation, beats,... I know she's a Beatles fan. Let's look at all the experimentation they did. John would have hit himself in the head with a rock if he had had to keep playing Love Me Do music, and Paul is always trying something new.

@rain.faded.

Жыл бұрын

@ghost mall Using super common (and overrused) chord progressions isn't a "style" lol

@tatereis4031

Жыл бұрын

@@jcarty123 Musically everything pop is boring. She is an artist targeting teens/young girls as her audience and in that category I have mad respect. She has limited grasp of musical concepts, plays her own instrument and seems open in regards to the fact that she's not a musicians musician, this is all I can ask of a pop artist. Most of them surround themselves with incredible musicians and give little to no credit. Also, in her Demographic (Young/Teen girls), she is in a powerful position of providing consistent music to people who DONT understand theory. All of us on this channel have a higher than average understanding of what goes into making music, people who just listen to Taylor Swift have no idea she's reusing chord progressions.

@jcarty123

Жыл бұрын

@@tatereis4031 Nice tone, very nice try, I like it.... so.... I do feel sorry to point out that you're still in the position of having to defend a s--- sandwich. "everything pop is boring" - TODAY. Which gets us to the discussion of how pop since the 2000s got fundamentally less varied. Suffice to say: Even teenage girls used to demand more. Beatles, Elton John, Zep, Clash, Nirvana, even Michael Jackson - all writing for teenage girls, all tried to make each track different from the last.

The first time you played the 4 chords of her most used progression (I V vi IV), my mind automatically filled in "... speaking words of wisdom, let it be."

@BeatlesCentricUniverse

Жыл бұрын

Amen!

@blunderr6113

Жыл бұрын

As did my mind lol

@PaulRippey

Жыл бұрын

Me too!

@guitarpaul3645

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, a progression is just a backbone. The melodies make the song. Let It Be is a beautiful melody. And Taylor is a first class melodist.

@noradosmith

Жыл бұрын

I swear sometimes the internet just reads my mind

Thank you for the way this was presented. I feel like I’ve seen these types of videos before where the person calls this type of pattern “lazy and bad writing” because of the repeated chord progressions. But this was very educational and respectful of Taylor’s craft, which I appreciate so much.

@guitarpaul3645

Жыл бұрын

Anyone who says it's lazy and bad is just wrong. A chord progression is just the harmonic backbone of a song, the melodies, rhythms and instrumentation and arrangements create a unique song. And Taylor is a genius melodist.. melody is where it's at. Nobody, and I mean nobody, does it better than she does.

@guitarcontestthrowaway7809

Жыл бұрын

It may not be bad, but it is lazy and leads to predictable melodies.

@caitlinx4962

Жыл бұрын

@@guitarcontestthrowaway7809 if you think her melodies are boring and predictable you’re clearly unfamiliar with her music

@floh2959

Жыл бұрын

@@guitarcontestthrowaway7809 agreed

@GoodFang

Жыл бұрын

@@guitarcontestthrowaway7809 you think you have a clue but you don't.

Oh boy, the Swifties are going to love this. Might take their mind off of Ticketmaster.

@joeyscerbo7776

Жыл бұрын

I think everybody should be thinking about how awful Ticketmaster is, not just Swifties

@CommanderGinyu

Жыл бұрын

As a European Swiftie I have no connection to Ticketmaster whatsoever and since she’s probably not even doing a European tour this time I care even less. She’s just not popular enough here which is a shame but I still think Americans overstate her worldwide popularity

@erik5374

Жыл бұрын

I think David is very aware of the Swifties jumping onto this vid.. Might be interesting what Swift inc. is going to do. The vid is for educational use and friendly to artist and fans.

@ziggystardog

Жыл бұрын

Like the video, the comment’s intended to be neutral, read into it what you will. Swifties aren’t exactly known for their nuanced online behavior, or understanding of issues. Hard to say how many knew of Ticketmaster’s history with Vedder or Pearl Jam until they “discovered” it. Or whether they’d stick around for David’s summary at video’s end or how they’d take it. Swift’s music is perfectly fine in my book, but I’m more impressed by her storytelling and production. Her fandom is another story, but that may be more a product of it growing up with social media. I feel Swift could do more to tame its more toxic elements, however.

@LovestarVGC

Ай бұрын

@@CommanderGinyujust wanted to drop in and say this comment aged like Milk 😂

The chills I get every time a new group of songs is played.

@DavidBennettPiano

Жыл бұрын

😃😃

I think the ability to create an interesting melody is one of her very strong points. It's so catchy, even with just using a common chord progression. Freaking 41 different sequences of melodies and lyrics written in just 2 chords progression and all of them sounds different but still nice and catchy. Not many artists can pull that stuff. Buying her album is not something I regret. It mostly contains 15++ songs (over 60 minutes) and all of them sound nice.

@guitarpaul3645

Жыл бұрын

Bingo. Her melodies are her genius.

@noradosmith

Жыл бұрын

Agreed. It's incredible really how she does it. Her last album hasn't got a bad track on it. They're all catchy.

@oliverwarren1074

Жыл бұрын

@@noradosmith When you (and others) say "she", are you suggesting she writes her own melodies? There's like half a dozen people credited each on these tracks.

@jasonfanclub4267

Жыл бұрын

Her melodies or the melodies of her composers? 👀

@guitarpaul3645

Жыл бұрын

@@jasonfanclub4267 What?!? Do you know anything about Taylor? She composes virtually all her songs herself. More than 50 of her songs are solo written (including an entire album), and include some of her BEST songs like Red, Forever and Always, Love Story, and Blank Space (yep, she wrote that on guitar, Max Martin just changed into a synth pop track and helped with arrangement). When she collaborates, she usually does most of the vocal melodies, on songs like Out Of The Woods, Wish You Were and Getaway Car.

The entire Red album was written the with C G Am F chords (not in that order, but only those chords were used). That album is completely versatile and is a great example how four chords can change so much Edit: I meant 1-5-6-4 chords, not C G Am F

@mirufiyu4810

Жыл бұрын

I remember learning to play guitar because of Taylor Swift and her Fearless album has a lot of D A Em G chord songs, easiest way for me to learn guitar with my favorite songs of her that time 😍

@rokale7418

Жыл бұрын

And how to give another boring, commercial, uninventive album

@kayajones7629

Жыл бұрын

actually if I remember correctly, Red was mostly in the key of E. So E A Bb and C#m. there may have been a song or two in C (all too well maybe), but saying that C G Am and F were the only chords used on the entire album is very not true.

@kxxn693

Жыл бұрын

@@kayajones7629 actually I meant that if you play all the songs on the guitar, you can capo it for some songs and it'll all end up using those four chords. For example, you can capo your guitar on the 4th fret and play those chords and the result would be Red

@Jojo13Lorin

Жыл бұрын

By the way- this is called the I- V- vi- IV progression; it's relative to whatever key the song is set in

This just gave me the sudden urge to learn every single Taylor Swift song on piano.

Hearing all her songs mixed together so beautifully made me so emotional 😭 You are absolutely right about these chord progressions being a familiar "bed" for her lyrics and stories to lay on. That is why so many like me always come back to her music. It's ever-changing but always feels like home 🥰

your mashups here are really beautiful! as a huge swiftie, I was amazed at how many times some of these have been used great video!

@absolving

Жыл бұрын

don't you feel like a fool when you realise your favourite musician is just recycling the same shit over and over again?

As a huge fan of what some might consider weird music, here’s a takeaway I have: All of these chord progressions are strictly diatonic. There’s nothing weird about them. That makes them feel comfortable and familiar, and easy to listen to. Contrast that with songs like Bliss by Muse, which is in C minor for the verses and switches to C major for the chorus, or The Cure’s song End which has a G minor, G major, F sus2 chord progression. Chromatic and adventurous chord progressions like that intentionally interrupt the flow, change the mood, and shake your foundation, and probably would not be appropriate for storyteller songwriting like Taylor uses, simply because it would be distracting.

@Stratlover

Жыл бұрын

True! Im not a fan of her music, but i listen edm music mostly, these chord progressions are edms base of emotion, and im happy with it

@leikfroakies

Жыл бұрын

She also uses unconventional chord progressions on occasion which are only unconventional when used on occasion. Not exactly the same thing but the reason her two 5/4 songs (tolerate it and closure) work so well is because they break from convention and use the time signature to convey a very specific message - the cognitive dissonance of unappreciated love or a situation in which the narrator is barely holding back her anger

@elmo44449999

Жыл бұрын

It's worth noting that she uses some chromatic chords too (like in Lover or Sweet Nothing); they're just not among her most common progressions.

@merna5685

Жыл бұрын

this doesn't make any sense, especially considering how a lot of folk and popular songs are written in modes (like Mixolydian or Dorian). You can write songs in non diatonic way it has nothing to do with interrupting the flow

@womplestilskin

Жыл бұрын

@@merna5685 modes are diatonic, you have to go outside the key to be non diatonic. There's 7 diatonic modes in any key.

It’s so weird when I heard the I V ii IV chord progression by itself, I instantly recognised it and it made me feel like home.

@haileysprinkles8157

Жыл бұрын

As soon as I heard it, I thought of Getaway Car and Wildest Dreams, which are my two favorite TS songs haha

@sunlakestar2549

Жыл бұрын

I think it's her most recognizable chord, at least for me anyways. I heard it and started blasting out all the songs that came up after. For her #1 chord progression, I didn't actually recognize it until Love Story.

Interesting to note is that her 4th and 5th most common progressions (vi-IV-I-V and IV-I-V-vi) have the same chords in the same order, they just start the loop in a different place.

@mastod0n1

Жыл бұрын

It's also the same as her most used chord progression. It's just the axis of awesome chord progression but with different starting points.

A student of mine told me that she has a friend who only knows 4 chords and played the same 4 chords for an hour and figured out 20 Taylor songs. Also, you should really do a video on Bob Dylan's chord progressions. A lot of people say that his lyrics are better than his music and while that is largely true, he's quite clever with his chord choices and very often they act as the song's main hook, more than the melody. You can recognize several Dylan songs just by the chords.

@minoena

Жыл бұрын

yup

@gamer966

Жыл бұрын

wow! any particularly noteworthy examples?

@NeonRadarMusic

Жыл бұрын

@@gamer966 Simple Twist of Fate, Idiot Wind, Just Like A Woman, Sad-Eyed Lady of the Lowlands, Hurricane, Dark Eyes, As I Went Out One Morning, It's Alright Ma, This Wheel's On Fire and many more.

@gamer966

Жыл бұрын

@@NeonRadarMusic thanks a lot! have a nice day

@ricocinna

5 ай бұрын

@@NeonRadarMusic perfect!

I’ve been arranging covers of 13 songs from each of her albums (did 13 Days of Red last year for the re-recording release) so thanks for saving me a lot of time going forward 😂 Also the mashups are a great example of how she could go about performing more than 10% of her output for the Eras tour. 👏

@MJ-he1hf

Жыл бұрын

Can you imagine if she did huge mashup/medleys like this on tour 😱😱 Amazing 😭

@jennym7786

10 ай бұрын

@@MJ-he1hf i remember when she did a medley of back to decemeber/apologize/you're not sorry during her speak now tour and i loved that arrangement, especially with the strings.

“Now you come around here just to break me like a promise / so casually cruel in the name of being honest.” That’s such a good lyric that it’s going to get people regardless of how many times you’ve heard it before

@XxBloggs

Жыл бұрын

That’s not what she sings. It’s “and you call me up again just to break me like a promise”

Yo, give this to Taylor Swift, she's gonna need it for all the mashups in the Eras Tour 😂

@ricocinna

5 ай бұрын

she just did a mashup in Buenos Aires. I'm hoping she'll do more!

i think a very cool thing of hers is that she can hold on to a chord for a long time. many people go through the progression very quickly, but she usually holds each chord in the progression for a long time, making the melody kind of more satisfying. that's why she doesn't need that many weird or varied chords, because her melodies already do so much within each single chord

your mashups give me major goosebumps. as someone who’s grown up with taylor, they hit so hard. someone must be cutting onions in here

Even as a budding music theory snob (and marginal TS fan), I've never detected all these chord progressions she uses so much--I think it's a bit of a testament to how she's able to make them sound so different with her lyrics, vocal melodies and rhythms, etc. It's cool; thanks for the video!

@milanforever7014

Жыл бұрын

if you haven't detected that, you are obviously not a music theory snob dude sorry

@guitarpaul3645

Жыл бұрын

Exactly, it's her MELODIES that are her genius, and she creates so many memorable and beautiful ones. That's what maked people fall in love with her songs... melody is always the strongest suit in music IMHO.

this is inspiring. it always feels a bit like cheating anytime i use a chord progression more than once

@badgasaurus4211

Жыл бұрын

I’d say it is

@slidenaway

Жыл бұрын

@@badgasaurus4211 well cheating seems to contribute to Taylor’s massive success so… why wouldn’t you cheat lol

@bonkknob3240

Жыл бұрын

@@badgasaurus4211 how

@thesahel7218

Жыл бұрын

@@badgasaurus4211 it's statistically impossible. There are only so many progressions and songwriters write hundreds of songs (usually all in genre)

@ninabru7528

Жыл бұрын

@@badgasaurus4211 why?

Let's also remember that Taylor has a discography of over 200 songs at this point. Most artists are lucky to ever reach that number. Of course there's gonna be stuff that gets repeated.

@craigmoon2121

Жыл бұрын

That's what I was thinking. This video was well-presented though.

@keith1222

Жыл бұрын

The Beatles had well over 200 songs (in only 7 years), but I don't hear them constantly repeating themselves by using the same chords and the same (autotuned) sound.

@craigmoon2121

Жыл бұрын

@@keith1222 Autotune's kinda a problem with modern music, but Taylor's a really bad example of complaining about autotune cuz she hardly ever uses it.

@leon723

Жыл бұрын

It's a LOT of repeating, not just some stuff.

@rokale7418

Жыл бұрын

@@craigmoon2121 WHAT? You have big ear problems if you don't hear the use of her autotune on her songs

When I taught myself to play guitar, all I played was Taylor Swift songs because I could play so many of them with the few chords I knew. Definitely an interesting topic for a video! It brought me back to that for a minute

This teaches us music, not that she is limited. A Chord progression contains infinite songs.

@Jantonov1

Жыл бұрын

Bennett doesn't really say that. Clearly he has respect for Taylor but what I got from the video is that she repeats herself often. And that's her sound.

@LS-us1jm

Жыл бұрын

No she’s pretty limited

@viktor_h787

Жыл бұрын

@@LS-us1jm limited or not, she the 3rd biggest artist in the world on spotify so who cares

@happygilmore8321

Жыл бұрын

​@@viktor_h787 the people who would care are those who know better songwriters and artists exist out there and aren't getting the recognition they deserve. While someone else can repeat the same chord progression 21 times and make it to the top 10. Not saying she's bad or lazy even, just that other people may also deserve that kind of recognition. I like Taylor Swift tho. She has some great music

@viktor_h787

Жыл бұрын

@@happygilmore8321 yeah but you cant force the people to discover said great songwriters. it either happens or doesnt happen, so we might as well not shit on the ppl that are currently in the spotlight

I really like your conclusion to this, that chords are colours and painting and liking the same colours isn't always a bad thing. I think Taylor Swift does it well because while I knew some of her songs had similar progressions, I had no idea about the amount that shared the exact same ones (and I've been a big Taylor Swift fan since my teenage years when I first heard Love Story). They sound similar but different enough, and I enjoy that, honestly. It made me curious about an album that's just one singular progression but each song is done differently, trying to make it sound unique despite sharing that progression. I don't know if anyone has done this - and I'm definitely not the right person to do this!!! - but I would be really interesting in it if they have.

@ReprobateMind

Жыл бұрын

I like this idea alot, I'm probably going to steal it for a project. But I'll let you know when it's done haha

@91fallings

Жыл бұрын

replying here so that i’ll get notified cause i’m genuinely curious and excited about the project :)

@VivekPatel-ze6jy

Жыл бұрын

@@91fallings Same :)

Honestly, it’s quite understandable that these are her favorite chords if you remember her background is playing a guitar and all that country music. Those chords (C, G, D, Am, F) are basically the most popular chords and kinda the first chords any person learning a guitar would in fact learn. Lots of rock music (played with a guitar obviously) is played basically with only those chords, with a few additions here and there. It all makes sense. She isn’t some Jimi Hendrix type of a person, she’s a lyricist first, so it makes sense that her music might be seen as quite basic in terms of chords. UPD: corrected guitar virtuoso's name

@locustkllr

Жыл бұрын

Exactly and those 5 chords are also physically easy to play and mess around with. When was the last country or pop music song that had a Bm7 in it?

@pedrofauluchi7540

Жыл бұрын

Not only because of the lyrics. For someone that likes to improvise on a base (not taylor's case), those chords are simple and easy to play with

@memeteam2692

Жыл бұрын

@@locustkllr F physically easy to play???

@mikebarrett1466

Жыл бұрын

@@memeteam2692 lol

@wingracer1614

Жыл бұрын

@@locustkllr I have no idea and I'm not about to go looking for it (I hate country) but I'd be willing to bet Kieth Urban has played it.

Also, 3 of the 5 chord progressions are just shifted versions of each other (the chord sequences are identical, it's just which chord you start on that changes). So you could play 39 of the songs using the exact same loop of chords, you would just need to shift the start of your lyrics phrasing.

These mashups made me cry. Goes to show just how effective her melodies are.

@jayazoriginal4879

Жыл бұрын

You've Just sensitive

@craigmoon2121

Жыл бұрын

@@jayazoriginal4879 It's nearly impossible for anyone with a heart to listen to Ronan without at least wanting to tear up though.

Awesome video. I feel like the reason Taylor uses so many simple chord progressions stems from the fact that she focuses so heavily on lyricism and telling a story in her songs which can be difficult to portray on top of having complex chord progressions

@AutPen38

Жыл бұрын

In the past, there were "storytelling songs" that also had chord structures that wandered off in interesting directions (e.g. The Beatles), but I don't think modern audiences have the attention spans that listeners had in the past. We all just want simplicity served up these days. Fast food microwave pop music. There's nothing wrong with it, per se, as the world has changed since the old days, but one has to wonder where pop goes next. I can't see any reason why we'd go back to using 8 or 10 different chords in a song, when the message can be understood with 3 or 4.

@zeejay4458

Жыл бұрын

So it’s fair to say T Swift is bad at guitar then right? Because she’s a lyricist first?

@nuclearcatbaby1131

Жыл бұрын

Danny Elfman wrote very complex music for his band Oingo Boingo but his lyrics were really good as well. Though I have to say that his songs that are stronger musically are weaker lyrically and vice versa.

@aliyaf9869

Жыл бұрын

@@digitaldirtbagg David is a good musician and teacher, I wish I could get lessons from him. He knows how songs work and their structure regardless of who he’s talking about. He’s never bashed an artist but understands things from their point of view. He’s one of my favourite KZreadrs but unfortunately he attracts a lot of pretentious music chords with one armed arguments, just like Taylor being bashed for the ‘same chord progression’ when many artists will do the same including people from the rock and punk genre.

I thought I was the only one who pays attention to the chords Taylor uses in her songs lmao and immediately whenever she has a song with the chord progression IV I V vi, I fall in love with it because it's just beautiful. I also love it when she uses IV vi V ii like in New Romantics, it's just a pretty chord progression.

@Mermelephant

Жыл бұрын

Kinda silly you thought you were the only one listening to the chords used by one of most prolific American singers of this generation.

@womplestilskin

Жыл бұрын

@@Mermelephant music training is cut from education and not a lot of theory analysis is done on pop music. while you might be right in any absolute sense (there's more than a handful) the relative number of people allen might encounter in life or social media is objectively tiny.

@jhazscx

8 ай бұрын

the thing is, realistically, no one cares about chord progressions, unless you're really into music. as someone who grew up with music, I pay attention to even the tiniest details, and with Taylor, I pay attention to her chords usage. You might think it's silly but throughout my life, I have never met someone who is as interested to chords as I am. But I do agree that she is one of most prolific American singers of this generation; I can't argue with that.

i remember learning all too well on the piano for the first time and being like "cool..." and then i learned champagne problems and i was like "woahhhh these are the same chords!!" and then learning cornelia street... "THESE ARE STILL THE SAME CHORDS!!" i do realize i chose the most similar-sounding songs out of all her songs with this chord progression (what can i say i love a good cry) but i love how she uses melodies, lyrics, beats and other parts of the song to make songs with even the most basic chords extremely intriguing and different from each other. great video!!

Thanks for being so humble, modest and benevolent ♥️

@DavidBennettPiano

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!

This was a great video and the most I’ll ever hear Taylor’s music. My biggest gripe with this type of pop is that it lacks imagination and color. But I can see that if you’ve grown up with her music she honors it by never leaving the construct.

Ok, I've never really been a Swiftie, but the mashups you made were so beautiful that it's got me interested in digging into some of her back catalog to see if I can get more into it. Great video!

I appreciate the subtle effort to make these medley transition nicely between each other. That's how you know you care about the music, becuase you want it to ound nice even when you're making a point.

I don't know how anyone can belittle this style of songwriting while praising 12-bar blues, or minor pentatonic solos, or any other genre-defining trope. It serves its purpose beautifully, even if it's not the purpose some of us would prefer.

@jcarty123

Жыл бұрын

Yes, Taylor Swift is the new Robert Johnson! So gritty! So authentic! No one can share the pain of being a wealthy female celebrity like Taylor!😜

@BeatlesCentricUniverse

Жыл бұрын

@@jcarty123 Trying to be funny and edgy, but dumb comment really.

@jcarty123

Жыл бұрын

@@BeatlesCentricUniverse If (if) that's your manner of defending Taylor's poor "music", your criticism works out as a compliment. Thank you.

@BeatlesCentricUniverse

Жыл бұрын

@@jcarty123 I stand by my 1st comment.

@jcarty123

Жыл бұрын

@@BeatlesCentricUniverse Pissing off Taylor-supporting dummies isn't my chief intention - yet proves to be fun anyway.

I know I already said it but it deserves it's own comment alone: The vocal editing showing the progressions and songs and how they work together are brilliant! Beautiful! Amazing!

I dont know a thing about music theory but the proof in the mashups are amazing

As soon as I realized that #5 was just a cyclic reordering of the I-V-vi-IV, my immediate reaction was, "Oh, man, are they all like that? Is that the whole list?!" It's not. But, with the exception of that ii in the "Believe" progression, they are all _permutations_ of I-V-vi-IV.

Nice work! I always watch your videos, cuz I find they help me with my guitar journey! Keep making videos!

I think this makes me respect her more as a songwriter actually, to have reused the same progressions so many times but without the songs sounding like each other. I've never noticed any of her songs being just like an old one. That's impressive

I think to me her 2nd most common progression I V ii VI is what I most associate with her music. It might just be that they're the songs I listened most to other than her axis of awesome progression

@zacyoung6411

Жыл бұрын

It feels like coming home. I can’t describe it any other way

@gudegudemeh5195

Жыл бұрын

Same! A lot of my most favorite songs from her are in the list.

I appreciate how much work you put in this video!!! I love Taylor and I’ve been working on playing some songs on piano and this makes things so much easier. Not to mention the mashups and editing. Thanks for this (:

Hearing all of these repeated chord progressions makes me think that this is what makes so many of her songs feel familiar and like instant loves when she creates new albums and new songs. These chords are the building blocks that create the whole vibe and atmosphere we associate with her.

Fantastic video! The amount of work involved in splicing and tempo-shifting those mashups must have been immense, but so worth it. Chord recycling aside, I think Taylor’s genius (and yes, i think she is one) is in finding unique and memorable hooks that fit over these classic progressions. Her lyrics are relatable and often striking too, but her melodic sense is unmatched, while never being pretentious (unlike this comment 😬)

@djnoy842

8 ай бұрын

Agree!

@ricocinna

5 ай бұрын

Love 😃

I love your videos but this video has quickly become such a calming presence for me, something about your voice and how the video is arranged. Was super anxious today and this really helped.

I really did enjoy the mash ups, I've had my fill of Taylor for the day haha! Thank you for the wonderful explanation and tips of what chords are best to use.

How can you use the same 5 chords and still make it sound new and fresh every time you apply it to a song. Taylor!!!!!!! How?!!!!

This actually turned out to be a demonstration of how much the melody makes the song.

I love this video so much. Thank you for the hard work you've clearly put into it.

These mashups give me chills. I need full versions

Can’t blame her - those progressions are so in our ears - they just will work. Thanks for this Video (I never followed her)

As a Taylor fan, I love to sing the lyrics of one TS song over the chord progression of another when I hear they match, and I try to see how many other of her songs I can fit in. She is such a talented storyteller and songwriter that the chords are just the vessel for her words - and she is a pop writer after all so… those satisfying chords are gonna come up a lot to make hit songs.

Thanks a lot. Informative, respectful, with lots of work from you behind the montages. Thanks!

Such an awesome analysis and those mashups are beautiful!! Thank you so much for your work! I’m off to listen to her the rest of the day now❤

So insane that these songs all sound so different. I can’t handle this woman’s genius. Great mashups in this video!

@jonasvalero

Жыл бұрын

Lol, it doesn't take a a genius to write familiar music once you recognize a pattern.

@Will-sb4hf

Жыл бұрын

@@jonasvalero Then why are not having more people like her?

@rickytikitavi4101

8 ай бұрын

@Will-sb4hf Because most people don't have the rare combination of good looks, determination, and an extremely wealthy family.

@rommel500

7 ай бұрын

lol "genius"

@jfacts2113

6 ай бұрын

they don't sound different at all and there is nothing genius in what she does. you can find these melodies in countless other songs done before

all of those mashups were so beautiful and actually got me emotional 😭😭

Great study of popular chord progressions. I didn't know many of these songs, and may have gained more respect for Taylor as a musician. Love how he explains and makes like medleys of songs to demonstrate the progression he's highlighting.

This is simply brilliant! Thank you so much for giving me my Saturday morning Taylor buzz - those mashups are so good!

Lots of artists do exactly the same, virtually all Noel Gallagher songs are Wonderwall with a different melody. What you say is so true, if the listener likes something then they usually want more of the same.

This is a great video, thanks for being so thorough and informed. I do agree that the lyrics are why we keep coming back to her music, but for her there is also an element of performing the songs. She often plays her own instruments, there are so many words to all her songs lol and she’s also performing with her entire self. There’s only so much room for mistakes this way, and allows her to mash the songs together easily when singing live

I love the mashups! So well done and sounds really pretty 😊

I don’t listen to contemporary music but it’s refreshing to know that someone still uses the good old I vi IV V progression

Interesting piece and your comment at the end, that TS is simply using a reliable foundation for her story-telling is very true. They may have similar chords but they certainly don't all sound the same! (By the way, you're picking-up a lot of low-freq. stuff on your mic - you might try a bit of roll-off).

Thank's for this massive effort you put into these videos! I have an video idea: There is a long tradition of these 'story-telling songs' in pop music you mentioned at the end of your video. All the classic song writers have a few 5min+ songs with a simple chord progression looped throughout. Newer examples I can think of are eg by Father John Misty or also The National (Not in Kansas)

Really good video. The production of this was so creative in how you mixed the examples of the songs.

Dude the mashups are masterfully done - your quantization skills are insane 👍

Thank you! Very cool! It’s like chocolate chip cookies have certain ‘main’ ingredients but can taste quite different depending on the person (or company) that makes them. She makes sweet songs because she has a solid base recipe and then her lyrics/vocals are the different added ingredients or toppings.

Great timing for me, seeing this, as I just created a cover of Love Story which has 1564 in the chorus but also other progressions in the verses, refrain and bridge. And a massive key change at the end.

I think you've pretty much nailed it here. Her popularity among her 'target' audience - teenage girls (fight me) - comes from the lyrics, tied to the standards of pop music chords. Also, even though I don't know much of her music, it's obvious that your mash-ups of her songs are spectacular. Impressive.

This is such a great video and I adore the mashups!

All those progressions tend to form nice comfy loops. They set a mood for the story in the lyrics. Seems to work just fine.

Now I want full length Swift + Swift + Swift mashups

Love the concept and execution of this! Beautiful to watch, easy to follow. 🤙

your videos are so well made! appreciate the work you do

Can we just appreciate the fact that this guy took the time to go through Swift's WHOLE DISCOGRAPHY? And not just to casually have it as background music, but to be listening carefully to each song, looking for similar chord progressions? At 200+ songs (according to one of the comments here - I didn't count for myself), that's gonna take an incredibly LONG time (speaking partially from personal experience). Huge props to this guy for his dedication!!!

@swan6630

10 ай бұрын

Ikr!! He even included songs like Crazier, Only the Young, the Christmas songs, and Beautiful Eyes! Massive respect

I get so hyped for every new video of yours!! Also, no copyright issues for these songs??

@DavidBennettPiano

Жыл бұрын

Oh, rest assured, there are copyright issues 😅

@pacorka9943

Жыл бұрын

@@DavidBennettPiano Lol I figured. I don't know much about copyright but I know Taylor Swift's songs are all in a weird place being owned by her and her old record studios.

@richarddoan9172

Жыл бұрын

I'm guessing -- extract the vocals from the recording, trim to a short segment, then change them to be in the same key and tempo for the mashup. Voila! Algorithm thwarted.

@pacorka9943

Жыл бұрын

@@richarddoan9172 lol. Honestly makes sense considering the format of the video.

Wow, this is an incredibly well done video. great mashups!

Brilliant video! Very enjoyable to listen to, and educational to boot. Loved the editing. Thank you!

I am a fan of Taylor’s, and I really enjoyed her recent album Folklore. If she broke out of these familiar chord progressions a bit, I think it would make her music better.

@TheMOReviewers

Жыл бұрын

I'm definitely inclined to agree, but it's good to note there are already some great examples of songs which buck these trends. Even off the top of my head, Everything Has Changed, Right Where You Left Me and Safe & Sound all use more than 4 chords, and also don't repeat the same pattern throughout.

@Samantha-vlly

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely agree. It's a bit risky for her to do that and unusual as well. But I’d love to if she’ll do it in the future.

@TheMOReviewers

Жыл бұрын

@Day Yes I did notice that when I typed it lol. That's mainly because I happen to have learned those songs on guitar! But I will check Speak Now later and get back to you! I will say that was pretty early in her career, and she definitely has gotten more adventurous over time - especially in albums like evermore, where she experimented a lot more with different structures to her songs and even time signatures (tolerate it and closure are both written in 5/4). But now I'm intrigued to look into the more interesting structures she's implemented in her solo written tracks. Not to say that I would always credit her collaborators when she departs from the norm, but I guess it's sometimes harder to tell.

@nuclearcatbaby1131

Жыл бұрын

@Day She hasn’t done a wholly self-written album since Speak Now though, which was rather weak but there was a huge improvement in the self-written songs on Red.

@nuclearcatbaby1131

Жыл бұрын

@Day Maybe some of her collaborators but not Jack Antonoff. He’s even less adventurous than her. A lot of their collaborations have poor melodies because she just writes it to match a background music he already made. I think she usually writes the melody first and then picks chords to fit it and it just so happens that it’s usually the same chords that fit these melodies. So in order to get more adventurous with chords she would have to pick the chords first and write a melody that matches it. Or get more adventurous with writing melodies so that they match different chords.

I guess you could say that she Taylors her music to her lyrics.

@DavidBennettPiano

Жыл бұрын

😂

Wow. All I can say is wow... what an amazingly compiled and edited video. Thoroughly explained the use of each of the chord progressions which was amazing, and the mashups of each of the songs that use the chord progressions were absolutely beautiful. Genuinely incredible, appreciate the hard work. Wish more people put this much effort into their videos, it's definitely something to admire!

Bravo! This was so well done. Very enjoyable!

Cardigan caught my ear, it got me doing some analysis to figure out what what’s going on. Eb Major, with the verses going ii V IV V, no I until the chorus. Later the vi is used oddly, sometimes vi V IV.

i hate being a contrarian (i am a proud basic bitch and love pop music) but i realised here that basically no songs from folklore use these common progressions, and that is my favourite album of hers by FAR. the urge here is to say that she should push the boundaries more because she’s sooo good when she does, but perhaps it’s because she thrives in these tried and true sounds that it’s such a treat when she mixes it up. loved this vid!

@taka-taktak

Жыл бұрын

He just used illicit affairs and epiphany in the video as examples of the common chord progressions though.

chills mate listening to the compilation of Taylor songs clipped together

really appreciated your mashups here. great video

The first thing I thought of when you showed the #5 progression was "That's the Axis loop, but starting at a different point" and then you showed #4 which was that same progression but starting on another chord. It became quite obvious what the #1 would be. It's really quite remarkable how many songs can be harmonized with simply the 1-5-6-4 chords. Congrats on this video by the way. I think it will prove to be one of your most popular uploads, but it must have driven you half mad getting all the bits together and then syncing up the various album covers. Well done!

Any chance you could also share a list of the I IV and I IV vi IV songs? Always looking for more of those as they are good chord progressions for beginning ukulele students (since C, F, and Am are some of the first chords they learn) Love your work!

What a video! So much work behind! The second you put for me sounds Cold Play

Very well done vid. And effective in conveying great content. Thank you!

We need an Axis of Awesome medley of Taylor Swift songs

Brilliant video! David could you break down melodies of popular artists? (Bob Dylan, Taylor Swift, Sting, etc.) Your chord progression breakdowns are really interesting, but just as interesting and intriguing (I would assume) are melodies.

@nuclearcatbaby1131

Жыл бұрын

I want one for Danny Elfman (his songs from Oingo Boingo)

Loved the way you managed to put chords with her vocals with different songs♥️♥️♥️👌👌👌👏👏👏

Love the way he explained everything !! Thank you ! You gained a new subscriber!