Please join the David Starkey Members' Club via Patreon www.patreon.com/davidstarkeytalks or Subscribestar www.subscribestar.com/david-starkey-talks and submit questions for members Q & A videos. Also visit www.davidstarkey.com to make a donation and visit the channel store shop.davidstarkey.com. Thank you for watching.

@normamorris9803

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Dr. David starkey I've been a fan of yours for a very long time,

@alayneperrott9693

Жыл бұрын

Bravo!

Buckingham faced the axe, Wolsey faced the axe, Fisher faced the axe, More faced the axe, Cromwell faced the axe, Norfolk and son faced the axe - his son, Surrey, died; he, Norfolk, lived because Henry VIII predeceased him. Wolsey and Cromwell never ceased to be the King's creatures. Buckingham, Norfolk and son were self-interested noblemen who conceivably threatened the King's position. If you must die at the hands of the King, better to die for a higher purpose, like Fisher, More, and also Becket. Your life can be taken from you, your morality never can be but of you own choosing.

@jopuk9518

2 жыл бұрын

What if you have a family that you are leaving behind? The Boleyns would have probably faced much worse consequences had Anne, George or Thomas stood firmly and opposed the King even more.

@renshiwu305

2 жыл бұрын

@@jopuk9518 What matters more? Wealth and position or dignity and truth? Thomas Boleyn obviously thought the former, which is why he kept schtum for the remaining three years of his sad life. His children were murdered by conspiracy and he said nothing. He thought silence was worth it. I wouldn't have thought that. Maybe he was thinking about his granddaughter's future. Well, I really don't think Henry would have executed his own child like a Russian tsar (Ivan IV, Peter I, Stalin). Even in this scenario, if I read Thomas Boleyn's mind correctly, wealth and status (Elizabeth's potential queenship) was his calculation.

@grannyannie6744

2 жыл бұрын

You forgot Margaret Pole.

@astardustparade

Жыл бұрын

You forgot Anne Boleyn

@maryearll3359

Жыл бұрын

@@jopuk9518 Brother George was beheaded the day before Anne's demise- allegations of incest. No one could oppose the King, those were dark times.

Listening to David starkey helps me lots with my biopilar disorder keeps me carm and seem to be able to connect with events David teaches us in. I thank you very much new member to your club 🇬🇧💙

@grannyannie6744

2 жыл бұрын

Me too.

@davidprobert8078

2 жыл бұрын

@@grannyannie6744 Hi Annie we both love David’s videos hope brings you pleasure like myself 💙

@robertm7071

Жыл бұрын

My best wishes to you David. I am sorry you have that condition but I hope things can improve in the future and that you will lead a happy life.

@jaspreetKaur-tp8uv

Жыл бұрын

If u have bipolar, u keep on reciting Jesus name all the time, u will be cured

I love More's quote just before he is beheaded " I die the King's good servant, but God's first".

@MarilynRB

2 жыл бұрын

@Ruth Collins I couldn’t agree more! I hope his last words were repeated to Henry and maybe it caused him some pause. I know it’s easy to look at these events in our 21st century eyes; however, I think the death of Moore was perhaps the most tragic of all of those Henry used and disposed of,

@petah-peoplefortheendlesst4668

2 жыл бұрын

More had it coming. Read Mantel's "Bring Up the Bodies". He was awful.

@kenbell3250

2 жыл бұрын

@@petah-peoplefortheendlesst4668 She is a novelist, so not a legitimate source for More or anything else. To be fair, neither is Robert Bolt, the playwright.

@AM-vq2ol

2 жыл бұрын

One of the people I admire most. Along with Katherine of Aragon.

@pattierotondo1108

Жыл бұрын

@@MarilynRB Cardinal Fisher was also brave in the face of Henry's tyranny. It may have been easier for him, since he had no family for Henry to avenge himself upon. Better to die with the truth than to live his last years as a lie. More tried hard to avoid speaking out, but, in the end, he does so. I think he was trying to protect his family. If he had no family, he might have spoken sooner.

Such a luxury & a rarity - in these present days - to listen to the informed perspectives of Dr Starkey - beautifully orated - accessible intelligent historic accounts about the heritage & history of our country - wonderful. Clearly a case where "wokery" worked in the public's favour. Love that latter irony!

@Redrosewitch

2 жыл бұрын

What Cambridge University foolishly threw away, we get to benefit from.

@marinaknife4595

2 жыл бұрын

@@Redrosewitch Exactly & isn't it wonderful ... always look forward to Dr Starkey's videos.

@MarilynRB

2 жыл бұрын

@Marina Knife I couldn’t agree with you more. It’s for that very reason I support him on Patreon. I want to see his KZread channel subscribers go to the MILLIONS!

I can think of no greater pleasure than seeing a new David Starkey video to enjoy on a Friday night after a tiring week at work. I shall have a glass of wine or two and enjoy. Thank you David xXX

As a lawyer and a Catholic, I've always found More fascinating. Inspiring history presented in Dr Starkey's compelling style. Always a pleasure.

I still enjoy watching A Man for All Seasons, with Paul Scofield as More and Robert Shaw as Henry.

@somyod2u

2 жыл бұрын

From a play written by Robert Bolt - a Roman Catholic.

@bekytwining2522

2 жыл бұрын

i think that More believed in torturing protestants and did it!!!! so, as a saint he was à Saint!!!

@grannyannie6744

2 жыл бұрын

Great movie.

@stellakowalski1

Жыл бұрын

@@bekytwining2522 prove that.

@tommyjordan1988

Жыл бұрын

A wonderful film!

When I was a boy here in Germany, like many other youths, I was a member of the KJG ( Catholic youth). It wasn't very religious though but Thomas Moore (Thomas Morus for us) was it's patron saint. We were never told anything about the man. Now I know. Thank you.

@SATMathReview1234

2 жыл бұрын

Pray for us all St Thomas More

I didn't realise Henry had known More since childhood. Well that certainly explains why he relied on his advice so much. Until More started to not do what Henry wanted. No wonder he was so inspired by Beckett.

I’ve always loved this from A MAN FOR ALL SEASONS: “When a man takes an oath, Meg, he's holding his own self in his own hands. Like water (he cups his hands) and if he opens his fingers then, he needn't hope to find himself again. Some men aren't capable of this, but I'd be loathe to think your father one of them.” Robert Bolt, A Man for All Seasons

Saint Thomas More. Thank you for sharing.

I think if David had been a historical consultant on A Man For All Seasons he would have made it an even greater film.🎥🎬😂

Sir Thomas More will always have my respect . A man with absolutely integrity Principles and Honor. I’m sure you are in a place where you are respect value & love . Thanks for you videos they are very much appreciate . Greetings from California. 💕

@AM-vq2ol

2 жыл бұрын

I admire him so much.

@keithrobinson5752

2 жыл бұрын

Those principles include the killing and torturing of people for 'thought crimes' He was blind to the quite clear problems in the Church of Rome, remember the pope refused Henry's request for a divorce for political, not religious reasons. The same pope was happy to grant divorces when it was 'profitable '

@maryearll3359

Жыл бұрын

@MJ Richards.... I did too until I learnt he tortured and then killed over, if I remember correctly, about 100 people who wouldn't repent from wanting to worship but not to the Roman Catholic rules. Couldn't reconcile that to a man of God. He was a fanatic. Went right off him

@pattierotondo1108

Жыл бұрын

@@maryearll3359 Who are you talking about? More had no power to torture or execute anyone.

@ianbanks3016

9 ай бұрын

@@pattierotondo1108 He was Lord Chancellor, of course he did.

When Michelangelo was crafting a statue of Pope Julius II, Julius offered this suggestion: "Put a sword there [in my statue's hands, rather than a scroll], for I know nothing of letters."

Brilliant! I've always liked More because he educated his daughters, and female wards, to the same level as his sons. I like that in a man. Thanks, Dr. Starkey.

@dianeshelton9592

Жыл бұрын

Yet he had no,problem at all authorising torture and death on others. He is very much a man who is bigoted in his beliefs. Not sure that is enough to overcome educating his own daughters, yet not other daughters.

@maryearll3359

Жыл бұрын

@@dianeshelton9592 At last ! Someone else who recognises More was a murderer.

@pattierotondo1108

Жыл бұрын

@@dianeshelton9592 Where is your evidence? More didn't have that kind of power - Henry did,

@pattierotondo1108

Жыл бұрын

@@maryearll3359 On what evidence? More didn't have the power to execute anyone - Henry did. I sense some anti-Catholic bigotry here, not knowledge of history. Stating that heretics should be punished is not the same as doing it.

Henry had almost a pathological way of disposing of people once they weren’t useful to him any longer. I wonder if he ever looked in the mirror and thought “God, what have I done?”. I always thought the death of Sir Thomas Moore to be the most tragic of all those Henry used and discarded of, or at least close to what he did to Catherine of Aragon. Who is with me? I’d love to discuss this in the comments.

@AM-vq2ol

2 жыл бұрын

Katherine of Aragon is one of the people I love and admire most, along with St Thomas More. Remarkable, both of them. True to themselves, and courageous to the end. They never wavered.

@MarilynRB

2 жыл бұрын

@@AM-vq2ol I couldn’t agree with you more. My heart truly aches for Catherine; after 20 years to just be tossed aside like she was a mistake? Again, he was pathological the way he just got rid of people.

@edithengel2284

11 ай бұрын

He did apparently have some regret about Cromwell ex post facto. The French ambassador, de Marilliac, reported that Henry had complained to him that, "under pretext of some slight offences which he had committed, they had brought several accusations against him, on the strength of which he had put to death the most faithful servant he ever had." Henry also treated Cromwell's son (married to Jane Seymour's sister) with consideration, and made him Baron Cromwell only 5 months after Thomas's execution.

Happy Feast day, Dr Starkey! Your knowledge is abundant and your gift of sharing a true treasure ❤❤❤ Please do a new video soon!

Thank you Dr Starkey. You not only make me think - but make me rethink.

Thanks Dr Starkey. You always bring a new perspective to these famous figures whose stories we've heard so often, ones that make them feel fresh again. And get us thinking. I'd certainly hate to be in the positions of either Thomas Beckett, John Fisher or Thomas More. Because what dilemmas they faced. Didn't Henry II make Beckett Archbishop of Canterbury, because he was so sure that his old friend would always side with him? But then, of course, Archbishop Beckett realises that he might be the king's friend, but his Master is actually God. And he can't serve two Masters. And then looking at the history between Henry VIII and Thomas More. It's not to be wondered at that such as especially egotistical and selfish monarch would assume that More would never say 'no' to him. But Henry find that there's a rival that he can't win against, and that's God. Thomas More believes that his king wants him to agree to something that goes against God's Will. And he can't do it. But imagine the fear of knowing that you stand to lose something, whichever way you turn. Say 'no' to the king and you're a traitor which means death. Say 'no' to God and you're a heretic, which means Hell and Damnation.

I found this moving. Thanks very much David.

Once again, a superb video. Thank you, David.

Wonderful having my brain exercised with my favorite historian

Brilliant, totally absorbed by the talk great.

Thank you so much for this! I am minded of Joseph Campbell's wonderful quote about the importance and influence of heroes: "We have not even to risk the adventure alone, for the heroes of all time have gone before us. The labyrinth is thoroughly known; we have only to follow the thread of the hero path. And where we had thought to find an abomination, we shall find a god. And where we had thought to slay another, we shall slay ourselves. And where we had thought to travel outward, we shall come to the center of our own existence. And where we had thought to be alone, we shall be with all the world."

brilliant another DS video - Thank You so much.

The Lord Chief Justice says: "if it's an Act of Parliament, it's good enough". Then Dr Starkey says: "a classic position of English Common Law". I hope David will forgive me, but an Act of Parliament is *Statute Law* - a very different animal from English Common Law, which derives from centuries of judicial precedent and basic humanist principles of natural justice - one could even call it "common sense". Indeed, Sir Thomas More could not have been condemned under English Common Law (which was eventually adopted by the United States and countless other jurisdictions around the World). It was *Statute Law* which sent him to his death. Aside from this, yet again a wonderfully insightful account. Many thanks.

@dan4lau

2 жыл бұрын

I think the point David was making, was that according to common law, there is nothing... within the realm of England, that an act of parliament cannot do/declare. It's a common law position on the power of statute law. I hope that makes sense... and I hope I'm not mis-representing Professor Starkey.

@maryearll3359

Жыл бұрын

@@dan4lau Absolutely.

Would absolutely love a dedicated video to Becket. Really enjoyed this exploration of Thomas More, probably my favourite of Henry’s Thomas servants!

Thank you for your fortitude!

I'd love to hear you talk about Cardinal Newman.

Thank you David for an amazing video once again! Stay amazing.

Yes, Thomas More suffered the agony of martyrdom. So did the "heretics", arrested on the orders of More. John Frith being an example of that.

@pattierotondo1108

Жыл бұрын

And it was HENRY who was responsible for the deaths of them both. More was following the faith and was punished for defying Henry.

@helpmaboabb

Жыл бұрын

​@@pattierotondo1108Hmm... he was only obeying orders. Not exactly a robust defence.

Another great talk. Many thanks.

A Man For All Seasons (Al Stewart) What if you reached the age of reason Only to find there was no reprieve Would you still be a man for all seasons? Or would you just have to leave We measure our days out In steps of uncertainty Not turning to see how we've come And peer down the highway From here to eternity And reach out for love on the run While the man for all seasons Is lost behind the sun Henry Plantagenet still looks for someone To bring good news in his hour of doubt While Thomas More waits in the Tower of London Watching the sands running out And measures the hours out From here to oblivion In actions that can't be undone A sailor through the darkness He scans the meridian And caught by the first rays of dawn The man for all seasons Is lost beneath the storm And I should know by now I should know by now I hear them call it out all around Oh, they go There's nothing to believe in Hear them, Just daydreams, deceiving They'll just let you down What if you reached the age of reason Only to find there was no reprieve Would you still be a man for all seasons? Or would you just disbelieve? We measure our gains out in luck and coincidence Lanterns to turn back the night And put our defeats down to chance or experience And try once again for the light Some wait for the waters of fortune to cover them Some just see the tides of ill chance running over them Some call on Jehovah Some cry out to Allah Some wait for the boats that still row to Valhalla Well, you should try to accept what the fates are unfolding While some say they're sure where the blame should be falling You look round for maybe a chance of forestalling Bot too soon its over and done And the man for all seasons Is lost behind the sun

St Thomas More was "cancelled" by Henry . It's the same concept as is being currently applied to those who speak out the truth.

@AM-vq2ol

2 жыл бұрын

Definitely a parallel there

As always an illuminating discussion.

Absolutely fascinating. Thank you for this analysis and insight.

I really like these deep-dives into specific people or aspects of your domain of expertise.

Thank you!! Excellent insights to More's connections to Henry personally & politically. I could listen to you talk history all day.

I love your history talks -- informed, insightful, enlightening and endlessly rich.

I enjoy so much these talks. Thank you, Dr. Starkey. Your expertise and fact-based insight keeps me coming back to listen.

Thankyou David for these wonderful history talks. I look forward to them so much. Please keep them going. Thankyou so much.

LIKE. Even before the talk starts.

Thank you Dr. Starkey, amazing video, as always. Best regards from NJ, USA.

Excellent as usual. Thanks

Thank you Dr. Starkey.

Wonderful channel thankyou Dr David Starkey I could listen to you all day ❤️

Great thanks for this, @David Starkey. Brilliant, historical talk on Sir Thomas More here Sir. I have subscribed. Thanks again, Patrick ✨🙏😊

I feel so lucky to have such an opportunity to listen to these wonderful and interesting talks. Thank you so much.

David Starkey is such a great historian! I would like to watch more video lectures from other time periods of UK history.

I'm so glad I found you. I shall be a binging!

Another first rate video. These are surely the best TV programmes on history there has been. This is the real thing

Dear Dr Starkey-Please forgive this intrusion upon your time. May I begin by saying how very much I enjoy your work.Your style is both erudite and entertaining, and I doff my cap to you sir. It always strikes me as odd that the ecclesiastic policy of King Henry VIII constitutes a complete denial of one of the primary articles of the Magna Carta, namely "that the English Church shall be free, and shall have its rights undiminished, and its liberties unimpaired". Very odd for a King as patriotic as the eighth Henry to so openly flout so vital an aspect of ancient law. If I may ask, what is your view.

@tobiasbellhouse8107

2 жыл бұрын

?

Thank you.

Keep em coming. Love them.

This is great. love history, David Starkey is brilliant 💫

Excellent as usual.

Absolutely wonderful. History was difficult for me in school, because it was forced upon us to learn dates and the like. This really brings it to life. The pieces of the jigsaw puzzle are falling into place thanks to you. Greetings from New Zealand.

Great video David love your channel

fantastic speaker. i always loved listening to you and will always subscribe to any places where you speak

My high school was sir Thomas more high school. Catholic of course . Saw the portrait every day when I walked into school. Sparked the beginnings of my love of history

@Eris123451

2 жыл бұрын

History as practiced by Roman Catholics tends to be extremely biased, partizan and and leans toward indoctrination, I still remember trying to explain the Protestant Reformation and it's antecedents to 3 Roman Catholic children of my former acquaintance and it was almost completely beyond their ability to comprehend. Apparently the main cause of the Reformation was that Martin Luther wanted to shag a nun, which make me wonder if people like Starkey and peers aren't perhaps wasting their time a bit ?

@maryearll3359

Жыл бұрын

@shelleygibbons1065 .....I used to admire him until I found out he was a murderer.

I find More's dedication to his faith admiral. Both him and Fisher I believe earned their sainthood in the Roman Catholic Church

David, thank you so much for taking the time to educate me on history. Continue to do excellent work. I'd be interested in hearing about Oliver Cromwell's life and times.

I greatly enjoy your Videos.

Could you please do a video on St. John Fisher

Interesting history I didn't know about one of my favorite saints, Thomas More.

a man for all seasons is an allegory, a moral tale. moore was a religous fanatic at a time when religion and politics were the same . he lost in the game as did cromwell. moore tortured and condemned men for their beliefs so he got what he deserved. he was not a man for all seasons

i hope david that you had a good new year for 2022 i think this upload is one of your best so far no one i am sure would say that sir thomas more was not brave to go against harry but it is good to know that thomas is a patron saint for children and also for our parliament but our mps have not his good nature or his sense of right most of them dont or cant come close as sir thomas more thanks again for your upload see you soon stay well and safe yours avon leicestershire 2022

Hello Starkey i do enjoy your videos. Could you make a video about Jeanne D' Arc. Thank you

Were I to have lived in that time I certainly would have been religious. Born in the '50s, though, I could not imagine how anyone could be. Thus, I struggle to understand so much of the past in the context of religion. Thank you, Dr. Starkey, for illuminating this in the case of More - a case I never felt I understood.

@amysill3815

10 ай бұрын

I was an atheist for 20 years… never again. Pretty awful time and worse yet, atheism isn’t even true. Praying for you.

@BlueBaron3339

10 ай бұрын

@@amysill3815 Truth is obviously not on the side of religion. Truth is indeed often unpleasant and rarely comforting. So...I get it. I do. But spare me the passive-aggressive promise of prayers on my behalf.

@amysill3815

10 ай бұрын

@@BlueBaron3339 truth is on the side of Catholicism. You have my prayers anyway. You need them.

@BlueBaron3339

10 ай бұрын

@@amysill3815 Well, Amy, if you're right, one day, in the fullness of time, you can say to me, "Told ya so. And, *you're welcome!*" 😄

@amysill3815

10 ай бұрын

@@BlueBaron3339 I would just rejoice.

Thank

Brilliant

Obviously More was relatively on the side of the law, people and tradition. And he wasn't alienated or marginalised. He was murdered by a criminal tyrant. He's rightly a saint.

I like to drink beer before and during Mr Starkey's presentations. That way, when I watch again, it's like it's all new. Double value.👍

Really interesting and often revelatory in his field of study. Rarely so outside of it.

@twotonne5580

Жыл бұрын

Outside of it he is best described as “sound and fury, signifying nothing.”

St Thomas died for the Church, it's dogma, doctrine and papal fatherhood. Because someone who disowns their own father is not a true son. We can also call him the resolute opponent of the Revolution. Because all politics is also belief. And all conflict theological.

It is, as always, a pleasure to listen to Dr Starkey (presume that has not been rescinded) but shall once again begin my comment by suggesting Dr Starkey sit further away from the camera -- it would improve things greatly (see Peter Whittle's programme). Also, the line from the great play is: 'To do the right THING for the wrong reason.'

If Sir Thomas More could speak, I wonder what legal case he would make of today's crisis. The unlimited exercise of Govt power against the most basic rights of the individual is something he knows well about.,

We disagree on many political things but I love your voice and its a shame your not on TV anymore

We all have our orders, whether it be by command of Church or State.

It is doubtful that More said " the king's good servant, but God first" because More was very cautious not to antagonise the king's council, fearing that it could endanger his family (More's).

I think that Saint Thomas More was great, he didn't want to die and he expressed reason and logic and the truth but against evil and lies, it doesn't matter, what's interesting is the very small number of people who stood firm, to the point of death and I guess this is normal, very few people can face death , most people aren't martyr material , even among the early Christians the number of martyrs was small by percentage among them , life is so precious, to be put to the test would be frightening .

Shame you're not on the telly any more. I seem to see the girl parade on the BBC history now: Alice Roberts, the goth girl and somewhat dull Lucy Worsley.

I have a question. As a Catholic, do you believe that England will ever condemn it's split with the True Christian Church?

A democracy is an aristocracy or orators (Thomas Hobbes).

Dearest David . I’m so disappointed that you reply to members only . I’ve made this clear some months ago. Some of us cannot pay the required amount for membership and so on. Why not select a non members question once a fortnight? Or once a month? I just watched both movies relating to this subject. Becket, Burton was great but O’toole was sensational. And A man of all Seasons. Scofield sublime. I have had very similar thoughts and questions as Rory. And I’m delighted to watch you answering these points of inquiry so fully and with compelling answers and reason. I as many miss your first class historical tv production’s on network TV. And surprised that you have not received offers from National Geographic or Discovery or Sky documentaries to name a few, for your enlightened historical knowledge , honesty , integrity that allows you to entertain us with our very own history. Programs on Becket and or Thomas More would be so informative and delightful. A new perspective regarding your favorite Henry viii? And an in depth program on Richard iii , with regards to the evidence of his brother not being sired by the same father , the Tudor destruction and altering of Richard’s portraits and the hump or not the hump :) finally twins in the tower . Please consider your admirers and the people who respect your opinions and would continue to hear them even though they are not members. I wish you all the best and I hope you can find the time to respond to this comment in the hope that your team passes it on to you. Yours sincerely. Dave in Hamburg

A symbol of the Church over the state or over the monarchy?

thanks again david for your most kind and good upload for our sir thomas more if i could have been in that time i would have begged harry not to execute thomas in the series the tudors harry tells his charles brandon that he regreted what had happened to thomas and that he wished that thomas did not die to see his execution in the series of the tudors was and is so sad but just like the poor cardinal them boleyns were to blame yours avon leicestershire 2022

I was listening to a Holbien art expert. Holbien knew Thomas More, and he liked him. Holbien did not care for Thomas Cromwell. The painting of Anne of Cleves was wooden. Holbien knew Cromwell thought her a good match and perhaps made Anne of Cleves look better than reality. He used a weird frontal view imo the current Prince Henry is what you get with a state church. The current pope is moving toward synodality which started with the counter reformation.

So, being an 'honourable' man More make no attempt to use his position as, a-hem, a 'platform' to espouse his convictions in opposition to his king and friend. What a novel notion!

Henry Tudor, but why did he chew her?😆

A classic act of English common law murdered More? Henry tore up Magna Carta for a start.

What was the role of Moore in the ultimate martyrdom of Tyndale . After all you wouldn't want people reading the Bible in the common language would you ?

Interessante

Perhaps the problem for Moore was the degree to which he was a good 'imitator of Jesus', or not. Am I not correct that Moore had no hesitation in sentencing human beings to be burned alive? If that is correct, where were his 'principles' in those instances? And it is not sufficient to state, "He was a man of his times"; because the 'model' for him was the same as it is for us today.

Saint sir Thomas Moore, English martyr, ora pro nobis.

When is the Prince Andrew episode so called scholar

Hi, would you please add a post box address or street address for those who would like to donate with snail mail? Would you do a history report on why so many people left England for America between 1620 - 1740. Our US history is not covering it well.

Why did Beckett go against Henry II to the extent he must have known his life was in danger? Not something consistent with common sense.

Didn't the Pope have Moore military might than any Henry? Hence advise to kneel before Pope? Unless you build an army so grand the Pope wouldn't dare take it on?