What a treasure and a miracle to behold this on my screen. "Every day of my life that is not spent in your company is a day wasted." "Stay. Make a life with me." Powerful beyond words. Sublime beyond words. I wish I could adequately express how grateful I am to see this but my words fail. Thank you from my heart for this community and for the opportunity to share this, together. ❤❤❤

@ladyguenevere3501

Жыл бұрын

I feel the same.

@audreycumby1075

Жыл бұрын

I agree!

@lisakirby4743

8 ай бұрын

100% agree!

Charlette turns alexander down out of duty....both, of them are of strong moral character, even if to detriment tothemselves... what makes us admire them, true jane austen style 😊

That headshake with the almost whispered "Stay" tears my heart out

@ladyguenevere3501

Жыл бұрын

I loved that too. That headshake! He wasn't giving up! The thing I most loved about Colbourne after all he'd been thru is he fought for love! His courage to step out of his shell and fight for love! THAT dear friends is what real love does.

Xander ‘shooting his shot’ was incredibly brave given his relationship history; his declaration to Charlotte was so moving. Not to mention the pleading🥹in his voice as he asks her to stay and make a life with him. I love that he finally got out of his head and told Charlotte how he felt even though he had no way of knowing how she would react. Charlotte was naturally upset because she knows she’s in love with him but because of her strong morals feels she must stand by the commitment to Ralph and her parents. I really felt for both characters in this scene…heartbreaking, fortunately where there’s a will there’s a way 😉

Oh, the agony of being in love ! This is destined to be one of the most talked-about scenes in Sanditon. Rose Williams' acting here is superb.

@audreycumby1075

Жыл бұрын

And Ben Lloyd Hughes is brilliant also!

@stephenmorse8811

Жыл бұрын

@@audreycumby1075 Oh, I didn't notice him ! 😜

@maddissonstratford9407

Жыл бұрын

@@stephenmorse8811 😂😂😂

@amritawhitman8112

Жыл бұрын

I agree! I've lost count of how many times I've watched this scene. I pursued a career as an actress when I was Rose's age many years ago and I know how difficult scenes like this one are to do and to do well! They both nailed this scene and knocked it out of the park for a homerun (American baseball phrase! 😊). Nice to see a gent who likes Sanditon! I went over to your YT channel, listened to your piano videos, enjoyed them and subscribed.

Oh, that speech! The "stay. Make a life with me." That gets me everytime. I just wish that he called Charlotte by her name in this scene instead of by miss Heywood. Saying something like "I tried to deny it but, I am in love with you Charlotte." To me that would have made the scene even more romantic

@LadyPhoenix2000

Жыл бұрын

Right!! or even Charlotte Heywood. Its acutally the only thing I don't like about this scene. Hasn't stopped me rewatching this episode multiple times since the 19th however. lol

@amritawhitman8112

Жыл бұрын

YES! It would have been great to hear him say her first name just once particularly in this scene! Oh but the emotion in his voice from beginning to end, and his shocked reaction after she asks, "Then why didn't you?!" was just perfect!

@tarad6160

Жыл бұрын

Yes he should have channeled Sidney and the way he would say "Charlotte" with such longing!

@ashleyminihan370

Жыл бұрын

With all due respect, I like that Colbourne doesn't call her Charlotte in this scene. I find it kind of sweet and very in character. He's doing this thing that is so beyond the bounds of propriety (confessing his love to an engaged woman), yet he still observes the rules by calling her "Miss Heywood." Colbourne is NOT Sidney, an outlier who often breaks the rules of decorum. Colbourne obeys the rules, even to his own detriment, and that's why it's so exciting (and sexy!) when he finally lets himself break them in this scene.

@amidthephantomsrose

Жыл бұрын

@@ashleyminihan370 you have an excellent point. I never thought of it that way before

"Stay...make a life with me" dear god !! Ralph who?? Come on Charlotte everyone would have jump on him 😂

@karenshurley4793

Жыл бұрын

Ralph who? I’m surprised after that kiss, Charlotte even remembers Ralph’s name 🤭 3:17

@aprilrose6630

Жыл бұрын

@@bernieoconnell5515 What?! He's not handsome? What's a pudding face? That he's smoothe and sweet like pudding? 😉😊

@aprilrose6630

Жыл бұрын

Why is the other comment gone

@marymesesan7139

Жыл бұрын

​@@karenshurley4793 😂- Karen Shurley - have you seen the memes?

Even though I really enjoy what leads up to this scene, Augusta being comforted by Leonora, Edward writing a letter to her, Georgiana thinking about Otis and burning his contact info, I like how you put this together because we can really focus on just the two of them. For me, having studied and pursued a career in acting years ago, what makes this scene work so well are her conflicting feelings about him. This is a man who broke her heart a few months before this scene. While she knows she is still drawn to him, so much so that she kisses him, she's fighting her feelings and she doesn't know if she can trust him. I paused the video after he said "Stay, make a life with me" and the look in her eyes said it all. All the emotions were there. Excellent acting by both of them!

1: He did not tell her before because of his experience with his previous marriage. He was simply afraid. 2: After that speech who wouldn't jump his bones. Wait until episode 6😅

@soniaflores5761

Жыл бұрын

Jump his bones.😅

Happiest birthday BLH. You have brought us so much joy (and longing). Your bright career is ahead of you and we can’t wait to see you in many more such shows that bring out your immense talent… 💕

@ladyguenevere3501

Жыл бұрын

I agree! This is the first time I saw BLH and was astounded at his talent! An amazing actor!

Xander walking toward her on that cliff top is ten times better than Mr. Darcy walking through the mist in 2005 Pride and Prejudice! 😍 It sounds crazy but I actually like that Charlotte turns him down this time because it shows how strong her sense of morality and loyalty is, she genuinely believes in the importance of keeping your word and honoring your promises and to be fair Xander jerked her around at the end of last season for reasons she’s not aware of. Then when they finally get their happy ending later it’s because they’ve resolved their own issues and are both in a good place for a relationship…it makes it so much more satisfying an ending! ❤❤❤

I watched this a few times. This man right here walks down from that hill to deliver that incredible love speech. In that way. Charlotte. The word you’re looking for is yes, woman. He’s a forward thinker, too? Listens to you??? Doesn’t mind if you have a job in that time period? Looks good and has an estate? Yes. And can you say I love you at least once? He will die if you do not. Look at him.

I loved this scene on the cliffs but what I have enjoyed so much more is watching and enjoying this show as a community ❤😊😊😊 thanks for posting!!!

@rikabesancon6599

Жыл бұрын

It is beautiful.❤

@maddissonstratford9407

Жыл бұрын

Oh I so agree with you on that! I love reading everyone’s comments 😊

Yes, she did rise up on her tiptoes to kiss him! That's part of what makes this scene so memorable. The drama and conflict for them also makes it memorable. Both characters have high principles and integrity, so to see them struggling with their feelings for one another pulls at our heartstrings! Charlotte must walk away from Colbourne because she can't be the one to disappoint Ralph AND her parents by running off with Colbourne! What I love about Rose's performance is watching her struggle with all of it! She loves him but she's angry with him for putting her in this position and for not telling her how he felt about her. Colbourne, a man of integrity and high principles, is shocked by his brother's suggestion that he somehow interfere with Charlotte's plans to marry Ralph but at the same time he's afraid she will leave Sanditon the next day, get married, and he'll never see her again, so he's desperate. The drama and passion of it all is why this particular video has had almost 300,000 views as of October 2023!

We haven’t seen much of Colbourne in his office in Season 3. I love that he retreated there to think after seeing Charlotte at the shooting party. He (with a little nudge from Samuel) prepared himself to go and properly confess his love to her. At last!

-how many times have you watched this? -me: yes

Something’s always going down on those cliffs. 😂

@audreycumby1075

Жыл бұрын

😀😀😀😀

@shahnazotanian6486

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂

@charliecharmander3213

Жыл бұрын

No fr if you’re talking about Jane Austen novels/movies/series in general it seems like so many iconic things happen on a cliff bro. Also just in this series alone haha 😅

@karenshurley4793

Жыл бұрын

I’m so happy Ben fought to have Xander make that long walk 🥵🥵

The most well realized concept in sanditon is to get to experience the evolution of love through Charlotte, and to see how love can find you, even when all hope is lost, you just have to be opened to see it.

@ladyguenevere3501

Жыл бұрын

💖 would that true love would find us all!

This series has been the best ever for me ,

Sidney could not have said those words. Ben was the best, he is the one.

@ladyguenevere3501

Жыл бұрын

Honestly after seeing Colbourne (BLH) I can't even watch season one anymore. Sidney was just Meh...compared to Colbourne. HE is Charlotte's soul mate and IMO BLH is by far the better actor. Bye bye Sidney. I couldn't have been more thrilled at seasons 2 and 3. The finale! OMG! So satisfying to see everyone finally find happiness! I've seen a lot of period pieces and they are my favorite genre but Sanditon has come be to my top favorite! In every aspect. Perfectly done. Rose Williams was so good as were they all and that little girl Flora who played Leo! So great. Great future ahead for her. But to me it was BLH and his wonderful embodiment of Colbourne that made these last two seasons. That and the amazing chemistry he and Rose had. Thank you cast, directors...everyone. What a joy to experience! TY PBS! xoxo

@carokat1111

Жыл бұрын

@@ladyguenevere3501 Well said. I totally agree.

@audreycumby1075

Жыл бұрын

I wholeheartedly agree! Sanditon Seasons 2 and 3 are Masterpieces! Ben Lloyd- Hughes is phenomenal!

@sharonzulick5715

Жыл бұрын

Maybe I am a romantic, but I love the love story. I can relate to Mr. And Charlotte. I have been there but came to futriion.

@helenecarlsson4997

Жыл бұрын

Totally disagree with u

Great episode! Thanks Susan!

Thanks Susan, very beautiful video!

I squealed like a little girl at the end of episode 3. 🤗🤭

@susanfirth9883

Жыл бұрын

You were not alone 🤣❤

@user-hj6hc5pz1i

Жыл бұрын

I was just going to say you are not alone! ❤

@soniaflores5761

Жыл бұрын

Same!

@audreycumby1075

Жыл бұрын

Me too!

@karenshurley4793

Жыл бұрын

We made a chorus!

Merci Susan pour cette vidéo d'une importance capitale. Tout d'abord la discussion entre les deux frères est décisive dans la décision de Alexander. Samuel lui fait comprendre que rien n'est perdu car Charlotte n'est pas ENCORE mariée. Et nous assistons ENFIN à une scène FABULEUSE : LA DÉCLARATION D'AMOUR DE ALEXANDER ! Moment inoubliable où les mots choisis sont d'une telle force, d'une telle beauté, d'une telle humilité ! La voix d'Alexander est cassée, brisée par l'émotion qui l'envahit ! Il se livre totalement : Il lui avoue être amoureux depuis le premier instant de leur rencontre. Charlotte est troublée et répond avec son AMOUR en lui donnant un baiser. Comment résister devant tant de passion, tant de constance, tant d'abnégation ? Mais la réalité reprend vite le dessus hélas ! Nous sommes au 19ème siècle et, une parole donnée est sacrée. ''Trop tard' répond-elle ! Elle le quitte désespérée et lui reste statufié anéanti par sa décision. Que cette scène est jouée avec une intensité qui nous laisse pantois d'admiration ! Tout sonne vrai : les gestes, les regards, les voix, les mots ! Nos deux acteurs sont sur la même longueur d'ondes, en OSMOSE TOTALE ! Il y a une ALCHIMIE FABULEUSE entre eux deux ! Ils sont GRANDIOSES, LEUR TALENT CRÈVE L'ÉCRAN ! Un tel talent aussi naturel est très rare, quasiment inégalé, leur interprétation sonne juste à chaque seconde : ils sont INCROYABLEMENT EN HARMONIE ! Grâce à leurs FABULEUX TALENTS, Rose et Ben portent SANDITON au premier rang des séries réussies. Cette merveilleuse histoire d' amour nous emporte loin, vers des sommets jamais atteints : L'EXCELLENCE !

I just finished this seasons episodes. Loved it and can’t wait for MORE!

Beautiful words expressed in such a beautiful setting... Mr Coulbourne does a great honor to Mr Darcy here...

We waited a whole year to hear what was said at the cliff. Finally! Didn’t disappoint! Too bad when she asked “Why didn’t you”, he didn’t get to explain how he thought he would fail her like the way he failed in his 1st marriage. Now they have to get out of this pickle!

@jstypula1619

Жыл бұрын

He was going to, but she stopped him ...Parkers drawing room ...

@ngaimingyee2970

Жыл бұрын

@@jstypula1619 Naw..., I think in the scene at the end of Season 2 in the Parkers' drawing room, Alexander still lacked the confidence to spill out his feelings and once again was about to ask Miss Heywood to return as the girls' governess ---- a variation of his usual lame "the house misses you already." Charlotte rightfully stopped him from completing his weak request. After all, Charlotte had been badly disrespected. Alexander has a long way to go to redeem himself before our honorable and truly remarkable young heroine. I'm glad to see Charlotte wiser and not blindly swept up this time.

@susanfirth9883

Жыл бұрын

Actually, Ben Lloyd-Hughes has said in an interview that Alexander was coming to Trafalgar House to propose. You seem pretty sure of your opinions and also pretty harsh on the poor man. "Lame" and "weak" are not words I would use to describe Alexander Colbourne 🔥 If you delve deeper, you may find the compassion to understand that he has been very badly treated and is coming from only love for Charlotte, and wanting to protect her.

@jstypula1619

Жыл бұрын

@Susan Firth jane austen wrote with her own take on morality right and wrong. Alexander, although not born of her name, I don't think would have been written differently... He and charlette are both of very aware people, I think, more than others on the show, why their journey to each other is complicated. Just my thoughts...there are so many layers here it is truly deserving of deeper explaration

@peterdyste1247

Жыл бұрын

If there weren't pickles to get out of there wouldn't be a show.

My daughter was watching this over my shoulder and though the book Charlotte was carrying was a mobile phone!!!😂😂😂😂

So eine wunderbare Liebesgeschichte...dies ist meine Lieblingszene. Diese Sehnsucht und Verzweiflung...diese lang unterdrückten Gefühle die sich endlich Bahn brechen. Das warten auf die dritte Staffel hat sich gelohnt.❤

OMG! How could she remember Ralph after a declaration of that! I don't know what Charlotte was thinking but it took Alexander a lifetime of courage just to confess his deepest feelings to her. Then to have her show that she returns his affection and deep love (she did kiss him) and then say it was too late! What kind of girl could walkaway from the man she loves with that evidence! Later on when she mentions her parents again in reference to keeping her promise to Ralph, I would have thought they would say they only wanted to see her happy. I am pretty sure they would have trusted her to make her own decisions. So glad though Charlotte did come to her senses and drop Ralph and marry her love.

From The Eve of Saint Agnes - "Agnes sweet, and Agnes fair, Hither, hither, now repair; Bonny Agnes, let me see The lad who is to marry me." And then, there he is.

Thank you for uploading this scene, and for the Spanish subtitles! It's such a moving, romantic, and sincere moment for Alexander & Charlotte. When I first watched this, I was speechless for a moment but was squealing internally! ❤❤

No idea how she turns him down after this speech!

@Ra_Q

Жыл бұрын

Lol right! Gosh it’s what we all want to hear

@AndreaLee-ms9rl

Жыл бұрын

Commitment to Ralph and her Parents. Honor was very important then . Even when Alexander professes his love ,he remains a proper Gentleman calling her Miss Heywood.

@parkerbrown-nesbit1747

Жыл бұрын

Ralph? Ralph who?

Aww..I love, love,love it! Today, I order the DVD, finally and can´t wait to watch the whole season 🙂

@maddissonstratford9407

Жыл бұрын

It’s already out?

@carokat1111

Жыл бұрын

@@maddissonstratford9407 Yes. Ordered mine yesterday.

Such great acting skills by both! Charlotte was so sad and miserable all of S3. I would have thought, sorry, Mom, and Dad, and goodbye Ralph. "Stay... and make a life with me." YES!

@adevrespios

Жыл бұрын

Fortunately we live in 2023 with options about controlling ourselves as we choose ...well most of us. Back then , they couldn't.. just say "YES"....... especially those in bad economical situations.They had to marry for money ....Love ? How many back then could marry for love? Certainly not from the working class....the odds.. those who married for love to those who couldn't afford to do that ...well was beyond measurement. The unfortunate of our era is that everything has taken the "ugly" road ,that some times for some people , there is an uncontrollable freedom of speech and way of acting as they please.Too much "yes's".

I have rewatched this scene a zillion times and I keep coming back again and again. Sigh. If Xander had said that speech to me I would have tossed that poetry book off the cliff and grabbed him and run. 😁

@shahnazotanian6486

Жыл бұрын

Perfectly said

@denisefisher9727

Жыл бұрын

Same 😂

@karenshurley4793

Жыл бұрын

I concur

@marymesesan7139

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely!❤❤

@aprilrose6630

Жыл бұрын

Yesss 😊❤

As Alexander sees Charlotte on the cliffs, it makes me believe looking forward to the future and getting a charge out of if their feelings and the best result if you believe them. Thank you for providing these videos.

Is it just me, or is it Charlotte that kisses Alexander?!? 2:15 Check it out for yourself. The moment she's been pinning for ever since she returned home in Season 2 and saw him again at Georgiana's birthday party in episode 1. Their fingers touching each other in episode 2 at the concert. Their chemistry crashes upon the screen moreso than the waves upon the shore. 💘

@Ra_Q

Жыл бұрын

Yezzzz! She DEFINITELY kissed him! Bless her heart!

@Ra_Q

Жыл бұрын

And my favorite part is when he nods his head back and forth when she tells him that she’s to be married❤️

@susanfirth9883

Жыл бұрын

Our girl definitely made the first move!🔥🔥 I loved that!! 🥰

@barbarad.3273

Жыл бұрын

With every fiber in her body she kisses him. Notice how Charlotte’s neck muscles tense up as she reaches UP to kiss her man! They couldn’t be closer, not a wisp of the cliff breeze is getting through their bodies at that moment. Wake up Charlotte!

@karenshurley4793

Жыл бұрын

I had to purchase defibrillators - for me and the tv! 🤭

I’m in the UK & can’t watch it yet so I’m living for your art ❤

The scenes we all needed! Thank you! 🙏😊

Everything was going so great and again that nail in the shoe - Ralph... 😤

I loved the music from Sanditon, this scene in particular, and thought you all would like to know that the soundtrack for Sanditon seasons 2 and 3 is now available on Spotify and posibly other platforms too!

I love these scenes! 😊

His brother is so fine!

@marymesesan7139

Жыл бұрын

Both of those Colbourne men are oh so fine!❤❤

Can’t wait for tomorrows episode!

Superb scene and acting 🏆🎭🎬

I could stare into Rose's eyes forever.

♥♥♥♥ Oh the heartache - for us all!!

chère Susan, ce message vous est directement adressé. En effet, aujourd'hui 14 avril est le jour anniversaire de Ben LLYOD HUGHES. Je ne sais où le lui souhaiter donc je m'adresse à vous qui avez plus de relations. Cet acteur possède un talent immense doublé d'un naturel confondant. Une adoratrice française lui souhaite un très bon anniversaire, que ses souhaits qui lui tiennent le plus à coeur se réalisent. Par avance je vous remercie pour ce que vous pourrez entreprendre. Toujours en attente de vos prochaines vidéos. Merci.

I mean i think that’s fair. 🤷‍♀️🤣

I was so crushed when Xander let that evil man get into his head, knowing what a douchebag he is. That Xander then fired Charlotte so coldly. And then wants to get her back by telling her that the house misses her and that he was only there to ask her back because his niece asked him to. If he had at least started by apologizing for his words and saying that he missed her, he might have saved himself all this heartache.

Every day of my life that is not spent in your company is a day wasted. Stay. Make a life with me. I'm gutted.😭😭😭

@shahnazotanian6486

Жыл бұрын

Me too

@sharonzulick5715

Жыл бұрын

Oh! My

@aprilrose6630

Жыл бұрын

Aw such a sincere deep loving reveal of his true feelings! Few words but with such power and poignancy...um, Ralph who?!! ❤

Where could I find a Xander?

I confess ...I am very drawn to these kind of era and the way they lived and the conduct and speak...If I had to choose when and where I would like to be born... that era I would choose...but not London.I would prefer a place like Sanditon or somehere else in the country with similar grounds . An other matter ...after watching and reviewing this scene again and again ...I am asking my self an other question ...Is it that the role and the script ..that makes the actors...lovable .. for me ..or all of us... to be drawn to them ? I am not UK resident and I do not know a lot of UK actors and actresses .I have never seen or known Ben Lloyd-Hughes before, so I wonder ...if he was playing a role like the one of E.Denam or Ralph or Mr Stringer's....would I be able to notice him and consider him as a goodlooking man and fascinate me ?I so much desliked JACK FOX. What would I think if he had the role of Alexander?

Is Colbourne walking towards Charlotte a nod to the 2005 P&P Darcy/Elizabeth scene?

@susanfirth9883

Жыл бұрын

Yes, in fact Ben said in an interview that he wanted to pay homage to that Darcy scene ❤️

@karenshurley4793

Жыл бұрын

@@susanfirth9883And he did such a fantastic work of it too😀

I have an obsession with the backdrop music and i just cant find it on spotify. Does anyone know the songs title and composser?

@googleknowsus8184

Жыл бұрын

Jon Wygans :)

@Anika74215

Жыл бұрын

According to the composers, the season 2/3 soundtrack will be out soon,

@stephenmorse8811

Жыл бұрын

@@Anika74215 Great news !!

I need the music from this scene please!!!

They always come forward too late

Is the score/soundtrack out for this particular scene or not? 😍

@susanfirth9883

Жыл бұрын

open.spotify.com/album/59xBuRAH2bHBz0mAJqr60F?si=Tcl6zRxZSo2Fbm7ohFObrQ&nd=1&_branch_referrer=H4sIAAAAAAAAA7WN0QqCMBiFn2Zeqs0yCiSUGNJNZF11I9ucOZxu%2FW5kPn0a9AjBgQPn4%2BM01pphHwSD0VbWb58a4yvZt8HBgK4ct4k2ovcQXtdOqdKBSppFQVGKMJmzYP9nc93NE1XMLb3ZjZkr0hyzPJvCLj09IQ4JisggUXS8cRVPxXi%2FakxYt9UNOTO4fJ%2BoUozy9v9vCMd9NdOVVwtqHYhEw4P2knsliFoACEjsS1or4AObuViaKQEAAA%3D%3D&product=open&%24full_url=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Falbum%2F59xBuRAH2bHBz0mAJqr60F%3Fsi%3DTcl6zRxZSo2Fbm7ohFObrQ&feature=organic&_referrer=twitter&_branch_match_id=1197725253882624443

Quel désastre quelle vie gâcher Charlotte qui se revendiquait une jeune femme libre cède à la décision des autres pour les choix fondamentaux de sa propre vie et de son bonheur futur pourtant elle aime Alexander qui a beaucoup progressé et a fait la démarche de revenir vers elle et de lui déclarer ses sentiments je soupçonne un certain orgueil et ressentiment chez Charlotte car il l'avait repousse une première fois mais il convient de faire tomber les masques pour voir clair dans la nuit et ce ne serait pas un roman la façon de Jane Austen il n' y avait pas du suspens dans les retournements de situation

Does anyone know if we find out why Alexander did not tell her before?

@amidthephantomsrose

Жыл бұрын

It goes back to season 2.after finding Leo in the militia camp with Lennox, Lennox tells Alexander that Charlotte is in love with him and that he better not fail her like he did his first wife, Lucy. That makes Alexander feel guilty and shy away from Charlotte, bury his feelings, and not tell her how he truly feels. He is afraid to hurt someone again. He then dismissed her as governess. Claiming that their relationship was inappropriate and that he took advantage of her. Charlotte tries to advocate for herself and says that no one took advantage of her. That she was a willing participant. But Alexander still dismisses her. He thinks he's being noble and must sacrifice his happiness for her sake. Charlotte is heartbroken. Meanwhile, Mrs. Wheatley tells him that "you'll regret this." Knowing that he's in love with her. Also, she caught them kissing earlier. And he says "it's for her own sake." To which Mrs. Wheatley puts her hand in Alexander's arm to try and comfort him. Then when Augusta confronts Alexander about why Charlotte left (she doesn't know what happened between them yet), she begs him to go after her. He goes to the Parker's, and I believe he was about to tell her how he felt, but Charlotte stopped him and told him that she was leaving sanditon. Charlotte said she could never be in any kind of relationship where someone showed her so little respect. Alexander leaves, hesitating at the door. It pains him to not tell her, but he doesn't. We then see Charlotte alone where she cries and says"enough!". After these events she returns home and gets engaged to Ralph because it's what her parents think is best for her. Also she's trying to move on and heal. That's why everyone is so shocked at Alison's wedding when she tells them she's engaged to Ralph. They know it's not right and that Charlotte is not really happy. Meanwhile Alexander goes off to Bath to try and get away from things and forget Charlotte, But he can't. And here we are in season 3 where they are pushed back together again.

@renolittle4950

Жыл бұрын

@@amidthephantomsrose I think in Season 2 where Alexander goes to the Parker's to talk with Charolotte - he was going to propose to her.

@audreycumby1075

Жыл бұрын

@@renolittle4950 I agree..

@STwGrandma

Жыл бұрын

@@amidthephantomsrose i guess I always felt that Lennox was insinuating something more than just that Alexander's love wasn't enough for Lucy when he said that all he did was comfort her when her husband could not. Perhaps you are right though, and this is all that Lennox meant. I guess I was really asking if there is any scene in which Alexander explains to Charlotte why he didn't tell her before, meaning does he explain to her how Lennox's comments affected her. I assuming that he doesn't actually explain this.

@amidthephantomsrose

Жыл бұрын

@@STwGrandma so far, I don't think that there has been a scene where he explains anything to Charlotte about how Lennox's comments affected him. I could be wrong, but I think the writer's are under the assumption that it's just implied and that the audience will understand and read between the lines. But I'm with Charlotte in this one "why didn't you!" I think it would have made things clearer for her and she wouldn't have been as hurt or mad at the situation maybe

is this a film...

@susanfirth9883

Жыл бұрын

TV show on PBS ❤️