State vs Politics; How Elite Capture works in Pakistan - Two Pakistans - Shehzad Ghias

Ойын-сауық

Our new series, Two Pakistans, looks at the conflicts in Pakistan and uses Dr. Mohammad Waseem's book, "Political Conflict in Pakistan" to explain the fault lines in Pakistan.
Episode 3 looks at the conflict between the State Elite and the Political Elite, as well as the role of the Pakistani Middle Class.
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
Twitter.com/shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Why I defend the awaam
8:16 Elite Capture, State Elite and Political Elite
22:40 Middle Class, Bureaucracy and the Fear of the Masses
27:00 Muslim League and a Lack of Ideology
29:30 Anti-Poor Politics and Pakistan's Political Class
33:48 PPP Bias
39:54 Distorted History, Military Propaganda and Imran Khan

Пікірлер: 421

  • @sunala1265
    @sunala126524 күн бұрын

    *What's defference between Pakistan and India?* *Idealogy with identity crisis* Pakistan’s nuclear missiles are named Ghazni, Ghauri,Babur and Abdali. Each name is a symbol of Muslim victory in Hindu- Muslim conflict. Modern India has named its nuclear weapons after the elements of life-Agni, Aakash, Prithvi (Fire, Sky and Earth). The difference is in the ideology- Destruction versus life. Source-MJ Akbar’s Tinderbox-The past and Future of Pakistan. *As I live I Learn* If agree upvote

  • @baazinews1027

    @baazinews1027

    23 күн бұрын

    Pakistan's goal has always been to try and somehow bring back the Mughal Empire [ where Hindus pay Jiziya ( extra Tax ) ], or if not that, then at least somehow suppress and subvert Hindu culture and show Sunni muzlims as superior to all other in the Indian Subcontinent. And that Desire of Sunni Muzlim superiority has narrowed down further to Desire for Sunni Punjaabi Superiority. And now that they see the Gap is so vast and their desires and goals have failed, they have other games that they are currently experimenting. Shehzad the owner of this YT Channel is one of those several games that they are experimenting. of course, they will not work, but a Pig's habit is to get himself dirtied in the muddy water which will never change. They don't understand the meaning of peaceful and harmonious co-existence. ( neither did their ideological ancestors understand ) It's a demonic ideology in the Age of Kalyug Just like how you see Zombies in several Webseries and Movies.

  • @PoliticalSeer-ii3wh

    @PoliticalSeer-ii3wh

    23 күн бұрын

    Pakistan's goal has always been to try and somehow bring back the Mughal Empire [ where Hindus,Sikhs,Jains pay Jiziya ( extra Tax ) ], or if not that, then at least they want somehow suppress and subvert Hindu culture and show Sunni muzlims as superior to all other in the Indian Subcontinent. And that Desire of Sunni Muzlim superiority has narrowed down further to Desire for Sunni Punjaabi Superiority. And now that they see the Gap is so vast and their desires and goals have failed, they have other games that they are currently experimenting. Shehzad the owner of this YT Channel is one of those several games that they are experimenting. of course, they will not work, but a Pig's habit is to get himself dirtied in the muddy water which will never change. They don't understand the meaning of peaceful and harmonious co-existence. ( neither did their ideological ancestors understand ) It's a demonic ideology in the Age of Kalyug Just like how you see Zombies in several Webseries and Movies.

  • @sakootdacca6706

    @sakootdacca6706

    23 күн бұрын

    Pakistani are all princely . Pervaiz Elahi house is called Elahi palace. . Really really. . This is a tragedy of Pakistan realities is bakhari but wants to be considered a prince

  • @yazdansyed8319

    @yazdansyed8319

    23 күн бұрын

    ur legit comparing ur nuclear bombs to life lol

  • @vinsin328

    @vinsin328

    23 күн бұрын

    Giving Nuclear capable missiles names to elements of life doesn't mean they will give life to anyone. Even though many Hindus have an identity crisis, many follow Brahmavad, not Hinduism.

  • @namansrivastav2008
    @namansrivastav200824 күн бұрын

    Holi originated in Pakistan ??? It wasnt Pakistan when Holi generated from Multan bro ! Even Islam didnt arrive in your Pakistan when Holi was originated . These are all indigenous festivals originated in pre islamic indian subcontinent

  • @drsiddiqui77

    @drsiddiqui77

    24 күн бұрын

    Great piece of information! Thank you.

  • @PoliticalSeer-ii3wh

    @PoliticalSeer-ii3wh

    24 күн бұрын

    Don't Worry Bro, He Will Get a Message Soon. This Guy has been appointed to Whitewash Izlamic Crimes and for Apropriation of Hindu Culture His Time is Short

  • @humzanafees9348

    @humzanafees9348

    23 күн бұрын

    Holi did originate in Pakistan, same as the Indus Valley, both Pakistan and India did not exist back then so it makes since to say it originated in Pakistan.

  • @abhaypatel4292

    @abhaypatel4292

    23 күн бұрын

    ​@@humzanafees9348India is what keeps the best legacy or baton of Indus valley alive. Lol Egyptian claim the legacy of pharos,rome by itlay and greek by the eastern Europe.. Not a single of them were there when all the events happened.. If today Indian stopped celebrating holi it's dead.. You have a leagcy.. wait sollowing on invaders count as legacy??

  • @namansrivastav2008

    @namansrivastav2008

    23 күн бұрын

    @@humzanafees9348 It was , is and always be called Indian Subcontinent !!! Holi didn't originate in barely 70 plus years old Pakistan which is founded on the basis of foreign religion that didn't even exist at the time when HOLI originated . You can blabber whatever you want but facts are facts !!!

  • @Health-Blitz
    @Health-Blitz24 күн бұрын

    Mujhay 1 European Christian Bandey Ne bataaya Tha that Christmas, Easter and Hanukkah also Originated in Paksitan 😲 And Jesus was born in Pakistan 😲 The Jewish religion also Started in Pakistan Area 😲 In Fact, the People that Built Pyramids also went from Paksitan to Egypt to Build Them 😲

  • @A.TechMotors

    @A.TechMotors

    23 күн бұрын

    😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @A.TechMotors

    @A.TechMotors

    23 күн бұрын

    Mohmmad bhai bhi pakistan me hi paida hua hoga?☺️😊

  • @ranarajput7368

    @ranarajput7368

    21 күн бұрын

    Yaha tak ki theory of relativity bhi Einstein ne pakistani scientists se hi churaya tha😂

  • @r-fay

    @r-fay

    18 күн бұрын

    ​@@ranarajput7368😂😂😂

  • @prabhatsingh513
    @prabhatsingh51324 күн бұрын

    "Army is the main problem " One line summary on today's Pakistan condition

  • @zaheerzulfiqar1885

    @zaheerzulfiqar1885

    24 күн бұрын

    The state of Pakistan is the problem itself, since its inception.

  • @zahidkashmiri1851

    @zahidkashmiri1851

    24 күн бұрын

    Army, the judges and top civil service all are problems for the people of Pakistan. It can be explained if required. But I know people understand it all and why. They are burden on the poor of Pakistan and the poor go hungry and their children don’t go to school. The treasure is being fiddled.

  • @pranaypratik1551

    @pranaypratik1551

    24 күн бұрын

    Pak army are declared itself as the defenders of physical as well as the ideological boundaries of Pakistan. Which is kind of true. If Pak army didn't behave like this and people really start questioning the differences and why the events have happened the way they have happened, people will eventually deny the need for partition. So for Pakistan to exist the Pak army has to keep itself in power.

  • @prabhatsingh513

    @prabhatsingh513

    23 күн бұрын

    @@zaheerzulfiqar1885" boya ped babul ka , to aam kaha se hoye " - sant kabir

  • @Cjahaga

    @Cjahaga

    22 күн бұрын

    @@zaheerzulfiqar1885 Khalistan Nagaland Tamil Kashmir freedom soon

  • @manmeetmalik78
    @manmeetmalik7823 күн бұрын

    Let's not over simplify the issue. The conquests were territorial no doubt but it was achieved by weaponising religion. Arabs were not interested in territories outside Arabia but Mohammed did use religion to motivate them to conquer territories with the stated aim of doing God's work. Christians did the same!!

  • @Health-Blitz
    @Health-Blitz23 күн бұрын

    One Day someone's BP could rise without any reason and organs could fail, after sweating profusely ... leaving the body paralyzed if alive And then a Person wanting to escape life, but not able to ...

  • @drsiddiqui77
    @drsiddiqui7724 күн бұрын

    You are doing a great service. You have changed my mindset and perspective. Kudos to you and your team! Keep up the great work. Pakistan needs it. Pakistanis need it. The world need more of you!

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @queenPAK

    @queenPAK

    21 күн бұрын

    👏👏👏

  • @muneezamir8212
    @muneezamir821224 күн бұрын

    We want all the remaining chapters. Keep up the good work!

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @ramachandraization
    @ramachandraization24 күн бұрын

    This was one of the best realistic video. Keep it up. Thanks.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @dryogeshmalhotra
    @dryogeshmalhotra24 күн бұрын

    Nice explanation. Keep it up, Happy to see that the future is in good hands.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @hamzaahmad549
    @hamzaahmad54922 күн бұрын

    Love this series. please continue it till the end

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @hassanshaheen2860
    @hassanshaheen286024 күн бұрын

    I love the format and the way you explain the chapters of the book For a person like me who doesn't like to read. it works very well for me.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @Shakeel.Irshad
    @Shakeel.Irshad24 күн бұрын

    Can we get the PDF copy of this book Sir

  • @munhibmazhar1748
    @munhibmazhar174824 күн бұрын

    Amazing Podcast Shehzad as always!!

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @agonnoga6100
    @agonnoga610024 күн бұрын

    1947 wasn't independence but a transfer of power from the British to their allies in the subcontinent. Which is why the loot by those allied with the British continues to this day.

  • @OneCrown
    @OneCrown23 күн бұрын

    Your podcast is very informative. Thank you for sharing such balanced views. We need more people like you, across the world. God bless you.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @shrawins
    @shrawins24 күн бұрын

    I fucking love the speed at which these vids are rolling out. Gotta say, keep em coming. Good luck and godspeed.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @SaberKingStarfish

    @SaberKingStarfish

    24 күн бұрын

    Indians watching 😊we like liberal human beings...hate Islam (not because of liberal Muslims) because of the Radical elements in it.

  • @faisalmubarak8041
    @faisalmubarak804124 күн бұрын

    Heard first time. Very intelligent analysis Masha'Allah. Keep it up son!!

  • @m08082
    @m0808223 күн бұрын

    Good video. You should continue with the series.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @syed4494
    @syed449423 күн бұрын

    great work brother keep videos coming

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @samdes678
    @samdes67824 күн бұрын

    Shehzad - nice episode. I beg to differ on the assessment that the war was never Muslim va Hindu. There isn’t any standing temple today in all of northern India including todays Pakistan which is 400 years or older. Try reading Baburnama or Masere Alamgiri. The whitewash of history got to stop for an honest assessment

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    There are temples in present day Pakistan which predate partition

  • @indumatick

    @indumatick

    24 күн бұрын

    ​@ThePakistanExperience In terms of proportion to the hindu population of north India their temples are top less. I am from south India (Tamil Nadu), when I travelled north for the first time I was very surprised that when they vote heavily on religious lines, why are very few temples and the temples that are over 1000 years are negligible, whereas, in the south we have too many temples. Islamic rule during the medieval times in the north was not very kind to Hinduism/native faiths or or its structures. If I am not wrong temples in Pakistan may be or may look like the last residues of Hinduism in Pakistan. I think this is why OP was trying to say that the north India has no major hindu temples.

  • @PoliticalSeer-ii3wh

    @PoliticalSeer-ii3wh

    24 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience Tu Bohot Whitewashing Kar Raha Hai Kisi Din 72 Hoor Ke Paas Na Pahunch Jaaye .. ( Ekdum Se Waqt Jazbaat aur Halaat Badal Jaayenge ) Wese Bhi Karachi Mein Sirf 5,000 Ke Liye Nashedhi Bikk Rahein Hain ..

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    @indumatick fair

  • @hammadhussain3082

    @hammadhussain3082

    22 күн бұрын

    Babur aur Alamgir pe aa ke kyun sui atak jaati hai? Muslims have ruled Hind for 800 years. Many Emperors came and went. Most Muslim Emperors used to have Hindus in important positions such as governors/ ministers and army chiefs.

  • @HamzaAli-ee1oh
    @HamzaAli-ee1oh24 күн бұрын

    Please continue this series. You're doing tremendous work bro. Keep it up🌺

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Abhi next episode ka script likha hay uskay baadh shayad bhai log continue na karnay dain 😂

  • @HamzaAli-ee1oh

    @HamzaAli-ee1oh

    23 күн бұрын

    Eagerly waiting bro😂❤

  • @gulraiztanvir8777
    @gulraiztanvir877724 күн бұрын

    World Class ❤❤❤ Pls continue the series....

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @mtariqkhan3056
    @mtariqkhan305619 күн бұрын

    bro you should continue this series its really helpful in understanding different crisis in Pakistan. and I think you should cover each and every chapter of this book as it has a lot of knowledge and facts.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    19 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @dainali1318
    @dainali131823 күн бұрын

    Interesting perspective 😮

  • @areebanaveed9485
    @areebanaveed948524 күн бұрын

    Love your new energy and the consistent videos ❤.....u should do more solo videos ❤

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @Fahadali_malano
    @Fahadali_malano20 күн бұрын

    Shahzad you're doing great work and you have transformed my personality completely... I was pro Imran, used to think that Islamic system should be imposed on Pakistan and many other conservative ideas I had... I have decided to study the history of Pakistan thoroughly and understand the Islamic touch and other conservative ideology being imposed on us.... Than you for opening our eyes because as an adult we are in our prime age full of energy our decision at this age will define our destiny and once again thanx for turning my ideas 180°

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    20 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @UsmanAli-db6yl
    @UsmanAli-db6yl23 күн бұрын

    Yes please keep making this kind of content on these topics

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @sasadasifh
    @sasadasifh24 күн бұрын

    Do you have PDF of Political Conflict in Pakistan?

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Say no to piracy 🙈

  • @sasadasifh

    @sasadasifh

    24 күн бұрын

    Konsi shop sey milay gi?​@@ThePakistanExperience

  • @laddu95
    @laddu9523 күн бұрын

    Good one Shahzad!

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @ghulamsarwar5569
    @ghulamsarwar556923 күн бұрын

    Nice effort.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @nvdalam96
    @nvdalam9619 күн бұрын

    Great job❤…

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    19 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @adeelakif814
    @adeelakif81422 күн бұрын

    dont stop this series please

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @SyedMSawaid
    @SyedMSawaid24 күн бұрын

    That kiss at 31:00 was personal.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    😅

  • @lowrygupta
    @lowrygupta23 күн бұрын

    Very interesting

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @danialhashmi1125
    @danialhashmi112523 күн бұрын

    Very informative keep it up. Don't defend yourself in your political stance just keep it neutral.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @Kam-8455
    @Kam-845524 күн бұрын

    You look slim bro keep the good work going.😅😅

  • @danishstariq
    @danishstariq23 күн бұрын

    Please make a list of books that one should read to understand the untruths about Pakistan.

  • @Kashef-Majed
    @Kashef-Majed20 күн бұрын

    Shahzad, I have been listening to your shows for a long time, and I differ with you on a lot of opinions. However, the facts you presented in today's podcast are 100% correct. Stay safe, buddy.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    20 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @ampirzada
    @ampirzada23 күн бұрын

    regarding the macro vs micro debate - punishing one individual fiercely doesnt get rid of the social issue completely but it does send shock waves across the society of the dire consequences of certain actions and helps to increase the mental barrier for next criminal. Although the thrill of harsh punishments also motivates some people (especially the younger ones) to attempt the sin and get away with it. But the net impact is, in my opinion, a positive one.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    Certainty of conviction is a deterrence, intensity of it is not. Does sending Zardari to jail for 11 years deter corruption in Pakistan? No, not at all

  • @ampirzada

    @ampirzada

    22 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience Agreed. I would take certainty over intensity too. But when its almost impossible to achieve (for e.g. in our justice system), the next best option imo is severity. Doing complex root cause analysis and then figuring out hurdles of fixing them is definitely the right way to go in an ideal world - but good luck with that!

  • @hamidakhtar4831
    @hamidakhtar483124 күн бұрын

    Thanks for refreshing my memory in ZA Bhutto sending Gen Tikka khan to curb unrest in Balochistan

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    No other channel will talk about it except us still I am labelled a jiyala

  • @kkbhai254
    @kkbhai25423 күн бұрын

    Great

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @Samiakram1
    @Samiakram122 күн бұрын

    So much conflicts found within

  • @Shrimpspiration
    @Shrimpspiration24 күн бұрын

    52:43 it took me the entire video to realize that I am the middle class you are talking about 😮

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙈

  • @acmkamos

    @acmkamos

    23 күн бұрын

    And it is not middle income by any means

  • @rohand04
    @rohand0424 күн бұрын

    Sorry buddy there is a problem with your overview of history.. you believe that Muslim rulers were secular.. they were always agnostic towards the native population.. mostly the north temples are destroyed.. The Muslim public may not have a clear disdain for the non Muslim community but they never stood up against the atrocities committed by the leadership.. just like Pakistan today.. muslim rulers and scholars have burnt libraries of ancient knowledge.. Your violent mob did it again last month ago in France.. And you are hurt by just one.. When gajnavi came to destroy somnaath he could have stopped by just looting the temple . As requested by the pundits.. But he didn't wanted to be just a looter he wanted to be an idol destroyer .. Aurangzeb destroyed more than a thousand temples in his tenure And you guys consider them your hero.. So if you guys didn't respect us why do you expect respect from us.. Islamic law in quran can never be apolitical or secular.. Because quranshreef isn't secular.. It give second class treatment for non Muslim the overall attitude of islamic world.. That's hypocrisy of islamic world don't you feel

  • @Quran_and_Logic

    @Quran_and_Logic

    23 күн бұрын

    quote a single verse from quran in which it talk about second class citizen to support your argument

  • @rohand04

    @rohand04

    23 күн бұрын

    ​@@Quran_and_Logic surah al taubat 9-5 surah al nisa 56

  • @Quran_and_Logic

    @Quran_and_Logic

    23 күн бұрын

    kyu aapna dil ma aik particular group ka lia nafrat pada kar raha ho so that you blame them for your failures . koi religion galat baat nahi karta ha people are the one who use religion for their own motives

  • @rohand04

    @rohand04

    23 күн бұрын

    ​@@Quran_and_Logic And please read the pact of umar wherein the non Muslim community had to agree to living in Muslim countries... This is the basis of dimini status.. Who in turn is the criterion or laws and the place of non Muslim in Muslim countries.. Now please tell me in a vise versa condition a Muslim will agree to these conditions.. I will ask will any Muslim even agree one of these conditions.. they cry oppression. If anyone even come close to implement these conditions.. Infact historically Muslim have done opposite of these stance with non Muslim community when they were in minorities.. ie build mosques, used it for raising enemity for non Muslim community, used it for protection of spy against the non Muslim majority.. use of loudspeaker for azan

  • @rohand04

    @rohand04

    23 күн бұрын

    ​@@Quran_and_Logic Bhai mere muze kisi group se nafrat nahi hai.. I was raised by a Muslim family my nanny.. I still call them maa and baba.. I have 3 of 5 best friends of mine who are Muslim.. I don't blame Muslims for the hate .. as individuals they are great.. But face it the teaching of islam.. give you a superiority complex over non Muslim.. hence you essentially don't find it odd or disgusting how non Muslim minorities are treated in Muslim countries..

  • @sasadasifh
    @sasadasifh24 күн бұрын

    Bro aap kay paas is book ka pdf hai? Please 🥺

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Nahee hay 🙈

  • @sasadasifh

    @sasadasifh

    24 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience Mein kaisay parhoon

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Liberty books par available hay

  • @sasadasifh

    @sasadasifh

    24 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience thanks bro 🙂

  • @sasadasifh

    @sasadasifh

    24 күн бұрын

    Yeh LUMS ki library mein ho gi?

  • @kayk9204
    @kayk920424 күн бұрын

    Keep it up

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @junaidahsan783
    @junaidahsan78324 күн бұрын

    Our elite also have identity crsis. Some elite think that we are form South of Central Asia. Some elite think we are Arabs. Some think we are persian

  • @mylakshmiveganheaven4562

    @mylakshmiveganheaven4562

    23 күн бұрын

    Where are you from , why dont you return to your hindu roots Why have a Arabic name , isnt that hypocrisy? Let me Name you Juna lal Ahuja from Junaid ahsan .

  • @yashsingh0010
    @yashsingh001023 күн бұрын

    Mujhe to ye bataya gaya tha ki chinese bhi lahore se nikle the, infact ek banda to keh raha tha human civilisation, sialkot ke gali no 4 se nikli hai. Kitna jhut koi bol sakta hai, ek intellectual nahi mila aajtak jo atleast 75% research kar ke bolta ho

  • @shatnermohanty6678
    @shatnermohanty667823 күн бұрын

    27:15 yes , you are right . In the Separate electorate based on religion , Muslim league's ideology was limited to that constituency . But when Muslims became the Majority in the new nation , the Muslim league didn't have the experience in grassroots Democracy to win elections . They didn't have a plan on how would be the Political system in the new country . And with the death of Jinnah , everything unravelled and it has been continuing till today

  • @FahadZahr
    @FahadZahr23 күн бұрын

    Shehzad bhai I miss your old podcasts, it used to have variety but now it’s only confined to Politics, Economics and History. I wish someday we can have some Musician, Scholar or a sports person on the podcast.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    Sir aap batayen kisko bulaon usko bolatay hain mera khud mood hay non political podcasts karnay ka

  • @FahadZahr

    @FahadZahr

    23 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience Koi Musician hu jaye tu kia he baat hai, being a Rock music lover myself, I know only you can invite someone related to that specific genre, other podcasters won't even think about it.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    Aap farmaish karayn batayen kisko bulao I’ll try getting them

  • @FahadZahr

    @FahadZahr

    22 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience Asad Ahmed Gumby Faraz Anwar Junaid Khan Omran Shafique Nabeel Nihal Chishty Sherry Khattak Altamash Sever Any of these pleaseeeee

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    Aadhay log toh in mai say hay hee nahee Pakistan mai. I’ll try getting Gumby

  • @Arsalankhan-di2nb
    @Arsalankhan-di2nb22 күн бұрын

    Talking about elite wearing Rastah brand. Love your videos 💯

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    They sent it to me for free 🙈

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @syed1559
    @syed155923 күн бұрын

    Amazing. I am surprised how much understanding you have at this young age. We need more people like you in Pakistan if this country wants to be somewhere.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @HistorywithShahrukh
    @HistorywithShahrukh24 күн бұрын

    Mere khayal se jitna acha explain kr dea hai naaaaa ab revolution ani chaiye Zabardast bhai Thank you Syed Muzammil jisko dekhny k liay me is channel pe aya or ek acha channel mila mje God Bless you God matlab Allah Taala Please no Kufr k fatway

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    ❤️🙌

  • @himanishdasgupta7217
    @himanishdasgupta721724 күн бұрын

    An islamofascist Pakistani ex diplomat Abdul Basit was labelling bilawal Bhutto ghaddar and anti islam for greeting namaste by joining two hands when he met jaishankar.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Unfortunately that was a disgusting propaganda peddled by many in Pakistan

  • @himanishdasgupta7217

    @himanishdasgupta7217

    24 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience thank you for replying bhai, expecting more light hearted issue based podcasts with geniuses like uzair yunus with some standup comedy videos as well 😊

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @drsiddiqui77

    @drsiddiqui77

    24 күн бұрын

    Indeed a wrong thing to do and disgusting propaganda!

  • @dawoodsdiary8209
    @dawoodsdiary820922 күн бұрын

    I am not gonna be surprised if the Army comes after him 🥲 Stay Safe bro. Keep making this content.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    Agli video in this series Kay badh toh Pakka

  • @mobasherahmed7451
    @mobasherahmed745124 күн бұрын

    Your diagnosis of farce democracy in Pakistan excellently narrated. Democracy was neverever practice in Pakistan. Unfortunately Pakistanis have no idea what democracy means n how it promotes have-nots in due course of time. You are doing something which gives a fair idea why we are far far behind in today's world. Please continue this series. I think there were three main usurpers in political history who did rape with the country i.e Ayub khan, Bhutto n Zia ul haq. Looking forward to next episode.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @madhvivarma8802
    @madhvivarma880223 күн бұрын

    OMG Shahzad, this is exactly what I believe, when people talk about a minimum education requirement for those who contest elections, I feel like checking how stupid they are!

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @user-he5xd3ld1g
    @user-he5xd3ld1g24 күн бұрын

    Ver interesting. The author that came up with the term elite-capture Olufemi Taiwo, also believes that the true problem lies in the system itself that produced the elites in the first place

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @getakif
    @getakif23 күн бұрын

    Pakistan couldn’t have middle class unless work opportunities from Gulf. It was income of skill/unskill labor income from which substantial middle class in Pakistan came into being

  • @user-dv8sx3cn8z
    @user-dv8sx3cn8z24 күн бұрын

    "How charming people are!-always doctoring, increasing and complicating their disorders, fancying they will be cured by some nostrum which somebody advises them to try, never getting better, but always growing worse. Are they not as good as a play, trying their hand at legislation, and imagining that by reforms they will make an end to the dishonesties and rascalities of mankind-not knowing that in reality they are cutting away at the heads of a hydra?"

  • @sakootdacca6706
    @sakootdacca670623 күн бұрын

    Pervaiz Elahi. Calls his house as Elahi palace. Really really . Princely complex in Pakistani ,contrast it with India

  • @MrCheapwiskey
    @MrCheapwiskey24 күн бұрын

    Welcome to Pakistan

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @MrCheapwiskey

    @MrCheapwiskey

    24 күн бұрын

    It's up to us .... We our self support this system....we vote for for them ... We support our army ... But do they support us ...NO ... Hence PPL will leave ..for better pasture

  • @n.abhinavchandrasekar2248
    @n.abhinavchandrasekar224822 күн бұрын

    even today the society in indian subcontinent is highly victorian, I guess you can identify those by their fav drink Tea or Whiskey dono Angrez ki den

  • @mangiferaindica1613
    @mangiferaindica161324 күн бұрын

    Apka Wo dost Syed muzammil shah tha ??? Jis ko apne bola tha gari bhagga 😅

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Nahee

  • @harisqaiser2202
    @harisqaiser220224 күн бұрын

    Do more

  • @manjitsinghathwal9217
    @manjitsinghathwal921724 күн бұрын

    But sir you’re people not understanding this you are 100/. right ❤🎉

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @DevKulkarni
    @DevKulkarni24 күн бұрын

    This is so important for Indians to listen too. Especially the ones that oppose reservations just to establish a sanitised landscape.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @sahilsinghnegi7041

    @sahilsinghnegi7041

    24 күн бұрын

    Reservations should be for poor and not a person whose family has bunch of govt employees.

  • @srijandatta287

    @srijandatta287

    24 күн бұрын

    How does reservations establish a non-sanitised landscape??

  • @prasenjitbarman8860

    @prasenjitbarman8860

    24 күн бұрын

    @@sahilsinghnegi7041 for the people of lower castes being financially well to do doesn’t lead them to be confident. Even though people show respect in their presence but behind the back they always face discrimination. I am not saying reservation is a pill for all the ailments and do also think that it has only made people aware of the caste. We should already stop the reservation politics but continue with what is going on.

  • @sahilsinghnegi7041

    @sahilsinghnegi7041

    24 күн бұрын

    @@prasenjitbarman8860 its your opinion because you possibly can't measure confidence like that and building confidence is not the goal of reservation, respect is earned through meritocracy not through quota.

  • @geetaprabhakar4261
    @geetaprabhakar426124 күн бұрын

    Fear of the masses ,is the most appropriate description of what is wrong with both Pakistan and lndia .Yaar ,Police is really meant for carrying out the writ of elite or political class and keeping poor under check .

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Yes

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Legacy of colonialism

  • @shatnermohanty6678

    @shatnermohanty6678

    23 күн бұрын

    Bureaucracy under the British was kept exclusive from the ordinary people . That model shouldn't have been followed after independence . Even today , whenever a common person visits any government office , the staff there view them as obstacles . The office exists and the staff working there get their salary to provide the service to the people visiting the place . That is explains the desperation of many people to get a sarkari naukri , because they believe it provides income without having to do any work .

  • @umeramjad01
    @umeramjad0119 күн бұрын

    How are you still alive bro Keep it up, might help people realize the bullshit that is going around in Pakistan since inception

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    19 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @noblejohnson3464
    @noblejohnson346424 күн бұрын

    "Zimiwaar" 5:37

  • @WaqarAhmad1.
    @WaqarAhmad1.24 күн бұрын

    Partition was a wrong move or not? Explian it in one video

  • @harshitgarg3436

    @harshitgarg3436

    24 күн бұрын

    it was the best thing that happened to us, had the population exchange been done completely and peacefully it would have been even better. the partition kept us away from afghanistan russia usa saga, it keeps us away from the middle east lafda, and it gave us breathing space to develop although we started it after 1991, but der aaye durust aaye. Had the partition not done, we would have a sizable islamic population and that extremist population would keep themselves and us into poverty. We are already very poor and are crawling our way up, having the extra burden of 40+cr muslims who would swipe the sword on minorities neck whenever given a chance, both the area of Pakistan and India would go down.

  • @talhaashraf8473
    @talhaashraf847324 күн бұрын

    Maalik. Poori series complete karna. Haqeeqat sun kay apni bohat kuch seekhnay ko milta hai. 😢😅

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @mollyv4908
    @mollyv490824 күн бұрын

    today bhai is looking like a sona munda. hair game on another level

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    😅

  • @sakootdacca6706
    @sakootdacca670623 күн бұрын

    All properties in dubi need to confiscated and used as debt payment to UAE. Dubi and Qatar

  • @kandarppathak4515
    @kandarppathak451524 күн бұрын

    Bhaiya female ko object karna aapke Islam me hai. Aurat aapki kheti hai hadith uthake dekhle. Ese kahi hadith hai jisme female ko object ki tarah bataya gaya hai.

  • @cadence764

    @cadence764

    24 күн бұрын

    Islam hi problem hai

  • @hammadhussain3082

    @hammadhussain3082

    22 күн бұрын

    Vedas kehte hein women are less intelligent then why did your Sanatani RSS PM appointed a female president? Indrā had said, “The woman mind cannot be disciplined; she has very little intelligence.” ( RigVéda 8:33:17)

  • @hammadhussain3082

    @hammadhussain3082

    22 күн бұрын

    Upanishad teaches Râpe 101: Without a doubt, a woman who has changed her clothes at the end of her menstrual period is the most auspicious of women. When she has changed, then, one should approach that splendid woman and invite her to have sex. Should she refuse to consent, he should bribe her. If she still refuses, he should beat her with a stick or with his fists and overpower her, saying: “I take away the splendor from you with my virility and splendor” (Brhadārankyaka Upanishad 6.4.9, 21)

  • @wordpressaccoumt7746
    @wordpressaccoumt774623 күн бұрын

    Congratulations on combing your hair.

  • @prasenjitbarman8860
    @prasenjitbarman886024 күн бұрын

    When the raae of a Brazilian woman took place in Jharkhand, my first reaction was who asked her to stay in the open and somehow was blaming her for what happened to her. Let me tell you I am a well educated guy with progressive mindset. And then I reflected back and realised how to utterly disgusting my thoughts were. I realised that it was the society at fault and at large the fault of the state that has done nothing to better the thought process of the society. It is the duty if state that a person can sleep on the footpath and his safety is ensured. Even a case of theft shouldn’t happen let alone r*p*. And every single person be it citizen or not should feel safe be it in Jungle or in open area. But the state has prevented progressive thoughts for their politics and distract masses from real issues!!!

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Unfortunately, rape culture is rampant in India and Pakistan, using that terms of the ideas that are promoted and perpetuated in our society.

  • @srijandatta287

    @srijandatta287

    24 күн бұрын

    The issue with this is, there is something called pragmatism which is necessary to live in this world. We normally don't go near bears because they are dangerous. Similarly a country where population per police officer is really low maybe half of most western nations and judiciary that sits on cases for years which means justice isn't served swiftly, it is pragmatic to not camp in the middle of nowhere. West has this as well, evident by their r@pe rates and the show 'to catch a predator'. Understand how it can be solved, surely education and mindset matter but being pragmatic matters more as no one can or should sleep on the footpath anyway, western nations literally do not allow it, homeless people are driven out of parks etc on a regular basis there. Theft and other crimes happen in the west as well, along with stuff on the dark web. Crimes are a reality of every society as humans are flawed that's a necessary realization. There is nothing called r@pe culture here. No normal person here thinks about doing it to anybody. They do blame the victim though which is slowly changing and should. If you feel safe in a jungle you are not really in one. It is supposed to be survival of the fittest. Only humans save their 'weaks' as much as they do. A hungry apex predator will strike no matter how chill you are. This is why nuances in arguments/debates is so necessary. Pragmatism and Realism is the only way to survive.

  • @prasenjitbarman8860

    @prasenjitbarman8860

    24 күн бұрын

    @@srijandatta287 all your points taken but don’t you think you are tacitly justifying the act. I am not comparing west to east. Don’t you think as a society we have failed. Yes pragmatically it is difficult to do what I suggested but shouldn’t it be the debate of the hour. I already said that I had the line of thought similar to yours but then I realised how disgusting the thought is. It is the case of a misjudgment by the foreigners but what in the cases where a minor is r**** by her relatives. It was pragmatic for the nobles of India to take foreign aid but look what it lead to. A society who relies on pragmatism lives in status quo, it takes a new idea to make a state progress. And can we liken a human to a bear? A human has an ability to think beyond his line of upbringing. Can a bear or other animal do so. Should we just on the name of pragmatism not discuss the issue and should we just take it as it is and say thats how the world acts?

  • @prasenjitbarman8860

    @prasenjitbarman8860

    24 күн бұрын

    @@srijandatta287 and also just because it is not pragmatic should we just lay hand in hand and not aspire for better society where our society respects women, poor and questions the leader be it the one they support or are against. I too am proud of this country, and would go nowhere even if it offered me a better standard of living. And for that very reason I want my society to become modern and not western.

  • @sitarampradhan8488

    @sitarampradhan8488

    24 күн бұрын

    Bollywood promoted and promotes rape and eve teasing culture

  • @HistorywithShahrukh
    @HistorywithShahrukh24 күн бұрын

    Bhai sun k meri to phat gaye DHA wali bat Shukar hai mè America me hun

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    😂

  • @saleemnaqvi2200
    @saleemnaqvi220023 күн бұрын

    A quick question: the Barelvi sect was peaceful since its inception and then the state used them in the shape of TLP. Agreed. Let's condemn the state together. But once we have done that, would it be disingenuous to ask whether they bear any blame for becoming pawns of the ... ahm, (I don't want to use the 'E word')? Do individual bear no personal responsibility for their actions? Would the claim that one was manipulated and exploited by the E be sufficient to claim immunity from moral responsibility for one's actions?

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    Don’t I say in this video that I am not absolving the individual and they should get punished for their crimes?

  • @saleemnaqvi2200

    @saleemnaqvi2200

    22 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience You did say that, but the overall impression that was created was that the state manipulated the minds of the Barelvi sect and created TLP, and I agree with you on this; AND that changed the psyche of the people as if they were دودھ پیتے بچے who couldn't tell right from wrong and whatever wrong they do now is the responsibility of the state. I don't agree with this assertion. Also, you say that the responsibility for seemingly jaahilana acts lies more with the society that with the individual. I think the society is made up of individuals from the same area and its attitudes are a collective manifestation of the attitudes of its members, who are individuals.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    And if we are to fix society then that soch will need to be fixed, punishing individuals won’t lead to social change, society will keep producing such individuals

  • @saleemnaqvi2200

    @saleemnaqvi2200

    22 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience Thank you for replying again. Shows you care.

  • @drjawadish
    @drjawadish23 күн бұрын

    It seams like boys were in control from the Word go. Thats y bhutto send the same bucher to Balochistan.😅

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    Next episode on this. Shoro say kaisay control lia

  • @drjawadish

    @drjawadish

    22 күн бұрын

    @@ThePakistanExperience Keep on doing the work. You are changing my perception about Jahil Avam i used to think before. You have given me another viewing angel. Much love and respect.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    ❤️

  • @RohitSharma-oh8qm
    @RohitSharma-oh8qm24 күн бұрын

    I am confused in some terminology . Why is he saying awam(common people) and middle class , different? .. middle class is also awam . Majority of awam is middle class .

  • @HistorywithShahrukh

    @HistorywithShahrukh

    24 күн бұрын

    Actually in Pakistan there is very less middle class

  • @rohand04

    @rohand04

    24 күн бұрын

    ​@@HistorywithShahrukh not just Pakistan

  • @RohitSharma-oh8qm

    @RohitSharma-oh8qm

    24 күн бұрын

    @@HistorywithShahrukh 30% of pakistanis are in poverty ,, doesn't that make rest atleast 50% middle class ?

  • @RohitSharma-oh8qm

    @RohitSharma-oh8qm

    24 күн бұрын

    @@rohand04 never heard , middle class and common people used as 2 different group of peoples.

  • @HistorywithShahrukh

    @HistorywithShahrukh

    24 күн бұрын

    @@RohitSharma-oh8qm bhai 70 percent kdr ho ap

  • @rainman.21
    @rainman.2124 күн бұрын

    Solution? Solution please ? Anyone ???

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    Inquilaab

  • @AzlaanSaifKhan
    @AzlaanSaifKhan23 күн бұрын

    Yar most of the thing you are saying is not what the middle-class people in DHA Karachi thinks

  • @rehmanpiracha5002
    @rehmanpiracha500224 күн бұрын

    Great job, can you share some time the feedback you are getting from your viewers? I might have missed listening but whenever I listen it seems that listeners are not getting it as you seems responding to decades old beliefs repeatedly, I am worried about your mental health and determination

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @malikzubair8405
    @malikzubair840523 күн бұрын

    I think this is a good analysis and much balanced. But saru cheze imran khan pe na dal dia kro ap😂

  • @ndacadet1
    @ndacadet124 күн бұрын

    He is 11th avatar . Any worshipping will be less . 🤯

  • @2413sharefree
    @2413sharefree23 күн бұрын

    𝐀𝐋𝐋𝐀𝐇𝐔 𝐀𝐊𝐁𝐀𝐑!

  • @YousufAhmad0
    @YousufAhmad020 күн бұрын

    @Shehzad bhai, it is a common fallacy that the Barelvi sect was historically a peaceful or tolerant sect (relative to other regional sects). Ahmad Raza Khan Barelvi sb was famously a takfiri extremist, who a issued a fatwa against the ulama of Deoband and all their followers. I don't adhere to or identify with either sect so I consider myself a neutral commentator on this matter. What can be more intolerant and militant than declaring an entire sect as kharijul Islam, which, as you know, by their perverse interpretation, equates to irtidad, from where, as you are well aware again, they draw further dangerous logical conclusions.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    20 күн бұрын

    Saray hee sects aur ulema ek dosray Kay khilaaf fatway de rahay thay us time. How many people were mob lynched as a result of it

  • @muhammadimrankhan3294
    @muhammadimrankhan329424 күн бұрын

    How could a student buy this book, it's to expensive, 9000 RS only.

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    23 күн бұрын

    Is hee liye i am making this series

  • @shahzadtameem2388
    @shahzadtameem238810 күн бұрын

    shahzad bhai na kanga kar ka u turn la liya....

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    10 күн бұрын

    🤣

  • @mjay7
    @mjay724 күн бұрын

    I will miss you and occasionally wonder what happened to that chubby guy.

  • @Samiakram1
    @Samiakram122 күн бұрын

    Good knowledge, nothing new, high biasness, could be seen zero personal contribution, not only in creating/drafting some thought but also in any dot connections or mixing of ideas

  • @hasanawan1
    @hasanawan122 күн бұрын

    bhai shehzad ap ne hamari ankhy khol di ha

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    22 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @ziki08
    @ziki0823 күн бұрын

    You have a clear command on the language however, there are very few episodes that I actually thought was informative and beneficial for betterment. For example, instead of cursing history speaking of a one sided view, perhaps incorporate both sides of history. I think biased views are like listening to a wife complaining about an "evil/demonic" mother in law. I might as well watch any 9pm soap.

  • @manjulmayankshukla7852
    @manjulmayankshukla785224 күн бұрын

    Ise utha lo shayar Ahmad k liye kuch banaye

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    We put up a post everywhere

  • @TradeRainmaker-xl6wr
    @TradeRainmaker-xl6wr23 күн бұрын

    In logon ko ab tak nahi pata Chalayan ki problem kya he...abhey army he tumhara problem... 25% budget ka kha jate he....

  • @adityamshukla3617
    @adityamshukla361724 күн бұрын

    Yes you are right holi festival started from Pakistan and some famous sweet which is so tasty are also belong to Pakistan soan halwa soanbarfi belong to Pakistan (multan)

  • @ThePakistanExperience

    @ThePakistanExperience

    24 күн бұрын

    🙌

  • @shatnermohanty6678

    @shatnermohanty6678

    24 күн бұрын

    Multani mitti and Kasuri methi

  • @srijandatta287

    @srijandatta287

    24 күн бұрын

    When were these sweets invented?? How is holi pakistani, there was no pakistan before 1947. What a dumb thing to say.

  • @srijandatta287

    @srijandatta287

    24 күн бұрын

    It (holi) also started during the gupta period. Any evidence of it being on the area of Pakistan??

  • @adityamshukla3617

    @adityamshukla3617

    24 күн бұрын

    I'm sorry for troubling you @srijandatta287 but we are talking about the history in which these places are present in Pakistan now

  • @ishaali3666
    @ishaali366624 күн бұрын

    Shehzad bhai Have some guts to invite Qaiser ahmed raja in your show. Why you r scared to hv debate with him

  • @vikasbhargava5653
    @vikasbhargava565324 күн бұрын

    What is wrong with Paxstan's middle class? What Middle Cleass? Paxstan has no middle class. Paxstan has a few thousand very very very very very rich and all others are very very very very very Poor. Maybe a few hundred Middle Class which are the new Vloggers.

  • @mylakshmiveganheaven4562

    @mylakshmiveganheaven4562

    23 күн бұрын

    Pakistan has few lakhs zamindars class peoples and few traders merchants rest are all agricultural class peoples . They have a growing middle class who is now almost in poverty due to economic downfall .

Келесі