Gabon way way WAYYYY to low

With so many top-heavy casts, you’d think Kat has returned 10 or so times

@sethbryant5539

Жыл бұрын

Lol

@Cris-qm3yu

Жыл бұрын

HWHABEBW I’m dead😭

Gabon being low is kinda insane but aside from that I respect the ranking

@SB-jq8jj

Жыл бұрын

Gabon is one of the best casts of all time for me. Even the “duds” have their moments

@ryanarostegui3677

Жыл бұрын

@@SB-jq8jj W

@ThePPQQ1

Жыл бұрын

I like Gabons cast but I can understand why others wouldn't

@rajorajo7429

Жыл бұрын

@@ThePPQQ1 yeah but he literally said gameplay is the least important aspect and characters are the most important. Gabon is easily top 10 in terms of characters

@NYChica23

Жыл бұрын

@@rajorajo7429 Facts...this is a season where you'll be underwhelmed if you're looking for gameplay, but if you want pure entertainment/memorable characters, Gabon is pretty high up there

You know it's gonna be good when it's over an hour long 😍🔥

@eastonburnor4018

Жыл бұрын

Exactly lol

@GangstTheEr

Жыл бұрын

You guys should collaborate!

@BanditSurvivorContent

Жыл бұрын

@@GangstTheEr myself and BLM?

@GangstTheEr

Жыл бұрын

@@BanditSurvivorContent yeah you guys are both awesome

@BanditSurvivorContent

Жыл бұрын

@@GangstTheEr I mean I'm happy collab with anyone ☺️ I just don't think Meranian does many collabs (to my knowledge) but you never know!

Gabon cast being slept on

How do you not even mention Kenny for Gabon?

Tbh whenever I think of Gabon, Gillian is one of the first people I remember so idk what you are talking about

HOW DARE YOU PUT GABON THAT LOW

babe wake up meranianreview uploaded

Having one world above Caramoan is like saying Colton is more fun to watch than Cochran or Malcolm or Andrea or Dawn or Brenda or Erik or Eddie or Reynold or Phillip or Matt or even shamar. Respectfully Caramoan is too low.

Nah the HvV cast is WAY better than the WaW cast.

@sarapesenacker4781

Жыл бұрын

No.

@bdj2896

Жыл бұрын

All winers!

@kalebdunaway

Жыл бұрын

@@sarapesenacker4781 I’m actually right, factually.

@kalebdunaway

Жыл бұрын

@@bdj2896 All winners is cool and all, but HvV has a way better cast even without all of the winners. Most of the new school winners were pretty lame, while almost everyone in HvV was great.

I think Drea had enough bitterness she overtook the entire 41 cast

How you gonna not mention Kenny with Gabon. Best character on the season. Good list though

I feel like Kelly Czarnecki is an underrated funny character

@uglyaniimals

Жыл бұрын

agreed, i would've rly liked her to at least get a mention on the "worst players of all time" list. legitimately one of the few people i can think of who is a 0/10 socially, strategically, AND physically

My personal take on your rankings: - Samoa too low - I feel like even Yasmin/Ben are memorable due to their arguments, Marisa as a first boot fighting against Russell, players like Dave Ball and Shambo vs Laura M - Redemption Island too high - Zapatera might be good players but not entertaining people (except for Ralph), Ometepe really boring aside from Phillip. - Gabon wayy to low - gameplay is so erratic and that comes from the entertainment value of the players - Gillian was memorable, we have great villains in Ace, Marcus, Randy, Corinne, there's Crystal and Kenny running the game, and Sugar having so much power, etc - 41 too high - this cast will soon become forgettable - the pre-mergers are really not big games and the only memorable merge players are Shan and Ricard. I'm struggling to remember many other players and it only aired last year.

@sawyerscheitler6416

Жыл бұрын

Agree with all these!

@simonbaumgartle6357

Жыл бұрын

I agree with 41. We were so hungry for new Survivor that we were excited at anything!

I love listening to your videos / podcasts while I wind down for bed. I can tell that some of your favorite players / seasons are some of my least favorite and Vice versa, but of course some of them we agree on. But it’s still fun to listen to. Figi is one of my favorite casts but Thailand and Caramoan and One world are my bottom three so it’s fun to see that we still agree on a lot of stuff. Agree that every season has at least one fun character (we even had Shii Ann in Thailand). So much of how we interpret a cast has to do with the edit / the content they get, for better or for worse. I was glad to hear you give Russell Swan / Shambo / some of the lesser edited players their flowers on Samoa. Honestly I liked how you tried to say some positive things about every season because it’s true that even on a “bad cast” there was at least one memorable / fun player each season. “Lacking fun” is the best way to put my finger on exactly why I hate Game Changers so much despite some of my all time favorite players being on the cast. It’s just not fun. I feel like by editing Sarah the way they did and sort of hiding her game they made her more unlikeable. I found her a lot more humanized in WaW. She felt kind of robotic like Spencerbot to me this season.

Really good video and I agree with most of your ranking. You should do a video where you go through how 41 and 42 fit into all your rankings and what if scenarios that they weren't a part of.

It's crazy that people could ever not like your vids with the amount of work you put in. Massive respect BLM.

@ehar8058

Жыл бұрын

I love your videos too! Keep up the good work

@FlynnMasters

Жыл бұрын

@@ehar8058 thank you so much !

Your the best survicor content creator OMG I get so hyped when you upload

How could you not mention GC on Gabon?

Great ranking!

@Itsmeraccoon is going to be mad about Gabon's placement

Would you ever consider dream casting/ realistic casting of second Chance 2 with players only post 31? I would LOVE to see it!

idk what it is about it but i love guatemalas cast, I think Jamie vs Bobby Jon was extremely entertaining along with the main 3 characters of the season, I think it had some duds but they all left very early so it just left off in a good note to me

Love the videos! Favorite KZreadr

Gabon is easily top 10 for me, what a blindside at #33

How is Carter forgettable. He was literally in a grocery story, stole milky ways

whenever you do the initial preface before you reveal the season, I pause the video and try to guess which one you’re talking about 😅 I guessed right a couple times! This was a good video idea 👍🏻

@MKWIIJACOB

Жыл бұрын

I do the same haha

@phobiccobra991

Жыл бұрын

I usually get them right in any player rankings

Honestly I loved the returnees of caramoan

@WilsonReviews

Жыл бұрын

Me too. Caramoan is extremely underrated, especially the cast

really the one thing i learned from this video is we need brain vs brawn vs beauty 3

44:50 you’re breaking my part, snubbed from top 10, my baby.

Gabon's cast was rockin' in my opinion

A big brother one would be neat too!!

@pandumb7060

Жыл бұрын

This

I completely agree with the ranking of Kaoh Rong. I don’t think there’s a single person from that cast I don’t remember.

very good list

Definitely one of your better rankings 🤪Agree with most of your rankings, the only huge changes on my list are 41 and 42 both in my top 5, DVG is above Cagayan, and ghost island is a lot lower.

@joeertman

Жыл бұрын

41 AND 42 both in top 5!!?? Are you sure that’s not recency bias?

@uglyaniimals

Жыл бұрын

@@joeertman idk if i'd put them both top 5 but 42 is easily top 10 and i think 41 is close to that as well

@joeertman

Жыл бұрын

@@uglyaniimals ok that’s a bit easier to understand lmao

@Cons-hh5ef

Жыл бұрын

41 is bottom tier

You should do a top ten characters of all time

Could you do for What if Winners vs Biggest Jury Threats? Interesting to see how dominate some winners really are

@grantgoffin4774

Жыл бұрын

These are the only winners who would beat the biggest jury threats. Season 10- Tom Season 11- Danni Season 14- Earl (maybe, he even might lose to Yau) Season 15- Todd Season 18- JT Season 24- Kim Season 29- Natalie A Season 30- Mike (maybe, might lose to Tyler) Season 31- Jeremy (maybe, might lose to Kelley, Keith, or Kimmi in fact) Season 36- Wendell (since he already did) Season 40- Tony

I love that the overwhelming amount of comments are in defense of the Gabon cast. The hilarity of that cast makes that season great. If not for that set of characters there wouldn’t be many redeeming parts of that season in terms of good television

Let’s go

1. HvV (20) 2. WaW (40) 3. FvF 1 Micronesia (16) 4. All stars (8) 5. Cagayan BvBvB 1 (28) 6. DvG (37) 7. Second chance Cambodia (31) 8. China (15) 9. BvW 1 (27) 10. Worlds apart (30) 11. EoE (38) 12. Philippines (25) 13. Game changers (34) 14. Kaôh Rōng BvBvB 2 (32) 15. The Australian outback (2) 16. Borneo (1) 17. Season 42 18. HvHvH (35) 19. BvW 2 San Juan del sur (28) 20. Pearl islands (7) 21. IOFI (39) 22. Ghost island (36) 23. Africa (3) 24. MvG (33) 25. Tocantins (18) 26. Season 41 27. Marquesas (4) 28. Nicaragua (21) 29. Gabon (17) 30. Cook Islands (13) 31. FvF 2 Caramoan (26) 32. Panama - Exile Island (12) 33. The Amazon (6) 34. Vanuatu (9) 35. South Pacific (23) 36. Redemption island (22) 37. Guatemala (11) 38. Palau (10) 39. Samoa (19) 40. Thailand (5) 41. Fiji (14) 42. One world (24) This is my ranking , honestly really really surprised by some of your picked tho I must say I didn’t includ legacy as a criterion, I just thought counted the really really bad ppl and legends and by the HvV beat WaW by 11-9 and I just thought who I wanna see play again more

@nadavamrami1702

Жыл бұрын

היי ישראלי, 😏 לדעתי הקאסט של קאגאיאן יותר טוב משל מיקרונזיה. גם את הקאסט של טוקנטינס הייתי מדרג יותר גבוה. כן, בגדול שני הקאסטים של 20 ו40 הם שני הקאסטים הכי טובים.

Shain't no way he put Worlds Apart at 14

@heykraizelburd

Жыл бұрын

I KNOW! It’s honestly bottom 5, easily. Unlikeable, forgettable cast that made for a sour, unsatisfying season.

Survivor 42 is a top 10 cast stop being a hater of fun

switch worlds apart and gabon for a near perfect list 👍

Forget free Brittany. FREE JENNY FROM NOT COMING BACK

38:18 DAWSON IS ICONIC (albeit underedited) TAKE THAT BACK

South Pacific criminally underrated. Below Nicaragua??? Prince Albert, invisible Rick, Edna and her hats, Christine on RI, Jim Rice, "You disgust me" Whitney, Semhar's spoken word... I can name more of this cast than Nicaragua and ghost island, and the characters have more notable moments

@queenzoroark

Жыл бұрын

Tyrone, Jimmy T, Wendy Jo, Fabio, NaOnka, Purple Kelly and Jane Not-so-Bright and Marty "Chessmaster" Piombo are better than most ypu just mentioned.

@alexbenedict1879

Жыл бұрын

Agree I love Jim Whitney Stacey and Mikaela and it’s a top 10 season for me 🥶

You should rank every location

Bro, ik u might never do it, but if you ever rank every single player in the game.... Everyone's mind will be completely blown, but that's a lot of fucking work 😭♥️

Micelle Yi was also a grate casting

Cook Islands needs to be higher!!!

“The likes of Colton”

My predictions before watching the video 1. Winners at War 2. Heroes vs. Villains 3. Cagayan 4. China 5. David vs. Goliath 6. Kaôh Rōng 7. Micronesia 8. Philippines 9. Millennials vs. Gen X 10. Cambodia 11. 41 12. All-Stars 13. Pearl Islands 14. Tocantins 15. Blood vs. Water 16. Edge of Extinction 17. Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers 18. 42 19. Panama 20. San Juan del Sur 21. Ghost Island 22. Island of the Idols 23. Worlds Apart 24. Game Changers 25. Borneo 26. Guatemala 27. Nicaragua 28. South Pacific 29. Samoa 30. Fiji 31. Caramoan 32. Gabon 33. Cook Islands 34. Redemption Island 35. Africa 36. Marquesas 37. Palau 38. Amazon 39. Vanuatu 40. Australian Outback 41. One World 42. Thailand

I'd swap Vanuatu and SJDS but I think I agree with everything else. I just feel like SDJS had too many memorable boots for the duds to drag it down so far

@nizzle428

Жыл бұрын

yeah and i feel like it has one of the stronger groups of pre merge characters. val, john, drew, and even dale all had entertaining downfalls

Sir do you even sleep

@bigbrotherspoilers9756

Жыл бұрын

a video twice a week lol

Prediction before I watch the video: Thailand 42 One World 41

In Palau Angie Jakusz was a standout character. Sad she never returned, and now she is dead.

Austrian outback has Jerri Colby Tina Varner Alicia Amber Kimmi Keith Elizabeth And you put it that low

My friends mom was in survivor season 1

Tired now isn't it, my favorite casts are Africa's, China's ,Gabon's and HvV's

I agree no duds in survivor Cagayan

Wonder of Angelina would get the jacket?

i prefer original cast seasons over all star ones: best ones are pearl islands, australia, cook islands, cagayan, eoe, gabon, phillipines, milgenx....worst are samoa, RI1, thailand, one world, ghost island, 42 (all type a personalities. not an interesting social experiment) every other cast is like a 7.5-8.5/10. enjoyable, but not special. the best all star season is HvV by a mile.

Hey, just started watching with fiji cause yauman seemed cool, means there's only ups from here, coming from hell's kitchen i definitely got some hk season 13 vibes, in there being one stand out character, a couple somewhat memorable people and the vast majority be completely forgettable

Don’t understand how 41 and 42 are up the Philippines

14:33 bob only memorable bc hes old lolololol

1:00:06 I was thinking the same exact word lol

30:36 why is like everyone wearing a hat in the africa cast pic

Rank every big brother player that came back in the game after already being evicted like Kaysar, Judd, Victor etc.

@bigbrotherspoilers9756

Жыл бұрын

victoria who im having a brain fart

@ethanuy2261

Жыл бұрын

@@bigbrotherspoilers9756 Typo my bad

Redemption Island not being in the bottom 5 seasons is almost criminal. world's apart is too high also imo

26:29 its val not vel

How is pearl islands this low

Nicaragua is so high for no reason, definitely a bottom 3 cast.

Did he Forget Michelle Yi Season 14

Fiji in 42? Sure some of them are forgettable, but Yao-Man, Rocky and Dreamz, were great

Thailand for 1

hard disagree abt samoa being so low when it has legends like shambo and danger dave (who answers the age old question of "if coach and tyson had a love child, what in god's name would that child be like ???) i also think yasmin is an underrated trainwreck with some great confessionals and erik is a pretty solid narrator. russell is great too but is only the third best character of the season and it's a shame that the edit gave him such massive amounts of airtime at the expense of literally everyone else

@bigbrotherspoilers9756

Жыл бұрын

dave is a legend?

Finally someone else who recognizes how bad Gabon's cast was. Only thing is you were way too easy on them.

Putting Redemption Island that high alone is criminal. Redemption Island should be dead last.

Panama being that high is insane, outside of the Casaya 6 plus Terry the cast is very forgettable.

So happy Koh Rong got ranked so highly. My favorite Newbie cast

Cook Islands How is it lower then 30 its Top tier

I know I’m probably in the minority but I would put 41 near the bottom. While you have some really interesting characters on the season with pretty interesting storylines I just find the cast as a whole so unlikeable & likability has to be a big factor & I don’t think a single person on that cast was very likeable whatsoever

How on earth is WaW ahead of HvV, Cagayan, and DvG

@chasedaniels7314

Жыл бұрын

This is satire right? No hate I’m just wondering how a cast full of some of the best players ever wouldn’t be there over a bunch of casts that still have MANY misses

@seanberrodin801

Жыл бұрын

@@chasedaniels7314 nah, the problem with WaW is that great players don't mean great characters. When looking at a cast I think character trumps all else. Even the bad players on DvG, Cagayan, and HvV have good confessionals, fun arcs, and a good spirit among other castmates. WaW (in my opinion) has too many cast members who aren't the best at confessional and don't have the screen presence of some of the best survivor castaways.

My ranking (of seasons I have fully watched) just based on personal preference before watching: 1. WaW 2. HvV 3. Cambodia 4. DvG 5. Cagayan 6. Game Changers 7. 41 8. EoE 9. Micronesia 10. MvGX 11. IoTI 12. 42 13. SJDS 14. Kaoh Rong 15. Philippines 16. HHH 17. China 18. Tocantins 19. Panama 20. BvW 21. Cook Islands 22. Ghost Island 23. Borneo (don't hate me) 24. Nicaragua 25. Gabon 26. Caramoan 27. Redemption Island 28. South Pacific 29. Worlds Apart 30. Samoa (barring literally 2 people) 31. Fiji 32. One World (so easy to hate)

@tonyvlachosfan

Жыл бұрын

41 top 7 😬

@simeonfrancis6751

Жыл бұрын

41 over 42 lmao check out your eyes

@tonyvlachosfan

Жыл бұрын

@@simeonfrancis6751 I’m confused what you mean. I can see you have 41 over 42

This is all subjective and I genuinely enjoyed watching this…but Redemption Island is far, far too high.

Wanda = robbed goddess 👸

Spencer wasn't a likeable person despite being gameplay position. Joe pretty much the same thing

Koah Rong too high

My list from worst to best: 42, Amazon 41, Fiji 40, Thailand 39, Guatemala 38, Nicaragua 37, Vanuatu 36, Palau 35, Samoa 34, Ghost island 33, One World 32, RI 31, South Pacific 30, WA 29, Gabon 28, Caramoan 27, Australian outback 26, Africa 25, Panama 24, Island of the idols 23, 41 22, Cook island 21, 42 20, Game changers 19, Marquesas 18, Tocantins 17, SJDS 16, Pearl island 15, Borneo 14, All Stars 13, MvG 12, Kaoh Rong 11, EoE 10, Cagayan 9, China 8, HHH 7, BvW 6, Micronesia 5, Philippines 4, WaW 3, Cambodia 2, DvG 1, HvV

I feel like survivor aus 2-5 would be super high on this list

@sammo2560

Жыл бұрын

Don’t agree about All Stars but agree about season 2 (2017), one of the best reality tv casts ever. Literally every character who makes merge is fantastic.

@Iukeafk

Жыл бұрын

@@sammo2560 you don't think so? Au all-stars is basically same as Us all stars, fantastic cast, couldn't be better, but one guy brought the duds to the end

@uglyaniimals

Жыл бұрын

@@sammo2560 pete ? ziggy ? also has odette who strikes me as an all time stinker of a casting decision (i guess minus people who are actively bad people since she seems nice enough)

@sammo2560

Жыл бұрын

@@uglyaniimals even Ziggy had iconic moments. Pete is likeable even if he’s not super memorable. Do agree about Odette she’s very bland.

Brett Clouser forgotten by production and BLM lmao

Ghost island is way to high. Literally other than Dom, Wendell, Chris, and Michael are nobodies.

Samoa? At 38? No

@lukassvoboda4107

Жыл бұрын

Yeah... Ben and Yasmin are terrible choice. Only Russell S and H, Laura and Shambo are intresting character. Samoa is really bad season because of edit. If you like Russ H, you liked Samoa. But for People who dont like Russ Samoa is terrible😅

You keep using the word "icky".

i personally dont love the koah rong cast

EoE has such an amazing cast and is also the best season ever (Hot take I know but I'm dead serious) I respect ur opinion tho

I understand but Heroes vs Villains is number 1

First

41 is wayyyyy to high. Terrible cast. Otherwise good list