The fact that they're giving us an absolute phenomenal live performance of Sherlock which has one of the most vocally complex layers without their two main vocalss is so commendable. Only SHINee can do that.

@ParaSim_Kpop_Animations

11 ай бұрын

True

@naggymama2021

11 ай бұрын

Both JongHyun and Onew have said very clearly SHINee is a all vocal group, I trust their words.

@riahlexington

11 ай бұрын

@@naggymama2021yes!!

@dlstmxkakwldrl5668

11 ай бұрын

@@naggymama2021 Doesn't matter that they're an all vocal group. They're covering live for kpops two best vocalists as well as singing their own lines for songs that specifically have no space to even breath in. That is a big feat and 2minkey should be praised endlessly for that.

@Csb1289

11 ай бұрын

exactly. All of shinee are incredibly talented, I love it.

Two members missing yet still achieved a masterpiece. Nobody but SHINee.

@user-iv2pb8tg7g

11 ай бұрын

안무없이 부르는 셜록 와~~노래 넘 잘불러 놀라고 다잘부르지만 태민이 와 넘잘불러 놀랬다 3인샤이니 너무멋지다❤

@pedromendesrbd

11 ай бұрын

where is onew?

@feat_ciel

11 ай бұрын

@@pedromendesrbdhe’s taking care of his health rn!

@riahlexington

11 ай бұрын

@@user-iv2pb8tg7gTaemin is a good singer he has been for a long time

@katieedsallreamy4756

11 ай бұрын

This is what it's like when everyone has great vocals 😊

OMG Taemin held all the main vocal part of the whole song by himself!!!!!! That's really amzing that the main dancer can also be the main vocal :D

I love that you can still hear Jjong in the backtrack as they sing so passionately with him. They're all very strong vocally and I'm so proud of them.

I'm getting goosebumps RN. I never imagined a SHINee without the vocal powerhouse Onew and Jjong. And then, here they are proving supremacy. I'm really impressed with each member every time they make a comeback. How can I quit KPOP when I stan this group? like how?

@mustikatieka2162

11 ай бұрын

Yesssss they amazing

@daiishi_kinyoubi

11 ай бұрын

same honestly

@rr.magazine

11 ай бұрын

Let us give it up, my dear...and surrender to these god-tier legends. They define K-Pop artistry, and deliver superior quality performances. Let us surrender to the undeniable idol supremacy of SHINee! We are stanning the right and perfect idol group! !!! ALL HAIL SHINEE!!!

@kitizen394

10 ай бұрын

I was told once I tasted SHINee I can't exit. Sigh it's true. Don't quit K-pop, free SHINee into the mainstream world so we can love them for another 20 years!

Taemin did such a great job covering many of Jonghyun and Onew’s parts. And MinKey’s rapping, singing, and harmonizing really make the song. Of course, it would be great to have all of them performing together, but I’m so glad they gave us this wonderful performance. ❤️

@miamiric6051

11 ай бұрын

I look to forward to Onew performing with them when he recovers.

@louiselemmon5029

11 ай бұрын

Key covered onew too

@miamiric6051

11 ай бұрын

@@louiselemmon5029 Yes, I know! That’s why I said “many of.” Key did a wonderful job too! I just wanted to highlight Taemin’s vocal performance because I really enjoyed it.

Where you can find idol group can sing their song powerfully with just main and lead rapper and main dancer without their main and lead vocal, only SHINee

The immense talent of Taemin, Key, and Mihno as singers allowing them to cover effortlessly the parts of Onew and Jonghyun in such iconic track without compromising the quality of the song is worth of standing ovation 👏👏👏

I can't be more proud of our boy. They did amazing singing Onew and Jonghyun's parts. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

THIS! This is what a WORLD CLASS ACT looks like! Man, SHINee just gets stronger every comeback, mind blowing! May all your artistic dreams come true SHINee!!

@noemibernal4882

11 ай бұрын

Can't agree more!

@loverain1257

11 ай бұрын

💯

@lollypop3718

11 ай бұрын

I agree!!!💯

@kitizen394

10 ай бұрын

Guys gals cats dogs etc let's free SHINee into then less ageist mainstream world so they can make awesome shows for us for 20 more years!

@UniteSHINeeWorld

10 ай бұрын

Yes to all of the above!

팀에 대한 애착으로 메보 두명의 부재를 노력으로 채워내는 멤버들이 정말 대단하다 샤이니는 정말 아이돌의 모범인 듯

@user-cy4ib3vz1n

11 ай бұрын

말씀 너무 예쁘게 하세요🥺 감동받고 갑니다,,,

Love that we can still hear Jonghyun's adlibs and high notes behind their voices ❤❤

메인, 리드보컬 없이 이렇게 완벽하게 해내는 그룹은 진짜 없는데 샤이니는 진짜 대단한듯..

@jmin3259

11 ай бұрын

한명한명이 다 메인 리드 역할을 다 해주는게 너무 멋있고 샤월에서 못벗어나는 이유에요 ㅜㅜ 무대 보고 멋있어서 소름 돋음

@user-tm2ug4qu7c

11 ай бұрын

네

@ewapaszkowska551

11 ай бұрын

Super ❤Super ❤Super 💞💞💞💞💔🇵🇱🤗🫰

@svetlana0905

11 ай бұрын

💎💎💎💎💎💎💎👑👑👑👑👑

@ThansG

10 ай бұрын

They surely made their hyungs proud.

Do u have any idea how *HARD* (no, this is not a joke) is to sing JJ and Onew's lines? No, I dont think you know. They are literally two of THE best vocalist of this industry it's been 15 years and yet, they managed to sang their lines. I could not be more proud and happy for them. Especially Minho, cgs honey

Got goosebumps all over my body. They absolutely nailed it despite 2 members missing. No wonder they are still so talented after 15 years!

Key hitting all the high notes and then rapping effortlessly is just SO SATISFYING to watch! My ult Kpop bias! True almighty Key!

This is one of the hardest songs in Kpop history and our boys did it perfectly with just 3 members. I’m so proud

SHINEE literally showed the whole world and Kpop community who are the true kings, Only 3 right now, still powerful to perform WOW I can still hear Hyungs voice

This brought tears to my eyes, I was a huge fan of the original song and now there’s three members singing it, but they do it amazingly. This is what shinee represents, resilience and talent.

shinee's vocal line is so strong, it's basically all the members

Only SHINee can do this. This song is so vocally complex yet Taemin, Minho and Key cover so well for everyone. I am so proud of SHINee and so proud to be a Shawol!

SHINee proved yet again they can SHINe in any situations, any recombination, any musical style, any location, any era, any any any.... AAAAAHHHH keep making music SHINee!!!

They were so insane for this,, crazy good vocals~ OT5 forever 🫶

댄스담당이었던 태민이가 메인보컬인 종현이 자리를 대신해 노래부르는 거 보니까 왜 눈물이 날것같죠 이게 아이돌은 꿈과 희망을 주는 존재라고 불리는 이유인가 봐요

Taemin does such a good job covering Jonghyun's vocal parts.

👏👏👏 And, ladies and gentlemen, there you have it. This is why Shinee are the legends that they are. What a performance!!! 🔥🤩Sending my best wishes to Onew, btw, and always remembering Jonghyun too

샤이니팬은 아닌데 개인적으로 볼때 라이브쩌는 아이돌중 하나라고 생각함. 난 얘네가 거의탑이라고 봄. 춤을 추면서도 라이브를 저렇게 잘할수있구나 했는데 노래만부르는거면 들어보나마나임. 진짜 놀랍다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

스탠딩 마이크 앞에서 서서 노래 부르는데 각자 원래 파트 나오면 춤출 때 동작 조금씩 나오는 게 아련함ㅋㅋㅋ 그... 그냥 시원하게 춤춰 줘!!

Why do i feel emotional watching this even if the song is sherlock? 🥹 good job boys!! Covering parts of other members is not easy, this is the reason why I'm always proud of you ❤❤

@0k0a0r0y0

11 ай бұрын

I know! I've never cried to Sherlock before! I'm so proud of them, my heart feels so full right now.

@user-bb2iy4gk3w

11 ай бұрын

Me too! I'm crying...

@xpolarisx

11 ай бұрын

I always get overwhelmed over the outro for some reason but this version hits unlike any other

@viko_piko

11 ай бұрын

this song is always a little sad, but Onew is taking care of his health as well now, so only three of five are singing it... that made me shed a tear

@jalankaki5138

11 ай бұрын

Not to mention the one who they covered are The Main Vocals. Respect.

3명에서도 이렇게 빈틈없이 완벽하게 꽉꽉 채울 수 있다니,, 멤버들끼리 교감하며 기깔나게 소화하는 셜록 라이브 듣는 나도 감회가 새롭고 형용할 수 없는 감정에 눈물났어. 세상에 이런 완벽한 아이돌, 다시 태어나도 울 샤이니밖에 없을거야 오래도록 이대로 오십주년 달려가자 너무 고맙고 사랑해🩵💎🩵💎🩵

Gilaa!!! Mau berlima, berempat, bertiga mereka tetep bisa se luar biasa ini, betapa mereka bekerja keras untuk membuat SHINee tetap bersinar.. dan ini sangat luar biasa! Udahlahh! Gabisa berkata2 lagi. Cuma bisa teriak I LOVE YOU SHINEE!!!

십몇년이지나도 샤이니는 목이터져라 라이브 해주는구나

SHINee and their vocals are just unbelievable!! They sound more and more mature as the time goes on 🤌🏻💙 💎✨️

@dbzz2288

11 ай бұрын

Agree with you! More mature!!❤❤❤❤

이제 샤이니 한테는 누가 메인보컬이고 서브보컬이고 랩퍼이고 이런 구분이 실례 같음... 특히 이번 8집에서 확실히 느꼈다.. 이런 그룹 2번 다시 없음.. 늦덕이지만 지금이라도 열심히 응원할 수 있어서 행복해 ♡우리 오래오래 가쟈

너무 잘해서 가슴이 너무 벅찬데 왜 눈물이 나지... 메인보컬 두명이 없이, 화려한 퍼포먼스도 없이 단 세명만으로도 이렇게나 무대가 꽉 찰 수 있구나.. 셜록 나왔을 때가 중1이었는데..그때는 나의 온 세상이 샤이니였던 시절이 있었는데.. 언제 시간이 이렇게나 흘러 삼십대 샤이니를 바라보고 있고 단 세명만으로도 이렇게나 완벽한 무대를 보고 있다는게 벅차면서도 마음 한 편이 너무 시리다.. 우리 리더 얼른 건강하게 낫자.. 샤이니 이제 행복하고 또 행복하기만 하자. 나의 전부였던 샤이니. 어딜 내놓아도 자랑스런 샤이니.

의도한건진 모르겠는데 태민 종현 창법이랑 비슷한데 종현 파트 태민이 부를때 백그라운드로 종현 보컬 소리 백그라운드로 희미하게 겹쳐 들리는 느낌인데..미친거같음 진짜..

이게 각 솔로앨범 낸 가수의 위엄이다 진짜 각자 다 노래 개잘해 밴드와의 호홉도 환상적이고 멋있어

셜록 분면 신나는 노랜데.. 메인 리드보컬 둘 없이 다섯이 했던 노래를 하는걸 보니 왠지 모르게 눈물이 났어요. 성장한 능력치로 서로의 자리를 채우며 온 힘 다해 노래하는게 뭉클했나봐요 ㅎㅎ 샤이니 건강하게 오래가자!✨️

minho covering jonghyun's part makes me so proud of him, he is main vocalist material

There are K-pop groups and then there is SHINee! They are the only group that I get goosebumps in live performances.. Thank u SHINee for making our World more light and SHINeeeeeeee 💎💎💎💎💎 always 5 but a Big props for their hard work as 3! Now Onew is back, I hope we can see them together soon.😊

I can tell how much they are into their music, they are real performers.

Passion in every single note - Shinee, ladies and gentlemen 🔥🔥🔥

샤월은 아니지만 그때 그 시절이 떠올라 너무 뭉클하고, 지금 들어도 여전히 너무 세련됐고 너무 명곡이고 청량 아련 그 자체다... 메보 리드보컬 없이도 완벽한 멤버들 실력에 더 짜릿하다... 샤이니는 영원하다 진짜

I compared the original video and this one, the true that I am speechless, what quality of artists more that quantity.

Fan-freakin-tastic! 5hinee with a live band is always on point - no one can beat them. Bravo Key, Minho, Taemin! 100% Professionals who love what they do. And the world, who loves what they do too! What an awesome performance!

THIS MASTERPIECE WITH A BAND AND WITHOUT THEIR MAIN VOCALISTS - STILL, IT STANDS UNDEFEATED. I can see how Taemin, Minho and Key are doing their best for Onew and Jonghyun!! WE LOVE YOU GUYS, 5HINEE FOREVER 💎💎💎💎💎

this version is fire! from time to time I can hear Jonghyun and Onew's btracks, and the blend they have with 2minkey is amazing. SHINee is five! 💎💎💎💎💎

콘서트때도 느꼈지만 멤버의 공백이 느껴지지 않게 꽉찬 무대를 만들기 위해 셋이서 얼마나 노력했을까 싶어서 눈물날 지경임 샤이니는 진정 모두가 메보다 너무 자랑스러워 사랑해 샤이니 ❤

SHINee singing SHERLOCK with a band is always top tier!! Thank-you Taemin, Minho and Key for your amazing performance! It was fun watching your road trip as well! Love you all ~ Onew, Jonghyun, Key, Minho and Taemin!

Without their two main vocalists and doing THAT. SHINee is true K-Pop royalty.

The best !

I can't help but imagine if Jjong was still with us, how awesome would he be in this vid.

진짜 샤이니는 우리가 뭘 원하는지 말 안해도 아는 느낌이라 너무 행복해서 벅찬 그런 느낌이야 고맙고 사랑합니다,, 셜록을 서로 바라보면서 부르고 민호 노래부르는것도 너무 좋고 그냥 최고 ㅜㅜㅜ 우리의 영원한 샤이니즈백..❤️

It's such an amazing feeling to be able to see SHINee evolve over the years. Taemin's vocal growth since their debut is insane. I've never seen anything like it. Like he's out here singing his hyung 🕊 part with ease! Minho sang beautifully ❤ he went from being awkward to this extremely handsome man, It's unreal. And Key is truly an ACE ♠️ visually, singing, rapping, and dancing. I truly love these men and will forever support them 💎 Onew we'll be waiting for you. Get well!

Managing to slay this song without Jonghyun's vocals proves shinee's talent as a whole!!! This is insanely good

2:48 본인파트에 이어서 종현파트까지 이어서 부르는 태민이 왜 눈물나지 ㅠㅠ 셋이서도 꽉 찬 무대 너무 감격스럽다 역시 샤이니가 샤이니했네

@lululu2482

9 ай бұрын

종현이가 보고 너무 대견해하겠다 태민아 너무너무 잘하고있어.

I can't help but watch this performance over and over again. Top notch!!! When I watched this on JTBC 15m, goosebumps were all over me. Key at 2:29 followed up by Minho at 2:44, and Taemin at 2:59 is INSANE. Everything was so perfect.🙌

Shinee is consist of 5 main vocal

It's so impressive that the 3 of them could step up and take on all 5 parts. It makes me tear up, so bitter but so sweet. ❤ And let's give a hand to the instrumentation too!

I cried so hard! This was an insane performance!! I always miss JOnghyun's voice but SHINee pull thru every time!!!! I LOV YOU SHINEE!

@AG-hx6qn

11 ай бұрын

Good not just me. I can't see well right now. Lmao

Love the idea of a live band. It gives special sparkle to Sherlock. Also camera work is really good. Congratulations on your comeback. ❤

SHINee is really amazing.. They can do this song without 2 main vocal❤

SHINee never dissapoints, I've been a shawol for 11 years now and to be honest they still manage to surprise me and overwhelm with every new thing they put out there. It's been a long time already and they still bring tears to my eyes. Love you forever my talented boys

They're doing great on behalf of all 5. I am so proud of maknae line ❤

❤️‍🔥🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻❤️‍🔥 You guys definitely came through with a great performance! SHINee can’t stop, won’t stop, and will live forever and ever as the best kpop band in the 🌎 !

오직 세명이서 셜록을 이렇게나 꽉 채워주다니... 대단하고 감동이다..!!

최민호 노래 실력 진짜 늘었다 미친.. 노력의 아이콘이네 샤이니 모두

@vespa2223

10 ай бұрын

I thought he was always good, and I liked the quality of his deeper voice, but wished they would let him sing more. Too bad it took necessity to give him greater opportunity. They are an amazing group in all iterations.❤

@edithlunatemix2313

10 ай бұрын

No dejan de sorprenderme❤ siempre me dándolo mejor de eyos uaqrl qregrese onew yahse falta🎉

I love hearing jjongs voice under taemin’s wow. Just wow that the three of them killed it without their two main vocals. Thats how world class SHINee is

@isabelove95

11 ай бұрын

I think they put jjongs voice as a base for taemin. He always be there for them❤

샤이니 최애곡 셜록을 밴드버전으로 불러줬더니 넘 감사합니다❤❤❤❤❤️💎💎💎💎💎

@ceciliaplachot7791

11 ай бұрын

💎💎💎💎💎❤❤❤❤❤ FOREVER 5HINee

@miraelee2899

Ай бұрын

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💎💎💎💎💎

This is so amazing!! For a very complex song they just nailed it! This is how 15 years singing like pros looks like!

My love ❤

shinee is insane. being able to pull off such an amazing performance like this while missing two members is incredible. no one is doing it like them

컴백쇼 진짜 너무 좋았음ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 멤버들 소소한 얘기부터 일상적인 모습들, 새로운 무대들까지!!

다섯명이서 쉴새없이 몰아치던 곡을 셋이서 모자람 없이 채워나가는걸 보니 멋지고 대견하고 뿌듯하고 아련하고 눈물을 참을 수가 없네.. 다섯남자 여전히 사랑해 어디서 뭘하든 행복하자

SHINEE ROCKSTARS🤘🏼💘🫶🏼🎶💎😍❤️‍🔥

I am so amazed at how they covered Joghyun's and Onew's parts though we definitely missed their unique vocal colors. It's amazing how SHINee has 5 great vocalists!

Vocal 100% Visual 100% Performance 100% 5HINee forever 💎💎💎💎💎

If you were there when this came out, if you loved that song and SHINee when it came out, I'm 100% sure you are feeling the same way I do: overwhelming nostalgia, joy and sorrow all at once. Fuck. That hits sooo hard..

I've got chills, this is incredible!!! Even down to three they are unreal

I was so touched by this performance. This was absolutely amazing hearing Jonghyun live on through the music and Onew's parts being executed beautifully. Mind you, their voices are unique and irreplaceable. Music is a time machine; I know they traveled back like I did. They are SHINee, and they are back. Congratulations, guys, on 15 years. Buy the album!

샤이니 컴백할 땐 늘 이 노래부터 듣는데 아 밴드버젼 무슨 일인가요 미친 넘 좋다🙈🙈🙈 음색 가창력 리듬감 다 미쳤어!!

Simply amazing. SHINee is such a talented group, they can do anything

어려운 고비가 올때마다 이겨내고 해내는 샤이니 보면서 정말 많이 배우고 더욱 더 좋아할 수 밖에 없다

Wow... Simply wow! This is why SHINee is the best of the best. I'm so proud of being a Shawol. It's like, you can't go wrong hahahaha I love you so much, my beloved princes. I hope Jinki is recuperating well ♥

@lenykurniaty7071

11 ай бұрын

🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗💎💎💎💎💎

Seriously SHINee is so unique and their Level is so far advance. I get goosebumps when I see their performances, vocals and visuals. They take us to a total different World. SHINee are Legends!

@KAK_PAN

11 ай бұрын

Its SHINee not SHINEE, you should edit dude.

@cherry1311

10 ай бұрын

I give you the thumbs up number 100

@Shineefansince2009

10 ай бұрын

@@cherry1311 thank you 🙏

@kitizen394

10 ай бұрын

Yes! Let's take SHINee mainstream, so they can make goosebump legend art for us for another 20 years!

Even with 2 lead vocalist missing they still slammed it! Well done Taemin Key & Minho! Onew and Jonghyun will be very proud of you

Im so proud of them for covering all the parts !!! SHERLOCK is honestly legendary! LOVEEEE this version!!! Lets keep on shining

This was so good 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 I hope we can get more SHINeexBand again in the future ❤❤❤❤❤

베이스로 깔려있는 멤버들의 목소리에 다섯이 함께 노래하는 것 같아서 뭉클했어요. 앞으로도 계속 함께 노래할 수 있기를❤

Only shinee🎉❤

명불허전. 군계일학. 아는 한자성어 다 동원해도 표현 못 할 실력. 셋으로도 꽉채운 사운드. 온몸으로 부르는 노래. 샤이니 숨겨진(?) 팬으로 산지 몇년. 너무 즐겁다. 태민이 호호 할아버지 될 때까지 샤이니 해주세요.

Manifesting, SHINee will make other performance like this with another song. I really love this performance, wishing Onew speedy recovery too, so that he can join!!!

*WHO WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT OUR KINGS SHINEE FOREVER RAISE THEIR HANDS.* 🙌

@raraleeyara

11 ай бұрын

Me me 🙋🏻‍♀️

SHINee is flawless and timeless

I cry so bad just.... Look at them, not even a main a vocal but act and did as one!

밴드 라이브 HARD 할만도한데 갓벽하게 소화해버리는 샤이니💎 셜록이란곡이 샤이니에게와서 너무 감사해 ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

잘한다 잘해. 샤이니가 서로를 바라보며 부르는 셜록이라니. 최고야!

@alice85850

11 ай бұрын

ㅇㅈ이요

I am feeling so proud to be a shawol ♥️

SHINee are amazing, very cool

Fireworks!!! Being able to convey such an energy with a complex song like Sherlock with just three members... SHINee is the greatest group in kpop, because every single member is a soloist and when the are together they shine brighter than ever 💎💎💎💎💎