I was wondering if I should upload this video or not...I hope that time has hardened all of us who are sick, and I miss you.

@NK-yo8lx

Жыл бұрын

Thank you very much for uploading this video.

@erikamiglioranza1559

Жыл бұрын

Thank you for uploading ❤️

@Lolakid1412

Жыл бұрын

What's the radio name and what time i can hear it live?

@shinedays

Жыл бұрын

@@Lolakid1412 This broadcast ended. To be exact, MINHO was on the radio temporarily for a few days on her behalf because the radio's DJ was unable to host the show for a few days due to personal reasons. So he doesn't host the radio anymore.

@Lolakid1412

Жыл бұрын

@@shinedays thank you ✨.

i know it is hard for them, but i'm so grateful they still share jonghyun's music and moments with us

@alynnshortcakes

Жыл бұрын

Because like Onew said, SHINee will forever be 5. So, as long as this journey continues, Jonghyun will always be here with us❤

@shirlysaenz4707

9 ай бұрын

No dejo de a mirarlos que todavía estén juntos y recordando a su líder, porque muchas no lo olvidan ni lo olvidarán, son muchas canciones que produjo, donde todavía se siente que está en este mundo.

It's still depressing for us as fans but everytime I still feel more saddened for Minho, Taemin, Key and Onew because they lost their best friend, a band member, a brother.

@judycasley108

Жыл бұрын

Such insightful words. Tears are running down my cheeks, so I can only imagine Shinee’s feelings.

@estellafernandez2536

Жыл бұрын

i know

@mi0321

11 ай бұрын

I miss you…

Me watching this video trying so hard not to cry especially since it's Jonghyun's birthday and Minho who says he misses his voice looks like he's about to cry and making it harder for me not to cry. But I'm proud of myself for not crying since I'm at work and that would be bad. You did well Jonghyun, rest well. Happy Birthday our SHINee Blue Moon Angel

@imaginempress3408

Жыл бұрын

Yeah I cried right away.

@belonahaobam7039

Жыл бұрын

Same here i cried alot on his birthday

@elivile.

Жыл бұрын

I cried for you.

@JLynnEchelon

Жыл бұрын

100%. I still remember exactly where I was when we heard about it. It was actually on my birthday and every year since I think about how I've gotten so old and he just did not get the chance.

@imaginempress3408

Жыл бұрын

@@JLynnEchelon heartbreaking. His talent was miraculous. I hate that he was suffering.

The way Minho looked up at the end of the song was the end of me. Jonghyun is still missed and will always be loved. With the news now of Moonbin I hope they are both at peace.

@mckalahanes4203

Жыл бұрын

Right, I truly hope that - as long as it’s to an extent that their mental health can handle it - Shinee members reach out to Astro members to support them an offer understanding. It must be SO uniquely traumatic to lose a member, brother, best friend that you built your dreams with in a VERY public way to suicide. And it must be triggering to the Shinee members, reliving it when another seemingly joyful, talented young singer who seemed to have it all just like their friend but still did lot want to be here anymore. Not only are you shouldering your grief, but the fandom’s grief, and there are contracts to honor, a company to make money for, you’re reminded of it every time you produce a new song without him, etc…I’m sure they’ve reached out behind the scenes and stuff, and obviously this is very private and personal and the healing does not and should not be so nakedly public. But that’s just what I really really hope happens, that they can support each other and know none of them are alone

@Sidena

Жыл бұрын

Sammeee...It must still be so hard for them.

@beomgyujin

10 ай бұрын

@@mckalahanes4203moonbin didn't commit suicide

@wiseman3750

9 ай бұрын

@@beomgyujin I agree.

Minho's expression especially 4:20 onwards really made me wanting to hug him.. he used to be the one who consoles the other members sometimes I wonder who will console him when he's having that look on his face like that 😢

@ratrianindyajati3858

Жыл бұрын

And Jjong.. happy forever 27, every 0804 and 1812 I always pray for you to have your forever spring in heaven. Pls be happy as your winter days is gone forever now, Jonghyunah 😊😊

@gregorynuptials

Жыл бұрын

I remember my friend showed me a bit of the funeral footage and we didn't break until we saw him crying. Truly a sad thing to see someone like Minho break down like that 😢

@user-on5by4xp2b

Жыл бұрын

❤

This is a beautiful moment. Minho, you are an absolute treasure and we are honored to listen to this with you. We love you SHINee, we love you Jonghyun❤❤❤❤SHINee is 5

Ever since we lost Jonghyun, I barely listened to SHINee's new songs. After 2 years, I finally had the courage to watch his MV "Shinin" and I bursted into tears. This video made me realize again that I was unfair to my remaining 4 boys, who also I am sure are hurting more that I am. Maybe one day, listening to their songs won't hurt me that much.

@yobaes

9 ай бұрын

i did it too, it hurts so bad that we lost an angel like jjong. it was unfair but we did it simply bcs it was too damn hurt for us, hearing their songs without his voice..😭🥺

@yobaes

9 ай бұрын

but they did their best, and i'm glad at how they open up showing us their stories, sharing their feelings with us way more freely these days. thank you shinee, u saved me again and again❤

@YeosChicken

7 ай бұрын

I did the same to myself, only watching shinin this year. I know it was wrong but I was scared. I was your when I lost him and I didn’t know how to process losing someone you love. He was the first person to ever understand me.

It is wonderful to see that raw emotion shared with us from Minho. Jonghyun is still with us all to this day, and we keep him alive by sharing these an many other moments. 5Hinee is an always will be a family. He did well, and remembering keeps him with us always.

My daughter after 5 years still can't listen to his songs. She became a fan of Shinee in her teens; she's 30 now. JH was her favorite or what you guys call bias.

@Nina-uk6zg

Жыл бұрын

I got to know shinee when I was 17, I am 30 now and it took me almost 3-4 years to be able to hear Jonghyun oppa’s voice. I can totally relate to how your daughter must be feeling. I cannot even imagine how our Shinee members could be feeling. I will forever and ever be a Shawol, love and support them until my last breath. This is what I can do to protect them ❤❤

@jolynekujo486

10 ай бұрын

i took me time to be able to listen to SHINee songs again… since that day till two months ago i couldn't stand to listen or enjoy their music without feeling sad or blue… but now i just smile everytime i listen to his voice and feel the warmth i felt during my high school days when i met SHINee ^^'

@marzia723

10 ай бұрын

On the contrary, I can't listen Shinee without JH anymore

Oh the ending. When Minho looks up (like he does in every concert now) I just burst into tears. We'll all meet again one day x I hope Shawol Family is doing okay x

Heartwarming and heart wrenching simultaneously. These beautiful young men have suffered so much but remained stoic, loving, giving and supportive of one another through it all. Jonghyun, you did well. We all know it: we all knew it: we all wish you had known it, too. The way Minho's hand is shaking the paper he picks up at 4:06 tells you how much he loved you and loves you still. Watch over your members, Jonghun, and know that, at the "End of the Day", we all love you still.

@lamtiensi

11 ай бұрын

🥺🥺🥺

I'm glad that Minho is open about how he feels. I miss you, Jonghyun. I will be cutting a cake and releasing a balloon for you today. I even made you a little mini figure of yourself! :)

By moonbin's passing. It reminded me of jonghyun again😢.. It was hard😭

I hope if heaven is real Jong-Hyun is looking down and realizing just how many people loved him.

And then now it moonbin😭 I still can believe it 😔 how to move on from this😩😭

And yet another tragedy strikes us today, another bright star taken away from us. I prayed that no other group should face such a situation again, so my heart breaks all the more to know the pain Astro members, his Family and Friends will be going through right now. May you rest in peace! 😢❤

I love the fact that they never forget that he was the part of their team and that they are a family and I also love the fact that they always remember him like he is with us at the very moment……5hinee group of 5 always and forever❤

I think we sometimes seem to forget how this event has scarred them. Shinee fans feel the loss but I can't begin to imagine how it must feel for the boys. I often wonder if they ever took the time to really give all of this a place in their minds and hearts. I love how they still include him in so much of what Shinee does. It breaks my heart to see Minho about to cry but I apreciate the fact that he isn't afraid to show how much it still hurts, well all of them for that matter. When he picked up the paper and it was shaking, all I wanted to do is give that man a hug...

It's even hard to imagine what a range of emotions Minho felt, what a strong person he is... Perhaps he recalled the brightest moments since their first meeting. Or maybe he remembered how they could lose sight of such a little hyun ... In any case, they are all great fellows. Happy birthday shinee angel!

I realise once again how magical Jonghyun’s voice was…

WOW... his heavenly voice still gets to me. I have tears falling down cheeks. I so wish I had the chance to see him in concert just once. Minho, thank you for playing this song. Stay safe, healthy and strong.💙💙💙💙💙

@imaginempress3408

Жыл бұрын

Me too. Rolling rolling down.

보고싶다...

I discovered SHINee through the I Live Alone Episode of Key in 2022. Just watching and hearing Jonghyun, I can see what a sweet person he was as well as see the struggles he was dealing with. It's a tough battle but I hope anyone, including myself can push through any crushing situation we are going through. It's not always easy, it might be the hardest most trying time in your life, but, let's all stop the stigma of mental or emotional depression and helps those, or ourselves, so we never have to lose our loved ones again.

It´s rare to see Minho sharing his emotions, especially when it comes to Jonghyun Hyung. When he looked up at the end of the song, i broke.. we miss you, Jonghyun. ❤

I have a lump in my throat and on my heart. You did well, Jonghyun. We miss you and will meet you again someday.

It's been 5-6 years already, I'm just one of the million fans. I can't imagine how it's like to their members. and I still remember it like yesterday, And I'm also stuck in the past in my life and with him in mind as well

Jonghyun has a very good voice. When you listen to his singing, it becomes calm in the soul🌷

Not Moonbin also passing away...like it's so heartbreaking...like was crying so much when Jonghyun passed...and now with MoonBin too...like I feel like I'm getting depression from having to see my favourite people just leaving the world...I can't even imagine how family and friends must feel...if I am also in tears and feel sick in my gut right now...Rest in peace Jonghyun and Moonbin...I love you guys and always will❤

Sadly, I did not know of Jonghyun until he was already gone. But still, hearing his voice pulls at my heart. I can only imagine how it must be for those who actually knew him. I’m glad he lives on through his voice and in the memories of those who love him still.

He was hurting and decided to leave. He never knew those who he left behind would have the most difficult time accepting his death and moving on. I can't help but feel anger at SM who knew from reports he was in a mental health crisis blew it off. His brothers never forget him or his wit and sense of humor and compassion. Seeing Minoh like this makes me want to hug him. They achieved more because they knew it's what he would want.

5 years. They say time heals everything. I wish it were so. ... it hasn't happened yet.

How Minoho held it together I'll never know. I still cry hearing this and and other songs Jonghyun sings. Jonghyun YOU are terribly missed. 🌹🌹💖💖

Around 4:30 he really is trying so hard to keep the tears inside. I know I'm just his fan, but I wish I could hug him at that moment. @SHINE days, thank you for uploading this. Even though a sad scene, I get to attend these moments and feel even more close to our lovely guys, the fandom and Jonghyun. Thank you and thank you MInho, Onew, Key and Taemin for remembering Jonghyun!

It’s ok to grieve, it’s ok to miss this beautiful soul. He will never be forgotten and that is the mark of a life lived well🙏🏻🙏🏻💜💜💜💜💜🇦🇺

To this day, I cannot listen to any Shinee song with Jognhyun's voice. I cannot help but cry.

Minho was watching and Listening to his beloved friend Jonghyun song End of the day. Jonghyun had a beautiful singing voice and vocal presence and range

My babies!! This song is so beautiful and I'm somehow heartwarmed seeing Minho wanting to listen Jjong sing. That shows it's healing a little bit.

The way he looked up after the ending as if he’s telling Jonghyun that he miss him.😢

I miss him so much too

Thank you for sharing. Today is Jonghyuns birthday. We are celebrating the life he shared to us with his beautiful smile and beautiful voice. I love you Shinee 5❤❤❤❤❤ and Shawol family.

Such a beautiful song. We are so blessed to have known the artist that was Jonghyun.

I still remember that day, I was so depressed after his death, I was not a fan but his death felt somehow unreal and fan's were fighting bcs that time some of the fan's were saying things like majority only support youngest in the group and ignore oldest members of that group, that's why he took his life like that etc... After that I got into BTS and slowly forgot all those painful memories of Shinee. But past somehow repeating again, I don't know what to say about this now.

As showels how can we forget jonghyun s voice❤

Just because someone is gone doesn't mean their music or who they were as a person should be forgotten. We miss you, Jonghyun, and you shall forever be apart of SHINee no matter what happens.

They are so strong. It's been around 6 years but this song still makes me cry, both happy and sad tears. Jonghyun will always be missed as an artist and as a friend, but I'm so proud of what the other members have achieved since then. They did a good job. They've done well.

Thank you Minho for sharing yourself in this honest & simple way. You belong on the radio as much as you do on the SHINEE stage. Your radio presence will continue, it simply must.

If I hear his voice once, my mind fills with thousands memories ❤

The way he looked up at the sky at the end. 😢#you did well Jonghyun❤️

We all miss him ❤️

아스트로 얘들도 이렇게 잘 이겨내주고 또 늘 아름답게 잘 기억해주면 좋겠다…

@shinedays

Жыл бұрын

샤이니월드에요. 힘들고 많이 아프고 많이 그리울 테지만, 분명 그 시간들을 보내다보면 아픔과 그리움 사이에서 담담히 예뻤던 그리고 행복했던 그 사람과 기억을 꺼내어 들 수 있는 날이 올 거에요.

Members miss their brother Jonghyun so much. And now the same will be with Astro. We won't see them with Moonbin again

This hit just a lil bit harder with Moonbin passing on as-well now..

There’s not a day that goes by that I don’t think of Jonghyun and miss him. His influence over my life has been profound, and his death plunged me into a clinical depression that lasted more than a year. Truthfully, I’ve always battled depression to some extend or other, but for a while then, I could barely get out of bed most days. So yes, I cried listening to this, one of the most iconic and beautiful songs he’s ever written, and watching him perform, it like a gift from the deapths of his soul to the world, was both gut wrenching and healing. Surly by now, our Jong understands how precious his life has been and remains in the world. God, I hope so. I hope he experiences joy like a continuous fountain, for every moment he felt alone and misunderstood, double joy and heart healing. I thank Minho for reminding us in this brief tribute, how beautiful Jonghyun was, and showing how much you too miss his presence among us.

I'm watching this as I am trying to process Moonbin's passing. This had me on the verge of tears.

It was hard to say im healed. But im patting myself that im still live to this day. Allow me to miss u hurtfully today, oppa. Smile for us there eoh 😊

i love you johngyun... and forever will.. thank you for the gift of you. thank you shinee .... together you will always be 5 in my heart. I love you shinee...

I've only recently discovered K-Pop, so I don't know anything about SHINee, but I remember the name Jonghyun from articles about Moonbin's passing away. I just watched "Hwarang" and wanted to find out more about Minho, so I stumbled upon this video. Now I'm sitting here crying, without being a fan or even knowing Minho as a singer or Junghyun a few minutes ago. What an amazing voice and what an emotional video!

Where to find another talented singer like him again? With that unique vocal. Miss him so much.

何年経っても涙が出ます

My sad feelings won't end for him😢 I miss him

Minho did a great job. Always remembering Jonghyun. Happy birthday! 💖🎂💖

We never moved on. We just learned to move forward. I miss you everyday. We love you, Jonghyun. ❤💎

He loves him and vice versa. My dearest JongHo! I love you so much!

gosh this song is making me cry ... I miss jonghyun oppa's voice

Jonghyun was a genius singer and song writer~ I love him

This breaks my heart all over again. Seeing Minho fighting so hard not to cry is like a knife to the heart. And it shows how much was lost.

God please send him back I miss him 😢

Sincerely 💖 blessing, s blossom 🌸, s Sincerely 🙏 SHINEE FAMILY, 😊💖🌸🙏🙏🌸💖💖🥰😍🤗🙂💕💓💞😇😎🫣🫡😊🫠🙃😀🤗🥰🙂😍💕💞💕💕💓💓💞😇😇😎😎💖💖💖🌸🌸🙏🎤🎵🎼🎼🎼🎵🎤🎤👟🇰🇷🎶🎤🎤🎵🎼🕺💃🫢🎸🎶👼😇💕💕💓💞💞💖💖💖🌸🌸🌸🙏🙏🌸🌸💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖🌸🌸🌸🙏

The most powerful, vibrant, lovely voice. Full of emotion. It breaks my heart that he could not cope with the world. Jonghyun was a true artist. No wonder the rest of the guys felt like the bottom had dropped out, when he left them. 🩵🩵🩵🩵🩵

watching this after the tragic news about Moonbin...... yeah................ it hurts a lot. My heart goes out to all the families, friends and fans of those who have lost a loved one in this tragic way. May they rest in love and shine like the most beautiful stars in the whole sky.

Still feeling the same pain since that day when we lost you angel

We will never let go

You can really tell that Minho was holding back his tears, hearing Jong's voice after so long. There are no words to describe the pain that he's feeling. All those beautiful memories just flooding..he can use a hug right now.

When a friend ends their life, you constantly blame yourself and replay interactions with them. It's horrible.

What a sad loss of an extraordinary talent. At least they can see him again in his videos. He lives in their hearts and in the hearts of his fans. I hope that wherever he is he is at peace.

Truly missed ❤❤

I will always grieve for and celebrate one the greatest singer/composers/voices of S. Ko. His loss is immeasurable.

I am happy that we are cherishing Jonghyun. He lives thanks to the millions of hearts he's touched.

His voice is my safe place. I miss him so much.

crying hours are open...i miss jonghyun so much it's actually insane. i'll never forget in my life when i opened twitter and saw the article, it changed me as a person 100%. shin5e forever. what a rollercoster of emotions while watching this seriously, i can only imagine how much it hurts them.

I cried and I wanted to hug Minho and thank him for sharing such a special memory

He holds his tears

This 5 boys has stayed together more then their real life families. They grew up together. They workhard together They care for eachother They are like a real families to eachothers. They cant never be separated.

I feel so sad for dear Minho and other band members. I have lost my husband and my brother. It’s just 3 years since my husband died and the pain of losing him doesn’t go away. My brother it’s two years and it hurts knowing he’s gone. Both my husband and brother were buddies whose deaths have left a huge hole in my world. I can imagine listening to Jonghyun’s beautiful voice is mixed feelings for Minho. Thank you for sharing this video. It made me a little tearful, but thankful to hear the voice. ❤

He was a gift to this world. My heart breaks for all that can not see how precious they are and can not find a way out of their pain.

We love you and miss you always ❤

I know your heart still yearns his existence in every form, we wish the same thing.. Take care Love SHINee5 ..God Bless

It's okay to cry whenever you're having a hard time, Minho. no one will blame you Even I am still sad about John, so it must be harder for you.

He's trying not to cry but I think he did secretly. It's still so hard for them I know... just keep on going Shinee 💚

I knew I shouldnt have watched this 😢 I have work to do but now I cant see through all of my tears. I will always love and miss you my beautiful baby boy 😢 What makes it so much more sad is, like I'm sad, but how must the rest of the members feel? They were family. Im just a random fan who never even got the opportunity to see him in person, but they lived with him, sang with him, danced with him, laughed with him, cried with him, EVERYTHING... What they mustve felt and still feel is so heartbreaking. Thats what gets me the most. 😢

I,m not ashamed to say that I cried watching this. Minho clearly misses his friend so much . Fly high angel❤

Omg he was trying everything to keep his emotions under control since they were still on air. But you can see his hands shaking when he picked up the paper and he kept fidgeting 😭 My heat 💔💔

i miss you my love😭

He should be remembered. Watching these... it's part of healing and keeping his memories alive.

Can't understand a word he is singing but his voice is something else so emotional and powerful...i love it

He had such a beautiful and unique voice that only God could give him. I hope and pray he is watching over SHINEE from Heaven. I believe that our merciful and loving God forgives those whom take their lives. It is very difficult to overcome your mental demons and be successful. They are not cowards for taking their lives they are just so desperate and hopeless at that time and in a very dark place mentally that is hard to escape so many times triumphantly. I am so grateful Minho shared this song and his blessed voice with the rest of us. I know it is still hard for the group to listen to his voice. Missing you forever.

As soon as he lifted the paper you could see that he was shaking. That is absolutely heartbreaking.

I'm grateful for minho for sharing this moment with us. But my heart aches seeing him fighting back tears. I can't imagine how hard it is for them. They lost a brother

Watching the shadow of a best buddy singing is the saddest thing ever & very heavy hearted moments🥺I got to know him in 2019 In 2020 I watched JH's various videos of Radio DJ, he was such a great DJ and extraordinary poetry reader, excellent lyricist and mesmerizing vocal! loss of JH is big gap in K-POP and it changed SHINEE's music career as well !!JH irreplaceable talent, May his soul rest in peace!!