Everyone keeps complaining about the audio quality but to me it honestly feels like Nimoy speaking to the younger generations, giving his wisdom from the past to the future to create better captains in us all. I like it, it's charming

@TheycallmeMrWonka

Жыл бұрын

I think to those that know the clips, it brings nostalgia and more meaning just knowing that it IS Nimoy. To those that have no real connection to the lines or who speaks them then they likely either don't even know why it sounds like that or don't quite understand why it was done the way it was done.

@matthewst537

Жыл бұрын

Spocks audio is music to my ears compared to the fake captain janeways command hologram should take over

@DanielS2001

Жыл бұрын

Also, it makes sense in context: they're historical clips in the ST universe itself and the computer is using them for the construction.

@DoremiFasolatido1979

Жыл бұрын

I'm happy with it as it is. The resurrection of dead actors into living roles is still somewhat in its infancy, so it shouldn't be expected to be perfect. But I do think that, given the time and budget, they could've still done considerably better. But, that's less a complaint and more an observation.

@JTB198819962006

Жыл бұрын

If Zachery Quinto did the voice of Spock for this there would be riots on the streets.

It’s seven years next month we lost Leonard. Got a little teary eyed watching Spock doing what he does best. Being the best confidant Starfleet ever had.

@danielhaire6677

2 жыл бұрын

In that case, you will love this from the Lost Years novels, when Spock was training cadets at the Academy. His students routinely ranked the highest in science, technical skills, and operational skill, but were also noted to have a dedication to duty, their crews, and the ideals of the Federation not eguivocally seen in other classes.

@carolprice1389

Жыл бұрын

Truer words could not be spoken better than what you have said!👍😇

@user-roninwolf1981

Жыл бұрын

It would be amazing to hear an actor dead-nailing Leonard Nimoy's voice.

I love this. Hearing Spock give Dal advice on how to be a great Captain is pure magic. This is why I love Star Trek.

@terrywest111

2 жыл бұрын

He should know a thing or two about being a great Captain, he served under 2 greats in Pike and Kirk and had a stint as Enterprise Captain, even though it was just a teaching post, but I think Spock's cadets performed admirably during the confrontation with Khan. Spock trained them well. (Granted it seemed he had help from some of the other original Enterprise crew members) Plus, there were all those times he took command when Kirk wasn't there.

@juanrisa945

3 ай бұрын

​@@terrywest111 He never came back, througth.

The increase in audio quality at the end, not to mention the age of the voice, really makes it feel like the ghost of Spock is emerging from the old recordings to address him directly.

@skippythealien9627

10 ай бұрын

it's interesting because the clips go relatively in chronological order, from TOS to the TOS movies to his one appearance in TNG and finally the Kelvin movies in a scene where we see Dal really starting to grow and mature, this wisdom is passed down to him from the own evolution of Spock throughout the Star Trek saga. Absolutely beautiful to watch

@hellwolf2251

2 ай бұрын

It's been almost 70 years since the first run with him and he still speaking the truth to the truth live long and prosper

Even though the audio is clearly choppy, hearing Leonard Nimoy as Spock in a holographic simulation makes it feel natural.

Spock compared him to another stubborn Starfleet officer he knew.. I can't think of a better compliment for the kid

@skippythealien9627

5 ай бұрын

it's interesting because the original audio comes from the episode where Spock meets Picard someone else mentioned this before but for all we know, Spock could be talking about Kirk or Picard or hell even Kelvin Kirk, since Spock has crossed between both universes

Think the producers left the voice unaltered through the years as how the holodeck would teach Spock's knowledge to Dal. And a nod to the legendary actor. RIP Leonard.

I love it. I don’t care how it sounds. It was a beautiful thing to attempt. It’s part of why I love both prodigy and Lower Decks.

@robstoppablecosplay

2 жыл бұрын

Me too. Both are terrific shows.

@highlander723

2 жыл бұрын

They did it intentionally as tribute to fallen actors. They didn't alter the pitch or reduce the background noise they really could have and make it sound so seamless that you would think the actors were actually there. A

@BluGiant14

2 жыл бұрын

Totally agree. I was late watching this ep, but it was heartwarming to hear those recordings.

@XeansIcemane

2 жыл бұрын

"The solution to the Kobayashi is tenacity" was a hell of an answer to the Kobayashi Maru conundrum.

@PhilDrury

2 жыл бұрын

Those two "kid's shows" bring back so many memories - well they would if we'd forgotten those memories. Anyway, it's nice to see any call-backs and references without suggesting that what we saw was a completely different thing to what we saw.

I still laugh at how Dal interprets Spock's Vulcan salute as a high-five.

One of the best uses of old voices archives probably in years, I really like the fact that really sound like old recording just projected on a hologram, kinda makes sense that they don't have a clear sound, and is incredibly nostalgic to hear the old voices giving still new meaning and Spock still is able to do what he does best, even if he is already gone, man I love this show so much.

spock is just that kind of wise sage you could always get good advice from.

@aliensguy4291

Жыл бұрын

Spock, yoda, and uncle iroh are the 3 wisest people in the multiverse

I give them props for using the original audio.

@MovieMagic515

2 жыл бұрын

It would be disrespectful to get an impersonator. The writer watched hours and hours of Star Trek to collect the right audio.

@eoghanlacey6384

2 жыл бұрын

@@MovieMagic515 that’s why I hate when people complain that the original audio seems out of place

@captainr800

2 жыл бұрын

@@eoghanlacey6384 because it is, his audio is from different episodes and movies, they don’t even match well it’s a good try though.

@Drakesonone

2 жыл бұрын

We all miss a great man and the auto clips show what we lost and what the character and actor at can never be replace fully

@larniieplayz6285

2 жыл бұрын

@@MovieMagic515 how would it be disrespectful?

Finally, someone high fives the vulcan salute 🖖🙏

Of all the characters of the Star Trek universe....Spock will always be the one many of us will remember as the years go by and as we get older. "Live long and prosper".

Even from beyond, even in just voice clips, that man can inspire. Thank you for all you ever were to us Trek fans...and the world, Leonard.

@stephenfarthing3819

Жыл бұрын

I quite agree.. And this would shut up a certain nincompoop who gave me, too much grief over New Star Trek series recently! I might just point him this way....

Loved the cameos, but sad we didn't get the Picard line about it being possible to do everything right and still fail

@isaacwall4951

2 жыл бұрын

Still, Spock helped Dal on learning about being a captain.

@mdxque8393

2 жыл бұрын

While that is a good quote and lesson, I think that might not have fit with episode and the kids might want to here Dal could get better. Though there is always an opportunity for characters and the kids to learn about that in an another episode.

@builder396

Жыл бұрын

True. I feel like Picards speech would have applied better and been a lot more coherent, even as voice clips. (Not that they need to, Patrick Stewart is still on their payrole thanks to getting his own series) As much as I love the fact that they tried to bring Nimoy back to life with his own old voice lines, this doesnt quite feel like a conversation or even a speech.

@Nighthawke70

Жыл бұрын

Better yet, a holo of Picard. We'll get to see him later on I'll wager.

The audio is weird at first, but honestly, I'm ok with it. Honestly, let's look at it this way, I really hope young and dumb hopeful and bright full of imagine kids are actually watching this. They won't get it like we do. But it's also for us, that BAD audio...really put me back there watching the actual show as a kid. Just wish I had a kid to watch this with LOL

@highlander723

2 жыл бұрын

actually I didn't mind the bad audio. I mean think about it with today's technology they could make it sound seamless they could make it sound like the actors were actually there.... They didn't do it because it was a tribute. You're absolutely right They did it because they wanted you to remember watching the original series for the first time or the episodes where those lines were said. given that it's a children's show I think it was a really super creative way to make us remember what it was like when we heard that for the first time It was brilliant.

@MattJohno2

2 жыл бұрын

To be honest the audio differences almost sound like different voice recordings for a video game, which makes sense seeing as this is on a holodeck, which is almost like one giant video game.

@dojokonojo

2 жыл бұрын

For some reason I feel like it was intentional. I'm sure they could have cleaned up the audio better but didn't.

@taiwansivispacemparabellum9546

2 жыл бұрын

Did you know all those lines, were original audio taken from TOS from our one and only Lenard Nimoy?

The past talks to the present. How beautiful! LLAP!!!

Spock has always been a sage of wisdom. Even a joking show can’t truly destroy him. Perhaps his katra does live on…

@matthewkreps3352

2 жыл бұрын

It maybe on Nickelodeon, but it is not a joking show.

@Nighthawke70

Жыл бұрын

I'd be tickled if Kirk himself made a show. He had a few nuggets of wisdom about leadership and captaining a starship. You can't shove your pains to the side, you NEED your pain to lead by. Your MISTAKES need to stay with you for your life in order to lead properly. Your starship is but a piece of metal in space. It is YOUR CREW that fills it, and makes it YOUR Starship. LEAD your crew and they will follow you to either glory, or to a flaming mess. You decide.

@SchneeflockeMonsoon

8 ай бұрын

@@matthewkreps3352 True.

I loved that High Five so much...

"It was like talking to a soundboard!" - Dr.McCoy. -- probably

@DennisMoore664

Жыл бұрын

"...with pointy ears! Dammit Jim - I'm a doctor not a DJ!"

All y'all nitpicking the audio differences... when there's a great moment here.

@unitedenginesofamerica3215

2 жыл бұрын

Its called fan service and doesn't work here

@6py7

2 жыл бұрын

It absolutely works

What I love about this entire sequence is how it's a firm gut punch to a lot of fans who fantasize about being captain of the Enterprise or really any Starfleet vessel. Yes, it would be awesome to work with our favorite crewmates. Yes, it would be insanely cool to pick and choose our command staff from the entirety of the Star Trek roster. But you have to be able to be a CAPTAIN in order bring them together to make it all work. Just having the top names on hand won't automatically make you win. Kirk made mistakes. Picard made mistakes. Janeway made mistakes. But what matters the most is what they did NEXT.

@matthewcaughey8898

Жыл бұрын

Hell I still make mistakes. Thankfully not making too many of them can be an asset later in life when you really need someone to “ give you a second chance “

Considering how Federation ships seems to record almost everything, it kinda make's sense that the holodeck computers would reuse the audio to form conversations with the holodeck user.

Oh my goodness. Yes this is a kitbash of different Spock lines but my goodness did that sound good! It felt like Leonard Nimoy was really back :)

That was fucking hilarious when he almost beat the Kobayashi Maru without cheating and he fails any way at the very end

@captaintalon4485

2 жыл бұрын

Dal didn’t even fail in a cool way either he just put his feet up on the console and accidentally blew up his own ship

@Guciom

2 жыл бұрын

@@captaintalon4485 He failed by showing overconfidence at the end. A captain should not let his guard down until his crew is cleared to be safe.

@matthewkreps3352

2 жыл бұрын

No he failed because the Kobayashi Maru is programmed to make him fail anyways.

@FirstLast-cg2nk

Жыл бұрын

The Kobayashi Maru is a test that perpetually evolves as people take it, so that even if a solution seemingly appears, the simulation adds new variables to make it unsolveable. It is a test to see how a cadet deals with seemingly unwinnable scenarios, and while there have been a few notable "wins" or "stalemates", those are outliers. You don't win, you just find your own way to lose.

@justins.1283

Жыл бұрын

It was never about winning but doing the right thing up untill the very end.

Complain all you want about how the audio sounds, but this show still did Spock more justice after Leonard Nimoy's death than what The Rise of Skywalker did with Leia after Carrie Fisher died.

@therearefourlights6926

2 жыл бұрын

That is a pretty low bar to set.

The creators literally watched every single ep of the og series to find the best lines to clip and use in this part and it makes this scene all the more special

I almost cried. Leonard Nimoy was the glue that kept the franchise going. Something that has now passed to William Shatner.

This way waaaay better than I expected it to be. Well done!

I hoped will be seeing a lot of cameo characters from past Star Trek shows, most especially the Captains.

The music in this scene do hit different

This was a fun episode.. even though you could tell the copy/paste audio clips from past cast members “Rip🖖🏽” it still didn’t matter this was fun 🙂

@zacharyjochumsen9677

2 жыл бұрын

Chrstophermay lenord be remberd

@olicityfan1150

Жыл бұрын

Maybe it has something to do with me editing videos for years or something, but to me it's really distracting and feels really lazy. They couldn't you know polish it up or something to make it flow better!

@TheycallmeMrWonka

Жыл бұрын

@@olicityfan1150 The using of the exact audio is the point. They weren't trying to make a flawless character speak they were using this Spock speaking to remind of the characters history. There is depth to that rather than just taking audio, polishing it to perfection and pressing play. As someone who edits video, surely you can understand that there is more to it than just a clean cut. I would say when you no longer attempt to put more thought and depth into your work than look/sound perfecttion THAT is the point you've become lazy.

@olicityfan1150

Жыл бұрын

@@TheycallmeMrWonka never thought about it like that, but that does make sense

They also had recordings of Jimmy Doohan, Rene Auberjonois, and Nichelle Nichols. Nichols was alive during recording (she just passed a few weeks ago, may she LLAP), but it would've been unreasonable to ask her to come to a studio to perform. Gates McFadden came to record some dialogue here, and seeing Beverly Crusher again was glorious.

OOOOOwwwwwww that was amazing. Leonard Nimoy is crying of happiness in heaven. RIP Mr. Spock!!!

Damn, the Enterprise-D keeps on getting blown up.

@SR71ABCD

2 жыл бұрын

Cause and Effect Love that episode

@terrywest111

2 жыл бұрын

You know it holds the record for getting blown up! :p

@jaspervlogt3843

2 жыл бұрын

@@terrywest111 And we dont even know teh exact number it happened

@thesailormercury2

Жыл бұрын

don't they know what bones said , treat the enterprise like a lady she will take you home, he did not say anything about blow up the old girl.

even in death Spock is still helping people out

I really wish they had normalized the audio quality. Given that it's all taken from various episodes and stitched together, it just doesn't carry enough emotional weight to the situation. But nevertheless, props for doing it. Just in concept, I love that he's learning from Spock. We all know Nimoy is no longer with us. I would not have faulted them if they were able to get someone who could do a spot-on impression of him. For instance, who they got to voice (and even physically portray) Dr. Loomis in Halloween and Halloween Kills had me convinced that Donald Pleasance had been brought back to life.

@homelessend8557

2 жыл бұрын

@Terra Prime what about discovery

@mrcritical6751

2 жыл бұрын

They’re also recasting Spock for the Telltale Star Trek game

@FomorViceroy

2 жыл бұрын

@Terra Prime Splicing audio together from various episodes and movies across a 25+ year period to form a sentence is just less than professional-sounding.

This is like when Chef left South Park. Then came back.

Bumblebee and Holo Spock would make great motivational speakers!

This was surprisingly good.

Little did this kid know that he's talking to the person that programmed the Kobayashi mission in the first place. And if he had selected Kirk, he more than likely would've aced it. He did after all beat the program by rigging it. Right?

@RafaelLopezNewton

4 күн бұрын

Yes but it is for best for him to learn and try and fail by himself. And have a pep-talk by the one of the best friends and confidantes of all time immediately afterwards.

I dont care about the audio quality... it was absolutely amazing that they used original old audio...

I love it. Give me classic Trek. The Classic Trek universe, which for me is TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY and ENT (Along with all the movies up to Nemesis and TAS) I'm also considering adding Lower Decks to that Universe, because it respects the canon so well. This show is well on it's way to earning a spot in that Universe too. I loved seeing Leonard Nimoy's Spock again. It was like seeing an old friend, along with several other old friends.

@nerysghemor5781

2 жыл бұрын

I still don’t quite consider Lower Decks canon but I saw a theory that it’s someone’s tall tales from that time period…as in, the overarching themes happened but someone (an older Mariner, I’d bet) put a comedic spin on the stories. (Though come to think of it, T’Ana could also be the one who told the stories too.)

@alastairward2774

2 жыл бұрын

@@nerysghemor5781 lower decks is canon because that's all it ever talks about. I've been made aware that I should enjoy the show because it contains so many "Easter eggs".

Its so weird hearing all these past voice reels from Leonard nemoy in this show

It’s so obviously audio recordings from different sources with Nimoy at different ages. It really doesn’t sound good, the audio quality is all over the place. Very distracting. especially when one remembers when each line was spoken. However, this might also work for the idea for this hologram. It’s not really Spock, the computer is just splicing voice recordings together to create the illusion of Spock talking to you. So this doesn’t work, and yet it does at the same time. It’s the best the computer could recreate.

@stuntmonkey00

2 жыл бұрын

It sounds like a clip of "Bad Lip Reading", they really could have gone the extra mile to clean up the audio

@Bartman954

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah. Only work arounds would make the hologram glitch or use the voice double used in Star Trek Resurgence. (Who does a damn good Leonard Nimoy impression)

@eoghanlacey6384

2 жыл бұрын

Idc it’s actually leonard that’s all that matters

@AssjVegeta68

2 жыл бұрын

@@eoghanlacey6384 Agree 💯

Anyone else notice Spock’s voice changes throughout ?

With today’s technology you would think that they could’ve smoothed over those soundbites from the great Leonard Nimoy a little bit more

As annoying as the archive footage is. The episode is worth it for the character growth

sarcastic vulcan salute

The creators of this tv program have made this hologram Spock a parrot, spitting out recorded words, it’s disheartening. I Loved Leonard Nimoy’s portrayal of Spock and it makes me sad.

I lookede at thet Debris effects and noticed NCC-1701-D. Reference maybe?

The audio was clearly a random actor and audio clips taken out of context. But I still like it

Shame Spock didn’t get back too his universe.

If anyone is curious on how to do this 🖖, just type spock

I always thought Spock's assertion that a crew should be lied to so that they believe its captain is perfect was a strange bit of 1960s TV machismo. It was a quite a surprise, given the many positive messages of leadership available, that Prodigy's writers chose that particularly peculiar clip for a 2022 children's moral story.

@AaronWaltke

2 жыл бұрын

It’s recontextualized to be about Dal’s assumption he has to be perfect. Like a zen master leading the student to the answer without giving it.

@jordancobb509

2 жыл бұрын

🙄

@kidprime6863

Жыл бұрын

I think it's supposed to mean that one must be aware of how one perceives one's command or something

We have another Kirk

Hmm ! I bet that Leonard Nimoy would have approved and appriciated it.. 😉 I know that I do.

The old audio is a nice call back but it seems very uncreative to me.

So the only logical answer to the Kobayashi Maru test is to turn and abandon the civilian ship? The needs of the many (your crew) outweigh those of the few (the civilian ship)?

@crash10125

4 ай бұрын

If you watch the episode, he does that and his holo crew retaliated.

Yikes. That was weird and scary.

It's the real people. However audio clips would have been better with AI help

He sounds so similar to Leonard Nimoy. Where can I watch it?

@matthewkreps3352

2 жыл бұрын

It is Leonard Nimoy. They used clips from other episodes.

@hannahsmith-0lsen437

2 жыл бұрын

@@matthewkreps3352 Oh ok.

Wait hold up are they just use Sparks lines from old Star Trek TV shows and movies for this series ?

@patrickschulz2193

Жыл бұрын

They did on account of the actor's unavailability; everyone else recreated in this episode received the same treatment

@david42371

Жыл бұрын

Okay I see I recognize sparks lines from tv show and movies so it was very familiar to hear it back yes

It’s pretty jarring. Worse than that, if you’re an experienced Trekkie, you immediately know source for nearly all the dialogue. It starts with Spock’s conversation to Garovick in Obsession, then to Kirk in The Enemy Within and then to old Spock from Wrath of Khan to his conversation with Picard in TNG’s Reunification, Part 2 and finally, I believe, his farewell to Chris Pine’s Kirk Star Trek 2019. “It’s the only logical conclusion” is the only line I couldn’t directly place because it’s pretty generic and I need a little more. In a society that has fully interactive holograms, this cut and paste Spock is a little weird. There’s a very good Nimoy impersonator out there. They should have used him instead.

The only good star trek show after ENT.

spocks voice and audio qualiy kept changing and his voices was ageing lol the recordings needed a bit of tweeking to be more seamless and consistant

I don't watch modern Star Trek. I think its absolutely dreadful what CBS have done to Trek. But having watched this, I applaud the creativity of whomever was behind this scene. Its inventive, creative, and bloody well done. More high production values like this would put Trek back where it belongs-as the best television ever produced anywhere.

@Kusanagikaiser999

2 жыл бұрын

Surprisingly this show that is done by Nickelodeon (yes co produce by CBS as well) is like 100 times BETTER than anything Netflix and CBS have produce, this episode is an excellent example, I will recommended giving this show a chance, so far have been excellent.

@jondonnelly4831

2 жыл бұрын

I second that, it's a good show! I love alien cast, I mean I'd like an ex borg in there too but oh well. They do need a Security Officer. They have a Captain, A No1, a science officer, an engineering officer, a helm officer. Well none of them are officers, just kids who find a ship and use it to escape slavery but do an awesome job considering! The pet is way cooler than Data's cat and they might be joined by a Furry for the next season which could be the medic.

@brenster21

10 ай бұрын

@@jondonnelly4831 at the end of season 1 they get a security officer.

I mean, they could have used Ethan Peck for Spock, he does sound similar to Leonard Nimoy…

The audio disturbed me. The disjointed tone in the assembled recording only reminded me that Mr. Nimoy is not here any more and this was a very hollow construction. Great message and concept, the execution could have used work.

Honestly, all those spliced Spock lines felt choppy and weird, even though it was nice hearing Spock's actual voice being used. I'm thinking it might have been better to have a voice actor do Spock instead.

@Kusanagikaiser999

2 жыл бұрын

You missed the point....this simulation is running archives sounds of the original projected in a hologram simulation of the Kobayashi Maru, it kinda makes sense why they sound so weird and not match the hologram projection, I find this a very cleaver and creative way to use the original voices, and no voice actor will get you more invested emotional with these dialogues than the OG Spock Leonard Nimoy himself.

@vulcanmemes9770

Жыл бұрын

@@Kusanagikaiser999 coping

I dunno, something about animating around live-action voice tracks always feels awkward, the sound quality is very inconsistent and the dialogue between the archival recordings and new audio doesn't feel natural. People will disagree, but simply getting a great impersonator to read the lines would have been better.

What the fuck is this?!

I get what they were going for, but oof that execution was awful. There's the obvious issue with the wildly varying audio quality for each line Spock delivers, but the real problem is the choice of dialogue. Some of it fits, but so much of it feels out of place and inappropriate for the scene. It comes off like they couldn't find dialogue that said what they needed, so they just went with something they hoped people would infer their attempted meaning from instead, and it's clumsy as hell.

Something about this just feels really dirty and I don't like it.

Not sure why so many people love this show so much. Horrible graphics, and just full of old ideas and nostalgia.

Yeah, this is disjointed. They could at least have gotten Quinto or the guy who plays Spock on Discovery to do it.

@KlingonCaptain

2 жыл бұрын

Um no... 👎

@eoghanlacey6384

2 жыл бұрын

Just no that’s disrespectful to the dead people they are honouring

@GrooveYouVerse

2 жыл бұрын

@@eoghanlacey6384 So playing the character Spock in new episodes and movies is just as disrespectful?

@GrooveYouVerse

2 жыл бұрын

I was kinda using my imagination here to help me better accept the disjointed audio of Spock. I was saying to myself, that since Protostar was disconnected from Star Fleet, and Dal had many choices available to him, the computer used archived logs and mission logs to put together Spock's audio in such short notice and little information to work with. That's my only explanation, because it's not just the audio quality differences, but the fact that Spock was just answering in quotes, instead of pure dialogue. Of course, the original audio was for nostalgic purposes, and respect to the late Leonard Nimoy, and putting together just bits from episodes and movies had it's obvious disconnect, but the my explanation helped me better accept the issue.

@mrcritical6751

2 жыл бұрын

It would’ve felt wrong to get Quinto or for guy from Discovery. Don’t get me wrong I love Quinto as Kelvin Spock but this is meant to be TOS Spock through and through, they needed Nemoy for this

I hate this show.

Recycled sound bites of Spock from TOS and then the movies. Strung together, recorded at obviously different times in Nimoys life, it sounds very disjointed and artificial indeed. You can’t watch this anyplace now, it seems Paramount as abandoned this orphan entirely. Perhaps for good reason. Voyager never struck me a kids show at all and to be kind to this one, it’s got more in common with animated Star Wars than Trek. I can see why it was canceled.

I've never watched Star Trek Prodigy before. What the heck is going on with the sound? It's awful. Get the guy to record his lines properly.

@Lucas-my6fm

2 жыл бұрын

Its not recorded nowadays. Its Nimoy's voice from back when he was alive.

Just heard about this show. At first I was optimistic as the title sequence actually looks quite good. But having watched a trailer, and now this, I can see it's the same old Kurtzman vandalism of Star Trek. True Star Trek is about a hopeful, enlightened future of mankind - a people who are civilized, dignified, orderly, and decent, living in a beautiful, aspirational world. In stark contrast, all I see here is ugliness, scruffiness, freakishness, and a spirit of rebellion. These characters look like villains, and this purple-faced freak is utterly grotesque to the senses. Real Starfleet officers like Kirk and Spock dressed smartly and decently and would never associate with slimeballs like these - more likely that Spock would nerve pinch this punk, like he did in Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home!

@BedaOfBorg

2 жыл бұрын

Just look the show. All of your complaints will disappear, i promise ;)

@Scripture-Man

2 жыл бұрын

@@BedaOfBorg LOL I really hope so! These two clips are all I've seen so far and as a life-long Trek fan, it looks awful to me!

@ilttpvvm

2 жыл бұрын

“These characters look like villains”? So did the mother Horta until Kirk was able to communicate with her.

@Scripture-Man

2 жыл бұрын

@@ilttpvvm What an excellent comment!

@raistlin3462

Жыл бұрын

That's because the action is centered in another sector of the Galaxy currently not under the influence of the Federation. Brutal, gritty and lawless. The main cast are kids who have been slaves during most of their lives and are trying to live up Starfleet ideas without any of the formal training. Of course they look undignified in their roles.

This is awful and sucks so much

...this series looks horrible, and the sound thing just...no. There’s no reason for it. The animation CGI combination sucks, but i guess if they make it up with good story telling I can’t be mad at it (is there a good story behind it?)

@matthewkreps3352

2 жыл бұрын

Extremely good storytelling.