Shubh Khalistani hai? | Khalistan Controversy Explained
You may have heard Punjabi singer Shubh's songs, even if unintentionally while scrolling through reels and shorts. He's quite popular, with a fan following that includes cricket sensation Virat Kohli and star player Hardik Pandya. However, in March this year, on the 22nd to be precise, Shubh posted a story on Instagram that created quite a stir. The story featured a map with Punjab in black and the rest of India in shades of light yellow and white. Jammu and Kashmir appeared heavily faded, almost invisible. This sparked outrage, with allegations that Shubh had shared a distorted map of India.
Kangana Ranaut also chimed in with a post, calling Shubh a Khalistani sympathizer. But, let's not forget, Kangana has a habit of making strong statements. Meanwhile, Shubh had a concert scheduled in India after this controversy, but things took a turn for the worse. Virat Kohli unfollowed him, sponsors withdrew their support, and the booking company declared, "We are not rolling." Public sentiment on social media was far from loving.
After the concert cancellation, Shubh posted a lengthy explanation, expressing his disappointment over the situation. He reminded everyone that India is his homeland too and that he was deeply saddened by the concert's cancellation. So, the question remains: did Shubh truly depict India's map incorrectly, or was he unfairly labeled a Khalistani sympathizer?
In March, Punjab Police arrested Amritpal Singh, a Khalistani supporter. To prevent the spread of fake news and to ensure people didn't take the law into their own hands, internet and electricity services were temporarily disrupted in parts of Punjab. Shubh had posted his story on the 22nd of March, amid this chaos. Things eventually settled down, but Shubh's following continued to grow.
He even planned an India tour under the name "Rolling-2," with BookmyShow as the organizer. Concerts were scheduled in several Indian cities. However, amidst all this, the Khalistani terrorist, Hardeep Singh Nijjar, was sho+ in Canada, and India and Canada engaged in diplomatic discussions after the G-20 summit. In the midst of this, Shubh's screenshot with the map went viral again, leading to Virat Kohli unfollowing him. At that time, Shubh had portrayed a map of India in a way that blacked out Punjab, with a police officer holding a wire and darkness over Punjab. However, the real controversy surrounded the disappearance of Jammu and Kashmir and the Northeastern states from the map.
Join us in this video as we dissect whether is it fair to label Shubh a Khalistani sympathizer?
#Shubh #HardeepSinghNijjar #Controversy
Script: Amrit Tiwari
Editing: Govind Thakur
🤝 Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @rohitupadhyay
🤗 Support me:
/ rohitupadhyay
FOLLOW ME ON:
📩 Telegram: t.me/rohitupadhyaychannel
📸 Instagram: / rohitupadhyaay
🐦 Twitter: / rohitupadhyaay
🎥 Facebook: / rohitupadhyay0
▶️ Channel: / rohitupadhyay
Пікірлер: 248
"Kisi desh bhakt Sikh ko khalistani kahna, khalistan supporters ki help karna" apki yeh baat 101% sahi hai.
Salute to you brother 👏🏼 आप जैसे लोगों के संग ही भारत भारत कहलाता है । You Always provide us valuable information and transparent truth about every matter. WE INDIAN'S NEED YOU BROTHER 🙏🏼 A LOT OF BLESSINGS FROM EVERY PERSON WHO HAS SAME MENTALITY AS YOU 🙏🏼
Yahi Virat , Hardik, Aman Gupta aur Kl Rahul tab Kahan the jab kisaan road per the😢😢
@md.sameerahmed9569
10 ай бұрын
Bangkok me body massage le rhe honge.... Manipur pe, Farmers strikes, Wrestlers pe inki bolti bnd rehti hai..kyu ki woh desh ka hissa ni hai na...😏
@sandhujatt1362
6 ай бұрын
shi bola
Agar Hindu Rashtra shi hai toh Khalistan bhi shi hai 💀 , lekin ye thodi dekhega koi ! Majority ki sarkar jo hai ! India sirf naam ka democratic reh gya hai
@GoluKr-hn3lb
6 ай бұрын
Hindu rashtra ka matalab tujhe pta hai? Acche se explain kar to jara kya hai hindu rashtra?
Pehla youtuber dekha jisne facts k saath sach bola … luv u brother
@vinodviny125
10 ай бұрын
Waheguru ji da Khalsa waheguru ji di fatah jai hind and khalistaniya di aisi di taisi
I dont have words to express gratitude to you for making this video brother. At first After seeing thumbnail, i was about to skip this video, considering it would be an average right winger once again trying to prove that shubh is khalistani. But now I am really very glad that I watched the video till end. Due to extreme negativity towards sikhs in general on social media All of a sudden, I was feeling alienated in my own country. I was wondering why it is always us that get trapped into this hatred trap. This video literally worked like a therapy. Thankyou Rohit Bhai. Much love from Punjab.
@vinodviny125
10 ай бұрын
Jas bhai waheguru ji da Khalsa wahe guruji di Fateh we respect Sikhs but not khalistanis
@Atheisttandpatriotic
4 ай бұрын
In reality subha is khalistani
Actually asli khalistani to Hindu rastra wale hai asliyat me inke uper awaj uthani chahiye per ye wo desh hai jaha hamesha galat chijo ko sahi thahraya jata hai
@punarbasunath7730
10 ай бұрын
Muslman Pakistan bana sak te he hum Hindu rashtra kiyu nahi
@The_Failureone
10 ай бұрын
@@punarbasunath7730 to jo uska hall hai wahi hamara bhi hoga
@Shivraj-Saroj
10 ай бұрын
@@The_Failureone❤
@Shivraj-Saroj
10 ай бұрын
Exactly 💯
@Ahmed_Mohiuddin
10 ай бұрын
@@punarbasunath7730Aaj Pakistan Economic Crisis se juj rha hai aaj 40% Pakistan ki Population Below Poverty line hai, Basic Amenities jaise Pani, Bijli, Ration jaise suvidhaon ke liye bhi aaj Aam Pakistani taras Raha hai, Kya Tum Bharat ko Hindu Pakistan banana chahte ho, Pak Kattar Islam ka naam per tabh tarah ho Gaya, Puri duniya mein Pakistan ko ek State Sponsor of Terrorism ki tarah dekha jata hai, Kya Tum Bharat ko bhi Usi nakshe kadam par le ja na chate ho, Agar haan toh tumhe apne aap ko Bharatiya, Indian ya Hindustani yahan tak ki Hindu bulane ka koi Adhikar nahi.
SHUBH NEED AUDIANCE ❌ AUDIANCE NEED SHUBH ✅
Baki youtubers toh brainwash krne mai lge huye sirf ek aap hi jo sach ka sath de rhe ho apko bhut hate milega stay safe 👍
Sir how mature..and intelligent uh are 🙌🙌🙌 itna achha kaise samjha lete ho ap yaar 💥🤗
bilkul ,,bharat ka naksha kagach pe toh accha lagta hi hai lekin humare dil me uski khoobsurti ka koi jawab nhi ,,, jai hind ,end the controversy
I am Sikh and really liked your video you are a very sensible person
@djnathmixing3974
7 ай бұрын
😍💛💚
ha bhai chomu aaj ka video dekh shubh ka ? ab kya video delete karoge ki usko b bachayega chamche :D
Rohil upadhyay arshdeep ko khalistani kahane hindu naam waali IDs ki jaanch hui to vo sab pakistani nikli, Tu kyo vakeel bana hua hai har deshdrohi ka & kyo pichhe pada hai hindu dharam ke Apni maa ko chakle par baitha de paisa hi sab kuchh hai tere lie to Haryana me konsi bijli gayi thi & internet vand kiya tha sirf tera bas chale to tu amritpal or yasin malik ko bhi justify kar de
Pakistani aur indian muslim ak view aur like pane keliye admi kitna niche ja sakta hai😂😂😂😂
Munawar Pakistaní , Shub Khalistani ,!! 😂 koi dusre religion ka progress na kray bas ! Rangna Lanawat ko khud kam ne mil raha hai , usko acha grill kia tha Diljit ne !!
Bro thumbnail & title change krlo, aur clearly likhlo no shubh is not khalistani and why explained. Ni to ye aisa lgra h aap use expose krne wale ho as khalistani in video. Baki video is good.
नहीं भाई पंजाब मैं मुस्लमान भी हैं। मैं पंजाब ही से हूं 1.06 हैं
Bhai only tu ek hindu h jisne shubh ko khalistani nhi bola tnc bhai
Dusro ko deshdrohi bolne wale andhbhakt hi sabse bade deshdrohi hain
@NiyatiiiSharma
6 ай бұрын
Deshdrohi jaise dikho aur bolo phir bolte mujhe deshdrohi bol rahe hai
Sikh hamare bhai hai.....ek hi baat BJP hatao desh bachao bhaiyo...
Hindu rashtra Ki Baat band Hogi to Khalistan bhi band ho jaega
Finally someone understood what shubh mean in his story ❤️ Love you bro
Aap ki report ka jawab nahi. Ek dam mind blowing. Keep it up.
Very well said sir . Please send to haters like kangna, gaurav arya etc
Jo log Hindu rashtra banane chata hai bho bhi khalistani hai👍
@sarsingh3292
10 ай бұрын
khalistani word hindu rastra se match mat kro hum pure khalsa hai gursikh ho amrit sakka ho woh wahi khalsa kehlata hai khalsa mero roop hind rastra ki mang krni hinduwadi bolo
I'm from Pakistan. love and respect 🇵🇰🇮🇳
@apnagamingaddaff
10 ай бұрын
I am from India ( Father of Pakistan ) and I support freedom of Balochistan. Jai hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@pritammehta7770
10 ай бұрын
First Support your Family. Hutiye 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@safwanafshan9611
10 ай бұрын
I am from bahrain, 🇧🇭 i support india 🇮🇳 ❤
@pukhtoongamer4515
10 ай бұрын
@@apnagamingaddaffAcha...teek hai.... Samaj gaya 😂😂😂 India musalmano par zolam band kardo. India main inteha Pasand log rahte hai
@arclasses210
10 ай бұрын
I am from afghanistan I support Baluchistan
Bhai media ne hamara kitna brain washed kar diya Aaj Maine ek sardar ji to tempoo chalate dekha or Maine unhe khalistani samjha pr kuchh der baad galti ka ahsaas hua or man me Allah se maafi mangi Unite India Great india❤
@pritammehta7770
10 ай бұрын
Bhai half media half Tera dimag pehle kharab tha shayad. Warna tempo Wale ko kon khalistani samjhega 😂😂😂
@arclasses210
10 ай бұрын
@@pritammehta7770भारत के सीखो का योगदान इसने शायद नहीं देखा मेरा गांव बॉर्डर पर है हर एक महीने में था बटालियन चेंज होती है और हर बटालियन में 5-6 से जवान पगड़ी बांधे रहते है सोचो खालिस्तानी सुनकर उन्हें केसा लगता होगा की हम किस देश की रक्षा कर रहे है
Aap sahi bol rhe ho ! Shubh khalistani nahi hai , mujhe bhi unke story PE Shak hua lekin Aisa kuch nahi tha woh ek khalistani nahi h , I'll always support shubh ❤❤
Bhai sahab aap 9:39 ke aas pass jo video me picture hai India ka jisse aap khalistan ko assume kr rhe hai wo to samjh aa raha hai mgr north east wale region me India Ka map to blue me dikhaya hai jisme asam hai mgr or north east wale region (A.p , manipur , nagaland ) ko blue me nhi dikhaya hai . esska video ke content ke assumption se koi lena dena nhi hai fir bhi usse blue se alag kyo diya hai . 1. video creater ki mistake hai 2. Aap north east wale issue ko bhi assume kr ke hi aisa piture dala hai ki agar unka bhi aisa bne to aisa India hoga 3. Any thing else ??
Low and order kharaab hai Ya galat hathon me hai? Aapki har video achi hai Rohit Bhai ❤
✨ Please 🥺 Collab with @HimanshuKALecture Bro 🙏 They also fight against hatred bro 🇮🇳 🙏
sir usne ye story kuch min. m delete kar di thi jab use laga map galat h par ye chij koi ni batayega
Bhai aap bahut ache insaan hai jo sirf reality batate hai aur nafrat se door rehte keep it up bro bhagwan aapko bal de aise hi ache content par video banate rhe, lots of love ❤❤❤
Hindu rashtra, Khalistan ❌ India, Bharat✅
Always support shubh
Ap ne bht hi acchi trh smjha dia H ,, 😊
Where is North East India. I belong to Assam & proud to be Indian...U forgot to mention About NE India sir...
@Prateekkataria
10 ай бұрын
north east is in my heart same as north south and west💌💌💌
Very well done brother nice video more power to you 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Bhai Hindu Rashtra ki demand krne walo k upr b koi content bnao
Apka pov bahut Accha lga. Khalistani bhi hindustani ho jayega apka analysis dekh kr❤.
I think shubh was right at this bcs he just do it punjab black bcs there was no electricity for some time people just started trolling anyone without knowing the real reason behind it thanku so much sir for clearing it thanku so much❤❤
Much needed video bhai sach btau bhut khushi hui apki video dekh kar pheli bar kisi ne sach bola ek video Sidhu moose wala pr bhi bnao pls ❤️😊
Lots of love brother...... ❤
Well said
Another great video
Mr Rohit Khan pls share the fact sheet which you are refereeing to ??????
Mai Bihar se hun mai aaj tak kavi kisi sikh ko nahi dekhi hun face to face.mai unse milna chahti hu baatein krna aur unke culture ko v janna chahti hn maine sirf movies m dekha h
Na Hindu Rashtra na Khalistan na Islamic Rashtra bas akhand or secular Bharat chahiye.
Subscribed bro❤❤
Nice explanation brother...iam from Hyderabad ❤
Bbai ap bade ache se apni bat rakh rahe ho ap jald hi bahut bade youtuber banne wale ho
Dil jeet liye bhai aap❤
I still don't get the point if inkquisitve doesn't wanted to support khalistan than why he marked haryana and some parts of Himachal too when there were internet shutdown only in punjab
@ParamjeetKaur-ql9re
6 ай бұрын
It's old Indian map
Good information brother ⛳
Sir kuch log jaan bhujh ke nhi samjhna chate kyuki na samjhne me he unhe faida h Per iska result bahut bura hogga koi baat nhi ...
Is muda ki sabsa sahi information h ye video....
AAP jaise logo ki respect krni chahiye
Hindu and Sikh are always together.... Shame on you Mr Rohit Khan
Desh ke itme tukde kar do ki confuse hi jae 😂 desh kon ha or jola kon ha 😂😂
Bhai jaha tak nakshe ki baat hai to jitne bhi downloa maine kiye hai abhi tak un sab me sirf aur sirf aadha Kashmir hi Hindustan ka hissa bataya jaata hai isme hum normal aam logo ki kay galti q ki zayadatar map graphics international companies hi banati hai.
Mai jyadatar apki baato se sahmat rahta hu kyuki mujhe pata hai desh me ek giroh hai jo desh ko dharm ke naam pr baat Raha hai, Lekin shubh Wale mamle me Mai apse asahamat hoon kyuki jo map shubh ne post ki thi usme se northeast pura gayab tha or J&K ko fade kar Diya gya tha jo ek aam bharatiy hone ke naate bura laga Agr virodh darj karna tha shubh ko to kai aur tarike the lekin unhone distorted map hi use kyu Kiya? Mai nahi janta ki shubh ki ideology khalistani hai ya hindustani isliye us pr isko lekar koi akshep nahi laga Raha Lekin aap kah rahe hai ki isme uski galti nhi hai to yaha aapse asahmat hoon Mai Ummid karta hoon ki aap mere is asahmati ka uttar jarur denge.😊
Bhai app akele ek KZreadr ho jisne sach bolne ki himmat ki hai baki sab nafrat faila rahe hai hame apas main pyar prem se rehna hai koi hame ladwaye to usko jawab dena hai ye hamara bhi desh hai❤
@vinodviny125
10 ай бұрын
Bilkul Bhai mai bhi sach bol raha hoo waheguru ji da Khalsa waheguru ji di fathe respect for Sikhs but khalistanis are terrorists they are not Sikhs jai hind jai bharat waheguru ji di Fateh
we support Shubh!!! defamation case should be filed against some people...
BHAI BACKGROUND TONE SE IRRITATING HOTA HAI.. PLS NEXT VIDEO MAI KHAYAAL RAKHNA.... BAKI AAPKI VIDEO HAMESHA KI TARAH ACHHI HAI....
I liked this video made it 1k likes from 999. As always this not sufficient for the content the likes must be 1cror and continue
Sir app baate naa bnae apki responsibility hai aap ik dum sahi map use kre glti ko chupane ki koshish nahi...or Rahi shubh ki...to aap bss manipulate ker rhe j and k or NE hi kyu gayab haii...kyu blur hai acc toh your video or aap jaante ho dispute bhi inhi per hai....phir kyu baatein bna rhe ho
Donon hi unconstitutional hai khalistan & Hindu rashtra
Love from heart 💖❤️
Bhai ye sab to thik hh... Uss ap Dhillon kiya jis ne India ke flag ko apne shoes pe dekhya tha...???
Bro your maturity made you perfect indian❤
Shubh ki image and tu jo dikha raha hai vo dono image me difference nahi dikhta akkal ke nadhe aapiye :D
Thanks Rohit for this video❤❤❤ Pehle mere ko lgga, ek aur so called bhakat hoga, jo khalistani ke naam pe views bna raha hoga, par after watching your video apko subscribe kr liya. Thanks again..
Ek punjabi singer ne ek line boli thi jisme desh ki rajdhani ko bola ja rha hai line hai keh keh badla lainda menu punjab .......kehndya ohh delhi vi nap lainda menu punjab kehndya ....
@AnkushThakur-to6ds
10 ай бұрын
Kya apko uss song ke lyrics smj mai aye?? Ya fir apne kisi ki video dekhi or usne esa kuch bola or apne sach Maan liya?? Vo uss song mai jassa Singh alhuwalia or baghel Singh ki baat kr rha tha ki kese unhone 17 baar mughalo se delhi jiti thi par kuch ghatiya logo ne uske gane ka glt mtlb nikal kr usko badnaam kr diya kyo ki Punjabi lyrics smjna har kisi ke bas ki baat nhi hoti isliye log ykin bhi jldi kr lete hai Don't hate if you can't understand lyrics ❌ check English subtitles of that song first 👍
Perfect explained
Itne ache se bat samjhai apne iske liye thankyou
Bharat ki azaadi mein sabse zyaada khoon Sikh aur Musalmano ka baha hai aur aaj jo angrezon se maafi maangte the woh inn dono qaum ko gaddaar saabit karne par lage huwe hain
@cr-pz5ou
10 ай бұрын
😂 muslims ka contribution sirf Pakistan mai hai😂😂😂
@MRBasu-rg9nw
9 ай бұрын
Ha sirf Pakistan banene me tha 😂
TELL THIS GUY that subha has proved khalistani,but leftist will try to clean his image😂
Unhone Jo khaa vo man le unhone sach bolne wali koi jadibuti khai he galti se Jammu kashmir or north east ke state hi chhip gya kyuki dono jagah problem chal rahi thi idhar chin udhar Pak se dusre state ke sath esa kyu ni hua unka nuksan unhe pta chal gya isliye bol rahe he Bharat ke hm bhi hr sacche deshbhakt hote to panjab me ashanti na fele log bhadke na isliye bijli Kati uska saport krte last me usne likha Panjabi ko khalistani na bole yaha Panjabi se desh me kisi ko koi problem nhi he na hi sikhho se jese ek soch ban gai he hindu muslmano se nafrat krte he esa nhi he nafrat atankwad se na ki musalmano se jo khalistan ka samarthan krta he usse to problem hogi subh ke vo story dalte time uske man me kya chal rha tha vo uski ek safai se man lena or use sahi man lena me to sahi nhi smjta
Bhai apko ❤❤❤ se salute
Great job 👍
you talk good man
Thanks..chlo bhai kise ne to shi batt ki..
I always liked u r post,,,
Punjab mein to chalo bijali nhi aa rhi h lekin north East aur kashmir ko fade krne se kya matlab ho skta ho sath mein aur kuchh bhi kahena chah rhe ho ki jammu kashmir aur north east ko bharat sarkar bahut andekhi kr rhi h bharat sarkar ko jaise lagta h north East mere desh ka hissa na ho
Well said 1000%
pls do not spread hate between us... shame on you
100% sahi baat
I agree with some of his points but still there are some gaps in his explanation let me say this. I don't need hindu rashtra but after looking at 56 islami countries and 158 Christian country I want Bharat to be Called Complete Hindu Rashtra. And please don't teach Secularism to the Hindu's we have already paid the big prize.
@yusufzaid5861
9 ай бұрын
abe tera hindu rashtra canada me bana le ya kahin aur. Bharat me nahi. Kyunki is mitti me sab ka khoon hai shamil. Aisa nahi hai ki sirf hindu log ne is desh ke liye lada hai.
@SageExpert
9 ай бұрын
@@yusufzaid5861 ya Hindu ka Ancestors land hai jaise Saudi Arabia Muslim O ka usi tarha Bharat Hindu ka ora bat rahi ladne ki toh Bharat ke do tukde nhi hote Religion ke bases par Aaj Pakistan main Hindu ke sath ky hora hai pata hain na. Isa mitti main srif Hindu ka khoon hai aur kisi ka nhi history padle kaise islam Hindustan main aaya aur Muslaman ne ky ky kiya Hindo ke sath😶
Love from North East Assam
@premsagar-ul9hi
10 ай бұрын
North East ko nhi dikhaya isliye khus hai😂
Sikh humare desh ki sabse honorable kom h unka humesa samman h ❤❤❤❤❤❤tulsi bole ram nanak dev ji bole ram ram❤❤❤❤
Great analysis ❤
Ek no bro
😂😂😂 yeh ek aisa desh hai jaha pfi muslim gajwa a hind,sikhs khalistan,bjp supporters hindu rashtra, navbaudh ambedkarite banta hai sab kuch dusra hi samjhta hai lagta hai kisi ko india india pasand nhi hai
thanks to you brother, atleast you tried to explain dumb people what the actual situation is
True bro ji
Salute Bhai
Love you bhai ❤❤❤❤❤
Salute sir
Good bhai ❤❤