Coltrane probably did this exercise and ended up with Satelite :) Always good to dig in and look at the harmony and how it moves! 👍

@PANDORAZTOYBOKZ

3 жыл бұрын

Sounds a lot like Moment's Notice to me, which checks out to me since it's changes so closely resembles an inverted Trane substitution

sounds like cramming the night before a Giant Steps final in a Jazz Improv class.

@future62

4 жыл бұрын

Professor: "This is brilliant! Way to capture the essence of continuity through these phrases" Rest of class: 🙄🙄🙄🙄

@funkyjohnmusic

Жыл бұрын

Actually it’s the morning of 😳

@Quinceps

Жыл бұрын

So that’s what we caught you doing? 😂

@markjohnson9485

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂😂

When giant steps and easy are in the same sentence, you have to listen

@TheIndogamer

5 жыл бұрын

**jazz music stops** **starts listening**

@MauroDoninibrotherjake

4 жыл бұрын

@@TheIndogamer unless easy means "easy to get lost"

@anirbanraha8952

3 жыл бұрын

Then listen: Giant steps is not easy at all!

@ShapochkinKirill

2 жыл бұрын

And be disappointed... 'cos this guy can't play well enough to teach the subject.

@shanedefeo6881

2 жыл бұрын

And that's where it could get complicated.

This is a great one note samba tutorial.

@ivyssauro123

5 жыл бұрын

YES! thank god someone noticed

@pete5668

5 жыл бұрын

HA! I thought the exact same thing :)

@BrotherDevious

5 жыл бұрын

One note... it truly is a "solo"

@mdmsr2000

5 жыл бұрын

Brazil 66?

@tehrobotjesus

5 жыл бұрын

@@mdmsr2000 Jobim.

Hi Rick, watching your videos every day makes me feel like I´m studying private KZread music academy. I can´t thank you enough!

I love the breezy feel you get by letting the simplified melody ride over the complex background chord changes. A nice alternative to the busy soloing often associated with this piece.

I spent an entire semester working on this tune back in 2019. Refused to play it since then and now it feels like I'm starting all over again trying memorize the progression, solo strategies etc... This tune is truly a right of passage. I actually think its a beautiful tune since it's all based around major 7 chords but man... It's just mind twisting to keep track of where you are in the progression.

I love this idea of approaching a piece by paring back the harmony to the simplest melody that works with the chords, then branching out from there. Thanks!

Informative tutorial. Giant Steps is the apex of jazz compositions in most jazz musicians opinion. With that said, it is to be performed tempo wise about 286 bpm. A musician especially a guitarist would have to have the speed and melodic dexterity to properly play it at the John Coltrane tempo. Practice Practice and practice! If you blink you will miss one or more of the II -V's. On the hand, a piano friend who mastered Giant Steps at the recorded tempo in high school told me don't try to play through all the II-V progressions. Leave space and or sustain common tones until you mastered each section/progression like the Instructor of this tutorial said. I'm working on 1st and 2nd section mastering those then adding each II-V progression slowly and deliberately. Again, the changes go by at the blink of an eye. Mastery is attained by practicing this composition with focus and concentration every day. I'm mainly talking to & motivating myself by writing this. I haven't mastered this tune yet.

@toneseeker87

5 жыл бұрын

Peter Callaway it is 290bpm actually.

@petercallaway3420

5 жыл бұрын

@@toneseeker87it very well maybe. That's why I said, "tempo wise it's about 286bpm. Someone else wrote it was 286bpm I never really clocked it. I'll take your word for it though. Thanks!

@petercallaway3420

5 жыл бұрын

@@toneseeker87 Cuban jazz Pianist Gonzalo Rubacalba, Drummer Jack DeJohnette, and bassist John Pattituci have a version that's 300bpm or above and it still sounds musical. Amazing!

@Jplent1

5 жыл бұрын

You'd get closer to "mastering" this if you took less time pontificating.

@petercallaway3420

5 жыл бұрын

@@Jplent1 You obviously spent 60 seconds to read my comment so you need to take your own advice Pete . Ya think?

I'm a baby boomer, Grew up playing alot of guitar as a teen, Then gave it up awhile cause of my obligations. But, Playing again. You make these lessons so clear. Exc. Keep up the great work. PS, I studied with Sal Salvador for awhile, He taught me a lot of harmony, it's coming back watching your vids. TY.

The whiteboard is the most superior interface for teaching. There's just something so intuitive to watching another human's brain work through their writing

The complex becomes (more) simple, when analyzed like this. Takes a good teacher to do it.

This is fantastic, Rick. Thank you. I am relatively new to jazz and deciphering the harmony and melody like this is exactly what I'm looking for. Keep it up!

This is a terrific lesson Rick! Thank you so much for your time and your knowledge. Truly a gift to all!

Jobim meets Coltrane lol... I kid, but awesome video. Thanks for posting.

Man every video you post has so much info to figure out and that has propelled my music journey (I'm still a newbie) to the point that I had to buy a notebook (the ones with pages and everything), so I can slowly work everything out. Thank you Rick, you are an outstanding teacher. All the blessings to you.

Thank you for your devotion to music, and your generous gift of knowledge and talent!

A very compelling lesson. This covers a lot of ground well past Giant Steps into soloing in general and building chord melody/harmony as well. Way cool, thank you...!

Rick, I dont know how to say thanks. I took my today's music challenge studing Giant steps. I've seen like 5 tutorials on youtube, and... you're the best. thank you so much

Absolutely great content. Thank you very much for this lesson!

Rick thank you for this helpful video. I am trying to get my improvisations better, but always just played. Your lesson helped me being more aware of what Iam doing. Writing everything out on paper, while you we're explaining also changed the game. Keep on ! Greetings

Thanks Rick. I'm glad I found you. Thanks for your instruction.

RICK you are a Gifted Teacher and Musician..Thank you for yout Generous Sharing.

Thanks for this! This was very helpful for me as I begin to approach these changes. From reading the comments, I see there are very many improvisational strategies available! Focusing on common tone analysis seems like a good place for me to start - an entryway to the infinite multiplicity of possibility. I'm inspired to try using common tones, especially on open strings, as pedal tones to pick against on guitar.

I appreciate this. This made it easier to understand. Idk why I was complicating things

This is helpful and all to someone who doesn't already think that way, and makes for good practicing, but a person isn't likely to play more than a chorus or so with this strategy. It will buy you time or make for an interesting 8 bars, but there's still a lot more to build to from this point. This just helps you hear some of the inner voices to navigate within. Eventually you'd have to build melodies around these voice leading and common tones, which requires a bit of an obstacle course of sorts.

@gregcarter8656

3 ай бұрын

To put it bluntly, the "approach" or "strategy" shown in the video, i.e., figuring out in advance the fewest possible notes one could play, is not useful for jazz improvisation. In the first place, it is not improvisation, by definition, to "compose" one's solo in advance. And as you pointed out, it cannot be maintained without being boring. Coltrane's melody is nothing like that, and neither is his soloing on this song. New title: How to Wimp Out on Giant Steps.

"F! F! F!" exactly what i say too when im improving on giant steps lol

Love giant steps and your approach to soloing now time to apply the concept to help demystify soloing on other jazz tunes and Coltrane pieces

Man. This is great content! Thanks Rick!

Awesome talk and very much what I needed

This is gold. Great tutorial.

What's really cool to me is you can take multiple common tone melodies and put them together to make a chord solo with some nice counterpoint.

Rising line of half-steps and whole steps (with two pair of repeated tones), change by change: B-C-D-D-Eb-E-F#-G-Ab-Bb-A#-C-D-E

Very peaceful and melancholic melodies with this strategy, pretty nice. Sound like some Bossa Nova vocals or something.

Maybe I'm a noob here, but this is like an entire method on how to practice improvisation, thanks!

HOLY CRAP! I wish I had seen (or thought about this) back when I was in college, and listening to Giant Steps. I always viewed this tune as untouchable. Thinking about it this way makes it very accessible.

Love you beato this was everything i needed

I would totally call Rick the night before a big gig to cram all this info into muy head, this is wonderful

Rick, you are amazing, man.

i have seen a lot of video and comments about Giant Steps, and i never read the apporach i prefer: using the ear! Using the ear can make this piece of music nice. In fact Coltrain said that that song was an exercise. So if this piece is so hard to practice, using ONLY the harmonic bond is not useful to me. The cool thing is that you can take a breath thanks to this.

What the crap!!! Thanks so much much! Just seeing this helps see how Coltrane can stay inside or go outside of the structure. THANKS!!!!!!

its funny how I understand this all completely on an intellectual level but not on a musical level

@donaldbarnat

5 жыл бұрын

There's a lesson in that.

@BeN-bn5yb

4 жыл бұрын

Same

Outstanding lesson. Helped me a lot!!

does he even have another color shirt

@marklondon2008

5 жыл бұрын

Black is 'slimming'. Haha- just kidding.

@arthurbrands6935

5 жыл бұрын

He's a professional musician, he only has one shirt.

@VivaToddVegas

5 жыл бұрын

The dark side's calling, now nothing is real. She'll never know just how I feel.

@ethanlocke3604

4 жыл бұрын

Tony Brophy 😂

This is great information even for a bass player :-) Appreciated

This is excellent! I wonder who the two folks are who disliked this fantastic content and, more importantly, WHY did they give it the thumbs down?!?

@irishmuso7129

5 жыл бұрын

Perhaps they couldn't understand it, or they could understand it and didn't agree with the idea that soloing over Giant Steps could be made 'easy'. Maybe one thought the former and one the latter. What's your view on the matter?

Rick, you’re great teacher!

I tried this and got kicked off the bandstand for playing F# as my entire solo. Jokes aside, this was really helpful. Thanks, Rick!

i thought he was gonna say "And that principle, is common sense." LOL. Great video

As a guitar player, I've found the easiest way to work through new changes (for me) is to try to play the chords as rootless shell voicings with a static drone note (usually the Sol or Do of the key, but for my purposes it could be Ra for all I care) on top. In my mind it really highlights the linearity between chords, because it forces you to move in the most closely related motion possible.

song's called giant steps, but we look for the smallest steps possible XD

@SimpleManGuitars1973

3 жыл бұрын

Baby Steps. LOL!

@hansvandermeulen5515

2 жыл бұрын

Baby steps for one person, giant steps for music.

Another great lesson Rick thanks! Was wondering if you could do a video on your gear? I love the look of your Les Paul Junior and would like to find out more about it as well as what kind of gear you need to be able to work full time in the music industry like you do, with regards to recording and gigging.

Thanks for this.

Easy for Rick!

This is great tip!

Thanks for that lesson, im really struggling to play this tune in 200 bpm and keep improvising over all that different changes. Though i think you showed me the key

Totally works in theory Work to a smaller extend in practice ;) Face it, that's a lot of work be able to play very few notes It can't stand alone but it is still amomg valid approaches to knowing the chords Here's another one : Think of all the M7 chords as Dominant frygian or Alt

Awesome!!!!!

I just noticed that your falsetto sounds like Dylan's speaking voice!

@taopagan

5 жыл бұрын

At first, I thought you meant Bob Dylan...and were somewhat puzzled!

Easy... about as easy as driving an F1 car. It's a tune to challenge anyone at any level for their entire life. A cool tidbit from the maestro Ted Greene... He theorized that Coltrane thought of a 'Giant Step' as a major third which equals 2 two whole steps or... A Giant Step. The tune is based around a cycle of key centers descending by major 3rds with a deviation at the end. This is again from private lessons with Ted, it blew it wide open for me. The test is, as he would ask... 'so...can you play it in another key?'

@zeroblackstar

4 жыл бұрын

Ted Greene knows his stuff, got some of his books!

Incredible work, Rick. Thanks a lot for the effort in creating this material. I heard you mention that you studied with George Russell. Have you thought about doing a video -or a series- about his Lydian Chromatic Concept?

Thanks Rick

Whenever Rick breaks out the whiteboard, I know that I am clueless for what's about to come!

For every musical problem I have... There's a Rick Beato Video. Day'um.

I should have known that I want to start learning jazz and this song specifically, then when I look I find Rick 😂

I have always had trouble soloing over the bridge of Have You Met Miss Jones, the predecessor to Giant Steps. It always sounded jerky melodically speaking. I will use this technique to smooth it out. Thanks for the tip.

@thesphericalguy9018

6 жыл бұрын

Try the first 4 bars of Humpty Dumpty out.. Took me months to get some kind of music out of it

@petercallaway3420

5 жыл бұрын

@@thesphericalguy9018 Yep...another ultra straight ahead tune with multiple changes and in my opinion a more complex melody. Colrrane's Countdown and Hancock's One Finger Snap are quite challenging as well.

@petercallaway3420

5 жыл бұрын

You should listen to jazz guitarist Johnny Smith 's version. His speed and dexteriy is jaw dropping!.

Muchas gracias!

What's interesting to me is that "Giant Steps" very much feels like a modal tune with bebop flair when you really get into it. There's a video of Barry Harris talking about playing over this tune and he goes on to say the way to improvise over it is to play a MELODY, not arpeggiate the changes which is what many beginners do when approaching this tune. In one way, we can see this as the same approach Miles Davis was trying to get in "So What" and what Coltrane would later write a contrafact of in "Impressions" - in those tunes, the whole premise is to reduce the harmonic motion down to one chord per section (D-11 and Eb-11 respectively) so the player is forced to play melodically. In contrast, "Giant Steps" has so much harmonic motion that it forces the player to play melodically, but our modes are now a major third apart every few bars instead of the half-step apart between A's and B's.

this is giving me first year jazz program anxiety all over again.

thank you! will there be a part for the 2nd half of giant steps?

It's best to just play a constant C pedal and convince people that the harmony is completely non-functional haha. Seriously, great video as always, Rick!

Thanks Rick, cool way to break this down and simplify. Would you think about that F#, for instance, over changes (e.g. Bmaj) as an F#Maj with b7? Or, is that complicating what you are showing us here? I'm asking as I'm working on chord/scale harmonizing and learning the notes in each chord with the goal of playing over changes and getting out of scale boxes.

So If we were to take all the common chord tones as target notes,would you suggest connecting these notes using chromatics?

this was v edifying

Visualization of the scale that works over each chord is what I would suggest and not get too hung up on common tones while striving for melodic linearity.

Ok, let’s here this!

it's funny that now when I listening too the chords I'm kind listening this melodys within then

You have to practice with the goal of getting the direction of the changes in your head then it becomes intuitive.

2:29 ahahahaha the theme

@stephenfunk690

4 жыл бұрын

The dude can't stop singing the song.

@Atezian

3 жыл бұрын

hahahahaha

May I suggest a different approach where you take the "giant steps" between each chord tone and voice lead like that?

great vid. is there an AB comparison vid where you and/or the kids do the same thing --- but by ear .. no paper and pen? don't let me give you ideas though ..

hi, Rick! this is unrelated, but I've enjoyed your What Makes This Song Great series. Ever consider doing one for one of the songs on Thriller by Michael Jackson? A guitar or synth lesson would super great too. Thanks!

Rick, common tones wow, you are amazing, are you a music teacher?

Just curious about the guage of strings used? Nice round tone.

Would targettng or creating lines off connecting to the guide tones be a valid approach too?

@Edspillanemusic

4 жыл бұрын

That's what I do man but it's not really possible to connect all of the 3rds and 7ths with stepwise motion. That's why in some cases it will be necessary to target other chord tones like the fifth. In the video, he used some non-chord tones or extensions like the 9th.

COOL

YES!

A lesson to find the 5 tones that fit over the whole song... I have a different expectation of "improvisation".

@JackChessa

3 жыл бұрын

Probably not enough to solo over several choruses, but this idea helps you anchor your ear as well as gives you a bit of a safety net. Also helps link more melodic ideas over these changes which tend to give rather jumpy lines.

@gregcarter8656

3 ай бұрын

@@JackChessa . . . . . "Probably" ????? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

hi rick! would you cover the different music era and what make them unique ? baroque,classical,romantic etc...) thanks :)

@RickBeato

7 жыл бұрын

I will once I figure out how to get a license to play music for more that 6 seconds. I really need to play recordings to teach that. I really want to get into it but can't get around it. Suggestions welcome.

@futurebeats898

7 жыл бұрын

+Rick Beato Midi files can probably get downloaded for free and than played in pro tools.

@futurebeats898

7 жыл бұрын

+c medeiros copyrights on very old composition turn obsolete i think im not sure. so the midi would be perfect

@MichaOssowski

7 жыл бұрын

There are lots of public domain classical music recordings on IMSLP. Even orchestral music.

@FernieCanto

7 жыл бұрын

The KZread content ID *very* often wrongly identifies copyrighted recordings, even when it comes to fully original renditions. Using a public domain recording is no guarantee that you won't have your video flagged for copyright infringement.

cool

I agree that the concept is similar too one note samba but i think it actually sounds a bit closer to Chet Baker

Nice! Question about your 2-5-1 chord changes: The 4th bar is the 2-5 leading to the Gmaj7 in bar 5. So it should be Am7-D7, but you have it as A7-D7. Similarly in the 9th bar, where the chords are a 2-5 setting up the Ebmaj9 in bar 10, it's Fm7-Bb7, but you used F7-Bb7 instead. I'm curious why you didn't use the minors on the 2s of those 2-5-1 changes like what is normally transcribed. Thanks Rick.

@FelterOfficial

3 жыл бұрын

He is! The "-" next to the chord denotes minor quality. He also uses the minor third in his chord spellings above (A C E G is the spelling of Am7, a C# would be the third of a dominant chord). Hope this helps!

@apparentlybrian

3 жыл бұрын

@@FelterOfficial Yes that did help. I don't use the "-" notation so it went right by me, as did the ACEG spelling. Brain fart? Or just a Brian fart? LOL Thx Collin!

I never noticed that F7 chords' notes read "FACE", that's mildly funny

@ChuloDavidcito

7 жыл бұрын

True! And when I'm in a bar, sometimes the FACED chord comes up.

@davyt5183

7 жыл бұрын

Funnier is that for F Dominant 7 it's FACE FLAT because of the E flat haha

@pleximanic

6 жыл бұрын

F "major" 7 does that

@Theworkingbassplayer76

6 жыл бұрын

F7 is F/ A/ C and E flat! Fmajor 7 is indeed FACE.. just a friendly observation brother

@cobyup10

6 жыл бұрын

Evidently not a sight reader then I take it lol

the content here is excellent but anyone also take notice of the woody tone that Rick gets out of that solid body? killin' me.

is this what you need to think about live?

oops there are two common tones between D7 and and Am7- why did you decide on the semitone movement rather?

@goodshipzion

5 жыл бұрын

Half-step resolution is a stronger pull.

Did Rick do an analysis of what Coltrane played over these changes?

@gregcarter8656

3 ай бұрын

That would be far more interesting, and far more useful, than this video on "How to Avoid Soloing on Giant Steps".

wow

Hey now I can solo on GS. Just play Gb. G Eb D *whole notes* (as fast as I can go at 286 bpm 😂 )

Uhhh when do do do's doesn't help me solo over the key changes....