Respond to this comment with your nomination for which character we should do next, or vote with a thumbs up if they're already listed!

@darthcaedus9130

8 ай бұрын

Jaina solo

@darthcaedus9130

8 ай бұрын

Jacen solo

@darthcaedus9130

8 ай бұрын

Anakin solo

@darthcaedus9130

8 ай бұрын

Ben skywalker

@SgtAJ218

8 ай бұрын

Shaak Ti

Syril is possibly the most relatable Imperial we’ve seen so far. He just wants to contribute to something bigger than himself, to feel like his life has meaning. Plus when he just sat there eating cereal while his mother berated him, I felt that.

@TheDandyMann

8 ай бұрын

Mother berating Syril "I got promoted" mother stops berating him and puts more cereal in the bowl

@Robert_Westwood

8 ай бұрын

He's nothing more than a gadfly...

@Captain_Insano_nomercy

8 ай бұрын

I have a narcissistic mother myself, and all her scenes trigger the hell out of me. It's like I'm back home again. I actually loathe his mom so deeply it's hard to articulate 😅😂

@officialmonarchmusic

8 ай бұрын

Cereal Karn

@DylanSmith-kc2gc

8 ай бұрын

⁠@@Captain_Insano_nomercyI get as much familial ptsd triggers from mamma Karn as I did from both those shots in The Bear and Bloodline I can relate lol😅

Who dared to give Syril an “F”? 😡 Only one person can rate him that low and that person is his mom.

@jxchamb

8 ай бұрын

She would consider him unratable.

@BugRib

8 ай бұрын

Syril's mom is on KZread and watches this channel, confirmed.

@Paul_McSeol

8 ай бұрын

👏. Well played.

@CornyBum

8 ай бұрын

Haha, maybe privately with just her son, but I think his mom would be the type to actually talk him up in front of others. It seems like some people misunderstand her, like that person who described her as "sadistic," which I find kinda simplistic, though the one-sided exaggeration's funny enough. People who've had a mother like that and have come to a reflection and realization decades later, or perhaps just someone who understands people better, can get that she really does love him and thinks pretty well of him but shows it in some bad ways.

@kamillavalter

8 ай бұрын

@@CornyBum totally agree! That’s what I meant: his mom believes that she is the only person who is allowed to rate him low. I’m sure that she brags to her neighbor (the one she shouted at) about her son’s achievements, even when he was a deputy inspector.

People tend to forget, that just to get off of Tatooine,even Luke wanted to apply to the Imperial Academy, where he could travel through space,travel to different systems, meet exciting and exotic people and killing them. This is before he learned about the Jedi or Darth Vader.

@thalmoragent9344

8 ай бұрын

Well, the killing them part isn't exactly what they all join for but, yeah, that's always a possibility.

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

@@thalmoragent9344 The "killing them" part isn´t in the Imperial propaganda holo-adds. It´s always something like "bring order and peace".

@markli6763

8 ай бұрын

Honestly I didn't event think of him as a villain watching the show. I didn't like him, but thats because he's so weirdly attached to this one thing and won't let go. All while everyone else has moved on with their lives. He's the guy where if I knew him irl I just want to tell him to shut up and move on with his life.

@SiriuslyBlack7

8 ай бұрын

@markli6763 That's the beauty of his character.So unassuming,and downright insignificant,even in the eyes of his Imperial peers..In that same way, it would be poetic if he becomes the "Inspector Javert" to Cassian Andor's "Jean ValJean",leading him into a fanatical chase that will eventually claim his life, when the thing he was really pursuing was personal meaning and significance. (sorry for the overblown Les Miserables reference!)

At his best, he's a lawful neutral character that keeps everyone on their toes. At his worst, he's like a pest that won't go away. He believes that he's in love with everything that the Empire has shown him so far. He's convinced that he's on the same mission as Dedra. But what happens when he sees a side of the Empire that he can't deal with? Or if the Empire betrays him? That would be a really interesting character path for Syril Karn. Regardless, give us more Blue Milk with some of that Star Wars cereal!

@MaxRamos8

8 ай бұрын

Absolute B that will go to an A if he ships with his waifu Dedra =)

@TheDemigans

8 ай бұрын

When he sees a bunch of unarmed civilians being shot by armed soldiers his response is to save Derdre. He has no empathy for people who he doesn’t consider supporting the law/Empire.

@Lobsterwithinternet

7 ай бұрын

@@TheDemigansYou mean the unarmed civilians who just chucked a bomb at them and killed an officer with a brick while rioting and attacking Imperial troops?

@TheDemigans

7 ай бұрын

@@Lobsterwithinternet 1: the officer crawled back. 2: everyone can see it was a single person who did that. The fight is unarmed vs armed soldiers. The moment they open fire and no counterfire or explosives are thrown they know the civilians remain unarmed.

@Lobsterwithinternet

7 ай бұрын

@@TheDemigans Who saw it? Nobody did besides the audience. And no, they don't know that. All they know is they’ve been attacked by rioters, one of whom threw a pipe bomb at them.

I mean, he’s probably one of the most maturely and well written characters in Star Wars. I think people dislike him because he isn’t a Jedi or an action star.

@Jedishill680

8 ай бұрын

I think it’s a case of most Star Wars fans considering some actions passive like talking/ emotional support/ telling people what to do as passive actions while shooting a gun/ swinging a sword/ flying a ship to be active actions. I think most fans consider him to be a passive character

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

People who dislike him are 8-10 years old. Some of them only mentally.

@TheDemigans

8 ай бұрын

I think its more that his story hasn’t climaxed yet. Other stories had low moments which followed highs. Syril has been going from low to a different low, and at the end saves Derdra but that doesn’t really offer a high. Not yet. We don’t even know how Derdra will respond to it. Consider also that this is wedged in between Maarva’s funeral speech and Luthen standing at the edge listening to his victory of causing the Empire to go too far as the unarmed civilians scream and blaster fire echoes across the buildings. His high isn’t that noticeable.

@Robert_Westwood

8 ай бұрын

He's actually rather predictable and unrelatable as far as I'm concerned. I'm predicting that his story arc will be at best anticlimactic and a disappointment...

Too often in film and media, villains can end up being unrelatable and even cartoon like. But real world evil is often the result of the system that they work in. Many are never knowingly aware of the consequences of their actions, and those that do are numbed by nihilism or a desire to do something meaningful. Syril's backdrop with a neglected resentful mother makes him an ideal victim to be exploited by the system. I feel that even if he achieves his goal of power and respect, he'll never truly be fulfilled.

@KnowledgeDriven

8 ай бұрын

And for those that do rise through the ranks or are from privilege to begin with, if nihilism or a desire to do something meaningful doesn't numb them, typically $30 million does (ie. Rachel Maddow annual contract). And that's how the MSM has an approval rating just above Congress, which is very low.

I don't know a single character in Andor that I wouldn't give an A to, they're all so well thought out, written & acted. It really has made me see how lazy & undercooked that most of the content is.

The F vote is from his mom

Homie just wanted to do a decent, competent job in his line of Military Work. I respect it.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

I’ve seen worse. He reminds me of one of those officers who just got out of OCS. By the book, sharp, and with a colossal stick up their ass as well as being nervous about everything. It takes a while and some experience to put someone like him right.

I think that saying he is both likeable and dislikeable really describes him well. It makes him a rather unique character in Star Wars. One of the interesting possibilities for season 2 is if he were to be confronted with the true tyranny of the Empire and is faced with the possibility of switching sides. What would he do?

@FlymanMS

8 ай бұрын

I think he's definitely going to go rogue after some soul searching. Probably not out sympathy for Rebellion but because he is disappointed with the Empire.

@Daniel_Huffman

8 ай бұрын

I think an interesting possibility is to have Syril willingly overlook the actions that the Empire is carrying out, all the while convincing himself of it being a good cause, although it is clear that he is believing his own lies, and by the time he realizes that the Empire is a lost cause, he's past the point of no return.

I think he's very unique for a Star Wars character. Never read or seen about anyone like him before in this franchise

@Daniel_Huffman

8 ай бұрын

There's certainly plenty of characters like him in the former Expanded Universe, but they are regularly being swept under the rug by Lucasfilm's employees, who act as though the previous material never happened and that they are breaking new ground.

Dude just wanted law and order. In another setting he would've been the hero.

@kirkdarling4120

8 ай бұрын

All it would take is viewing the story from his point of view instead of Andor's. He's a cop. His life hasn't been oppressing the natives, he's only been chasing street-level bad guys.

I can relate to him very much. Tries his best and fails epically and trying to find ones purpose again. Even though it may not be an ideal purpose in his case.

Hey Thor, did you see the series final of Andor got more views than Ashoka? It was the last of the great classic like Star Wars shows.

@eugger3011

8 ай бұрын

Makes sense. Andor's viewership increased as more people found out hiw high-quality it was, while Ahsoka's decreased.

@MedalionDS9

8 ай бұрын

Season finale, not series finale... we still have this upcoming but it's the last season.

@timtimbly2433

8 ай бұрын

@@MedalionDS9 For Ashoka (Series final) 🤣

@MedalionDS9

8 ай бұрын

Unfortunately neither is true, Ahsoka sounds like it is getting a 2nd season @@timtimbly2433

Honestly Syril isn't a bad guy. A creep, sure, but all he does is try to uphold Imperial law. He's a perfect character pulled from a desk job into something way over his paygrade, and he suffers the consequences

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

Imagine if this took place during either the Republic or New Republic. This guy could have been a hero in most other places.

Syril is an HR case just waiting to happen.

@cancerstinks1

8 ай бұрын

I can totally see him having an “I AM A SURGEON!” Moment

@Lord-Emperor-Vader

8 ай бұрын

@@cancerstinks1 I would say he is the walking definition of a HR case but Johnny Bravo exists and he is the definition of an HR case

It's funny, during the third episode, I was wondering how die Syril Karn end up having such, for a lack of better words, overcompensating personality. Then the following episodes introduced his mother, and all question evaporate as it's obvious why Syril has severe emotional issues.

One of the solo twins would be really cool to see a video about

Spot-on characterization of Syril Karn as that guy at work who takes it more seriously than everyone else, and the conflicting sentiments a co-worker can feel about that kinda guy.

I love Syril because he's totally me.

@chasehedges6775

8 ай бұрын

Soooo true. He’s the Everyman

@eternalhistory4706

8 ай бұрын

He's just like me fr

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

Run away from that narc of a "mother". Run and go no-contact.

Honestly he’s one of the few characters I can’t decide on how I think about him

@texanplayer7651

8 ай бұрын

That's because he hasn't developed as a character yet. For now, we know only that he has an immense sense of zealotry and that he was unlucky to cross paths with Andor. Now his zealotry is turned into anger and revenge.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

I can and I like him. He's an immature officer who believes in justice and that if everyone did what they were supposed to do, the world would be perfect. That's why I can't be too harsh on him for being the only rent-a-cop who wants to do their job. He's just the right guy in the wrong place and time.

This guy is in every job and every military unit out there. There's always one. I recall guys like this in the military and just hating them 😂🤣 never could stand them but this is why the character is so great

@CornyBum

8 ай бұрын

These guys keep things _running!_ So long as they don't get too salty and outrank you D:

@Captain_Insano_nomercy

8 ай бұрын

@CornyBum they are always on a power trip and that often causes more issues than not. They are so grating that morale depletes and work slows

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

@@Captain_Insano_nomercyPartially, they're also the only ones making sure everyone has their shit so the whole unit doesn't get chewed out for losing it. Then again, my experience is these guys as butter bars.

@Captain_Insano_nomercy

8 ай бұрын

@Lobsterwithinternet there's a line for sure, I've just seen more guys over the line than under it. They are so oppressive that morale plummets and nobody gives a fuck to give 100% anymore. I see butterbars like that but also a lot of fresh corporals in the Marines. There's always one guy who when he picks up rank he becomes a complete douche

It was hard for me to grade him. Feels like there’s much to be revealed, and yet he is very 3 dimensional and crucial. Great comments and commentary here to offer additional perspective. I think it’s time for an Andor rewatch. It won’t be my first.

I think of Cereal Karn every day at breakfast when I douse him with milk. Poor guy. He should set his mom up to get arrested and jailed for a long time. Then he would have the house to himself. His father already ran to the other side of the galaxy to get away from her.

@MaxRamos8

8 ай бұрын

Absolute B that will go to an A if he ships with his waifu Dedra =)

@CornyBum

8 ай бұрын

Syril still believes that Dad's gonna return with the blue milk someday.

I liked that they left us wanting to know where the character is heading as well. Dedra seems to be cut from the same cloth. It will be interesting to see where both of them end up and not just for a shipping sake.

@MaxRamos8

8 ай бұрын

Absolute B that will go to an A if he ships with his waifu Dedra =)

@Daniel_Huffman

8 ай бұрын

While I would not be opposed to the two of them becoming something more, I wholeheartedly believe that it was a wise decision to not have this happen in Season 1. Syril's behavior towards Dedra, while certainly really creepy, is seemingly out of his reverence for her authority, and having their last appearance be Syril saving Dedra and telling her that she doesn't need to thank him was a good point to leave them at. Even in these circumstances, having the two develop healthy feelings for each other, even if only platonic, would have felt forced upon the audience and would have distracted from the chaotic riot going on around them.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

@@Daniel_HuffmanI think it's more of his reverence _for_ authority. That he sees her as a kindred spirit and what he wishes he can be. Especially when compared to what he sees as the lack of authority, initiative and justice with the Preox-Morlana rent-a-cops at the beginning of the show.

@Daniel_Huffman

8 ай бұрын

@@Lobsterwithinternet I think you worded that part better than I did. I'm going to leave my comment the way I did so that the context of yours is left intact. The incompetence displayed by Syril's coworkers reminds me of the flanderized depictions of the Empire that popped up in parodies so often that the official media decided to go along with it. (Now stormtroopers can't be taken seriously) I particularly remember the mention that they spelled "Ferrix" wrong in their mission report, given my personal adherence to proper grammar and spelling.

I think Zahn would appreciate a good writer like Tony Gilroy to write about Thrawn instead of trying to "fix" the character post-HOC with his interviews. Why is Filoni the only one allowed to hold EU characters hostage?

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

Because Darth felonius is Darth Kath-Leen´s apprentice. They are the W0ke Sith.

One day, fans will understand, that if the future of Star Wars is written like Andor, the the franchise will have a future.

@debelmeis2311

8 ай бұрын

Future of sleepy nap time

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

@@debelmeis2311Better than baby’s playtime.

@debelmeis2311

8 ай бұрын

@@Lobsterwithinternet sorry you forgot hoe to have imagination

The fall? Oh no. His star is about to rise. He's the hero of the show. At least for me.

The last comment hits hardest. Cyril is another A grade character from Andor. People might say it is not star wars, but too me Andor doesn't even need to be Star Wars tv show to be great. Star Wars needs Andor more than Andor Star Wars

This guy was still more competent than Thrawn in Ashoka

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

Because you can't write a character that's smarter than you are.

I really don't think Syril is a particularly bad guy. He's just a person trying to help the good guys (you know, the Empire) catch a cold-blooded murderer who brutally killed a couple of his (Syril's) co-workers. For this reason, I hope he switches sides in season two when he gets a firsthand view of the brutality of the Empire--you know, the "good guys". ...Or maybe I'm forgetting something really evil that he did. It's been a while since I watched the Andor series.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

To be honest, I hope he doesn't and we get an actual ‘good’ Imperial rather than either the psychopath or the bumbling moron we’ve seen since Disney took over Lucasfilm.

I think Syril was a very interesting character to show what someone in the imperium can be like without being totally evil. He surely wasn't the best character in the show, but a good side character in a very well written show. I would not say he is A-tier, but he is sure above average for what he needs to be in the show. So B-Tier seems about right for me as well. He is interesting and not one dimentional but relateable.

Deedra Meero

Syril is a regular guy with a dream of being somebody important or at least doing something important. He grew up on stories of the Clone Wars and he wants to be a hero, but he's just a nobody from nowhere on the wrong side of history. I want to see what he will do when his chance at greatness conflicts with his moral underpinnings. Is he evil or good? We don't know and thats what is appealing to us.

I just hope we get the same quality writing and directing in season 2

Thanks for a great well done video

He’s like an inept and charmless James Bond. He follows his jingoistic fervor but while Bond somehow always makes it work, Syril trips over his own feet.

I had a coworker who was known as a “blue falcon” because he would tell on our coworkers when they didn’t follow all the little rules like he did. He ended up being disliked by everyone in my department, got promoted into management, then left 2 months later due to getting a new job. He ruined all these relationships for a promotion that he ended up throwing away.

@CornyBum

8 ай бұрын

_[SHITBAG DETECTED]_ Haha, really though, while I tend to relate to guys who do things by the book and stuff, if he ended up that disliked on the whole, he was probably doing a few things wrong.

How is such a well-written, realistic character right above fanfic-tier trash like Bo-Karen (who should have rating refreshed because there was a revote) or Hera. Hell, how is Mara Jade under those dumpsterfires???

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

Simple: Most of the votes were from younger people who grew up with the Click me Wars cartoon and less on the books from the ‘90s.

What happened to the HK47 battle of the heroes?

An instant icon

Andor is all about regular but passionate people doing big things that'll have a ripple effect throughout the galaxy eventually. This isn't just exclusive to the rebels, as Dedra's insistence on 'connecting the dots' and rising above her coworker is another example, but of imperial passion. I think Syril's obsession with Dedra, eventually saving her from getting torn apart in the finale, is gonna have some big effects in Season 2. The two of them are gonna accomplish something potentially catastrophic for other characters (or themselves).

Paz Vizla next

Syril is not a bad guy... he thinks he is doing the right thing. He wants to bring justice... only in the sense to make him feel he is worth something and has control over his own destiny. Syril going from that private security force to the Empire makes sense because he doesn't see the politics behind it, he just sees it as a means to impose order and to make himself feel big and accomplished. Very relatable ideas.

One thing I'd love to see is Disney bringing Senator Garm into the canon.

I like how despite being pro-Empire, he is no Emperial at heart. If he was he'd just stay and do his job. He is a rebel at heart, wanting to go far and beyond what he knows.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

Just goes to show that the Empire is filled with all sorts and not just with either baby-eating psychopaths or ineffectual nameless grunts.

If anything Syril is the type of antagonist that doesn't get as much focus in Star Wars. Someone who naively believes in the strength of the Empire and that it means something good, even though it isn't. Honestly there isn't really any character I don't like in Andor. Even the villains are well thought out and executed. Hell even the minor characters are well thought and executed. That shot of the son who lost his father shedding tears after Maarva said that Ferrix was sleeping is one of the most heartbreaking shots in the show.

Syril Karn is a villain who in a different story would be a hero chasing a criminal. Sadly, he is enforcing the law of the Galactic Empire.

Thor said he is holding off on the HK-47 battle of the heroes and villains since he doesn’t think it will be an interesting video. So let’s make the next winner an even worse choice by making the three of these the three highest rated comments in case of an Admiral Blue Jeans incident so HK-47 is the topic of the next video. I have been busy and can’t always make it early on a video but I am asking all to help get these names commented and be the highest rated on each of these until HK-47's video is released. (Top) Senator Bail Antilles, (2nd) Pedrin Gaul (Red 5), (3rd) Captain Raymus Antilles.

@istari0

8 ай бұрын

No, let's not do that. Let's respect that this is Thor's channel and the final decision is his.

@user-yq9im9dk9z

8 ай бұрын

​@@istari0no, it's a democracy where we vote for characters, not a dictatorship

@Lord-Emperor-Vader

8 ай бұрын

@@istari0 The deal with this series is to get a video on the person who wins the vote the viewers want to see HK-47.

@TVforyourCats

8 ай бұрын

@@user-yq9im9dk9zno it’s actually the internet. Touch grass.

@istari0

8 ай бұрын

Did either of you create this channel? Have either of you made all the videos that are on it? No, you did not. I repeat, it is Thor's channel and the final decision is his.

Thor, what do you think of the idea that shows like Andor, that explore what it means to be an Evil Empire and who supports it (why would enyone, etc) is actually beyond the scope of Star Wars? All stories have a scope, the fact that the Empire is evil is a given of the setting well established by the storyteller in the original films. You're already dealing with things that do not, and CANNOT, exist. What then is the justification of pulling at that thread when there is a very real possibility that in doing so the whole 'sweater' might unravel and actually do damage to the internal logic of Star Wars?

@CornyBum

8 ай бұрын

This is an interesting question that I would have liked to see him pick and address in a video, though I have a good idea which side he'd fall on, because he's stated that he very much believes in keeping the Empire and Sith evil, while considering _Andor_ a masterpiece. I'm basically of the same opinion, except I think I'm less beholden to the notion that George Lucas should continue to have the final say in _Star Wars._ There is such a thing as good and evil in _Star Wars_ (and in life, I'd say), and I think it's best to stick to that, but there is so much that can make for rich storytelling by exploring the nature of something like oppression, fascism, rebellion, war, espionage, etc. that invites us to a more nuanced, understanding (and even sympathetic) look at the _Star Wars_ universe...without unraveling it all, as you say.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

By that notion, then there can be no new Star Wars as there is no place for it to go.

@kirkdarling4120

8 ай бұрын

There are numerous stories possible in the Star Wars universe, just as there have been many stories of Europe between 1910 and 1945, without any of them turning the Nazis into good guys even if some Germans are sympathetic.

Do Darth Zannah!

Syrill has serial killer vibes if you ask me

I suspect Syril will suffer further rejection and it will push him over the edge. He looks like an individual who will start shooting his co-worker's, but after killing his mother. The man is a walking time bomb.

Syril immediately reminded me of Dwight Shrute

Wicket.

Dang. Maybe I am Syril.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

Syril’s our guy.

How is Ahsoka in 53rd?? But otherwise I agree with Syril's ranking

@DavidWalker1987

8 ай бұрын

Because the Ahsoka show conflicted with TCWs/Rebels (and that it was at best, a very flawed season).

@fulcrum101

8 ай бұрын

@@DavidWalker1987 I agree that the Ahsoka show was flawed, but it's doesn't completely ruin her character. To say that she is below Jabba as a character is wild. She was near perfect in TCW and Rebels.

@cameronfarrell9076

8 ай бұрын

​@@fulcrum101what's interesting is how a good story and good writing can affect ones perception of a character. When I first heard that andor was going to be a show I thought it was a terrible idea to make a marvelized spinoff show about a forgettable side character from a spinoff movie that was also a prequel. But then I watched it and was amazed at how they managed to get me so invested in casian. Compare that to ahsoka, where they took my favorite star wars character and turned me off caring about what was happening in the show and where her story is going.

@DavidWalker1987

8 ай бұрын

@@cameronfarrell9076 Agree 100%. The characters in Andor are actual human beings and the plot has been checked and double checked and a zillionth checked to the point where everything works... compare that to the characters in Ahsoka / BoBF / Obi Wan... its just laughable. @fulcrum101 Luke Skywalker pre TLJ. Near perfect character / character arc. Luke Skywalker post TLJ. Horrible character arc ... with TLJ ruining the character for me and many other people. Ahsoka S1 is the same (but to a lesser degree as Ahsokas character arc isnt finished etc). The second season better have actual fucking dialogue and structure and plot ... and Thrawn had better not be lobotomised again ... because if they dont, the entire era theyre trying to create... stalls before its even started. Tbh it might already be too late - but like a domestic abuse victim i keep coming back to SWs hoping they get their shit together.

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

IMO she has always been overrated fanfic character who was only so high previously because of childhood nostalgia. She is a Mary Sue written for kids, doesn´t translate well into live action and the Ahsoka show was trash. She is definitelly worse character than Jabba. Jabba has a purpose in the story, he´s not shoehorned into it and doesn´t screw the canon and lore. Nobody hammered timetravel nonsense into SW just to save him from the death.

5:00 I mean the civilians who worked the gas chambers in the holocaust said the same thing... It also got them off scot free because "I was just following orders." is the perfect excuse IRL... the Wills may hate it in the star wars galaxy but the evildoers on Earth love it.

@GreenBlueWalkthrough

8 ай бұрын

Which the guy is just obsessive not evil as what has he done that was in the least bit bad?

This guy has a more consistent character than garbage like Darth Maul and Baylan Skoll 😂

Dwight Schrute

Syril feels a bit incel coded. I dunno, his scenes with Deidre just felt like him latching onto the first woman who gave him the time of day which probably would leave a huge impact given his home life

It's difficult to rank a guy like Syril because he is so much an average dude who is kinda a bit of a loser, down on his luck guy with a real confidence issue... I love the character but at the same time how does one rank this character in a pantheon of awesome characters who are larger than life versus an average schmoe? I suspect a B is the right place.

Hahahahahahahaha

Where is HK-47?

Where’s the HK-47 video?

@TVforyourCats

8 ай бұрын

He’s not making it. Are you going to be ok?

@darthvenamis1396

8 ай бұрын

@@TVforyourCats I’m ok with continuing to ask him for the video. Are you ok with scrolling past the other comments asking for HK-47?

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

@@TVforyourCats Why? He made several KK and DiSSney bull**** videos but he didn´t have a time to make the HK-47 video? He made videos for every other character who was rated. Even those from the sequels, or other characters from games who are not so well-known. So why not HK-47? It seems like trolling at this point.

@darthvenamis1396

8 ай бұрын

@@Mouse_Metalword. And it’s not even the fact that it’s taking so long that I find stupid. It’s the fact that he’s actively skipping HK-47 and not explaining why that’s so ridiculous

Please do Chopper ! C1-10P

I'll be perfectly honest, I forgot who this guy was supposed to be for the longest time.

The book Lost Stars I think did a better job than anything in Andor about good people working for the Empire.

Can we get some nemec content? Holy shit a socialist dreamer in star wars yay! q No, but he is a good character.

Absolute B that will go to an A if he ships with his waifu Dedra =)

I have typed it before and I must type it again. I hate, hate, hate Syril. I have zero interest in him. I truly cannot stand him I will probably fast forward nearly all of his scenes in season 2. 😡👎

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

He is an natagonist. If you hate an antagonist or if you are conflicted about them, it means the writer is doing something right. If you hate the pseudocharacter who is supposed to be the her-o it means the writer is a hack.

looking over the ratings table. it's pretty condemning of the ST that 8 out of the 10 worst characters are from it, down with Jar Jar. Poor Sabine got abused by y'all. Don't understand the hate for Barriss - she was one of the more interesting characters from the CW . . . and Quinlan also - how can he be rated so badly? Y'all are schizophrenic, I think, lol.

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

If everyone else seems schizophrenic to you, chances are it´s you who is actually schizophrenic. :D Dangerhair Wren belongs even lower, people were still too nice to that fanfic-tier Mary Sue abomination. Also, calling a low rating of a FICTIONAL CHARACTER abuse is distasteful and disrespectful to all real victims of abuse. People are chronically too nice on Felony´s trash OCs because of nostalgia for those animated shows for kids, so stop complaining. Bo-Karen belongs at the very end because she is an unique type of Mary Sue - a villain who keeps falling upwards and is treated like a hero by the plot which bends into a triple pretzel around her. She is not even a character, she is whaamen can do nothing wrong ag3nda. Mara Jade, the female character who was on the villains´ side and became good, the character who is everything Bo-Karen is supposed to be according to Felony but isn´t, is lower than Bo-Karen. Barris is low because TCW ruined her for those who knew her from the "legends" material which was written before TCW. The most of sequels characters are just bad or so underused it´s hard to rate them, so people give them low rating.

Syril Karn is nothing more than a predictable and annoying gadfly who has done nothing more than make this sleeper series more 🥱. Why he received such a high ranking leads me to believe that most voters are just easily led by the Vote of the Week...

@FlymanMS

8 ай бұрын

Or maybe you are not getting it because you are used to cool laser saber pew pew space battle stuff in SW

@Robert_Westwood

8 ай бұрын

@@FlymanMS , cool story, bro...

@Mouse_Metal

8 ай бұрын

Go back to Rebels, that´s the type of writing aimed at you.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

@@Mouse_MetalMore like Ewoks. The cartoon show.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

@@Robert_WestwoodVery cool story. Shame you couldn't stay up through it to watch.

He's not a villain, he's just a guy in a situation, trying to do what he thinks is right based on the information he has. He's also a rebel, in that he is willing to put himself at risk and violate Imperial law in order to do (what he thinks is) the right thing. I think the character is ripe for eventually seeing the truth of what the Empire is, and eventually joining the Rebel Alliance.

@Lobsterwithinternet

8 ай бұрын

Maybe, but I'm honestly tired of another ‘Imperial joining the Rebels’ story and would prefer if he remained a ‘good’ Imperial but sacrificed himself in the finale to save Cassian’s life or to save some innocent people.