Hey folks! I'm looking to start my own podcast, and I could really use some help to get things rolling. UPI: istiyaqs@fifederal PayPal: @ishtiyaqpir

Damn, sheikh coming hard with those references,

@redwoodsam

10 ай бұрын

spot on! Shaykh's references on point and coming down hard. wow!

Al-Hasan bin 'Ali said: "I remember that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: 'Leave what makes you in doubt for what does not make you in doubt. The truth brings tranquility while falsehood sows doubt.'" Another chain reports a similar narration. Jami` at-Tirmidhi, 2518 In-Book Reference: Book 37, Hadith 104 English Reference: Vol. 4, Book 11, Hadith 2518

@RealHadith

10 ай бұрын

Doubt then go to Scholars

@nobodyisborngayislam

9 ай бұрын

I was confused if music is haram especially with difference of opinion amongst the scholars I made dha to Allah SWT and result I got was music is haram Alhamdulilah Anyways you guys can visit website called abu khadeeja and search for this article to find out why music is haram The Islamic Ruling on Music and Singing ―Ibn Bāz, Al-Albāni, Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn Al-Qayyim and the Four Madhhabs And Allah knows best

Vallahi, all of the people, yes everybody in this comment section needs to learn what adab is. May Allah ﷻ guide you all!

Enjoyed this content? Don't miss out on more like this! Follow/subscribe for regular updates and exciting posts!

In the Quran the word specially used is Entertainment. It could be argued that by sticking to music....then we are neglecting other entertainment that could take one away from the remembrance of Allah. For example, there are many many that will get so involved in gaming either online or off line, those that watch movies, those the play or watch sports....even those that almost aimlessly scroll through social media. All being entertained.....just killing time! To focus on music alone is to ignore other .. entertainment that occupies people far more than what music does or did! Allah used the word.... Entertainment....we should not reduce this to simply music. May Allah bless us with hikma, unity & acceptance. Ameeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeen

@nobodyisborngayislam

9 ай бұрын

I was confused if music is haram especially with difference of opinion amongst the scholars I made dha to Allah SWT and result I got was music is haram Alhamdulilah Anyways you guys can visit website called abu khadeeja and search for this article to find out why music is haram The Islamic Ruling on Music and Singing ―Ibn Bāz, Al-Albāni, Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn Al-Qayyim and the Four Madhhabs And Allah knows best

“There exists a difference of opinion among scholars about listening to songs with and without musical instruments. This is a matter about which one should not be difficult/harsh while denouncing the one who indulges in it. This was the reason which prompted me to compile this work (on music), because there are some deluded people who think - due to their lack of knowledge of evidences - that the ban on musical instruments has been affirmed with certainty and that the consensus of scholars supports the ban. And you now know that this understanding is undoubtedly falsehood and inevitable ignorance." - Imam As-Syawkani Fath al-Rabbani, 10/5205

@bwyaneh

Ай бұрын

It’s the Salafis’ fault. They make it out as if any Tom Dick or Harry can derive rulings from primary sources and bypass 1400 years of scholarly tradition.

Please make a detailed separate video on this. Us youth really need guidance on this matter.

يقول ابن القيم : لا يجتمع حب القرآن وحب الغناء في قلب المؤمن! فمن يجتمعان في قلبه ستكون الغلبه للغناء ، لأن القرآن لا يحل في القلب الخرب لأن القرآن نظيف Ibn al-Qayyim Rahimahullah said, " the love of the Quran and the love of singing will never coexist in the heart of a believer! If they do coexist, the love of singing will dominate because the Quran does not dwell in a corrupted heart, for the Quran is pure." What then about music which some sahaba called the Quran of Shytaan.

"In fact, it’s these three words, terror not territory, that we need to understand how Israeli propaganda works. Territory is about history. I once had a student tell me that the most radical class I taught was where I went over the actual history using maps of the conflict. Once you know the facts, it’s very clear what the just and moral position should be, especially if you’re neutral within this. That is why the history is made out to be so complex that only experts can speak. The reality, of course, is that the so-called Israeli-Palestinian conflict is the simplest and most straightforward in the modern world to explain-if you just tell the story of territory, if you just tell the history, if you stick essentially to the facts. So Luntz says, this is his advice, he says, avoid history. Avoid facts. Focus instead on terrorism. In the same report, Luntz goes on to outline strategies for how to deal with horrific civilian casualties that will inevitably make their way before the eyes of the American public. Once you’ve done that, Luntz says, you also have to get people to empathize with Israelis by describing what life is like for them, living in constant fear of Hamas rocket attacks. So again and again, we hear the focus-tested phrase that the rockets are raining down on Israel.... Clips show newspeople and leaders repeating the phrase “Hamas rockets raining down on Israel.” Any advertising executive will tell you the essence of propaganda is repetition. Then the Israelis ask the American people what would you do?] The story never starts with the violence of the occupation. The story always starts with Hamas rockets. In fact, if Hamas did not exist, Israel would have to invent it. It really matters where history starts, where the story starts. If it starts with the violence of the occupation, then what the Palestinians are engaged in is legitimate resistance. If however it starts with Hamas rockets, then what the Palestinians are doing is terrorism. One of those stories, it works much better for Israel than the other one. The function of PR is to put this story, that the responsibility for the violence lies with the Palestinians, to put those ideas and your words into someone else’s mouth so that it does not appear as your speech. That is the essence of public relations. It is how it is different from advertising. Advertising is visible and it’s clear who is speaking. The best PR is invisible because you’ve got someone else, in this case hapless and hopeless American journalists, to mouth your words. I’m not even sure they know what they’re doing." Professor Sut Jhally

What about writing a book containing vulgarity, with the intention of promoting literature and stating facts of the time we live in?

@user-zb6ke8wi4s

4 ай бұрын

i think it would depend upon the extent to which the writer takes the vulgarity to

@faizubhai3969

3 күн бұрын

More dependable on the reader i guess

Appreciate the references, but where is the middle ground? He said daff is allowed and musical instruments with strings and music with any form of vulgarity or evil is not allowed. So what's the middle ground? Which music are we allowed to listen to.. 'house'?

@esadcan7290

10 ай бұрын

What do you mean by which music? Do you expect a music producers name to listen to? You can listen to Beethoven

@steamstrategy7670

10 ай бұрын

@@esadcan7290Beethovan uses string, so if we go by what Sheikh Asrar Rashid said, then Beethoven would be haram.

@ADawoodKiwi

10 ай бұрын

He is saying anything other than the haram by ijmaa is a grey area. The suggestion is it is better to abstain but if someone partakes you cannot call them faasiq because of khilaf in the issue.

@wsaaccount-iu6nt

9 ай бұрын

Folk or any music without any string instruments and vulgar words/vulgarity. Thats what I understood from the podcast

Thank you for the info. I listen sometimes but will try to keep it in line. One issue I have is demoralisation because of apparently institutional lack of concern for climate change action and activism. The ulema seem to be unwilling to accept it’s of vital concern or to coach the faithful. Then, ergo by analogy I conclude , if they can be wrong there why not elsewhere? Hence demoralisation and a breakdown of trust in their advice. So I may be perceived as rebellious. But climate change is due to fasad ( corruption ie of the earth) afaict. Why take taqlid from ulema who seem to care more for music than a massive existential threat to future of living planet and civilisation. Taqwa involves generally avoiding harm? And doing good. Healthy stuff. I believe this goes beyond the rituals of faith and beard length etc. Isn’t waqiya the root meaning to guard, ie to safeguard in both the natural visible and spiritual domains? Isn’t it mustaqim( ie straight + proper) to care? Care brings naimat, apathy brings ruin. Hearts seem to be sealed from caring for things not blatantly obvious , tenting only to things in Bukhari but not geology or climatology. Where the licence for people to ignore (?) the empirical sciences.? It’s not going to lead to success… I’m not blaming you brothers. But relating issues with morale. I know it’s a non sequitur to conclude you’re all utterly useless , but please try to understand. Plus it would be good for public image and dawa. Science isn’t perfect it’s an approximation and model. Because but we use engineers and doctors without much hesitation and rightly so. Right = correct= mustaqim. Mustaqim -> naimat. Naimat -> muflihoon. Not tornados and floods and fires.

@tasalsul09

10 ай бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/ioCbu7ywka_Jg8o.htmlsi=LapBg9YjW2MGmYV6

@khairt1731

10 ай бұрын

The "fasad" comes from the U.S Military. The SAME ppl that advocate that "climate change" exist are the same politicians and scientist bought by big pharma and the military industrial complex. The military with its vast naval force, air force(jets) and hundrends of military bases are producing more CO2 than countries combined. There is an Agenda going on here.

@Scott-Eesa

10 ай бұрын

You justify listening to music because you don’t think the ulama are putting enough emphasis on climate change? That’s quite the stretch. Music is clearly haram from the evidence we have in the Quran and Sunnah. Climate change, while almost certainly an issue (at least pollution is an issue) is based on kafir science and is undoubtedly mixed up in the intentional hysteria that the liberal powers seek to stir up in order to control us. Trust the ulama more than the media, that’s my advice. We all sin. We all fall short. But don’t look for excuses to try and make it so sins aren’t sins.

all 'ulama and no qur'an and sunnah. What happened to the ayat, ahadith and ijmaa' prohibiting music without exception?

@tasalsul09

10 ай бұрын

There is no ayah prohibiting music. And for the Ahadith we leave them to the interpretation of the Fuqaha. P.S: I am not in direct contact with the Shaykh so I can't talk on his behalf. But since the podcast had so many questions to be answered and this wasn't the main point of podcast. Maybe that's why the Shaykh didn't elucidate in detail.

@Scott-Eesa

10 ай бұрын

@@tasalsul09Ibn Masud gave tafsir of at least one ayah as prohibiting music.

@mewzi

10 ай бұрын

@@Scott-Eesa yes as al-hakim narrated with authentic isnad واللهِ الذي لا إلهَ غيرُه هو الغناءُ ، يُردِّدُها ثلاثَ مراتٍ. How misguided can a person be to reject ayat, ahadith, ijmaa' and sayings of the sahabah, tabi'oon and atba' al-tabi'oon.

@spawnnpwn4166

10 ай бұрын

@@mewzi Can you share a reference of Ibn masud RA's tafsir? Jazak Allahu khair

@mewzi

10 ай бұрын

@@spawnnpwn4166 wa anta ya akhi fajazaak Allahu khayran. You can find his quote in many books alhamdulillah, I referenced al-Hakim 3582 in the chapter of surah Luqman. it's also in dhim al-Malahi by ibn abi al-Dunya 26 in the chapter of al-Mizmar, al-Tabari 20/127 under the tafsir of لهو الحديث and ibn abi shaybah 6/309 under the same ayah

imam Ahmed Raza Khan Al Barelvi said it is Haram. He also prohibited dancing. Asrar Rashid is transgressing against Barelvi positions.

@tasalsul09

9 ай бұрын

Ahlus Sunnah, or Sunni Islam, is a broad and diverse tradition that includes not only Ala Hazrat Imam Ahmad Ridha Khan but also numerous other revered scholars and predecessors. In this comprehensive tradition, there is room for a diversity of opinions and interpretations. Hence, individuals who may differ from Ala Hazrat on specific issues can still be considered Sunni Muslims. Furthermore, Shaykh Asrar Rashid has addressed Ala Hazrat's perspective on the topic of music in his other videos, providing a more in-depth understanding of this aspect. It's important to clarify that my statements here are not on behalf of Shaykh Asrar Rashid, but rather an attempt to convey the general perspective within the Sunni tradition while expressing admiration for Ala Hazrat.

@m.ssiddiqui1327

Ай бұрын

Correction :- Ala hazrat: declare music is haram, and about raqs he said their is a ikhtilaf on it but my opinion is avoid a raqs(not declaring haram)

The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful... If one of them is haram then all of them are haram!

@Zaingillani_09

10 ай бұрын

Running water is pure for wudhu , would you apply this on running water which has impure severage lines merging into it ? Its never so black and white , there's a reason scholars write entire books upon such subjects .

@jon_009

10 ай бұрын

@@Zaingillani_09 everytime people dont like something they cry out maslaha. Haram is Haram - just because someone with sever skin condition is excused for wearing silk it doesnt make the ruling gray

@Zaingillani_09

10 ай бұрын

@@jon_009 you're reaching here . The example you gave was a condition of uzar(excuse) , whereas the issue of music is completely different from it.

@radirandom

4 ай бұрын

​​@@Zaingillani_09 Music is haram by declared ijma. This khilaaf is rejected expect few expections

Dance is permitted?? That’s new for me.

This type of video only encourages the deviant ones to think "well, it's open to debate, so I'm going to listen to music" But if you go back in time before the scholars he's mentioned, to the first 3 praised generations, then you'll see that the overwhelming majority were against music (with the exception of girls playing the duff for weddings/Eid etc). May Allaah ta'ala guide brother Asrar to say that which pleases Him ﷻ and not that which pleases the laymen from amongst the Muslims.

@esadcan7290

7 ай бұрын

wdym, there is ikhtilaf on many things not only music. One should go to his own scholar from whom he takes, and should follow him that's it the easiest way

@bluepoison004

2 ай бұрын

@@esadcan7290 yeah the ikhtilaf is batil by consensus

Is it me or why is this video so fast it sounds wierd

Music undoubtedly haram in islam. Shame for those Muslim who say music is halal

@tasalsul09

10 ай бұрын

What degree do you hold to say so. Are you an authority in Islam. Have you even memorized 1 hadith with the chain going back to Rasoolallah Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam?

@MoeedKhan1979

10 ай бұрын

@@tasalsul09 i said on the degree of thousand muslim scholars and muhadiseen who told us that music is haram. Dozens of hadeeth says music is bad. By the way why you advocating shaitan trap which is music

@tasalsul09

10 ай бұрын

@@MoeedKhan1979 When an Issue Is disputed/ikhtilafi you don't go on cursing Muslims. The position of Muslim is disputed within Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jamaa'h. So it may be haram for you and permissible with conditions for someone else.

@MoeedKhan1979

10 ай бұрын

@@tasalsul09 no you are wrong because majority of high rank scholars have the view of music is harram

@MoeedKhan1979

10 ай бұрын

@@tasalsul09 dont compare little rank scholars with high rank classical scholars

Music is haram

Whoever listens to music and promotes for others to listen to it is a fool. Nasheeds are fine with ANY instruments. Daff is an exception where it applies ofc.

@radirandom

4 ай бұрын

With any instrument?

@ANONz_

4 ай бұрын

@@radirandom thanks for the correction, I forgot all about this comment I made and I was meant to say “without ANY instruments” Thank u

Hanafi fique is a another religion music is clear cut haram don’t know what these asharis are on about

@AlphaMaverick1111

9 ай бұрын

Don't lie, what you said is akin to doing takfir of hundreds of millions of Muslims who follow the Hanafi fiqh. be careful of what you say. Hanafis are Sunni Muslims not a separate religion.

@greentube1357

9 ай бұрын

​@@AlphaMaverick1111simple nowadays some people think them self aalim just cuz they have social media and can easily make fatwa 🤗.

@AlphaMaverick1111

9 ай бұрын

@@greentube1357 It's pure deviancy and is an attempt to harm to the Ummah. The Ummah does not unite upon falsehood.

@greentube1357

9 ай бұрын

@@AlphaMaverick1111 bro look at his comment even a fool question his existence

You write a damn book you get to decide utter nonsense. Can’t wait for the new age to come in.

QURAN AND HADITH VERY CLEAR MUSIC IS HARAM MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS IS HARAM.