It’s not government job to run a business …. Because they are not good at it..

@salmanazhar5306

Жыл бұрын

Pakistanis will never understand this. India is doing a great job promoting free market economy. The whole world has moved towards free market meanwhile Pakistanis are still considering Socialism as a solution.

@luciddoggo5094

9 ай бұрын

​@@salmanazhar5306 ehhh we still have unfortunately very anti free market. As shown with the farm law protests that unfortunately got overturned. Even the most popular prime minister in indian history can barely liberalise a single bank without wide scale protest. One of the greatest destructions britan did was training indian intellectuals to follow fabian socialism! Then they stayed on the liberalisation pass while we started nationalising our industries. Yes what britan did to us was horrible but Pakistan India were all richer than china post independence, if we had actually performed economic liberlisation from the start we would be richer than china.

@Attitudezero884

7 ай бұрын

​@@luciddoggo5094 as if the individual businessman were innocent😂😂😂😂😂look into 1943 femine and see how jehangir ratan tata and mirza ahmed ispahani( that time owner of bangladesh conglomerate ispahani group) have looted people and sold their food products at double prices those kind of incidents only made people to support nationalisation concept.

@hassaanmirza3942

4 ай бұрын

Bro hum aap ki tarah intelligent nahi hain. Hamien lagta hai businesses bhi government hi kary gi❤🇮🇳🇵🇰

I don't know about Pakistan, but India definitely benefitted by opening the economy and giving industries in private hands. India was growing with 2-3 percent until 90s but after the reforms, it has grown with 5-7 percent per year after that

@parjanyashukla176

6 ай бұрын

That growth means nothing, but unfortunately you won't understand what I mean.

Watch the full podcast with Taimur Rahman: kzread.info/dash/bejne/q36Kysqun8yelbw.html&

@richardsking

Жыл бұрын

Nationalization has destroyed India, now these people will destroy Pakistan with their opposite thinkings😂, India don't need to do anything, these are enough to destroy Pakistan🙄

So let’s blame global recession for Bhutto’s idiotic economic policies… if you buy that argument, 2020 pandemic was responsible for IKs mismanagement of economy

@iqra07ify

Жыл бұрын

yes i was thinking the same that he is in a favour of nationalization. but it is not true.

@muhammad_bariz

Жыл бұрын

And ironically Pakistan's economy thrived during pandemic. Our GDP increased while having a current account surplus in 2020.

Giving the government so much control is not good, specially when it comes to economy

Mcb zia ke time pe nahi, mian sahab ke time pe privatise hua tha, and the ideology behind nationalisation is not even socialist its actually communist which is dangerous for a country

@hassaanmirza3942

4 ай бұрын

Agree❤

With due respect to Dr Taimur I disagree Bhutto nationalization was the main reason of deindustrialization of Pakistan Shahzad please do a podcast with Mian Mansha and other big businessmen

common people in rural areas still love zulfikar ali bhutto very much.Because they believe he is the only leader who stood for them

@hassaanmirza3942

4 ай бұрын

Ghanta

Adah such jhoot sa zaida khatarnak hota ha

Shehzad request u to study UPI and AADHAR stacks - Link totally with all govt dept

Record's, theek kaaroo MCB 1991 maa, Private hoowaay thaa, Jaab Mian sb PM thaay.

Impossible to endure. Keynes. Friedman. Thatcher. What all these names have to do with an impoverished Jinnah’s Muslim ghetto? Nationalization? In a ghetto?

Agreed 👍🏻

Please do comment like this or any other comment...if you want to continue to watch free content like this because it encourages KZread algorithm to give this video more reach and more views....Keep doing the good work sir ....

@ThePakistanExperience

Жыл бұрын

❤❤❤

Kaha say latay hu aisa bandy dhund dhund k 😜

@danishsaeed2105

Жыл бұрын

Iski gulti ni hai bro ye bichara intellectuals dhund dhund k la kar ata hai per awam engineer sab jaisay shoppers ko sunna pasand karti hai 😜😜😜

And to this day all this (haram) price fixing from his time is rigging the economy to fail. Here are some of the things the state still decides and sets the prices: 1. Flour 2. Cooking Oil & ghee 3. Chicken 4. Meat 5. Tomatos & other basic vegetables 6. Milk & yoghurt 6. Electricity (subsidized for retail and over priced for commercial) 7. Gas (subsidized for retail over priced for commercial) 8. Petrol (subsidized for retail over priced for commercial) There's a long list of government set prices we receive in Bahria Enclave every week. Then we complain that these business who are forced to sell at government rates rather than letting the market decide: 1. Don't provide good quality 2. Use cheap dangerous chemicals to boost production 3. Worse milawat mixed in Well businesses can't survive if the government is setting the prices rather than the market, so many are forced to take these short cuts to stay afloat, and can't invest in R&D to improve. FWD

Now.i.realize the power of Bell icon

@ThePakistanExperience

Жыл бұрын

:D

He is still against privatisation of PIA. A corrupt inefficient organisation providing the worst service ever eating billions of tax payers rupees each year. I like Taimoor but sometimes his ideology goes against reason and logic.

Good luck

I condemn

Mn ne comment kya tha k Engineer wale podcast p murtid haris sultan zaror bat krega abhe ghanta pehle us ne podcast p bat ke h yahe agenda tha ghaias sahab ka jo bat ghais nhe keh ska Pakistan mn hone ke waja se wo haris kr raha h apne chanel p

Please explain this why is a nice educated , pleasant commi guy named after the most bloodthirsty central Asian savage after genghis khan ? Was his dad a ultra right winger ?

Capitalism is very important for any country. Communism is very dangerous

surkha

Liberalization of China starting 1979 and India since 1991 pulled out hundreds of million out of poverty. Singapore, South Korea, Vietnam, Thailand, Malaysia, Bangladesh all succeeded due to liberalization NOT due to liberalization. USSR economy crashed due to communist policies and rose agai. When capitalust policies were adopted by Russia. Taimur should actually present data instead of simply claiming data exists that nationalization improves growth and luberalization hurts it.

bakwas khob krty hu

Typical communist/socialist arguement.. look at scandinavian countries especially Sweden who had nationalized everything initially and almost went bankrupt in 1970, opened up and today it is a developed nation. China under Mao Zedong suffered severe food shortages but under jiang zemin,benefited more from captialism than their communist ideology , opened their econmy in 70s and is now the second biggest economy. Indian story is also same, was bankrupt in 80s with licence raj , excessive nationalization and other beauracratic red tape, improved only after 90s when economy was opened up. Countries which remained true to their socialist/communist ideology are struggling. Cuba, Venezuela,Russia,North Korea the list goes on. The typical arguement against the above mentioned countries is that they were all ruled by dictators. When you place so much control into one government institution, as often happens in communism dictatorship is the norm, not the exception.

Lal bandar is a joker he knew nothing about free market