I like it... not everyone has to sing as Bartoli, each one has her personal style, and that is all what music is about.

@poppya54

2 жыл бұрын

Sorry, she has an ampty style.

@alexalvear7722

Жыл бұрын

Si totalmente cierto. Aunque de igual manera tanto Bartoli como Sumijo lo hacen espectacularmente cada una a su estilo

@camilaminuzzizanchetta1816

Жыл бұрын

I agree, both (Bartoli and Sumi Jo) are great and I love both renditions 😍❤

@cguzmmang

11 ай бұрын

No, esta musica debe cantarse como está escrita.

@user-dq8fj5vu4q

10 ай бұрын

​​​@@cguzmmangthis is mezzo soprano song. You have to know that

Stupenda! Mi piace molto queste arie vivace! E anche l'abito è un'opera d'arte.

Now that’s what an actual good sound opera should sound like!!! Well supported, transparent, no wobbly voice or unstable tone,

Sumi Jo versetzt mich immer wieder neu in Euphorie für ihre wunderschöne Stimme (und, keinem weitersagen, für ihre Schönheit)!

I love both Sumi Jo and Cecilia Bartoli in this aria!!!

its just astonishing...like, who knew the human voice could do that?

no entiendo porque comparan tanto cada quien tiene su estilo esta interpretacion me encanto lo hiso perfecto en mi opinion ❤️

It was the 4/4/2006 in Paris at the Théâtre du Châtelet. Ypu can see me in the middle of the third row. It was a great evening and a triumph for Sumi-Jo with a great parisian public!

Wenn man diese brilliante Leichtigkeit mit manchen anderen Versionen vergleicht, wächst die Erkenntnis: Sumi Jo ist einfach das absolut höchste Ergötzen!

and there she goes taking mezzo soprano roles! well at her beginning she thought she was a mezzo soprano so she surely has some mezzo skills. And what skills! her coloratura is excellent as always! flawless rendition! love sumi :)

@alejandrotm

2 жыл бұрын

Mezzosoprano = half soprano in Italian, and both voices share a good deal of their range (C4 to A5 is basically shared by both tessitura), with some mezzo being able to hit G3-A3 (typical contralto notes) and sopranoes being able to hit notes above A5, up to C6, sometimes reaching as far as F#6 for the lightest sopranoes.

@baritonebynight

2 жыл бұрын

Jessye Norman would say "didn't you realize that pigeon holes are only comfortable for pigeons?"

@gilbert-noelsfeir4842

Жыл бұрын

@@baritonebynight But isn't this a transposition for soprano tessitura, at least a higher scale than mezzosoprano's?

@baritonebynight

Жыл бұрын

@@gilbert-noelsfeir4842 You miss the point. Nobody cares!

émouvant, la rencontre de deux virtuoses, extraordinaire Sumi, trésor de Corée et Vicenté, à mon avis le meilleur pianiste qui l'a accompagné pendant une partie de sa magnifique carrière !!!

Bueno yo soy cantante y profesor de un Conservatorio, y puedo opinar con cierta experiencia: Tanto Sumi Jo como la Batoli, son cantantes excepcionales, de las mejores en su genero, que hagan algo que no es para su tessitura, lo pueden hacer. aqui veo una gran agilidad en una autentica soprano ligera, buen ataque en el diafragma, gran fiato, trinos stacattos, fiorituras, muy bien colocados con brillos diversos. REPITO: Una cosa es que algunos no les gusta tal cantante, y otra que no cante bien.

BRAVISSIMA!!! che bella voce!!!, per me la vera diva d'oggi,Sumi Jo!!!

It's just amaze how many colors she brings to this music. Amazing performance. Great rendition!

@gilbert-noelsfeir4842

Жыл бұрын

Exactly! She brings in a lovely varied palette.

Summy Jo estupenda y el pianista ni se diga bravo

She makes it sound easy to sing. Great performance.

VERY GOOD !! This is something different from Bartoli's performances. DON'T argue who is better. It's as green as children. " which is more stronger between tigers and lions?"

@utoobah

3 жыл бұрын

@Dorian G. doesn’t mean she makes a better sound. Contrary to popular opinion, Bartoli doesn’t really make such a stable, clean, nice and transparent sound. She has a lot of issues like Knodel sound and wobbly voice. If you watch a channel called: Floria Tosca you will know what I mean. Sumi Jo on the other hand, is rarely amazing in today’ opera scene! She’s one of the sopranos who are the closest to Old School singing.

@alexsandroalvesartecultura5116

3 жыл бұрын

Cecilia Bartoli!

@poppya54

2 жыл бұрын

@@utoobah Cecilia Bartoli ha la voce traballante? 😯Guagliò tu nun staje bbuon, te ha fa verè a ' nu bbuon miereche 😡

Me encanta cuanto buen hacer y derroche de energía maravillosa

If only Vivaldi knew one day she gonna perform this magnificent piece....

I love how such an excellent coloratura sang this in a mezzo style and so different from Bartoli or Cangemi. All amazing for sure, but Sumi did flawlessly here in such a brilliant manner!

Very brave woman with matchless qualities. Let us just enjoy her for the gifts she has and shares with us.

Einfach erfrischend.

콜로라투라 소프라노가 이곡을 제대로 소화한다는것 자체가 어려운일인데 조수미씨는 아주잘 소화하셨다고 생각해요

Dispide of not looking "'Agitata", her performance is lovely

와... 갓수미!!!❤️심지어 여유로워보이심

카스트라토를 위한곡인데도 콜로라투라가 이 곡을 소화했다는게 정말대단하다고 생각해요(^o^)

Bartoli has a non traditional and somewhat controversial technique that works for her alone. Jo sings it with conventional technique.

이 곡을 들을때는 그녀가 정말 사람일까? 라는 의문이 든다... 놀라울따름이다.

박력 넘치네요 이렇게 힘있게 부르는 사람 아직 본적이 없네요 멋져요 힘들어 하지도 않는것 같아요

@user-ns9jb8vf6f

7 ай бұрын

После Чечилии Бартоли вообще не впечатлила.

Interessante é perceber o retorno das árias de Vivaldi no cenário operístico atual. Poucos se recordam que o selo Naïve auxiliou na popularização de óperas antes esquecidas, além de cantores que se debruçaram no repertório barroco. Parabéns pela avetura

@camilaminuzzizanchetta1816

Жыл бұрын

Que bom né!! Amo muito Vivaldi. Eu escuto desde criança pq meu pai amava, me lembro de brincar com essa trilha sonora 😍

@filipameireles4091

3 ай бұрын

Operático.

just bear in mind that while she's having this recital, it's her father's funeral on the other side of the world. This recital is her tribute to her dead father.

@jmsampietro En realidad solo es una versión distinta de lo que estamos acostumbrados a escuchar con esta aria, Sumi Jo da una buena y distinta forma de escuchar este tema pues ella es soprano y una de las más respetadas en su generación, una de las mejores voces actuales

her and natalie dessay are the TOP coloraturas in the world. i like dessay slightly better, more her tone than anything. but sumi jo is STILL amazing!

@allthenamesrtook It was 250 on one breath, with a sustainable length of over a minute and was attributed to the castrato Farinelli by Joachim Quantz.

Cecilia es Cecilia,pero esta mujer no desmerece nada.Muy buena.

thank you

Beautiful😍💓 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

It';s mezzo-coloratura Aria.

omg - someone please organise that mans music! so off putting. She, on the other hand is extraordinary! love you Sumi :)

@joshuapadilla6588

6 жыл бұрын

Adam you're awesome

@ternitamas

5 жыл бұрын

that's such a mess haha

BRAVISSIMA!!!!

Vivaldi was a composer who was utterly insensitive to the natural limits of human vocal capacity. (He wasn't the only one -- Beethoven and Mozart, among others, had a similar problem.) Agitata seems to have been written for a string virtuoso then transcribed for voice. All singers who try Agitata have difficulty with it, Including the remarkable Bartoli. Ms. Jo accepts the challenge courageously and does a fantastic job with an impossible piece. Brava! Well done!

Amazing!!!

Nice I can definitely hear the accent 👌

Estoy harto de todo el mundo haciendo comparacion entre esta interpretacion y la de Cecilia. Si Cecilia era mejor, pero esta es una interpretacion valida. Y no era tan mala. Porfa! Dejala en paz y apreciala por lo que es.

♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

@primohomme castrati are just brilliant haaa i cant remember who but one could do a thousand note passage in a minuet with one breath haa they were simply amazing but its a good thing they dont exist anymore :)

Why did she omit B part? The Baroque aria should consists with Da capo form with middle B part. This is very important terms at all.

I prefer bartoli but she sings it nicely :) regards

io non amo particolarmente la bartoli, ma non c'è paragone, la bartoli in confronti è una dea

bueno, soy flautista pero he hecho musica de camara con cantantes, en primer lugar no es una mala version, lo que pasa es que no es brillante; para un cantante segun mi experiencia, su interpretacion depende de muchos factores externos e internos y aunque se trabaje el 300% para la perfeccion simpre hay un margen de error, y ella canta esta aria de una forma decorosa, sabiendo que no esta hecha para su registro ella inteligentemente sube las octavas nescesarias, es una version muy racional!!!!!!

This song for Mezzo soprano however Sumi is a high tone soprano rite?

@Yotam1703

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, this aria is written for a medium coloratura mezzo (originally for a male castrato), while Sumi Jo is a high lyric coloratura soprano. Her chest is developed enough for her to hit the main low notes (1:43), though you can hear her struggle in some of the more complicated low sections (2:57) and flat out re-write them (2:20, and she skipped the entire low B-section) in others. She is absolutely wonderful in this rendition in my opinion, given she’s the wrong voice type :)

she is beautiful

wonderful voice

Antonio Vivaldi is my favourite composer, and Jo Sumi my favourite soprano, so you can imagine how much emotive is this performance for me. Heavenly voice, Jo Sumi.

@Denuhm that is a question!

I have a feeling that she cuts it in pieces to be able to sing it... i am not an expert, this is my feeling, especially after Bartoli...

@VeronicaBellSoprano

5 жыл бұрын

yup, she does

Sarò anche l'unico a pensarla così, ma non ci siamo proprio sia come accompagnamento che come canto.

Hey! Where;s the adagio (middle) section?

Hey!!! Very good! Sumi Jo does a very good job! I love this aria, and altough it's not for Cecilia's voice, I think Cecilia Bartoli puts a great energy to this aria.

@skyhaileducation24

3 жыл бұрын

me too I love Cecilia Bartoli. n Sumi

@user-dq8fj5vu4q

3 жыл бұрын

@@skyhaileducation24 because this aria is not for cololatura Sumi jo is cololatura soprano

@poppya54

2 жыл бұрын

Her voice and interpretion is too much snuffed. She lacks the soul.

i only seem to find concert performances of Sumi Jo. Does she do opera too or does she stick to recitals?

@robertvalence7899

10 жыл бұрын

In May-June she was in Arabella in Hamburg and as I write she's Rosina in the Barber in Florence. But her concert recitals tend to predominate.

@mrturtle1128

7 жыл бұрын

It is indeed hard to find her doing operas on KZread, though there are some great recording of her live operas if you dig a bit deeper~~ Like La Sonnambula, good luck on treasure hunting :)

진짜... 교과서... 수미 누나랑 세실리아ㅜ

the pianist doesn't "hesitate with the tempo" -- he RUSHES as soon as a more difficult (pianisticly) passage comes!

Je trouve sa prononciation beaucoup plus propre que celle de Bartoli qui applatit les sons et les décolore souvent !

@poppya54

2 жыл бұрын

Now after your comment, we put away Bartoli 😂

0:55

i know this is kinda farfetched but is the accompanist looking at his hands somewhere around 1:08??????

Brawo. Compliments from Poland

Il y a trop de cons dans les commentaires. Brava , soomi!

I know ive sung it, (I'm a countertenor) but today its seen as a mezzo song becuase there really arn't any castri 'running' around anymore :P

En duo avec un piano, c'est plus difficile qu'avec un orchestre à cordes. Sumi Jo est exceptionnelle mais je pense que pour cet Aria, elle aurait à y gagner avec un orchestre.

@baritonebynight

Жыл бұрын

Sumi Jo could care less what you think.....when you do a recital with piano you do a recital with piano.

@MrCurryFan It's all a matter of personal choice! If you prefer Bartoli enjoy her, please don't come here making silly statements. I never never insult other singers, I simply don't listen to them. In my world Sumi Jo is and always has been number one.

I love cecilia bartoli. !!!!

@leveluz Favorites. Usually Mozart for me. Sumi Jo always always always!

Haha! I've never seen Sumi struggle with an aria like this!

마지막부분은 조금 바꿔서 부른건가..와

Pianist not doing very good job there.

@etoiledelkirov ahahahahahah questa cosa mi ha fatto ridere di gusto! bartoli's interpretation is so much better than sumi jo's, without any doubt!

I like this piece accompanied by an orchestra better than the piano. Prety though i do prefer Cecilia Bartoli when it comes to Baroque music. Sumi did a nice job though.

This is simply a fucking SAD performance!!!

Es sabido que no es para su registro, con sólo leer el libreto se consta. ¿ Por qué tántas críticas contra Sumi Jo ? Es una de las voces más grandes de éstos tiempos y por algo está donde está y se da lujos como éste, son versiones, al igual que a Caballé las desterraron por éste aria (recién ví el video y junto con él sus comentarios despectivos) a mi me daría verguenza faltarle el respeto de esa manera a una DIOSA como lo son ambas.

@rmcinuk ... and how can you understand if you like a singer or not, if you don't begin to listen to them? :) moreover, i didn't insult her. i was replying to a person who said something not very flattering to bartoli. and then, why did you reply only to my comment when there are many many other comments about how much bartoli is better than sumi jo?

je découvre cette interprétation et je préfère de très loin Bartolli eu Lehzneva ça manque de "coffre"

@Denuhm This was not for mezzosoprano but castrati... However i would say I, yes, indeed, prefer Bartoli's interpretation for this aria.

@baritonebynight

2 жыл бұрын

Thankfully we don't do such barbaric things anymore and I don't wish to return to the days of the castrati. We will never know what a good castrato sounded like (Moreschi wasn't a good one...he was only a choral singer).

MERAVIGLIOSA!!!!

I don't get it, why's everyone bitching 'bout this? It's not THAT bad. And for your information, Bartoli doesn't own this aria. She owns Armatae Face, but not this. This one is better done by both Emma Kirkby and Veronica Cangemi. :)

I have to agree. She just stands there and with much effort gets most of the notes out. It's more like a workshop recital. I always say, if you can't even pronounce what you're singing you shouldn't perform it at all.

Por algo fue una de las engreídas de Karajan...

Cecilia is the best

I like Sumi Jo's rendition more than Bartoli's. I don't like Bartoli's voice, too mechanic. Not saying she's not good, but I prefer Sumo Jo 💕💗🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹bravoooooo

@contatolirico el que esta fuera de foco eres tu! Vivaldi escribe esta aria para voces especiales que podian cantarlas SOLO tessituras unicas desde baritonos hasta sopranos y las voces tenian los colores de la voz diversa.

Agreed...the pianist is not great at all. However, Sumi Jo is incredible in this piece, although Bartoli is more polished. The comment about Asians is completely unwarranted though! As a Chinese-Canadian I take much offence to the comment you made - it sounds like Asians are not competent. "Not bad - for an Asian?" I don't think so. She's amazing!

Anybody complaining about her repertoire choice needs to unstuff their shirt.

Cierto, Como la Bartoli y Genaux ninguna...

@Palomom

5 жыл бұрын

Oscar Grau prefiero a la Cangemi

I PARTLY agree with you on Koreans: vanity, yes, lack of individuality bordering totalitarianism, yes, but stupid? NEVER! They are some of the smartest people. And Sumi Jo is one magnificent songbird, and that's all that matters here. This performance does not display Sumi Jo at her best (well, she's way past her prime anyway), but still it's more than respectable. She desperately needs Baroque specialists. She has the right instrument, but she has no style. She might get a great result.

@poppya54

2 жыл бұрын

She is brava but she lacks soul.

If only the pianist was up to the task.

She does look really uncomfortable. It sounds to me this piece is new to her (also to the pianist!). I wonder what made her decide to tackle this, especially after Cecilia Bartoli's perfect interpretation (fabulously accompanied by authenitc Baroque bands twice over) is branded in everyone's ears. Perhaps she's resentful that she never got to do all the great Baroque parts during her prime, which would've been superb. The informed Baroque performance movement missed her and vice versa.

está jamona

Of course she perhaps to work on the style, she never said she is the queen of baroque period, anyway she sing nicely this piece and Whatever we can say on the style she we still stay THE sumi Jo. I think that on the fact that she is a really great soprano she has nothing to prove anymore... Beside that she is doing strange out of tone notes at 2:35 , I don't know why...

Non basta essere brave, fare i vocalizzi, studiare, esercitarsi....bisogna saper interpretare, emozionare, avere intensità e profondità...quindi o lei é sopravvaluta, oppure le mie orecchie sono abituate a qualcosa di meglio! It is not enough to be good, vocalize, study, practice .... you have to know how to interpret, excite, have intensity and depth ... so either she is overrated, or i have used my ears too well ll ne suffit pas d'être bon, de faire les vocalisations, d'étudier, de pratiquer ... il faut savoir interpréter, émotioner, avoir de l'intensité et de la profondeur ... donc, ou elle est surestimé, ou J'ai trop bien utilisé mes oreilles!

Creo que no es una mala interpretación, sin embargo, no es la misma expresión vocal al oírla con las maestras Vivica Genaux o Cecilia Bartoli. Claro que los castrados si querían la cantaban con mezzosoprano o contralto y hasta soprano, si se les ocurría, vocalmente para ellos nada era imposible.

This woman thinks that an array of vocal fireworks is enough to make justice to music...she must listen to Bartoli's performances of this same aria...and try to LEARN something!