Buhat acha show hai, We well come our bahari Muslims brother in Pakistan (punjab)

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Whatever, but do explain what’s wrong with Bangladesh, it’s a Muslim country isn’t it. Pakistan Zindabaad

@kumar7586

2 жыл бұрын

​@@madeehasaeed786 Yes, but these Biharis supported Pakistan in 1971. They remain loyal to Pakistan. They have been waiting for the last fifty years to come to Pakistan. You are a Pakistani by birth. Very easy! These people have suffered a lot for their belief in Pakistan. It's a shame that they remain in refugee camps in Bangladesh even after fifty years waiting for the Pakistan government to repatriate them to Pakistan.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@kumar7586 Yes, but you fail to realise that it matters not what they (the Biharis of Bangladesh) feel about Pakistan, whether they have belief in Pakistan or belief in the idea of Pakistan or as you say fought for Pakistan (I personally strongly reject the idea of Pakistan made up of two wings, East and West Pakistan, they should never have been one “state” or “political entity” in the first place but always two separate countries, so as far as I’m concerned they only fought for their position of power in East Pakistan/Bangladesh which was afforded to them by virtue of the fact that being Urdu speakers they had the backing of West Pakistan which gave them an upper hand vis-à-vis the local or native Bengalis of East Bengal/East Pakistan/Bangladesh and NOT for Pakistan itself) or for that matter they the Biharis of Bangladesh wish to migrate to Pakistan, you see I may wish to migrate to New Zealand and have belief in the idea of New Zealand and love New Zealand with all my heart but neither the government nor the people of New Zealand are in any way obligated to accommodate me in New Zealand or to give me citizenship and rightly so, every people and every state or country has the sovereign inalienable right to make its own policies and especially to decide who can and who can’t come to “their”very own country, that’s a fundamental right that cannot be denied. Plus look at the facts, after 1971, which should never have happened as both Pakistan (West) and Bangladesh should have been two separate countries and therefore having nothing to do with each other there would never have been deployed any military or civil employees of the federal government from West Pakistan to East Pakistan, therefore no military of West Pakistan origin would have been in East Pakistan/Bangladesh and therefore no debacle of 1971, but that is a different story, the point being that after 1971 millions of Biharis were brought over to West Pakistan (and the Biharis that we are talking about are the very small fraction that were not brought over, so at least appreciate the fact that Pakistan brought over the vast majority of Biharis even though those Biharis had absolutely no connection with the land or people of West Pakistan whether ethnically, linguistically or culturally and we really had no obligation to bring them over, but no that will never be appreciated and it will always be “do more”, sorry we have already done more than enough) and simultaneously the rise in ethnic tensions in Sindh and especially in Karachi and Hyderabad became intense leading eventually to the emergence of the likes of the MQM and like minded parties and the obnoxious and vile demand for a separate muhajir province which then would lead inevitably to the demand for a separate muhajir country, obviously something that a person like me can never ever in a million years accept, is that all a coincidence, allowing in millions of Biharis and all the ethnic bloodshed that came along with it, I don’t think so. So the question now arises that after spending 30 plus years and expending the blood sweat and tears and the very lives of thousands of Punjabis, Pakhtuns and Sindhis in the military and the police smashing the likes of the MQM we should now throw it all away and bring in hundreds of thousands if not millions more Biharis and again put in danger our country and again invite those horrors again and again allow the intensification of that bike and ugly demand of a separate muhajir province, that’s a risk I cannot take and in my humble opinion not a single, not one more Bihari of Bangladesh should be allowed into Pakistan, after all it is our country and we should have the right to decide such things and I would be more than happy for this to be taken to a referendum, let the people decide. The other point that nobody seems to consider or respond to when it is brought up us the very material fact that the government of Bangladesh offered Bangladeshi citizenship to the Biharis in 1972 but the Biharis themselves rejected taking Bangladeshi citizenship and voluntarily opted to go into refugee camps in the hopes that Pakistan would take them, hence again the question, what’s wrong with Bangladesh, it’s a Muslim country, their parents and grandparents being voluntarily migrated there, it is in effect next door to Bihar, yet for some reason they wish to come to Karachi 2 thousand miles away, strange, when they could have very easily accepted Bangladeshi and still can and walk out of the refugee camps and become part of Bangladeshi society, but no, tgey want to come to Karachi and cause further demographic instability in Sindh and further push the Sindhis towards becoming a minority in their very own land and country, just like the Palestinians in Palestine/Isra*l, I say no thanks to such BS, I for one have no desire to become a minority in my own country and have no desire to become the equivalent of the Palestinians. Thanks but no thanks. Also if you think about it all that has really happened is that East Pakistan has rebranded, it had changed its name to Bangladesh, that’s no reason to leave Bangladesh, it’s a Muslim country, it too in the larger scheme of things was made as a separate Muslim country for Muslims and yet simply because it changed its name it is now unfit for Biharis, for muhajirs and for Indian Muslims in general, why? If it be the case that simply by rebranding Bangladesh is now no longer a home fit for the Muslims of South Asia then may be Pakistan should change its name and then all the Bangladeshis/Bengalis, Biharis, Indian Muslims (muhajirs) should immediately leave Pakistan, that’s a good idea, but for some reason I doubt very much anybody will leave no matter what the new name of Pakistan is, the only reason that the Biharis want to come to Pakistan is so that they have an advantage due to the Urdu language, an advantage that abruptly ended in 1971 (one reason they were fighting against Bangladeshi independence, their own benefit) rather than accept Bangladeshi citizenship, leave the camps and become normal law abiding members of Bangladeshi society and compete with the local and native Bengalis on a level playing field in the Bengali language (not in Urdu that was so wrongly imposed on the Bengalis by the Urdu speaking elite of West Pakistan in 1947/48, that is the crux of the matter, they want an easier ride , but I for one am not in the least bit sympathetic, they can at any moment become citizens of Bangladesh but purposely choose not to, that’s on them and not on the native peoples of Pakistan, by the way I’m not a Sindhi but a Punjabi and the b m as five inflow of muhajirs hadn’t affected Punjab so much but I don’t want to take that chance and nor do I wish to see any further damage to the position of Sindhis demographically speaking in Sindh, nor could I hear the division of Sindh, to be it’s a sin of biblical proportions and no way can I acquiesce to such a thing that is a danger to my country and to the natives of this country, sorry. You said it’s easy for me as a person born in Pakistan, that’s a meaningless statement to make, yes, not only am I a born Pakistani but a native Pakistani, a native of the land of Punjab and this is my ancient and ancestral heritage and homeland for at least a thousand years, therefore that gives me the right to decide along with my fellow sisters and brothers who are the rightful heirs of these lands and therefore of this country by virtue of being natives who can and more importantly who CANNOT come to Pakistan, that is a basic and fundamental God given human right and a sovereign right of the state! Pakistan is a country, it is not a yateem khana, “anath ashram” or orphanage for the unhappy Muslims of South Asia nor is it a dumping ground for the worlds refugees. Again what is wrong with Bangladesh that these Biharis will not accept Bangladeshi citizenship, an offer that has been on the table since 1972, that’s right the offer of Bangladeshi citizenship has been there for fifty long years, is it not arrogance on the part of the Biharis and a slap in the face of the Bangladeshi people, government and state, how dreadfully shameful. Pakistan Zindabaad Sindh Zindabaad Punjab Zindabaad, lol, lol Pakistan Zindabaad

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@kumar7586 Your last sentence or line to be precise says “repatriate them to Pakistan”, that is an entirely false statement and a misuse of the word “repatriate”. You can only be repatriated to a land or country you an actual connection with or you were actually from, that is definitely NOT the case for the Biharis of Bangladesh, tgey have zero connection with any province of Pakistan and zero connection with any of the native peoples of Pakistan, tgey have zero historical ties to Pakistan and tgey were never ever from West Pakistan, so by all definitions tgey cannot be “repatriated” to Pakistan. On the other hand tgey do definitely have a connection with East Pakistan now called Bangladesh and as such tgey don’t to be repatriated to Bangladesh but to simply accept Bangladeshi citizenship and become its loyal law abiding citizens, how easy is that, or if they insist on repatriation then that would mean going back to where they came from and that means Bihar in India, in other words Bharat matta, think about that next time before you loosely use words in order to support your false narrative. Pakistan Zindabaad

@amnamumtaz8774

Жыл бұрын

They don't be trusted, like they betrayed bengalis by collabrating with Pakistan back in 1971. They may collabrate with taliban or americans in future against Pakistan , for God sake don't send them to Pakistan. Their history say that They don't loyal to their country of residence.

وہ تمام مسلمان جو کیمپوں میں مقیم ہیں وہ سب کے سب ہمارے بھائی ہیں پاکستان گورمنٹ کو ان سب کو پاکستان میں آباد کرنے کا انتظام کرنا چاہیے۔ اور آج تک جو ان لوگوں نے پریشانی اٹھائی اس کے لیے معافی مانگنی چاہیے۔

Please bring our Muslim brother's and sister's 🇵🇰 🇵🇰 to Pakistan

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Nope!

@amnamumtaz8774

Жыл бұрын

They don't be trusted, like they betrayed bengalis by collabrating with Pakistan back in 1971. They may collabrate with taliban or americans in future against Pakistan , for God sake don't send them to Pakistan. Their history say that They don't loyal to their country of residence.

اب تو سارا بلوچستان خالی پڑا ھے وہاں ترقی بھی ھونا ھے ان تمام بھائیوں کو لا کر انڈسٹریل زون کے ساتھ آباد کیا جائے لیبر کی ضرورت بھی پوری ھو گی بھائی بھی اپنے وطن آ جائیں گے

وہ ہمارے بھائی ہیں ان کو جلد پاکستان لایا جائے تاکہ ان کو اپنا اصلی ملک مل جائے پاکستان زندہ باد

Please bring these pakistanis at home 🇵🇰 🇵🇰 Pakistan ZANDABAD

From Sind Hindus are moving to India as refugees. Their land &homes can be awarded to these Bihari people.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

No thanks, let them fight for their own country somewhere in Bharat matta.

@kumar7586

2 жыл бұрын

​@@madeehasaeed786 From where YOU are from! BJP IT cell!

@madeehasaeed786

Жыл бұрын

@@kumar7586 Well I can’t be from the BJP if I’m saying they can fight for their own country in Bharat matta which would imply them waging war against India or Bharat matta and as such against the BJP, you are not very bright are you, it’s seems you are intellectually challenged and extremely lacking in logic, try harder next time, and stop saying the same thing in every comment like “BJP IT Cell”, very poor of you. Pakistan Zindabad

@invisiblesecretofpeoples2442

Жыл бұрын

​@@kumar7586 abe wo paksiatni dp laga ke muslim name h alg pata chal raha h wo paksiatni extremist h tuje yaha bhi bjp dikh rahi h pakisatn me bhi bjp ki branch h kya chutiye

We have forgeten our Pakistani who still willing to come Pakistan.PLease don't tell Bihari they are actually pakistani.they save our Pakistani army in 1971 in East Pakistan.I strongly recommend to bring them immediately without further delay.I regret to say this is a shameful being a Pakistani.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

If it’s that shameful then how come there are over thirty million muhajirs, millions of Biharis, more than six million Bengalis and three plus million Rohingiyas in Pakistan, they should all go back to their ancestral homelands or wherever else in the world and leave Pakistan alone, logically speaking. Pakistan Zindabaad

@ArshadAli-ru9pz

Жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 agr ye bat hai to Pakistan ka atomb bomb b ik muhajir ne hi bnaya h. Pakistan nuclear power nhi hta to aj tukre ho jate Pakistan k. Is k ilawa Pakistan ka nam, jhanda India se ane wale musalmano ne hi bnaya h.

@ArshadAli-ru9pz

Жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 Muhajiron ne Pakistan banaya hai, India ka zulm Muhajiron ne saha hai. Ap lgon ki trhan subha uth kr Pakistan nhi dekha balk is k lye apne Janon ki qurbani di hai hum ne.

@madeehasaeed786

Жыл бұрын

@@ArshadAli-ru9pz Talk to yourself as my comments no longer appear, either you have made a spurious complaint or the channel or KZread themselves have removed my comments, that’s great for freedom of speech, but I’ll just say this if you think it’s right to flood and swamp our country with foreigners against (what I contend is) our will and without our permission and you are confident of the righteousness of your position then take it for a referendum and see what happens. I guarantee that only muhajirs whether Biharis, or Rohingiyas or otherwise will vote for such a thing. The vast majority of the native peoples of Pakistan will most definitely vote against allowing in the Biharis and for that matter allowing in any more muhajirs, I’m that confident, besides it’s our country so we should and do have every right to decide who can and cannot come to Pakistan. Anyway nice job with the censorship, congratulations who ever did that, bravo, especially to the channel owners, if people don’t agrwith your BS then Demeter their comments. Bye. Pakistan Zindabaad

@madeehasaeed786

Жыл бұрын

@@ArshadAli-ru9pz Sorry, my genuine mistake, I thought my comments were being deleted but that’s because you have made the exact same two comments to me in completely different threads on this video, please discard the first portion of my reply/comment and just see the rest or better still see my answer or reply on the other thread which is in more detail, I think the original comment in that thread is by a person called Qureshi, sorry again for my mistake. Pakistan w

افسوس ان کو جلدی پاکستان لانا چاہیں

We should bring back these people from Bangladesh it will not burden on government of pakistan they are hard working people just give some little help to settle in Pakistan they will find the way and they are loyal to Pakistan even they are outside look those people living in Pakistan and they oppose Pakistan kick them out and replaced with these people

@firerangerover5436

3 жыл бұрын

And put them where? In tents, camps? For this Pak Gov needs to build accommodation for them. Unfortunately Pak is not able to do this as hundreds of thousands of Pakstanis themselves are homeless and do not live in appropriate homes.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@firerangerover5436 Even if Pakistan was a very rich country with massive resources it still shouldn’t be bringing in these Biharis to Pakistan. This is a country, it’s not a yateem khana, “anath ashram” or orphanage for the unhappy Muslims of South Asia nor is it a dumping ground for the worlds refugees. Thanks. Pakistan Zindabaad

@kumar7586

2 жыл бұрын

​@@madeehasaeed786 BJP IT cell!

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@kumar7586 Is that the level of your intellect, BJP IT cell, come on you can do better than that. Tell me what’s wrong with NOT wanting to be swamped with millions of foreigners, aliens and refugees and be turned into a minority in our very own country, what’s wrong with not wanting to become the equivalent of the Palestinians or the Native Americans of North America, as far as I’m concerned there is nothing wrong with that, but go ahead and give it a go if your brain has the intellectual and academic ability to do so. Logic would dictate that H1ndu fundamentalists and extremists of India, of the like of the BJP, would disoriented get rid of as many millions of Muslims from India and push them into Pakistan, getting rid of Indian Muslims winks be a dream come true for the BJP, on the other hand I’m resisting such shenanigans and am against mass migration, in other words what I’m saying is diametrically opposite to what the BJP would love to happen, logic and intellect are not on your side, simply emotions and accusations, what a sad show, try harder next time. And yeh, I’m a Pakistani, a Punjabi, a Muslim, from a village (that I won’t name) around ten miles from the city of Faisalabad and I sure as hell don’t need your certification of whether I’m a Pakistani or not, by tgey grace of the one true God I’m a Pakistani, not an Indian and definitely not a member of a BJP IT cell, as far as I’m concerned the whole of India can vanish from the face of the earth tomorrow, thanks to God I’m a Pakistani. Pakistan Zindabaad Sindh Zindabaad Punjab Zindabaad, lol, lol Pakistan Zindabaad

I am very pro armed forces but knowing the history, our armed forces are responsible and our government is not intrested to bring them to Pakistan while we can still accommodate Afghan and Bangalies and Nepalies.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

May be chuck out the Afghan, Nepalese, Bengali, Bihari, Rohingiya and Indian Muslims (muhajirs) in general from Pakistan, why chose between these different aliens, foreigners, refugees, immigrants and the offspring of immigrants when it is better to get rid of all of them, after all tgey all fate us natives with a vengeance and tge more you allow into Pakistan the worse things will get and the louder the demands for a separate muhajir province and a separate muhajir country will get, kind of risky for the federation and a danger to the native peoples of Pakistan, no thanks. Besides the Afghans still have close (very close) racial, ethnic, linguistic, cultural and geographic connections to two of Pakistan’s four provinces whereas the Biharis (and muhajirs [Muslims of Ind1an origin]) have absolutely none, they gave nothing in common with Pakistan, no link or connection whether ethnic, linguistic, cultural or geographical with Pakistan, with any of its provinces or territories or with any of its native peoples, a far cry from the Afghans, so your comparison is a false equivalence. A better solution is to get rid of the groups you mention and also get rid of all the Biharis, Gujjus, bhaiyas, Marathas, Dakhans (Takhans), Tamils and of course tge Rohingyas, and at the same time get rid of everyone and their offspring that came to Pakistan after 1957, just for starters, who came in 1958 to Pakistan, ohh yes that would be Altaf Hussain and his family. Let’s just put it this way, Pakistan is not a yateem khana, “anath ashram” or orphanage for the unhappy Muslims of South Asia nor is it a dumping ground for the worlds refugees, thanks for your support, understanding and cooperation. Pakistan Zindabaad

I think we should bring them home . We have given shelter to Afghanistanis for many many years so why not them they are Pakistanis... Give some of the imran khans homes to them or even just bring them home be good news for them ..

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

What’s Imran Khan got to do with it. Let’s not bring them to Pakistan at all, let them be loyal citizens of Bangladesh instead, that is their country, and in fact let’s get rid of all the foreigners including tge Bengalis, muhajirs, Biharis and Rohingyas, a much better idea, Pakistan isn’t a yateem khana,” anath ashram” or orphanage for the unhappy Muslims of South Asia nor is it a dumping ground for the worlds refugees, thanks for your cooperation. Pakistan Zindabaad

@kumar7586

2 жыл бұрын

​@@madeehasaeed786 BJP IT cell with a fake Muslim ID!

@ArshadAli-ru9pz

Жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 agr ye bat hai to Pakistan ka atomb bomb b ik muhajir ne hi bnaya h. Pakistan nuclear power nhi hta to aj tukre ho jate Pakistan k. Is k ilawa Pakistan ka nam, jhanda India se ane wale musalmano ne hi bnaya h.

@ArshadAli-ru9pz

Жыл бұрын

Muhajiron ne Pakistan banaya hai, India ka zulm Muhajiron ne saha hai. Ap lgon ki trhan subha uth kr Pakistan nhi dekha balk is k lye apne Janon ki qurbani di hai hum ne.

@madeehasaeed786

Жыл бұрын

@@ArshadAli-ru9pz Oh sorry. I didn’t realise a muhajir built Pakistan’s nuclear bomb capability, how silly of me. Now let’s examine this claim a little that muhajirs, Indian Muslims in general and those that have fallen victim to their seventy year propaganda campaign of bugging themselves up at the expense of every other community, a zero sum game. Yes a muhajir brought over designs from the Netherlands (Holland) of nuclear centrifuges used in enriching uranium, he was then handsomely rewarded by the state for that job and also made head of the program, he was a metallurgist and that was his expertise, thousands of scientists and engineers worked on building those centrifuges, getting parts from all over the world usually in illegal ways according to the Jawa of those countries and in doing so risked their freedom and very often their lives, but they are never mentioned, why is that. Let’s just say the centrifuges have been built, is that it, who established a he uranium mines, who built them, who mined the ore, who refined it to a rudimentary level, again thousands of people involved yet only the bane ofQ Khan ever mentioned in order to brainwash people. Then there is the long and laborious process of the actual enrichment of uranium to weapons grade uranium, no easy feat in itself, again probably hundreds of not thousands of engineers and scientists working on that project, but no mention of anybody else. That is just the uranium enrichment part, did AQ Khan have any contribution in this gr other parts of the project? Did he design and build the detonator, the most crucial, critical and important component and a n fact the most difficult and complex , NO, tge designs came straight from China, nothing to do with a muhajir, what about the design of the overall nuclear bomb itself, who was that by, again the answer is it was provided by China, yet you big up one man at the expense of everybody else, even people who lost their lives in the endeavour, rather shameful behaviour in my humble opinion. Then there is the delivery mechanism, after all what good is a nuclear warhead if it can’t be delivered to its target, the missiles were at that time provided by North Korea including their technology, once again absolutely nothing to do with AQ Khan, then there is the capability to launch nuclear missiles from jet fighters that had to be developed, that was done by the airforce, in fact the whole project was organised and carried on by the military and of course funded by the state. The nuclear program started in the time of President Field Marshal General Mohammed Ayub Khan (I know most muhajirs don’t like him as he took power away from you and also moved the capital to where it should be), again funded by the state, it was taken to near by another great person (for all his faults) Mr Bhutto who basically took the project forward against massive international objections and pressure, he dealt with the pressure not AQ Khan, and he had to suffer the consequences, he also did one other good thing in getting rid of the Bengali menace, tge vest thing that could have happened to West Pakistan, then there is President Zia, ten years he guarded the project and tge likelihood is that the “bomb” was achieved early on in his government, then there is Ghulam Ishaq Khan, then Nawaz and Benazir, and then Musharraf, granted he was a muhajir but still a representative of the state and it was under his rule that AQ Khan was placed under house arrest and blamed for nuclear proliferation, not done by any native Pakistani but by one of your own, and after Musharraf came Zardari and Nawaz and the program carried on, yet one man apparently according to muhajirs gave Pakistan its nuclear protection, oh Lord help me. It is the state that has organised, nurtured, protected and financed every single aspect of this absolutely huge undertaking, not an individual, and it probably cost many many billions of dollars, yes give credit where it’s due, 1) the centrifuge designs or blueprints taken from the Dutch company, 2) his work in finding the correct alloys to make the centrifuges with, that had to be researched and developed in Pakistan and again many many scientists and engineers (and machinists, but nobody cares for them in this elitist world) worked tirelessly for many years to get that right through trial and error and experimentation, again all credit to one man, wow what a false v B a restive that has been built up and shoved down the throats of Pakistanis especially native Pakistanis, but this kind of propaganda doesn’t have the same effect anymore. So to conclude this part let me say that had it not been for say AQ Khan then the state would have acquired those uranium enrichment centrifuges through some other means, it is that simple, Pakistan has been sanctioned many times over many decades but like any other country in a pickle it has ways and means, the rest of the work would continue regardless as it has done, whether it be the building of the facilities, their protection whether militarily or politically and of course their financing, and every other aspect that required tge input of thousands of engineers and scientists, so no a muhajir didn’t give Pakistan its nuclear bomb although he had a contribution like many others and in fact he should be thankful to the state that he was given such a high position and also paid so well. But what was the main topic of tge thread and my comment, the OP mentioned Afghan migrants (refugees) being in Pakistan so why not bring in the Biharis of Bangladesh, my response was to that, why should Pakistan bring them over, what’s wrong with Bangladesh as a country, it’s a Muslim country too and in the wider scheme of things it too was made as a home for the Muslims of South Asia, but yet Bangladesh is beneath these Biharis the country to which their parents and grandparents migrated to from India and tgey were born in and spent their whole life, not only that tgey were offered Bangladeshi citizenship in 1972 yet arrogantly refused that offer and instead “voluntarily” went into refugee camps in the hopes of being settled in Pakistan (West), a land and country tgey had absolutely no connection with, not ethnic, not linguistic and not cultural, yet Pakistan was meant to accommodate them, using deceptive terms like repatriation, you can only be repatriated to a place that you are from or even gave a link with, these people had no historical affiliation or link either with the people of Pakistan or with the land whether it be Sindh, Baluchistan, KPK+FATA or Punjab or the two allied territories of Pakistan, Azad Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan, that is a fact that simply can NOT be denied, besides shouldn’t it be up to us as the majority and as natives of this country (simply by right and by the fact that it is our very own land and country) to decide who can and can’t come to this country, it is in that basis that I have objected to bringing in the Biharis of Bangladesh, but not only them I reject allowing in any more Indian Muslims in general and also allowing in any more Rohingiyas as it is against tge interests of the native peoples of Pakistan, what’s wrong with that view, logic and intellect please, not emotions. So again why not tge Biharis be loyal citizens of Bangladesh and accept the offer of citizenship so generously offered to them in 1972 instead of stapling g the government and people of Bangladesh in the face, why the urge to come to Pakistan and leave the land of their elders? The rest of my comment was a counter to the OP’s proposal or call for accommodating or settling the Biharis in Pakistan by saying let’s get rid of all foreigners including the Afghans who again were mentioned by the OP, as though to say we have these Afghans so let’s bring in Biharis too, actually no, if the Afghans are a problem then that should be removed, not the problem doubled, so why not get rid of all of them and problem solved. I personally am not calling for the removal of people from Pakistan who are settled and citizens, the point was to show how stupid the original argument about bringing over the Biharis was. But I will say this that I 100% stand by not allowing in to Pakistan a single Bihari,Rohingiya or Indian Muslim in general, and I 100% stand by the last part of my comment that “Pakistan isn’t a yateem khana, ‘anath ashram’ or orphanage for the unhappy Muslims of South Asia nor is it a dumping ground for the worlds refugees”, 100% I stand by that, tell me which country had taken in as many foreigners and refugees as Pakistan to tge point of causing major demographic instability to parts of its population, to the point where the refugees and immigrants or their offspring demand a separate province which is simply the initial stage to a separate country, no country has done that and nor would any country ever tolerate such obnoxious demands, so allowing in more Biharis can only make that situation worse and only intensify such ridiculous demands and after spending thirty odd years and the lives of thousands of Punjabis, Pakhtuns and Sindhis in the military, the rangers and the police in order to smash the lines of the MQM we simply cannot risk allowing anyone else in to Pakistan, that’s just how it is. We can’t take that risk, nor can we allow a separate muhajir province ever, it is not acceptable to the Sindhis and nor is it acceptable to any of the people of the other provinces, that bring the case why on earth would a sane minded native Pakistani want more muhajirs or Biharis to come to Pakistan, it would be suicide, hence people should remain in their own ancestral lands and not antagonise others, thank you. Pakistan Zindabaad Sindh Zindabaad Punjab Zindabaad, lol, lol Pakistan Zindabaad

Government of Pakistan should be bring them back Pakistan

Behari pakistani bhaion ko pakistan aana chaey..

I proud to be a behari and hum Nye is Pakistan k lye do dafa hijrat ki phly India se phly mashriqi Pakistan 1947 main phir 1971 main Dhaka fall py phir Pakistan aye.. Pakistani government ko bohat zimadari sirf inki hi banti hai k wo inko Pakistan wapis lye... Kitna zulm howa hai Allah jald is masly ko hall farmye.

Thank you Public TV for highlighting this issue

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

What is wrong with Bangladesh? It’s a Muslim country isn’t it? So why Pakistan and do the natives of Pakistan want any more Biharis or Rohingiyas or Indian Muslims migrating here? Probably not, I’d be willing to test that in a referendum. Pakistan Zindabaad

Ham vi Bangladesh ka Dhaka ganava camp ka rahna wala hu i love Pakistan ❤❤❤❤

@antaraanikapiya

2 жыл бұрын

So please go to Pakistan and leave my country alone. You guys eat and breathe in my land and yet your love for this land is nonexistent, rather a land thousand miles away makes you feel at home, who doesn’t even want you or care for you. bah bah! 👏🙄

@Sonyasaad

2 жыл бұрын

We care our brother and sister.not.only bihari are our brother..all indian muslim brothers and bangladeshi are our brothers.ok

It is a tragedy, they need to be brought back, Pakistan needs to right this wrong

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

They can’t be brought “back” to Pakistan when they were never here or from here in the first place, they never had anything to do with West Pakistan, their only place to go back to is Bharat matta (Bihar) or stay in their own country (Bangladesh, formerly known as East Pakistan) that heir grandparents and parents migrated to, all it (Bangladesh) did was change names from East Pakistan to Bangladesh, ohh poor Biharis don’t like the name change, or is the truth they want to come to Pakistan so they don’t have to compete with the local Bengalis in the Bengali language and the fact that Urdu as a language has about as much value in Bangladesh as a piece of sh1t and their entire identity is built around Urdu, how sad, yes of course Pakistan should turn the Sindhis into a minority in their own land and country just to please these bu*thurt bihar1s and to please muhajirs in general who go around calling native Pakistanis of whatever ethnic or linguistic origin or of whatever province in Karachi as “ghair maqami”, lol, how utterly stupid of the ones from Bharat matta. Pakistan Zindabaad

@amnamumtaz8774

Жыл бұрын

They don't be trusted, like they betrayed bengalis by collabrating with Pakistan back in 1971. They may collabrate with taliban or americans in future against Pakistan , for God sake don't send them to Pakistan. Their history say that They don't loyal to their country of residence.

They are free to leave Bangladesh for their beloved Pakistan but it is pyara pyare Pakistan that is letting them down by not taking them back, so it's a kick in the teeth to them but yet these guys are clueless and still day dreaming to this day of returning to Pakistan or India. I would be happy if they want to leave Bangladesh, whatever is best for them plus it would free up some much needed space in Bangladesh, we shouldn't get in the way of them leaving but it is India or Pakistan that is not taking them back so this isn't our fault. I wish them all the best and yes the BD government should always help them even if it means sending back to Pakistan by way of agreement on a government level.

@donjames7647

Жыл бұрын

Bangladesh government need to accept a million bengolies so they can leave pakistan and india to make place for behari people . Pakistan and india needs to put bengolies in camps like animals

@abhinay4200

9 ай бұрын

they arer not Indians , just leave them at sea

Trust me bangali brothers r much more faithful then afgan brothers. I deal with both communities.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

I don’t trust you, you just want to fill Pakistan up with illegals, aliens, foreigners, immigrants and the offspring of immigrants, whether they be muhajirs from India, Biharis of Bangladesh or Rohingiyas, regardless of how good any of them are they are still aliens and unlike tge Afghans you mention gave absolutely nothing to do with Pakistan whether it be in terms of race, ethnicity, heritage, language, culture or even geographically, those are facts and you are more than welcome to try and refute them, facts are facts and emotions are emotions. Pakistan Zindabaad

@naeemtahir2012

2 жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 alien? Why you say that?

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@naeemtahir2012 Go ahead and check what alien(s) means in a dictionary, we are not talking little green men from Pluto or outer space.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Alien is somebody that is a stranger to your land, hence a Rohingiya or an Ind1an Musl1m or a Bihari are all aliens to the lands of Pakistan, in other words like a stranger, not like the natives or the original inhabitants such as tge Sindhis, Baluch, Pakhtuns, Punjabis and Kashmiris etc, hence the terms aliens, foreigners, outsiders, refugees and immigrants go together. If I say that Chinese person or a Vietnamese person is alien to the land of Pakistan then it should make sense, but that Chinaman can never be considered to be alien to China. Pakistan Zindabaad

@naeemtahir2012

2 жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 you calling bangali and bahri aliens? Tusi panjabi ta nahi? Only a panjabi can look down at people's like this. They r much batter Muslim then our peoples more educated more seccessful. What u say now?

in logon ki sbse badi ghalti ya thi ke inhon ne ghddar pakistan ka sath diya ghddar generalon aor hukmrano ka sath diya. ye woh laanti mulk he jahan pakiatan ko todne wale 20lakh bangalion ko sheheryat milgai rehne ke liye. woh afghanistan jo hr din border pr pakistan ki maa behen ek krta he un 30lakh afghanion ko sr ka taj bna kr apne mulk me rkha hua he. jinhon ne apna sb kuchh qurban kiya is laanti mulk keliy woh aor unki nslen brbad hogain.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

What’s wrong with Bangladesh?

Pakistan stabbed these people in the back. These people remained loyal to Pakistan in 1971 and STILL remain loyal. They are waiting for the last fifty years to move to Pakistan.

پاکستان انکو ضرور اپنے یہاں کسی بھی جگہ لاکر بسا دے، یہ وہ پاکستانی ہے جو کسی بھی پاکستانی سے زیادہ پاکستان سے محبّت کرتے ہیں، ایک راستہ یہ بھی ہے کہ انہیں گوادر میں لاکر ایک چھوتی سے سہولت کے ساتھ جگہ دے دے، دیکھ لینا ہے گوادر کی ترقّی میں وہ کام کرینگے اور سبز بڑھ کے خود کو خود کے ملک کے لیے اپنا سب کچھ قربان کرینگے، ضرور عمران خان کو یہ سوچنا چاہیے

Please bring these our brother back please all this mess bhutto created for one nation. V love our brother and sister. PAKISTAN IS UNITED AND we R 1.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Bhutto was a great person, he got rid of the Bengali menace otherwise there would probably be fifty or sixty million ethnic Bengalis/Bangladeshis squatting in Pakistan right now screwing up the delicate ethnic, linguistic and cultural balance, cohesion and harmony of Pakistan and turning the natives into minorities in their very own land and country just like what has almost happened to the Sindhis, no thanks. This would have been on top of the six million Bengalis already here and who refuse to go back and the thirty plus million muhajirs and the millions of Rohingiyas, if bhaiyas are demanding a separate muhajir province and then a separate muhajir country as it is now then had we stayed united (what a stupid union on paper only) with East Pakistan/Bangladesh then it would gave Vern impossible to stop such demands, we as native Pakistanis couldn’t allow that to happen, so good riddance to Bangladesh and thank you Mr Bhutto, a great job well done, bravo! Pakistan Zindabaad

پاکستان میں جتنی لُوٹ مار ایک سیاستدان،ایک بیوروکریٹ یا ایک جرنیل کرتا ھے صرف اتنی رقم سے پاکستان کے ان اصل مالکوں کو کا کر آباد کیا جا سکتا ھے۔اگر پاکستان میں ایک بھی غیرت مند مسلمان صاحب اقتدار ھے تو

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

No thanks. Tell me when these same people turn around and start demanding even more loudly than is the case now for a separate muhajir province and a separate muhajir country then what, why take that risk, why take the risk of further turning native peoples of Pakistan into minorities in their very own land and country, especially the Sindhis who are almost there and are for all practical purposes disenfranchised from the larger urban areas of Sindh, why take the risk of antagonising them and putting Pakistan further into danger, why when all of these people whether muhajirs in general, Biharis, Bengalis or Rohingiyas absolutely hate the native peoples of Pakistan, why should we let them into Pakistan? I can’t think of a single reasonable and sensible reason to settle these people in Pakistan. Plus tgey gave zero connection with Pakistan whether it be ethnic, linguistic or cultural nor any geographical link like say the Kashmiris or the Afghans, I say no thanks to this BS. Pakistan Zindabaad

پاکستان گوررنمنٹ واپس لائے ان مسلمانوں کو

Pakistan ko wapis lena chaiye ab

wait, are you deaf? This is being talked now, isnt it? Thanks Pakistan for raising awareness.

آسان حل یہی ہے جو بنگالی کراچی میں رہتے ہیں ان کو بھیج کر ان لوگوں کو وہاں آباد کریں

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Even easier get rid of the Bengalis in Pakistan, get rid of tge Biharis already in Pakistan, let’s forget about the Biharis in Bangladesh and also get rid of the Rohingiyas, that sounds much better. Pakistan Zindabaad

It is the responsibility of the government of Pakistan. These people madly love Pakistan, still today, they don’t believe in Bangladesh. It’s not the responsibility of Bangladeshi government. Pakistani government has failed to bring these people to Pakistan. No blame should be put on Bangladeshi government.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Why is Pakistan responsible and not Bangladesh, and why should the Biharis come to Pakistan as opposed to stay In Bangladesh. Is Bangladesh not good enough for them? Do they not like the Bengali language, do they have any connection with the land of Pakistan (West)? Of course they gave no connection with Pakistan. Your other point about them loving Pakistan or wanting to come to Pakistan is a complete irrelevance, I too want to go to New Zealand and am madly in love with New Zealand and the USA, and Australia and Canada etc but does that mean that the government of New Zealand (or any other country) is in any way obligated to abide by my wishes, of course it isn’t, are the people of New Zealand obligated to abide by my desire to settle there, of course NOT, what are you going to call them racist or something for making such sovereign decisions like any people, society or country is entitled and duty bound to do and make. As a b native Pakistani I am sick to death of hearing about Biharis, Bengalis, muhajirs and Rohingiyas. This country Pakistan is not a yateem khana, “anath ashram” or orphanage for the unhappy Muslims of South Asia nor is it a dumping ground for the worlds refugees, thanks for your support. Pakistan Zindabaad

@abhinay4200

9 ай бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 idiot as mentioned in the story, they wanted to come to Pakistan but Jinnah forced them to go to Bangladesh to work in Railways . Pakistan should take these Biharis.

@salahshah3858

8 ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂

Pakistan should fulfil its responsibility and bring back these patriotic pakistanis to Pakistan

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Why is Pakistan responsible?

@jamilsiddiqui1985

2 жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 They are Pakistani nationals and have a right to come to Pakistan, both morally and legally

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@jamilsiddiqui1985 But they are not Pakistani nationals though are they, they are Bangladeshis and the last time I checked Bangladesh is a Muslim country and as such it is equally responsible for tge accommodation and settlement of these Biharis. Besides what have they got to do with Pakistan, NOTHING, they have no link or connection to Pakistan (West) whatsoever whether it be ethnic, linguistic, cultural or for that matter even geographical, they have no link with any of the native peoples of Pakistan and no connection with any province or territory of Pakistan so why on earth is Pakistan responsible to accept them. These people were offered Bangladeshi citizenship in 1972 (an offer that still stands for those willing to take it and become Bangladeshi citizens) but these Biharis rejected that offer and opted to go into refugee camps in the hopes of being one day settled in Pakistan, why is Bangladesh so beneath these Biharis that they can’t accept Bangladeshi citizenship, or is it that after 1971 they would have to compete with the local Bengalis on a level playing field in the Bengali language and the advantage that they previously enjoyed over the Bengalis because of Urdu would no longer apply and the fact that the Urdu language wouldn’t even be worth sh1t and these people had built their entire identity around Urdu, ohh poor Biharis, how sad, and instead the Biharis want to come to Pakistan, specifically Karachi so they have the advantage of Urdu and at the same time can further turn the Sindhis into a minority in their very own land and country (the Sindhis are nearly there already), cause further demographic instability, diminish even more the ethnic, linguistic, cultural balance, cohesion and harmony in Sindh and exasperate even more tge disenfranchisement if the Sindhis from the larger urban areas of Sindh, instead we should be bringing in millions more of these Biharis who have nothing to do with Pakistan, no thanks to such BS. Let us for a moment accept that we bring these Biharis to Pakistan and further turn Pakistan from a country into a yateem khana then what? Wouldn’t that intensify the already very loud demands for a separate muhajir province and a separate muhajir country, so why should we bring in more of these people when tomorrow tgey will just fill the ranks of the MQM and other like minded parties, why let rookie in to Pakistan who absolutely hate the natives of this country whether they be Punjabis, Sindhis, Baluch, Pakhtuns or Kashmiris and would calve up Sindh and tear Pakistan apart, o can’t take that risk and I would be fully with long to leave it up to a referendum to decide, not just about the Biharis, but the Bengalis, the Rohingiyas and the concept of mass migration of Ind1an Musl1ms from India, do we really want to open the borders of our country, not me. These people couldn’t live with their non Muslim neighbours in India in 1947 and came to Pakistan West and many millions to East Pakistan, in West Pakistan they were so bloodthirsty that they terrorised their native Sindhi Hindus and Parsis and forced them all to leave the major urban centres of Sindh like Karachi and Hyderabad and took everything that belonged to those people, probably one of the greatest crimes in human history even worse than what the Israel1s did to the Palestinians, they then in East Pakistan couldn’t live with the native Bengalis and came running to Pakistan (West) a land they have nothing to do with and then started all the troubles in Sindh, is that a coincidence, the MQM, tge demand for a separate muhajir province, the expulsion of the Punjabis in the late 1980’s and early 1990’s, their attempts to expel the Sindhis and the Baluch from Karachi, just look at where Karachi is on the map, in Sindh right next to Baluchistan and they also couldn’t tolerate the Pakhtuns, all of these groups are natives to Pakistan but they couldn’t tolerate any of them, and now their ever increasing demands for a separate muhajir province and then country, can Pakistan take the risk to even allow in one single Bihari, Indian Muslim or Rohingiya knowing all of this, I don’t think so, and at the end of the day I really don’t care one bit, their country is either Bangladesh or Bihar (Bharat matta), it’s that simple. Pakistan Zindabaad

@jamilsiddiqui1985

2 жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 Pakistan Zindabad! They are Pakistanis by any definition and as such they have the right to settle in any part of Pakistan. Besides they don't have to give up their mother tongue - urdu. You are absolutely ignorant of the history of Pakistan and are promoting factionalism and son of the soil and non son of the soil concept which is detrimental to the solidarity of the country

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@jamilsiddiqui1985 I’m not promoting any such thing, just being pragmatic and practical, tgeir convection is with East Bengal/East Pakistan/Bangladesh, not with what was once West Pakistan, their country simply changed its name to Bangladesh, tgey should have automatically accepted Bangladeshi citizenship as it was offered in 1972, tell me that’s a lie if I’m so ignorant, tgey refused to become Bangladeshi citizens and opted instead to go into refugee camps (their choice), tell me I’m wrong about that too as apparently I’m ignorant, and tgey did this with the hope of one day being settled in Pakistan (West) a land they have nothing to do with, fact. Tell me what is wrong with Bangladesh, why can’t they accept that as their country, tell me logically without emotionalism and resorting to calling me ignorant, and by the way I know Kentucky about the history of Pakistan and the history of the Pakistan movement, I don’t need any lessons from anyone, thanks. Again tell me is it promoting factionalism or division when it is the muhajirs demanding a separate muhajir province and a separate muhajir country, why in earth should we bring in more Biharis, muhajirs, Bengalis and Rohingyas when every single one of these gates the native peoples of Pakistan and even call us “ghair maqami”, lol and they will only add to the demands for the break up of Sindh and therefore Pakistan, simply put we can’t allow that and we can’t take that risk, I can’t help it if you don’t like it but that’s the way it is, besides it should be for us native Pakistanis to decide who can and can NOT come to Pakistan, I’d have thought that was pretty elementary. Pakistan Zindabaad Sindh Zindabaad Punjab Zindabaad, lol, lol Pakistan Zindabaad

Pakistan should bring them to Pakistan

Why not pak govt bring back all of them ,

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Why?

@indusreaction8664

2 жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 🙃

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@indusreaction8664 Well go on then, let’s have your academic and logical reasoning as to why it’s a good idea to bring these Biharis to Pakistan, not “back” to Pakistan as you state as they were never here in the first place, were never from here and have absolutely no connection with Pakistan (West) whatsoever, whether it be ethnic, linguistic, cultural or even geographic unlike say the Kashmiris or the Afghans, those are facts, not emotions, you are more than welcome to try and refute those facts. Also let me know what is wrong with Bangladesh as a country, is it not Musl1m country, are the Bengalis not human beings that the Biharis consider them beneath themselves to the extent that they can’t accept the offer of Bangladeshi citizenship that was offered to them in 1972, is it that they have to compete with the local Bengalis on a level playing field in the Bengali language and that the Urdu language has absolutely no value there and these people have built their entire identity around Urdu, poor Biharis, so they wish to come to Pakistan, more specifically Karachi where they will have the advantage of the Urdu language and where they can further turn the poor Sindhis into a minority in their very own land and country, the Sindhis are pretty close already to becoming a minority, tell me who in their right mind wants to become a minority in their own country or become the equivalent of the Palestinians, not me for sure. Let’s for tge sake of argument accept that they are allowed to come to Pakistan (God forbid) will they just not add to the voices of muhajirs who are already demanding a separate muhajir province and a separate muhajir country, why have more of these people when the risks are so great, in fact why even allow a single Bihari, even one more Ind1an Musl1m (muhajir) or one more Rohingiya into Pakistan when they hate the native people of Pakistan and will turn into a security threat for Pakistan especially for Sindh and the Sindhis, I call BS on all the emotional arguments and calls to settle the biharis in Pakistan, you will have to do better than a stupid emoji, lol. Pakistan Zindabaad Sindh Zindabaad Punjab Zindabaad, lol, lol Pakistan Zindabaad

Imran khan prime minister of Pakistan please in Saab Pakistaniyo ko Bangladesh se wapis le kar aao please Allah pak ke liye please prime minister

Why can't we expose this and create more awareness in our current government

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

What’s wrong with Bangladesh.

Pakistan government should bring them back to Pakistan and Bangladesh should recognize them if they don't want to come back. And Bengalis in Pakistan should also recognized by Pakstani government.

aaj bangla desh ki maishiyt aor currency is bhikari mulk se ziyada mzbut he. bangla desh bhik mangkr 50 salon me traqqi kr liya aor pakistan bhik mang mang kr bhkari ka bhikari hi reh gaya. halat yaha tk aagai ke tmam srkari adare bikna shuru ho gaye estate bank bhi hath se gaya ab iske baad army navy air force nuclear plant bhi bohot jald bik jae ga.insha allah baqi reh jae ga baba ji ka ghanta sari zindagi qom aor hukmran use hi bjate rehna.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Well go to Bangladesh then if it’s so good and Pakistan so bad and take all these Biharis, bhaiyas, Gujjus, Marathas, Dakhans (Takhans), Tamils, Bengalis (yes there are over six million of them squatting in Pakistan) and the Rohingiyas, it will be much appreciated, after all Pakistan is so sh1t isn’t it? Pakistan Zindabaad

Why did they betrayed our country. They deserve that treat

Look I'm a Bangladeshi, But I never heard these thinks, 🤨

TWO. NATION THEORY. ZINDA. BHAG.

Very nice show love from Khulna, Bangladesh ♥♥

Eyieh Imran khan Ka Zimawari Ghey Iska Koyieh Hal Ghoona Chayieh

Sare jahan se achha Hindostaa hmara I love my india

Wapas laya jaya in sab ko. Bangle wapas beyjo aur Pakistani ko wapas laya jai.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

But tgey are not Pakistanis though are they? No connection with Pakistan whatsoever. No link whether ethnic, linguistic or cultural or even geographic like the Kashmiris or Afghans have, so the answer has to be a massive NO. Pakistan Zindabaad

@renoxfreefire9651

Жыл бұрын

Bangladesh me jo Bihari hai bo acche jindegi ji Raha hai abb bhikhari ko leke ham quality life jine walo ke sath exchange nhi kar sakte bhul jaw

@likematestopprocrastinatin946

Жыл бұрын

Quality life?literally the most polluted corrupt country on the planet is Bangladesh lmfaoooo

PM Imran Khan should bring these people to Pakistan

Pakistani govt must being them back ، they are the true pakistanis read history

It was fall down of Pakistan and it's a saqoot-e-Islamabad but it is not fall of Dhaka. It was rise of Dhaka. Its a fastest growing mega city in South Asia. Pakistan and Pakistan Army officially surrender in Dhaka in 16 Dec 1971 but Dhaka did not surrender. Pakistan was surrender both way politically and Militarily in Dhaka. Don't be emotional because East Bengal was never a part of Pakistan but it was a colony of Pakistan. Bengali people and East Bengal were treated as 3rd class citizen and burden of Pakistan. Pakistan never treated them as equal. East and West never were a brother, its a misconception of Pakistan and there were no brotherhood policy in Pakistan, Relation was like Owner and slave, Don't you know that from 1947 to 1971 Pakistan systematically took all the revenue and resources from east Bengal. After 24 years of partition why in 1971 East Bengal became as 2nd poorest part in the world. Still Pakistan doing same unhuman injustice with Baloch people in Baluchistan. So don't be emotional because its not just for you and its not suite for the people of Pakistan. Thanks God Bangladesh has been saved in 1971.Almighty Creator is a great planner. Otherwise Bangladesh would had been situation like as Baluchistan or Afghanistan. Pakistan should release the chief justice Humidor Rahman Report on 1971 war. People of Pakistan should take right education from the right sources and should correct the history paper of Pakistan. Game of Throne among the Punjabis Army in Pakistan has been going on last 75 years, its a Great Show on the Earth only get to see in Pakistan, hope this will long for next 75 years. If the Grass look greener on the other side, Stop staring, Stop comparing ,Stop complaining, and Start watering the grass you are standing on ..%%

Harmeet ne buhat acha sowal othaya hai.

Subscribed after this

Where there is a will there should be a way. Government should make a concrete plan to settle them . Make a city for them in Pakistan

ان کو کیا خبر ہو گی کہ قربانیاں دے کر آئیں گے جس منزل کی تلاش میں لا الہ الا اللہ کی خاطر. ربع صدی گزرنے سے پہلے بنگالی اسے محض اپنی قوم کا صرف اپنا دیش قرار دے دیں گے افسوس کہ کوئی مدینہ کا انصار نہ بن سکا نہ بنگلہ دیش نہ پاکستان

Friends of community should try to relocate some of them as a genuine refugies in USA.

👍💐👏👏🤔😊

Pak go

مل کے بھی ان سے منزل چھن گئی💔 ہجرت کر کے اس کے مصائب سہہ کے آئے تھے محض پاکستان کی تلاش میں

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

East Pakistan simply changed its name to Bangladesh otherwise it’s the same place, no reason for the Biharis not to be loyal citizens of Bangladesh, and do remember Bangladesh is a Muslim country too but for some reason it seems like it is beneath these Biharis. Plus if Pakistan allows them in then they will only add to and intensify the already loud demands for a separate muhajir province and a separate muhajir country, can Pakistan really take that chance, can the native peoples of Pakistan really risk that and can Sindh take that risk, I think not. Pakistan Zindabaad

contempt of court petition was filed with the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court today against Dhaka North City Corporation (DNCC) Mayor Atiqul Islam and six others on charge of conducting an eviction drive in Dhaka's Mirpur-11 ignoring its chamber judge's order of status quo on the eviction. The six others are chief estate officer of DNCC Mozammel Haque, its chief engineer Brigadier General Aminul Islam, commissioner of Dhaka Metropolitan Police (DMP) Shafiqul Islam, its deputy commissioner (Mirpur zone) Mahtab Uddin, councilor of Ward-5 of DNCC Abdur Rauf and officer-in-charge of Mirpur Police Station Kazi Wazed Ali. Masud Alam, Md Jiban and Md Nader Hossain submitted the petition to the apex court, saying that the respondents evicted them from their designated (Bihari) camp on January 21 and 22 by willful disobedience of court's order though they showed the order. The respondents have not honoured the court's order which is a contempt of court, and so, they may be punished as per law, petitioner's lawyer Sagir Hossain Leon told The Daily Star, citing the petition. After a brief hearing on the petition, chamber judge of the Appellate Division Justice Md Nuruzzaman today sent the petition to its full bench for hearing on the matter on April 11. Lawyer Sagir Hossain Leon said the High Court Division of the SC in a verdict in 2018 had cleared the way for the authorities concerned to evict the Bihari camp in block-C of Mirpur-11. Later residents of the camp filed a petition with the Appellate Division seeking stay on the HC verdict. Following the stay petition, the chamber judge of the Appellate Division on October 6, 2018 issued an order of status quo on the eviction drive. In continuation of the case, the apex court chamber judge on October 29, 2020 issued another order of status quo on the eviction till May 2 this year. READ MORE: DNCC eviction drive continues In the meantime, the respondents have conducted the eviction drive and demolished around 300 structures including 150 shops in violation of the chamber judge's order, the lawyer added. He said the petitioners prayed to the Appellate Division to issue a contempt of court rule against the respondents and to summon them to appear before the court for giving explanation on the issue.

they are pakistani....bring them back

jb Afghanistan k logon ko panah di jaskti he tou in mazloom Pakistanion k liay amli iqdamat kiun nhi

What about Bangladeshi living in Pakistan.

PAkistan ZINDABAD 💕

Wapis lay kar ay unko g

Bangladesh mey jo Pakistani 71 mey reh gaye hai oun ko wapis lana chahiye..

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

Wait what? Some Punjabis, Sindhis, Baluch, Pakhtuns or Kashmiris are still in Bangladesh , I never new any such people migrated to East Pakistan/Bangladesh except on business or deputation from West Pakistan to East Pakistan on behalf of the federal government or military of that time, this is news to me, yes please break no back the non existent Punjabis, Sindhis, Baluch, Pakhtuns and Kashmiris apparently stranded in Bangladesh, lol. Pakistan Zindabaad

mare vhai eye juta baat hay,bangladesh ma bihari logoune bhut acca jindegi basar raha bay.

Tum.logun ko shram aniy chahea humare behn bhai wehun zulm ki chakiy me oes rahe hun kay ke ao aoni shakkun goum kero unko lay ke ao pakistan

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

They were actually offered Bangladeshi citizenship in 1972 if you care to check, but they didn’t want to compete with the Bengali locals on a level playing field in the Bengali language and the fact that the Urdu language had about as much value in Bangladesh as a piece of sh1t, something they had built their entire identity around and so stupidly rejected that offer of Bangladeshi citizenship (still open if they wish to accept it) and instead opted to stay in refugee camps (their choice) in the hopes of one day being allowed to settle in Pakistan, meaning in Karachi where tgey would gave the advantage of Urdu which would be absent in BD and could also further turn tge Sindhis into a minority in their own land and country and all this despite the fact that they have absolutely nothing to do with Pakistan (West) whether it be ethnic, linguistic, cultural or geographic, NONE, and as such Pakistan has no responsibility whatsoever for them. Tgey should accept Bangladeshi citizenship and become loyal citizens of Bangladesh, it’s that simple or is it too complicated for you. Pakistan Zindabaad

@shoaibbutt7775

2 жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 yes I see what's going on there but there is my people Pakistani people we left their we must be bring it in Pakistan thanks for giving answer

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@shoaibbutt7775 See that’s where you are wrong, they are not my people, they are not a people connected in any way shape or form to any of the native peoples of Pakistan, they are not a people connected to Pakistan as a whole (talking about West Pakistan) or to any of its provinces or territories, they have no links to Pakistan or its people whether ethnic, linguistic, cultural or even geographic, they are from a land that is thousands of miles away from Pakistan and in fact a land that is next to West Bengal and therefore by extension East Pakistan/Bangladesh, their grandparents and parents migrated to East Pakistan, they grew old and died there and these people now were born there, grew up there and spent their entire life’s their and yet they have no connection or loyalty to Bangladesh and wish to come to Pakistan a land which neither they or their parents or grandparents or ancestors have ever seen, whose languages they don’t speak and in fact whose people they hate. Do tell me how on earth they are our people, they are not the people of any of the natives of Pakistan whether they ve Sindhis, Baluch, Pakhtuns, Punjabis or Kashmiris etc, they may well be the people of the muhajirs and I understand it from their point of view to bring in to Pakistan as many aliens, foreigners, refugees and immigrants in order to increase their numbers vis-à-vis the Sindhis in particular and all the native communities in general at least as far as Sindh is concerned, increased numbers, increased demands, intensification of the demands for a separate muhajir province and a separate muhajir country, these people, the Biharis and by extension the muhajirs and the Rohingiyas all hate the natives and are dangerous to Pakistan and its people, as soon ch I’m not in any way in favour of taking such a risk with either the territorial integrity of Sindh or that of Pakistan, so to answer the question, NO, they are definitely not our people but they may be yours and Pakistan sure as hell isn’t responsible for them. Let me ask again what is wrong with Bangladesh as a country, is it not a Muslim country that these Biharis can’t live there, is it the fact that the language there is Bengali and rightly so that these Biharis can’t live there with the local and native Bengalis, do we really want such people here in Pakistan? Again tell me logically why Pakistan is responsible for them and why they are allegedly “our people”, not emotions but logic and facts. Pakistan Zindabaad

@shoaibbutt7775

2 жыл бұрын

@@madeehasaeed786 how you did says not people my dear use right words for human I am talking about that Bihari people

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@shoaibbutt7775 I think you have issues in simple English comprehension, read my comment again and tell me where I said they are not a people, I said they are not my people but they may be yours and or they may be the muhajir’s, but nowhere did I say tgey are either not a people or worse still not “people”, how ridiculous of a claim for you to make, again all emotions and no facts or logics, you are welcome to take the points raised one by one and challenge them, tell what point I made that was not factual or was a lie, please. Pakistan Zindabaad

They are rajakar.

PUNJABI and SINDHI govermemt not provide the acess biharo come to pakistan real pakistani wahn maar rahen han afghani aur falan falan yahn han.

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

If you think that about the Punjabi and Sindhi governments just wait till you ask the governments and people of both Baluchistan and KPK+FATA, you will then get to know the real price of tomatoes, lol. None of the native peoples of Pakistan want these Biharis to be settled anywhere in Pakistan, especially in Sindh for tgey are a danger to the peoples of Pakistan and to Pakistan as a country, they will only increase the demand for a separate muhajir province and a separate muhajir country, sorry, no can do. Pakistan Zindabaad

😪

Kya ya loog west pakistan se gaey thay? Ya behar sa ja kar east pakistan abad houway thay?

@naeemtahir2012

3 жыл бұрын

They went from Indians stats and loads of them r from there

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@naeemtahir2012 In other words they have nothing to do with Pakistan. Pakistan Zindabaad

These people break bengal in 1905 and established Muslim league. Ab Maza aya.

Bangladesh Government accept them. And they have Bangladeshi citizenship.

You are saying they are pakistani, still you don't want them take back, you want Bangladesh to give the citizenship.

The main reason is that Punjab doesn't want to add Urdu-speaking people in Punjab. Pathan can get all the facilities in Pakistan but no Urdu Speaking Pakistanis.

@PTI.Shorts

3 жыл бұрын

kis ny kaha Punjab Add ni krna chahta?

@naeemtahir2012

3 жыл бұрын

Bakwas

@GREEN-gu9ud

2 жыл бұрын

Bakwas band kar tou apni Musharraf bhi Bangladesh gaya tha wo r Tou Urdu speaking tha wo kyun nahi lekar aya wapis lanati insan

@GREEN-gu9ud

2 жыл бұрын

Punjab ma add bhi hojain tou Punjab ko koi farq NAHI pare ga na population demographics change Hogi na hi land ki koi kami ha

I'm proud muslim and I don't like bihari muslim and bihari hindu 🤬🤬

Pakistan m pahle Panah gazeen kam hain?

@GREEN-gu9ud

2 жыл бұрын

Aik dafa Apne aap ko us jagah rakh kar soocho Fikr na karo unhe Sindh ma NAHI Abad Kiya jaye ga

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@GREEN-gu9ud Don’t want them in Punjab either, and you are also welcome to ask the people of Baluchistan and KPK if they want them but I’m sure you know the answer to that question, try holding a referendum and see what happens. Pakistan Zindabaad

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

@@GREEN-gu9ud Your point on putting oneself into their position is valid, but why is Pakistan responsible, what’s wrong with the other fifty Muslim countries, how about Nigeria, is that okay, besides what is wrong with Bangladesh as a country, it’s a Muslim country, why not become loyal citizens of Bangladesh? Pakistan Zindabaad

Bengladesh take away their bengladeshi live in Karachi nd back our Buhari in pakistan

hindustan pakistan se hzar drja behtr he ke woh 22 caror musalmano ko rkha hua he apne mulk me hindu hone ke bawajud. ek ye laanti mulk he jo 5 lakh apne hi musalman bhaion ko rkhne me mot aarahi he. jbhi to allah ka azab aor laant he is mulk pr ke ye din ba din tbahi o brbadi ki trf jaraha he. esa mulk dunya ke liya nasoor he.

@KT-zu7nw

3 жыл бұрын

Agar Bangladesh insan da potar ni banta to hum ko b 45lac Bangalis ko wapis send karna chaye

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

That’s why thirty million plus of those Indian Muslims (muhajirs) are in Pakistan? If Pakistan is so bad and India so good then bay ge the first thing should be for those muhajirs to go back to India, for the Biharis, Bengalis and Rohingyas to all get out and leave this country alone. This is a country, not a yateem khana, “anath ashram” or orphanage for the unhappy Muslims of South Asia nor a dumping ground for the worlds refugees. Thanks. Pakistan Zindabaad

jhoot bol raha hy..ye rongiyan walay hean..na banglasdesh walay na burma walay ar na india walay le raheay hean...

@ayaat7094

3 жыл бұрын

No they are Biharis please educate yourself bhaia g

@madeehasaeed786

2 жыл бұрын

And even if they were Rohingiyas why should any country including Pakistan take them anyway, besides these are most definitely Biharis but they still don’t have any right to come to Pakistan as they have no connection to Pakistan whatsoever whether ethnic, linguistic, cultural or geographic, that’s just facts. Their country is Bangladesh which simply changed its name from East Pakistan, does not mean they now gave a right to come to what was West Pakistan just simply because it is still called Pakistan, no way, that’s BS. Only the people of Pakistan and that too to be honest the native peoples of Pakistan should have the right to decide who can and more importantly who can NOT come to Pakistan, that should be easy to understand, not very complicated is it? Pakistan Zindabaad

Afghni should be deported india or Afghanistan Bangladesh east pakistani should be brought to baluchitan has large land to settle the east pakistanis