Great talk SETI, I hope we were able to come up with new ideas on Space.

"They've got a different funding model." Seth's quips kill me!

24:52 Shostak's response is priceless.

Ok, as a radio guy, let’s take a look at our own recent history. RF has only been emitted by humans for about 100 years. High power within the last 50 years. SUPER high power within the last 30 - the now defunct SPAWAR space fence at 216 MHz transmitting about 9 giga-watts ERP with stability of a millionth of a Hz. This would reasonably be detected as the beam briefly illuminates another system. But there is a concern here. As our technology has advanced, it has become more efficient, and therefore less power is required. The huge CW radar was replaced by smaller, pinpoint beam, pulsed radars at 1000 times less power. Television is now lower power DTV, and the overall trend continues to decrease. So, radio will probably remain detectable for maybe another 50 years. Your mobile phone comment is a great example. The signals are minute. A window of 100 years is but a “blip” in time. Carl Sagan described the next stage as a purposefully curious civilization, building transmitters and receivers purposefully with extreme power and apertures to both look for and send messages. The same could be said of high power lasers. A “stage 2” civilization actively transmitting would be required. In addition, there are interstellar effects such as dispersion, Doppler, and even Raman shifting taking away useable energy. So far, the most modern, and promising technology is sensitive spectral capability to see natural and biological markers. Chemistry is a whole dimension.

Thanks, folks! ❤🎉

@ericperez4612

8 ай бұрын

Hello ? every one knows they are here. Why are astronomers even involved this a communications issue! Not astronomy.

@Damaged7

2 ай бұрын

@@ericperez4612If they were here and they didn't mind us knowing, then we'd know. Like, it would be super well known common knowledge. That isn't the case, so if they are here, then they don't want us to know.

@ericperez4612

2 ай бұрын

@@Damaged7 Ya well thats another issue. My complaint is that SETI is misguided. In light of the facts. Im no expert but my personal lifelong hobby involves investigateing and locateing targeted radio communications. Its my affinity. I actually considered joining setis search program . If i had i would be angry at this point. I am angry ,They are not utelizeing the obvious criteria

I hope they visit us and show us how to live 200 years old, with no pain.

Since we have detected gravity waves, is there a gravity spectrum ❓

Not all civilisation communicates the same as us. Our civilisation is based on premise of oxygen, water and communications that requires signalling. My question is what happens if we come across a civilisation that do not communicates via signalling- can our technology reach a civilisation that communicates via telepathically- a civilisation which have no needs for radio signals? Alternatively, a civilisation that has become so advanced- that they switches off radio based communications, does that mean what SETI is doing is only catching a niche amount of civilisation that communicate the same way as us?

start at 5:15

would they be looking at Earth millions of years ago, we are just still moss?

Would we still be a civilization if they ever find us? Or would they only find reminiscent of what we someday were?

@alanmcmillan6969

Жыл бұрын

A rosy future for us tolook forward to.

@TheDavidlloydjones

8 ай бұрын

Anybody able to travel the light-years will probably have the techniques with which to dig up some DNA and reconstruct whatever they're curious about, doncha think?

Maybe someone could send a signal that would broadcast Carl Sagans "Cosmos" in its entirety + maybe one of the NOVA Chanels Documentaries showing our planetary features, including the good, the bad, and the ugly

@azraeljo6862

Ай бұрын

Not all civilisation communicates the same as us. Our civilisation is based on premise of oxygen, water and communications that requires signalling. My question is what happens if we come across a civilisation that do not communicates via signalling- can our technology reach a civilisation that communicates via telepathically- a civilisation which have no needs for radio signals?

In Crick’s book Life Itself: Its Origin and Nature, he writes: “The immensity of complex coded and precisely sequenced information (in DNA) is absolutely staggering. The DNA evidence speaks of intelligent, information bearing design. For life to form by chance is mathematically virtually impossible.” What's more, scientists have no idea what caused the Cambrian explosion when animals with brains, eyes, skeletons, appendages, hearts, etc. appeared out of nowhere from simple multi-cell organisms like sponges, overnight. Fermi's Paradox explained? Not to mention how DNA appeared on Earth only 600 million years after the Earth was formed. Something very curious going on here.

@spiralsun1

Жыл бұрын

This is exactly correct. My first book 20 years ago (where I quote Francis Crick from our conversations about meaning) I showed how all life and even the universe had to come from an alien intelligence. But it’s not like people think- or don’t think😂-because they just project the themes of what we do here “out there”. We are in a rapid transition phase as humans. This is not “it”. I already found unequivocal evidence and proof of an extra-terrestrial intelligence at work. My more recent articles and books keep getting rejected. Even though I am right, because people cannot imagine how it works. Aliens are supposed to come in ufos. 😂 There’s an “information signature” I talk about in my book.

@Living_Matrix1

Жыл бұрын

@@spiralsun1 Aliens: the new God of the gaps.

@spiralsun1

Жыл бұрын

@@Living_Matrix1 It actually is god. That’s the extra-terrestrial intelligence. My book was “The Textbook of the Universe: the Genetic Ascent to God”. 😂👍🏻

Is it possible to know the DATE of the interview, please ?

@AllPlanets

Жыл бұрын

April 20 (check the description)

Are we still searching for intelligent life in our solar system? Or have we given up on that? Are there any telescopes staring at like Saturn or Uranus trying to find technosignatures?

1 light year is for leakage radiation right? Radars are more powerful and can be picked up from a greater distance? From what I recall, the Arecibo planetary radar could see itself from 100 light years or so.

" They're real, they are biological " I trust

They hear spectral emmissions between the auditory coretex....and the visual coretex.

Keep heading East of betrayant nine!

Very entertaining. Poor Molly. She had to drag the answers out of them. Did they willingly go into this interview? Seth brilliant as usual. Paul’s brilliant ‘you’ll know it when you see’ analogy. Paul reminds me of Steve Buscemi. At any moment some gangster will rush on stage and finish him off. Thank you SETI

Meet the dreamers. To dream the impossible dream.

🎉

Sound fades out. Need better stage sound management.

we never turn the space telescopes for shots of earth, why not ?

@comrademartinofrappuccino

10 ай бұрын

How would you even be able to do that? that I could only think of by building telescopes on the moon.

@Damaged7

2 ай бұрын

We have already done it. I forget which satellite it was but it was instructed to turn around and take a picture of Earth before it left. The reason we don't usually do it,is because some of the satellites aren't designed to be taking photos of planets.

I think the next search for et is small asteroid's in chemical environment sweet spots.

The sound was good in the beginning, and then too low so I can't listen to this unfortunately

@SETIInstitute

Жыл бұрын

We accidentally had Seth's mic off for a few moments, but we fixed the issue. You may want to skip ahead.

@galaxia4709

Жыл бұрын

@@SETIInstitute Thank you, SETI :) Please tell Molly that I love her in the podcasts (and of course Seth Soshtek too).

@djvincekline7338

Жыл бұрын

That's on purpose. The aliens are listening with ;-)

i have seen one

Earth is a bright star at the wavelength of television. What do They see of us? Hitler opens the 1936 Olympic Games. Horror follows: a thousand years of "I Love Lucy."

Terrascope.

They see everything they are here NOT IN SPACE !

MAKE NINE ?ETI

If there is intelligent life out there (I believe there is) shouldn't SETI researchers be looking and listening for anomalies that could be forms of communication by an intelligence that is 1000's of years ahead of our current capabilities?

If an alien were observing Earth and attempting to learn about human communication, it would find that while it is possible, the most important aspects, such as when, how, and where. Greetings from Simeta("Simeta, The Story Tale from Moravia,2021")

If any alien race is more advanced than us....would humans be safe if they found us? There are more risk than reward to send out signals of our location. We are not ready.

@Sinistercabbage

Жыл бұрын

But weve been sending signals for decades now. The bottom line is if they can get here and threaten us they can detect our radio emissions. But if they can get here then they would have no reason to hurt us (unless they are total sadists).

@jamesrey3221

10 ай бұрын

what happens when two different specie meet? A bear and man, a dog and cat, a lion and deer, etc...usually the strong eat the weak.

Extraterrestrial civilizations will find us by our first high powered television broadcasts, beginning with Hitler at the Olympics.

Of course. They can see thru walls and bathroom doors. You mist buy a Lead lined Shower curtain.

@deliapearsall6334

8 ай бұрын

You are correct. I have experienced lazers beams following me throughout my house. Trust me, these extraterrestrials and their technology exist. I was visited August 16th 2023. And I have questions, and need help.

@GreenPeelEL34

6 ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂😂

they are interested in big human events, like one time djengis kahn had seen 5 stars arranged in a line, those were no stars, and probably they also helped humanity if it fits their agenda

DAVID GRUSH. Looks like the game’s finally up.

@GreenPeelEL34

6 ай бұрын

Yeah, he ran his mouth and the world stopped to laugh.😂

@MultiBikerboy1

6 ай бұрын

@@GreenPeelEL34 not sure I even understand what you’re saying. 🤔

Wow four months old. Luis elisondo did his piece over 2 years ago. This is four months old. They are either lieing through their teeth or very misinformed. Maybe both. I always thought seti was for real

No kidding ...speak up

Terrible volume control.

@SzymczykProductions

Жыл бұрын

Always someone who complains about something. Smfh

@The1Helleri

Жыл бұрын

​@@SzymczykProductions Yeah, it's a valid fucking complaint. It's all over the place. I don't put on a video that's over an hour long to sit there with my handle on the volume control. I got roommates. So either they complain because my speaker volume is randomly way too loud or I experience actual pain because I can't anticipate the changes quick enough to turn headphones down. How is someone expected to listen to any of what their saying if they also have a job to do. A job that could have been done by whoever recorded it, edited it, uploaded it. Several opportunities to check for and fix major audio issues. No one would even have to listen to it to know. Just import the audio track into a program like audacity (which is a free program so it doesn't even cost anything) and it could be seen that the levels are all over the place at a glance. And there's features in such programs (which one could learn to use from a few youtube video tutorials) that let one fix such issues. It's not the kind of thing that should ever get past a team. That's part of why there should be more than one set eyes on it. Something that bad usually doesn't get passed a whole team. unless that whole team is one person. Maybe the same person who was very concerned about getting various camera angles for no good reason. But at the same time couldn't be bothered to make sure filming equipment wasn't in frame half the time. No hate on the person or people who filmed it and tossed it up. maybe they were not invested. maybe they haven't done much in the way of editing or recording. I was trying to be nice. I left a three word comment that expressed my discontent so that perhaps someone responsible for it would see it, take it on board and do better in the future. Your comment three weeks after the fact is what brought me back to elaborate.

@SzymczykProductions

Жыл бұрын

@@The1Helleri lmfao you need help 🧐

I wonder how it feels to have wasted your life with 'Silly Efforts To Investigate'?

@mickec5245

Жыл бұрын

Eppur si muove

They see pure pornography, let's be real about it hahaha 🤣

Why are this discussions so dumbed down? This chanels audience has got 80% of this videos informaton learned by heart from other videos...

The one over the US military base the size of a football field is a great concern. There's a few things we should be doing in detection locally instead of looking out into the abyss. Maybe the giant tear in the magnetic field might give an indication of an anomaly or a large quantity of a material that can interfere with the magnetosphere. We are ants in comparison, and whatever they are here for we are not in that plan. (No one look at the spy balloons, and no one ask why they used heat seeking missiles for balloons. 😂) Sorry buddy, but they aren't friendly or idealistic, love the hope of good intentions. Probably the best comparison is Columbus going to America, except in this case they might like change a few things to the environment, or even our DNA through virus manipulation. The absolute shitstorm in US politics happening in the capital over information coming out and protection of whistleblowers on this subject. The one terrifying thought is that if they can jam sensors (which is a capacity already demonstrated on video publicly) they most likely already have access to our internet and communication systems. Our computer systems, technology, would be a blip in the ocean.

1st

I always thought seti was for real. This is just propaganda

they see slaves................................................nothing more......nothing less