Sadhguru ने नॉर्थ vs साउथ की लड़ाई पर जो कहा वो सबको सुनना चाहिए | Aarvam | Ep:26
Aarvam - Episode 26
In this episode, Akshita Nandagopal interviews Sadhguru and asks about:
- North vs South debate
- Sadhgurus dressing style
- Message behind his fashion sense
- Sadhguru's favorite Hindi movie
- Best tourist places in South according to him
Sadhguru also talks about must visit places from North India. Watch the video to know about it.
#Aarvam #Sadhguru
Instagram: / thelallantop
Facebook: / thelallantop
Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Maneesh Negi
Пікірлер: 478
I am North Indian married to a South Indian and this is the best thing that can happen to Indians.
@abhinavshrivastava9434
Жыл бұрын
Married to which state of south india
@pragti1234
Жыл бұрын
@@abhinavshrivastava9434 may be tamil
@kunjar
Жыл бұрын
Marathi woman
@ashwinikumar-gx2wm
Жыл бұрын
Comments makes people hero...😅
@PawanSingh-lf1uv
Жыл бұрын
🤔 Tamil Theruma 🙏🔱
काश सदगुरू जी को हिंदी आती, हिंदी भाषी राज्यों तक भी उनकी आसान पहुंच होती । परंतु ये भी ठीक है। विविधिता से कभी भेदभाव नहीं होता शानदार गुरुजी। सादर नमन। चरणों में कोटि कोटि प्रणाम।
@sarozkumar3939
Жыл бұрын
सदगुरू को हिन्दी भाषा भी सीखना चाहिए ताकी उनकी देशना उन्हीं की ध्वनि में लोगों तक पहुंचे जैसे श्री श्री रविशंकर बड़ी सहजता से हिन्दी भाषा में लोगों से बात करते हैं। 👁️
@anukoolawasthi7452
Жыл бұрын
Ye north india Hindi k alawa koi dusri bhasa kyu nhi seekhna chahte hai, why don't you guys learn Tamil, English
@saurabhsaxena6963
Жыл бұрын
Guru se Gyan lene ke liye shishya ko prayas karna hota hai.guru ko Sagar hain Gyan ka ye to shishya ke shamta hai ki wo kitna Gyan le pate hain
@A_s6468
Жыл бұрын
@@anukoolawasthi7452 Bhai North Indian logo ko bhi English aati ha, Yaha sare illiterate nahi ha🤔 Tumhare south me 100 % logo ko English aati ha kya?🤔 We love Hindi but not rude for Others language just like South Indian people, they hate hindi language.
@knidhi8993
Жыл бұрын
@@A_s6468 Hey R C, better you remain RC! "South Indian people hate hindi language" kis ne keha? tera hindi bhasha mei kitna kavya hai? bas, RC hi rehna, khayali pulao!!
I am from Aurangabad Maharashtra where Kailasa temple is located.. Thank you Sadguru for highlighting the greatness of the city. These things help to grow travel industry.
@manikarnika9690
Жыл бұрын
संभाजी नगर u mean?
@satishgaikwad3475
Жыл бұрын
@@manikarnika9690 no he means Aurangabad
@MLICS2717
Жыл бұрын
@@satishgaikwad3475 why? Name not change yet?
Why is this not longer...It's a blessing to be in the presence of Sadhguru.
am a person from Bihar, the most backward state of India. I speak Bhojpuri language, which is recognized within Hindi. According to the people of South Indian and other states of India, Bhojpuri is also Hindi language. I agree that we speak a dialect called Bhojpuri, but we (bhojpuri speakers) are very happy to speak it. In the same way, I also understand that no citizen of any province of India should be forced to learn any one language in any way. And Sadguru we also think that our food is better than malyai or tamil or telgu foods (depends on person choice) , I expect you to try to eat Sattu once.
@vinaymann838
Жыл бұрын
I speak both Haryanvi and Punjabi languages, but some people thinks that Haryanvi is not a language but a dialect of Hindi. You can apply this rule to Punjabi also which is similar to Haryanvi but recognised as a language because it has its own script. So, I and nearly all Haryanvis recognise Haryanvi as a language not a dialect.
@prakashpatel6532
Жыл бұрын
@@vinaymann838 bro the only difference between dialect and language is this only that Languages have their script but dialects don't have .
@iamworstgamer
7 ай бұрын
I dont understand why bhojpuri is considered hindi. Bhojpuri is damn difficult language
@preranaparth
7 ай бұрын
@@iamworstgamer 100% true
Sadguru Namaskaram . North is also has rich verities of food. In fact we north Indians have included whole south indian foods in our main cuisine. We also eat Dosa & Idly in breakfast, Rasam, multiple verities of vegetables etc. In north specially in Rajasthan & Gujrat you may find a lot of different cuisines in vegetable food specially. We prepare our food as per weather. No doubt weather is more harsh in North ans South is blessed in this regard and I want to say that We also don’t like Aalu that muchh😅. आपसे निवेदन है कि अगली बार आप उदयपुर ( राजस्थान ) पधारिए और यहाँ का ख़ाना चखिये। आपके आतिथ्य में हम कोई कमी नहीं रखेंगे। नमस्कारम 🙏🙏
Sadh guru is very very diplomatic when it comes to divide. But he does prefer the south always 😎
"As a Nation, we should ENJOY THE DIFFERENCES"
I think Sadguru needs to explore north India food badly. From Gujrat to Bengal to Kashmir to Punjab there are so many different flavors and varieties. It’s wrong to categorize everything under Aloo Jeera.
@vikaskumar7019
Жыл бұрын
😀😀😀👍
@jackripper8843
Жыл бұрын
Bro it's well frog mentality exists all over the world, cant help such ignorant ppl unless they help themselves, these chaps do not discover other unknown stuff much, n r confined to whatever they cud understand nearby them easily, without investing much thought, as per their capacity, their thought process n expiriences r shallow n narrow.
@ALC0A021
Жыл бұрын
You haven't included the northeastern India bro'
@2sridhark
Жыл бұрын
You are right! I am a Tamilian who grew up in Delhi, and my wife is from Kerala. I have grown up eating North Indian (mostly Punjabi) food along with south Indian stuff which by the 70s was popular even in Delhi. South food like Idli, Idiyappam, Dosa are better health wise, the first 2 being steamed and not fried and last needing a little oil. That apart, I love North Indian stuff and we prepare it constantly at home. Sadhguru's Tamil is also very shaky even though he is a Tamilian. His English is fluent which makes me think he went to an expensive English medium school!
पता नहीं क्यों सतगुरु जी को देखकर ऐसा लगता है कि इनको तो फराटे दार हिंदी आती होगी¡🙋♂️
I always wanted him to be on #lallantop and again I would love to see him in guest in the news room show! 🤞
@gooogle3533
Жыл бұрын
Dabao like
@bonagirisrikanth7174
Жыл бұрын
Don't you think this is unfair, lallantop didn't cover about what is #Savesoil movement and why..???
World would be boring if there were no differences. Sadhguru is ❤
Akshita ji was so elegant in this interview.
@TheLallantop
Жыл бұрын
Thankyou :)
सौरभ दादा इनको ला कर तो आप ने हमें आपका क़र्ज़दार बना दिया 🙏
@sanjaykumarsingh2329
Жыл бұрын
I am also agree with you
Such a beautiful start, I'm a born UP and my love for my south never reduces, specially Tamil Nadu, rameshwaram. We might have different genetic origins but indian nature of service and gratitude remains the same, principles of yoga is what connects us. This centrism has Indian origins and i thanks saurabhtop for taking it forward. 🤍🙏🏽
I love sadguru.... morning starts with his thoughts and teaching...but FOOD...we north Indians have variety and taste 😃
@benstokes7588
Жыл бұрын
True...
@TheNara1207
Жыл бұрын
Of late i discovered that the type of food we are used to eat is the food we like.
South Indian food can never be better than North Indian food in terms of variety. His statement of only aaloo is wrong. Right statment should have been that aaloo can be mixed with most of the vegetables and that is why it is called as sabjiyo ka raja. Anyway He needs to explore more. But actual fact is south Indian food only about the rich rice and rice. Idli dosa. That's all.. Lack of vegetables and nowadays more dependent on Meats, checken and nonveg.
I'm a hindi speaker but I always found Dravidian language amazing and beautiful😍❤ even now I listen most of South Indian songs 😊.
@rushabhmunot1635
Жыл бұрын
Islam invasion is biggest cause of destruction of North India... South was lucky in that case ....
@sachinbharti6308
Жыл бұрын
@@rushabhmunot1635 Yeah dude so much invasion and bloodshed so that now we didn't afraid of death habitual 😊. Islamist try a lot to destroy but they didn't get success totally . South India actually save our old temples they didn't get invasion 😊
@rushabhmunot1635
Жыл бұрын
@@sachinbharti6308 actually it was because of Maratha Empire... Maratha Empire was called as a door to Deccan(dakhan) south India... Marathas didn't let aurangazeb capture south India.
Tamil Nadu certainly has some divine aspects . Swamiji Vivekananda loved very much especially Tamil Youths. They are intelligent , diligent & innovative, He felt. Vivekananda also meditated on the Rock now called "Vivekananda Rock" and had a vision about India's glorious Future. However , We too not find South food very satisfying. We too from Bengal have a great range of Recipy. Yes! We enjoy the differences of food & language
Now Finnally I subscribed this channel just because LallanTop bring Sadguru at their platform.....
I agree with most of the things sadhguru says but when it comes to food specially vegetarian north is way above south. Indian food which is popular in western world is mostly north indian curry.
@2sridhark
Жыл бұрын
You are right but South foods especially the ones that need just steaming and not frying in oil are more healthy. Anyway this argument is redundant today given the fact that Idli, Dosa etc have become ubiquitous in North too! Indian restaurant in US mostly caters to North Indian food but that may be because Gujaratis, Punjabis are more enterprising when it comes to business than South Indians who are mostly into tech. You do find some South Indian restaurant here and there in New Jersey where i lived but are few and far between
Save soil 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 Thank you SADHGURU ISHA Foundation Everyone join the movement
I am a keen listener to Sadhguru. I am always in awe of his extraordinary wisdom. I have been listening to him for 5-6 years now. His SAVE SOIL movement further brought him & his extraordinary ability to world attention. All said & done. He has fierce regionalism.
You are the Lallan part, I'm the Top part🤣
Thank you for inviting shadguru in Aarvam . Thanks to Akshita and saurabh. What I say ,Lallantop win our hearts. Small session but very interesting specilly Akshita. I like your Hindi talking. Regarding food shadguru is true but our fooding varieties are according to weather condition.Its totally आयुर्वेदिक. Which I like most .what we eat in summer ,it's not in winter. In North Vegetables are more abundantly available which is absent in south states. In north Potato is so cheap so that it was main course of our food. I see lot of farming is doing on Mathura Belt. Presently I am in bangalore and I am realizing same what shadguru told. Firstly I thought in south everyone talking Rice in breakfast. But In Rice too many differences. Tomato rice ,lemon rice ,pulluogyre, Chitrana, pongal, Rice bath and many more and Taste are too different from other. I also visited Isha yoga center on 01Jan 2023 having Nice experience.
परमपूज्य शंकराचार्य जी ने दझिण से उत्तर की यात्रा करके देश को एक माला की तरह पिरोया और आप सिरे खींच रहें हैं।
@DJosh20
Жыл бұрын
I agree and was surprised to see that he said things like these about North and South food. I am from Maharashtra but I get to differ with what Sadhguru said. I can say that south indian food is healthy but north indian food is equally tasty and good. In fact if you go any part of India you will find home cooked food healthy and very tasty. It is wrong to label any food better then yours. Surprised Sadhguru..
This is what we love about Aarvam and Lallantop altogether, they don't miss a clip, a interview or a story chance based on their shows and its genre whenever they go to meet someone. Waiting for some more brilliant minds from South India to make their debut in Aarvam. Who knows if someday I will be sitting their and talking about Jagannath culture from Odisha...
@TheLallantop
Жыл бұрын
Thanks Roshan :)
have had best friends from South. I love the people, food, culture and everything as much as I love them in north. I have lived for decade in mumbai, couple of years in bangalore. Worked with folks across all possible cultures from India.... our strength is diversity and not to harp on who is better. Love for south, east and west from North (Gurgaon). All are welcome here and every Indian is welcome everywhere
Should have been longer at leat 1 - 1.5 hours, even Sadguru in the news room, would be a fantastic chapter for all the human kinds watching lallantop
Superb sir. belur n halebeedu.....tanjavur , kailash temple yes all these are one must watch in life time. Thanks for bringing sadguru on LT.
I have visited Kailash temple thrice to make me believe how dedicated, outstanding people were who made this wonder, three generations worked to finish the work. There was not a second chance to recitify any mistake but they have done with perfection.
Sadhguru has great knowledge but also has a South Indian bias. The terrain and food is also great in the north. I have heard him draw from Aryan Invasion theory in some other video as well. 😶
@msraja1230
Жыл бұрын
Aryan invasion is truth bro, skin colour and many similarities between language, culture etc. of North and middle-east and central Asia speaks scores.
@shashank6872
Жыл бұрын
@Ms Raja you fail to see linguistic and skin color similarities between people of North and South and also the fact that all Indians are mixed with people from upper hemisphere, just proportions are different.
@rog5asus416
Жыл бұрын
Linguistic similarity? How? Sanskrit is Indo-European stretching from western Europe to central Asia and North India. All languages in the north of India follow the same grammatical structure and similar scripts. Whereas, Tamil is completely distinct in terms of both scripts and language structures. The other Southern languages have varying degrees of Sanskrit influence in them, but still follow the Tamili script. It is beyond any doubt that the north Indian culture and language is more central asian and middle eastern than ancient Indian. You can attribute it to invasions if you want but that is an undeniable fact
@shashank6872
Жыл бұрын
@rog5asus416 the southern language are inspired from the ancient Indian script Brahmi and the vocabulary has Sanskrit words too. Not all Northern languages follow the same script. Check Odia and Assamese. Their scripts look different but again the vocabulary has many words from Sanskrit.
TRUE in south there are variety of foods ...however, in north ..specially in Village the vegetable rules...yes in city Aloo is predominantly used.
अलग अलग प्रकार फूल(भाषा,रंग,खान-पान,पहनावा, संगीत,खेल,मौसम आदि इत्यादि) गूंथकर भारत रूपि सुन्दर माला बनती है। ख़ूबसूरती भी इसी में है कि हम mutual respect करते हैं। हम देखने में अलग लग सकते हैं लेकिन अंदर से एक हैं। भाईचारा जिन्दाबाद, भारत जिन्दाबाद।
We all worship same dieties whether in South or north east or west. This we should remember and tell people
I am not agree with sadgurus... Comment on food of North india... Because I have been travel southern part... And we also think that southern people eat only rice rice and rice... Maybe we are wrong because we don't know much about southern food... We eat only idali dosa and vada all the time.. In lunch and dinner also... Similarly North is not about only potatoes and jeera... Northern part also have so many variety.... You just need to find..
@ravishingravi
Жыл бұрын
Understand sarcasm or joke. It's not a serious comment.
U forgot asking - AAPKE ENERGY KA RAAZ KYA HAI.. nice 👍👍👍.. such brave access journalism.. Ditching d old format to make it a PR session & coffee table useless magazine of upper middle class living in their islands. Out of all the experts u find him ? n previously Adani interview? Wow bravo !!!
That's the reason why I always support lallantop, this is the amazing initiative taken by lallantop, Love you lallantop
Wow... Sadhguru... great to hear him!!
🙏 sadhguru's aura is just another level.his smile ,the way he seating ,his wisdom omg! He making conscious planet .love u sadhguru.
शानदार 🙏
Always felt why Shadhguru is not in Guest Room at Lallantop
Best episode of Aaravam...
Coimbatore food is good but not from whole south and even North have too much good enough food. I totally disagree with Sadhguru on this.
Mughal, Turks, and many more islamic invaders came through Punjab and the Britishers also focused mainly in North India. All the islamic invaders fought with North Indian kings. North India was busy fighting with the invaders that's why the South India has the liberty to maintain their peace and Dharma. The situation is far more different in North India.
My god this was a big 😮 surprise
So much of clarity in his answers
I love sadguru but for food, I would just say that it's only in hotels or restaurants they sell potato poori largely but we have variety of foods, scrumptious food with diverse taste and it also varied from city to city even diverse culture in food can be seen in single district ...
Namaskaram Sadguru🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻Thankuu saurabh sir and team Lallantop for this lallan+top session 🥳🥳quench isn't end here🙈🙈i wish to spend at least an hour in this part but it's ok something is better than nothing☺☺
@vishalkumargupta8315
Жыл бұрын
Well Akka Its really so so beautiful...
"REQUEST" When will previous format will be back I thought this week would be coverage of real guru like siddeshwar swamiji who died lived simplest life his will states that there should be no samadhi or any monument he rejected padmashri he did not took anything from devotes such people were not covered in main media but i thought arvam would atleast cover in these times such personalities should be known to every persons.his last rites attend by lakhs of people just see the videos.
Shocked and happy to see him on lallantop☺️❤️
Great initiative supported by Sadhguru of celebrating both north and south together.
@Randomindian7
Жыл бұрын
@@user-fp8xx7qf1w no...
*सौरभ जी आप सौभाग्यशाली हो कि सद्गुरु ने आपके चैनल पे दस्तक़ दिया है, इसके लिए आपके सभी मेम्बर को बधाई,*
Sadhguru ROCKING.. as usual...
Would like a longer version, if possible. Thanks anyway!
Bhut khub
Sadguru should also talk in hindi.we like it.we are one India and I like to listen to him
@livingcosmos_3
Жыл бұрын
You talk to him in Tamil
@mrnobody8337
Жыл бұрын
भारत के सब लोग हिंदी बोले ये सोचना बंद कर दो आधे से ज्यादा भारतियों की मातृभाषा हिंदी नहीं है
@ashishsoni1364
8 ай бұрын
@@mrnobody8337even the other half’s mother language is not Hindi. But we do speak Hindi so that we can communicate 😊 you see we are not biased on using English.
So happy to see Sadhguru on lallantop
Great video 👍👍
Lalantop team thanks 🙏🙏🙏
This is most entertaining interview of Sadhguru 👍👍😊😊
Sir aap sadguru ji ko aapne office mein bulaye plzzzz....🙏🙏🙏🙏
Ab aacha kam kiye hai lallan top wale best of luck 🤞
Very nice ... loved it ...
spl thank saurav dewedi and lallantop and all member of lallantop
Good effort.
Y Hui na lallantop 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳bat ❤️ sadguru
Sadguru ji ko koti koti pranam 🙏
@ashishsoni1364
8 ай бұрын
I wonder if he will say here I can’t speak Hindi.
Suparb अक्षिता जी ❤️🔥
Good, but Respected Sadguru is not well informed about the variety of masalas in North India.
yesss,,,,this is correct that if they will come to know everything then they wilk come to south india. we are lucky thar we came here to Coimbatore and adopted this culture which is ancient and very close to God. Real india is south india. I am a pure punjabi and my family too but we want to live here in south for ever. Being a coimbatorian I have this gift of God, Sadhguru ji and off course The Isha. Thank God and Thanks to this culture.
Sadhguru is Gem❤
Wonderful
अठारह मिनट पचपन सेकंड मे आरवम के महीनों के प्रयास पर पानी फेर दिया जग्गी बाबू ने वो तो भला हो अक्षिता का जिसने पूरी शालीनता से कार्यक्रम की गरिमा बनाए रखी हालांकी बहुत बड़ी बात होगी मगर निःसंदेह पूरे इंटरव्यू के दौरान अक्षिता का व्यक्तित्व जगदीश जी पर भारी पड़ा।
दझिण भारत के रेस्तरां होटलों मे जो खाना मिलता है वही खाना उनके रोजमर्रा का भोजन होता है जो उनके घरों में पकता है मगर उत्तर भारत मे जो खाना घरों में बनता है वह रेस्तरां होटलों मे (कुछ अपवाद को छोड़कर) नही मिलता है। हमारे लिए बाहर खाने का मतलब घर का खाना नही होता है इसलिए जब कोई दझिण भारतीय उत्तर भारत के रेस्तरां होटलों मे खाना खाता है तो उसे विविधता नही दिखती।
Namaskaram Sadhguruji 🙏
Saurabh sir please invite Sadhguru in guest room show
@SumitSharma-pq2vr
Жыл бұрын
🔥🔥🔥🔥
I think the interviewer should have been from north side and full of contents for this subject to make the interview more interesting and informative. Nevertheless, I liked to hear Sadhguru as always
Well done good initiative
Most humble person mystic Sadhguru ♥️🖤
@knidhi8993
Жыл бұрын
achcha? jaan gaye aur maan gaye, guru!
Ma'am next episode plzzz tell information about sabrimala temple and bhagwaan aayeepa and it's 41 days dikhsha process in detail many youth suffring bad habits and self conscious problem in daily life. Please ma'am 🙏 I am from up
अच्छी चर्चा।
Such a cheerful and kind Anchor. Full on positive vibes. Feedback- Thank you for not letting Siddhant ji host it. He has hosted a few Guest In NewsRoom episodes and was a disaster. He seems to be good human but very substandard interviewer.
Sadhguru ❤️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Very good one
North Indian Food is best 😁😁
@sarozkumar3939
Жыл бұрын
I like south indian 👌🙏
@suprabhatkumar8628
Жыл бұрын
@@user-fp8xx7qf1w oldest civilization is Indus valley civilization in North India. North Indian loves every one except terrorist and Anti nationals 🙏 😁😂
@mountain375
Жыл бұрын
@@user-fp8xx7qf1w who care your perspective
@DJosh20
Жыл бұрын
I love both and rest of Indian food..Surprised how of all the people sadhguru saying what he said about food, region and weather.
आपका डोसा इडली जिंदाबाद है मगर हमारा दम आलू जिंदाबाद था जिंदाबाद है और जिंदाबाद रहेगा।
@millennialmind9507
Жыл бұрын
😅🤣 looks like there is going to be food riots here
मैं उस क्षेत्र से हुँ जो अटल टनल के उत्तरी छोर पर है जिसे लाहुल स्पीत्ति कहते हैं.. हमारा क्षेत्र लद्दाख के साथ उत्तर में और दक्षिण पूर्व में कुल्लू मनाली का क्षेत्र के निकट है.. देखा जाए तो हम कर्नाटक, तमिलनाडु और आंध्र से सुदूर उत्तर में हैं.. फिर भी कहीं न कहीं.. दक्षिण के पौराणिक महाबली को हमारा समुदाय एक विशेष त्यौहार के दिन याद करता है और उनसे वरदान मांगता है.. महाबली अर्थात राजा बलि के नाम त्यौहार का नाम है बड़ीदानो त्यौहार.. मुझे नहीं पता यह संबंध कैसे सम्भव हुआ..?
Sadguru 🙏🙏🙏I am coming.
Thanks both of you💙💙😄😄
Dear @lallantop team, thanks for bringing Sadhguru in Aarvam.. Great show.. this is real Bharat Jodo show 😂. But felt like Sadhguru and other South Indian Bros and sis thinks they have a better culture, food, entertainment etc etc they have and I agree for that but that doesn't mean other part of India doesn't have so.. I'm from Madhya Pradesh, I am in Bengaluru for last 6 years and I embraced kannadigas culture, Iga nānu ardha kannadiganagiddene, nanu kannada kalite.. but the way we respect, this culture same we expect from our South Indian brother and sister.. aur agar aap aalo ko le ke itna concern hai hm bhi to rice ko le k concern ho sakte h.. Differences may be there but love this show.
@madhugreenleaf11
Жыл бұрын
He is being humorous. Also he is not right about everything.
Sadguru ji Pranam 🙏🙏🇮🇳
Beautiful Hindi . Both of u.
Mam please ask about ancient and Vedic times North India🇮🇳 vs South India🇮🇳in Vedic and Ancient times
My favorite show Aravam.👌
We all come from sanskritam We are Unite in diversity ❤️ I have to learn Tamil Marathi and Assamese language ❤️
@shashankgiregol
Жыл бұрын
Sanskritian 😂😂😂 Tamil is more ancient than that
@abhilashkuthe95
Жыл бұрын
No dude....u r having wrong info..... everything is not sanskritian
👍👍
Lallantop is blessed today 😇
प्रणाम सद्गुरु 🙏🙏
It's unbelievable to see Sadhguru in lallantop. Saurabh Dwivedi should be interviewing him, it would have been more interesting.
@akshaykumar465
Жыл бұрын
he doesnt come because he hates sadhguru and anybody who speak english, or talk about spirituality other than shastras , one reason is also that he supports BJP in center and Congress in Karnataka (sadhguru received support from Congress 's Sidhharamayya for rally for rivers in 2017)