if you read the lyrics, it's pretty obvious that this is about Valkyrie's downfall... they were literally singing about their demise as it was happening, which just makes it even more sad...

@cupangoreng

2 жыл бұрын

i just realized... why 😭😭😭😭

@toyrajinshorts7220

2 жыл бұрын

it made me sad too but shu with a uniform in enthralling threatre song but how sad they sing they're demise

@fireworksforme2

Жыл бұрын

D:

@siaorihara

Жыл бұрын

that's why when they sing it in the anime, I think that it was Nazuna telling his old unit mates a formal goodbye to become fully apart of Rab*its and leave Valkyrie with no more regrets

@gladionfan

Жыл бұрын

LUKA??

The fact that Shu said that Valkyrie was no castle of sand during the Neverland Event makes me cry even more.

@fireworksforme2

Жыл бұрын

omg fr im crying

@snailuka

Жыл бұрын

character development

@dazaisbandages1906

Жыл бұрын

They grow up so fast 😭

@jovelleeeee

Жыл бұрын

Honestly, it could also be a good thing. Because he’s saying him and the rest are no longer the same, they have changed (positively) and are now free from his old harmful ideals/

Shu singing the line "Ah, though everything has been shattered to pieces"...with Nito and Mika saying in follow-up "these engravings are not wounds", it makes me cry

@curlypubes69

3 ай бұрын

Real, my eyes become teary when that part plays

This song is so beautiful with such a bittersweet story behind it. This song gives me feelings I can’t explain. Everyone in Valkyrie (including Nito ) really has been through a lot

Can anyone here the super high register someone is singing in? It's insane. If that's nito then serious props to his va cause that has to be challenging

@kaleidoscope3549

2 жыл бұрын

cmiiw, it's nazuna, he's always in charge of higher register in old!valkyrie's songs. iirc his va ever talked abt how he worked his ass off to learn singing in higher register and soprano voice so he could show us the perfect image of nazuna in shu's world aesthetic

@knivoras

2 жыл бұрын

@@kaleidoscope3549 props to him bc holy

@mctimmie8190

Жыл бұрын

I can't hear it ;;

@hjalmprimul

Жыл бұрын

@@mctimmie8190 when they're all singing tgh, you dont listen to the main loud voices, hear the soft high pitched tone. You gotta strain your ears to listen, but after some time you can hear it better

@MarS-zh9ek

Жыл бұрын

@@hjalmprimul I didn't also heard it at first, but when I finally heard it, it gave chills, that damn high and so perfectly made, my props to the va.

最後「糸のない人形の重ねた歌声は静かに響いてる」の所の歌詞が追憶のあの場面と重なり過ぎてて辛い…

hearing this song in the anime made me want to sob like a baby UPDATE: I AM NOW SOBBING LIKE A BABY HELP ME 2023 update: i’m still crying.

@krinedanialle

2 жыл бұрын

Wait it's in the anime? I've watched abt 24 episodes and idk if theres more but pls tell me where this song appears in the anime I wanna see it

@_ENGURISHU

2 жыл бұрын

@@krinedanialle im pretty sure its in ep 22 the part where nazuna joins valkyrie again for a performance

@heyitsmadie485

2 жыл бұрын

@@krinedanialle yep! it’s episode 22

@DZTWoo

2 жыл бұрын

Can anyone tell me whats the anime? Im new to enstar

@beomahdan3136

Жыл бұрын

Same the last one

曲を聞いているだけで 鳥肌がたちます… 新人プロデューサーですが、 旧Valkyrieは本当に尊いもの ‪”‬だったんだな‪”‬ と思うと涙が止まりません。

This comment section perfectly shows the duality of enstarries shshd

2人のときでも宗とみかちゃんの声が合わさっていていいけど、3人になると宗とみかちゃんとなずなの3人同士で3人の声を包み込んでいる感じがあって好き!!!!

This song is so beautiful, I love past Valkyrie 😭😭❤️

@cb97chahn

2 жыл бұрын

RIGHT

@Aki4s

2 жыл бұрын

Current valkyrie is better though

@tangerine247

2 жыл бұрын

@@Aki4s i think it's equal. Ngl i will prefer current Valkyrie when we talk about character development. but still, past Valkyrie song are so goddamn good, especially Nazuna's part, that high voice is angel

@Aki4s

2 жыл бұрын

@@tangerine247 i don’t really care about nazuna but i love valkyrie so im biased. All their songs are amazing though, both past and current.

@tangerine247

2 жыл бұрын

@@Aki4s understandable

Damn it fine. Valkyrie has to be like, the saddest unit ever

@krinedanialle

2 жыл бұрын

FRR

@MarS-zh9ek

Жыл бұрын

@Galaxyfnaf And Dino that sure would explain why I love both

@angelofuentes6010

Жыл бұрын

But for me, it became a good opportunity to nazuna to express himself more rather than a puppet only in performance

I’m always amazed by nazuna’s va when i hear how high his voice can go. I know it’s probably not possible but i’d really like to hear yonai-san do a solo cover of this song or if someone could find audio of his voice only for it. His high notes are always sung with shu and mika, which sounds really good together, but you can’t fully experience his skill alone which makes me a bit sad because it’s clear he worked really hard to get that high.

Nazuna's voice omg it's angelic

After returning to this vid for the nth time i just realized how foul they are for giving the "these engravings are not wounds" line 3:20 only to mika and nazuna and now im bawling my eyes out at 9 in the morning

何度も聞きたくなるほどこの曲好き

This song is so good it literally wants to make me cry

I don't know why singing along with them brings me to tears

@Izasuki

Жыл бұрын

I’m quite literally tearing up while singing along to the chorus

@MarS-zh9ek

Жыл бұрын

Right? 😭

3:45 日本語歌詞の 一粒に閉じ込めた追憶は〜 と 留めていた時間はさらさらと崩れていく の順番が逆になっています……！

この三人の歌声、歌詞いいよね…ホント好き、いつか旧ヴァのイベント待ってます…

なずな兄ィめちゃくちゃ声高…低くても好きやけどな！！！！！！！！！！！！

3:55 - 4:25 the lyrics, the feels, it's too much too handle I'm crying

音ゲーでも出きるようにして欲しい

@user-oi4vc5lp3j

10 ай бұрын

それなー

puts them in my mouth and chews

@lshsiuakdd

2 жыл бұрын

???

@lshsiuakdd

2 жыл бұрын

HLEP

@ayathoma

2 жыл бұрын

@@lshsiuakdd I FORGOT THIS IS IN MY BIO AND I COMMETNED GO AWAYAYWY

@zoeybm6036

2 жыл бұрын

swallows them

@lshsiuakdd

2 жыл бұрын

@@ayathoma bozo

this song gives me many a feeling and i cannot THE LYRICS ARE SO 😭 valkyrie best unit forever

"And to even the fact it's broken it remains oblivious" Man oh man the tears just won't stop But again this song also lives to serve how much Shu (and Valkyrie) have grown from ! Era to !! Era. Im so proud of the three of them😭😭

Normally, no matter how sad a song is I never cry, but this made me cry, especially after learning more about Past Valkyrie, well, at least things are better now. I have itchy tennish shoes (eichi tenshouin or however his last nam is spelt)

@mrglassman9554

7 ай бұрын

Tennis shoe😭???

ツョウケースめちゃくちゃ笑う

@harutya_0429

2 жыл бұрын

なんの事かと思ったらホントにツョウケースになってたw

@hina-lf4dr

Жыл бұрын

それなwwwwwwwwwwww

ex valkyrie makes me so sad

Yeah It's a very sad song but I never gonna ignore how Mika said watarus name

@mctimmie8190

Жыл бұрын

@Galaxyfnaf And Dino i know. It's still funny.

@mafuuya02

11 ай бұрын

the amount of times "hibiki wataru" appears in es lyrics is crazy, i‘m convinced they’re doing it on purpose, he’s just everywhere

This song was the only good thing that came from the war era

One time I actually enjoyed a KZread ad... But I must understand this... WHY ARE ALL THESE SONGS FUCKING BANGERS!?

The Yuki Kajiura vibes were so strong in this one

@eira3365

2 жыл бұрын

You're right !!

How I miss the old valkyrie... to be honest, I love the old valkyrie so much... than the current one because it feels something is missing...

@noya3453

2 жыл бұрын

The old valkyrie was very toxic from the start thats why they had a downfall in the first place,, im happy things are the way they are now tbh, nito can freely smile now, mika isn’t a worthless member anymore and shu doesnt have to carry valkryie by himself on any longer

@KOHAKU_28

2 жыл бұрын

@@noya3453 I think it's good for all of them that Nito left Valkyrie. They wouldn't be able to move on due to Shu's attachment to Nito. And Nito is much happier now. I think that Mika and Shu become more carrying for each other. I like that things are like that(sorry for my eng)

@soramafuforlife7247

2 жыл бұрын

Ex Valkyrie is absolutely charming and Nazuna's voice is the most gorgeous thing ever in it but I definitely prefer the current Valkyrie much more as the above commenters have said already. The way Mika can stand as Shu's equal and how Shu has developed to be a much better person and wants Mika to see himself as a human rather than a doll now is beautiful.

@itrysometimes4312

Жыл бұрын

I find this a very fascinating discussion because it could be interpreted that the old Valkyrie is in fact the 'better' version, technically, because Nito was essential to Shu's vision of making perfect art. The current Valkyrie 'lacks something' (Nito), and we feel that. However, it was able to become something more - a real idol unit, if we're leaning into the human vs doll, Pinocchio, themes here, where Mika and Shu can perform happily as equals despite finding faults with it as 'art'. Old Valkyrie is an idyllic, but bygone era, the nostalgia perfects it in rose-tinted glass, but it finds its place within a Museum to be admired. While the current Valkyrie lives, breathes and performs for the present, straddling the line between perfection and what finding humanity in their art will create (Acanthe). I'm in love with both Valkyrie's because of the dichotomy Art vs Idol, Happiness vs perfection (Steampunk Museum), Human vs doll thing they've got going on, it cuts deep and enables discussions like this which are also very thematic. It's all the art of Valkyrie and I live for it.

@kazto_

Жыл бұрын

@@itrysometimes4312 the way you worded it was amazing, i completely agree

anime watchers are sobbing rn

@_ENGURISHU

2 жыл бұрын

!era enstars readers crying screaming dying on the floor rn

@JJ.23

2 жыл бұрын

I read the wiki 😭✋ so ik what happened and omg I'm in pain

bro im crying rn i ain’t lying

Valkyrie past songs is so Emotional and full of sadness and scar's, it's makes my heart hurt also makes me cry, 😔 they have suffer to much 😭😭😭😨😨😨

FUCKING NAZUNAS VOICE I LOVE HIM

I love mikachan voice in this song. It's so soft...

Gonna sob fr. I miss ! era. It's so nostalgic and holds such a special place in my heart :')

this song is so powerful i just started vibrating in an extremely high frequency

4:18 if you listen really closely, it sounded like someone was sobbing in that line. I wonder who that was…

i only play the rhythm game and Valkyrie had a third member? I’m so confused but this song is amazing

@joannavechellea2955

2 жыл бұрын

They used to, but a lot happened and they went through downfall. The third member, nito left valkyrie and formed ra*bits instead. It's really sad, actually. If you want to know more about them, you can watch the anime and read the story.

@subaruakehoshi573

2 жыл бұрын

@@joannavechellea2955 where can i watch it? Cause i have been looking for it

@lucascheesespringles6307

2 жыл бұрын

@@subaruakehoshi573 pirate sites have it

@casylie

2 жыл бұрын

@@joannavechellea2955 where can i read the story??

@Anna-vf4wj

2 жыл бұрын

@@casylie you can copy the link to any story before like 2022 on the wiki and put it in the wayback machine to read it. to know more about whats being talked about in the song i suggest reading marionette

tears crying

I love this song💖💖

旧Valkyrieほんとに好きなんだよなぁ…もちろんいまのValkyrieも大好きだけど…なんか儚い… 三人の声きれいすぎて（ ; ; ）

brb crying

im smiling so bitterly

ほんとに麗しい…⏳⋆͛

the intro of the song sounds like Honeymoon Un Deux Trois 😳

What I find interesting about this song and Sacred Youth Games is that Mika sings during them, when it was stated he wasnt allowed to sing with Nazuna and Shu during that time period. That means that these were likely the only songs Mika recorded with them during ex-Valk (likely due to Nazuna's insistence), which means these songs are probably held dear to all of them.

@clowd..

8 ай бұрын

Actually this song was sung by Valkyrie after their downfall At this time nazuna was already in ra*bits, he just came to sing this both to apologize and to help mika who is in a little trouble bcuz shu was late( leo and izumi(?) Found him passed out in the snow) mika still hadnt fully trusted nazuna and was scolding at him backstage untill shu appeared then they all sang together Also shu said that this song was supposed to be centered around mika

this song is so good oh my gpd

why this song gives me major pixie hollow vibes? lol

this song makes me cry everytime i listen to it to the point i memorised half of the lyrics

i got chills. this song is so sad

past valkyrie hurts me alot

This is literally my favorite song

Bruh this song makes me so emotional for no reason. I love past valk lore this song is fckin beautiful

참 슬픈 노래입니다.

*cries*

Valkyrie's sad past and the reason why Nazuna left the band makes me cry. That is why this song is so fragile and beautiful.

I don't get it. I've heard this song a million times. Yet when I try to sing it, I start to cry.

砂上ノ楼閣良😇😇😇😇😇って思ってたら字幕のツォウケースで現実に戻ってきた

BAWLING ಥ_ಥ

this causes me so much physical and emotional pain

2:08 Wataru jumpscare

旧ヴァほんとすき‥

Please i'm crying:'(

Start crying so bad

2:28 CRYING

여기서 한국인 찾는 미카아내이자 구발키리오시..

@Sooyuuun

2 жыл бұрын

저입니다 축하드려요 (외국권에서도 사랑받는 울 애긔들을 보니 행복하군요)

@user-lp3fx3in7r

2 жыл бұрын

미카 찾다가 왔소..ㅎ 발키리는 종ㄱ((퍽

i love this song but also i’m glad nazuna left because holy hell wtf shu 😭

I hope enstar can make this song into the MV game😗😗😗

This song just makes me cry every single time. Beautiful and sad. 3:19 man...

@SpikoDreams

5 ай бұрын

where is it from?

@SoraPawz

4 ай бұрын

@@SpikoDreams Ex-Valkyrie

I'm crying 😭😭 you crew too,😭😭 we both crode...😭😭😭😞

i thoufg the only ex valkyrie song was sacred youths games 😭😭

@01_xvn

2 жыл бұрын

there’s 3 so far ! sacred youths game, this one and i think d’arc?

@ca1rozz

2 жыл бұрын

d’arc? I only know youth games and castle of sand what is that one?

@mistypedmistake

Жыл бұрын

@@ca1rozz it’s from the stage play I think

@Seoneoji

Жыл бұрын

yes there is a song from them that appears only in a stage play

@ca1rozz

Жыл бұрын

@@mistypedmistake the comment is pretty old so I already found out thank you ether way its quite sad that its only in stage play

va;lkyrie best unit fr

Wow look a good band hope nothing happens to that person on the left hahaha ha ( before you comment, I KNOW WHAT HAPPEMD TO POOR NAZUNA)

someone said that I'm just like shu bc I prefer nito in Valkyrie but can't you rlly blame me? I love rabbits with all my heart but his voice in old Valkyrie was just too unique and beautiful to not miss

@CyberMinkk

Жыл бұрын

Yeah…nazuna is my all time favourite as a ra*bitsp. if only ra*bits can do more dark emotional-cute concepts, cus fall in love wonderland is the closest thing we’ve got. Hopefull for sad ra*bits song 🙏🏻

@Saphius-

Жыл бұрын

I mean, the thing is that Nito could not sing like that anymore due to his voice changing. Persisting is a stasis was vain and toxic, espcially when you consider the distress it put Nito in

😄😊😄😊👍👍👍👍👍 love

NOO I REGRET READING THE LYRICS

i love yuou

1:03

i want this on my wedding ngl

2:18 - 2:44 this. part.

0:50

3:07

common nazuna sweep

I WISH NAZUNA WAS STILL IN VALKYRIE

BY THE POWER OF RA!!!

I keep seeing Wataru's name everywhere...

Recuerdo haber escuchado esta canción antes pero la ultima parte del coro era FULL ACAPELLA (Si alguien la tiene o recuerda haber escuchado esa versión que me diga donde esta ese video?)

i cri

3:58 who's singing the high(?)/ Falsetto(?) part??? Please i need to know🥲

@poopboy6548

5 ай бұрын

Nazuna

shrimp feelings

I'm trying hard not to be a crazy nitpicky stan, but does the fact they used current era Valkyrie's logo when it's past Valkyrie bother anyone else? I'm so sorry... I just can't help it!

聖少年遊戯で「黒い爪で」ってところが「黒いすね毛」に聞こえます😂

So you are telling me I can't play old songs on enstars??😭😭

@torinrin1602

Жыл бұрын

for now yeah .... but they added eccentric party night so i do have some slim hope for exvalk songs

@butterscotchdandelion5452

Жыл бұрын

@@torinrin1602 I really hope they bring the songs back cause new players like me want yo enjoy the whole experience and they are such good songs too😭

@marshacore

11 ай бұрын

well they added only one ex valk song in the bgm es coin shop

@bunlj9404

10 ай бұрын

​@@marshacoreBoth of the ex Valkryie songs is in the bgm es coin shop-

@marshacore

10 ай бұрын

@@bunlj9404 my bad

😢 naaa...zuna

旧varukiri-には是非絡繰りドールを歌って欲しい！！切実に、