Arrest was illegal says SC. This is what we call undeclared emergency in India.

Shame. What about making the govt. responsible for putting him in jail wrongfully. Imagine the plight of the common man who does not have the privilege of representing him.

How will dr. Purukasyastha be compensated for illegal detention. Those responsible for this act should be made to serve double time in prison, so that they don’t repeat this on other citizens. THEY MUST BE PUNISHED. THEY MUST BE PUNISHED . THEY MUST BE PUNISHED.

thank God, SC didn't take years to do this

@maureensamson4863

17 күн бұрын

That it even happens is bad enough ....

Looks like the rest of the courts have all gone to sleep. Why is it none of the courts are able to see such simple stuff earlier ?

This has become a pattern partly because those responsible for wrongful arrests are not held accountable. There is no compensation for the loss of time, health and opportunities. If there was a fine for such arrests, there would be probably fewer people behind bars without a good reason.

it took so much time to declare his arrest illegal ? democracy has become an ass

Now who will be held responsible for this patently illegal custody? How can the Home Minister be Not responsible?

I can now sympathize puryakastha

Who is going to compensate for this illegal arrest; time spent in jail; tarninishig his image .

The News click Founder and the senior journalist should be paid a heavy compensation, and the culprits should be punished for the injustice done.

and who will give him back his time...and his mental health

Shameless home minister and NIA and RAW head. They shd hand their head in shame

Justice being contaminated is fact of life all over world

Supreme court need such long time to comprehend wrong doings . BUT same court get it before time in Arnab Goswami's case . What great court we have .

Shameful act.

Banana republic = India Not even opposition talks about bringing law to punish officers and pay compensation for wrongful arrest. All parties want to enjoy the benefits of loopholes in justice system

yes , the process is the panishment. SC should come heavy on the agencies so that this is not repeated.

@A4Aqua

17 күн бұрын

Coming "heavily" on the agencies orally is not going to be of any consequence.

@maureensamson4863

17 күн бұрын

The arrest of people on flimsy grounds and false evidence is not something new...

When the Hon SC directed his release, why didn't they simultaneously slap heavy penalties on all concerned with this illegality? That would have at least stopped this sort of witch-hunting by the govt.

@kareemkhan-hv1yp

17 күн бұрын

SC is also part of fooling game of common Indian....you arrest and keep them behind bars and we will release them once a lesson in taught to him...SC and Government have been fooling common Indian since decades but more frequently in the last 10 years

This once again demonstrates abuse of power considering due process is not followed. Would the persons behind his arrest subject themselves to similar adhoc procedures involving imprisonment? When the crooked rule, such grave offences by the State will be common. The crooked should never be given power if human well being is to be secure.

Why should the head of arresting agency not be made to pay crores as compensation??and a jail term

There is a huge difference between ujjal ni…. & $ Sanjay Hegde

If it is illegal then who is responsible and what punishment is justified against him/them ?

Then the officials must be punished. They must be accountable. Otherwise this menace will continue to settle scores. All know news click always critical of govt

All these examples only assert the fact that we are a banana republic... The PMLA, UAPA etc arrested and jailed if declared innocent.. The arresting authorities and judges should be send to non bailable retension.

@avgopalan2761

17 күн бұрын

Absolutely Sir, …Judiciary is also biased in favour of the ruling government and party in any state…!! How many can go to Supreme Court to get justice……

Amazing!

Thanks for the justice and what a way to describe our Supreme Court.Come what may because of the judgement you are coming out with this news.God's Supreme. ❤

In each of such judgement of exoneration, the judgement,if there is any, should mention at what stage error occurred in wrongly arresting the individual so that future course of action can follow. Otherwise such cases will go on recurring.

Thank you Faye and Mr.Hegde

What is Magistrate court doing? these trial courts and Magistrate courts have become just a formality. Every issue needs SC to resolve it or grant justice. These judges when found not delivering justice to this level of granularity, the SC has to take action. Send them back to training or some action. Here there is no question of interpretation of law wherein the judges may differ, here its a procedural lapse and the Magistrate has not observed it!!!!!

@alexwilliam5627

17 күн бұрын

Who is that Magistrate, at least Bar council need to take action against him.

Wonderful session Faye

I think , anyone in custody without basis must be given compensation

EVEN SINNERS HAVE FUTURE..... It's is GEM of SC observation..

Shame shame

Shyam rangeela and other independent candidates....this case should be taken up.. remember Distinguished Gentleman

Keep up your good work. Thank you!

Brilliant Sanjay Hegde!

Keep up the good work

Are those Delhi Police officials punished?

Awesome 😊

Wow great news that’s democracy- lovely - freedom of speech upheld.

Unfortunately the Umer Khalid Q was left unanswered .

Its time for the PEOPLE Of India;1.4 Billion should now STAND UP and fight.. all Democratic ..enjoying Democracy rights and freedom of People; Playing with rights of People.. misusing/abusing:Police/CBI/IT/ED and on and on.. This must STOP.

The standard and quality of Magistrates in the lower courts is abysmally low. Its been for a long time that the need for raising the standard of the bar was required to conduct exam in line with the UPSC , but that's been pending for long. Judiciary exam should be held in line with medical, engineering and other disciplines on All lndia basis. NLU'S were established to raise the standard of our judiciary, but unfortunately students passing out from the top NLU'S opt for other avenues. The void of good advocates is therefore fulfilled by a large no of private law colleges approved by the BCI producing third grade lawyers for whom the accused person don't get access to quality lawyers.

Where else would a supreme court advocate share his knowledge 🤌 i love these legal/professional discussions

What u r saying Sanjay hegde is that you all lawyers and judges don't understand law at all.. and if you did u all dont follow law. It's a shame for our judiciary!!

Shame. Supreme Court cheers

Imagine the appreciations of ordinary citizen who has no connection etc while dealing with police and powerful people. They simply choose to be silent. Among 200 nations, India is way behind in giving its citizens a good system to live.

@4Nevyn

17 күн бұрын

There are number of people who are in jail for years like this. No one talks about it because there is no one talking about them. When they finally get released it is after 10-20 years. They are just happy to be out and sit with their head down. That is the reality of minorities in our country.

Sometime seems our supreme Court some judges are the only source of justice for indians.

Sad then what will happen to Common people

This is crazy

Good afternoon. A rather, very, quite,.."welcome", move.

Faye. What about Mahesh batt,( if am not wrong )former DGP of Gujarat i hope who tweeted against modi. . Is there anyone helping him to get bail, for a long time he is in jail.

@marianfurtado7495

17 күн бұрын

It's Sanjiv Bhatt and I agree there should be a fair representation for him as he's in jail for carrying out his duty. It's a which hunt which is keeping him in jail. I want him to be set free. Why can't the SC take cognisance? They're his only recourse

@ebenezerking475

17 күн бұрын

@@marianfurtado7495 yes yes correct, thanks for making it clear. It's a long time he is in jail, for just to said the truth. Maybe there someone is trying.

Many poor Remand Prisoners are not served any paper. Most of the magistrates are mechanical.

Now they say it? ☹️🥺😡

All judgements shd be propagated

It would be better if Faye doesn't rock herself whilst reading or speaking.

❤

Now I do not believe all this heresay

Your vlogs are very informative and i always watch. However, you need to improve your sound quality please

This is has been happening routinely and increasingly especially in the past 5 years. Is the Supreme Court so busy that it is not able to SEE this happening. Does it have to come up specifically in the SC for relief?

@user-kj9vw9jd8i

13 күн бұрын

Thank god he is given justice God bless the sc

Absolutely 💯 agree. Corrupt MoAdani🩴is dictatorial at its core. Panauti 💩MoAdani is such a loser🩴 IITian 🇮🇳 UPSC Topper Arvind Kejriwal ji 🌞 Prime Minister 2024 hai❤️🇮🇳I❤️Arvind Kejriwal ji🇮🇳Arvind Kejriwal ji 🇮🇳🌞 ka Education Health Transportation aur Infrastructure development model🙏

In a world of universal deception telling the truth is a revolution.

JO MANMANI SE BINA RULE KE ARREST KAR LE US AGENCY KO JAIL KYUN NAHIN KARTI SUPREME COURT ..HIGHLY OBJECTIONABLE ..DO U HEAR SC ..WHAT IS DETERENCE FOR THESE CULPRIT GOVT AGENCIES ACTING AT WILL...

Now India looks like Modi Govt. V/s SC what's happening in our country?

My question is, how come politicians can do what ever they want. Why cant its possible to stop them, even after we have reached the 75 years of Independence.why not any of our institutions (supreme Court) can bring strict laws even if it tamper the integrity of the country. Is it not shame.

There is hope in this country; 😊🎉

Banana Republic

To borrow a phrase from a movie, I happened to've witnessed, in the near past -" We happen to be, not in the businesses of justice. Rather of, law". Does there exist anything, under the sun, perhaps in, the whole of existence and beyond, farther, further,..which has somehow been able to've escaped the jurisdiction of stupidity, inefficiency, incompetence,.. (the) purview of, "commodification". Also, just to add, people across the wildest possible range of occupations, professions,..should be able look, see, view,..things beyond, the prism of salary, fee,..rise to a higher motivation, drive,..and act, or, have acted, in accordance with it, the same/identical,..

Being a firm believer in liberty in full sense of word , glad super court has released the man . Will those who were criticizing SC , now go back on their back foot .

@maureensamson4863

17 күн бұрын

They declare bias !

Did you and Mr Hegde defend the arrest of Arnab Goswami ?

@evilandrew1097

17 күн бұрын

Suprised that Anti-national Goswami is not still in jail

@SPVerma-mr8dh

17 күн бұрын

@@evilandrew1097 Put him in jail. The entire eco system is yours.

@evilandrew1097

17 күн бұрын

@@SPVerma-mr8dh I am not an andhbhakt and BJP will never put there puppet arnab in jail ever

@evilandrew1097

17 күн бұрын

@@SPVerma-mr8dh As long as BJP is in power he will enjoy freedom

This only happens under failed criminal Saffron BJP governance.

PM has become a redundant senile monster for power

😂 enjoy reales of sino wahabi lobby