FOR THE FULL WATCHALONG REACTION : www.patreon.com/user?u=66095054&fan_landing=true P.S I MEANT 180 guys I’m sorry

@Reshtarc

Жыл бұрын

This is the way we can treat our own..... Imagine the way we were to the Neanderthal. Extinction is human nature.

@christinegelabert1651

Жыл бұрын

You asked what is he doing in the beginning... when you saw the young boy and the other man in the opening scene. THAT is one of the prayers in Hebrew... you say it over food to bless the meal. It goes~Baruch Ata Adonai Eloheinu Melech Haolam. It means`Praised are you, Our God, Ruler of the Universe, Who has given us Life and sustained us and enabled us to reach this season ok? I CHOSE to be a NON Denominational prison Minister because of the fact that you have to branch out into MORE THAN just one belief system. I have studied and ALSO belonged to a few different religious paths, including Judaism at one point. It's so wild because I haven't practiced Judaism in OVER 40 years but every time I hear this on tv. I just automatically start to recite it inside of in my head at the same time. It's the same thing when I go to a high holy Catholic mass I'll sit there and be speaking a lot of the priests part in Latin along with the congregation responses. AT one time, don't laugh~I wanted to be a nun...yes a "penguin nun" who wears the black habit and wanted to live away from society NBA and live cloistered existence in a convent. There's other religious beliefs I've followed but it's always been the prayers that stay in my head... AND the music. #NYGenXBIKERLady

@Dov_ben-Maccabee

11 ай бұрын

Remember Raoul Wallenberg - another Righteous man.

Anyone who thinks this couldn’t happen again isn’t paying attention.

@jillk368

Жыл бұрын

Yeah. It is. When I think about why hatred against Jews started in the first place, I feel a little sick. All of this traces back to ancient monarchies that were so threatened by a religion that refused to worship them, they felt they had to demonize them to their nations. Monotheism traveling in little packs around the world is what started this. What propagates it is pure greed. Hatred and division means money and votes for politicians. We are all individuals, and should be valued as such. Sorry, didn't mean to ramble. But, yes, I hope people will get a clue soon. A look at Europe after WWII might do it.

@phillychick4196

Жыл бұрын

❤USA❤

@lisarainbow9703

Жыл бұрын

Precisely. *sigh*

@ehudnold9

Жыл бұрын

what do you mean killing jews?

@montist1

Жыл бұрын

Shout it from the mountains! It can happen

In our school in the Czech republic the teacher made us watch this in about the age of 10 years during history class. We were absolutely horrified. The teacher told us that these deeds are not to be ever forgotten, that this all happened in modern and civilized 20th century and that we youngsters must never allow to let happen things like these. A great teacher, I must say.

@robertcampomizzi7988

11 ай бұрын

My brother was 11 and I was 13 when this came out. Our parents took us to see it. Both families were in Italy at the time of the war and came to Canada not long after it. They wanted us to know what horrors had occurred and why it was wrong... Sometimes, words aren't enough. AMERICAN HISTORY X is another movie that has some similar teachings.. different setting but same kind of themes.

@christhornycroft3686

11 ай бұрын

I’m Canadian and we not only learned about the Holocaust in Social Studies 10 but we saw this movie in Film Studies the year after. I knew about it, but it was still shocking to me and terrible at 16. I think a lot of the kids fell asleep.

@mariannevontrapp1063

9 ай бұрын

Here to on the school progam, for 14 years old.

@charlievanilla

8 ай бұрын

I had this with the pianist i was so horrified in cinema. I was too young…

@daedalron

4 ай бұрын

10 - 11 years old is too soon for this movie. Spielberg himself made the "girl in red" actress swear she wouldn't watch it before being 18. She broke that promise, and watched it at 11. She was traumatized and blamed her parents for having let her play in the movie. It's only years later that she understood the importance of that movie, and felt proud to have been in it.

This movie is very hard to watch, but it's something everyone needs to see. The historical importance of this film is second to none.

@watchwithjayy

Жыл бұрын

I agree

@CBGB_1977

Жыл бұрын

It’s awful how some people deny the holocaust. History not learned will repeat.

@missydehart6920

Жыл бұрын

Agreed

@skyshroudsylvan6022

Жыл бұрын

My wife and I are going to watch this movie tonight, upon my request. I've never watched the movie, nor has she. I've watched a lot of reactions to it. All of them made me cry. History is important for us to be better, for the future. Too many people assume, instead of talking on neutral ground. There's a lot of lost truths, too many lost lives, and awful crime.

@tracyglennmurray

Жыл бұрын

Exactly.

We complain about how difficult this is to watch. Imagine actually having to live through it. It's one thing to examine the atrocities of war and genocide through an intellectual lens. As if it were some abstract concept. Movies like this help the message hit home on a far deeper level.

@Buphelous

Жыл бұрын

Imma stop you when you lying but you telling the truth so keep going

@timdyer5903

Жыл бұрын

​@@Buphelousgenocides are real buddy. Go travel the world a bit more.

@Buphelous

Жыл бұрын

@@timdyer5903 Reread what i said

Spielberg has said in interviews that he had to tone down the depiction of Amon Goethe from what he was REALLY like because he was concerned that the audience would think it was too extreme and unbelievable, so he "toned it down." Let that sink in. The reality was SO much worse than what was depicted.

@LlamaLlamaMamaJama

Жыл бұрын

I Googled Amon Geoth… and absolutely believe this

@sbtopel

Жыл бұрын

@@LlamaLlamaMamaJama My mind just can't grasp that level of evil within a single human being.

@Patrickbatemanharvard

Жыл бұрын

90% of the Germans at that time hated jews, they wanted them extinct. They didn't had any regrets back then and many at the time of trail told that they would do it again if they have to.. And also remind that, there are remnants of them left in Denmark, Germany, United States and Russia..

@ForgottenHonor0

Жыл бұрын

Amon Goethe was literally so psychotic that even fellow SS officers wouldn't put up with his shit and he was kicked out of the organization! Let THAT sink in!

@sbtopel

Жыл бұрын

@Nick Craig I had not heard that before. Explains why he was in the sanitarium when they arrested him before his execution!

You can keep all of those Taken films Liam but you will never top that last scene when you said "I could of got more" that performance was gold standard.

@kevtb874

Жыл бұрын

That's one of my favourite acting scenes ever commited to film. Hits me somewhere deep every time. The other is De Niro punching the wall in Raging Bull. Just insane. The power of what acting can bring forward.

Ralph Fiennes, the actor who played Amon Goeth, played the character so well, and looked enough like him, that one of the actual survivors (I believe it was Helen, Goethe’s “maid”) was on set and had a full fledged panic attack upon seeing him. Ralph immediately broke character to help comfort her. ❤❤❤ I know this is a very painful watch. But it is important to remember that even within the darkest moments in life, darker than most people could even imagine, you can always find moments of light and love. And it’s those small moments where the light shows itself, that it’s still there, just forced into hiding, that gives us hope and helps keep us moving forward. Even the fact that couples were still getting married while in the camps brings tears to my eyes. Love truly is a powerful and persistent little bugger ☺️

@HK--nf1sc

4 ай бұрын

It was Mila Pfefferberg who met Mr. Fiennes.

The child in the Red coat symbolizes indifference and cruelty in plain sight.

@solvingpolitics3172

Жыл бұрын

It was based on a true story of a father who saw his daughter in a recognizable jacket disappear into a line for the gas chamber. Each time he looked over she became more & more obscure until she disappeared forever.

@lacm64

Жыл бұрын

This broke my heart.

@greggthompson959

Жыл бұрын

She also reminded me of Anne Frank--one obscure girl spoke for a generation. I think her red coat represented blood, the blood of the innocent--that the Jewish people were innocent.

One of the most important movies made in the last century. It's a tough, but necessary watch. We still feel the pain of those lost in the Holocaust.

This movie makes me cry EVERY time! Sobbing, gasping, red faced crying.

@watchwithjayy

Жыл бұрын

It got me bad at one point it wasn’t included in this reaction but I was shaking

@geminiacleo7ewe

Жыл бұрын

@@watchwithjayy It breaks my heart, knowing all his businesses failed and he died broke.

@Michalyist

Жыл бұрын

​@geminiacleo7ewe if it makes you feel better, the people who saved made sure he was never broke. His dying wish was to be barried in Israel, and he was. His grave is at the mount of Olives in Jerusalem. May he rest in peace

@geminiacleo7ewe

Жыл бұрын

@@Michalyist it... kinda does...🙂

@jonathanmoon86

Жыл бұрын

Not to change the subject, but what is so amazing about Spielberg is Jurassic Park came out the same year. Incredible director!

Back in the late-90's, when I was a teenager, they played this movie on TV uncut with no commercials, just an intermission or two, if I remember correctly. My mother made us two older kids watch it with her while she explained throughout what was going on and why. This movie changed me. I had known about the Holocaust by this time, but only in a history book. Seeing it played out and knowing it only touched the surface on how awful it really was, I went to bed that night and didn't go to sleep. I just kept thinking about what I just watched. It was my first look into just what humans are truly capable of.

The shower scene : they expected deadly gas streaming out of it as it was intended, but for this special time only - it was water indeed. That´s why they´re so relieved. Imagine such horror.

@mimikurtz2162

2 ай бұрын

It was not "for this special time only", it was routine. On arrival, the transported jews were selected for either labour or 'special treatment'. Most of those fit for work showered and got uniforms while those earmarked for 'special treatment' went to the gas chambers.

Another very powerful WWII movie is, "Life is Beautiful", which is not quite as dark as this was. I highly recommend it, it won the Oscar for Best Picture the year it came out...

@skullslace2426

Жыл бұрын

Thogh the ending breaks you just as much. Jeez, that film did so much to my class when we were watching it, probably because of how lighthearted the first half is.

I'm not sure if it's already been said but the women putting blood on their faces wasn't for makeup. It was said that they would look more lively for the medical inspection and not be sent to death.

Oscar always cared he could not afford to show that he did. It was dangerous to his family as well as him. As the war went on he became more emotional about their lives. Imagine some one today saying the holocaust was not about race.

@Annonymous0283745

Жыл бұрын

You mean like Whoopi?

@drbubonic4942

Жыл бұрын

But you specifically in this generation shouldn't get brownie points for not even living in it

@popejaimie

Жыл бұрын

​@@drbubonic4942 no one should get "brownie points" for surviving genocide, not sure what you're trying to say anyway

@melsangelbard

Жыл бұрын

​@@Annonymous0283745 she didn't say it was not about race...she said it WASNT only Bout race... It wS an ETHINC cleansing not a racial one as Jew are white...The Nazis killed Jews, Black's, Romani people, Homosexuals and disabled people.

@donl1846

11 ай бұрын

Unfortunately "indoctrination, propaganda and hate" is happening again on a world-wide level. We have not learned and it is the fault of governments and its agencies that are the root of this

The end song with the survivors walking and at the grave is "Yerushalayim Shel Zahav" (Jerusalem of Gold) because that's where he's buried--Jerusalem. After he failed at businesses, the people he rescued supported him financially and arranged for his burial in Israel, where most of them ended up.

@daustin8888

8 ай бұрын

The only National Socialist buried in Jerusalem

@meggo329

7 ай бұрын

Pray for the Holocaust survivors that were kidnapped by Hamas

@ninjacat4929

5 ай бұрын

​@@meggo329I certainly do pray for them !

In my country, we are shown this film as part of the curriculum in school. It was a hard but important lesson for young people to understand and see what happened as to not let history repeat itself. Truly heart breaking.

@mossbresnahan3072

Жыл бұрын

What country?

@smp6565

Жыл бұрын

@@mossbresnahan3072 Switzerland

@mossbresnahan3072

Жыл бұрын

@@smp6565 Great country! Have you been to latterbrunnen or grimmewald?

@emilianosintarias7337

Жыл бұрын

did they mention that it had repeated already?

@smp6565

Жыл бұрын

@@mossbresnahan3072 thank you 😊ive never been to grindelwald but its very beautiful

I love Ben Kingsley in this film.His character is the conscience and the heart of it.

@OriginalPuro

Жыл бұрын

Sir Ben Kingsley is a master actor, period.

@MeTheMayo

Жыл бұрын

He also played the father of Anne Frank very well in a movie adaption about her

@azharmomin1

Жыл бұрын

His Oscar winning "GANDHI" was the epitome of his acting, NO CAP!

Actually, the scene with the water coming down on the women, they were happy that it was water, a shower, and not the gas they were expecting that would have killed them. That reality of never knowing when something good or bad was going to happen to them was one of the most stressful things they endured.

I'ts a brave thing to watch this alone for the first time I watched this when it first came out. We had never seen anything like it before. The cinema was stunned into silence throughout the film. Just as it was right at the end. i still feel the same way to this day.

Saw this in the theater when I was a Senior in H.S. with friends. We had a 30 mile drive home and not one of us said a thing the entire time.

@anavilhanas

Жыл бұрын

O filme foi reapresentado nos cinemas no Brasil em um festival sobre o Spielberg. Eu revi no cinema de novo depois de 30 anos. Quando o filme acabou ninguém se levantou por 5 minutos e ninguém disse uma palavra também.

@trumphatesyou

Жыл бұрын

@@anavilhanas sorry man I only took 2 years of Spanish.

This has not stopped, in Rwanda, Uganda, Sierra Leone,Bosnia, Iraq, Syria, Georgia, now in Ukraine. Genocide is an on going issue.

@zunbake3

Жыл бұрын

Don't forget about Cambodia and Pol Pot's Killing Fields of the Khmer Rouge!

@kalleluukkainen43

3 ай бұрын

I served in Bosnia, 1997-1999. It was not so plesent. Ofcourse i was the one who wanted to go there.

@mimikurtz2162

2 ай бұрын

Not Ukraine. Russia's aim is to conquer Ukraine and force the population to be Russian, not to exterminate them all.

Big props to you Jayy and God bless you for reviewing this important piece of History. 🙏😌 'Those who don't know their history are destined to repeat it." long with the near genocide of native people, this is an important lesson in why we must always speak up against racism in all it's forms. Here is what white supremecy leads to. The man who plays the accountant is Ben Kingsley, who plays the part of Ghandi, in a film by the same name. Ghandi influenced dr. M. L. King's approach of nonviolence. Thank you.💞 You are a beautiful person and the world can use more like you.

@michaelpalmer7954

Жыл бұрын

Yep. Dr. Arnold Fruchtenbaum has many You Tube videos on end times. The Footsteps of the Messiah: Revised 2020 Edition byDr. Arnold Fruchtenbaum 5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent reference source and scripturally accurate Reviewed in the United States on March 17, 2023 Verified Purchase This is not 'light reading', but it is a must-have for true Christians who want to understand the plans from before the foundation of the earth that God has revealed for all who know Christ. Dr. Fruchtenbaum is a brilliant and highly respected Messianic Jew who is both a faithful theologian and thorough eschatologist. I keep a copy of this book on my nightstand and often reference it when something comes to mind, especially as we see prophecy unfolding in these last days. I have gladly recommended this book to friends and have purchased a couple as gifts for those who I know will really appreciate it. Make sure to get the latest edition as the author has updated a couple of points...our understanding gets clearer as we draw closer to Jesus's soon return! Maranatha!

@michaelpalmer7954

Жыл бұрын

Yes. Search for Dr. Arnold Fruchtenbaum on here.

@CBGB_1977

Жыл бұрын

Yes, precisely. Long before the holocaust there was the trail of tears. These very ugly moments in history must be remembered and taught as a requirement. White washing history as some states are currently doing is only a detriment to the young. Ignorance leads to intolerance and entitlement which is so very dangerous to our humanity and society.

@davidbroz6755

Жыл бұрын

I am a white male, educated, European... I know the feeling of superiority. Thank God He opened my eyes. It is so easy to be blinded and live in the false pride that I have a "better" color, gender, education, citizenship, nationality, culture, values, religion... A person is not bad because he is white or black, male or female... It's so very easy to be a fool and believe lies. When circumstances change and external inhibitions disappear, then people lose their masks and turn into beasts. That's why the world is the way it is.

@joaniewaller6504

Жыл бұрын

Did you watch the movie the Killing fields or Hotel Rwanda? That was the same and not from white supremacy . ALL people are capable of letting the Anti -christ in their heads and hearts. Guard it your eternity depends on it.

A MOVIE THAT SHOULD NOT EVER BE FORGOTTON IN THIS LIFETIME, OR ANY FUTURE LIFETIME!

@OriginalPuro

Жыл бұрын

No need to scream, we're adults here.

I've seen this film a dozen times or more. And each time, I end up sobbing by the end of it.

Wonderful reaction Jayy! As others have stated, this is a movie everyone should see! Don't worry about the emotions and the tears. I assure you, you were not crying alone. Thanks for doing this masterpiece!

It floors me how the real stories are so much more horrific than any fiction. No author could devise a more traumatic scenario.

I can find out everything I want to know about a person by watching this movie with them. Your a brave and empathetic person to be vulnerable enough to react to this. SUBSCRIBED

@OriginalPuro

Жыл бұрын

"I can find out everything I want to know about a person by watching this movie with them." I think you are under the spell of the Dunning-Kruger effect.

This is a remarkable, important, terrifying, horrifying, beautiful movie. I just have to remember that scene with the ring to cry to this day. Glad u got to see it.

My aunt was a prisoner in one of the labor camps during the war..... My family thought she was dead and had to cross all of Germany in secret to return home ( by foot , horse ) ..... My family didn't recognize hem the day she finally arrived home.

My poor sweet girl. 😢 Sometimes there are things I don’t want you to know. You see the experiences because they assist in your edification but “knowing things” hurts sometimes. Know that I wished I was there to share it with you, sister. All my love to you…

I read an interview Spielberg did after the movie came out. He mentioned the girl in the red coat. He said a father said as the Nazis separated the people his wife and son disappeared from his view quickly, but his little girl had the red coat on and he saw her standing out because of that. He got to watch her till she finally disappeared. So freaking sad.

Oskar came to Poland to profit from the war, and he made a fortune. He spent every cent saving Jews from the Holocaust, and died broke. He's recognized by Israel as a Righteous Gentile, and is buried in Jerusalem. The final scenes are the people he saved that were still alive, and the actors who played them in the film visiting his grave there. Leaving the pepple is a Jewish custom of respect. He was a flawed man who faced with the unimaginable, did the right thing in the end. As terrible as the history is, it gives me hope that there will always be people who do stand up and do the right thing, no matter what it costs.

When Schindler sees the body of the girl with the red coat-- you're watching, in real time, a piece of his soul dying. 😭

The water was actually a relief-- they were in there to be gassed. History has everything to tell us... and have to listen. Thank you for your reaction.

@mimikurtz2162

2 ай бұрын

No, they were NOT in there to be gassed; as new workers they were in there to be washed and deloused. They only FEARED that they were about to be gassed. A giveaway is that they had room to move. If they were there to be gassed they would have been packed without an inch to spare so that the humidity from their combined breath would release gas from the poison crystals more quickly.

I think that you missed the girl in the red coat was one of the bodies being exhumed and burnt at the camp - Schindler saw, remembered her and decided to take the last step and create his list.

How anyone can deny that this tragic horrific event happened less than 100 years ago. History repeats if we don't learn from it. We must never forget

At the beginning, Oskar only saw opportunity... by the end he saw nothing but humanity...

The little girl in the red coat is not a memory of schindlers. She is a memory of the actress Aurdrey Hepburns who spoke of seeing a little girl through the darkness and screaming bodies was this beautiful little girl. What Aurdrey Hepburn couldn't shake was the look on her face cause with adults screaming shouting there she was with a look on her face that seemed that she had accepted her fate as she was passed onto a train by a nazi officer. Stephen Spielberg wanted to pay his respects to this little girl by putting her in the film so she will never be forgotten even tho nobody knows her name.

A true masterpiece. The shot near the end where it transitions from black and white to color with the real people is among the greatest moments ever in film

It was hard to see you so upset, Jayy, but this movie is a must-watch, as others have said. The first time watching it is always a shock to the system. I hate to make you feel even worse, but I think you were talking about how humiliating the shower scene was. Actually, when Jews were sent into the concentration camp showers like that, they were normally gassed instead of showered, so the water coming down was actually a relief!

I’ve said this before but you have the most genuine, and beautiful reactions on KZread! I’ve watch so very many reactions here I can’t think of anyone else who is more uniquely enjoyable to watch here. You have a gift in relating to others! God bless you and thank you for the lovely reaction!

I read in a comment in one of this movie's other reactions that the "girl in the red coat" was a reference to the trial of Adolph Eichmann (one of the master planner of the Final Solution) that the father couldn't recognize any of his family at the camp except for his little girl that was in a redcoat

Wonderful reaction. I’m glad you could appreciate the horror of this in all its magnitude. One correction though: Schindler never, ever disliked Jews. He grew up with them as a child. He just joined the Nazi Party because of the business opportunities, and at that time, he had no idea of the cruel treatment Jews were going to be exposed to. So he didn’t all of a sudden do a 180 (not 360!), because he had a good heart all along.

@daedalron

4 ай бұрын

I wouldn't go so far as to say he had a good heart. The man was totally fine with war profiteering and slave labor. He wasn't a sadistic psychopath, though, unlike the SS. He looks like a good man because he lived at a time and place where he was surrounded by absolute evil men.

He wasn’t working with an underground resistance group or anything. He solely went off based on what his conviction told him to do. To do the right thing.

has a certain positive irony that Amon Göth's granddaughter is half black.Due to family circumstances, the grandchild initially grew up in a home but was regularly visited by the grandmother. Amon Göth's daughter could never really come to terms with her father's fate, in which her parents played a very negative role.

It might sound just unbelievable, but Amon Goeths grandchild is actually a black woman (-->Jennifer Teege)!! She had no idea about her family because she was adopted. One day she went into a library, took a random book out of the shelf, and on this random book cover there was a a small picture of an old woman on the cover. By browsing threw this book, she finds out that it was the story about her cruel grandfather.

The girl Amon was sleeping with wasn't Helen. It was his wife. He was married and had a daughter at the time this was happening. She didn't know about what her father was until this movie came out. She wrote a book about the experience of finding out her father was a bloodthirsty monster.

@joshuah9109

Жыл бұрын

I wanna read that book!

@Serai3

Жыл бұрын

@@joshuah9109 I went back and looked, and it turns out I was a little off. Amon's daughter, Monica Hertwig, detailed her experience in the documentary film "Inheritance". It was her half-black daughter, Jennifer Teege, who wrote the book titled "My Grandfather Would Have Shot Me". Both of them grapple with the effects of having such a monster in their family tree, with Jennifer's story having the added issue of Nazi racist ideology added in.

@daedalron

4 ай бұрын

It wasn't his wife. His wife lived in Vienna with their 2 kids. The woman in the bed was his mistress, Ruth Kalder. The daughter you're talking about, Monica Hertwig, was born from that mistress.

Never forget what humans are capable of. Human nature doesn't change.

When thinking of the people the Reich murdered…the loss of generations of people…who they would have been…how different the world may have been had they not been stolen from life…it’s breathtaking. It’s soo hard to watch, but the importance of remembering and not forgetting the depths of depravity humans can sink to…we must NEVER forget and always have the uncomfortable conversations. There aren’t enough words to say for the souls lost. Thank you for your reaction. The importance of watching and learning is paramount.

The soundtrack is absolutely beautiful. Those violins sound like they’re weeping.

That’s a rough movie to watch, but such an important film. I’m glad you had your emotional support bear with you!

17 of my family members were murdered in the Holocaust. Thank you for honoring their memories. May we never forget.

the little girl in the red coat can be seen lying in the pile of dead bodies, as she is carted off to be burned with the rest of them... my interpretation of it is that it represents both for the audience and for Schindler a moment of connection... the realisation that that specific person that you have taken notice of is now dead, makes it more impactful than staring at a hundred nameless faces. I thank you for having watched this movie. Watching reactors channels has become something of a hobby for me, and whenever this movie pops up, I make a point of sharing the experience. It's a movie that every person should watch, as part of their school curriculum (back when I was in school, when it came out, it was indeed watched pretty much by everybody)... it saddens me that many reactors, especially americans, often don't realise until the end that this is not a fictional story, that Schindler was a real person. Luckily, this was not the case with you... we all have burdens, and we all struggle with discrimination for many different reasons and in many different circumstances. I for one, don't wear the source of it on my skin like you do, so in that sense I have an advantage.. but these things cut deep nonetheless. Being confronted with such a dark page in history is a lesson we all must go through... we must not forget... but eventually, I fear we will. the people who lived through this war are almost all gone now, only a few remain. Listen to their stories, and carry them over to your children... show them this movie when they are old enough to understand....maybe the lesson will not be lost on them.,, whether it's about their own people or those sat next to them on the bus.

I just want to give Jayy a hug!!

@jillk368

Жыл бұрын

Jayy, you have a big heart. Thank you for reacting to this. I know it's a tough movie to watch. The person that gets me the most in the last scene, at Schindler's grave, is Emile Schindler, her facial expression. I feel like she never fell out of love with him, or maybe she just loved him as a friend, but that Mona Lisa smile she gives toward his grave just tugs my heart; I feel like only she and he would understand it. Schindler was a man who seemed to have no idea how big his own heart was until it was put to the test. I wish he could have lived to see this film. I'm glad Emile did, as she was part of it too. Oskar Schindler certainly did make a name for himself, and I personally will never forget it. Bless his memory always. Thanks again, Jayy. All the best to you.

@jillk368

Жыл бұрын

I feel like the girl in red was the first individual person that seemed to catch Schindler's attention. Seeing her in the other scene, where she caught his eye again, I think, was symbolic as to what changed his heart, though it was also in progress before this. But that seems like a poignant moment where his understanding caught up with his underlying feelings.

My mama lived under Nazi occupation in Yugoslavia. I heard some true horror stories.

I wish that more people had your empathy for such a horrific event. That said, the movie is extremely difficult to watch for anyone with a soul. But... it is a movie that I believe every human on earth should have to watch.

Oscars breakdown: I haven't seen anyone not cry at this moment. Not a single person

“Build it like she said” is the absolute punchline of the movie. So dark.

@daedalron

4 ай бұрын

Though that specific scene was altered for the movie. It didn't happen like that in real life, the architect was smart enough to know not to go to Goeth. Instead, she was executed as the scapegoat when part of a constructed building collapsed, after the german supervisor of the construction put the blame on her. Also, she was an engineer from the university of Lviv, not Milan. My guess is that they altered it in the movie to show how the SS didn't tolerate any educated jew who would dare to talk back to them.

I was crying right along with you, Jayy. A really heavy film. Be well and stay strong.

Joseph Rabe is another Schindler like figure who is still celebrated in China today for saving hundreds of lives in Nanking. "City of war" is a powerful film relating his actions, proving some members of the nazi party were still human beings. He even tried to petition Hitler to intervene in trying to stop Japan's war crimes in the city. Predictably little came of it, but it gives Hope that even those who allied themselves to murderous ideologies can recognize when that ideology is unworthy.

In case no one else pointed it out, it looked like you missed the fact that when they were digging up the bodies to burn them, that little girl in a red coat was amongst the bodies.

When he was on horseback overlooking the scene of the shooting going on below , was when the monstrous magnitude of what was happening to the Jews struck him .

Instant sub. You were not ready. It changes a person. So glad it's being viewed by your generation.

The little girl in the red coat being ignored represents the Jews suffering being ignored by the world

@watchwithjayy

Жыл бұрын

Oh I guess I seen it wrong I took it as a symbol of the innocent lives that was taken by the nazis. the red to me represented the blood spilled (the murders ,deaths etc) and the child represented the innocence (how they were killed brutally when they didn’t deserve it ). Thank you for sharing this

@pangkaji

Жыл бұрын

@@watchwithjayy at least Stephen Spielberg said so in the 25th anniversary of the movie. He was interviewed by NBC's Lester Holt. However, to one each own. Anybody can make their own interpretation. There was a conference in Evian, France in 1938 attended by 32 countries to discuss the Jewish refugee plight. There were efforts to get attendee countries to admit more refugees. Other European countries, Latin American countries and Australia to take more in. Attendee countries showed sympathy but none took more in. The Australian delegate said "we don't have a Jewish problem and we are not going to start one now".

You "got it" sister... I loved watching you understand this. So many reactors don't. God bless you!

I watched it once ten years ago. I still cannot watch it again. Just clips still make me cry.

Perfect description, EVIL AND you had me over here crying with you 😢

A great great reaction. Glad I found your channel. If I may suggest one thing for viewers like me on the iPhone without headphones: the movie audio to be lowered and yours raised! Love it.

Jayy, I'm sorry you feel so bad but this did happen and always remember it so it never happens again. PS my sweets, it's a 180, a 360 would mean he ended up back where he started, a complete about face is a 180. Love ya, take care!

The survivor s and actors who play these are real people ❤

The worst thing is, people don‘t learn from our (german) history. A lot of countries getting more and more nationalistic.

@eq1373

Жыл бұрын

Nationalism has been around for centuries. That doesn't equate to Nazism

@m.r4841

Жыл бұрын

@@eq1373 Nationalism is a key characteristic of Nazism and it can very easily lead to Nazism.

@charlievanilla

8 ай бұрын

@@m.r4841No it was feeling the superiority of the Nation over other ones.

@m.r4841

8 ай бұрын

@@charlievanilla Yes, racism was also an important part. But one doesn't exclude the other. There were many characteristics

@chrisstorm3804

Ай бұрын

Nothing wrong with nationalism. To care for your nation and people.

*According to me 2 most heartbreaking scenes ever in world cinema.* 😭😭 *1. (**43:36** to **45:55**) on Schindler's List.* *2. When Amitabh Bachchan died in "Sholay 1975".* *I am 100% sure that even a stone hearted person will cry after seeing these 2 scenes.* *Nothing can match these scenes in world cinema in terms of most emotional heartbreak scenes.*

Your reaction was so beautiful and heart felt!❤️❤️

The movie pointed out not just the hate but the level of hate for the Jews. It's heartbreaking and extremely uncomfortable to watch but a true masterpiece.

So many things I took from watching this masterpiece of education back in sixth grade that was 22 years ago. The girl in red representing innocence and seeing her dead representing the death of that innocence. Learning what happens when hate and prejudice goes unchecked and not called out could lead to. That some of the survivors who saw amon goeth actor had ptsd episodes because he reminded them of so much of goeth. The real amon goeth was way more brutal in real life and Spielberg had to pull back on some of his character because he didn't think anyone would have believed the monster he truly was. Lastly the ignorance of today's generation making comparisons of the holocaust/shoah to anything be it corona,abortion, animal slaughter houses, are completely full of it knowing all of that doesn't even scratch the surface of what the shoah survivors went through.

This is a hard but essential watch! Remember and don't ever let it happen again!

Amon Goeth (Ralph Fiennes character) was far crueler than the movie portrays. This is how prisoner Joseph Bau (Prisoner Number 69084) described Goeth: “A hideous and terrible monster who reached the height of more than two meters. He set the fear of death in people, terrified masses, and accounted for much chattering of teeth. He ran the camp through extremes of cruelty that are beyond the comprehension of a compassionate mind - employing tortures which dispatched his victims to hell. For even the slightest infraction of the rules, he would rain blow after blow upon the face of the helpless offender and would observe with satisfaction born of sadism, how the cheek of his victim would swell and turn blue, how the teeth would fall out and the eyes would fill with tears. Anyone who was being whipped by him was forced to count in a loud voice, each stroke of the whip and if he made a mistake was forced to start counting over again. During interrogations, which were conducted in his office, he would set his dog on the accused, who was strung by his legs from a specially placed hook in the ceiling. In the event of an escape from the camp, he would order the entire group from which the escapee had come, to form a row, would give the order to count ten, and would, personally kill every tenth person. At one morning parade, in the presence of all the prisoners he shot a Jew, because, as he complained, the man was too tall. Then as the man lay dying he urinated on him. Once he caught a boy who was sick with diarrhea and was unable to restrain himself. Goeth forced him to eat all the excrement and then shot him”. Spielberg said they had to tone the character down for fear it would not be believed.

I am from Germany thats a Part of our history

I’ve watched many, many KZreadrs react to this movie. And, to me, yours was the purest. I witnessed seeing your heart break. You are a good soul.

@watchwithjayy

4 ай бұрын

Wow, thank you!

The girl in the red coat is when Oskar Schindler stops ignoring what's around him and Starts doing something about it that's when his humanity wakes up.

I remember when leaving the movie theater, there was complete silence. No one said anything.

Powerful Movie & Reaction Jayy - this one cuts deep 😢

I remember watching this at the cinema when first released..i never came out with so many viewers totally silent trying to take in what they had just seen...an absolute sobering wonderful film which needs to be shown to younger generations to show how low humanity can sink ..and learn what pure racism can lead to

@kathynicholson103

Жыл бұрын

I saw it in the theater, too. I could hear people sobbing, and all the women ran to the bathroom immediately afterward.

@davidsavage5630

Жыл бұрын

I saw it in the theater when I was 12. Questionable parenting decision maybe but I don't remember being bored or lost during any of it. Just....speechless. I do remember saying that how gleefully Spielberg showed Nazis being killed in the Indiana Jones movies makes more sense now and I did not mean that as a joke in the slightest. All the sudden the end of Raiders made perfect sense how the swastika burned off of the crate and how the villains were on the receiving end of the literal Wrath of God. Because if they were involved in what I saw in Schindler's List they deserved nothing less than the wrath of God..

Some scenes were not shot at all. Goeths crimes were so cruel, sadistic and inhumane that the producers thought the viewers might perceive them as constructed only for the film, thus damaging the whole work. I am German and the so-called "German culture of remembrance" is a matter of course in our country. Every day, for example, there are documentaries on at least two channels which show among other things the background of how Hitler was able to lever out parliament to come to power, the crimes of the GESTAPO (Secret state police) in their torture cellars, the deportation of the Jews, underlaid with original images from the concentration camps, the cruelest war crimes of the SS, which followed the Wehrmacht on the campaign and then brought unimaginable suffering to the rest of the population, which was also filmed at the time. (Some already in color, which makes the whole thing seem even more bizarre). Trenches, on the edges of which Jews were killed by the hundreds with shots to the neck, etc., etc., etc. There are also "Stepstones". Small memorial plaques laid in the ground, so-called Stolpersteine, are intended to commemorate the fate of people who were persecuted, murdered, deported, expelled or driven to suicide during the National Socialist era. The square brass plaques with rounded corners and edges are inscribed with letters hammered in by hand using a hammer and hammer letters, showing e.g. who was deported in that house. They are usually set into the sidewalk or surface of the respective sidewalk at the same level in front of the last freely chosen homes of Nazi victims. On December 29, 2019 the 75,000th Stepstone was laid in Memmingen. In the German extermination camps, the women and children were gassed first, so that no more Jews could be born and grow up. Very few Germans wanted to have known about the concentration camps, which of course was complete nonsense. For example, thousands of apartments were suddenly vacant because the Jewish residents had been deported during the night. The very next day, "Aryan" Germans, mostly belonging to the party cadre, moved in. Then hundreds of civilian German guards were employed in the death camps, who were even proud of their "work" and bragged about it to their acquaintances and friends. I could give many more examples, which prove that it was total bullshit, when it was claimed not to have seen anything and not to know what was happening there. In any case, I am a little proud of the fact that in Germany, even more than 75 years after the war, these unimaginable crimes against humanity have been and are being dealt with.

15:34 i would play dead too

GREAT reaction to a VERY IMPORTANT film. You did so welll. Thank you. (Just a minor detail: I know you meant he did a "180°" - A "360°" would just be the same (well it does not matter...).)

I saw this in theaters when it came out so many years ago. I think I cried the entire time. I know my cheeks were wet, and every now and again I was startled almost out of a scene when a cold drop of moisture hit my collar bone...I hadn't realized I was crying until then.... I've watched so many reactions... One thing I remember sharply I don't think I've ever seen anyone ever mention. .... all those headstones that had been laid out as if they were bricks to "pave" a road... I remember the black and white video of vehicle tires rolling over the "cobble stone" puzzle pieces of headstones laid out to make a road. ... I am sickened at the thought of does it still exist? It can't be taken up...to PROVE it happened it has to still be there.... But that road has to be blocked off so no one can drive across it ever again It's such a stupid thing to remember from this movie ... this drama "documentary" ... thank you for sharing your pain of seeing WW II as more than chapters of annoyance in our High School History classes.

You should have had that reaction over what Whopsie Goldturd (the View) said about the Holocaust.

Very good reaction. This is one of the hardest movies to watch and react to but it is so important to keep in the public memory like this. We always have to be watchful and make sure the road we're going down doesn't turn into something like this again. It didn't start with death camps and killings after all. Steven Spielberg said that he had to tone down the horrors of what reality was for the general public to watch because what really happened was too unbelievable.

Hats off, not an easy movie to watch, but necessary. The violence was actually toned down from the reality of it. The scary part is realizing they weren't some faceless monster but regular people doing monstrous things

@AliceBunny05

6 ай бұрын

The violence was VASTLY toned down. The movie is mostly about schindler, not about the worst atrocities of the nazi's because in that regard it does not even come close.

Just an interesting fact: Those mass showers they had in the camps were also used as the gas rooms aswell. They combined the two so people wouldnt rebel everytime they were processed for gassing due the likely hood of taking a shower instead so the tention grows old and fades away.

This was the Holocaust. A span of about 5 to 6 years. This is history that must be remembered.

@m.r4841

Жыл бұрын

It's actually about 12 years

Thank you for watching this one, everyone should watch it at least once as an adult, so we know what it was just a bit.

My family left Europe before this, so we were safe in America. But relatives who stayed were slaughtered. That is the only Holocaust site I have actually seen in person...the place where 5000 Jews, some my relatives, were machine gunned to death in one day. It is a VERY long grassy field. Walking along that field really drove home what it meant to shoot 5000 people in one day. It took forever to walk that distance. I wish "Never again" was real. But it is just an ideal.

Thanks for your reaction . Never forget .

Great job Jayy can't wait for the next movie

Think this movie is something we all need to remember,one more person.

Those who forget the past are condemned to repeat it. It’s critically important that we heed these words as members of humanity. This must never happen again. Never.