🔴 Galaxy Watch 6 Classic*: geni.us/GalaxyWatch6Classic 🔴 Galaxy Watch 6*: geni.us/GalaxyWatch6 🔴 General Amazon link*: geni.us/thequantifiedscientist 🟢 Instagram: instagram.com/quantified_scientist/ 🟠 Shorts: studio.kzread.info/dron/cpARGzXNaC62UQWns2dh2Q.html 🔵 Newsletter: www.robterhorst.com 🟡 Twitter: @QuantifiedRob * Affiliate (paid) links support the channel by earning me a commission on any sale, and it doesn't cost you any more! My opinions are completely my own, and this content is not sponsored. ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ 👇 $30 off any new WHOOP membership, affiliate* (paid) link, supports the channel!👇 join.whoop.com/QuantifiedScientist ($30 off any new WHOOP membership) ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ 👇Amazon Affiliate* (paid) links. Supports the channel, doesn't cost you any more!👇 ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬BEST WATCHES▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ 🔴 Oura Link: I recommend you search for a discount on reddit with the "Refer-A-Friend" program! If you can’t find one: ouraring.sjv.io/rQ4L33 (affiliate link that supports the channel, but doesn't have a discount) 🔴 Whoop Strap 4.0: join.whoop.com/QuantifiedScientist ($30 off any new WHOOP membership) 🔴 Eight sleep 200$/150$ discount*: eight-sleep.ioym.net/TheQuantifiedScientist + add code “TQS” for 200$/150$ total discount

@Mau365PP

10 ай бұрын

Please review the Huawei Watch D!!! Is measures blood pressure 😋

@imD1yeah

10 ай бұрын

Hi sir can u do, sleep for redmi watch 3 and redmi watch 3 active

@henzoarruda4582

10 ай бұрын

It would be nice if you could redo the analysis after a few months of release and with new possible software updates that may improve the results of the device

@ukaszmalec8737

10 ай бұрын

Hello! Are you planning to make a review of Huawei Watch 4 Active? :) Greetings from Poland! :)

Hey Rob, great review again! How soon can we expect a review on the Huawei watch 4 Pro? I mean please😍

It would be nice if you could redo the analysis after a few months of release and with new possible software updates that may improve the results of the device

I feel like Samsung just brought the same device like 3 times. (watch 4, 5 and 6).

@joemammatube

10 ай бұрын

Agree!

It's so depressing being an Android user when in the market for an accurate watch.

@javigrcia

10 ай бұрын

Agree, it's a lost war; the decent option would be fitbits but paying a monthly fee for premium content after investing 250$ in the damn watch is grotesque.

@merom.1248

10 ай бұрын

Huawei Watches are so accurate. The only brand compared to Apple watches

@quest666PL

10 ай бұрын

You guys never heard of Huawei watches ? Watch 4 pro or gr 3 pro

@Hypo666crisy

10 ай бұрын

Huawei GT3 Pro (46mm) is the best android watch ;) Don't know about the GT4 (Pro) though.

@bjpa1151

10 ай бұрын

Huawei watches and bands are way more accurate and also affordables. If you're only looking for accuracy they're more than great

Brilliant review, as always. Thank you for your hard work, Rob.

Nice video. Disappointing to see that in 2023 Samsung, as the premier Android maker, is still lagging behind Apple and by such a large margin.

Loved the review as usual Rob! Thanks for your input and I really hope @Samsung takes more reviews like this into consideration before releasing their next smartwatch!

Great review as always. I have a question, any schedule to review Huawei Watch 4 and 4pro ? thanks

Thank you Samaung for affirming my decision in getting the Huawei Gt3 Pro. Thanks as well Rob for another detailed analysis!

Thank you! Super useful content as always

Great review once again! What about reviewing Ultrahuman Ring AIR at some point? Would be super interesting to see you compare it to the Oura ring 3

ive been waiting for this

I wasn't waiting for this actually but your presentation forces me to watch your reviews, doc

Nice and well rounded scientific review as always 👍🏽 I would also really appreciate If you can do a scientific review about the Huawei watch 4/4pro 👌🏽

Thank you so much for the very thorough test results! I ordered a Watch 6 Classic, mainly to control apps, but also for heart and sleep monitoring. I hope they can improve with updates...but if not it is probably still okay for me. They really need to step it up, though...

@RicstasTech

8 ай бұрын

I just ordered mine.I hope they can fix it and make it more accurate 😅 How have you found the tracking to be so far? (Seeing that you made this comment a month ago👀)

@justinkase1360

8 ай бұрын

@@RicstasTech I think it does an okay job for comparing one night to the next, generally. I have honestly stopped wearing the watch to bed. I slept fine with it, using the Samsung fabric band, but it just wasn't ideal. Ultimately, I don't think sleep tracking, even if accurate, really does much for me. I know when I SHOULD go to sleep and I know that magnesium supplement personally helps me sleep better. What more do I need to know? I'm more interested in BP monitoring...which isn't allowed unless you do something with the software. Supposedly it's real easy to do, but I haven't done it yet.

@RicstasTech

8 ай бұрын

@justinkase1360 thank you so much! I am stoked to get mine, I got the sports band and the fabric band as well, looking to see what us more comfortable when sleeping, or if it will be chilling on my bedside table charging. Appreciate your response 💪😁

@justinkase1360

8 ай бұрын

@@RicstasTech I also received those two bands. Fabric is more comfortable and actually looks good, IMHO. I had the Watch 5 and never wore it, but I'm really liking this Watch 6. I use it A LOT for Spotify. The volume control using the bezel is awesome and I can favorite songs right there on the watch, even change from DJ to various playlists. Anyway, enjoy!

@TheQuantifiedScientist Nice job! I hope you can help me with an interest question, and I believe there are not much solid information about it around tbe internet. There is any problem using fitness trackers/smartwatches/smartbands on the inner side of your wrist (palm side)? I mean, how bad is it (if bad at all) to the accuracy of the device? Do you have a word on this issue? Maybe you can consider doing a video testing it, would be great!

As always, great video. Appreciate the time and effort you put into these. Another disappointing showing from Samsung. I wish Samsung would hire you to lead their analytics team to help them make a better fitness device!

Love the video, still waiting for the ticwatch pro 5 review tho 👌💪

Great review! As a suggestion for devices that support it - would be good to do Blood Pressure & ECG tests as well. Keep up the good work!

Thanks a lot for all your work. After watching about 15 videos and telling all my sport friends about your channel, which I had found on Reddit, I finally bought a watch for myself. No, it's not Galaxy. I decided to go for Huawei. I hope the 4-version will be as good as the previous one. I'm sure in a month or two there will be a review here, which we all look forward to! You are a hell of a man. I can't believe you are just the only one on the whole Planet who did something that everyone needs and nobody thought of.

Great analysis. Thank you! As many others here, I am also curious about Huawei Watch 4 PRO performance, since it has sensors from Watch GT 3 PRO which tops your HR accuracy chart along with Apple Watch. Huawei also claimed they improved sleep detection, which was not that good. Another "true smartwatch" alternative to Samsung Watch 5 PRO what would be great to see is Ticwatch PRO 5. It is missing eSIM version right now, but that may not be deal breaker for many.

@HoroshoShaman

10 ай бұрын

Same, Lukas. Look forward to the review of HW 4, but I have already purchased it though and love it. Especially the price, since initially I was thinking of Garmin, and it's not the case anymore.

@zefe3886

10 ай бұрын

​@@HoroshoShamanDid you get the watch 4 or the watch 4 pro?

New to your channel and Thanks for sharing this information and all your hard work.💯✌️

Still waiting for Huawei Watch 4 Pro review.

Great review, thanks))) waiting for HUAWEI WATCH 4 review?

Come on Samsung get your stuff together.

I don't want to be samsung biased but I have the watch as well as the huawei one and both the heart rate and the sleep tracking appear to be almost exactly the same when I tested the two during a workout sessions and in the morning for sleep. Maybe it depends on the person but for me I get very very similar results. For example the heart rate on the samsung now(when writing this comment) is 76, while the huawei is 77, the lowest and highest heartrates of the day are 44:140 and 44:139 and the sleep is 8h11m to 8h01. The max difference between steps at the end of the day is 200-250 with over 15,000 total steps. In conclusion during my testings the results are both mainly the same.

Wow so fast with the reviews ❤

I have been in touch with Samsung and have had my watch since the 6th so 5 days before release. All of the inaccuracies seen in this video I have also noticed. However I believe the physical hardware is probably not the issue. I was assured by multiple support associates that the watch was designed with the new updates in mind that are coming to android. I would hope that after an update or two these issues will be fixed. Please repost comparisons afterwards to see if there is actual improvement.

@fahadbinfarid5927

4 күн бұрын

Hey, what about now? How is the watch 6 classic now?

@girduncer

3 күн бұрын

​@fahadbinfarid5927 it's inconsistencies held up even after a couple updates. Not super impressed for the price. Hoping future iterations can be better.

@mikerosoft1009

10 сағат бұрын

​@@girdunceris it probably that the sensor making contact with the wrist just isn't as good as apples? I'm Android and looking for an android watch.

I love your videos. Thanks to you I got the Huawei GT Runner ❤

Thanks for the in-depth analysis. 👍I've used the Smartwatch 6 to track overall sleep time, the last couple of nights and to me it seems pretty accurate. I also fell asleep during the day yesterday, and it picked that up. I'm not so concerned about REM or light sleep, at the moment. Glad to see HR at rest, is overall accurate enough and blood-oxygen as well. When I exercise, I cycle outdoors and will not be wearing my watch for that. Don't want a tan line 😃, and don't need it. For GPS I have a Garmin and the app on my phone. Again, thanks. Look forward to any other updates.

Perfect video! Thank you! I pre-ordered Galaxy Watch 6 classic, and already regretting it...

Hello, thankyou for checking this smartwatch into depth. I got an question, would the update of week 35 so last week of august, improve it? They said its stable, and not in beta anymore for Galaxy watch 4-5. Only America-Korea has the beta still.

what a wonderful job you did.

I would like to see a number for the percentage of overall sleep stage agreement, not just a graph of the single (worst) and aveage percentage. Perhaps this could be added as a column in the agreement chart. Maybe, also, if your going to plot the worst, plot the best... Also, mixing measurements from different references on the same chart would me much more useful if that chart included measurements from (at least) 1 reference device for every watch. Yes, this would mean multiple measurements (for a single watch) on the graph, but at least the data would have more relevance. For me, the issue of accuracy isn't just relevant to the best available measurements but also relevant to other devices. When the graph plots points from different reference measuring devices, the relevance of the plot points can be lost (between some devices). That said, I really appreciate your approach and testing. I find it extremely valuable even as is.

Excellent video Rob. Does anyone know if software updates have fixed the issues? I have Watch 4 now and was looking a upgrading but after watching a few videos on the different brands, looks like Apple is best in class.

Great video, thanks! Maybe it would be helpful to compare chest straps at some point. I have a PowrLabs that seems pretty accurate compared to my pulse oximeter. I decided to get a Garmin HRM Pro Plus to go with my Garmin watch and get extra walking /running info but had a lot of trouble with HR accuracy compared to the pulse oximeter. The conductive electrodes on the Garmin didn't seem to get a reliable signal from my skin and would put out readings that were off. I finally returned it. Maybe I'll try the Polar strap next.

14:03 wow! You got PewDiePie as guest star! Great video as always!

Ready appreciate such a detailed video. Could you please do it for Huawei watch 4 pro as well ?

was waiting for this and finally got my watch 6 classic as well. The results from previous review are still holding, including the R with POLAR, the inertia in catching up to changes. Idk if the performance merits the price tag, and Samsung probably knows it too, that's why all the deep discounts (got 30%+ discount myself). Just holding it for the sake of the "ecosystem", and it looks alright.

Thank you very much for your existence!!! As a man, who very deeply tries to find a right buy for myself, I spend a looot of time for searching and comparing things, to make a good/perfect decision. Your channel and work with independent review is a honey for me. Very structural, great graphics, great comparisons. Because it's too hard to find a right gadget in this mess of them. Thank you one more time!

Hello Rob, Thank you very much for your excellent videos. I would like you to test the huawei watch 4. I remember your test on the GT3 pro with good results except for sleep. I would like to buy a GT3 pro but maybe the huawei 4 is really better ? I need your tips. Thank you very mutch !

Thank you for another excellent review and hard work Rob. I already cancelled my watch 6 classic pre-order based on your initial findings and it's bittersweet to know my decision was the right one. I cannot support Samsung in their watch devices until they improve the accuracy of their health and fitness measurements to be competitive.

@thechuches3879

10 ай бұрын

I wouldnt take this video as guide. The sampling on the HR polar 10 is extremely low on the Apple watches compared to the Samsung watches in the spinng, biking, weight lifting. The sampling of the HR polar 10 should be constant in every review, but i see that it is lower on the graphs of the apple devices vs the samsung ones. You can see it on the playlists of apple and samsung watches. apple: kzread.info/dash/bejne/in2s2KmSl5XHkrQ.html&pp=iAQB samsung: kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZmuXqsaGn5iam9Y.html&pp=iAQB

@lordsb20

10 ай бұрын

​@@thechuches3879That is a valid observation that I hope Rob can answer. My decision was largely based off of his detailed analysis, Samsung's history in this space and unfortunately many other reviews like DC Rainmaker's which confirm such inaccuracies relative to competitors. DC Rainmaker's Review: kzread.info/dash/bejne/eqmtsadrfqSdoqQ.html

Would love to see you branch out into the smart scales

It's so wild and cool that the cheap chest strap out performs all the watches no matter how expensive.

@thechuches3879

10 ай бұрын

it is specialiced to only do that, also taking measurements in the chest is way more constant than in the wrist.

@Alexchii

10 ай бұрын

That's like saying it's wild and cool that my simple, 15 year old speaker set has vastly better sound than my brand new phone

@SwordTomato

10 ай бұрын

@@Alexchii I dont think thats too crazy

Do you plan to test the new huawei watches gen 4

The time has come for me to replace the phone and this time I gave up the Samsung I had been buying for many years in favor of the iPhone 14 PRO with Apple Watch ultra. For now, I'm getting used to the new system, but at first glance, my old Galaxy Watch 5 doesn't even stand up to the competition! I feel like I finally have the right equipment, thank you Rob! 👍

@marioqwertz9639

10 ай бұрын

You won’t regret it 👍🏻

Hey, Rob! It would be really interesting if you compared the sleep tracking of garmin watches to the firstbeat bodyguard 2 or 3. Garmins algorithm is actually made for firstbeats bodyguard, so if you compare them you can see if it's the algorithm itself that is bad, or if it's Garmins watches that just don't work well with it.

Thanks for the rigor you put into these reviews, could I request a device to be reviewed? The Redmi Watch 3 Active looks like a very interesting little device

I was looking for this. Perfect. I'm shocked disappointed happy and excited. Really hope the new garmin watches can peak or match apples performance.

Thanks for the detailed testing of Galaxy Watch. Disappointing that Samsung still haven't figured out to get as accurate in readings as possible. This really stops me from buying Samsung phones as there's no point in paying same as Apple watch but getting a mediocre product. As always thanks for taking the time to test these watches and giving us the correct opinion before putting our money into them.

It's interesting there are big differences in measures between Galaxy 4, 5 and 6 on the other side. Great videos as always!!! Also, you are intelligent to point about personal differences at the end of your videos and that points me to a personal question I hope you can answer, what is your height and weight? Best regards.

I literally won't buy a watch until Rob has released his review. I can't think of anyone providing more reliable data

Good video demonstrate Samsung watch 4, 5 and 6.

How did you export the heart rate data? Also did you have the 47mm or the 43mm version. I compared both on my (skinny) wrists and noticed the 47mm has way more wiggle room. Which would definitely result in the sensor not picking up data properly

Hey Rob, just wondering if you wear watches for a couple of weeks prior to doing the tests to allow it to "get to know" your body? I have read a lot of smart watches require this learning period before they start giving accurate data. Thank you so much for your videos, you are providing a public service!!

@TheQuantifiedScientist

9 ай бұрын

Hi! Usually I don’t have this time unfortunately. Sometimes I use an account where a previous watch from that brand was connected

Excellent video! Very valuable measurements and overview of results. Thanks for explaining so clearly. Would watch size be a significant variable to analyze? Not sure if the size would impact the contact of the sensor with the skin? Also, the band type/material may also impact the way the watch "slides" on the wrist.

I dont know if I missed it, but how many nights of sleep tracking were tested? I've heard many say, that continuous use of the watch could improve the accuracy of that.

Rob, please review the Huawei Watch D!!! Is measures blood pressure 😋

I was hoping you could do a review on the regular version the Galaxy watch 6 and see where that falls in line compared to the rest. I purchased both models pre-order and ended up keeping the regular and sending back the classic. This decision was partially made from watching your videos get the first reviewer who actually does real-world testing alongside a medical device can you please do a test with the regular Galaxy watch 6

Toujours très intéressant.

Thank you for the video! I wonder if you could do a review with the Huawei watch fit special edition. I wanted to know how it performs compared to the Huawei watch fit 2

I really appreciate your incredibly rigorous testing. Just got this watch, and as disappointing as it is to find out that its data collection is rather mediocre, at least I know not to put too much stock in it now.

Hi, are you able to tell anything about accuracy watch 6 classic vs amazfit balance yet? Which do you think will be more accurate?

hey brother I have a question about the variant of watch 6 classic you are using. is it the LTE version or bluetooth?

Heavier watches seem to have worse HR measurement, and I wonder if the regular GW6 would measure HR more reliably than the GW6 Classic. However, spotty HR measurement is easily remedied by the ability to connect with a separate HR monitor, like the chest strap. I wish the GW's could do that natively. The ability to access other monitoring devices is a huge benefit of Garmins, for example.

We are still waiting for HUAWEI WATCH 4 PRO scientific review!!

Will you be testing the Huawei watch 4 pro soon? Would love to know how it compares with the gt3 pro and apple watches.

Hey are you gooing to do a review of the huewai watch 4 pro?

Ty. I'll stick with my versa 2. It's great. Battery awesome, steps and heart rate good. Add polar strap and you get all you need

Hello, will u review new Huawei?

sticking with the 5 pro, thanks for the info.

Could you please test the Garmin 265?

can you also do a full review of the up coming OPPO watch 4 pro? Thank you so much!

Could it be an issue with software, that was actually fixed? Could you be bothered to redo the test after some time?..

Please review the Huawei Watch D!!! Is measures blood pressure 😋

I just bought a 4 classic and I'm glad I did.

You should try making a detailed review on pininfarina hibrid watch

The only review I care about

Do you plan testing watch 6 47mm any time?

after 8 months with all the updates it has received, is it better or the same?

In every video I watched regarding this watch, I mentioned your channel saying how you test and compare these watches. I was counting on getting this watch, but after seeing your reviews, I shall wait yet another year. The most important features I look at are hr (daily use - not sports) general health tracking and sleep tracking. I've read a few stories about the Apple watch saving lives, not so sure this watch will provide the same service. Can you not contact Samsung and show them your results? For me, personally I was so disappointed.

How is running accuracy in terms of heart rate and zone training?

Hi Rob! Due to the bad results of the SW6 is it a sensor problem or software and algorithms? If software issue, can it be solved in the future? Thanks for the great review 🙌

@Genial1990

10 ай бұрын

This a question that is asked every time that new Samsung watch is released and there is always someone in the comments saying that accuracy will improve in the next few software updates... but it never did for any previous Galaxy watches afaik. So, you can risk it and hope that it happens this time, but probably it will not.

@imershed

10 ай бұрын

@Genial1990 Thank you for the satisfying answer 😁 I bought the classic version 47, I've been using it for about 10 days now but I will send it back today, and I will buy iphone 15 with apple watch. I will try it with apple this time, hope I won't regret it.

@masterrobin3176

8 ай бұрын

I have been sleeping for some nights with both the 5PRO and the 6 Class, swapping from left to right in between the nights. The sleep tracking results differ majorly between the two. The only thing they agree about is the end time of the sleep. There IS a difference between the software of the two; I have pursosly not updated the PRO 5 to the latest version (which would bring it to the same version as the 6 class.

Are these issue things that can be solved through updates?. I pulled the trigger cause i really needed a smartwatch and have been reluctant to pull the trigger for so long

Nice vid as always. I got the Classic 4 for may mom 2m ago (needed some medical monitoring), I compared it to my Apple and I found it actually useless. When I saw the 6 and the "sponsored" propaganda, I thought it was going to be better.... Wish I had waited for your review before wasting more money in this brand. It's better than the E610 I got recently (for a fraction), that one I knew was going to be a wa$te, and this one is a bigger waste. Instead of these 2 I could have probably just waited one month and bought the next Apple Watch. Cheers and keep the good work- Vielen Dank.

Damn you quantified scientist ... My samsung ecosystem was about to be completed with this watch ...already has ear bud pro2 ,S23 samsung, charger and powerbank ...but i know need to carry on with my old venu sq 2

Any chance on a refresh of the pixel Watch before the second watch comes out? Not a fan of what Samsung is doing with their new watches

I am dying to see your review of the Huawei Watch 4 😭 Do you have it in your radar at all?

I would like to see you maybe do a re-review of r watches after a few firmware updates to see if they improve or get worse after an update

I've seen that both watch 4 and 5 boosted HR when riding eBike at high speed on electric mode. It was basically cheating heartrate estiamte based on GPS speed. Is it still the case on Watch 6?

Your reviews are awesome! I really like the data based comparisons although this doesn't make my search for a good watch easier. Nothing to with your amazing videos but there seem to be a big difference between apple products and 'the rest'. Or did i miss on? Is there an android watch with: hr sb/ob/wl aver. r: 0,9+ sleep match aver. 80%+ with rem 60%+

@eddiev.261

10 ай бұрын

Did you skip over the graphs with other watches? Huawei is basically on par with Apple.

@Thehs1981

10 ай бұрын

​@@eddiev.261true for hr, but at sleep tracking they really suck and for me both aspects are important.

One day can you make data analysis fr huawei watch 4 pro.. thank you..

Can you please suggest an smartwhacth for android that can capite with the apple whacth SE 2022 regarding sleep tracking and weightlifting heart rates 🙏🙏

Hi awesome review as per usual ,Pls review the Xiaomi watch S1 and S1 active ,I read that its as accurate as the Polar H10 !? PLs take a look

Any idea as to why the HR tracking is actually worse compared to the Galaxy Watch 4 results?

Thank you!!!,

Was about to buy the Galaxy Watch 6 Classic. So glad I watched this before pulling the trigger. Going to wait for the Pixel Watch 2 as the Pixel Watch 1 appears to do much better than Samsung's efforts

@theophiled

10 ай бұрын

Personally I will wait for next year as Samsung should release the Galaxy Watch 6 pro. Hopefully it will be a major upgrade ..

@eddiev.261

10 ай бұрын

​@@theophiledGood luck with that

@arvi8843

10 ай бұрын

​@@theophiledIt's not their priority so nope.

@nguyenhuyhoang1946

10 ай бұрын

@@theophiled don't hope, look Galaxy Watch 5 pro 😢

This is great video review.

Are different apps that use the same sensors work worse or better?