This is fire but I will not let Puth breathe for ducking out of the video! Better get a part two with him in the rain too; Someone get this man a white fit!!! 🤣🦁

@tocraash7430

2 ай бұрын

Puth has been wack throughout this whole process, bro did not promote this song ONCE, like puth didn't mention it at all across all of his socials

@tocraash7430

2 ай бұрын

But the song is amazing and I'm so happy for the boys to be able to collab and hopefully this gets them so much more attention in many different scenes

@katjalovesmusicals4337

2 ай бұрын

Hahhahahha dare him , will you!

@lauren3135

2 ай бұрын

I think those were just props. They weren’t in the states when this was filmed.

@eghstay0810

2 ай бұрын

He did make a comment on Twitter about it but I think he was mostly being quiet about it probably due to the amount of people accusing him of being a Zionist.

As a fellow production nerd... 😅 There is an Intro where SKZ talk about the process on their channel, but the tl;dr is: 3Racha did a song camp with Charlie Puth when they were in NYC for Global Citizen Festival last September. And it seems like it was a Charlie-led production, but with 3Racha contributions. However, Bang Chan directed the recording of the SKZ vocals. And knowing their style, I'm pretty convinced (no solid evidence though), that Bang Chan's arrangement credit comes from adding finishing touches. Compared to your average Charlie Puth song, this one feels a bit crisper and more polished in a way I really only have heard Bang Chan's relentless perfectionism reach. However, they didn't talk about that in detail, so it could also just have been 3Racha knowing what they are looking for. It does definitely have their signature on it, even if it is a bit more subtle than on other songs. I would also like to point out that Stray Kids are such brilliant collaboration partners. The 4 songs they have done with features (or been the feature) as a full group where 3Racha also produced, they managed to hit the essence of that artist's style every time, while also giving it the SKZ shine. And doing that in 4 wildly different genres (Topline/TigerJK, Social Path/LiSA, All My Life (SKZ Remix)/Lil Durk, and now this as well). They are just so incredibly talented.

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

Agreed they have no missed on any of this collabs!

@Resistance_Is_Futile1of3

2 ай бұрын

I also love the early EDM song from Alesso/Corsak - Going Dumb... a very catchy song collab that SKZ were featured on also... me & the babies dance party to it still 🖖🏽

@jaimeeshivers5001

2 ай бұрын

@@Resistance_Is_Futile1of3soooooo goooood

@NightengaleBird

2 ай бұрын

I’d like to see Laurent Bourgeois (of the dance talent, “ Les Twins”) and Hyunjin ( Stray Kids) collaborating with a dance!🕺🏽 🕺🏽 I wonder if they already know each other ? 🤔

Lyricist(s): Charlie Puth, Jacob Kasher Hindlin, Natalie Salomon, 3RACHA Composer(s): Charlie Puth, 3RACHA, Johnny Goldstein Arranger(s): Charlie Puth, Johnny Goldstein, Bang Chan

@jelenajs5017

2 ай бұрын

+ Producer(s): Charlie Puth, Johnny Goldstein

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

Ahh yes yes, I could feel it in my bones

It seems to me the idea of MV is to show that for the sake of love, a choice is made between a familiar and long life without a soul and a new world with a short and difficult life full of love. This is an analogy with the Little Mermaid on the contrary, so there is a lot of water, symbolising the connection with another world, the world of water with a long life without love, which the guys are ready to leave. The last frame is very symbolic. And Lee Know one withstood the test.

Although 3 Racha is the exception to your rule of musical geniuses not being able to dance!!😂❤️

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

True but I don't know them personally (YET) so I wasn't including them

I love the song so much!! Especially Changbin vocals! He said in the Intro video that he didn't want ppl to say, "Well, he's a rapper." He put his entire, well-built ass into his part. They're all so freaking pretty in the video, too. My Stay heart is happy. Also, funny you mention being clumsy/uncoordinated. I.N is super clumsy and breaks things a lot. He can still dance, though!

You need to watch the Intro by Stray Kids that discusses this song and the processes behind it. 🙂

@NightengaleBird

2 ай бұрын

@kdog … Yes!!!!! Indeed, because they talked about the process of nailing the vocals and appropriate English pronunciations. They even talked about the choreography … Very interesting! Each member had input🙂

It is, is a 3racha + Charlie song :) they are in all credits, lyrics too

Honestly I think JYP could have possibly left Puth out because when it came out SKZ was collabing with him it did not go over well. Some stays have chosen to boycott the song as it has been said that Puth is problematic regarding some political issues including some sexist comments that have been made. I believe Puth is distancing himself from SKZ for those very reasons as well. I think he wants this to go well for SKZ. I am assuming that is the reason. According to the credits it looks like Charlie Puth and another producer are credited so 3racha isn’t credited for production but Puth and 3racha were credited as song writers and there were a couple others as well. If you would love see Binnie singing more, he was on Koreas Masked Singer. That was from prob 4ish years ago. I live for Binnies vocals lol

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

Ooh interesting I didn't know that

@LeeKnow3rdEye

2 ай бұрын

@@AmariLeonenot true. They are boycotting because he Jewish and are calling him a Zionist. It’s the Palestine thing

@stephaniehatcher4817

2 ай бұрын

@@LeeKnow3rdEye That is why I put a disclaimer saying that these are my assumptions and not fact in regards to Puth’s absence in activities with SKZ. That is what I meant by political opinions. Also, they are boycotting because he liked a couple of post that were pro Israel which led to him being called a Zionist. I don’t talk politics and tend to keep it out of music unless it is a song that is regarding it. They have also mentioned the sexist comments he has made as well. Not just the Palestine and Gaza situation

@MakeGoodTrouble

2 ай бұрын

​@@LeeKnow3rdEyeit's actually all of the above. He's a zionist. He's said and done sexist/misogynistic things (on video no less) and not shown much remorse or made efforts to change (there's stuff involving Selena Gomez, Ke$ha, and Little Mix in this vein - with 2 of them it really seems he doesn't take being told "no" very well). He's generally seen as just not a good guy for those who have taken the effort to actually look into all of the complaints about him. I generally liked him and his music prior to this. Started seeing a lot of stays raising red flags about him so I researched it. Look, I'm not about cancelling some one over 1 or 2 rumors, but when there's multiple instances (some on video no less) and I don't see any effort from the person to show remorse and an effort to change, then that tells me all I need to know. Needless to say I'm a fan no more and I'm one of the ones boycotting. Love SKZ and will support in many other ways, but it's a hard no on this one for me. It's morals over music for me.

@NightengaleBird

2 ай бұрын

@Stephanie … True … ChangBin can sing. They all can. All of the members can sing, rap, write, and dance … but they are divided into a particular specialty. All doctors know how to listen to the lungs … but some specialize in orthopedics … oncology … etc. Despite their focus, they can still perform the basics. Each member of Stray Kids knows the basics- They’re just highly specialized in their own rights! Makes them a powerfully talented group!🥰

I'm a new sub, and I just gotta say you crack me up. 😂 there is something about changbin's vocals that draws me in. You should watch the intro video for this song they explain why it's different to their other music.

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

I appreciate that! And yeah I'll have to check it out

Well worth the wait❤. Grammy Stay loves it😂❤

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

They did a good job with it!

they have also released a SKZ version that has some changes to it and it’s really good as well!

I'm not a pure western pop fan in general so this will never be my favourite SKZ song, however it IS very catchy and they do an awesome job (those vocals!) so I'm enjoying giving it a listen although hands way up really because I'm hearing Lee Know...Changbin...Bang Chan's adlibs...Would I listen to it on repeat if it was only Charlie? Nope. But that's personal preference. And I love how their collabs are all perfect with the collabing artist and stretch the SKZ members in the creating. I hope it will open a door for some new baby STAYs because who doesn't want that. My favourite bit is probably Hyunjin's - he's doing Hyunjin, but vibing with the Puth aesthetic; he doesn't sound like Puth. P.S. Appreciate the TASTE tangent!

I saw the Waffle House - when Felix and Hyunjin crossed pathways … Maybe part of the video was filmed somewhere in Georgia?? During an Atlanta concert, Bang Chan … or maybe Felix asked where’s a good place to eat - The audience shouted, “ The Waffle House!!”

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

They gonna see the fight of a life time & HYP is never going to let them step foot in the south again I fear but Waffle House is forever a go to lol

@NightengaleBird

2 ай бұрын

@ Amarileone ( from Sierra Leone?) … ?? I stumbled across your channel yesterday … I must say … your commentary is the most thorough, thoughtful, and cohesive review. Most KZreadrs are too star struck to offer insight to the idiosyncratic elements of Stray Kids music … no disrespect to them … I can’t blame them. Sometimes after hearing a new Skz song, all I can say is “ Wow! Just wow!!” But … since I’m a pseudo musician-I play the organ, piano, and guitar by ear … I’m always noticing the slight changes in pitch, rhythm, etc. I’m also a writer - BA and MA degrees in English so I’m able to analyze the bejesus out of “Mary Had a Little Lamb” …. I appreciate themes/tropes. It’s sooooooo very refreshing to hear someone in this entertainment realm with so much depth!! I appreciate your knowledge! 😊 Keep your analytics coming … I’m a fan!!!

Thanks for the reaction

You imitating us spazzy extra Stays is everything ...... tell me where the lie tho lol!!!

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

You know me I'm right there with y'all lol

Credits!!! Writer(s)---> Charlie Puth, Jacob Kasher Hindlin, Natalie Salomon, Bang Chan (3RACHA), Changbin (3RACHA), Han (3RACHA) Composer(s)----> Charlie Puth, Bang Chan (3RACHA), Changbin (3RACHA), Han (3RACHA), Johnny Goldstein Arranger(s)----> Charlie Puth, Johnny Goldstein, Bang Chan (3RACHA) Producer(s)----> Charlie Puth, Johnny Goldstein + Yes, this totally sounds like a Puth song! They've talked about how they worked with him on their channel (or on JYP Entertainment... I think on their channel). and it totally sounds like a 90's song... lol It doesn't really sound like a "typical" STRAY KIDS song (if you can call their music typical. but you get what I mean. They have a certain unique taste to them)... It's a good song, they sing and perform amazing don't get me wrong, but I always prefer the Kids' own special sound, be it a "rough" sound or a soft sound. + Of course they're singing! They're the Freaking ACE GROUP!!! They can all sing, rap, and dance... Our amazing golden boys! ALSO, I love dancing in the rain scenes in M\V's. It looks so perfect! Sexy and Cool at the same time.

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

Hey sweetie! Hope all is well in Foxyland (*eh eh* see what I did there lol). And yes this doesn't sound like their typical offerings but it's great nonetheless. Also yes! Rain dancing scenes are forever fire, truly evergreen!!

Thanks for your reaction. By the way, great song at the end of the video! After seeing the reaction, I wondered if I liked SKZ as a whole or the song itself. The guys' voices are wonderful, but... The second part is more catchy where at least some variety of melody begins. This is generally an atypical sound for popular SKZ songs. But the dance, the visual and what we know from the Intro about the process of creating the song, the effort expended, the hopes of the guys, makes it more relatable. Maybe only for me, but... I wonder if there is something for the musicians/producers that indicates successful song? Without awards and charts. Not "nice" but "wow, incredible, masterpiece". Or like God's Menu once brought Stray Kids to a new level... I'm waiting for another great work from 3Racha.

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

Thanks that's my song No Worries (by Amari Leone, available here on youtube & on all streaming platforms). From a musical standpoint I think it's super subjective what that "wow" song is. I've heard artists say they knew the second they made a song it'd be their biggest hit & others say they had no idea when they released a song it'd be that popular. Did SKZ say they felt that way about this song?

@withoutanywords

2 ай бұрын

​@@AmariLeone Thanks for the answer! No, the SKZ did not say anything like that. This is more of a theoretical question, not about this song, but in general, are there any “rules” by which musicians/songwriters can create music that will attract more people. Or is it really a matter of chance. I hope my questions are correct/no negativity in English, I'm not very good at this language.

Exactly what I said..most def a Puth type song..both produced.

The song is realy good.

Ahahaha your comment on Puthie's coordination was funny. Correct assumption. Went to his concert and he indeed does free spirited moves that I think are very cute just because it's Puth 😉. If you watch Stray Kid's behind the song clip, they said they worked on this song with Puth at a song camp.

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

I could totally see that but also when you're that talented musically, dancing is just a bonus lol

Nuce reaction

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for giving it a watch!

Got a question for a producer...you! I'm not one at all but I've thought for some time that a good match music wise for stray kids for a colab would be twenty one pilots, what do you think? Especially if you listen to something like Holding onto you or Lane Boy...

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

Oooh that would be FIRE! I could see Tyler rapping or singing with the boys. #Let'sManifestIt

@cassc23

2 ай бұрын

@@AmariLeone Nice! Glad I'm not delusional 😆...here's hoping!!

I love this. It's absolute fire! But I prefer SKZ production dynamics to be completely honest. Western pop is kind of repetitive and not as interesting. For their noncollabs (is that a word😂) I hope they revert to their more unique style ❤

kzread.info/dash/bejne/p5iuksNuh8jJqM4.html pretty sure it says the credits on this video somewhere (also the intro videos are super interesting for more backstory on the recording and choreo process) 😊

@AmariLeone

2 ай бұрын

Thank you, I'll check it out!