This youth orchestra delivers with more verve than many professionals! One violinist has a violin that sang like a flute, first I thought was a flute but then heard flute player later. A very talented group!

I am a 67 year old musician myself and I cannot tell you how much joy it gives me to hear and see these very talented beautiful young people play with such dedication inthis wonderful symphony. Yes, it makes me cry, I confess....

Though not as popular as the 2nd I think this is Rachmaninov’s best symphony but of course all 3 are master works. Great playing by this very talented young orchestra, they are wonderful 😊

@peterpickguitar

3 жыл бұрын

I'm ranking my listening of symphonies and although this is my first listen, I gave this one a 7 on 10. Rachs 2nd for me is a 10 on 10. Mind you my ranking is based on emotional feel and not on any other technicalities. As a reference, I ranked Shostakovich symphony #5 9 on 10. There's so many symphonies and so little time :)

Überwältigend: Das Werk, der Dirigent, das Orchester, alle!

The wonderfully inventive Rachmaninov, so different in each of the five symphonic works (Youth symphonic movement, Nos. 1-3, the Symphonic Dances, which is really no.4), here gathering new energy and verve in this magnificent work, so stunningly played here.

Love that he did not slow down the ending as so many do.

I have an eternal question! Why does Rachmaninoff's music reach into my heart and bring instant tears. What does this melancholy composer have in his nature to write music that "pulls at the heart" so effectively. This symphony is an absolute "well" of beauty and melancholy. The main theme of the 1st movement absolutely "knocks me out." Not fake tears but real tears of melancholy. Rachmaninoff is a timeless composer of authentic emotions that truly involve the "heart" of the person listening. Why is he so proficient at writing themes that involve the "heart and feelings" of the listener? This is an eternal question!

@jonathanteller6550

2 жыл бұрын

The main theme of the first and second movement are indeed the most beautiful themes Rachmaninoff has composed. To answer your question; he must have a deep emotional understanding of life born of much life experience. His music is simply an expression of this understanding. When we listen to his music, our heart hears it, not our head. That is why we break down. This music bypasses the defenses of our intellect.

@leoinsf

2 жыл бұрын

@@jonathanteller6550 Beautifully expressed!

@ronaldbeield7946

Жыл бұрын

I'll give my standard answer. This music was written by the hand of God, and Rachmaninov was just taking dictation

@leoinsf

Жыл бұрын

@@ronaldbeield7946 God bless!!!

@jesika7869

Жыл бұрын

There is a film on KZread about Rachmaninoff's life, "Harvest of Sorrow".

What a challenging piece for these young adults to perform - and they did it extremely well! You can tell they are not as experienced but some bright futures for these amazing musicians some day. Bravo!

Loving watching this group of young diverse musicians delivering this performance of another great symphonic work! Thank you!

Mov. I - 0:35 Mov. II - 17:13 Mov. III - 33:20 Спасибо!

@doyleperkins4916

3 жыл бұрын

Ilia, thank you.

@chroxify8913

3 жыл бұрын

Спасибо!!

@user-vv4oh5xk1w

2 жыл бұрын

Спасибо, но Mov. ||| - 29:40

@xkay-six1845

2 жыл бұрын

3rd movement is at 29:40

@user-vv4oh5xk1w

2 жыл бұрын

@@xkay-six1845 I say the same

Wonderfull young group, emotional I have never heard such a young orquestra playing so well, Gracias, Bravo

This is brilliant playing It is always something special, and an affirmation of life, to see extremely talented young musicians tackle masterpieces of the repertoire. There is all the freshness of youth, and energy and ambition, and delight in pure facility! None of the professional vanity of old and jaded hands. Whenever a great youth orchestra comes to play in London, at the Royal Festival Hall, or the Barbican or Royal Albert Hall, one or more of the sisterhood lady lovers and I, we grab some cheap sets, and let our hearts be ravished. Rachmaninov, with his Russian tendency to "Slavic melodrama, melancholy and damnation", and that quite opposite "psyche-embracing" deliciously-lush, post-romantic harmony (not an ounce of the tedious minimalism of Anton Webern - my goddess I'd rather sit chewing the program notes) seems very suited to an American orchestra. Like Copeland, Barber or Hanson or Korngold. In 1001 years, we must pray that whatever becomes of our human sensuous-comprehension, and our general social relations, and technical powers, we can still say that genius symphonic music played by eager and fresh young souls will seem ... like circles of blessed heaven within our dirty cynical world. Inshallah! Love andrea

Good to see more diverse group of people in classical music, hope it'll go in this direction.

@PeterLunowPL

2 жыл бұрын

my thought exactly!

What is more important than our youth dedicating themselves to such an endeavor, making the world better. Bravo beautiful!

This is A VERY RARE case of a gifted/taslented youth symphony orchestra just sounding SUPERB! Of course with R achmaninoff and his exqusite music he wrote any orchestra could make it sound pretty good.

@paullewis2413

4 жыл бұрын

‘Very rare” case? Not in my experience. Recently I heard a performance of Prokofiev’s 6th symphony by the students of the RAM/London which was mind blowing. Similarly Nielsen’s 4th symphony with students of the RCM/London of which I commented to one of the players that they sounded like a World class professional orchestra! I love the way this obviously gifted young conductor keeps the pace moving, so many conductors fall into the trap of overly sentimentalising Rachmaninov’s great music. This guy knows how to conduct Rach.!

@davebarclay4429

4 жыл бұрын

A VERY RARE case?? Really? Leaving aside why you feel the need to SHOUT, have a look at the National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain playing Messaien's Turangalila Symphony, one of the best performances of this hugely complex and difficult work you'll find anywhere. kzread.info/dash/bejne/dqlqr5tvdZuxqag.html

I much appreciate the repetition of the exposition in the first movement, that is quite often ignored by the conductors.

Que maravilla rachmaninof no me canso de oí sus sinfonias

Just Amazing

La había escuchado ya tenía un comentario ahora me doy cuenta que tiene partes como la segunda

Starting with the wrong sound! This is something new!

nice performence

Que linda esta sinfonia

@steveburrus9171

2 жыл бұрын

Please translate that.

I think it was Nielsen who said that having a harp in the orchestra is like having a hair in the soup! I don't agree with him.

Aunque me gusta más la segunda

Just like t he public reaction to his 1st symphony the public's--and some cri tics---opinion of his 3rd symohony was negative. I r eally don' t know why. It sounds wonderful to me. Poor Rachmaninov was misjudged.

@keybawd4023

2 жыл бұрын

Those who despised Rachmaninoffs music were intellectual snobs who couldn't accept the fact that he could write divine melodies.

@ronaldbeield7946

Жыл бұрын

He was never "misjudged". These so-called critics are sent to the ash heap of history, but Rachmaninov's music will live on forever.

@jesika7869

Жыл бұрын

"Pay no attention to critics. No one ever erected a statue to a critic." --- Jean Sibelius, Finnish composer

Orchestra corretta , ma con poco smalto. Tempi un po' allungati